Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

STATE THROUGH INSPECTOR OF POLICE CBI CHENNAI v. NARESH PRASAD AGARWAL

Supreme Court Of India
Feb 13, 2024
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal arose from a judgment of a learned Single Judge of the Madras High Court. Two proceedings were decided together by that judgment:

  • A petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, seeking quashing of the charge-sheet in C.C. No. 3 of 2014 pending before the Special Judge, CBI Cases, Chennai.
  • A criminal revision challenging the Special Judge’s order dated 4 August 2015 rejecting an application by the respondents for discharge in the same case.

On 17 April 2017, the Single Judge pronounced only the operative portion of his decision, quashing the charge-sheet against the first respondent and allowing discharge of another accused. The Judge demitted office on 26 May 2017, but a detailed reasoned judgment running to more than 250 pages was released only on 23 October 2017—five months after the Judge had left office.

The State through the CBI appealed to the Supreme Court, contending that delivery of reasons after demitting office rendered the High Court judgment invalid.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a High Court Judge can validly supply a detailed, reasoned judgment several months after pronouncing a one-line operative order and after having demitted judicial office.
  2. Consequently, whether the impugned High Court judgment should be set aside and the matters remitted for fresh consideration.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (State/CBI)

  • Highlighted that the Single Judge pronounced only a one-line order on 17 April 2017 and issued the full 250-page judgment five months after leaving office, an act amounting to gross impropriety.
  • Contended that such conduct violates the fundamental principle that justice must not only be done but be seen to be done.
  • Urged the Supreme Court to set aside the High Court judgment in its entirety.

Respondents

  • Requested the Supreme Court to ignore the procedural irregularity and independently examine the merits of the quashing and discharge orders.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted that the Single Judge had five weeks between pronouncing the operative order and demitting office, yet failed to deliver a reasoned judgment within that period. Retaining the file for five months thereafter to write reasons was characterised as “an act of gross impropriety.”

Invoking Lord Hewart’s dictum that “justice must not only be done, but must also be seen to be done,” the Court held that the circumstances undermined public confidence in the administration of justice. It declined the respondents’ invitation to decide the case on merits, concluding that the only permissible course was to set aside the tainted judgment and remit the matters to the High Court for a fresh, lawful adjudication.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The impugned judgment in Criminal O.P. No. 21243/2014 and Criminal Revision Case No. 1191/2015 is set aside; both matters are restored to the file of the Madras High Court for fresh disposal in accordance with law. The Supreme Court expressly refrained from ruling on the merits of the underlying criminal proceedings, leaving all issues open.

Implications: The immediate effect is that the High Court must rehear the quashing and discharge applications. The Supreme Court’s decision underscores judicial propriety: a judge must deliver reasoned judgments before demitting office. No new substantive precedent on criminal law was created, but the ruling reinforces procedural norms vital to public confidence in the judiciary.

Show all summary ...

2024 INSC 120

NON-REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS.829-830 OF 2024 (Arising out of S.L.P.(Criminal) Nos.2210-2211 of 2024 @ Diary No.29911 of 2018)

STATE THROUGH INSPECTOR OF POLICE

CBI CHENNAI ... APPELLANT(S)

VS.

NARESH PRASAD AGARWAL & ANR. ... RESPONDENT(S)

J U D G M E N T

ABHAY S.OKA, J.

Delay condoned.

2. Leave granted.

3. Heard the learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant and the learned senior counsel appearing for the respondents.

4. The learned Single Judge of the Madras High Court decided two proceedings by the impugned judgment. The first was a petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 for quashing the charge sheet in CC No.3 of 2014 pending on the file of the learned Special Judge, CBI cases, Chennai. The second was a Criminal Revision Application challenging the order

1

dated 4th August, 2015 by which an application for discharge made by the respondents in the same case was rejected by the impugned judgment. The learned Judge quashed the charge sheet, insofar as the first respondent is concerned and by setting aside the order dated 4th August, 2015, an order of discharge was passed as regards another accused.

5. One of the contentions raised in these appeals is that on 17th April, 2017, the learned Single Judge pronounced only one line order declaring the operative part. The learned Judge demitted office on 26th May, 2017 and a detailed judgment was made available only on 23rd October, 2017, nearly 5 months after the learned Judge demitted the office. On these facts, there is no dispute.

6. The operative part was pronounced on 17th April, 2017. There were five weeks available for the learned Judge to release the reasoned judgment till the date on which he demitted office. However, the detailed judgment running into more than 250 pages has come out after a lapse of 5 months from the date on which the learned Judge demitted the office. Thus, it is obvious that even after the learned Judge demitted the office, he assigned reasons and made the judgment ready. According to us,

2

retaining file of a case for a period of 5 months after demitting the office is an act of gross impropriety on the part of the learned Judge. We cannot countenance what has been done in this case.

7. The learned senior counsel appearing for the respondents tried to urge that we should independently hear the case on merits.

8. Lord Hewart said hundred years back that "justice must not only be done, but must also be seen to be done". What has been done in this case is contrary to what Lord Hewart said. We cannot support such acts of impropriety and, therefore, in our view, the only option for this Court is to set aside the impugned judgment and remit the cases to the High Court for a fresh decision.

9. Accordingly, we set aside the impugned judgment in Criminal O.P.No.21243/2014 and Criminal Revision Case No.1191/2015 in Criminal M.P.No.3613/2014 in CC No.03/2014 and restore both the matters to the file of the High Court of Judicature at Madras. Both the cases shall be decided by the High Court afresh in accordance with law.

10. Needless to add that we have made no adjudication on the merits of the controversy and all issues are left open to be decided by the High Court. If there are any

3

subsequent events, the parties are free to bring it to the notice of the High Court in accordance with law.

11. The appeals are accordingly partly allowed.

..........................J.

(ABHAY S.OKA)

..........................J.

(UJJAL BHUYAN)

NEW DELHI;

February 13, 2024.

4