Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

DEEP CHANDRA TIWARI v. M/O RAILWAYS

Central Administrative Tribunal
Feb 1, 2024

1

Court No. 5(Item No.24) (OA No.1053/2021)

Central Administrative Tribunal Principal Bench

OA No.1053/2021

Reserved on:17 .01.2024 Pronouncement on: 01 .02. 2024

Hon'ble Dr.Chhabilendra Roul, Member (A)

Deep Chandra Tiwari S/o Sh. Jagdish Chanda Tiwari, Ex ADSO) age about 61 years, 107-D, Phase-2, Pocket-A, Mayur Vihar, Delhi-110091 -Applicant.

(Through Advocate: Mr. B.C. Nagar)

Versus

1. Union of India though the General Manager Northern Railway Baroda House, New Delhi.

2. Divisional Railway Manager, Northern Railway Moradabad

3. Sr. Divisional Finance Manager, Northern Railway Moradabad.

4. Sr. Divisional Personnel officer Northern Railway Moradabad

. -Respondents (Through Advocate: Mr.Ranjan Tyagi, Mr. Piyush Gaur )

O R D E R

By Hon'ble Dr.Chhabilendra Roul, Member (A):-

2

The present Original Application has been filed by the applicant, seeking the following relief(s):-

"(1) to direct the Respondents to quash the impugned orders passed on 04.02.2021.

(i) to refund the illegally deducted amount of Rs. 15,50,884/- (Fifteen lack fifteen thousand six hundred sixty four) from the DCRG of the Apllicant along with suitable penal interest against the Respondent.

(ii) To pay arrears of difference of DCRG, Leave encashment and full and final Pension from the date it became due by revising the Pension of the Applicant with suitable and penal interest against the respondents.

(iii) Any other relief, which this Hon'ble Tribunal may deem fit , just and proper in the circumstances of the case, may also be passed.

(iv) Cost of the present case may be awarded infavor of the Applicant and against the respondents."

2. The factual matrix of the present case is as follows:

2.1. The present applicant was appointed as TCI-III with the respondents on 25.03.1982. During his service carrier the applicant earned four promotions. Prior to his superannuation on 31-03-2020, the respondents prepared the detail history sheet of the applicant and the account branch of the respondents vetted a pay of Rs. 1,04,400/- in level 10 and forwarded to the concerned authorities for final payment of retirement dues. The applicant was

3

superannuated on 03.03.2020. However, the respondents vide order dated 14.04.2020 refixed the Last Pay drawn by the applicant and reduced his pay from Rs.01,04,400/- to Rs.87,400/-. Vide order dated 04.02.2021, the respondents advised the applicant to refund of Rs.15,50,664/- so that his gratuity, DCRG can be paid. They further asked to deposit a sum of Rs. 53,669/- so that his leave encashment and other retirement benefits could be finalized. The applicant submitted a representation dated 01.06.2020 for re- fixation of his pay. This was followed by another representation by the applicant dated 01.07.2020. However, the respondents have not responded to his representations as yet. Being aggrieved, the applicant has filed the present O.A., seeking the aforementioned relief.

3. On admission of the OA, notices were issued to the respondents and they have filed their counter affidavit to which the applicant has also filed rejoinder to the same.

4. The applicant in his OA as well as through the arguments by his counsels has tendered the following grounds in support of relief claimed sought by him.

4

4.1. The reduction of pay and recovery of amounting of Rs. 16,04,463/-. from the retirement dues will put the applicant in a great financial hardship. This recovery from the DCRG and other retirement benefits is iniquitous and harsh to such an extent that it would outweigh the equitable balance of right of the employer to recover. The learned counsel for the applicant drew attention to the Apex Court's decision in the case of State of Punjab & Ors etc. vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) C.A. No. 11527 of 2014. In the Rafiq Masih (supra) judgment, the Apex Court has enumerated the situations where it is impermissible in law to recover from the retirement benefits of the government employee. Particularly he drew attention Clause (ii) of Paragraph 12 of the said judgment, which states that it is impermissible law to recover from the retired employees who are due to retire within one year. Again Clause (iii) of the said paragraph of the Rafiq Masih judgment states that when the excess payment has been made for a period in excess of five years, before the order of recovery is issued, such recovery is not permissible under the law. He further avers that this judgment has been re-affirmed by the Apex Court in Thomas Danial & ors. Versus State

5

of Kerala and Ors. In Civil Appeal No. 7115 of 2010 decided on 02.05.2022.

4.2 Relying upon the aforementioned judgments of the Apex Court, the learned counsel for the applicant states that the action on the part of the respondents in ordering recovery of amounting of Rs. 16,0443/- from the retirement dues of the applicant is against the settled law. The respondents have refixed the pay of the applicant w.e.f. 01.04.2011 and issued the recovery order dated 04.02.2021. In view of this, it is against the settled law as per the aforementioned two judgments of the Apex Court.

5. Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondents drew attention to the counter affidavit filed by the respondents. The respondents in Paragraph 4.10 of their counter affidavit have stated that the applicant with the connivance of Account Department got his pay illegally fixed @ Rs. 10,4400/- instead of Rs. 87400/- and when the said discrepancy came within the knowledge of the Administration, the said recovery was ordered to be recovered from the retiral dues of the applicant. The respondents have, in their counter affidavit, stated that the applicant is guilty of playing fraud with the Railway Administration

6

because he managed to get his pay re-fixed wrongly in connivance with the Officers of the Accounting Department of the Moradabad Division. He drew attention to the judgment of Hon'ble Punjab and Haryana High Court and anothers vs. Jagdave Singh

in C.W.P No. 3500 of 2006 decided on July 29, 2016. In the said judgment the Hon'ble High Court has referred to the judgment of the State of Punjab & Ors etc. vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) (supra) case and states that :

11 The principle enunciated in proposition (ii) above cannot apply to a situation such as in the present case. In the present case, the officer to whom the payment was made in the first instance was clearly placed on notice that any payment found to have been made in excess would be required to be refunded. The officer furnished an undertaking while opting for the revised pay scale. He is bound by the undertaking.

12 For these reasons, the judgment of the High Court which set aside the action for recovery is unsustainable. However, we are of the view that the recovery should be made in reasonable installments. We direct that the recovery be made in equated monthly installments spread over a period of two years."

6. In the instant case, the applicant in connivance with the account department got his pay refixed wrongly and enriched himself at the cost of the Railway Board. Hence, the amount has rightly been ordered to be recovered from him.

7

7. I have heard the arguments advanced by both the counsels carefully and perused the records of the case thoroughly.

7.1 In the instant case, the respodents have alleged that the applicant, in connivance with the staff of Account Department of Moradabad Division, got his pay refixed w.e.f. 01.04.2011. However, the respondents have failed to produce any document or any inquiry report which substantiates such allegation that the applicant was hand in glove with the accounts department to refix his w.e.f. 01.04.2011. The re-fixation of pay continued for various periods thereafter and there might have been a series of account staff involved in since April, 2011 to March 2020. The respondents have failed to give details that who were the officials and who were the officers of the account division and who were hand in glove with the applicant in benefiting him through the enhanced pay. Hence, the contention of the respondents that, the applicant, in connivance with the account department, got his pay wrongly fixed and subsequent revised his pay from time to time, is not tenable. In view of this, the judgment of Punjab and Haryana High Court in Jag Dave Singh (supra ) is not applicable

8

to the instant case because of the facts and circumstances of that case is quite different from those obtaining in the instant case. On the other hand, from the settled law by the State of Punjab & Ors etc.

vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) (supra) case and as it has been reiterated in the case of Thomas Danial case by the Apex Court, it is impermissible in law to recover from a retired employee and also it is impermissible to recovery any amount which relates to a period in excess of five years before the order of recovery is issued. In the instant case, the excess payment starts from 01.04.2011 and the recovery order has been issued on 04.02.2021. In view of this, the judgment of the Apex Court in State of Punjab & Ors etc. vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) (supra) case is squarely applicable in the instant case. Accordingly, the recovery order dated 04.02.2021 is against the settled law and is considered as irregular.

8. In view of the above, the recovery order dated 04.02.2021 by the respondent is quashed the respondents are directed to refund the amount which has been recovered from the DCRG of the applicant along with the payable interest at applicable GPF rates. Further the respondents are directed to pay

9

leave encashment and issue final pension to the applicant. They shall pay interest at the applicable GPF rates in respect of the leave encasement from the date of superannuation till the payment of such amount to the applicant. All these activities shall be completed within a period of eight weeks from received of a certified copy of this order.

8.1. The present OA is disposed of as per the above directions with no order as to costs.

(Dr. Chhabilendra Roul)

Member (A) /mk/