Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

STATE OF KARNATAKA v. SHRI. SHIVANAND SHIVAPUTRAPPA YALLUR

Karnataka High Court
Oct 3, 2023

- 1 -

CRL.A.No.100204 of 2017

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

DHARWAD BENCH

DATED THIS THE 03rd DAY OF OCTOBER, 2023

PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI

AND

THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE VENKATESH NAIK T

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 100204 OF 2017

BETWEEN:

STATE OF KARNATAKA,

THROUGH THE DODWAD POLICE STATION,

REPRESENTED BY ADDL. STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,

HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD BENCH.

…APPELLANT

(BY SRI. V.M.BANAKAR, ADDL. SPP).

AND:

1. SHRI. SHIVANAND SHIVAPUTRAPPA YALLUR,

AGE: 84 YEARS, OCC: COOLIE, R/O. BELAVADI,

TALUK. BAILHONGAL, DISTRICT. BELAGAVI.

2. SMT. GANGAWWA WIFE OF SHIVAPUTRAPPA YALLUR,

AGE. 58 YEARS, OCC: COOLIE, R/O. BELAVADI,

TALUK. BAILHONGAL, DISTRICT. BELAGAVI.

…RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. SANTOSH B. MALAGOUDAR, ADV. FOR R1 & R2)

THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 378

(1) AND (3) OF CR.P.C SEEKING TO GRANT LEAVE TO APPEAL

AND TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF

ACQUITTAL DATED 14.07.2015 PASSED BY THE VI ADDL.

DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE, BELAGAVI IN SESSIONS

- 2 -

CASE NO.269 OF 2008 AND TO CONVICT AND SENTENCE THE

RESPONDENT/ACCUSED FOR THE OFFENCES PUNISHABLE UNDER SECTIONS 498-A, 302, 201, 304-B READ WITH

SECTION 34 OF IPC AND SECTION 3 AND 4 OF D.P ACT.

THIS APPEAL HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED

FOR JUDGMENT ON 22.06.2023, COMING ON FOR

PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENT THIS DAY, VENKATESH

NAIK T. J., DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

JUDGMENT

The State has filed the present Criminal Appeal against the impugned judgment and order of acquittal dated 14.07.2015 in S.C. No.269/2008 passed by VI Additional District and Sessions Judge, Belagavi, acquitting the accused for the offences punishable under Sections 498-A, 302, 201, 304-B R/w. Section 34 of IPC and Sections 3 and 4 of D. P. Act. For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred to as per their ranking before Trial Court. The appellant is complainant - State and respondents are accused Nos.1 and 2.

2. Brief facts of the case are as under;

3. Accused No.1 - Shri. Shivanand Shivaputrappa Yallur was the husband and accused No.2 - Smt.

- 3 -

Gangawa W/o. Shivaputrappa Yallur was the mother-in- law of deceased Sarala. The marriage of accused No.1 solemnized with Sarala in the year 2003 and at the time of marriage, cash, gold, clothes and utensils were given to accused No.1 as dowry. After the marriage, the relationship of accused No.1 and Salara was cordial for couple of months and thereafter accused Nos.1 and 2 started harassing the deceased Sarala on the pretext that she should bring Rs. 20,000/- as additional dowry from her parents and in this regard, they physically and mentally ill treated her, threatened her with dire consequences to eliminate her, if she does not bring additional dowry of Rs.20,000/-. On 03.06.2008 at about 8:00 p.m., deceased Sarala was watching television in the house of one Gousmohammed Sab Mulla (PW7), thus, accused No.1 went there and abused Sarala in filthy language, dragged her by holding her hair, brought her to his house, and then strangulated her by using cloth around her neck and burnt the body by pouring kerosene and set

- 4 -

fire in order to destroy the evidence, thus, PW.1, lodged the complaint to the Dodwad police station, Belagavi District.

4. On the basis of the complaint given by PW.1, Dodwad police registered the case in Crime No.60/2008 against accused Nos.1 and 2 for the offences punishable under Sections 498-A, 302, 201 and 304-B read with Section 34 of IPC and Sections 3 and 4 of D. P. Act.

5. During the course of investigation, the investigation officer visited the spot, conducted the spot Punchnama, seized material objects, conducted the inquest Punchnama, recorded the statement of witnesses and after conclusion of the investigation, the investigation officer filed charge sheet against accused Nos.1 and 2 for the aforesaid offences before Jurisdictional Magistrate. After the institution of the charge sheet, the learned jurisdictional magistrate took cognizance of offence U/sec.190(1)(b) of Cr.P.C against accused persons in C.C.No. 595/2008 and since the

- 5 -

offences alleged exclusively triable by the Court of Sessions, the case was committed to the Court of Sessions. After committal of case to the court of Sessions, the Trial Court secured the presence of accused and after hearing both side framed charges for the offences punishable under Sections 498-A, 302, 201, 304-B R/w. Section 34 of IPC and Sections 3 and 4 of D.P. Act, and read over and explained to accused Nos.1 and 2, they pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.

6. The prosecution, in order to prove it's case got examined in all 21 witnesses as PW.1 to PW.21 and got marked 16 documents as Ex.P.1 to Ex.P.16 and material objects marked as MO.1 to M.O.13. For the defence 8 documents got marked as Ex.D.1 to Ex.D.8. After the completion of the evidence, statement of accused Nos.1 and 2 were recorded by the trial Court under section 313 of Cr.P.C. The case of the accused persons were of total denial and no witnesses were examined on the half of the accused persons.

- 6 -

7. The Trial Court, based on the oral and documentary evidence on record, framed the following points for consideration:

POINTS FOR CONSIDERATION.

1. Whether the prosecution proves beyond all reasonable doubt that accused No.1 and 2 have subjected the deceased Sarala for cruelty by demanding to bring addition dowry of Rs. 20,000/- from her parent's house and thereby committed an offence punishable U/s. 498-A r/w. Sec. 34 of IPC.

2. Whether the prosecution proves beyond all reasonable doubt that accused No.1 and 2 with common intention committed murder of Smt. Sarala at about 8.00 p.m. in the house of accused No.1 at Belavadi village by strangulating her by using a cloth tying around her neck and thereby committed an offence punishable U/s. 302 r/w. Sec.34 of IPC?

3. Alternatively, whether the prosecution proves beyond all reasonable doubt that on the above said date, time and place the accused have strangulated Sarla by using a cloth tying

- 7 -

around her neck and thereby they have committed an offence punishable U/s. 304 r/w. Sec.34 of IPC?

4. Whether the prosecution proves beyond all reasonable doubt that accused No.1 and 2 to destroy the evidence, have poured kerosene on the body of the deceased Sarala and set fire and burnt the body and thereby they have committed an offence punishable U/s. 201 r/w. Sec.34 of IPC?

5. Whether the prosecution proves beyond all reasonable doubt that accused No. 1 and 2 at the time of marriage of Sarla demanded and accepted cash, gold ornaments, clothes and utensils as dowry and thereby they have committed an offence punishable U/s. 3 of D.P. Act?

6. Whether the prosecution proves beyond all reasonable doubt that the accused No. 1 and 2 demanded Smt. Sarla who is wife of accused No. 1 to bring cash of Rs. 20,000/- as additional dowry from the parents of Smt. Sarla and thereby they have committed and offence punishable U/s. 4 of D.P Act?

- 8 -

7. What Order?

8. The Trial Court, after considering the entire oral and documentary evidence on record answered points Nos.1 to 6 in the negative and recorded a finding that, the prosecution failed to prove it's case beyond all reasonable doubt that, accused Nos.1 and 2 have subjected the deceased Sarala by demanding a sum of Rs.20,000/- as additional dowry from her parental house and on 03.06.2008 at 8.00 p.m., accused Nos.1 and 2 with a common intention committed the murder of deceased Sarala in their house at Belavadi by strangulating her, using a cloth around her neck and poured kerosene on the body of deceased Sarala, set fire and burnt her body. Accordingly, the trial Court acquitted accused Nos.1 and 2 for the aforesaid offences.

9. Aggrieved by the judgment of acquittal passed by the trial Court, the State has preferred this appeal.

- 9 -

10. Learned Additional State Public Prosecutor contended that the judgment and order of acquittal passed by the trial Court is contrary to law, facts and evidence on record; the trial Court acquitted the accused Nos.1 and 2 holding that the prosecution has failed to bring home the guilt of accused and the trial Court has not at all appreciated the evidence of PW.5 to PW.7, who are an eye witness to the incident; though, there is clinching, cogent and corroborative evidence in the testimony of prosecution witnesses, but, the trial Court has not at all believed the prosecution witness; the reasons assigned by the trial Court are not just and proper. It is further contended that PW.1 is the complainant and father of deceased, he has clearly deposed in support of prosecution case, he has deposed regarding the cruelty and ill-treatment given by accused persons to deceased Sarala and he has deposed about conciliation held between deceased Sarala and accused No.1 prior to the incident; the evidence of PW.1 is

- 10 -

corroborated by evidence of PW.2 - Vidya Mahadev Kamble, who is the circumstantial witness and the evidence of PW.3 - Smt. Chinnava Pundalik Huded, the mother of deceased and PW.4 - Basaningappa Annappa Huded, the relative of deceased. It is further contended that PW.5 to PW.7 were the witnesses to the alleged incident, who have rushed immediately to the spot after the incident and saw the injured in the house of accused and they have deposed about the conduct of accused, soon after the incident; their testimony is corroborative, consistent and conclusive in nature, but, the trial Court has not properly read and appreciated their evidence. It is further contended that deceased Sarala died within 7 years of her marriage and there is ample evidence regarding the cruelty and ill-treatment in respect of demand of dowry and the death of Sarala was un- natural; but, the trial Court did not raise any presumption under Section 113(B) of the Indian Evidence Act. It is further submitted that, the death of deceased

- 11 -

took place in the house of accused and it is for the accused to explain under what circumstances and in what manner the death of deceased had occurred as per Section 106 of Indian Evidence Act; but, this aspect of the matter has not been considered by the trial Court. It is further contended that PW.16 - Dr. Vikas Parappa Savadi, who conducted the postmortem examination of the dead body of deceased Sarala clearly opined that the death of the deceased Sarala was due to Asphyxia as a result of strangulation, and he has stated that the body was completely burnt and there was a kerosene smell on the body and he seen a cloth around the neck of the deceased Sarala and the cloth was with knot, there was a un-burnt skin around the neck, he seen a ligature mark around the neck; there were no carbon particles in the lungs; therefore the evidence of doctor is corroborative with the other witnesses; but, the trial Court has not assigned any valid reasons in discarding the evidence of Doctor and other circumstantial witness. It is further

- 12 -

contended that the trial court has acquitted accused Nos.1 and 2 relying on the contradictions and omission made in the prosecution case; the learned trial Judge has acquitted the accused on the ground that deceased Sarala was suffering from ill health and she herself committed suicide, but the reasons assigned are not supported by any legal evidence; the trial Court has acquitted the accused persons on the ground that there are no eyewitnesses to the incident and the reasons assigned by the trial Court are not just and proper; therefore the judgment and order of acquittal is not sustainable in the eyes of law and the same is liable to be set aside. Thus, the learned Additional State Public prosecutor prayed to convict the accused for the aforesaid offences.

11. Learned counsel for the respondent vehemently argued and sought to justify the impugned judgment and order of acquittal and contended that all the independent eye witness have turned hostile to the

- 13 -

case of prosecution; the case has been decided by the learned Sessions Judge on the basis of contradictions and improvement made in the prosecution case. It is contended that, as the deceased Sarala was suffering from ill health, she has committed suicide in the house of accused No.1; therefore, considering this aspect and the fact that there are no eye witnesses to the alleged incident, the trial Court has rightly acquitted accused Nos.1 and 2, after considering both oral and documentary evidence on record, and the same is just and proper and this Court cannot interfere with the same, thus, the counsel sought to dismiss the appeal.

12. In view of the rival contentions, urged by the learned counsels for the parties, the following points that would arisen for our consideration are as under:

- 14 -

POINTS

1) Whether the prosecution prove the homicidal death of deceased Sarala?

2) Whether the State/ appellant has made out any case for interference with the impugned judgment and order of acquittal for the offences punishable under Section Sections 498-A, 302, 201, 304-B R/w. Section 34 of IPC and Sections 3 and 4 of D. P. Act, in the facts and circumstances of the case?

13. Points No.1 and 2:- As points No.1 and 2 are interlinked in order to avoid repetitive of facts, both the points are taken together for common discussion.

14. On perusal of charge framed by the trial court it appears that, accused No.1 and deceased Sarala are husband and wife, accused No.2 is mother of accused No.1, they subjected deceased to bring additional dowry of Rs.20,000/- from the parents of Sarala and on 03.06.2008 at 8.00 P.M, accused No.1 strangulated

- 15 -

Sarala by using a cloth tying around her neck and set - fire, thus her body was burnt to death, thus, accused have committed an offence.

15. Per contra, the accused have denied the allegation as alleged by the prosecution and they contended that, deceased Sarala was suffering from mental illness and therefore, she committed suicide by Pouring Kerosene on her person set-fire ablaze thus, accused have not committed any offence.

16. We have given our anxious consideration to the arguments made by the learned counsel for the parties and perused the entire oral and documentary evidence on record. In order to appreciate the oral and documentary evidence on record, it is relevant to consider the evidence of prosecution witnesses and exhibited documents on record.

A) PW1 - Pundalik Basappa Huded, the father of deceased Sarala, who lodged the complaint (Ex.P1) has

- 16 -

stated that, the marriage of his daughter was taken place on 02.05.2003 with accused No.1. At the time of marriage, he had given household utensils and 1/2 Tola of gold and wristwatch to accused No.1 and after the marriage, her daughter joined the matrimonial house of accused No.1 and they were living happily for about seven years. He further stated that along with accused No.1, his father, mother and sisters were living with him. After eight months of the marriage, accused No.1 used to send the deceased Sarala to Coolie work and after returning from Coolie work, accused were not giving food to the deceased Sarala and accused were not taking her to the hospital, whenever she falls sick. PW.1 was cross examined. In the cross-examination, PW.1 admitted that, his daughter Sarala studied up to 7thstandard. He has three daughters through his first wife and a son, viz, Gourawwa, Sarala, Praveen and Sudha and his first marriage was held in the year 1982 and, his first wife died in the year 1994 and hence he got married PW3 as

- 17 -

second wife in the year 1995. At that time, the deceased Sarala was aged about 10 to 12 years. His second wife (PW3) took care of deceased Sarala till her marriage. At the time of marriage, there was marriage talk held and half Tola gold, clothes and wrist watch was agreed to be given to accused No.1. He admitted that at the time of marriage of Sarala, he did not give any gold and Silver articles to his daughter. He further stated that, the accused had brought clothes to her, his daughter's marriage was performed in Shaleshwara Temple at Belagavi and after the marriage, they were residing in Belagavi. He further admitted that Sarala was suffering from ill health, and deceased and her husband frequently used to quarrel with each other, hence, he brought his daughter to his house. He further admits that three months prior to the death of Sarala, accused No.1 brought his daughter to Belavadi and well wisher of accused No.1 were came to the house of PW.1 and had a Panchayath. Hence, PW1 sent his daughter to the house

- 18 -

of accused No.1. He further admitted that soon after the death of Sarala, one Ismail Mahadum Kittur - PW.5, informed over phone about the death of Sarala. Hence, he immediately came and saw the dead body of his daughter, and also seen the kerosene bottle. He further admitted that he do not know scribe of complaint, and its contents. He further admits that some third persons have forced him to give complaint that her daughter Sarala have committed suicide by setting fire to herself. Hence, he lodged a complaint. He further admits that the police had enquired him, but he did not know the contents of his statement. Hence, he denied the statement given to the police as per Ex.D.1. He further admits that, he did not know anything about the statement given before the police officers. He further denied the statement given before the Tahasildar as per Ex.D.3.

B) PW.2- Vidya Mahadev Kamble, the conciliator in her evidence, she has stated that she has been working as lecturer in law the college and she also

- 19 -

working as conciliator in Women Welfare Institution situated at Srinagar, Belagavi. She further stated that, accused No.1 came to their institution and complained that his wife has been residing in her parental house since 2 years and he is willing to live with his wife, therefore, she sent a notice to Sarala and her parents. The parents of Sarala told that, they won't send their daughter to the house of accused No.1, as accused No.1 is not taking care of Sarala and thereafter nobody appear before her, later she closed the complaint. In the cross examination, PW.2 admitted that accused No.1 came to the institution and requested her to solve the problem. She further admitted that deceased Sarala was in the habit of going her parents house on silly reasons. She further admits that, she enquired with Sarala and she was willing to lead her marital life with accused No.1, but her father PW.1 Pundalik Basappa Huded was not allowing her, and PW1 told accused No.1 to approach the Court of law and took her to his matrimonial home.

- 20 -

C) PW3- Smt. Chinnavva, the step mother of deceased Sarala and 2ndwife of PW2 was examined and she reiterated the testimony of PW.1.

D) PW.4-Basaningappa Annappa Huded, who is the cousin of PW.1 and he has stated about the marriage negotiation of accused No.1 with Sarala and he had attended the marriage, after the marriage he advised accused persons and sent Sarala to the house of accused. He has stated about cruelty made by accused to diseased Sarala. PW4 was cross examined. In the cross- examination, he admitted that Sarala was suffering from ill health and she was taking treatment at Dr. NaiK of Neginhal and she also took treatment at Dr. Suresh Chate at Bailhongal. She did not know that Dr. Suresh Charte is a psychiatric. He further admitted that they provided treatment to Sarala at Belagavi and took treatment by Dr. Chougala and Dr. Sameer Chate. He further admits that deceased was in the house of PW.1 almost for a period of 2 years by leaving her husband

- 21 -

and prior to her death, she was, residing with her husband accused No. 1. He admits that, father, mother and sister of accused No.1 were residing at Belagavi. He further admitted that 15 days prior to the death of deceased Sarala, the couple informed him that they were in cordial terms.

E) PW.5 Ismail Kittur is neighbor of accused No.1 and he is a chance witness. He has stated that, he is neighbor of accused No.1. He has stated that after the marriage of accused No.1 with Sarala, they came to Belavadi village and after 2 years of marriage, the difference of opinion arisen between the accused persons and deceased and thereafter deceased Sarala started to live in her parental house. Hence, father of accused came to him and requested to resolve the dispute. Thereafter, himself Shivaputrappa and others went to Pattihal village, after discussion and negotiation deceased Sarala was taken to the house of accused No.1. He further stated that Sarala was happily living in the house of

- 22 -

accused No.1 for a period of two months and after sometime deceased Sarala told that accused persons are harassing her. He further stated that one day in the morning accused No.1 went to Belagavi to his mother's house and came to house at 8:30 p.m. At that time, Sarala was watching Television in his house, thus, accused No.1 assaulted her. In this regard, he advised accused No.1 properly. Thereafter, at about 11 p.m., he heard quarrel sound, from the house of accused No.1, hence, he went to the house of accused No.1, at that time, accused No.1 was making hue and cry, and the body of Sarala was burning and there was a cloth in the mouth of deceased, and a cloth around the neck of the deceased. Hence, he came to know that accused No.1 killed deceased Sarala by burning her. PW.5- was cross examined. In the cross examination, he admitted that once he gave a statement to the police and after 8 to 10 days of the incident, woman police have not recorded his statement. He did not know whether the police came

- 23 -

from Bangaluru for investigation. He admits that at the time of marriage, he attended for marriage talks and he denied to have given statement as per Ex.D.6. He also denied that at the time of marriage, the father of deceased Sarala was agreed to give 20 gms of gold, cash of Rs.10,000/-, a wrist watch and cooking vessels to his daughter and the same is denied as per Ex.D.6. He further denied that he has given statement to the police alleging that 1 day at 11:30 p.m, he heard the quarrel from the house of accused No.1, hence, he went to the house of accused No.1 and saw Sarala's body and it was burning. Hence, he denied to have given statement as per Ex.D.6(b). He further admitted that the Inspector - Smt. Satyawati has not recorded his statement. He further admits that Accused No.2 Smt. Gangawwa lodged the complaint against him and others alleging that PW.5 and four others are liable to pay Rs.15,000/-, which was misappropriated by PW.5 and four others and the same is categorically admitted by him.

- 24 -

F) PW.6 - Mallikarjun Rudrappa Kumbi, the neighbor of accused No.1, he has stated that, on ill-fated day, when he was in his house, he heard quarrel sound from the house of accused No.1. Hence, he went there and saw fire on the body of Sarala and she was burning, the cloth was tied around her neck, therefore, himself and other persons who were there, tried to pour water on the person of Sarala, by that time, Sarala had died and accused No.1 was in front of his house and was raising hue and cry. Therefore, he presume that accused No.1 might have set fire. Immediately, he called the Dodwad police and handed over accused No.1 to the police and on the next day morning the dead body of Sarala was taken to burial ground. According to PW.6, accused No.1 might have murdered Sarala, but, he did not know the reasons. PW.6 - was cross examined. In the cross- examination, he has admitted that Dodwad police have recorded his statement in the house of accused No.1. He admits that, police officers have not recorded i.e., DYSP

- 25 -

has not recorded his statement. He has denied to have given statement as per Ex.D.7 and has admitted that soonafter the incident i.e., in the morning, he came to know about the incident and this part of statement is denied. He admits that he has not given statement that accused No.2 lodged the complaint to the police for not returning Rs15,000/-. Hence, his statement is marked as Ex.D.7(a). He further admits that, there is ill will between him and accused persons, and mother of accused No.1 has lodged the complaint stating that, PW.6 and four others recovered Rs.35,000/- for funeral expenses and retained Rs.15,000/- with them. Hence accused No.2 lodged a complaint against PW.6 and three others. He further admitted that till the death of deceased Sarala there was no quarrel between accused No.1 and Sarala and both were led happy marital life and accused No.1 was looking after the deceased Sarala well and rest of the suggestions were denied.

- 26 -

G) PW.7 - Goussab Mohammedsab Mujawar, who has also given evidence in the line of evidence of PW.6. PW.7 has undergone intensive cross-examination by the learned counsel for the accused. In the cross- examination, he admits that, accused No.1 and his wife were residing in Belavadi village and both were in cordial terms and they never quarreled with each other. He further admits that, though, he visited the spot, he did not pour water on the person of Sarala. Hence, he has denied his statement as per Ex.D.8, he admits that, the material object were recovered from the person of injured Sarala. He admits that, accused borrowed a sum of Rs.35,000/- with interest for the purpose of funeral ceremony and remaining amount was retained with PW.6 and 7 in this regard, accused No.2 - Gangawwa lodged the complaint against PW.6, 7 and 2 others.

H) PW.8 - Virupaxi Sangappa Karikatti, is the witness to Inquest Punchnama (Ex.P.3), in his evidence, he stated that police came to the house of accused No.1

- 27 -

and conducted inquest Punchnama on the dead body of Sarala as per Ex.P.3 and thereafter, Police also drew spot Punchnama as per Ex.P.4 and seized M.O.1 to 8 in his presence.

I) PW.8 - was cross examined. In the cross- examination, he admits that he cannot say the time of drawing Panchnama, he cannot say who has invited him to stand as pancha. He did not know the contents of Ex.P.3 and Ex.P.4, he did not identify any jewellery found on the dead body, he cannot say how M.O.1 to 8 were recovered and where it was recovered.

J) PW.9 - Ramesh Nagesh Joshi, the Police Constable of Ankalagi Police Station, is the one who brought the cloths of deceased Sarala from the hospital as per M.O.9 to 11, and handed over to I.O.

K) PW.10 - Shivaji Bhimappa Gandugudari witness to Ex.P.5 the cloth seizure mahazar, but he turned hostile to the case of prosecution.

- 28 -

L) PW.11 - Babu Durgappa Madar, is one of the witness to cloth seizure mahazar as per Ex.P.5, he also turned hostile to the case of prosecution.

M) PW.12 - Shivakumar Mallikarjunappa Shilavant Tahasildar of Bailhongal, in his evidence he has stated that, on 04.06.2008, the PSI of doddawad police requested him to conduct the inquest Punchnama on the dead body of deceased Sarala, hence, he visited the spot and conducted the Inquest Punchnama, in the presence of Virupaxi, Veerappa and Smt. Karevva, as per Ex.P.3 and he recorded the statement of father and mother of diseased and he also prepared another report as per Ex.P.6. PW.12 -was cross examined and in the cross- examination, he admits that, he cannot say the exact time of recording the statement of witness and he has not mentioned the time in Ex.P.6. He did not verify as to existence of any windows in the house of A1. He saw 12 bangles in each hand of the deceased. He did not see mangalsutra in the neck and there was no jewel in the

- 29 -

ear and nose of the deceased Sarala. He did not verify as to, if the fire is set, there is only one way to exit from the door, he did not see a broken bangles in the house. He admits that, the mother of deceased gave statement before him that her daughter informed her stating that since three months they were in cordial terms.

N) PW.13 - Konappa Ningappa Vagatti, the Secretary of Gram Panchayat, who issued property extract as per Ex.P.6. As per EX.P6, the house belongs to the father of accused No.1 and one Mahadevappa.

O) PW.14 - Ravindra Gourishankar Vantamutte, the Assistant Engineer, PWD, who prepared a sketch of the scene of offence and handed over the same to the Investigation Officer as per Ex.P.8.

P) PW.15 - S. Ganeshmurthy, the CPI of Dodwad Police Station in his evidence, he has stated that on 04.06.2008 at about 1:00 p.m, when he was in the police station, PW.1 came and lodged the complaint as per

- 30 -

Ex.P1, hence he registered the same in Crime No.60/2008 and sent FIR and complait to the Court and his superior officers and on the same day, he requested the Tahasildar Bailhongal for conducting the Inquest Panchnama, thereafter he handed over further investigation of this case to in-charge Dy.S.P, Bailhongal and later, as per the direction of Dy.S.P, he secured accused Nos.1 and 2 and produced them before the Investigation Officer.

Q) PW.16 - Dr. Vikas Parappa Savadi, a medical officer in Budarkatti Government Hospital. He has stated that, on 04.06.2008 at 5:45 p.m, he conducted post- mortem examination on the dead body of the deceased Sarala. The body was completely burnt and kerosene smell was there, the death was due to Asphyxia as a result of strangulation and the injuries found on the body are sufficient to cause death. He further stated that M.O.5 was in the neck of the deceased and there was a cloth ligature mark around the neck. There was a cloth

- 31 -

knot on the backside of the neck and the cloth was with knot. He further stated that right ulna and radius bones were fractured. Muscles of neck, artillery, tracheal and cartilages were injured. There were no carbon particles in the lungs and remaining organs were in tact and time since death is 12 to 24 hours. Hence, he issued postmortem report as per Ex.P.10, as per request of Investigation Officer, he has issued final opinion as per Ex.P.11. PW.16 was cross examined. In the cross examination, he admits that, he has not described the cloth tied on the neck of the deceased. He has also not mentioned the parts of ligature mark and its length. He admits that he has no material to show that the cloth seized from the neck of the deceased and ligature mark are tallied with each other. He further admits that, he did not release the knot found on the neck. He further admits that, before conducting the post-mortem examination, he separated the cloth tied on the neck and the same was handed over to the police. But he did not

- 32 -

handed over the same in sealed and packed condition. He further admitted that, the clothes seized from the neck of Sarala was a silk sari. He further admitted that, M.O.5 a piece of cloth shown in the court was not seized from the neck of the deceased Sarala.

R) PW.17, the D.S.P of Bailhongal in his evidence, he has stated that on 09.06.2008, he took further investigation of this case from Dy.S.P of Belagavi Rural, and thereafter he sent requisition to PWD official for preparing the spot sketch, who in-turn visited the spot and prepared the spot sketch as per Ex.P.8. Later, he collected house extract of accused as per Ex.P.7 and he handed over further investigation of this case to CID official on 17.06.2008.

S) PW.18 - Ninganagouda Patil, ACP, Hubli, in his evidence he has stated that, on 04.06.2008, he received information from PSI of Dodawad police station that a case was registered in Crime No.60/2008 for the offences punishable under Sections 498-A, 304-B and 302 IPC and

- 33 -

under Sections 3 and 4 of DP Act. Immediately he went to Belavadi village took over further investigation, recorded the statement of witnesses, conducted, the Panchnama, seized M.Os.1 to 8 from the spot. On the same day, PSI of Dodawad police station arrested accused Nos.1 and 2 and produced before him, thus he arrested them. He recorded the statements of Pundalik and Smt. Channavva and after the postmortem the clothes of deceased were seized them in the presence of panchas under seizure panchanama as per Ex.P.5. He admitted that on 05.06.2008 he recorded the statements of witnesses by name Ismail, Mallikarjun, Rafiq, fakkirappa, Basavaraj, Ramesh and Irappa. In the cross- examination, he admitted that he did not verify the dead body of deceased Sarala. He did not see the cloth around the neck of deceased. He did not measured the cloth seized by him. He further admits that cloth seized by him has not been produced before the Court and he cannot say the nature of piece of cloth.

- 34 -

T) PW.19 - Smt. Satyavati S., Police Inspector, Anti Dowry Cell, COD, Bangalore, in her evidence, she has stated that, on 02.06.2008, she took charge of this case. On 18.06.2018, she recorded the statement of uncle of deceased by name Basavalingappa Annappa Huded and Guruputrappa Balappa Holeyate and recorded their statements. On 19.06.2008, she recorded the further statement of PW1 - Pundalik Basappa Huded, the complainant and also recorded the statements of PW. 2 - Vidya Mahadev Kamble, PW.3 -Chinnavva Pundalik Huded, PW.4 - Basaningappa Annappa Huded, PW.5 - Ismail Magadum Kittur, PW.6 - Mallikarjun Rudrappa Kumbi, PW.6 - Mallikarjun Rudrappa Kumbi, PW.7 - Goussab Mohammedsab Mujawar. On 20.06.2008, she received M.Os.2 to 13 from Dodawad police station and send them to FSL Bangalore for chemical examination. On 07.08.2008 she wrote a letter to Medical Officer, Budurkatti PHC to know further details of postmortem. Thereafter, on 08.08.2008 Medical Officer gave his

- 35 -

written reply. Thereafter, she completed the investigation and filed the charge sheet as there was sufficient evidence against the accused. The FSL report has been produced before the Court against accused Nos.1 and 2.

U) PW.19 has been cross-examined, in the cross- examination, she has admitted that, before recording the statements of witnesses, the Dy.S.P of Bailhongal, had recorded the statement of witnesses. She further stated that, as per her the present case does not come within the purview of dowry death. PW.19 further admits that she has not examined neither of accused No.1 nor accused No.2. She further admitted that, she saw rose colour cloth around the neck of the deceased Sarala. She further admitted that the said cloth was completely burnt. She cannot say that the cloth is of cotton or any other cloth. So she admits that she cannot identify the cloth. She cannot describe it, as the cloth is cotton or any other cloth.

- 36 -

V) PW.20 - Vilas Irappa Kotabagi, the photographer examined on oath. In his evidence he has stated that, during the year 2008, the police called him as his availability in the village and he took photographs of lady and she was completely burnt. Hence, as per the request of police issued 2 photographs as per Ex.P.2(a) and Ex.P.2(b) and Ex.P.P 16.

W) PW.21 - Srinivasan, the constable who carried a FIR to the Court and thereafter he submitted that he has reported it to the Investigation Officer.

17. Based on the aforesaid evidence, the trial Court acquitted the accused persons.

18. Having perused the entire oral and documentary evidence on record, it is clear that, the deceased Sarala died in the house of accused and her dead body was completely burnt. It is the case of the prosecution that, accused Nos.1 and 2 were harassing the deceased Sarala during her lifetime in respect of

- 37 -

bringing additional dowry; on 03.06.2008 at 8 p.m, accused No.1 took quarrel with deceased Sarala when the deceased Sarala was watching the television in the house of Gousmohammed Sab (PW7), abused her in filthy language, dragged her by holding her tuft, brought her to his house, strangulated the deceased by using a cloth around her neck and burnt her body by pouring kerosene and set fire in order to destroy the evidence. However, the accused have denied the allegations made against them, under such circumstances, the prosecution has to prove the ingredients of Section 304(b) of IPC. The basic ingredient to attract offence under Section 304(b) of IPC are as follows;

"304-B. Dowry death.-(1) Where the death of a woman is caused by any burns or bodily injury or occurs otherwise than under normal circumstances within seven years of her marriage and it is shown that soon before her death she was subjected to cruelty or harassment by her husband or any relative of her husband for, or in connection with, any demand for dowry, (4) such cruelty or harassment should be for or in connection with the

- 38 -

demand of dowry; and (5) it is established that such cruelty and harassment made soon before her death.

19. Further, Section 113-B of the Evidence Act is also relevant for the case at hand. Both Section 304-B IPC and Section 113-B of the Evidence Act has to be looked into for drawing presumption.

"113-B. Presumption as to dowry death. - When the question is whether as person has committed the dowry death of a woman and it is shown that soon before her death such woman had been subjected by such person to cruelty or harassment for, or in connection with, any demand for dowry, the court shall presume that such person had caused the dowry death.

Explanation.-For the purpose of this section, 'dowry death' shall have the same meaning as in Section 304-B of the Penal Code.

20. In the light of aforesaid proposition of law, and the prosecution evidence, the counsel mainly relied upon the oral testimony of PWs.1 to 7. PW.1 who is none

- 39 -

other than the father of the deceased, PW.3 is the mother of the deceased and PW.4 is the uncle of deceased and PW.5 to 7 are residents of Belavadi village. On perusal of Ex.P.1 - complaint, it is alleged that after 2 years of the marriage deceased Sarala was subjected harassment and accused and few persons were started to harass her by demanding her to bring an additional dowry of Rs.20,000/- from her parental house and it is alleged that deceased Sarala was physically and mentally harassed by accused persons. But, there is no specific allegations against the accused persons, in respect of demand made by accused, but, on perusal of evidence of PW.1, the complainant - the father of deceased has stated that, after the marriage of deceased, she was happy in her in-laws house and thereafter accused started harassing the deceased, the accused started to send the deceased to coolie work, they were not providing food to the deceased and accused No.1 was demanding the deceased to bring an additional dowry of

- 40 -

Rs.20,000/- from her parental house. But, in the course of cross examination, PW.1 completely denied the statement given before the police as per Ex.D 1 to 3 and thereby given go bye to the allegations of dowry harassment. On perusal of Ex.D.1, it appears that, four days earlier, to her death, Sarala had telephoned to PW.1 and told that, she is happy in the House of accused No.1 and her mother-in-law and sister-in-laws were not in the house. It appears that, prior to the death of Sarala, she was happy with her husband. On perusal of the evidence of PW.3, the mother of victim, she deposed that she has not given any statement before the police as per the Ex.D.4 and on perusal of Ex.D.4, it appears that four days prior to the death of Sarala, he telephoned to PW.3 and stated that Sarala and her husband - accused No.1 were happy and their in-laws were not visiting their house, it clearly established that before the death of deceased Sarala, there was no harassment by the accused persons, in respect of alleged demand of dowry.

- 41 -

21. PW.4 who is the uncle of deceased also stated that accused No.1 and deceased Sarala were residing at Belavadi, but, PW.4 has not stated that there was a physical assault made by the accused persons to the deceased Sarala.

22. In the instant case, PW.5 to 7 are the main witnesses who are residents of Belavadi Village, they have stated that, at the time of incident, they visited the spot.

23. On perusal of evidence of PW5- Ismial Kittur, he has admitted that he has not given statement before the police as per Ex.D.6. On perusal of Ex.D.6, it appears that, PW.6 - Mallikarjun Rudrappa Kumbi has attended the marriage proceedings and at the time of marriage he negotiated as elders and in Ex.D.6(a), it is stated that Rs.10,000/- cash, 20 gms of gold, clothes and wrist watch were given to accused No.1 as dowry, but, PW.5 has not stated that he has given statement as Ex.D.6 and Ex.D.6(a).

- 42 -

24. So far as evidence of PW.6- Mallikarjun Rudrappa Kumbi is concerned, he has stated that, he has not given statement before the police as per Ex.D.7, 7(a) and 7(b), thereby denied to have given statement before the Investigating Officer. But, on perusal of Ex.D.8 it appears that, on 04.06.2008 in the morning, PW.6 came to know about the incident, but, on perusal of evidence of PW.7 he has stated that on 03.06.2008 in the night deceased was watching TV in his house, at that time, accused No.1 came and dragged her to his house and thereafter he heard the noise from the house of a accused No.1, thus, he went to the house of accused and saw that the deceased Sarala was burning, but, in the cross-examination, he has denied to have given such statement before the Investigation Officer. Further, PW.5 to 7, have clearly admitted that, there was ill will between deceased, accused No.2 and PW.5 to 7 in respect of loan borrowed by accused No.1 for the purpose of funeral expenses and amount was handed

- 43 -

over to PW.7. But, PW-7 had incurred an amount of Rs.15,000/- only towards funeral expenses and retained Rs.20,000/- with him. Therefore, accused No.2 had lodged the complaint against PW.5 to 7 and another person. Hence, the counsel for accused contended that the evidence of PW.1, 3, 4 and 5 to 7 appears to be interested witnesses, in order to get conviction of accused persons.

25. It is well settled law that, the evidence of interested witnesses required careful scrutiny to discover falsehood, embellishment or exaggeration, which must be eschewed.

26. The Hon'ble Apex Court in case of Hariram vs. State of U.P. reported in (2004) 8 SCC 146 observed that, "the evidence of related witness and their credibility has to be considered. In case of interested witness, foundation has to be laid, if plea of false implication is made, then in such case, the Court has to

- 44 -

adopt a careful approach and analyze evidence to find out whether it is cogent and credible".

27. Whereas in the instant case, the incident occurred in the house of accused No.1 and the house is standing in his father's name and the most natural witness would be PWs.5 to 7, who are the neighbors of the house of accused No.1. But, on perusal of the oral testimony of PWs.5 to 7, they have deposed contrary evidence and their testimony is not corroborated with each other.

28. Moreover, PW.5 Ismail Kittur, PW.6 - Mallikarjun Kumbi and PW.7 - Goussab Mujawar had ill will against the accused persons as accused No.2 has lodged complaint against PW.5 to 7 and another for not handing over of Rs.15,000/- to the accused. Further, PW.5 to 7 are not an eye witnesses. According to PW.18 investigation officer, PW.5 to PW.7 are not an eye witnesses to the incident.

- 45 -

29. In the case of unnatural death of a married woman, as in a case of this nature, the husband could be prosecuted under Sections 302, 304-B and 306 of the Penal Code.

30. As per the case of prosecution the accused persons were demanding additional dowry from the parents of deceased Sarala hence, she was subjected to cruelty soon before her death. Whereas, in the evidence of father (PW.1) and mother (PW.3), they have not stated about the alleged dowry demand made by accused persons and they have not given any statement before the police Inspector Anti Dowry Cell, in this regard. In order to attract Section 304-B of IPC and in order to draw presumption under Section 113-B of Indian Evidence Act, the prosecution must prove that soon before the death of Sarala, she was subjected to cruelty in connection with demand of dowry. Whereas, in the instance case the ingredients of Section 304-B is absent.

- 46 -

31. In Hira Lal v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) reported in (2003) 8 SCC 80 the Hon'ble Apex Court observed thus :

"9. … The expression 'soon before her death' used in the substantive Section 304-B IPC and Section 113-B of the Evidence Act is present with the idea of proximity test. No definite period has been indicated and the expression 'soon before' is not defined. A reference to the expression 'soon before' used in Section 114 Illustration (a) of the Evidence Act is relevant. It lays down that a court may presume that a man who is in the possession of goods 'soon after the theft, is either the thief or has received the goods knowing them to be stolen, unless he can account for their possession'. The determination of the period which can come within the term 'soon before' is left to be determined by the courts, depending upon facts and circumstances of each case. Suffice, however, to indicate that the expression 'soon before' would normally imply that the interval should not be much between the cruelty or harassment concerned and the death in question. There must be existence of a proximate and live link between the effect of cruelty based on dowry demand and the death concerned. If the alleged incident of cruelty is remote in time and has become stale enough not to disturb the mental equilibrium of the woman concerned, it would be of no consequence."

- 47 -

32. In view of the above proposition of law and decisions cited supra, in the present case, we have independently analyzed and scrutinized the evidence of the material witnesses and found that there is practically no evidence to show that there was any cruelty or harassment meted out against the deceased for or in connection with the demand of dowry, so as to attract Section 304-B of IPC.

33. The learned trial Judge has appreciated the evidence of PWs.2 to PW.7 in its right perspective and concluded that the evidence of these witnesses has not been established that the deceased Sarala was ever being harassed or ill-treated by the accused for bringing inadequate and insufficient dowry at the time of her marriage with accused No.1 or that the accused ever demanded dowry articles from the parents of the deceased before she committed suicide.

34. Therefore, the prosecution has failed to prove the allegations of ill-treatment, harassment and demand

- 48 -

for dowry, thus, the evidence against the accused in respect of section 304(B) of IPC, is insufficient and in-consistence with each other and this kind of evidence definitely cause fatal to the prosecution case. In this situation, the provisions of section 304(B) of IPC and section 113(B) of the Indian Evidence act, cannot be permitted to hold the accused persons, guilty of the offences of dowry death and that of cruelty in terms of section 498-A of IPC.

35. So far as the allegations against the accused persons as to commission of murder (302 of IPC) and destroying of evidence (201 of IPC) is concerned, PW.1 and PW.3 to 7 have stated that the dead body was completely burnt. They saw kerosene oil in the house and there was a cloth tied on the neck of the deceased Sarala. Admittedly, PW.1, 3 to 7 are not an eye witnesses to the incident. Therefore, from the circumstances, we must gather that whether accused No.1 is involved in the offence or not. As per the

- 49 -

evidence of PW1, as soon as he went to the house of accused No.1, the dead body of his daughter was lying in the house and it was completely burnt and thus, he lodged a complaint to the police.

36. As per the evidence of PW.3, the mother of deceased, she almost reiterated the averments made in the evidence of PW.1. Further, she has stated that the dead body was lying in the kitchen; she found that sari was tied on her neck and plastic kerosene can and poured kerosene on her person and set fire. Hence, she suspect, that it was a murder, therefore, her husband lodged the complaint. As per the evidence of PW.4- Basaningappa Annappa Huded the uncle of deceased has not visited the house of accused No.1 and he did not saw the dead body. Hence, the evidence of PW.4 is not came to the aid of prosecution.

37. PW.5 - Ismail Magadum Kittur, in his evidence, he has stated that on the date of alleged incident deceased Sarala came to his house, her husband

- 50 -

took quarrel with her under intoxication, but PW.5 did not came to the house of PW.1 and pacified the quarrel and on the same night at 11:30 p.m., he heard the sound from the house of accused No.1, he went to the house of accused No.1, he was raising hue and cry in front of his house and he saw the burning of Sarala and he also saw a cloth on her mouth and neck. Hence, he presumed that accused No.1 might have committed murder. But, in the cross-examination, he completely given a go bye, by denying the suggestion that, on the date of alleged incident at 11:30 p.m., he came to know that Sarala has committed suicide in the house of accused No.1 and he went to the house of accused, at that time, the dead body was lying in the kitchen of accused No.1. Hence, he denied the statement said to have given as per Ex.P.6(b), he admitted that, there is ill will between the accused persons and PW.5 and the evidence of PW.5 has also not came to the aid of prosecution witnesses.

- 51 -

38. On the perusal of evidence of PW.6, he has stated that he saw the dead body from the door, the dead body of Sarala was completely burnt and accused No.1 was rising hue and cry. But, in the cross- examination he has stated that, he has not given any statement to the investigation officer on 05.06.2008 and he has stated that, he came to know about the incident in the morning, hence, he has denied to have given the statement as per Ex.D.7. In the cross-examination, he admitted that, accused No.1 and deceased were in cordial terms, there was no quarrel between them and accused No.1 was maintaining his wife properly. PW.6 also admits that accused No.2 has lodged a complaint against him, PW.5 and PW.7, in respect of handing over of Rs.15,000/- to accused persons. In the cross- examination, he admitted that he made allegation against accused No.1 on a assumption that he might have committed murder of deceased. On perusal of evidence of PW.7-Goussab Mujawar, he has stated that

- 52 -

at 8:30 p.m., accused No.1 was raising hue and cry, hence, he went to the house of accused No.1 and at that time, deceased Sarala was dead and her body was completely burnt. Somebody poured water on her body by that time she lost her breath. But, in the cross- examination, he admitted that there was no quarrel between accused No.1 and deceased Sarala. He admits that, the persons who were present in the house of accused No.1 did not poured water on the dead body of deceased Sarala and he admits that he is not an eye witness to the alleged incident. He also admitted that accused No.2 lodged complaint against him, PW.5 and PW.6. In support of oral evidence of PW.1, 2, 3 and 5 to 7, the prosecution is relying upon the medical evidence i.e., PW.16.

39. On perusal of the evidence of PW.16 - Doctor Vikas Savadi he has stated that he has conducted the postmortem examination on the dead body of deceased Sarala, it was completely brunt, there was a ligature

- 53 -

mark on the neck, he saw knot on the neck, but, in the cross-examination he clearly admitted that he has not mentioned the present cloths on neck in his postmortem report, he has not mentioned the length of ligature mark and he cannot say ligature mark on the neck. He admits that there was a ligature mark but there was no over lapping. He did not open the knot and knot was loose with 2 to 3 knots and there was chances to insert fingers in the cloth tied on the neck. It appears that though cloth were tied to the neck, but, it was in loose condition and it was not tied tightly. He further stated that, entire body had blacken, cheered, peeling, scaring like parchetter and the muscle were visible. The Doctor opined that the cause of death is due to Asphyxia as a result of strangulation. PW.16 - Doctor was cross-examined at length. The Doctor had categorically denied the suggestions made by accused and further explained as to how and when the blisters would develop on the body on account of burning. From the said evidence of the doctor,

- 54 -

there remains no shadow of doubt that, the deceased Sarala's death is a homicidal death.

40. Therefore, this takes us to the next issue, as to how and who caused the death of deceased Sarala. The prosecution in order to prove the charges leveled against the accused examined PW.1 to PW.21. However, none of the witness had any knowledge about the alleged incident. PW.1 - father of the deceased Sarala had deposed that on 04.06.2008 in the early morning some elders of Belavadi village telephoned him, informing that, his daughter got burnt herself and hence, he came to Belavadi village and came to know that, his daughter Sarala was burnt to death. In the cross-examination, he had admitted that, accused No.1 never made any demand of dowry, nor any assault was made by him and soon before death of deceased Sarala and her husband i.e., accused No.1, was cordial. The father of deceased Sarala, Sri. Pundalika Basappa (PW.1), of course, had stated that, accused were not providing food to Sarala

- 55 -

and accused were not taking Sarala to the hospital whenever she falls ill and the accused persons were objecting Sarala, when she used to talk with neighbors. This fact was being informed to him by deceased Sarala. Father of deceased Sarala also admitted that, accused provided treatment of Sarala with woman's commission as Sarala was mentally retarded lady and accused also provided treatment with various psychiatric.

41. PW.3 - Smt. Chinnavva Huded, mother of deceased, PW.2 Vidya Mahadev, aunt of deceased Sarala and PW.4 Basaningappa Huded, the auncle of deceased Sarala were examined by the prosecution, However, none had any knowledge as to how, when and where the deceased was killed and burnt.

42. It is also pertinent to note that, the entire investigation carried out by investigating officers PW.19 and PW.21 were in a very cursory and shoddy manner. On receiving information from PW.1- Pundalik the investigation officer had reached to the spot and

- 56 -

registered the complaint against the accused persons, however, the investigation officer had not bothered to investigate as to how the incident had taken place. There was no investigation carried out by either of the investigating officers as to at which place the deceased was killed and burnt and how and by whom, her burnt body found in the house of accused No.1, whether deceased Sarala herself committed suicide or somebody has committed her murder. Further, there was no recovery and discovery of any incriminating articles made from the accused during the course of investigation and no attempt was made to collect any evidence much less cogent evidence to connect the accused with the alleged crime.

43. Further, the investigation officer made PW.5 to PW.7 as important witnesses. PW.5 - Ismail Kittur has stated that, accused persons were harassing a deceased on the pretext to bring cash and gold, but, in his cross- examination, he admits that, he has not given any

- 57 -

statement before the police vide Ex.D.6, Ex.D.6(a) and Ex.D.6(b).

44. PW.6 - Mallikarjuna Kumbi also deposed that accused persons were harassing a deceased to bring cash and gold from her parents. But, in the cross-examination he has admitted that, he has not given statement before the police as per Ex.D.8.

45. The prosecution examined PW.5 to PW.7 as the witnesses, who saw burning of deceased Sarala, they appears to be neighbor of accused No.1. But, their testimony is not consistent, clear and corroborative in nature. Rather, their testimony creates doubt. On further perusal of oral testimony of PW.5 to 7, they clearly admitted that, they were due for a sum of Rs.15,000/- to accused No.2 and in this regard she lodged complaint against PW.5 to PW.7 and therefore, there was ill will between them and accused Nos.1 and 2.

- 58 -

46. On further perusal of the evidence of PW.19 - Investigation Officer- Anti-Dowry Cell, it appears that, he conducted further investigation of this case, as the matter was entrusted to anti-dowry cell, he had recorded a statement of PW.5 to PW.7. In fact, earlier PW.19 also recorded statement of witness, in the present case, there are two sets of statements of PW.5 and 6, one recorded by PW.18 and another recorded by PW.19. On perusal of Ex.D.6 and 7, these two statements were given by PW.5 and 6 and as per Ex.D.6 and 7, they came to know about the incident, only next day morning. But, on perusal of statement of PW.5 and 6 recorded by PW.19, they have stated that on hearing hue and cry, they went to the house of accused No.1 and saw deceased Sarala was burning. Therefore, their testimony creates doubt as to whether PW.5 and 6 were really seen burning of deceased Sarala. Further, there was a complaint against PW.5 to 7 by accused No.2 and therefore there is every chance giving false evidence

- 59 -

against accused persons cannot be ruled out. Therefore, it is not safe to believe the oral testimony of PW.5 to PW.7, as their evidence is full of contradictions.

47. Learned Additional State Public Prosecutor has taken a contention that, deceased Sarala and accused No.1 were alone residing in the house, deceased Sarala died in the night and at that time accused No.1 was with her and therefore, accused No.1 has exclusive knowledge about the manner of incident and therefore the burden is on accused No.1 U/s. 106 of Indian Evidence Act, and he has to explain as to under what circumstances and how Sarala died in his house.

48. On the contrary, the accused has taken a contention that, the deceased Sarala was mentally ill, as her father got married a second wife. A suggestion was put to PW1 and 3, who are father and mother of deceased Sarala respectively, wherein, they admitted that, deceased Sarala was mentally ill and this fact was suppressed at the time of marriage, but this suggestion

- 60 -

is denied, however PW4, who is uncle of deceased Sarala has stated that, a treatment was given to Sarala by Dr. Nayak of Neginhal, Dr. Chate of Bailhongal and Dr. Chougula of Belagavi. PW4 also admitted that, Dr. Suresh Chate is psychiatrist and deceased Sarala was being treated by Dr. Suresh Chate and Dr. Chougula, hence, PW4 admits that, deceased Sarala was having some mental illness.

49. So far as death of deceased Sarala is concerned, PW16 the medical officer, who conducted autopsy on the dead body of Sarala has opined that, the cause of death is asphyxia as a result of strangulation. As per the prosecution case, accused No. 1 strangulated deceased Sarala with a cloth around her neck and to destroy the evidence, he poured kerosene on her person and set fire to deceased Sarala. As per the evidence of PW16, there was cloth around the neck of deceased and un-burnt skin around the neck and there was ligature mark around the neck. But PW16 has not given any particulars of the ligature mark. PW16 further stated

- 61 -

that, he has not given any explanation about the cloth which was around the neck of deceased. As per the Modi's medical jurisprudence, when a material with which an individual is alleged to have been hanged is sent for medical examination and the medical jurist should see, if the mark on the neck corresponds with its thickness, and if it is strong enough to bear the weight of the body or the sudden strain, he should also note its texture and length and after labeling it with some distinctive mark for future identification he should return it in a seat pocket to be handed over to I.O., But PW16 has not measured the ligature mark which corresponds with MO5, this is a serious lacuna and no witness have identified the cloth which was around the neck. It appears that, the doctor has mechanically conducted autopsy and returned the cloths of deceased to the I.O and thereby PW16 has not followed the medical formalities as stated Supra.

50. On perusal of Exhibit P11 the opinion of PW16, where in certain clarifications were given by Doctor, on

- 62 -

the request of I.O. Interestingly, PW16 has not measured the cloth. PW18, the investigation officer, though visited the spot and saw dead body of Sarala, but he has stated that, he has not noticed the cloth which was around the neck. He further admits that, the cloth which was seized in investigation, was not placed before the court. It shows that, a serious doubt is created in the manner of death of Sarala, whether she committed suicide or somebody has strangulated her with MO.5.

51. Therefore the evidence of PW5 to 7 are not believable and their testimony is not consistent, corroborative and satisfactory. The evidence of PW1 to 3 is contrary to complaint with regard to demand of dowry. The evidence placed by the prosecution so as to connect accused with the crime, is not sufficient, as the guilt of accused is not established beyond all reasonable doubt. On the other hand, accused No.1 brought certain aspects in evidence that, deceased Sarala was mentally ill. Therefore, the counsel for accused contended that,

- 63 -

deceased Sarala might have committed suicide by strangulation and then poured kerosene on her person and set fire.

52. Admittedly the present case is based on circumstantial evidence and there are no chain of circumstances established by the prosecution. The oral testimonial of the PW1 to 7 do not inspire the confidence to convict accused persons for the alleged offence.

53. In case of Boby vs. State of Kerala reported in (2023) SCC Online SC 50 (Criminal Appeal No.1439/2009 disposed on 12.01.2023), the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed as under:

"36. It is thus clear that the only circumstance that now remains is the circumstance of the accused last seen in the company of the deceased on the basis of the evidence of PW1. In that view of the matter, we find that, solely on the basis of last seen theory, the conviction could not have been recorded. The prosecution has utterly failed to prove that

- 64 -

the recovery of the dead body of the deceased was at the instance of Boby (accused No. 3/appellant herein). The recovery of the articles from the house of Boby (accused No. 3/appellant herein), even according to the trial court, is farce and fabricated. The recovery of the spade at the instance of Shibu @ Shibu Singh (accused No. 1) is from a place which, even according to the trial court, was also known on account of the disclosure statement made by Boby (accused No. 3/appellant herein).

37. In that view of the matter, we find that the prosecution has utterly failed to prove the chain of incriminating circumstances which leads to no other conclusion than the guilt of the accused.

38. Insofar as the reliance placed by Shri Balgopal, learned Senior Counsel on the case of Suresh Chandra Bahri (supra) is concerned, it is totally misplaced inasmuch as in paragraph 40, this Court has observed thus:

"40. …….Before we discuss the merits or demerits of the aforesaid

- 65 -

submissions we would like to state that the law relating to conviction based on circumstantial evidence is well settled and it hardly requires a detailed discussion on this aspect. Suffice to say that in a case of murder in which the evidence that is available is only circumstantial in nature then in that event the facts and

circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is required to be drawn by the prosecution must be fully established beyond all reasonable doubt and the facts and circumstances so established should not only be consistent with the guilt of the accused but they also must entirely be incompatible with the innocence of the accused and must exclude every reasonable hypothesis consistent with his innocence."

39. It will further be relevant to refer to the following observations of this Court in the said case:

- 66 -

"71. ……The provisions of Section 27 of the Evidence Act are based on the view that if a fact is actually discovered in consequence of information given, some guarantee is afforded thereby that the information was true and consequently the said information can safely be allowed to be given in evidence because if such an information is further fortified and confirmed by the discovery of articles or the instrument of crime and which leads to the belief that the information about the confession made as to the articles of crime cannot be false….."

40. A perusal of paragraph 71 of the said judgment would reveal that the Court has reiterated that the two essential requirements for the application of Section 27 of the Evidence Act are that (1) the person giving information must be an accused of any offence and (2) he must also be in police custody. The Court held that the provisions of Section 27 of the Evidence Act are based on the view that if a fact is actually discovered in consequence of

- 67 -

information given, some guarantee is afforded thereby that the information was true and consequently the said information can safely be allowed to be given in evidence.

41. In the facts of the said case, the Court found that there was, in fact, a confessional statement of the disclosure made by the appellant Gurbachan Singh which was confirmed by the recovery of the incriminating articles. As such, the Court believed the disclosure statement and the evidence led in that behalf. As already stated hereinabove, in the present case, there is no confessional statement of Boby (accused No.3/appellant herein) recorded with regard to recovery of the dead body of the deceased.

42. In the result, the appeal is allowed."

54. It is settled position of law that, circumstances how so ever cannot take place of proof and that, the guilt of the accused have to be proved by the prosecution beyond reasonable doubt. The golden principals laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Sharad Birdhi

- 68 -

Chand Sarda vs. Staste of Maharashtra reported in

(1984) 4 SCC 116 wherein at paragraph 153, it is observed as under:

"153. A close analysis of this decision, would how that the following conditions must be fulfilled before a case against an accused can be said to be fully established:

(1) the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn should be fully established. It may be noted here that this Court indicated that the circumstances concerned "must or should" and not "may be" established. There is not only a grammatical but a legal distinction between "may be proved" and "must be or should be proved" as was held by this Court in Shivaji Sahabrao bobade

V. State of Maharashtra (1973) 2 SCC 793: 1973 SCC (Cri) 1033: 1973 Crl LJ 1783) where the observations were made. Certainly, it is a primary principle that the accused must be and not merely may be guilty before a court can convict and the mental distance between 'may be' and 'must be' is long and divides vague conjectures from sure conclusions.

- 69 -

(2) The facts so established should be consistent only with the hupothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say, they should not be explainable on any other hypothesis except that the accused is guilty,

(3) The circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and tendency,

(4) They should exclude every possible hypothesis except the one to be proved, and

(5) There must be a chain of evidence so complete as not to leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent with the innocence of the accused and must show that in all human probability the act must have been done by the accused"

55. The Hon'ble Supreme Court while considering the provisions of Sections 302 and 394 r/w 34 of IPC and Section 27 of the Evidence Act in the case of Digamber Vaishnav and Another Vs. State of Chhattisgarh reported in (2019) 4 SCC 522 at pagraphs-18, 19, 40, 41 and 42 has held as under:

- 70 -

"18. In Sujit Biswas v. State Of Assam ., (2013)

12 SCC 406, this Court, while examining the distinction between 'proof beyond reasonable doubt' and 'suspicion' has held as under:

"13. Suspicion, however grave it may be, cannot take the place of proof, and there is a large difference between something that "may be" proved, and something that "will be proved". In a criminal trial, suspicion no matter how strong, cannot and must not be permitted to take place of proof. This is for the reason that the mental distance between "may be" and

"must be" is quite large, and divides vague conjectures from sure conclusions. In a criminal case, the court has a duty to ensure that mere conjectures or suspicion do not take the place of legal proof. The large distance between "may be" true and

"must be" true, must be covered by way of clear, cogent and unimpeachable evidence produced by the prosecution, before an accused is condemned as a convict, and the basic and golden rule must be applied. In such cases, while keeping in mind the distance between

"may be" true and "must be" true, the court must maintain the vital distance between mere conjectures and sure conclusions to be arrived at, on the

- 71 -

touchstone of dispassionate judicial scrutiny, based upon a complete and comprehensive appreciation of all features of the case, as well as the quality and credibility of the evidence brought on record. The court must ensure, that miscarriage of justice is avoided, and if the facts and circumstances of a case so demand, then the benefit of doubt must be given to the accused, keeping in mind that a reasonable doubt is not an imaginary, trivial or a merely probable doubt, but a fair doubt that is based upon reason and common sense".

19. It is also well-settled principle that in criminal cases, if two views are possible on evidence adduced in the case, one binding to the guilt of the accused and the other is to his innocence, the view which is favourable to the accused, should be adopted. This principle has a special relevance in cases wherein the guilt of the accused is sought to be established by circumstantial evidence [See Kali Ram v. State Of Himachal Pradesh ., (1973) 2 SCC 808].

40. The prosecution has relied upon the evidence of PW-8 to show that the accused and victims were last seen together. It is settled that the circumstance of last seen together cannot by itself form the basis of holding accused guilty

- 72 -

of offence. If there is any credible evidence that just before or immediately prior to the death of the victims, they were last seen along with the accused at or near about the place of occurrence, the needle of suspicion would certainly point to the accused being the culprits and this would be one of the strong factors or circumstances inculpating them with the alleged crime purported on the victims. However, if the last seen evidence does not inspire the confidence or is not trust worthy, there can be no conviction. To constitute the last seen together factor as an incriminating circumstance, there must be close proximity between the time of seeing and recovery of dead body.

56. The counsel for respondent submitted that, the trial Court has appreciated oral and documentary evidence on record and has passed well reasoned order and accordingly, acquitted the respondents, hence no interference is required to set aside the judgment of acquittal.

57. In view of the above proposition of law and decisions cited supra, in the present case, we have

- 73 -

independently analyzed and scrutinized the evidence of the material witnesses and found that there is practically no evidence to show that accused have committed murder of deceased Sarala in manner stated by the prosecution.

58. The learned trial Judge has appreciated the evidence of PWs.1 to 21 in its right perspective and concluded that the evidence of these witnesses has not been established that the deceased Sarala was murdered by accused No.1.

59. It is also to be noticed that the Trial Court on the basis of evidence has chosen to acquit accused persons on the ground that, the prosecution has failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt.

60. The Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in case of

N. Vijayakumar Vs. State of Tamil Nadu reported in

(2021) 3 SCC 687, the Hon'ble Apex Court held as under;

- 74 -

"Though, High Court was of the view that prosecution witness can be believed, unless it is held that the view taken by trial Court disbelieving the witness is not a possible view, High Court ought not have interfered with the acquittal recorded by trial Court, thus reversal of acquittal by High Court is not justified and thus, conviction set aside."

61. In case of Nagabhushan Vs. State of Karnataka reported in (2021) 5 SCC 222, the Hon'ble Apex Court observed that;

7.2.2. When the findings of the fact recorded by a Court can be held to be perverse has been dealt with and considered in para 20 of the aforesaid decision, which reads as under; (Babu case, SCC P. 199)

" The finding of fact recorded by a Court can be held to be perverse, if the findings have been arrived at by ignoring or excluding relevant material or by taking into consideration irrelevant/ inadmissible material.

The finding may also be set to be perverse if it is against the weight of the evidence, or if the

- 75 -

findings so outrageously defies logic as to suffer from the vice of irrationality.

7.2.3. It is further observed, after following the decision of this Court in Kuldeep Singh Vs. Commissioner of Police that if a decision is arrived at on the basis of no evidence or thoroughly unreliable evidence and no reasonable person would act upon it, the order would be perverse. But, if there is some evidence on record which is acceptable and which could be relied upon, the conclusions would not be treated as perverse and the findings would not be interfered with." (emphasis supplied)

62. On perusal of the ratio laid down supra, and the facts and circumstances of the case, it appears that the only circumstances remains against accused is last seen in the company of deceased on the basis of the evidence of PWs.5 to 7. In that view of the matter, we find that, solely on the basis of last seen theory, the conviction cannot be recorded, the prosecution must prove other aspects of the matter, such as, recovery of incriminating material at the instance of the accused, his

- 76 -

participation in crime, conduct of accused etc. In that view of the matter, the prosecution utterly failed to prove the chain of incriminating circumstances which leads no other conclusion than the guilt of the accused. In fact, the evidence of PWs.5 to 7 do not inspire the confidence, as their testimony is not corroborated with each other and there was animosity between accused person and PWs.5 to 7 in respect of refusal to pay a sum of Rs.15,000/- by them in favour of accused Nos.1 and 2.

63. Having given our careful consideration to the above stated submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties and in the backdrop of the evidence discussed hereinabove and tested in the light of the principles of law highlighted above, it must be held that the evaluation of the findings recorded by the Trial Court do not suffers from any manifest error and improper appreciation of the evidence on record. Therefore, the judgment of the Trial Court, acquitting the accused persons is sustainable in law.

- 77 -

64. For the reasons stated above, we are of the considered opinion that the evidence led by the prosecution in regard to the involvement of accused persons in the death of Sarala is not proved beyond reasonable doubt by the prosecution. Considering all these above aspects, we are of the considered opinion that the learned Sessions Judge has rightly held that the prosecution has failed to prove the guilt of accused beyond all reasonable doubt and rightly extended the benefit of acquittal to accused. We do not find any grounds to interfere with the well reasoned judgment passed by the trial Court. Accordingly, we answer point No.1 in the negative.

65. Point No.2: In the result, we pass the following order :

ORDER

i) The appeal filed by the State is dismissed.

- 78 -

ii) Judgment and order of acquittal passed by the VI Addl. District and Sessions Judge, Belagavi, in S.C.No.269/2008 dated:

14-07-2015, acquitting the accused No.1 & 2 for the offences punishable under Section 498(A), 302, 304(B) and 201 read with Section 34 of IPC and U/sec. 3 and 4 of DP Act, is confirmed.

(Sd/-)

JUDGE

(Sd/-)

JUDGE

PJ