Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

RAKESH  v. THE STATE GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI

Delhi High Court
Jan 3, 2024
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The present petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, challenges an order dated 09.11.2023 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge-03, South, Saket Courts, New Delhi, in Sessions Case No. 27/2020 arising from FIR No. 455/2017 registered at Police Station Neb Sarai under Sections 307/34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. The FIR originated from an incident on 27.08.2017 when the complainant, Hari Chand, alleged that the accused, Rakesh, along with his brother Bholu (now deceased), were consuming beer near a temple. A quarrel ensued when the complainant tried to prevent them, during which Rakesh allegedly attempted to kill the complainant with a sharp metal weapon causing injury to his head. The chargesheet was filed against Rakesh under Section 307/34 IPC on 23.09.2019.

During trial, the complainant (PW-1) and his wife (PW-2) gave their testimonies and were cross-examined on 30.03.2022. After prosecution evidence concluded on 03.10.2023, the accused sought recall of PW-1 and PW-2 under Section 311 Cr.P.C. for further cross-examination, which was dismissed by the Trial Court on 09.11.2023. The petitioner now seeks setting aside of this order and permission to cross-examine the witnesses again in the interest of justice.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Trial Court erred in dismissing the application under Section 311 Cr.P.C. seeking recall and further cross-examination of witnesses PW-1 and PW-2 after their evidence had been closed and they had already been cross-examined at length by the earlier counsel for the accused.
  2. Whether a change of counsel for the accused can constitute sufficient ground for recalling witnesses for further cross-examination under Section 311 Cr.P.C.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The earlier counsel did not cross-examine PW-1 on crucial points such as motive and intention, nor did he put forth the accused’s defence to PW-1.
  • PW-2 was not confronted with her earlier police statement during cross-examination by the earlier counsel.
  • The additional cross-examination is essential for a just decision and would not prejudice the prosecution as the prosecution evidence had just concluded.
  • The Trial Court rejected the application mechanically without proper consideration.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • PW-1 and PW-2 were cross-examined at length by the accused’s earlier counsel before being discharged.
  • A change of counsel is not a valid ground for recalling witnesses or reopening their evidence.
  • Allowing recall on such grounds would cause unnecessary delay and harassment to witnesses.
  • The impugned order is correct and should be upheld.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ratanlal v. Prahlad Jat (2017) 9 SCC 340 Recall of witnesses under Section 311 Cr.P.C. is permissible only if essential for just decision; not merely to ensure fair trial without tangible reasons. The Court relied on this precedent to hold that recall is discretionary and must be exercised judiciously to prevent failure of justice, not arbitrarily.
State (NCT of Delhi) v. Shiv Kumar Yadav (2016) 2 SCC 402 Change of counsel or mere incompetence cannot be ground for recall of witnesses; recall causes delay and harassment and should be based on bona fide reasons. The Court applied this principle to reject the petitioner’s claim that change of counsel justified recall of witnesses for further cross-examination.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by referring to Section 311 Cr.P.C., which permits recall and re-examination of witnesses if their evidence appears essential for a just decision. The petitioner’s application for recall was primarily based on the change of counsel and alleged inadequate cross-examination by the earlier counsel.

The Court examined the testimonies and cross-examinations of PW-1 and PW-2, noting that both witnesses had been cross-examined at length on material aspects including criminal background, incident details, relations between parties, and prior statements. The Court referenced authoritative Supreme Court decisions which establish that recall of witnesses is not a matter of course and cannot be granted merely on the ground of change of counsel or alleged incompetence.

The Court emphasized that recall must be exercised judiciously to prevent failure of justice and should not cause unnecessary delay or harassment. Since the witnesses were already cross-examined thoroughly, the Court found no justification for recall in this case.

Accordingly, the Court found no error in the Trial Court’s dismissal of the application under Section 311 Cr.P.C. and declined to interfere with the impugned order.

Holding and Implications

The petition is dismissed and the impugned order dated 09.11.2023 is upheld.

The direct effect of this decision is that the accused is not permitted to recall PW-1 and PW-2 for further cross-examination merely on the ground of change of counsel or alleged incomplete earlier cross-examination. No broader precedent is set beyond affirming established principles regarding recall of witnesses under Section 311 Cr.P.C. The Court expressly refrained from expressing any opinion on the merits of the underlying criminal case.

Show all summary ...

CRL.M.C. 8782/2023 Page 1 of 6

$~ * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

% Reserved on: 01.12.2023 Pronounced on: 03.01.2024

+ CRL.M.C. 8782/2023& CRL.M.A. 32763/2023

RAKESH ..... Petitioner Through: Mr. Amit Kumar, Advocate versus

THE STATE GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI ..... Respondents

Through: Mr. Manoj Pant, APP for the State with SI Ram Kishan, PS

Neb Sarai

CORAM:

HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SWARANA KANTA SHARMA

JUDGMENT

SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J.

1. By way of present petition filed under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 ('Cr.P.C.'), the petitioner seeks setting aside of order dated 09.11.2023 passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge-03, South, Saket Courts, New Delhi, in Sessions Case No. 27/2020 titled as „State vs. Rakesh" arising out of FIR No. 455/2017, registered at Police Station Neb Sarai, Delhi under Sections 307/34 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 ('IPC'). The petitioner also prays for re-calling of PW-1 and PW-2, and to permit his counsel to cross-examine these witnesses in the larger interest of justice.

1

2. Brief facts of the case are that the present FIR was registered on the basis of statement of Sh. Hari Chand who had alleged that on 27.08.2017, at about 8:00 PM, when he was returning home and had reached near a temple, he had seen his brother Bholu and his nephew Rakesh consuming beer. The complainant had tried to prevent them from consuming beer, however, the accused persons had started quarreling with him and during the course of quarrel, Bholu had caught hold of his hands from behind and Rakesh had suddenly taken out a sharp metal weapon with the intention to kill the complainant. In order to save himself, the complainant had leaned forward and the said metal object had hit his head, due to which he had sustained injury on the left side of his head. Thereafter, the complaint"s wife had called the PCR and the complainant had been taken to Batra Hospital. During the course of investigation, accused Bholu had passed away. The chargesheet in the present case was filed under Section 307/34 of IPC on 23.09.2019 against accused Rakesh i.e. the present petitioner.

3. The testimony of complainant/victim PW-1 i.e. Sh. Hari Chand as well as complainant"s wife PW-2 i.e. Smt. Kamlesh was recorded before the learned Trial Court on 30.03.2022. The prosecution had closed its evidence on 03.10.2023 and the matter was adjourned to 21.10.2023 for recording of statement of accused under Section 313 of Cr.P.C. Thereafter, an application under Section 311 of Cr.P.C. was moved on behalf of accused/petitioner Rakesh for re-calling of PW-1 and PW-2 for further cross-examination.

2

4. Vide order dated 09.11.2023, the learned Trial Court had dismissed the application filed on behalf of the accused under section 311 of Cr.P.C. The relevant portion of the impugned order reads as under:

"Heard the submissions of both the parties and perused the record.

Witness PW 1 and PW 2 were examined and cross examined at length through the counsel of the accused vide order dated 30.03.2022. after conclusion of the prosecution evidence, fresh opportunity to cross examine the witness PW 1 and PW 2 who were already cross examined on behalf of the accused through counsel who was representing the accused at that time is neither justified nor legally permissible. Hence, the application filed under Section 311 Cr.PC to further cross examine the witness PW 1 and PW 2 does not hold any merits and accordingly stands dismissed and disposed off."

5. The present petition has been filed assailing the aforesaid order, and learned counsel for the petitioner argues that the application under Section 311 of Cr.P.C. was preferred on the ground that the accused was earlier represented by some other counsel who had neither cross-examined PW-1 on certain points such as motive and intention and had also not put forth the defence of accused to PW-1, nor he had confronted PW-2 with her earlier statement which she had made to the police. It is stated that the cross-examination of PW-1 and PW-2 on the aforementioned points is important and essential in order to arrive at correct and just decision, and no prejudice will be caused to the complainant or prosecution since the prosecution evidence has been just concluded. It is submitted that the

3

learned Trial Court has rejected the application in a mechanical manner and therefore, the present petition be allowed.

6. Learned APP for the State, on the other hand, argues that there is no infirmity in the impugned order since PW-1 and PW-2 were cross-examined at length by the counsel for accused, after which they were discharged. It is contended that change of counsel cannot be a ground for re-call of witness and for giving any fresh opportunity to re-open the evidence of witnesses who have already been cross- examined at length by the earlier counsel for the accused. Therefore, it is prayed that the present petition be dismissed

7. This Court has heard arguments addressed by learned counsel for the petitioner as well as learned APP for the State, and has perused the material on record.

8. At the outset, it will be important to refer to Section 311 of Cr.P.C., which reads as under:

"311. Power to summon material witness, or examine person present.- Any Court may, at any stage of any inquiry, trial or other proceeding under this Court, summon any person as a witness, or examine any person in attendance though not summoned as a witness, or recall and re-examine any person already examined; and the Court shall summon and examine or recall and re-examine any such person if his evidence appears to it to be essential to the just decision of the case."

9. In the present case, this Court notes that the application under Section 311 of Cr.P.C. seeking re-call of PW-1 and PW-2 was primarily moved on ground of change of counsel i.e. on the ground that the earlier counsel appearing on behalf of the accused had failed to cross-examine the witnesses on certain material points.

4

10. In this regard, this Court notes that the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Ratanlal v. Prahlad Jat (2017) 9 SCC 340 while dismissing the appeal for re-examination of witness had relied on the decision in case of State (NCT of Delhi) v. Shiv Kumar Yadav (2016) 2 SCC 402, wherein it was observed that:

"... Certainly, recall could be permitted if essential for the just decision, but not on such consideration as has been adopted in the present case. Mere observation that recall was necessary "for ensuring fair trial" is not enough unless there are tangible reasons to show how the fair trial suffered without recall. Recall is not a matter of course and the discretion given to the court has to be exercised judiciously to prevent failure of justice and not arbitrarily. While the party is even permitted to correct its bona fide error and may be entitled to further opportunity even when such opportunity may be sought without any fault on the part of the opposite party, plea for recall for advancing justice has to be bona fide and has to be balanced carefully with the other relevant considerations including uncalled for hardship to the witnesses and uncalled for delay in the trial. Having regard to these considerations, there is no ground to justify the recall of witnesses already examined."

11. Further, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Shiv Kumar Yadav

(supra) has held that mere incompetence or change of counsel cannot be ground for recall of witness under Section 311 of Cr.P.C. and that it is not only matter of delay but also of harassment for witnesses to be recalled which could not be justified. It was also observed that normally, it has to be presumed that the counsel conducting a case is competent particularly when a counsel is appointed by choice of a litigant.

12. Having perused the records of the case, this Court is of the opinion that PW-1 and PW-2 were examined and cross-examined by

5

the counsel for accused/petitioner on 30.03.2022, after which these witnesses were discharged. The testimony of PW-1, filed on record, reveals that the earlier counsel for accused had cross-examined the witness at length and had asked questions on his criminal background and history, details of the incident, relation between the parties, false implication of accused by PW-1, etc. Similarly, PW-2 was also cross- examined by the counsel for accused on material aspects and the counsel for accused had also confronted her with her earlier statement given to the police under Section 161 of Cr.P.C.

13. Therefore, since both PW-1 and PW-2 have already been cross-examined at length on all material aspects by the earlier counsel for the accused, they cannot be re-called merely on the ground of change of counsel.

14. Thus, in view of aforesaid, this Court finds no reasons to interfere with the impugned order dated 09.11.2023 passed by the learned Trial Court.

15. Accordingly, the present petition alongwith pending application is dismissed.

16. Nothing expressed hereinabove shall tantamount to an expression of opinion on the merits of the case.

17. The judgment be uploaded on the website forthwith.

SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J

JANUARY 3, 2024/ns

6