- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
SMT. DULU DEKA v. THE STATE OF ASSAM
Factual and Procedural Background
An advertisement dated 28 December 1996 was issued by the Director of Elementary Education, Assam, to fill 7,500 posts of Assistant Teachers in M.E./M.V. schools. The appellant claims she applied and was interviewed in July 1997. After a Government-imposed hiring ban was lifted, the Sub-Divisional Selection Board (Udalguri Sub-Division) purportedly recommended her on 12 March 2001 for a vacancy in the Udalguri Legislative Assembly Constituency.
On the same date, 12 March 2001, the District Elementary Education Officer (DEEO), Darrang, Mangaldoi, issued an appointment order placing the appellant as an Assistant Teacher in Bengabari M.E. School on a fixed salary of Rs. 2,000 per month under the Operation Black Board Scheme, the tenure stated to end on 31 March 2002. She asserts that she has continued working without salary since that appointment.
In 2001, the Director of Elementary Education conducted an enquiry and, by order dated 18 October 2001, declared 509 such appointments—including the appellant’s—“illegal and void ab initio” because they were made against non-existent posts. The appellant never challenged that cancellation order.
She nonetheless filed WP (C) No. 595 of 2008 before the Gauhati High Court seeking salary from 12 March 2001 onward. A Single Judge dismissed the petition on 8 September 2008, and the Division Bench upheld that dismissal in WA No. 42 of 2009 on 8 January 2010. The present civil appeal challenges those High Court orders.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appellant’s appointment as Assistant Teacher was valid in law, given the Director of Elementary Education’s order declaring it void ab initio.
- Consequently, whether the appellant is entitled to salary for services allegedly rendered from 12 March 2001 onward.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant’s Arguments
- The High Court erred in denying salary; compelling the appellant to work without remuneration amounts to “Begar,” which is unconstitutional.
Respondents’ Arguments
- The appellant’s appointment was illegal and void ab initio as determined by the Director of Elementary Education on 18 October 2001; that order remains unchallenged.
- All 509 appointments by the DEEO, Darrang, Mangaldoi, were against non-existent posts.
- The appellant was recommended for a vacancy in the Udalguri Constituency but was appointed to a school outside that constituency, contravening the applicable rules.
- Because the appointment is invalid, no claim for salary can lie.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court affirmed the High Court’s findings, emphasizing:
- The appellant’s appointment letter does not refer to any advertisement or lawful selection process specific to Bengabari M.E. School.
- The Director of Elementary Education’s order dated 18 October 2001 declaring the appointment illegal and void ab initio was never challenged; therefore, it stands.
- Given the cancellation, the appellant had no legal right to continue in service beyond 31 March 2002, nor any entitlement to salary thereafter.
- The claim that the appellant has worked for nearly two decades without pay is implausible, and the writ petition itself was filed only in 2008—seven years after the alleged commencement of service.
- Because the foundational appointment was void, the doctrine against forced labour (“Begar”) does not arise; there was no subsisting employer-employee relationship in law.
Holding and Implications
Appeal Dismissed. The Supreme Court upheld the concurrent findings of the Single Judge and Division Bench of the Gauhati High Court, denying the salary claim. There is no order as to costs.
Implications: The decision leaves the parties as they stood; the appellant receives no salary, and no broader legal precedent is articulated beyond affirming that remuneration cannot be ordered when the underlying appointment has been declared void.
Rajesh Bindal, J.:— The writ petition WP (C) No. 595 of 2008 was filed by the appellant in the Gauhati High Court in the year 2008 praying for release of her salary from 12.03.2001 onwards. It was claimed that she was rendering service as an Assistant Teacher in Bengabari M.E. School and had not been paid any salary. The writ petition was dismissed Dated 08.09.2008 by the Single Judge. The order was upheld in an intra-court appeal W.A. No. 42 of 2009 Dated 08.01.2010. The said orders are impugned in the present appeal.
2. The facts of the case as enumerated in the order passed by the High Court are that, on 28.12.1996 an advertisement was issued by the Director of Elementary Education, Assam, for filling up 7,500 posts of Assistant Teachers in M.E./M.V. Schools. The appellant claimed that she applied for the post and appeared for interview in July 1997. The selection list was not published by the Director of Elementary Education, Assam, because the Government of Assam imposed a ban on the appointments. After the ban was lifted, the Selection Committee for Udalguri Sub-Division (General Area) in its meeting held on 12.03.2001, recommended the appellant's name with other candidates for appointment against vacancies in three Legislative Assembly Constituencies, namely, Dalgaon, Majbat and Udalguri. The appellant's name appeared against the vacancies in the Udalguri Legislative Assembly Constituency. The appellant was appointed as Assistant Teacher in Bengabari M.E./M.V./M.E.M. School vide order dated 12.03.2001 issued by the District Elementary Education Officer, Mangaldoi, Darrang, on a fixed salary of Rs. 2,000/- (Rupees Two Thousand) per month under the Central Government's sponsored Scheme, namely, Operation Black Board Scheme. According to the appointment order, the term of the service was upto 31.03.2002. It is claimed by the appellant that she has been working in the said school since then, however, she has not been paid any salary. A direction was sought to the State to pay the salary to the appellant. However, the High Court did not find any merit in the submissions made.
3. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the order passed by the High Court deserves to be set aside as the appellant cannot be made to work without payment of salary, which amounts to Begar, not permissible in law.
4. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondents submitted that the appointment of the appellant itself was illegal. In 2001, the Director of Elementary Education, Assam conducted an enquiry into the matter and vide his order dated 18.10.2001, declared all the appointment (Total 509 teachers) including the appellant's appointment, made by the then District Elementary Education Officer, Darrang, Mangaldoi as illegal and void ab initio, as all such appointments were made against non-existent posts. The aforesaid order was never challenged by the appellant. It was further submitted by the respondents, that the selection of the appellant, as claimed, was made against the vacancies in the Udalguri Legislative Assembly Constituency, however, she was appointed as an Assistant Teacher in Bengabari M.E./M.V./M.E.M. School by the District Elementary Education Officer, Darrang, Mangaldoi, which was beyond the Udalguri Legislative Assembly Constituency. Therefore, the appointment of the appellant beyond the Udalguri Legislative Assembly Constituency was invalid and in violation of the Rules. There is no error in the orders passed by the High Court and the appeal deserves to be dismissed.
5. After hearing learned counsel for the parties, we do not find any error in the order passed by the learned Single Judge, as confirmed by the Division Bench of the High Court.
6. The appellant claimed that she was appointed as an Assistant Teacher in Bengabari M.E. School against the vacancies in Udalguri Legislative Assembly Constituency by the Sub-Divisional Selection Board in the meeting held on 12.03.2001, pursuant to an advertisement dated 28.12.1996 issued by the competent authority to fill up the regular posts of Assistant Teachers. However, no appointment letter was issued to the appellant in pursuance thereof. Rather, the appointment letter dated 12.03.2001 issued to the appellant by the District Elementary Education Officer, Darrang, Mangaldoi, shows that she was appointed as an Assistant Teacher in Bengabari M.E. School, which falls in Mangaldoi, a sub-division of Darrang District. As is noticed in the impugned order passed by the Division Bench of the High Court, the same does not fall within the Udalguri Legislative Assembly Constituency. It is nowhere stated in the appellant's appointment letter that the said appointment was in pursuance of any advertisement issued or the candidates had undergone any selection process for the same. In fact, all the appointments made by the District Elementary Education Officer, Darrang, Mangaldoi, from 08.03.2001 to 31.03.2002 were declared to be illegal and void ab initio by the Director of Elementary Education vide order dated 18.10.2001. The appointment of the appellant was also included therein. It was found that the District Elementary Education Officer had appointed 509 teachers illegally against non-existent posts. The appellant did not challenge the order dated 18.10.2001. The Division Bench, further noticed that the appellant having been selected against the vacancy in Udalguri Legislative Assembly Constituency could not have been appointed in a school beyond the jurisdiction of the said Constituency. It was further noticed by the High Court that the appellant had not placed on record any material to show that there was any advertisement issued or the selection process undertaken for appointment in the school, where she was offered appointment and claims to be working.
7. Once the appointment of the appellant had been declared illegal and void ab initio, and was cancelled by the Director of Elementary Education, Assam vide order dated 18.10.2001, the appellant could not legally continue in service thereafter, unless that cancellation order was set aside. It has been noticed by the High Court that the order dated 18.10.2001 was never challenged by the appellant. Thus, the appellant had no legal right to continue in service, especially when there is no order or letter placed on record by the appellant that she was allowed to continue beyond 31.03.2002. No claim for payment of salary could be made for any period. Even otherwise, it is difficult to believe that a person has been working for two decades without any salary. Even the writ petition was filed by her in the High Court in the year 2008, claiming salary from 12.03.2001 onwards i.e., seven years later.
8. For the reasons mentioned above, we do not find any reason to differ with concurrent findings of facts recorded by the High Court. While concurring with the reasons recorded by the High Court, the appeal is dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
Alert