- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
VIJAY GOVARDHANADAS SHAH v. STATE OF KERALA
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners, accused Nos. 1 and 2 in C.C. No. 1690 of 2021 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Mattancherry, face allegations under Section 294(b) read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code. The case arises from Crime No. 608 of 2021 registered at Mattancherry Police Station. The petitioners are employees of Sri Navneeth Krishna Swami Temple, Mattancherry. The allegations stem from an incident where the petitioners allegedly uttered obscenities in a public place during heated arguments with the de-facto complainant. The petitioners contend that the allegations are false and motivated by civil disputes between the temple's managing body and the complainant's husband. The FIR was registered after a delay of over one month, which was not satisfactorily explained. The petitioners filed this petition under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. seeking quashing of the proceedings, and notice was served on the complainant, who did not appear.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the words allegedly uttered by the petitioners constitute "obscenity" within the meaning of Section 294(b) of the Indian Penal Code.
- Whether the prosecution for the alleged offence under Section 294(b) IPC can be sustained in light of the definitions and judicial interpretations of obscenity.
- Whether the delay in filing the FIR and the nature of the allegations justify quashing the proceedings under Section 482 Cr.P.C.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The petitioners are employees of the Sri Navneeth Krishna Swami Temple and the allegations relate to words spoken during heated arguments with the complainant.
- The words used, though defamatory, do not meet the legal definition of "obscenity" under Section 294(b) IPC.
- The allegations are motivated by ongoing civil disputes between the temple's managing body and the complainant's husband.
- The FIR was registered after a delay of more than one month without a proper explanation, undermining the prosecution's case.
- The petitioners sought quashing of the criminal proceedings under the inherent powers of the High Court under Section 482 Cr.P.C.
Respondent's Arguments
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Latheef v. State of Kerala [2014 (2) KLT 987] | Definition of obscenity under Section 294(b) IPC referencing Section 292 IPC; abusive or defamatory words do not necessarily constitute obscenity. | The Court relied on this precedent to clarify that the alleged words, though abusive, did not satisfy the legal test for obscenity. |
| P.T. Chacko v. Nainan Chacko (1967 KLT 799) | Test of obscenity: whether the matter tends to deprave and corrupt those susceptible to immoral influences. | The Court applied this test to conclude that the words used by the petitioners were not obscene within the meaning of the law. |
| Sangeetha Lakshmana v. State of Kerala (2008 (2) KLT 745) | Words alleged to be obscene must arouse sexually impure thoughts; mere abusive words do not suffice. | The Court used this precedent to reinforce that the petitioners' words did not meet the threshold of obscenity. |
| N.S. Madhanagopal & Another v. K. Lalitha [2022 Live Law (SC) 844] | Clarification of Section 294 IPC and reaffirmation of the test for obscenity as tendency to deprave and corrupt. | The Court cited this Supreme Court decision to support the interpretation of Section 294(b) IPC and to conclude that the offence was not made out. |
| Ranjit D. Udeshi v. State of Maharashtra AIR 1965 SC 881 | Accepted the test of obscenity as tendency to deprave and corrupt. | The Court referred to this precedent to endorse the uniform application of the obscenity test in India. |
| Queen v. Hicklin 1868 3 Q.B. 360 | Original articulation of the obscenity test focusing on depraving and corrupting tendency. | The Court applied this foundational test to assess the nature of the alleged words. |
| Samuel Roth v. U.S.A. 354 U.S. 476 (1957) | Obscenity defined as substantial tendency to corrupt by arousing lustful desires. | The Court referenced this judgment to emphasize the requirement of lascivious or sexual elements in words for obscenity. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the allegations and the legal definition of obscenity under Section 294(b) IPC, which is linked to the definition in Section 292 IPC. It noted that obscene words must be lascivious, appeal to prurient interest, or tend to deprave and corrupt persons exposed to them. The Court found that while the petitioners' words were abusive and humiliating, they lacked the necessary lascivious or sexual element to qualify as obscene. The Court observed that mere defamatory or abusive language does not constitute obscenity punishable under Section 294(b). Furthermore, the Court noted the absence of evidence that the words caused annoyance to others, which is a necessary ingredient of the offence. The Court also considered the delay in filing the FIR and the context of a civil dispute, concluding that the prosecution was an abuse of process. Reliance was placed on several precedents that consistently apply a stringent test for obscenity, requiring a tendency to deprave or corrupt through sexual impurity, which was not satisfied here. Consequently, the Court held that the criminal proceedings could not be sustained.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court quashed all further proceedings against the petitioners in C.C. No. 1690 of 2021 on the file of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Mattancherry.
Implications: The decision results in the termination of the criminal case against the petitioners for the alleged offence under Section 294(b) IPC. The Court did not establish any new legal precedent but reaffirmed the established judicial interpretation of obscenity under Indian law. The ruling underscores that abusive or defamatory language without lascivious or sexual content does not constitute an offence under Section 294(b) IPC, and that delays and civil dispute contexts may justify quashing criminal proceedings.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE GOPINATH P.
WEDNESDAY, THE 15TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2023 / 24TH KARTHIKA, 1945
CRL.MC NO. 6089 OF 2022
CRIME NO.608/2021 OF MATTANCHERRY POLICE STATION, ERNAKULAM PROCEEDINGS IN C.C.NO.1690/2021 OF JUDICIAL FIRST CLASS MAGISTRATE
COURT, MATTANCHERRY
PETITIONERS/ACCUSED 1 AND 2:
1 VIJAY GOVARDHANADAS SHAH,
AGED 55 YEARS,
S/O GP SHAH, CLERK, NAVNEETH KRISHNA TEMPLE, PALACE ROAD, MATTANCHERRY - 682 001.
2 SANKAR.S,
AGED 48 YEARS,
S/O SUDALAL MUTHU, STAFF, NAVNEETH KRISHNA TEMPLE, PALACE ROAD, MATTANCHERRY - 682 001.
BY ADVS.
JAYASREE K.P.
JOHN JOSEPH
RESPONDENTS:
1 STATE OF KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY THE STATION HOUSE OFFICER,
MATTANCHERRY POLICE STATION, KOCHI - 682 001.
(THROUGH PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, HIGH COURT OF KERALA,
ERNAKULAM)
2 JASMINE DEEPAK PUJARA,
W/O DEEPAK PUJARA, CC 8/1906, PALACE ROAD, MATTANCHERRY, KOCHI - 682 001.
SRI VIPIN NARAYAN (SR PP)
THIS CRIMINAL MISC. CASE HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
15.11.2023, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY PASSED THE FOLLOWING:
1
2
ORDER
Petitioners are accused Nos.1 and 2 in C.C.No.1690 of 2021 on the file of the Judicial First Class Magistrate court, Mattancherry, arising out of Crime No.608 of 2021 of Mattancherry Police Station. The petitioners face allegations of having committed offence under Section 294(b) read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code.
2. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners would submit that the petitioners are employees of Sri Navneeth Krishna Swami Temple, Palace Road, Mattancherry. It is submitted that the gist of the allegation is that the petitioners had mouthed obscenities in a public place as a consequence of the heated arguments they had with the de-facto complainant in the case.
3. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners would submit that merely because defamatory words are used, the same would not fall within the definition of 'obscenity' for the purpose of Section 294(b) of the Indian Penal Code. It is submitted that a false allegation has been raised on account of civil disputes between the apex body which runs the Sri Navneeth Krishna Swami Temple against the husband of the de-facto complainant demanding vacant
3
possession of buildings and structures let out to him. It is submitted that the allegations were raised merely on account of personal animosity on account of civil disputes pending between the apex body, which manages the affairs of the Sri Navneeth Krishna Swami Temple and the husband of the de-facto complainant. It is submitted that the F.I.R in the case was registered after a delay of more than one month and the delay has not been properly explained. It is submitted that in such circumstances, the proceedings against the petitioners is liable to be quashed in exercise of the jurisdiction vested in this Court under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. Notice of this petition has been served on the 2ndrespondent / de-facto complainant. However, there is no appearance for the 2nd respondent / de-facto complainant.
4. Heard the learned Public Prosecutor also.
5. Having heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and the learned Public Prosecutor, I am of the view that the petitioners are entitled to succeed. A perusal of Annexure - A2 final report will indicate that the allegations against the petitioners are the following:-
"ഒന്നും രണ്ടും പ്രതികൾക്ക് ആവലാതിക്കാരിയാടും കുടുംബയ ാടും വസ്തു സംബന്ധമാി സിവിൽ യകസ് യകാടതിിൽ കകാടു തിലുള്ള മുൻ വിയരാധം നിമി ം
4
ഒന്നാം സാക്ഷിക അപമാനിക്കണകമന്നുള്ള ഉയ,ശ്യയ ാടും കരുതയലാടും കൂടി 19.04.21 തിതി പകൽ 11.30 മണിക്ക് മട്ടായ9രി വിയ:ജ് ടി കരിൽ കിഴക്ക് പടിഞ്ഞാറാി കിടക്കുന്ന പാലസ് യറാഡിൽ H&HM ജംഗ്ഷനിൽ നിന്നും 20 മീറ്റർ പടിഞ്ഞാറ് മാറി ടി യറാഡിന് കതക്കുവശം കിഴക്ക് ദർശന ിലുള്ള നവനീത് കൃഷ്ണ യക്ഷത്ര ിയലക്കുള്ള ആർച്ച് രൂപ ിലുള്ള യഗറ്റിനക ് ഇടനാഴിിൽ 6.1/2 മീറ്റർ കതക്ക് മാറി പടിഞ്ഞാറുവശം കതക്കുവടക്കാി കിടക്കുന്ന മതിലികS പി:റിൽ നിന്നും 9.25 മീറ്റർ കതക്കുപടിഞ്ഞാറ് മാറിയും ആതിന് പടിഞ്ഞാറുവശം കാണുന്ന കിണറികS കിഴക്ക് ഭാഗ ് നിന്നും 1 മീറ്റർ യനകര കിഴക്ക് മാറിയും കാണുന്ന ടൈടൽ പാകി വീടിന് പുറകുവശത്തുള്ള
യക്ഷത്രമതിലിനടുയ യ്ക്ക് ഒന്നാം സാക്ഷിക ഒന്നും രണ്ടും പ്രതികൾ വിളിച്ചുവരു ി മതിലിയനാട് യ^ർന്നുള്ള കുടികവള്ള ടൈപപ്പികS വാൽവ് ഒന്നാം സാക്ഷിയും മറ്റും അടച്ചുകവന്ന് ആയരാപിച്ച പ്രതികൾ യ^ർന്ന് ഗുജറാ ി ഭാഷിൽ മാതാ യ^ാദ് (യവശ്യ) എന്ന് വിളിച്ച് കപാതു സ്ഥല ് പരസ്യമാി അസഭ്യം പറഞ്ഞും പ്രതികൾ കൃത്യ ിന് പരസ്പരം ഉത്സാഹികളും സഹാികളുമാി വർ ിച്ച യമൽ വകുപ്പ് പ്രകാരം കുറ്റം ക^യ്തതാി കവളിവാിട്ടുള്ളതാണ് ."
In Latheef v. State of Kerala [2014 (2) KLT 987], this Court has considered as to what would constitute obscenity for the purpose of Section 294(b) of the Indian Penal Code. It was held:-
"4. Sub Section (1) of Section 292 IPC provides that for the purposes of sub-s. (2), dealing with punishment and sentence for obscenity, "a book, pamphlet, paper, writing,
5
drawing, painting, representation, figure or any other object, shall be deemed to be obscene if it is lascivious, or appeals to the prurient interest, or if its effect, or (where it comprises two or more distinct items) the effect of any one of its items, is, if taken as a whole, such as to tend to deprave and corrupt persons, who are likely, having regard to all relevant circumstances, to read, see or hear the matter contained or embodied in it." Thus sub-s. (1) to S. 292 IPC gives a clear idea as to what is meant by obscenity under the law, punishable under Sections 294(2), 293 and 294 IPC.
5. Abusive words or humiliating words or defamatory words will not as such amount to obscenity as defined under the law. Of course there is no doubt that the words alleged to have been used by the revision petitioner are in fact abusive and humiliating. But to make it obscene, punishable under S.294(b) IPC, it must satisfy the definition of obscenity. Section 294 IPC does not define obscenity. Being a continuation of the subject dealt with under S.292 IPC the definition of obscenity under 292(1) IPC can be applied in a prosecution under S.294 IPC also. To make punishable, the alleged words must be in a sense lascivious, or it must appeal to the prurient interest, or will deprave and corrupt persons. In P.T Chacko V. Nainan Chacko reported in (1967 KLT 799) this Court held that, " the test of obscenity is
6
whether the tendency of the matter charged as obscenity is to deprave and corrupt those whose minds are open to such immoral influences." In Sangeetha Lakshmana V. State of Kerala reported in (2008(2) KLT 745) this Court held thus,
"in order to satisfy the test of obscenity, the words alleged to have been uttered must be capable of arousing sexually impure thoughts in the minds of its hearers." Thus it is quite clear that, to make obscene the alleged words must involve some lascivious elements arousing sexual thoughts or feelings or the words must have the effect of depraving persons, and defiling morals by sex appeal or lustful desires. I find that the words alleged to have been used by the revision petitioner in this case are really abusive and humiliating, but those words cannot be said to be obscene. As already stated, every abusive word or every humiliating word cannot, by itself, be said to be obscene as defined under the Indian Penal Code. I find that the conviction against the revision petitioner under S.294 (b)IPC in this case, on the basis of the above words alleged to have been used by him, is liable to be set aside, and the revision petitioner is entitled to be acquitted."
It is to be noted that in Latheef (supra), this Court followed the judgments in P.T.Chacko v. Nainan Chacko [1967 KLT 799] and
7
Sangeetha Lakshmana v. State Of Kerala [2008(2) KLT 745]. In P.T.Chacko (supra), it was held :-
5. The only point argued was that the 1staccused has not committed an offence punishable under S.294(b) IPC by uttering the words above mentioned. The courts below have held that the words uttered were obscene and the utterance caused annoyance to the public. I am not inclined to take this view. In the Queen v. Hicklin 1868-3- Q.B.360 at 371 Cockburn C.J. laid down the test of 'obscenity' in these words:
" …..the test of obscenity is this, whether the tendency of the matter charged as obscenity is to deprave and corrupt those whose minds are open to such immoral influences."
This test has been uniformly followed in India. The Supreme Court has accepted the correctness of the test in Ranjit D. Udeshi v. State Of Maharashtra . AIR 1965 SC 881 at 887. In Samuel Roth v. U.S.A (1957) 354 U. S.476, Chief Justice Warren said that the test of 'obscenity' is the
"substantial tendency to corrupt by arousing lustful desires". Mr. Justice Harlan observed that in order to be 'obscene' the matter must "tend to sexually impure thoughts". I do not think that the words uttered in this case have such a tendency. It may be that the words are
8
defamatory of the complainant, but I do not think that the words are 'obscene' and the utterance would constitute an offence punishable under S.294(b) IPC.
In Sangeetha Lakshmana (supra), it was held:-
"5. In order to satisfy the test of obscenity, the words uttered must be capable of arousing sexually impure thoughts in the minds of its hearers. The word "rascal" does not have the tendency of depraving or corrupting those minds which are open to the prurient of lascivious influences. Secondly, the occurrence itself allegedly took place when the Sub Inspector went to the flat in question in purported exercise of rendering aid to the bank for taking possession of the flat. As a matter of fact, as per Annexure B proceedings of the Debts Recovery Tribunal dated 12-7- 2006 all proceedings pursuant to the possession notice dated 7-7-2006 issued by the bank were stayed till 17-08- 2006. There is no dispute that the order of the Debts Recovery Tribunal was passed in the morning of 12-07- 2006. If so, neither the bank nor the police officer could have proceeded to the flat in question for taking possession of the same. Hence, the Inspector had no business at all at the premises in question, much less, do any act in discharge of his duties. If so, it cannot be said that the Sub inspector
9
(a public servant) was deterred by the petitioner from discharging his official duties. Such being the position, allowing the above C.C. Case to proceed further will amount to abuse of the process of the court. Accordingly, all proceedings in C.C. 293 of 2006 on the file of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ernakulam is quashed."
In a recent judgment of the Supreme Court in N.S.Madhanagopal & Another v. K.Lalitha [2022 Live Law (SC) 844], it was held:-
"Section 294(b) of the IPC talks about the obscene acts and songs. Section 294 of the IPC as a whole reads thus:
"294.Obscene acts and songs - Whoever, to the annoyance of others -
(a) does any obscene act in any public place,or
(b) sings, recites or utters any obscene song, ballad or words, in or near any public place, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to three months, or with fine, or with both."
It is to be noted that the test of obscenity under Section 294(b) of the I.P.C. is whether the tendency of the matter charged as obscenity is to deprave and corrupt those whose minds are open to such immoral influences. The following passage from the judgment authored by Justice
10
K.K. Mathew (as his Lordship then was) reported in P.T. Chacko v. Nainan (1967 KLT 799) explains as follows:
"The only point argued was that the 1staccused has not committed an offence punishable under Section 294(b) IPC, by uttering the words above-mentioned. The courts below have held that the words uttered were obscene and the utterance caused annoyance to the public. I am not inclined to take this view. In the Queen v. Hicklin, [L.R.] 3 Q.B. 360 at 371 Cockburn C.J. Laid down the test of 'obscenity' in these words: "……. the test of obscenity is this, whether the tendency of the matter charged as obscenity is to deprave and corrupt those whose minds are open to such immoral influences" This test has been uniformly followed in India. The Supreme Court has accepted the correctness of the test in Ranjit D. Udeshi v. State Of Maharashtra ., AIR 1965 SC 881. In Samuel Roth v. U.S.A., 354 US 476 (1957), Chief Justice Warren said that the test of 'obscenity' is the
"substantial tendency to corrupt by arousing lustful desires". Mr. Justice Harlan observed that in order to be 'obscene' the matter must "tend to sexually impure thoughts". I do not think that the words uttered in this case have such a tendency. It may be that the words are defamatory of the complainant, but I do not think that the words are 'obscene' and the utterance would constitute an
11
offence punishable under S. 294(b) IPC".
It has to be noted that in the instance case, the absence of words which will involve some lascivious elements arousing sexual thoughts or feelings or words cannot attract the offence under Section 294(b). None of the records disclose the alleged words used by the accused. It may not be the requirement of law to reproduce in all cases the entire obscene words if it is lengthy, but in the instant case, there is hardly anything on record. Mere abusive, humiliating or defamative words by itself cannot attract an offence under Section 294(b) IPC. To prove the offence under Section 294 of IPC mere utterance of obscence words are not sufficient but there must be a further proof to establish that it was to the annoyance of others, which is lacking in the case. No one has spoken about the obscene words, they felt annoyed and in the absence of legal evidence to show that the words uttered by the appellants accused annoyed others, it can not be said that the ingredients of the offence under Section 294 (b) of IPC is made out."
6. Having regard to the law laid down by this Court in P.T.Chacko (supra), Latheef (supra), Sangeetha Lakshmana (supra) and the law down by the Supreme Court in N.S.Madhanagopal and
12
Another (supra), which quotes with approval the judgment of this Court in P.T.Chacko (supra), I am of the view that the proceedings against the petitioners cannot be sustained.
Therefore, all further proceedings against the petitioners in C.C.No.1690 of 2021 on the file of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Mattancherry will stand quashed as against the petitioners. Sd/-
GOPINATH P.
JUDGE
DK
13
APPENDIX OF CRL.MC 6089/2022
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure A1 A TRUE COPY OF THE FIR IN CRIME NO 608 /2021 OF SUB INSPECTOR OF POLICE,
MATTANCHERRY ALONG WITH THE FIRST
INFORMATION STATEMENT
Annexure A2 A CERTIFIED COPY OF THE FINAL REPORT IN
CC NO. 1690 OF 2021 OF THE COURT OF THE
JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE OF THE FIRST CLASS,
MATTANCHERRY
Alert