Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bhaskar Raju And Bro... v. Dharmaratnakara Rai ...

Supreme Court Of India
Sep 26, 2023
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The order concerns a Curative Petition in which notice was issued on 18 July 2023. Having regard to the “larger ramifications and consequences” of the majority view in N N Global Mercantile Private Limited v. Indo Unique Flame Limited ((2023) 7 SCC 1), the Court directed that the matter be placed before a seven-Judge Bench to reconsider the correctness of the view taken by the earlier five-Judge Bench.

The proceedings were directed to be listed for hearing on 11 October 2023 before the seven-Judge Bench. The Court also recorded that a compilation of submissions/documents by several named senior counsel and other counsel had already been filed, and it set out further directions to organize a common electronic compilation through designated nodal counsel.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the correctness of the majority view in N N Global Mercantile Private Limited v. Indo Unique Flame Limited ((2023) 7 SCC 1), rendered by a five-Judge Bench, should be reconsidered by a seven-Judge Bench in light of its larger ramifications and consequences.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents' Submissions (as recorded)

  • Mr. Shyam Divan, senior counsel for the first, second, and fourth respondents, expressed concern during preliminary submissions that his case should not be reopened on facts.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' broader legal arguments on the merits.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
N N Global Mercantile Private Limited v. Indo Unique Flame Limited ((2023) 7 SCC 1) The majority view of the five-Judge Bench, noted as having larger ramifications and consequences. The Court directed that the present curative proceedings be placed before a seven-Judge Bench to reconsider the correctness of that five-Judge Bench view.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reasoned that, considering the “larger ramifications and consequences” flowing from the majority view in N N Global Mercantile Private Limited ((2023) 7 SCC 1), the matter warranted consideration by a larger Bench. On that basis, it directed that the proceedings be placed before a seven-Judge Bench specifically to reconsider the correctness of the five-Judge Bench view.

To facilitate the hearing before the seven-Judge Bench, the Court issued case-management directions: (i) appointing Mr. Debesh Panda and Ms. Pritha Srikumar as nodal counsel by agreement; (ii) requiring a common compilation of submissions, pleadings, documents, and precedents in terms of the Circular dated 22 August 2023 governing larger Bench submissions; (iii) directing completion by 6 October 2023; and (iv) requiring the compilation to be exclusively electronic and emailed to cmvc.dyc@gmail.com. The Court also structured the hearing so that petitioners seeking reconsideration conclude arguments in the first session on 11 October 2023, with respondents responding in the second session, with the aim of concluding arguments the same day.

Further, the Court recorded and acknowledged the concern raised by counsel for certain respondents that the case should not be reopened on facts, stating that this aspect would be borne in mind when arriving at a final conclusion before the seven-Judge Bench.

Holding and Implications

REFERRED / DIRECTED TO BE LISTED BEFORE A SEVEN-JUDGE BENCH to reconsider the correctness of the majority view of the five-Judge Bench in N N Global Mercantile Private Limited v. Indo Unique Flame Limited ((2023) 7 SCC 1), and LISTED for hearing on 11 October 2023 at 10:30 am.

The direct effect is that the Curative Petition will be heard by a seven-Judge Bench, with structured timelines and compilation requirements to regulate submissions. The order does not decide the merits of the reconsideration; it sets the procedural course for the larger Bench hearing and notes that the respondents’ concern about not reopening facts will be kept in mind. No new precedent is set by this procedural direction.

Show all summary ...

1. Notice has been issued in the Curative Petition on 18 July 2023.

2. Having regard to the larger ramifications and consequences of the view of the majority in N N Global Mercantile Private Limited v. Indo Unique Flame Limited (2023) 7 SCC 1, we are of the considered view that the proceedings should be placed before a seven-Judge Bench to reconsider the correctness of the view of the five-Judge Bench.

3. The proceedings shall be listed for hearing on 11 October 2023 before a seven-Judge Bench.

4. A compilation containing the submissions/documents of Mr. Arvind Datar, Mr. Gaurab Banerjee, Mr. Ramesh Singh, Mr. Shyam Divan, senior counsel and Mr. Debesh Panda, Mr. Shadan Farasat, Mr. Kunal Vajani and Ms. Pritha Srikumar has already been filed.

5. In order to facilitate the submissions before the seven-Judge Bench, it has been agreed that Mr. Debesh Panda and Ms. Pritha Srikumar, counsel shall act as the nodal counsel. They shall put together a common compilation of the submissions, pleadings, documents and precedents in terms of the Circular dated 22 August 2023 issued for regulating the course of submissions in larger Bench cases. This exercise shall be completed on or before 6 October 2023. The common compilation shall be made available to all the parties. The compilation shall be exclusively in the electronic form and shall be emailed to cmvc.dyc@gmail.com.

6. The petitioners who are seeking a reconsideration of the decision in N N Global Mercantile Private Limited (supra) shall conclude their arguments in the first session on 11 October 2023. The respondents would be at liberty to respond in the second session so that arguments are concluded on the same day.

7. Mr. Shyam Divan, senior counsel appearing on behalf of the first, second and fourth respondents in the Curative Petition has expressed his concern during the course of his preliminary submission that his case should not be reopened on facts. This aspect will be duly borne in mind in arriving at a final conclusion of the proceedings before the seven-Judge Bench.

8. List the matters on 11 October 2023 at 10.30 am.