- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M/S.GROUPE CHIMIQUE TUNISIEN SA v. M/S.SOUTHERN PETROCHEMICALS IND.COR.LTD.
Factual and Procedural Background
Southern Petrochemicals Industries Corporation Ltd. (“respondent”) issued five written purchase orders between November 2000 and July 2001 to Groupe Chimique Tunisien SA (“petitioner”) for the supply of phosphoric acid. Each purchase order specifically incorporated the Fertilizer Association of India (FAI) Terms, which in clause 15 contain an arbitration clause. The petitioner supplied the goods and invoiced an aggregate sum of USD 150,15,913.38, but the respondent failed to pay, repeatedly seeking extensions on grounds of financial difficulty.
The petitioner first sued for the price in the Amman Court of First Instance, Jordan (Case No. 223/2002). The respondent objected to jurisdiction, relying on the arbitration clause. Both the trial court (20 March 2003) and the Amman Court of Appeal (25 June 2003) dismissed the suit for want of jurisdiction.
Thereafter the petitioner: (a) issued a statutory notice dated 2 August 2004 demanding payment with interest; (b) filed Company Petition No. 276/2004 for winding-up before the High Court of Madras; and (c) by notice dated 30 August 2005 appointed Mr Justice D.P. Wadhwa as its arbitrator and called upon the respondent to nominate its arbitrator within 30 days. The respondent did not comply, prompting this petition under section 11(4) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, seeking constitution of an arbitral tribunal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a valid and binding arbitration agreement exists between the parties by virtue of the reference to the FAI Terms in the purchase orders (section 7(5) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996).
- Whether the petitioner is estopped from asserting the existence of an arbitration agreement after having denied it before the Jordanian courts.
- Whether the respondent, having failed to nominate an arbitrator within 30 days of notice, has forfeited its right to do so.
- Whether issues of limitation should be decided by the Court at the section 11 stage or left to the arbitral tribunal.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The purchase orders, signed by both parties, incorporate clause 15 of the FAI Terms; therefore an arbitration agreement exists under section 7(5) of the Act.
- Respondent’s non-payment breaches the contract; disputes must be referred to arbitration and an arbitral tribunal should be constituted.
- Limitation is not a bar due to acknowledgements in the respondent’s correspondence and balance-sheets; in any case, limitation is a matter for the arbitral tribunal.
Respondent's Arguments
- The petitioner earlier denied the arbitration clause before the Jordanian courts and is consequently estopped from now asserting it.
- The monetary claim is time-barred because the last bill of lading is dated 13 July 2001 and the last correspondence is 17 April 2002.
- No consensus ad idem exists as the petitioner never expressly agreed to arbitration; invoices do not mention arbitration.
- In the alternative, if an arbitration agreement is found, the respondent nominates Mr Justice S. Ratnavel Pandian as its arbitrator.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| U.P. Rajkiya Nirman Nigam Ltd. v. Indore (P) Ltd., (1996) 2 SCC 667 | A party is not estopped from seeking arbitration merely because it earlier took a contrary stand due to mistake or misapprehension. | Used to reject the respondent’s estoppel argument and permit the petitioner to rely on the arbitration clause despite its earlier denial in Jordanian proceedings. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
1. Section 7(5) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act states that a written contract referring to another document containing an arbitration clause constitutes an arbitration agreement if the reference makes the clause part of the contract. The Court held that the respondent’s purchase orders, expressly subject to FAI Terms, satisfy this requirement; therefore clause 15 of the FAI Terms is binding on both parties.
2. The Court rejected the respondent’s estoppel argument. The existence of an arbitration agreement is judged from the contractual documents, not from pleadings in later litigation. Citing U.P. Rajkiya Nirman Nigam, the Court observed that a mistaken earlier denial does not bar a party from invoking arbitration.
3. The contention that invoices lacked an arbitration clause was immaterial; the operative contracts were the purchase orders, not the invoices.
4. Limitation issues were deemed referable to the arbitral tribunal, consistent with established jurisprudence that arbitrators may decide limitation.
5. Although the respondent did not appoint an arbitrator within 30 days, the Court found the delay stemmed from a bona fide belief that no arbitration lay. Given the respondent’s subsequent nomination, the Court allowed its choice but completed the tribunal to avoid an even number of arbitrators, as required by section 10 of the Act.
Holding and Implications
Petition Allowed and Arbitral Tribunal Constituted.
The Supreme Court appointed a three-member tribunal: (i) Mr Justice R.C. Lahoti as Presiding Arbitrator, (ii) Mr Justice S. Ratnavel Pandian as the respondent’s nominee, and (iii) Mr Justice D.P. Wadhwa as the petitioner’s nominee. The Registry was directed to inform the arbitrators so that they may enter upon the reference expeditiously.
Practical implications are confined to these parties: their dispute will now proceed to arbitration in Delhi, and limitation and merits will be decided by the tribunal. The decision does not create new precedent but reaffirms section 7(5) principles and the non-applicability of estoppel where a party mistakenly denied arbitration.
http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 1 of 4
CASE NO.:
Arbitration Petition 4 of 2006
PETITIONER:
GROUPE CHIMIQUE TUNISIEN SA
RESPONDENT:
SOUTHERN PETROCHEMICALS INDUSTRIES CORPN. LTD.
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 24/05/2006
BENCH:
R.V. RAVEENDRAN
JUDGMENT:
JUDGMENT
ORDER
The petitioner has filed this petition under Section 11(4) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (for short 'the Act') for appointment of an Arbitral Tribunal for adjudication of its claims and settlement of the disputes between the parties.
2. The facts, in brief, as stated by petitioner are as follows:
2.1. Petitioner is a company incorporated under the laws of Tunisia. The respondent placed purchase orders dated 10.11.2000, 17.11.2000, 4.12.2000, 20.12.2000 and 13.7.2001 on the petitioner for supply of various quantities of Phosphoric Acid. Each purchase order stipulated the quantity to be supplied, the price, the payment terms and shipment particulars. All the purchase orders stated that all other terms and conditions are as per FAI terms (that is, the "Fertilizer Association of India Terms and Conditions for Sale and Purchase of Phosphoric Acid"). Clause 15 of FAI terms provided for settlement of disputes by arbitration.
2.2. The petitioner effected the supplies in pursuance of the purchase orders and raised invoice for such supplies. The respondent failed to pay the invoice amounts aggregating to US $ 1,50,15,913.38 in respect of the supplies against the said purchase orders, and went on seeking extension of time for making payment on the ground of financial difficulties.
2.3. The petitioner, therefore, filed a suit in the Amman Court of First Instance, Jordan, in Case No. 223/2002 for recovery of the amounts due. The respondent contested the jurisdiction of the said court, firstly, on the ground that the courts at Jordan did not have jurisdiction and, secondly, on the ground that there was an arbitration agreement between the parties, as per clause 15 of the FAI terms. The Amman Court of First Instance, dismissed the petitioner's case on 20.3.2003 on the ground of lack of jurisdiction. The petitioner challenged the same before the Amman Court of Appeal in case No. 1229/2003 which was also dismissed on 25.6.2003.
2.4. The petitioner issued a statutory notice dated 2.8.2004 demanding payment of the amount due with interest @ 7.5% per annum. On respondent's failure to pay, the petitioner filed a petition for winding up in Company Petition No. 276/2004 on the file of the High Court of Madras, which is pending. The petitioner also issued a notice dated 30.8.2005 through its counsel informing the respondent that the disputes and differences between the parties on account of non-payment of amounts due by the respondent shall have to be settled by arbitration in terms of clause 15 of FAI terms and appointed Mr. Justice D.P. Wadhwa, former Judge, Supreme Court of India, as its Arbitrator, and called upon the respondent to appoint its Arbitrator in terms of the arbitration clause within 30 days of the receipt of the notice. The petitioner also informed the respondent that if the
1
respondent failed to comply, appropriate proceedings will be initiated. In spite of it, the respondent did not comply, necessitating the filing of this petition for appointment of an second Arbitrator to the Arbitral Tribunal for adjudication and settlement of the claims.
3. The respondent entered appearance and has filed its counter, resisting the petition on the following grounds :
(i) The petitioner, having denied before the Jordanian Courts (Amman Court of First Instance and Amman Court of Appeals), the existence of arbitration agreement between the parties, is estopped from contending in this petition, that there is an arbitration agreement between the parties, or that the disputes should be settled by arbitration.
(ii) The claim of the petition is barred by limitation as the amounts claimed are in respect of goods dispatched as per the Bills of Lading dated 19.11.2000, 28.11.2000, 10.12.2000, 22.12.2000 and 13.7.2001, and the last of the correspondence from Respondent was on 17.4.2002.
(iii) The petitioner's contention that there is an arbitration agreement between the parties in accordance with clause 15 of the FAI terms is not tenable.
Without prejudice to the said contention, the respondent has submitted that in the event of this Court coming to the conclusion that there is a binding arbitration agreement, Mr. Justice S. Ratnavel Pandian, former Judge of the Supreme Court, he nominated as its nominee on the Arbitral Tribunal.
4. The respondent has not disputed the fact that it had placed five purchase orders (referred to above) on the petitioner for supply of Phosphoric Acid, or the fact that each of these purchase orders specifically provided that "all other terms and condition are as per FAI terms". It is also not disputed that clause 15 of FAI terms provides for settlement of disputes by arbitration (extracted below) :
"In the event of any question or dispute arising under or out of these conditions or in connection with or relating to this contract (except as to any matter(s) the decision of which is specially provided for in these conditions), the matter in dispute shall be referred to two arbitrators, one to be nominated by the seller and one to be nominated by the buyers or in the case of said arbitrators not agreeing, then to an Umpire to be appointed by the Arbitrators in writing before proceeding on the reference and the decision of the Arbitrators or in the event of their not agreeing, of the said Umpire shall be final and conclusive and the provisions of Indian Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and any modification thereon and the rules thereunder shall be deemed to apply to the proceedings. The arbitrators or the Umpires as the case may be shall be entitled with the consent of the parties to enlarge the time, from time to time for marking the award. The arbitrator/Umpire will give a reasoned award. The venue of the Arbitration shall be Delhi."
5. All the purchase orders were signed on behalf of the respondent and the same had been counter-signed by the petitioner in token of acceptance of the purchase orders. In fact, in its reply filed the Amman Court of First Instance, the respondent specifically contended that in view of the arbitration agreement between the parties (as per Clause 15 of FAI terms), the dispute will have to be settled by arbitration and therefore, the suit was not maintainable. It is also significant to note that in the counter statement filed in this case, the Respondent has neither denies having placed 5 purchase orders on the petitioner nor denied the fact that the purchase orders were all placed subject to the FAI terms and conditions, including clause 15 of FAI terms which provides for arbitration. On the other hand, the contention of the respondent is that the petitioner having denied the arbitration agreement before the Jordanian Court, cannot now
2
contend that there is an arbitration agreement. Respondent also contends that in the absence of any letter from the petition specifically referring to or agreeing to arbitration and in view of petitioner's denial of the existence of arbitration agreement in its pleadings before the Jordanian Court, there is no consensus ad idem between the parties to refer the disputes to arbitration and therefore there cannot be any reference to arbitration.
6. Whether there is an arbitration agreement or not, has to be decided with reference to the contract documents and not with reference to any contention raised before a court of law after the dispute has arisen. Reference to pleadings before the Jordanian Courts would have been relevant if the plea was that the arbitration agreement between the parties is contained in the exchange of statement of claim and defence in which the existence of the agreement is alleged by one party and not denied by the other (as contemplated under section 7(4)(c) of the Act). Be that as it may. Section 2(b) of the Act defines 'arbitration agreement' as meaning an agreement referred to in Section 7 (extracted below) :
"7. Arbitration agreement. - (1) In this Part, "arbitration agreement"
means an agreement by the parties to submit to arbitration all or certain disputes which have arisen or which may arise between them in respect of a defined legal relationship, whether contractual or not.
(2) An arbitration agreement may be in the form of an arbitration clause in a contract or in the form of a separate agreement.
(3) An arbitration agreement shall be in writing.
(4) An arbitration agreement is in writing if it is contained in
(a) a document signed by the parties;
(b) an exchange of letters, telex, telegrams or other means of telecommunication which provide a record of the agreement; or
(c) an exchange of statements of claim and defence in which the existence of the agreement is alleged by one party and nor denied by the other.
(5) The reference in a contract to a document containing an arbitration clause constitutes an arbitration agreement if the contract is in writing and the reference is such as to make that arbitration clause part of the contract."
7. The purchase orders placed by the respondent on the petitioner are the contracts between the parties and they are subject to FAI terms which contain the arbitration clause Sub-section (5) of section 7 specifically provides that where there is reference in a contract (in this case, the purchase order) to a document containing an arbitration clause (in this case, the FAI terms), such reference constitutes an arbitration agreement, if the contract is in writing and the reference is such as to make that arbitration clause a part of the contract. The case squarely falls under section 7(5) of the Act and there is an arbitration agreement between the parties as per clause 15 of the FAI terms.
8. The respondent next contended that in the invoices for the supplies, there is no reference to FAI terms or arbitration agreement and, therefore, the disputes are not arbitrable. As noticed above, the purchase orders are the contracts. Invoice is a document which is prepared with reference to the supplies made under the contract. When the contract (purchase order) incorporates an arbitration agreement by reference, the invoice need not contain a provision for arbitration.
9. It is true that the petitioner had contended before the Jordanian Court
3
that there was no arbitration agreement between the parties. But the said contention was not accepted and the suit filed by the petitioner has been dismissed on the ground of want of jurisdiction. Thereafter, on reconsidering the matter and taking legal advice, with reference to the contentions of the respondent, the petitioner has now proceeded on the basis that an arbitration agreement exists between the parties. If, on account of mistake or wrong understanding of law, a party takes a particular stand (that is, there is no arbitration agreement), he is not barred from changing his stand subsequently or estopped from seeking arbitration. (See U.P. Rajkiya Nirman Nigam Ltd. v. Indore (P) Ltd., [1996]
2 SCC 667, where the contention based on estoppel was negatived while considering a reserve situation).
10. In regard to limitation, the petitioner submitted that having regard to the acknowledgements contained in the series of letters written by Respondent requesting for time and the acknowledgements contained in the balance-sheets where these amounts are shown as 'due and outstanding', the petitioner's claim is not barred by limitation. It is, however, unnecessary to examine this aspect as the learned counsel for the respondent fairly conceded that this is a question which can be examined by the Arbitral Tribunal, in the event of a reference to arbitration being made. It is now well-settled that the limitation is an issue that can be considered and decided by the Arbitration Tribunal.
11. The next question is whether the respondent has lost its right to appoint its nominee to the Arbitral Tribunal in view of its failure to comply with the demand of the petitioner to appoint the arbitrator within 30 days from the date of receipt of notice dated 30.8.2005. It is apparent that the respondent did not appoint an Arbitrator as it was under a bona fide impression that there cannot be an arbitration. Further without prejudice to its contentions, it has nominated its Arbitrator.
12. Section 10 of the Act provides that the number of Arbitrators shall not be 'even'. The arbitration clause provides that the dispute shall be referred to two Arbitrators and in the event of Arbitrators not agreeing then an Umpire to be appointed by the Arbitrators in writing before proceeding to the reference. Having regard to section 10 of the Act, the Arbitral Tribunal shall consist of three Arbitrators (one to be appointed by each of the two parties and the Presiding Arbitrator).
13. For the aforesaid reasons, this petition is allowed and the following Arbitral Tribunal is constituted to adjudicate upon the claim made by the petitioner against the Respondent and to settle the disputes between the parties :
(i) Mr. Justice R.C. Lahoti, Former Chief Justice of India, Noida (U.P.) - Presiding Arbitrator;
(ii) Mr. Justice S. Ratnaval Pandian, Former Judge of Supreme Court, Chennai - nominee of respondent;
(iii) Mr. Justice D.P. Wadhwa, Former Judge of Supreme Court, New Delhi - nominee of petitioner.
14. Registry is directed to communicate the constitution of the Arbitral Tribunal to the three Arbitrators to enable them to enter upon the reference and decide the matter expeditiously.
4
Alert