Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Directorate Of Enforcement Petitioner(s) v. State Of Tamil Nadu And Others (s).

Supreme Court Of India
Feb 27, 2024
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, the Directorate of Enforcement (ED), filed Special Leave Petitions challenging a common interim order dated 28.11.2023 passed by the High Court of Madras in Writ Petition Nos. 33459 to 33462 and 33467 of 2023. The High Court had granted an interim stay on the operation of summons issued by the ED to the District Collectors of Vellore, Trichy, Karur, Thanjavur, and Ariyalur, which required their appearance to give evidence and produce records in connection with investigation/proceedings under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (PMLA).

The writ petitions in the High Court were filed by the State of Tamil Nadu along with the Additional Chief Secretary and the concerned District Collectors under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The Court characterized these writ petitions as unusual and noted that they sought relief that would indirectly stall or delay the ED’s inquiry/investigation based on four FIRs, some of whose offences are scheduled offences under the PMLA.

The ED’s summons were issued under Section 50(2) of the PMLA. The Court heard learned ASG Mr. S.V. Raju for the petitioner and learned Senior Advocates Mr. Kapil Sibal and Mr. Mukul Rohtagi for the respondents appearing on caveat.

The Court stayed the High Court’s interim order, directed the District Collectors to appear and respond to the ED’s summons on the next date indicated by the ED, listed the matter after four weeks, and directed completion of pleadings in the meantime.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the ED’s issuance of summons under Section 50(2) of the PMLA to District Collectors to give evidence and produce records during an investigation was lawful and binding.
  2. Whether the High Court’s interim stay of the operation of such summons was legally sustainable.
  3. Whether writ petitions filed by the State and its officers, which would indirectly stall or delay the ED’s PMLA investigation linked to FIRs containing scheduled offences, were maintainable or were misconceived in light of constitutional obligations, including Article 256.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

  • The Court examined Section 50(2) of the PMLA, which empowers designated ED officers to summon any person whose attendance is considered necessary during investigation or proceedings under the Act. It further noted Section 50(3), which binds persons so summoned to attend, state the truth, and produce required documents.
  • The Court observed that the ED was conducting inquiry/investigation under the PMLA in connection with four FIRs:
    • FIR No. 08 2018 dated 23.08.2018 (V&AC, Thanjavur) under IPC Sections 120(B), 421, 409, 109 and P.C. Act Sections 13(1)(c), 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2) r/w IPC Section 109, etc.
    • FIR No. 03 2020 dated 20.10.2020 (V&AC, Dindigul) under IPC Sections 41, 109 and P.C. Act Section 7(a).
    • FIR No. 02 2022 dated 05.02.2022 (V&AC, Theni) under multiple IPC and P.C. Act provisions, including Sections 7, 13(c), 13(1)(d)(1), 13(1)(a) r/w 13(2) and 12 of the P.C. Act; IPC Sections 120(B), 167, 379, 409, 465, 468, 471, 477 r/w 109; and amended P.C. Act provisions.
    • FIR No. 68/2023 dated 25.04.2023 (Murappanadu Police Station, Thoothukudi District) under IPC Sections 449, 332, 302, and 506(2).
    The Court noted that some offences in these FIRs are scheduled offences under the PMLA, thereby bringing the investigation/proceedings within the PMLA framework. Consequently, the District Collectors or other persons summoned under Section 50(2) are obliged to respect and respond to the summons.
  • The Court remarked that writ petitions filed by the State Government challenging such summons appeared “thoroughly misconceived.” It also characterized the High Court’s interim stay as passed under an “utter misconception of law.” The Court underscored that Article 256 of the Constitution obliges State Governments to exercise their executive power to ensure compliance with laws made by Parliament, indicating that State-initiated litigation that stalls or delays a statutory investigation runs contrary to this obligation.
  • In view of these statutory provisions and the nature of the investigation, the Court decided to stay the operation of the High Court’s interim order.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The operation and execution of the Madras High Court’s common interim order dated 28.11.2023 staying the ED’s summons is stayed, pending the Special Leave Petitions. The District Collectors shall appear and respond to the ED’s summons on the next date indicated by the ED. The matter is to be listed after four weeks, and pleadings shall be completed in the meantime.

Implications: The immediate effect is that the ED’s investigation under the PMLA may proceed without the restraint of the High Court’s interim stay, and the District Collectors must comply with the summons. The order is interim in nature and addresses only the parties’ obligations pending further proceedings; no broader legal precedent is set in this opinion.

Show all summary ...

1. Heard learned ASG Mr. S.V. Raju for the petitioner and the learned Senior Advocates Mr. Kapil Sibal and Mr. Mukul Rohtagi for the respondents appearing on caveat.

2. The instant Special Leave Petitions have been filed by the petitioner - Directorate of Enforcement (ED) challenging the common interim order dated 28.11.2023 passed by the High Court of Madras in Writ Petition Nos. 33459 to 33462 and 33467 of 2023, by which the High Court has granted interim stay of the operation of the impugned summons issued by the petitioner - ED, to the District Collectors of Vellore District, Trichy District. Karur District, Thanjavur District and Ariyalur District, requiring their appearance to give evidence and produce records as indicated in the annexures annexed to the said summons, in connection with the investigation/proceedings under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (PMLA).

3. A very strange and unusual Writ Petitions have been filed by the State of Tamil Nadu alongwith the Additional Chief Secretary and District Collectors against the Directorate of Enforcement under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, before the High Court seeking relief, which would indirectly stall or delay the inquiry/investigation being made by the petitioner - ED based on the four FIRs registered for the various offences, some of which are scheduled offences under the PMLA. It hardly needs to be mentioned that Article 256 of the Constitution of India obliges the State Government to exercise its executive power to ensure compliance with the laws made by the Parliament.

4. The impugned summons have been issued by the petitioner - ED, in exercise of the powers conferred upon it under Section 50(2) of the PMLA, which reads as under:—

“(2) The Director, Additional Director, Joint Director, Deputy Director or Assistant Director shall have power to summon any person whose attendance he considers necessary whether to give evidence or to produce any records during the course of any investigation or proceeding under this Act.”

5. Sub-section (3) of Section 50 thereof being relevant, reads as under:—

“(3) All the persons so summoned shall be bound to attend in person or through authorised agents, as such officer may direct, and shall be bound to state the truth upon any subject respecting which they are examined or make statements, and produce such documents as may be required.”

6. From the bare reading of the said provisions, it clearly transpires that the concerned officers as mentioned therein, have the power to summon any person whose attendance he considers necessary, either to give evidence or produce any record during the course of investigation or proceeding under the PMLA. Since, the petitioner - ED is conducting the inquiry/investigation under the PMLA, in connection with the four FIRs, namely (I) FIR No. 08 2018 dated 23.08.2018 registered by V&AC, Thanjavur, under Sections 120(B), 421, 409, 109 of IPC and Sections 13(1)(c), 13(l)(d) r/w 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (P.C. Act) r/w 109 of IPC etc.; (II) FIR No. 03 2020 dated 20.10.2020 registered by V&AC, Dindigul under Sections 41, 109 of IPC and Section 7(a) of P.C. Act; (III) FIR No. 02 2022 dated 05.02.2022 registered by V&AC, Theni under Sections 7, 13(c), 13(l)(d)(l), 13(l)(a) r/w 13(2) and 12 of P.C. Act, Sections 120(B), 167, 379, 409, 465, 468, 471, 477 r/w 109 of IPC and Sections 7, 8(1), 13(l)(a) r/w 13(2) and 12 of PC Act, as amended; (IV) FIR No. 68/2023 dated 25.04.2023 registered by Murappanadu Police Station, Thoothukudi District, under Section 449, 332, 302 and 506(2) of IPC, and since some of the offences of the said FIRs are scheduled offences under PMLA, the same would be the investigation/proceeding under the PMLA, and the District Collectors or the persons to whom the summons are issued under Section 50(2) of the Act are obliged to respect and respond to the said summons.

7. The Writ Petitions filed, at the instance of the State Government, challenging such summons issued to the District Collectors prima facie appears to be thoroughly misconceived, and the impugned order passed by the High Court also being under utter misconception of law, we are inclined to stay the operation of the impugned order.

8. Accordingly, the operation and execution of the impugned order is stayed, pending the present SLPs. The District Collectors shall appear and respond to the summons in question issued by the petitioner - ED on the next date, that may be indicated by the ED.

9. List after four weeks.

10. In the meantime, pleadings be completed.