- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
BANDEPPA S/O LATE VEERBHADRAPPA ANDURE ALIAS ANADURE v. GUNDAMMA W/O HANMANTHAPPA TAGARE AND ANR
- 1 -
NC: 2023:KHC-K:6511 RSA No. 200134 of 2022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
KALABURAGI BENCH
DATED THIS THE 17THDAY OF AUGUST, 2023
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE K S HEMALEKHA REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO.200134 OF 2022 (DEC/INJ)
BETWEEN:
BANDEPPA
S/O LATE VEERBHADRAPPA ANADURE
AGE: 69 YEARS
OCC: AGRICULTURE
R/O : NAUBAD DIST: BIDAR-585401 …APPELLANT
(BY SRI. SHARANABASAPPA K. BABSHETTY, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. GUNDAMMA
W/O HANMANTHAPPA TAGARE
AGE : 93 YEARS
OCC: HOUSEHOLD
R/O : H.NO.19-6-128
SHIVANAGAR NORTH
BIDAR-585401
2. BHAGIRATHI BAI ALIAS BHAGIRATHI
W/O BANDEPPA
AGE: 65 YEARS
OCC: AGRICULTURE
R/O: NAUBAD
DIST: BIDAR- 585401 …RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. KADLOOR SATYANARAYANACHARYA FOR R-1; NOTICE TO R-2 SERVED)
THIS RSA IS FILED U/S 100 OF CPC, PRAYING TO ALLOW
THIS APPEAL AND SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE
- 2 -
DATED:04.01.2022, PASSED BY THE ADDL. DISTRICT AND
SESSIONS JUDGE AT BIDAR, IN R.A.NO.27/2013 AND ALSO THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED:03.08.2011 PASSED BY THE
ADDL. SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AT BIDAR, IN O.S.NO.77/2003, IN
THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
THIS APPEAL COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY, THE
COURT DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
JUDGMENT
The present appeal by the unsuccessful plaintiff No.1 assailing the concurrent findings of the court below in R.A.No.27/2013 dated 04.01.2022 on the file of the Addl. District and Sessions Judge at Bidar confirming the judgment and decree dated 30.08.2021 in O.S.No.77/2003 on the file of the Addl. Senior Civil Judge, Bidar.
2. The parties are referred to as per their rank before the trial court.
3. Brief facts of the case are that:
Plaintiff No.1 - appellant along with one Bhagirathi (plaintiff No.2) filed suit for declaration and perpetual injunction against the defendant contending that the plaintiffs are the absolute owner in possession of the suit
- 3 -
schedule properties and that the plaintiffs' father performed the marriage of defendant in the year 1954 and the defendant has lost her rights in the properties of her father and the plaintiff No.1 being the only son succeeded to the properties and stated that the defendant got mutated Sy.No.122 measuring 03 acres 34 guntas in her name when plaintiff No.1 demanded.
4. The said suit was resisted by the defendant by filing written statement and contended that the properties belong to the father of the plaintiff No.1 and defendant, that Sy.No.122 stands in the name of defendant as per the wish of her parents while other Sy.Nos.83 and 90 are mutated in the name of the plaintiff. By way of counter, defendant claims half share in all the suit properties.
5. The trial court on the basis of the pleadings, framed the following issues.
"1. Whether the plaintiff proves that, he is the owner and possessor of the suit property?"
2. Whether, the plaintiff proves alleged interference of the defendant over the suit properties?
- 4 -
3. Whether the defendant proves that she is the owner and possessor of land Sy.No.90 measuring 2 acres 18 guntas of Naubad as claimed in the counter claim?
4. Whether the defendant is entitled for relief of perpetual injunction in respect of the land Sy.No.90 measuring 2 acres 18 guntas of Naubad? "
6. In order to substantiate their claim, plaintiff No.1 examined himself as P.W.1 and one witness as P.W.2 and got marked Exs.P.1 to P.4. On the other hand, defendant No.1 got examined herself as D.W.1 and got marked Exs.D.1 to 8.
7. The trial court on the basis of pleadings, oral and documentary evidence held that the plaintiffs have failed to prove that they are the absolute owner of the suit schedule properties and that the defendant has proved that she is the owner and in possession of the suit schedule properties to the extent of half share, moulded the reliefs under Order VII rule 7 of CPC and the suit of the plaintiffs and counter claim was partly decreed holding
- 5 -
plaintiffs and defendant are entitled for half share in SyNo.122 and Sy.No.90 and relief of perpetual injunction was rejected.
8. Aggrieved by the judgment and decree in O.S.No.77/2003, plaintiff No.1 preferred regular appeal before the first appellate court. No appeal was preferred by the plaintiffs regarding allowing of the counter claim of the defendant. The first appellate court on re-appreciation of the entire material on record and being the last fact finding court concurred with the judgment and decree of the trial court. Aggrieved by which, the present appeal is preferred by plaintiff No.1.
9. Heard Sri Sharanabasappa K. Babshetty, learned counsel appearing for plaintiff No.1 and Sri Kadloor Satyanarayanacharya, learned counsel appearing for the defendant and carefully considered the rival contentions urged by the learned counsel for the parties and perused the material placed on record.
- 6 -
10. This court has carefully considered the contentions urged by the learned counsel for the parties with regard to substantial question of law to be dealt with under Section 100 CPC. The relationship between the plaintiffs and the defendant is not in dispute. It is also not in dispute that the suit schedule properties are the ancestral joint family properties of the plaintiffs and defendant. It is the only contention of the plaintiffs that the suit schedule property has fallen to their share exclusively in light of the marriage of the defendant in the year 1954 and the defendant is not entitled for share in the suit schedule properties, by way of counter claim, the defendant sought half share in the suit schedule properties. The trial court in a suit for declaration sought by the plaintiff as absolute owner of the properties, moulded the relief under Order VII Rule 7 of CPC and granted half share in the suit schedule properties and also allowed the counter claim of the defendant seeking half share. Ultimately, the trial court decreed the suit holding that the plaintiffs are entitled for half share in Sy.Nos.122
- 7 -
and 90, in respect of Sy.No.83 was rejected holding that the defendant did not value the compensation amount since property was acquired. No appeal is preferred against non-granting of share nor the plaintiffs have assailed the judgment and decree against the allowing of the counter claim of the defendant.
11. The grievance of the plaintiffs is that the trial court would not have moulded the relief in a suit for declaration filed by the plaintiffs. It is relevant to note that trial court, held that plaintiff is not entitled for declaration and by moulding the relief, the trial court and exercised under Order VII Rule 11 CPC. One thing to be noted is that trial court partly allowed the counter claim by the defendant as well, granting half share to defendant, the said order is not assailed by plaintiff, what was assailed before appellate court was judgment and decree moulding of relief in the suit for declaration. The first appellate court concurred with the judgment and decree of the trial court and held that mere record of rights would
- 8 -
not create any right in favour of the plaintiffs exclusively and taking into consideration the proposition of law has concurred with the judgment and decree of the trial court holding that the plaintiffs and defendant are entitled for half share in the suit schedule properties in view of Section 6 of the Amended Hindu Succession Act, 2005.
12. Learned counsel for the plaintiff No.1 would contend that two applications were filed by the plaintiff No.1 seeking for remand of the matter on the ground of filing of additional document and that has not been considered by the first appellate court. The perusal of the judgment and decree of the first appellate court would make it evident that the said applications were rejected on the ground that the said documents are not necessary to resolve the dispute between the parties and accordingly has dismissed the said applications and the appellant i.e., plaintiff No.1 has made no case for remanding the matter.
13. Both the courts have taken into consideration the evidence and material placed before it and
- 9 -
concurrently held that the defendant is entitled for half share in the suit schedule properties and the judgment and decree on counter claim in O.S.No.77/2003 has remained unchallenged. In the said circumstances, the manner in which the courts below have considered the materials and evidence on record, this court is of the considered view that no substantial question of law arises for consideration to be dealt with under Section 100 C.P.C. Accordingly, this court pass the following:
ORDER
i) The regular second appeal is dismissed.
ii) The judgments and decrees passed by the first appellate court as well as the trial court stand confirmed.
iii) No order as to costs. Sd/-
JUDGE
BL
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 49
Alert