Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

B. P. TIWARI v. STATE OF CHHATTISGARH

Chhattisgarh High Court
Nov 22, 2023
Smart Summary (Beta)

High Court of Chhattisgarh — Writ Petition (S) No.2689 of 2021 (B.P. Tiwari)

Factual and Procedural Background

Petitioner B.P. Tiwari was initially appointed as an Assistant Revenue Inspector and served as Incharge Chief Municipal Officer, Nagar Panchayat Chhuriya. An audit for the financial year 2008-09 alleged misappropriation by the Petitioner and two other employees: the initial audit indicated misappropriation of Rs.1,30,137, while a subsequent special audit recorded a total of Rs.10,14,170 purportedly misappropriated.

No show cause notice or departmental inquiry was issued against the Petitioner prior to his superannuation on 31 March 2019. After retirement, when the Petitioner sought retiral dues (gratuity and pension), respondents issued orders dated 21 January 2021 and communication dated 22 March 2021 showing gratuity of Rs.6,89,535 sanctioned but withholding Rs.4,68,194; the Petitioner was paid Rs.2,21,341 only. The Petitioner filed the present writ petition challenging the withholding and seeking release of full gratuity (and related reliefs).

Respondents (State/1–5) stated that withholding was due to audit objections and that a departmental inquiry was pending; they also stated 90% of pension had been sanctioned while gratuity was withheld pending final decision on audit objection.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the withholding of a portion of the Petitioner's gratuity after his retirement was permissible in the circumstances of this case.
  2. Whether Rule 64(1)(c) of the Chhattisgarh Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1976 (and/or the principles in State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih) applied so as to permit recovery or withholding of gratuity from a Class-III employee who retired without any inquiry or show cause notice pending at the time of retirement.
  3. Whether, in the absence of any departmental inquiry or criminal proceedings pending on the date of retirement, the Petitioner was entitled to the entire gratuity amount and interest from the date of retirement until payment.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Before retirement (31.03.2019) no show cause notice was issued and no departmental inquiry was initiated against the Petitioner regarding the audit report of 2008-09.
  • Since the Petitioner retired as Revenue Sub Inspector (a Class-III post), Rule 64(1)(c) of the Pension Rules would not apply and, relying on the Supreme Court judgment in State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (2015) 4 SCC 334, recovery from or withholding of gratuity from Class-III/IV employees is impermissible.
  • Therefore, the Petitioner is entitled to the full gratuity amount which had been withheld.

Respondents' Arguments (State / Respondents 1–5)

  • The Municipal Corporation (Bhilai) had sought a No Objection Certificate from Nagar Panchayat Chhuriya for the period the Petitioner served there; this was not issued because of audit objections and pending recoveries.
  • After retirement, the pension case was processed and 90% of pension was sanctioned; gratuity has been withheld until final decision on the audit objection.
  • The State contended a departmental inquiry was pending against the Petitioner post-retirement and that the withheld gratuity would be released after the inquiry's conclusion consistent with law.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer), (2015) 4 SCC 334 The Supreme Court identified situations where recovery from an employee is impermissible, including: (i) recovery from Class-III and Class-IV employees; (ii) recovery from retired employees or those due to retire within one year of the recovery order; (iii) recovery when excess payment covers a period exceeding five years before the recovery order; (iv) recovery where the employee was wrongly required to discharge duties of a higher post; and (v) cases where recovery would be iniquitous, harsh or arbitrary. The High Court held that the present case falls within the situations contemplated in Rafiq Masih (notably recovery from a Class-III employee who retired without any inquiry or show cause notice pending). On that ground the Court found withholding of gratuity after retirement impermissible and ordered release of full gratuity with interest.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first recorded the undisputed facts: the Petitioner retired as a Revenue Sub Inspector (Class-III) on 31.03.2019; the audit related to 2008-09; and no show cause notice or departmental inquiry had been initiated prior to retirement.

The Court applied the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in Rafiq Masih, which lists categories where recovery is impermissible. The Court concluded that the present matter is covered by those principles because the Petitioner was a Class-III employee who retired without any inquiry or charge-sheet pending against him on the date of retirement.

The State's claim that a departmental inquiry was pending post-retirement was noted, but the State did not file supporting documents. The Court observed that no judicial/criminal proceedings under Rule 9(6)(b)(i) of the Pension Rules, 1976 were instituted or pending on the date of retirement; any charge-sheet was issued after retirement. Consequently, the doctrine that would permit withholding until completion of inquiry did not apply in the Petitioner's case.

On these foundations, the Court held that withholding gratuity after retirement was impermissible and the Petitioner was entitled to the full gratuity as of the date of retirement. The Court then determined relief in the form of monetary payment with interest and imposed a time limit for compliance, while expressly preserving the respondents' right to proceed in accordance with law with respect to the audit report.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The writ petition is allowed. The Respondents are directed to release the full gratuity due to the Petitioner and to pay interest as ordered.

Direct consequences and directions:

  • Respondents must release the full gratuity amount payable to the Petitioner.
  • Respondents must pay simple interest at 8% per annum on the full gratuity amount from the date of the Petitioner's retirement until actual and final payment.
  • If the Respondents fail to pay within three months of receipt of the order, interest at 10% per annum shall be payable for the same period in place of 8%.
  • The order does not bar the Respondents from proceeding in accordance with law in respect of the audit report; the Court's direction is limited to payment of gratuity and interest given the facts (no inquiry/charge-sheet pending at retirement and applicability of Rafiq Masih principles).

No indication in the opinion that the Court intended to lay down any new law or departure from the precedent; the decision applies established Supreme Court principles to the facts before the Court.

Show all summary ...

NAFR

HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH, BILASPUR

Writ Petition (S) No.2689 of 2021 B.P. Tiwari, son of late Chandrika Prasad, aged about 64 years, R/o Sector 7, Road No.36/1/D, Bhilai, District Durg, Chhattisgarh

----- Petitioner

versus

1. State of Chhattisgarh through Secretary, Mantralaya, Atal Nagar, Nawa Raipur, District Raipur, Chhattisgarh

2. State of Chhattisgarh through Secretary, Urban Administration Development Department, Atal Nagar, Nawa Raipur, District Raipur, Chhattisgarh

3. Joint Director, Regional Office, Urban Administration Development Department, Subhash Stadium, Raipur, Chhattisgarh

4. Deputy Director, Local Fund Audit Rajnandgaon, District Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh

5. Deputy Director (Pension), Urban Administration Development Department, Atal Nagar, Nawa Raipur, District Raipur, Chhattisgarh

6. Nagar Nigam, Bhilai through the Commissioner, Nagar Nigam Bhilai, District Durg, Chhattisgarh

7. Chief Municipal Officer, Nagar Nigam Bhilai, District Durg, Chhattisgarh

-----Respondents

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

For Petitioner : Shri Rahul Agrawal, Advocate

For Respondents 1 to 5 : Ms. Katyayani Vishnupriya, Deputy

Government Advocate

For Respondents 6 & 7 : Shri Rishabh Bisen, Advocate

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hon'ble Shri Justice Arvind Singh Chandel

Order on Board

22.11.2023

1. With the consent of Learned Counsel appearing for the parties, the matter is heard finally.

1

2

2. The instant petition has been moved seeking the following reliefs:

"10.1 This Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to quash the impugned order dated 22.3.2021 (Annexure P-

1).

10.2 That, as an alternative this Hon'ble Court may kindly direct the respondent authority to decide the audit objection within stipulated period of time to fasten the liability upon the petitioner for recovery.

10.3 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to direct the respondent authority to make payment of the gratuity amount to the petitioner.

10.4 Any other relief, which this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper, may also be passed in favour of the petitioner together with cost of the petition."

3. Facts of the case, in short, are that initially the Petitioner was appointed as an Assistant Revenue Inspector and was posted as Incharge Chief Municipal Officer, Nagar Panchayat, Chhuriya. During the financial year 2008-09 an audit was conducted in Nagar Panchayat Chhuriya and as per the audit report it was alleged that the Petitioner along with other two employees had committed misappropriation of fund of the Nagar Panchayat amounting to Rs.1,30,137. A special audit was also conducted in which it was found that total sum of Rs.10,14,170 was misappropriated by the Petitioner and other two employees, but, since then, no further action was taken on that issue nor was any show cause notice issued to the Petitioner nor was any inquiry conducted. The Petitioner

3

superannuated on 31.3.2019. Thereafter, when the Petitioner moved an application before the concerned authorities for grant of his retiral dues including gratuity and pension, the Respondents authorities issued the impugned order dated 21.1.2021 (Annexure P4) and the communication dated 22.3.2021 (Annexure P1) which show that the amount of gratuity of Rs.6,89,535 has been sanctioned. However, the amount of Rs.4,68,194 has been withheld. That is, Rs.2,21,341 only has been paid to the Petitioner towards gratuity. Hence, the instant petition.

4. In their return, the State/Respondents 1 to 5 pleaded that vide letter dated 5.8.2019 Municipal Corporation, Bhilai had sought for no objection certificate from Nagar Panchayat Chhuriya for the period while the Petitioner was posted as Incharge Chief Municipal Officer. However, the same was not issued owing to the audit objection and that recoveries of the dues were pending. After retirement of the Petitioner on 31.3.2019 the pension case of the Petitioner was received by the office of the Director, Pension, Urban Administration and Development Department and as such no dues, no inquiry and no event certificate was received. 90% of the pension of the Petitioner has been sanctioned, whereas the payment of the gratuity has been withheld. Vide order dated 21.1.2021, the Director sanctioned the final pension of the Petitioner and gratuity

4

amount of Rs.6,89,535. However, till the final decision is taken in respect of the audit objection, amount of Rs.4,68,194, out of total gratuity payable to the Petitioner, has been withheld. It is further pleaded by the State that a departmental inquiry against the Petitioner in respect of the audit objection is pending and as soon as decision is taken on the said inquiry the gratuity which has been withheld will be paid to the Petitioner in accordance with law as per the outcome of the said inquiry.

5. Learned Counsel appearing for the Petitioner submits that the Petitioner has been retired from service on 31.3.2019. Before his retirement, no show cause notice was issued to him nor was any departmental inquiry initiated against him in respect of the audit report. He further submits that the allegation of misappropriation of fund was of the financial year 2008-09 and the Petitioner retired from the service on 31.3.2019. Before retirement of the Petitioner, no show cause notice was issued to him nor was any departmental inquiry initiated against him in respect of the said audit report. Therefore, Rule 64(1)(c) of the Chhattisgarh Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1976 (henceforth 'the Pension Rules, 1976') would not be applicable and the Petitioner is entitled to get the entire gratuity amount. It is further submitted that since the substantial position of the Petitioner at the time of retirement

5

was Revenue Sub Inspector, which is a Class-III post, in the light of judgment passed by the Supreme Court in State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer), (2015) 4 SCC 334, no recovery can be made from the Petitioner and the Respondents cannot withheld his any amount. They are liable to release his entire gratuity amount.

6. Learned Counsel appearing for the State/Respondents 1 to 5 submits that a departmental inquiry is pending against the Petitioner in respect of the audit report and as soon as decision is taken on the said departmental inquiry his gratuity amount will be released and paid to him as per the outcome of the said inquiry.

7. Learned Counsel appearing for the Nagar Nigam/Respondents 6 and 7 opposes the contentions raised on behalf of the Petitioner.

8. I have heard the contentions put-forth on behalf of the parties and perused the material available including the documents filed with due care.

9. Undisputedly, the Petitioner was appointed as an Assistant Revenue Inspector and at the time of his retirement he was posted as Revenue Sub Inspector which is a Class-III post. Dealing with the issue, the Supreme Court in Rafiq Masih (supra) laid down certain situations under which the recovery

6

is totally impermissible under law. The situations as envisaged by the Supreme Court are as under:

"18. …..

(i) Recovery from the employees belonging to Class III and Class IV service (or Group C and Group D service).

(ii) Recovery from the retired employees, or the employees who are due to retire within one year, of the order of recovery.

(iii) Recovery from the employees, when the excess payment has been made for a period in excess of five years, before the order of recovery is issued.

(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully been required to discharge duties of a higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even though he should have rightfully been required to work against an inferior post.

(v) In any other case, where the court arrives at the conclusion, that recovery if made from the employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such an extent, as would far outweigh the equitable balance of the employer's right to recover."

10. I have perused the situations quoted above and considered them from the perspective of the present case. It clearly reflects that the matter of the present Petitioner is attracted and covered by the above-mentioned judgment of the Supreme Court. Therefore, on this alone ground itself the order of withholding of the gratuity of the Petitioner after his retirement is impermissible under law.

11. Further, it was the contention on behalf of the State that after the retirement of the Petitioner a departmental inquiry has

7

been initiated against him regarding the audit report. However, no document in this regard has been filed by the State. If the above contention of the State Counsel is taken as it is then also admittedly before retirement of the Petitioner no departmental inquiry was initiated against him nor was any show cause notice issued to him. For the alleged misappropriation of fund, which was done in the financial year 2008-09, since no judicial (criminal) proceedings in terms of Rule 9(6)(b)(i) of the Pension Rules, 1976 was instituted against the Petitioner or was pending against him on the date of his retirement and as submitted by the State Counsel charge-sheet was issued to the Petitioner after his retirement and issuance of final order after conclusion of the departmental inquiry will not be applicable in this case, the Petitioner is entitled for full gratuity amount on the date of his retirement.

12. For the foregoing reasons, the writ petition is allowed. The Respondents are directed to release the full amount of the gratuity of the Petitioner along with simple interest at the rate of 8% per annum on the full amount of the gratuity with effect from the date of his retirement till actual and final payment of the gratuity and this shall be done within a period of three months of receipt of this order, failing which, in place of 8% simple interest, 10% simple interest shall be paid on the same

8

full amount and for the same period as ordered above. It is made clear that this order shall not bar the Respondents to proceed in accordance with law with respect to the audit report.

Sd/-

(Arvind Singh Chandel)

JUDGE

Gopal