Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

DR T R RAMTEKE v. NARESH KUMAR CHIF SECRETARY & ORS GOVT. OF NCTD

Central Administrative Tribunal
Apr 11, 2023
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

By an order dated 30.08.2019 in O.A. No. 4564/2017 this Tribunal directed the respondents to release the applicant's retirement benefits within two months and provided that if the amount was not paid within that period it would carry interest @ 9% per annum from the expiry of one month until payment. The applicant filed the present Contempt Petition alleging non-compliance of that order. The respondents filed a compliance affidavit stating that gratuity of Rs. 10,00,000 was paid on 29.12.2022; interest on delayed payment of gratuity from 01.10.2019 to 29.12.2022 at 9% amounting to Rs. 2,91,250 was paid on 06.02.2023; commuted value of pension of Rs. 14,44,932 and leave encashment of Rs. 17,59,500 were paid on 29.12.2022. The applicant claimed entitlement to interest on the delayed payment of the commuted value of pension and on leave encashment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondents complied with the Tribunal's order dated 30.08.2019 by releasing the applicant's retirement benefits and interest for delayed payment.
  2. Whether the applicant is entitled to interest under the 30.08.2019 order on (a) the commuted value of pension and (b) leave encashment.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The applicant contended that, in addition to gratuity, he is entitled to interest on the delayed payment of the commuted value of pension and on the delayed payment of leave encashment in terms of the Tribunal's order dated 30.08.2019.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents asserted compliance with the 30.08.2019 order by paying gratuity, interest on delayed gratuity, commuted pension value and leave encashment on the dates stated in their compliance affidavit.
  • Relying on the DOPT OM dated 05.10.1999 (clause f), the respondents submitted that leave encashment is a benefit under leave rules and not a pensionary benefit, and therefore the applicant is not entitled to interest on leave encashment under the 30.08.2019 order.
  • With respect to commuted pension, the respondents stated that the applicant was receiving provisional pension equal to full basic pension; that statement was not disputed by the applicant's counsel, and on that basis the respondents denied entitlement to interest on the commuted value of pension.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal recorded the Division Bench order dated 30.08.2019 and reviewed the respondents' compliance affidavit which showed payment of gratuity, interest on delayed gratuity, commuted pension value and leave encashment on specified dates. The Tribunal considered the applicant's claim for interest on commuted pension and leave encashment. For leave encashment the respondents relied on the DOPT OM dated 05.10.1999 (clause f) to show that leave encashment is not a pensionary benefit and hence not covered by the interest direction in the 30.08.2019 order. As to commuted pension, the respondents stated the applicant had been receiving provisional pension equal to full basic pension; that statement was not disputed by the applicant's counsel. On these bases the Tribunal concluded the applicant was not entitled to interest on leave encashment or on the commuted value of pension, and that the earlier order stood complied with as regards amounts paid.

Holding and Implications

CONTEMPT PETITION CLOSED

Holding: The Tribunal held that the respondents have complied with the order dated 30.08.2019 by paying gratuity, interest on delayed gratuity, commuted pension value and leave encashment as reflected in the compliance affidavit, and that the applicant is not entitled to interest on leave encashment or on the commuted value of pension.

Implications: The direct effect is closure of the Contempt Petition and denial of the applicant's claim for additional interest on commuted pension and leave encashment. The opinion does not announce or rely upon any new precedent.

Show all summary ...

1

C.P. 360/2022 Central Administrative Tribunal Principal Bench: New Delhi CP No. 360/2022

in

O.A. No. 4564/2017

Tuesday this the 11thday of April, 2023 Hon'ble Mr. Justice Ranjit More, Chairman Hon'ble Mr. Mohd Jamshed, Member (A) Dr. T R Ramteke,

S/o late Sh. Shiv Ram Tamteke r/o B-7/ F-2, B Block

Dilshad Garden,

Delhi - 110 095

…Petitioner

(By Advocate: Prabhakar Narayan) Versus

1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi Shri Naresh Kumar The Chief Secretary Govt. of NCT of Delhi Delhi Secretariat, New Delhi

2. The Secretary Amit Singla

Health & Family Welfare Department Govt. of NCT of Delhi

9th Level,

Delhi Secretariat New Delhi

3. The Medical Superintendent SH Subhash Giri

Guru Teg Bahadur Hospital Dilshad Garden, Delhi - 110095

4. The Pay and Account Officer Shri Pradeep Kumar

PAO VIII, GTB Hospital Dilshad Garden, Delhi - 110 095 …Respondents

2

(By Advocate: Mr. Rohit Bhagat for Mr. Saurabh Chadda)

ORDER(ORAL)

Per: Justice Ranjit More, Chairman By the order dated 30.08.2019 passed by the Division Bench in OA No. 4564/2017, this Tribunal directed the respondents to release the retirement benefits of the applicant, within two months from the date of receipt of a copy of that order and if the amount is not paid within such period, it shall carry interest @ 9% per annum, from the date of expiry of one month, till the date of payment. The applicant approached this Tribunal by way of present Contempt Petition making grievance of non-compliance of the said order by the respondents.

2. On behalf of the respondents, Dr. Anil Kumar Yadav has filed compliance affidavit, which shows that the amount of Rs. 10 lakhs towards gratuity is paid to the applicant on 29.12.2022 and interest on the delayed payment of gratuity from 01.10.19 till 29.12.22 with 9% interest amounting to Rs. 2,91,250/- has been paid to the applicant on 06.02.2023. That apart, the commuted value of pension amounting to Rs. 14,44,932/-and an amount of Rs. 17,59,500/- towards leave encashment is also paid over to the applicant on 29.12.2022.

3. In light of the above, it is the claim of the respondent that said order dated 30.08.2019 stands complied with. Learned counsel for the applicant states that the applicant is also entitled for the interest in terms of the said order on delayed payment of commuted value of pension and leave

3

encashment. The claim of the applicant in this regard is denied by the respondents by relying upon the DOPT OM dated 05.10.1999. In terms of the clause f) thereof, it is clear that encashment of leave is benefit granted under leave rules and the same is not a pensionary benefit. In the light of this memorandum, the applicant is not entitled for interest on leave encashment in terms of the said order dated 30.08.2019. So far as the applicant's claim of interest on commuted pension is concerned that statement is made on behalf of the respondents that the applicant was getting provisional pension equal to full basic pension. This statement is not disputed by learned counsel for the applicant. In that view of the matter, the applicant is not entitled for any interest on the commuted value of the pension in terms of the said order dated 30.08.2019.

4. In the light of above, we are not inclined to proceed further with the present CP and the same is thereby closed. (Mohd Jamshed) (Justice Ranjit More)

Member (A) Chairman

/gm/