Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

R.Pandian(Advocate), v. District Register,Ariyalur.

District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Nov 22, 2022

1

Date of Filing: 15.10.2018

Date of Order: 22.11.2022

DISTRICT CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION PERAMBALUR

PRESENT:-

Thiru. D. JAWAHAR, B.Sc., LL.M., PRESIDENT Selvi. P. THILAKA, B.A., B.L., M.B.A., MEMBER I Thiru. M. MUTHUKUMARAN, M.Sc.,M.Tech., MEMBER II C.C No.24/2018

(TUESDAY, THE 22nd DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2022)

Pandian, Advocate, 5/63, Main Road, Krishnapuram post, Veppanthattai Taluk, Perambalur District, Pin : 621 116. ….Complainant. /Versus /

1. District Registrar, Jayankondam Road, Ariyalur - 621 704.

2. Sub Registrar, Sub Registrar Office, Veppanthattai - 621 116.

3. Devaki, Sub Registrar, Veppanthattai - 621 116. … Opposite parties. Counsel for the complainant : Pro Se. Counsel for the opposite parties : Selvi. Santhanalakshmi. Government Pleader.

This complaint came for final hearing before us on the 26thday of October -2022, perused the case records, the case having stood over till this day for consideration, this Commission passed the following:-

ORDER

THIRU. D. JAWAHAR, PRESIDENT :-

Brief facts of the complaint:-

2

Complainant presented the sale deed to the 2ndopposite party for registration with regard to his immovable property in favour of his wife. complainant incurred Rs.7630/- towards stamp papers and Rs.1085 towards registration charges, Rs.40 towards for sub division cost and Rs.150 towards computer and CD charges, in all totaling Rs.8905/- .When the complainant questioned the 3rdopposite party about the inordinate delay in registration process, she shouted at him and refused to register the document and returned the same to him. She also refused to give any reason for refusing to register the said document. A written complaint was made on 03.09.2016 for which he was called for enquiry a number of times but enquiry was not concluded wantonly by the opposite parties. 2ndopposite party ought to have registered the documents as per law, but they failed to do so, hence liable to compensate for the mental agony underwent by him.

Complainant prayed for compensation of Rs.2 lakhs for mental

agony underwent by him, Rs.8905/- paid towards registration charges and Rs.20, 000/- towards penalty and 10,000/- towards cost.

Brief facts of written version by the 3rd opposite party and adopted by the 1st and 2nd opposite parties :-

On 27.08.2015 at about 3.30 p.m, the petitioner Pandian came to the office of the 2nd respondent to register a sale deed of his property and also the Petitioner paid the registration fee. After the submission of the petitioner"s sale deed the 3rdrespondent who was incharge to the 2ndrespondent was perusing the records given by the petitioner Pandian. 3rdrespondent after the verification of the sale deed and records told the petitioner that

"you are not filing an original document of the sale deed", hence the 3rdpetitioner has denied to registering the document presented by the petitioner according to law and returned the above fee entirely to the petitioner. As per the instruction of the Circular office (Lr.No. 18339/C1/2012 dated on 25.4.2012) of the Inspector General of Registration in order to safeguard the public interest by preventing fraudulent registration of the document at the time of registration, the original document should be submitted by the public. Hence the 3rd respondent has denied to register the sale deed and she has not done intentionally any inordinate delay to register the sale the document and the same is filed herewith as document.

3

The 3rdrespondent should act as officially within the guidelines of Inspector general of registration.

3rdrespondent had explained to the petitioner why the document has not been registered which was given by him but the petitioner shouted in the office and spoiled decorum of the office. The petitioner is falsely filed a complaint against the respondents before the district consumer forum of Perambalur without any primafacie case. It is further stated that the 3rdrespondent has put an official entry on 27.8.2015 as" ,e;j Mtzk; bjhlh;ghf Kd; Mtz mrYld; jhf;fy; bra;a mwpt[Wj;jg;gLfpwJ vd;W gjpt[ bra;jhh;" and the same is filed herewith as a document and directed the petitioner to produce the original sale deed for registration.

Complaint given by the petitioner is not maintainable because the relationship between the petitioner and the respondents are not come under the scope of Consumer. Act the respondents are government servants and acted for the welfare of the public. The person who presents a document for registration and pays the stamp duty on it or the registration fee, does not become a consumer. The Petition itself is a frivolous one and against the statutory provisions. The respondents are discharging their official and statutory duties. It is further submitted that, if the vexatious petition is allowed by the Hon"ble court, it would be prejudiced the respondents. Therefore prayed to dismiss the petition otherwise the respondents will be prejudice and put into irreparable loss.

Point for Consideration:-

1) Whether there is any deficiency in service committed by the Opposite parties?

2) Whether the complainant is entitled to get relief as prayed for in the Complaint?

Complainant filed a total of 10 documents which were marked as Ex.A1 to Ex.A.10. And the opposite party did not filed any document.

POINT NO. 1:-

4

Document presented by the complainant for registration had not been registered by the opposite parties and the said document was returned to the complainant. As per section 72 of The Registration Act, the registering authority is mandated to make an endorsement

"registration refused" on the document itself, however, the 2ndand the 3rdopposite party did not make any such endorsement on the document Ex. A1. Even in the written version filed by the 3rdopposite party (adopted by the 1stand 2nd Opposite party), there is no averment that she has made an endorsement on the document as mandated under section 72 of The Registration Act.

By not making an endorsement as per law, the complainant was deprived of his statutory appeal against the order passed by the 3rdopposite party. Claim of the opposite parties that the 3rdopposite party had put an official entry on 27.8 2015 is just an afterthought, as no endorsement was made in the document presented for registration (Ex.A1), therefore, it is clear that the refusal to register the document presented for registration is not in accordance with law but for some extraneous purpose . 1st opposite party did not take any steps to redress the grievance of the complainant. Merely asking the complainant to come for an enquiry is not enough, and till date the enquiry has not been completed and no report of the enquiry was filed before this Commission. It is thus clear that the opposite parties did not act as per law, therefore, they are liable for the action under Consumer protection Act. Decision of the Hon"ble National Commission made in R.P No. 144/2004 in "the Joint Registrar Vs Tmt. Maragatham", cited by the complainant is relevant to the case on hand as „refusal to register" the document of the complainant is not bonafide . Therefore, the opposite parties are liable to compensate the complainant for deficiency in service. Decision of the Hon"ble High court madras made in W.P. (MD) No. 19745/2020, in Sivanadiyan Vs the Sub Registrar, Pudukkottai, cited by the complainant is applicable to the facts and circumstances of this case.

Hence, point number 1 is answered affirmatively.

POINT 2

5

Complainant is entitled for a sum of Rs.50, 000/- as compensation for mental agony underwent the complainant and also for a sum of Rs.8905/- for registration charges. Complainant is also entitles to get the document in dispute registered, if it is otherwise in order. Opposite Parties are also directed to pay Rs.10, 000/- to the complainant as cost.

In the result, complaint is allowed in part and the opposite parties are directed to pay, jointly and severally, a sum of Rs.50,000/- as compensation for the mental agony underwent by the complainant due to the deficiency in service committed by the opposite parties and pay the registration charges of Rs.8,905/- to the complainant. And the 2nd opposite party is directed to register the sale deed, if the document is otherwise in order, within a period of 4 weeks from the date of receipt of this order copy. Complainant is also entitled for a cost of Rs.10,000/-.

This order is dictated by the President to the Steno-typist, typed by her, corrected, signed and pronounced by us in open Commission, today, the 22nd day of November- 2022.

Sd/- Sd/- Sd/-

MEMBER I MEMBER II PRESIDENT.

List of Documents marked on the side of the complainant:-

01 Ex.A.1 - 27.08.2015 Receipt.

02 Ex.A.2 - 03.01.2015 Complaint.

03 Ex.A.3- 20.10.2015 Grievance letter to the Collector.

04 Ex.A.4- 05.11.2015 Reply by the Opposite party.

05 Ex.A.5 16.11.2015 Reply by the Opposite party.

06 Ex.A.6 19.02.2016 Reply by the Opposite party.

07 Ex.A.7 17.05.2016 Reply by the Opposite party.

08 Ex.A.8 20.10.2016 Reply by the Opposite party.

6

09 Ex.A.9 23.05.2017 Reply by the Opposite party.

10 Ex.A.10 25.07.2017 Reply by the Opposite party.

List of Documents marked on the side of the Opposite party :-

-NIL -

Sd/- Sd/- Sd/-

MEMBER I MEMBER II PRESIDENT.