- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sanket Kumar Agarwal And Another v. Apg Logistics Private Limited .
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant filed an application under Section 7 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) in June 2021 seeking initiation of a corporate insolvency resolution process against the respondent. The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) dismissed that application on 26 August 2022.
On 2 September 2022 the appellant applied for a certified copy of the NCLT order; the Registry received the request on 5 September 2022 and supplied the certified copy on 15 September 2022, the same day the order was uploaded on the NCLT website.
An appeal was e-filed before the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) on 10 October 2022, accompanied by an interlocutory application seeking condonation of a five-day delay. A hard (physical) copy of the appeal was lodged on 31 October 2022.
By judgment dated 9 January 2023, NCLAT dismissed the appeal as time-barred, construing the 45-day outer limit in Section 61(2) IBC as having expired on 9 October 2022. The present Supreme Court appeal under Section 62 IBC challenges that dismissal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appeal to NCLAT was instituted within the limitation period prescribed by Section 61(2) IBC, read with its proviso.
- Whether, in computing limitation, (a) the day of pronouncement of the NCLT order must be excluded under Section 12(1) of the Limitation Act, 1963 and Rule 3 of the NCLAT Rules, 2016; and (b) the “time requisite” for obtaining a certified copy (5 – 15 September 2022) must be excluded under Section 12(2) of the Limitation Act.
- Whether limitation stops running on the date of e-filing or only upon presentation of a physical copy, in light of Rule 22 and Rule 103 of the NCLAT Rules, 2016 and the Registrar’s administrative orders dated 3-1-2021, 21-10-2022 and 24-12-2022.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The ten-day period between 5 September and 15 September 2022 spent in obtaining the certified copy must be excluded; hence the appeal was within time.
- The day of pronouncement (26 August 2022) should be excluded under Section 12(1) Limitation Act and Rule 3 of the NCLAT Rules.
- NCLAT ignored the Supreme Court judgment in V. Nagarajan v. SKS Ispat & Power Ltd., (2022) 2 SCC 244, which recognises exclusion of time spent in procuring a certified copy.
- The order was unavailable in the public domain until 15 September 2022; drafting an appeal earlier was impossible.
Respondent's Arguments
- The appeal was e-filed only on 10 October 2022 and, under the applicable SOP and Rules, limitation ceases only when the physical copy is presented.
- The 3-1-2021 SOP requires hard copies in addition to e-filing; Rule 22 mandates physical presentation with a certified copy.
- The Registrar’s order dated 21-10-2022 (effective 1-11-2022) clarified that limitation is computed from the date of physical presentation; the order of 24-12-2022 changed the position prospectively.
- Even if e-filing were accepted, the appeal exceeded the 45-day outer limit.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| V. Nagarajan v. SKS Ispat & Power Ltd., (2022) 2 SCC 244 | Limitation commences on pronouncement; time taken to obtain a certified copy is excluded if the application is made within the limitation period; Rule 22(2) NCLAT Rules requires filing with a certified copy. | Distinguished: Unlike in V. Nagarajan, the appellant here applied for the certified copy within the original 30-day period; therefore the ten-day period (5–15 September 2022) was excludable. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
1. Section 61(2) IBC provides a 30-day limitation period, extendable by a further 15 days on sufficient cause, creating an absolute outer limit of 45 days.
2. Rule 3 of the NCLAT Rules and Section 12(1) Limitation Act require exclusion of the day on which the impugned order is pronounced. Accordingly, 26 August 2022 was excluded.
3. Section 12(2) Limitation Act mandates exclusion of the “time requisite” for obtaining the certified copy once an application is made within limitation. The appellant sought the copy on 2 September 2022; the Registry received the request on 5 September and furnished the copy on 15 September. Hence, the ten-day period 5–15 September 2022 was excluded.
4. When these exclusions are applied, only 45 days elapsed up to the e-filing on 10 October 2022, bringing the appeal within the maximum permissible period (30 + 15 days).
5. NCLAT mis-computed the period as 46 days by failing to exclude the day of pronouncement.
6. Administrative orders on e-filing vs physical filing were prospective (order dated 21-10-2022 effective 1-11-2022) and in any event were superseded on 24-12-2022. At the material time (10–31 October 2022) there was no binding directive making limitation dependent on physical filing.
7. Consequently, NCLAT erred in holding that it lacked power to condone the delay; the appeal was within its discretionary range under the proviso to Section 61(2).
8. The Court also criticised the “flip-flops” in NCLAT’s administrative guidance, emphasising the need for consistent rules encouraging e-filing and reducing unnecessary duplication of physical documents.
Holding and Implications
ALLOWED – The Supreme Court set aside NCLAT’s judgment dated 9 January 2023 and restored the appeal to NCLAT for decision on merits. Any pending applications were disposed of.
Implications: The ruling clarifies computation of limitation for IBC appeals, reaffirming exclusion of (a) the day of pronouncement and (b) time spent obtaining a certified copy where due diligence is shown. It confirms that appeals e-filed within the 45-day outer limit are entertainable, and it criticises inconsistent administrative practices, urging tribunals and the Union Government to streamline and prioritise e-filing. No new substantive precedent is set beyond this clarification and administrative guidance.
Dr D.Y. Chandrachud, C.J.— Admit. This appeal arises under Section 62 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (“IBC”) from a judgment dated 9-1-2023 2023 SCC OnLine NCLAT 695 of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (“Nclat”). Nclat dismissed the appeal against the order 2022 SCC OnLine NCLT 375 of the National Company Law Tribunal (“NCLT”) on the ground of limitation.
2. The appellant instituted an application under Section 7 IBC in June 2021 seeking the initiation of the corporate insolvency resolution process against the respondent. The application was dismissed by NCLT by an order dated 26-8-2022 2022 SCC OnLine NCLT 375. On 2-9-2022, the appellant filed an application for obtaining a certified copy of the order which was pronounced by NCLT. The application was received by the Registry of NCLT on 5-9-2022. On 15-9-2022, the order was uploaded on the website of NCLT and a certified copy was provided to the appellant on the same day. The appellant lodged an appeal before Nclat on 10-10-2022 in the e-filing mode along with an interlocutory application (“IA”) seeking condonation of delay of five days. A physical copy of the appeal was filed on 31-10-2022.
3. The appellant submitted that the appeal had been filed within the period of limitation from the date the order was made available in the public domain i.e. 15-9-2022. However, as a matter of abundant precaution, the appellant had considered 26-8-2022 2022 SCC OnLine NCLT 375 to be the date from which limitation would commence. The appellant stated that the prescribed time period of 30 days for filing the appeal ended on 5-10-2022, after accounting for the exclusion of 10 days (from 5-9-2022 to 15-9-2022 on account of the time taken to provide a certified copy). The appellant submitted that the inadvertent delay of 5 days in filing the appeal had been caused due to the additional time needed to obtain legal advice, collate documents and connect with counsel during the festive season.
4. In the background of the above sequence of events, the issue before Nclat was whether the appeal was instituted within limitation. In its impugned order 2023 SCC OnLine NCLAT 695, Nclat observed that the appeal was lodged through the e-portal on 10-10-2022, which was the 46th day after the order 2022 SCC OnLine NCLT 375 of NCLT. It observed that while Section 61(2) IBC prescribes a 30-day deadline for preferring an appeal against an order of the adjudicating authority, the Appellate Tribunal can condone a delay of up to 15 days, if sufficient cause is shown. Furthermore, it held that the ingredients of Section 61 IBC do not visualise that an aggrieved person has to wait till he is in receipt of a certified copy of the impugned order before preferring an appeal. The Tribunal held : (Sanket Kumar Agarwal case 2023 SCC OnLine NCLAT 695, SCC OnLine NCLAT para 32)
“32. It cannot be gainsaid, that the ‘expiry of 30 days', after the ‘pronouncement of the impugned order’, dated 26-8-2022 2022 SCC OnLine NCLT 375, was on 24-9-2022. The 30 days period in preferring the ‘appeal’, by any ‘person aggrieved’, in respect of an ‘order’, passed by the ‘adjudicating authority’, is the ‘deadline’ prescribed as per Section 61(2) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. If an ‘Appellate Tribunal’ (Nclat), is satisfied on ‘sufficient cause’, being shown to its ‘subjective satisfaction’, in regard to the preferring of an ‘appeal’ (after the ‘expiry of 30 days period’), then, ‘such period, shall not exceed 15 days', as per Section 61(2) of the Code. Admittedly, the ‘completion of 45 days' (30 + 15 days), was on 9-10-2022. In effect, the maximum 45 days being the outer limit (30 + 15 = 45 days), beyond which, the ‘Appellate Tribunal’ (Nclat), is ‘bereft’ of any power, to ‘condone the delay’, in the teeth of the mandate, prescribed under the I&B Code, 2016, as opined by this ‘Tribunal’.”
(emphasis supplied)
5. Nclat held that even according to the version of the appellants, the period of 30 days would end on 4-10-2022 while the appeal was filed on 10-10-2022. It noted that 10 days (from 26-8-2022 to 4-9-2022) were spent prior to the application for a certified copy and between 15-9-2022 and 4-10-2022 another period of 20 days elapsed.
6. Nclat concluded that the appeal was barred by limitation on the ground that it was instituted on the 46th day following the order 2022 SCC OnLine NCLT 375 of NCLT, exceeding the outer limit of 45 days that was permissible under Section 61 IBC.
7. The appellant questions the order of Nclat on limitation.
8. The following submissions have been urged by Mr Bhanu Gupta, counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant:
8.1. Nclat ought to have excluded the period from 5-9-2022, when an application for obtaining a certified copy was filed till 15-9-2022, when the certified copy was received, while computing the period of limitation;
8.2. Nclat has erroneously taken the entire period between 26-8-2022 and 10-10-2022 by failing to exclude the date on which the order was pronounced, namely, 26-8-2022 in terms of Section 12(2) of the Limitation Act, 1963 and Rule 3 of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal Rules, 2016 (“Nclat Rules, 2016”);
8.3. Nclat has disregarded judicial precedents including the judgment of this Court in V. Nagarajan v. SKS Ispat & Power Ltd. (2022) 2 SCC 244, (2022) 1 SCC (Civ) 741 (“V. Nagarajan”); and
8.4. Since the order of NCLT was uploaded on the website on 15-9-2022 on which day the certified copy was also made available, it was impossible for the appellant to draft an appeal prior to 15-9-2022 based merely on the pronouncement of the order without knowledge of the grounds for dismissal.
9. On the other hand, Ms Rashi Bansal, counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent urged that:
9.1. The appeal was filed on 10-10-2022 in the electronic mode;
9.2. On 3-1-2021, a circular was issued by Nclat notifying a standard operating procedure (“SOP”) for e-filing in terms of which physical copies were required to be filed as per the procedure prescribed under Nclat Rules, 2016 along with the e-filing receipt;
9.3. On 21-10-2022, a further order was issued by the Registrar of Nclat clarifying that the period of limitation shall be computed from the date of the presentation of the appeal as per Rule 22 of the Nclat Rules, 2016, the effect of which was that the period of limitation would cease to run only after a physical copy was presented;
9.4. By an order of 24-12-2022, notified by the Registrar of Nclat, the earlier order dated 21-10-2022 was withdrawn and it was notified for the first time that limitation shall be computed with reference to the date of e-filing; and
9.5. Even the e-filing of the appeal on 10-10-2022 would not result in limitation ceasing to operate and it was only when a hard copy was filed that limitation would stop running.
10. The dispute in the appeal arises over the period of limitation applicable for filing an appeal against an order 2022 SCC OnLine NCLT 375 of NCLT under the IBC. The IBC is a complete code. Section 238 IBC provides that the Code shall have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith contained in any other law for the time being in force or any instrument having effect by virtue of any such law. Relevant provisions of the IBC, the Limitation Act, 1963, Nclat Rules, 2016 and administrative orders are extracted below and are referred to, in turn.
11. Section 61(1) IBC stipulates that notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in the Companies Act, 2013, any person aggrieved by the order of the adjudicating authority “under this Part” may prefer an appeal to Nclat. Sub-section (2) of Section 61 provides for a period of limitation in the following terms:
“61. Appeals and Appellate Authority.—(1) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained under the Companies Act, 2013, any person aggrieved by the order of the adjudicating authority under this part may prefer an appeal to the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal.
(2) Every appeal under sub-section (1) shall be filed within thirty days before the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal:
Provided that the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal may allow an appeal to be filed after the expiry of the said period of thirty days if it is satisfied that there was sufficient cause for not filing the appeal but such period shall not exceed fifteen days.”
12. Sub-section (2) of Section 61 provides for a limitation period of thirty days. The proviso to Section 61(2) provides that Nclat may allow an appeal to be filed beyond a period of thirty days by a maximum of fifteen days on the demonstration of sufficient cause for the delay.
13. Section 238-A, inserted in the IBC by the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Second Amendment) Act, 2018, contains a specific provision in regard to the Limitation Act, 1963. Section 238-A provides that the Limitation Act would inter alia apply “as far as may be” to appeals before Nclat:
“238-A. Limitation.—The provisions of the Limitation Act, 1963 (36 of 1963) shall, as far as may be, apply to the proceedings or appeals before the adjudicating authority, the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, the Debt Recovery Tribunal or the Debt Recovery Appellate Tribunal, as the case may be.”
14. The Central Government, in exercise of the powers conferred by Section 469 of the Companies Act, 2013, has formulated Nclat Rules, 2016. Rule 3 of the Nclat Rules, 2016 stipulates that for computation of a time period as provided, the day from which the said period is to be reckoned shall be excluded. Rule 3 provides as follows:
“3. Computation of time period.—Where a period is prescribed by the Act and these rules or under any other law or is fixed by the Appellate Tribunal for doing any act, in computing the time, the day from which the said period is to be reckoned shall be excluded, and if the last day expires on a day when the office of the Appellate Tribunal is closed, that day and any succeeding day on which the Appellate Tribunal remains closed shall also be excluded.”
15. Part III of the Nclat Rules, 2016 deals with the procedure for the institution of appeals. Rule 22 provides that an appeal has to be presented at the filing counter of the Appellate Tribunal, and should be accompanied by a certified copy of the order under challenge. Rule 22 provides that:
“22. Presentation of appeal.—(1) Every appeal shall be presented in Form Nclat-1 in triplicate by the appellant or petitioner or applicant or respondent, as the case may be, in person or by his duly authorised representative duly appointed in this behalf in the prescribed form with stipulated fee at the filing counter and non-compliance of this may constitute a valid ground to refuse to entertain the same.
(2) Every appeal shall be accompanied by a certified copy of the impugned order.
(3) All documents filed in the Appellate Tribunal shall be accompanied by an index in triplicate containing their details and the amount of fee paid thereon.
(4) Sufficient number of copies of the appeal or petition or application shall also be filed for service on the opposite party as prescribed.
(5) In the pending matters, all other applications shall be presented after serving copies thereof in advance on the opposite side or his advocate or authorised representative.
(6) The processing fee prescribed by the rules, with required number of envelopes of sufficient size and notice forms as prescribed shall be filled along with memorandum of appeal.”
16. In terms of Rule 103, the Appellate Tribunal may allow the filing of an appeal or proceedings through electronic mode. Rule 103 provides that:
“103. Filing through electronic media.—The Appellate Tribunal may allow filing of appeal or proceedings through electronic mode such as online filing and provide for rectification of defects by e-mail or internet and in such filing, these rules shall be adopted as nearly as possible on and from a date to be notified separately and the Central Government may issue instructions in this behalf from time to time.”
17. On 3-1-2021, Nclat notified a revised SOP for the hearing of cases through the virtual mode, using its e-filing portal. The SOP notices that an e-filing facility was available for filing of appeals and related documents, and exhorts “all concerned” to “avail the same through Nclat e-filing portal”. The circular provides as follows:
“It may be noted that it is mandatory that learned Advocates/Authorised Representatives/Parties-in-Person shall file the appeal/interlocutory application/reply/rejoinder, etc. in hard copy also as per the procedure prescribed in Nclat Rules, 2016 along with the e-filing receipt. The online filing and hard copies must match with proper pagination. The court fee shall be paid through Bharat Kosh (https://bharatkosh. gov.in) and the payment receipt should be attached.”
18. Subsequently, on 21-10-2022, the Registrar of Nclat issued another order F. No. 10/37/2018-Nclat, dated 21-10-2022 with regard to computing limitation for the purpose of filing an appeal before the Appellate Tribunal. The order notices that while Rule 22 of the Nclat Rules, 2016 provides for the presentation of an appeal at the filing counter of Nclat, Rule 103 permits the filing of appeals or proceedings through the electronic mode. After adverting to the SOP dated 3-1-2021, the order indicates as follows:
“The SOPs and directions issued by the Appellate Tribunal do not contain any direction with regard to computation of limitation as to whether limitation is to be computed from the date of e-filing of the appeals or from the date when appeals are presented before the Appellate Tribunal as per Rule 22 of the Nclat Rules, 2016. The Competent Authority has, therefore, decided to issue directions in exercise of power conferred by Rule 104 of the Nclat Rules, 2016 with regard to computation of limitation for the purposes of filing an appeal in the Appellate Tribunal.
Hence, with regard to computation of limitation in appeals, following directions are hereby issued by the Competent Authority:
(1) The period of limitation shall be computed from the date of presentation of appeal as per Rule 22 of the Nclat Rules, 2016.
(2) The requirement of filing appeals by electronic mode shall continue along with mandatory filing of the appeals as per Rule 22 of the Nclat Rules, 2016.
(3) This order will be effective with effect from 1-11-2022.
All concerned shall ensure that appeals are presented as per Rule 22 of the Nclat Rules, 2016 within the period of limitation at the filing counter.”
19. The above order dated 21-10-2022 indicates that the SOPs and directions which were issued by Nclat did not contain any provision for the computation of limitation, more specifically on whether limitation has to be computed with reference to the date of e-filing or from the date on which the appeal is presented before Nclat, in terms of Rule 22. Hence, in exercise of the power conferred by Rule 104, it was notified that the period of limitation would be computed with reference to the date of the presentation of the appeal in terms of Rule 22. Moreover, the requirement of filing appeals by the electronic mode was directed to continue together with the mandatory filing of appeals under Rule 22. The order dated 21-10-2022 was to be effective from 1-11-2022.
20. Eventually, on 24-12-2022, another order was issued by the Registrar of Nclat in the following terms:
“It is seen that appeals are e-filed from different parts of the country where the appellant in some cases is located in far away places and time is taken to file physical copy. It is further seen that physical copy is filed within seven days of e-filing.
Hence, with regard to computation of limitation in appeals, following directions are hereby issued by the Competent Authority:
(1) The order F.No.10/37/2018-Nclat dated 21-10-2022 is hereby withdrawn and superseded by this order.
(2) Limitation shall be computed from the date of e-filing. The hard copy has to be filed within 7 days of e-filing. However, the competent authority is at liberty to notify to extend the period of filing hard copy in case of any unforeseen exigency. In a case where hard copy is filed after 7 days, the appeal will be placed before the Tribunal for appropriate order.
(3) The requirement of filing appeals by electronic mode shall continue along with mandatory filing of the appeals as per Rule 22 of the Nclat Rules, 2016.
(4) This order will be effective with immediate effect.
All concerned shall ensure that appeals are presented as per Rule 22 of the Nclat Rules, 2016 within the period of limitation at the filing counter.”
21. Hence, by the order dated 24-12-2022, it was clarified that limitation shall be computed with reference to the date of e-filing while the physical copy would have to be filed within seven days of e-filing. The order clarifies that the requirement of filing appeals by the electronic mode shall continue together with the mandatory filing of appeals in terms of Rule 22 of the Nclat Rules, 2016.
22. Having regard to the above sequence of Rules and administrative orders, it is evident that on the one hand, Rule 22 of the Nclat Rules, 2016 requires the presentation of an appeal at the filing counter in the prescribed mode, but on the other, Nclat also envisages e-filing of appeals. This is made evident in the SOP dated 3-1-2021 which mandates the filing of a physical copy of an appeal as per the procedure prescribed in Nclat Rules, 2016, while referring to the procedure for the hearing of cases through the virtual mode, using the e-filing portal. The subsequent order dated 21-10-2022 acknowledges that there was an absence of clarity in regard to the period with reference to which limitation would commence. Hence, the order purported to state that the period of limitation shall be computed from the date of the presentation of an appeal under Rule 22. Significantly, the above order was to be effective from 1-11-2022. In the present case, admittedly, the appeal was e-filed on 10-10-2022 and even a physical copy was lodged on 31-10-2022 prior to the date on which the order of the Registrar dated 21-10-2022 was to come into effect. The order dated 21-10-2022 was subsequently withdrawn on 24-12-2022. The order dated 24-12-2022 now clarifies that limitation would be computed with effect from the date of e-filing but a physical copy would have to be filed within seven days of e-filing.
23. In the present case, the order was pronounced by NCLT on 26-8-2022 2022 SCC OnLine NCLT 375. Rule 3 of the Nclat Rules, 2016 stipulates that the date from which the period of limitation has to be reckoned (i.e. the date of the pronouncement of the order) would have to be excluded. Hence, the date on which the order was pronounced by NCLT, namely, 26-8-2022 would have to be excluded from the computation of limitation. This is in line with Section 12(1) of the Limitation Act, 1963. As noted earlier, the provisions of the Limitation Act, 1963 are made applicable, inter alia, to appeals before Nclat by virtue of Section 238-A IBC.
24. Section 12(1) of the Limitation Act, 1963 provides as follows:
“12. Exclusion of time in legal proceedings.—(1) In computing the period of limitation for any suit, appeal or application, the day from which such period is to be reckoned, shall be excluded.”
25. Between 26-8-2022, when the order was pronounced by NCLT, and 10-10-2022, when the appeal was e-filed, a period of 45 days elapsed after excluding the date on which the order was pronounced. Nclat has erroneously proceeded on the basis that the appeal was lodged on the 46th day whereas correctly computed, the appeal was lodged on the 45th day. This is evident from the following table:
Sl. No. Period Days 1. Between 26 August to 31 August 05 days 2. Between 1 September to 30 September 30 days 3. Between 1 October to 10 October 10 days Total (5+30+10) 45 days
26. The power of condoning a delay of up to 15 days beyond the original period of 30 days lies within the discretionary power of Nclat. The appeal was instituted within the outer limit of 45 days.
27. Furthermore, in terms of Section 12(2) of the Limitation Act, 1963, the time requisite for obtaining a copy of the order appealed from has to be excluded while computing the period of limitation. The Explanation to Section 12 clarifies that the time taken by the court to prepare an order before an application for a copy thereof is made shall not be excluded. The relevant part of Section 12 provides as follows:
“12. Exclusion of time in legal proceedings.—(1) ***
(2) In computing the period of limitation for an appeal or an application for leave to appeal or for revision or for review of a judgment, the day on which the judgment complained of was pronounced and the time requisite for obtaining a copy of the decree, sentence or order appealed from or sought to be revised or reviewed shall be excluded.
(3)-(4) ***
Explanation.—In computing under this section the time requisite for obtaining a copy of a decree or an order, any time taken by the court to prepare the decree or order before an application for a copy thereof is made shall not be excluded.”
28. In V. Nagarajan (2022) 2 SCC 244, (2022) 1 SCC (Civ) 741, a three-Judge Bench of this Court observed that Rule 22(2) of the Nclat Rules, 2016 mandates that an appeal has to be filed with a certified copy of the impugned order 2023 SCC OnLine NCLAT 695. The Court held that limitation commences once the order was pronounced and the time taken by the court to provide the appellant with a certified copy would be excluded, as clarified in Section 12(2) of the Limitation Act, 1963, if the appellant had applied for a certified copy within the prescribed period of limitation under Section 61(2) IBC. In the facts of the case, this Court held that the appeal was barred by limitation as the appellant demonstrated no effort to secure a certified copy and only relied on the date of the uploading of the order of the website. This Court (2022) 2 SCC 244, (2022) 1 SCC (Civ) 741 held that : (V. Nagarajan case (2022) 2 SCC 244, (2022) 1 SCC (Civ) 741, SCC pp. 264-65, paras 29 & 31)
“29. On the question of a certified copy for filing an appeal against an order passed by NCLT under IBC, Rule 22(2) of the Nclat Rules mandates that an appeal has to be filed with a certified copy of the “impugned order”:
***
Therefore, it cannot be said that the parties can automatically dispense with their obligation to apply for and obtain a certified copy for filing an appeal. Any delay in receipt of a certified copy, once an application has been filed, has been envisaged by the legislature and duly excluded to not cause any prejudice to a litigant's right to appeal.
30. ***
31. The import of Section 12 of the Limitation Act and its Explanation is to assign the responsibility of applying for a certified copy of the order on a party. A person wishing to file an appeal is expected to file an application for a certified copy before the expiry of the limitation period, upon which the “time requisite” for obtaining a copy is to be excluded. However, the time taken by the court to prepare the decree or order before an application for a copy is made cannot be excluded. If no application for a certified copy has been made, no exclusion can ensue. In fact, the Explanation to the provision is a clear indicator of the legal position that the time which is taken by the court to prepare the decree or order cannot be excluded before the application to obtain a copy is made. It cannot be said that the right to receive a free copy under Section 420(3) of the Companies Act obviated the obligation on the appellant to seek a certified copy through an application. The appellant has urged that Rule 14 of the Nclat Rules empowers Nclat to exempt parties from compliance with the requirement of any of the rules in the interests of substantial justice, which has been typically exercised in favour of allowing a downloaded copy in lieu of a certified copy. While it may well be true that waivers on filing an appeal with a certified copy are often granted for the purposes of judicial determination, they do not confer an automatic right on an applicant to dispense with compliance and render Rule 22(2) of the Nclat Rules nugatory.”
(emphasis supplied)
29. In the present case, the application for a certified copy was sent from Delhi to Chennai on 2-9-2022, which was received on 5-9-2022, within the period of limitation of 30 days specified in Section 61(2). This aspect lies in contrast to the facts as they obtained before this Court in the judgment in V. Nagarajan (2022) 2 SCC 244, (2022) 1 SCC (Civ) 741 where even the application for obtaining the certified copy was not filed. In the present case, the appellant exercised due diligence and applied for a certified copy upon pronouncement of the order in terms of Rule 22(2) of the Nclat Rules, 2016. The certified copy was provided to the appellant on 15-9-2022. Hence, the period of 10 days between 5-9-2022 and 15-9-2022 taken by the court to provide a certified copy of the order ought to be excluded when determining the period of limitation under Section 61(2) IBC.
30. In view of the above discussion, we have come to the conclusion that Nclat was in error in dismissing the appeal on the ground of limitation. The explanation which was advanced by the appellant for condoning the period of 5 days (beyond the period of 30 days stipulated for the filing of an appeal) was, in our view, sufficient and the delay should have been condoned within the four corners of the statute.
31. Before concluding, we cannot but fail to notice the flip-flops on the part of Nclat in providing administrative guidance on whether limitation would commence from the date of e-filing or from the presentation of the appeal at the filing counter. With technological advances, the country's judiciary and tribunals must move towards e-filing. This process has already commenced and is irreversible. The Union Government must have a fresh look at the rules to encourage e-filing across tribunals. Perhaps one way forward would be to constitute a Working Group to make a comprehensive assessment of the position across tribunals and suggest regulatory changes. Moreover, it is utterly incomprehensible why Nclat should insist on physical filing in addition to e-filing. This unnecessarily burdens litigants and the Bar and is a disincentive for e-filing. A lawyer or litigant who is compelled to file physical copies in addition to e-filed documents will have no cogent reason to resort to e-filing. This duplication of effort is time consuming. It adds to expense. It leaves behind a carbon footprint which is difficult to efface. The judicial process has traditionally been guzzling paper. This model is not environmentally sustainable. If some Judges are uncomfortable with e-files, the answer is to provide training to them and not to continue with old and outmoded ways of working. The judiciary has to modernise and adapt to technology. The tribunals can be no exception. This can no longer be a matter of choice. The IBC is a significant prong in economic reforms. It has radically reshaped the law relating to insolvency and bankruptcy. The manner in which the law is administered will have to keep pace with technology. Both the Union Government in its rule-making capacity and the administrative heads of tribunals must ensure a seamless transition to working in the electronic mode.
32. A copy of this judgment shall be forwarded to the Chairperson of Nclat and to the Secretaries to the Union Government, respectively, in the Ministries of : (i) Finance; (ii) Corporate Affairs; and (iii) Law and Justice for ensuring compliance and remedial steps.
33. We accordingly allow the appeal and set aside the order of Nclat dated 9-1-2023 2023 SCC OnLine NCLAT 695. The appeal shall accordingly be restored to the file of Nclat for disposal on merits. Pending application(s), if any, stand disposed of.
Alert