Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

PRAGNA EDUCATION SOCIETY (R) v. STATE OF KARNATAKA

Karnataka High Court
Sep 22, 2023

- 1 -

NC: 2023:KHC:34472

WP No. 6823 of 2021

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

DATED THIS THE 22ND DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2023

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE ASHOK S.KINAGI WRIT PETITION NO. 6823 OF 2021 (EDN-RES) Between:

1. Pragna Education Society ® Registered Office at Main Road, Irakasandra Colony, Koratagere Taluk, Madhugiri Educational District, Tumkur - 572 132.

Represented by its Secretary Prabhakar N.,

2. Ravindra Bharthi Vidya Samsthe ® Registered Office at Koratagere Koratagere Taluk,

Madhugiri Educational District, Tumkur - 572 132.

Represented by its Secretary Shobha Krishnamurthy

3. Lalbahdhur Shastri Education Society ® Registered Office at Holavanahalli Koratagere Taluk,

Tumakuru District-572 129.

Represented by its Secretary

Seebi Rangamma

4. Citizen Education Society ® Registered Office at Koratagere Koratagere Taluk,

Madhugiri Educational District, Tumakuru-572 132.

Represented by its Secretary Ismail Ahamed Shariff U.I.

- 2 -

5. Kannika Vidya Peeta ® Registered office at Doddapete Koratagere, Madhugiri Educational District, Tumkur-572 132.

Represented by its Secretary

K.S.V.Raghu,

6. Teresa Vidya Samsthe ® Registered office at Near Katteganapathi Temple Koratagere Madhugiri Educational District, Tumkur-572 132

Represented by its Secretary Asma B.,

7. Sree Muttanjaneya Grameena Shikshanabhivruddi Trust (R) Registered Office at Kolala, Koratagere Taluk,

Tumakuru Distritct-572 140 Represented by its Secretary Nanjundaiah K.M.,

8. National Mahila Mandali ® Registered office at Akkirampura, Koratagere Taluk,

Madhugiri Educational District, Tumkur - 572 132.

Represented by its Secretary Geetha V.N.,

9. Sri Jnanakshi Education and Charitable Trust (R) Registered Office at 35, Bandekodigehalli (V and P) Jala Hobli Bangalore North - 560 013 Represented by its President

Dr. Narendra Kummara K.R.,

10. Spoorthi Vidyanikethan Public School, Registered Office at 10, Rajagopal Reddy Extension CIL Layout,

Cholanayakana Halli, Hebbala, RT Nagar, Bengaluru - 560 032.

- 3 -

Represented by its Authorized Representative, R.Nandakumar,

11. KNA Educational Trust (R), Registered Office at Old CR Patna Road, Holenarasipura,

Hassan District - 573 211. Represented by its President K.A.Venkatesh

12. Sridevi Education Society (R) Registered Office at Kuvempu Nagara Channarayapatna, Hassan District - 573 116. Represented by its President

Dr C.K.Vijayakumar,

13. Vidya Vikas Vidya Samsthe (R) Registered Office at Basaveshwara Talkies Road, Chitradurga, Chitradurga District - 577 501. Represented by its Secretary B.Vijayakumar,

14. Puttu Education Trust SS (R) Registered Office at Northern Extension, Hassan - 573 201

Represented by its Secretary Mamatha P.,

15. Amblee Education Trust (R) Registered Office at Maraloor, Tumakuru, Tumakuru District - 572 105 Represented by its Secretary Dr. Prasanna Shankar Babu

16. Sri Sharadha Vidya Samsthe (R) Registered Office at Javagal, Arasikere Taluk, Hassan District - 573 125 Represented by its Secretary

Dr. Vinayaka S.,

- 4 -

17. Bethel Education and Charitable Society (R) Registered Office at Gubbi Cross, Hethagowdanahally Post,

Arkalagudu Taluk, Hassan District - 573 102 Represented by its Secretary

Santhosh Kumar

18. Nivedita Vidya Samsthe (R) Registered Office at Nivedita Vidya Shale, Arkalagudu, Hassan District-573 102. Represented by its Secretary

A.R.Subbarao

19. Jeevitha Kumar Vidya Samsthe (R) Registered Office at Honnudike Tumakuru Taluk

Tumakuru District-573 102. Represented by its Secretary Nalina H.D.,

20. K.B.K Memorial Education Society (R) Registered Office at Ullenahalli-Konanur Arkalgud Taluk, Hassan District-573 102 Represented by its President Imran Khaleel Mohammedi

21. Shree Jnana Jyothi Vidya Samsthe (R) Registered Office at Belavadi at Post, Arkalgudu Taluk, Hassan District-573 102. Represented by its Secretary

Dharma B.R.,

22. Dakshina Kashi Vidya Samsthe (R) Registered Office at Ramanathapura, Arkalgudu Taluk, Hassan District-573 102. Represented by its Secretary

B.R.Rajegowda,

…Petitioners

(By Sri. S Sudharsan, Advocate)

- 5 -

And:

1. State of Karnataka Represented by Principal Secretary Department of Education

(Primary and Secondary School Education) Vidhana Soudha, Bengaluru - 560 001

2. Commissioner of Public Instruction Department of Education

(Primary and Secondary School Education) Government of Karnataka

Nrupathunga Road, Bengaluru - 560 001

3. Director of Public Instruction Department of Education Government of Karnataka Bengaluru North District K.G.Road, Bengaluru - 560 002

4. Deputy Director of Public Instruction Department of Education

Government of Karnataka

Bengaluru North District

K.G.Road, Bengaluru - 560 002

5. Block Education Officer Kortegare Taluk

Tumkur District

Karnataka-572 132

6. Block Education Officer Holenarasipura

Hassan, Karnataka-573 211 …Respondents

(By Smt. Mamatha Shetty AGA for R1 to R6)

- 6 -

This Writ Petition is filed under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, praying to declare that the circular issued by the Government of Karnataka bearing the Notification No.EP 46 SHH 2020 dated 10.11.2020 Annexure-A at Page Nos.24-29 is Ultra-Vires the Karnataka Education Act 1983 and etc.

This Writ Petition, coming on for preliminary hearing, this day, the court made the following:

ORDER

1. The petitioners filed the said petition seeking a writ of certiorari, declaring the circular dated 10.11.2020 as ultra vires and quash the endorsements dated 25.01.2021 vide Annexure 'B', dated 21.01.2021 vide Annexure 'C', dated 17.12.2020 vide Annexure 'D' and also sought for a mandamus directing the respondents to consider the prayer at 'e' and 'g'.

2. The brief facts leading rise to filing of this petition are as under:

It is the case of petitioners that they are the societies or trusts duly registered under The Societies Registration Act, 1960 for the purpose of establishing and

- 7 -

administrating educational institutions in Karnataka. On 10.11.2020, the State Government issued the circular and pursuant to the said circular, the private schools were forced to carry out certain compliances in respect of the building and more particularly to install the over head tank with a minimum capacity of 10000 liters. The impugned circular is purported to be issued for the implementation of the Karnataka Education Act, 1983. Primarily there is no power conferred on the Government in the principal Statute for causing the issuance of such circular. Further, the legal challenge stems from the ground that instead of implementing the aforesaid principal Statute, the impugned circular plainly and clearly contravenes the said statute and is invalid and illegal for that reason. The respondents pursuant to the circular dated 10.11.2020 have inserted amendments to the existing law, more particularly Karnataka Educational Institutions (Classification, Regulations and Prescription of Curricula Etc.,) Rules, 1995. It is contended that the action of the respondents in their colourable exercise of power are in no

- 8 -

way at liberty to make such an insertions through a mere circular. In April, 1994, the Government of Karnataka sought to make Kannada a compulsory medium of instruction during primary education in schools across the State. However the same was challenged and the State Government lost in its endeavor. The Government has resorted to numerous ways and means to trouble the private unaided schools in the State and the impugned circular was issued in the year 2019, after the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Avinash Mehrotra Vs. Union of India and others - (2009) 6 SCC 398. It is further contended that the circular dated 10.11.2020 has prospective effect, wherein the State Government is giving retrospective effect, which is impermissible. Further it is contended that the petitioners have fulfilled the norms as required under the law. Hence the learned counsel for the petitioner prays to allow the petition.

3. The respondents-State filed statement of objections contending that Section 145 of the Karnataka

- 9 -

Education Act, 1983 empowers the State to make Rules to carry out the purposes of this Act by issuing notification and after previous publication of the same. It is contended that in the exercise of powers under section 145(1) of the Act of 1983, Government of Karnataka made Karnataka Educational Institutions (Classifications, Regulation and Prescription of Curricula etc.,) Rules, 1995 and these Rules are amended from time to time. It is contended that Rule 4 deals with general regulations relating to the buildings of the educational institutions. Rule 5 deals with the general regulations relating to the minimum accommodation per student furniture and etc. Rule 5-A deals with measure for safety and security of students. It is contended that the circular issued by the respondents is in accordance with law and pray to dismiss the petition.

4. Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners and also the learned Government Advocate.

- 10 -

5. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that this court in the case of Associated Managements of Primary and Secondary Schools in Karnataka (KAMS) Vs. State of Karnataka and others in W.P.No.5380/2022 disposed of on 14.11.2022, is aptly applicable to the present case on hand. He submitted that this writ petition be disposed of in terms of the order passed in the aforesaid writ petition. He further submits that the Government has issued the circular 10.11.2020, it was brought into force with retrospective effect. He submitted that the respondents ought to have given effect to the said circular with effect from 10.11.2020. Further in support of his argument he placed reliance on the judgment of the Division Bench of this court in the case of

Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences and another Vs. Samarth S.S. and others in W.P.No.1208/2022 and connected matters disposed of on 11.01.2023. Hence on these grounds he prays for allowing the writ petition.

- 11 -

6. Per Contra, learned counsel for the respondents- State does not dispute the order passed in the aforesaid writ petitions and submits that this writ petition may be disposed of in terms of the same.

7. Heard and perused the records and considered the arguments of the learned counsel for the parties.

8. As the co-ordinate bench of this Court in W.P.No.5380/2022 (supra) has considered the dictum of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Avinash Mehrotra (supra) and held that the order dated 15.07.2021 issued by the second respondent therein makes a distinction with regard to newly established schools and old schools; and remaining circulars have been issued by the Government, whereby direction is issued to the schools to obtain necessary NOC from competent authorities seeking renewal of the recognition/approval annually and further having taken note of the observation made by the Hon'ble

- 12 -

Apex Court in the case of Avinash Mehrotra (supra), it was further held that retrospective application of notification dated 10.11.2020, to the existing schools which are established prior to the academic year in the year 2017-18 is not correct and quashed the notification dated 10.11.2020. Further though the statement of objections filed by the State are silent in regard to the existing schools, circular dated 15.07.2021 and endorsement dated 02.11.2021 was set aside. The order is squarely applicable to the present case on hand.

9. Hence the learned counsel for the petitioners submit that petitioner no.1 to 11 and 13 to 22 are established prior to 2017-18. He submitted that the said circular is not applicable to the existing schools. Further he submitted that in so far the petitioner No.12 is concerned, the said school was established in the year 2018. The circular dated 10.11.2020 came into existence with effect from 10.11.2020. As on the date of circular

- 13 -

come into force, the petitioners/schools were already existing. Hence the circular got prospective effect. In view of the same, the writ petition is allowed and the endorsements dated 25.01.2021 vide Annexure 'B', dated 21.01.2021 vide Annexure 'C', dated 17.12.2020 vide Annexure 'D' are quashed.

Sd/-

JUDGE

sd, List No.: 1 Sl No.: 10