- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
SAMINENI VENU BABU v. MARGADARSI CHIT FUND PVT LTD
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners challenged a docket order dated 11.09.2019 in E.A.No.310 of 2019 in E.P.No.11 of 2015 in O.S. No.538 of 2011 (II Additional Senior Civil Judge, Visakhapatnam). The decree‑holder, M/s Margadarsi Chit Fund Pvt. Ltd., filed E.P. No.211 of 2015 under Order XXI Rule 43 CPC for attachment of movables belonging to the 3rd judgment‑debtor B. Murali Krishna. Warrants were returned because the 3rd judgment‑debtor's house was under lock and key. The decree‑holder filed E.A.No.311 of 2019 in E.P.No.211 seeking permission to empower the Field Assistant to break open locks; the court below passed the impugned docket order granting break‑open permission. The husband of the 3rd judgment‑debtor had earlier filed a claim petition in E.A. No.219 of 2016 under Order XXI Rule 58 CPC which was rejected on 23.04.2019 and was pursued before this Court in CRP (SR) No.22473 of 2019. The High Court issued notice (13.09.2019), permitted personal service, later extended interim protection and directed clubbing of CRP (SR) No.22473/2019 with CRP Nos.2870 and 2871 (order dated 26.08.2022).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Court below erred in issuing permission to break open locks to enable attachment of movable properties of the 3rd judgment‑debtor (i.e., whether coercive steps to take possession were permissible in the circumstances).
- Whether the authorities relied upon by the petitioner (notably the Supreme Court decision in Brahmdeo Chaudhary) apply to preclude the break‑open permission and/or require proceedings under Order XXI Rules 97/99 instead.
- Whether Order XXI Rule 43 CPC (attachment of movable property by actual seizure) is the applicable provision governing the decretal relief sought.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- E.P. No.211/2015 was filed under Order XXI Rule 43 CPC for attachment of movables of the 3rd judgment‑debtor.
- The Court below should not have initiated coercive steps to take possession because a claim petition by the husband of the 3rd judgment‑debtor under Order XXI Rule 58 CPC (E.A. No.219/2016) had been rejected and was under challenge before this Court (CRP (SR) No.22473/2019).
- Relied on Brahmdeo Chaudhary v. Rishikesh Prasad Jaiswal and another to contend that the statutory scheme of Order XXI (Rules 97/99) governs objections by strangers and obstructors and limits re‑issuance of execution warrants backed by police force.
Respondents' Arguments
- Relied upon B. Venkata Reddy v. P.A. Vanajakshi and the provisions of Order XXI, particularly Rule 43 CPC, to contend that attachment of movable property must be effected by actual seizure and that Rule 43 is the apt provision for the relief sought by the decree‑holder.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Brahmdeo Chaudhary versus Rishikesh Prasad Jaiswal and another 1 (1 997) 3 Supreme Court Cases 694 |
Scope of Order XXI (particularly Rules 97 and 99) concerning objections by purported strangers/obstructionists to execution and the need to adjudicate such objections before forcible dispossession. | The Court held that the citation relied upon by the petitioner "has no application to the present facts of the case." |
| B. Venkata Reddy versus P.A Vanajakshi 2 (2 005) 1 ALD 72 9 |
General procedural scheme for execution of decrees and applicability of Order XXI Rules (notably Rules 41–54 and Rule 43 for attachment of movables). | The Court noted Rule 43's requirement of actual seizure for attachment of movables and treated the authority as supporting the view that Rule 43 is applicable; this informed the Court's conclusion that no flaw was made by the court below. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court observed that the core facts concern attachment of movable property under Order XXI Rule 43 CPC, warrants having been returned because the 3rd judgment‑debtor's house was locked and the decree‑holder seeking permission to break locks to effect attachment. The petitioner’s reliance on the Supreme Court decision in Brahmdeo Chaudhary (dealing with Order XXI Rules 97/99 and objections by purported strangers) was considered but the Court concluded that the cited authority did not apply to the facts before it. The Court analysed the respondents' reliance on B. Venkata Reddy and Rule 43, noting Rule 43 requires actual seizure and custody by the attaching officer for attachment of movables. Applying that provision to the facts, the Court found no infirmity in the lower court's docket order granting break‑open permission to enable attachment. On that basis the Court found no merit in the revision petitions.
Holding and Implications
Holding: DISMISSED — The Civil Revision Petitions Nos.2870 and 2871 of 2019 and CRP (SR) No.22473 of 2019 are dismissed.
Implications: The impugned docket order of the executing court (granting break‑open permission to enable attachment of movables) stands affirmed; no order as to costs was made and all pending miscellaneous applications are directed to stand closed. The opinion does not purport to lay down any new precedent beyond applying existing Order XXI provisions and the cited authorities.
HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
FRIDAY ,THE TWENTY FOURTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY THREE
PRSENT
THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE K MANMADHA RAO
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 2870 OF 2019
Between:
1. SAMINENI VENU BABU , S/o. Late Venkateswarulu, Hindu, aged 51 years, Business, R/o. Flat No.S-II, Sri Sai Gayatri Nilayam, Santhinagar, NAD Kotha Road, Visakhapatnam
...PETITIONER(S)
AND:
1. MARGADARSI CHIT FUND PVT LTD M.V.P. Colony Branch, Visakhapatnam,
Rep. by its Branch Manager Sri M. Sudhakar.
2. C. Jagannath Sastry, S/o. C. Pallayya.Sastry, Aged 45 years, R/o. Flat No.18, Devi Towers, Akkayyapalem Highway Signals,
Visakhapatnam-18
3. B. Murali Krishna, S/o. B. Rajagopala Rao, Hindu, aged 38 years, Proprietor, M.K. Electronics, Shop No.19, Vidya Janata Complex, Eenadu Junction, Seethammadhara,
Visakhapatnam-13.
4. S. Seshu Kumari, W/o. S. Venu Babu, Hindu, aged 40 years, R/o. Flat No.S-II, Sri Gayatri Nilayam, Santhi Nagar, NAD Kotha Road, Visakhapatnam.
5. B. Jyoti Kamala, W/o. B. Murali Krishna, Hindu, aged 26 years, Prop. M/s.Bharath Electronics, Shop No.19/1, Vidya Janata Complex,
Eenadu Junciton, Seethammadhara,
Visakhapatnam-13.
6. C. Lalitha Subhashini, W/o. C. Jagannath Sastry, Hindu, aged 30 years working as Senior Assistant Physics, Z.P. High School (Girls), Koppam, Chittoor District-517 425.
...RESPONDENTS
Counsel for the Petitioner(s): G RAMA GOPAL Counsel for the Respondents: P DURGA PRASAD
The Court made the following: ORDER
1
HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE K. MANMADHA RAO CIVIL REVISION PETITION Nos.2870, 2871 of 2019 & CRP (SR) No.22473 of 2019
COMMON ORDER :
As the issue involved in these civil revision petitions is one and the same, these matters are taken up together for disposal by this Common Order.
2. These three Civil Revision Petitions are filed against the docket order dated 11.09.2019 in E.A.No.310 of 2019 in E.P.No.11 of 2015 in O.S No.538 of 2011 on the file of the II Additional Senior Civil Judge at Visakhapatnam.
4. Heard Mr. G. Rama Gopal, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Mr. P.Durga Prasad, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner argued that E.P. No.211 of 2015 was filed by the D.Hr i.e., M/s Margadarsi Chit Fund Pvt. Ltd., under Order 21 Rule 43 CPC for attachment of the moveables belonging to the 3rdJ.Dr i.e., B. Muralikrishna, for realization of the decretal amount as per the decree granted by the Court below in the suit in O.S
2
2
No.538 of 2011. Thereafter, the Court below ordered notices to the said 3rdJ.Dr for attachment against the moveables belonging to them. The warrants of the 3rdJ.Dr are returned as the house of the 3rdJ.Dr was under lock and key. In view of the same, the D.Hr has filed E.A.No.311 of 2019 in E.P.No.211 of 2015 in O.S.No.538 of 2011 seeking to empower the Field Assistant to break open the locks. In the said E.A., the Court below has passed docket order. Questioning the same, the present CRPs are filed.
6. The Court below, vide order dated 11.09.2019 has passed the following order :
" Heard. In view of return endorsement of Ameena dated 19.09.2019, issue break open permission as prayed for."
7. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the Court below ought not to have initiated coercive steps to take psossession of the moveable properties inasmuchas the husband of the 3rdJ.Dr filed claim petition in E.A No.219 of 2016 under Order 21 Rule 58 CPC and the same was rejected on 23.4.2019. So, the claim petitioner carried the matter before this Court vide CRP (SR) No.22473 of 2019.
3
8. This Court vide order, dated 13.09.2019, has issued notice and also permitted the petitioner to take out personal notice to the respondents. Thereafter, in view of the submissions of learned counsels, this Court, vide order dated 26.08.2022, while extending the interim order till 15.09.2022, directed the Registry to club the said CRP (SR) No.22473 of 2019 along with CRP Nos.2870 and 2871 of 2019.
9. Learned counsel for the petitioner has relied upon a case reported in Brahmdeo Chaudhary versus Rishikesh Prasad Jaiswal and another1, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that :
"In short the aforesaid statutory provisions of Order XXI lay down a complete code for resolving all disputes pertaining to execution of decree for possession obtained by a decree-holder and whose attempts at executing the said decree meet with rough weather. Once resistance is offered by a purported stranger to the decree and which comes to be noted by the Executing Court as well as by the decree-holder the remedy available to the decree- holder against such an obstructionist in only under Order XXI Rule 97 sub-rule (1) and he cannot bypass such obstruction and insist on re- issuance of warrant for possession under Order XXI Rule 35 with the help of police force, as that course would amount to bypassing and circumventing the procedure laid down under Order
1 (1 997) 3 Supreme Court Cases 694
4
XXI Rule 97 in connection with removal of obstruction of purported strangers to the decree. Once such an obstruction is on the record of the Executing Court it is difficult to appreciate how the Executing Court can tell such obstructionist that he must first lose possession and then only his remedy is to move an application under Order XXI Rule 99, CPC and pray for restoration of possession. The High Court by the impugned order and judgment has taken the view that the only remedy available to a stranger to the decree who claims any independent right, title or interest in the decretal property is to go by Order XXI Rule 99. This view of the High Court on the aforesaid statutory scheme is clearly unsustainable. It is easy to visualise that a stranger to the decree who claims an independent right, title and interest in the decretal property can offer his resistance before getting actually dispossessed. He can equally agitate his grievance and claim for adjudication of his independent right, title and interest in the decretal property even after losing possession as per Order XXI Rule 99. Order XXI Rule 97 deals with a stage which is prior to the actual execution of the decree for possession wherein the grievance of the obstructionist can be adjudicated upon before actual delivery of possession to the decree-holder. While Order XXI Rule 99 on the other hand deals with the subsequent stage in the execution proceedings where a stranger claiming any right, title and interest in the decretal property might have got actually dispossessed and claims restoration of possession on adjudication of his independent right, title and interest dehors the interest of the judgment-debtor. Both these types of enquiries in connection with the right, title and interest of a stranger to the decree are clearly contemplated by the aforesaid scheme of Order XXI and it is not as if that such a stranger to the decree can come in the picture only at the final stage after losing the possession and not before it if he is vigilant enough to raise his objection and obstruction before the warrant for possession gets actually executed against him. With respect the High Court has totally ignored the scheme of Order XXI Rule 97 in
5
this connection by taking the view that only remedy of such stranger to the decree lies under Order XXI Rule 99 and he has no locus standi to get adjudication of his claim prior to the actual delivery of possession to the decree-holder in the execution proceedings. The view taken by the High Court in this connection also results in patent breach of principles of natural justice as the obstructionist, who alleges to have any independent right, title and interest in the decretal property and who is admittedly not a party to the decree even though making a grievance right in time before the warrant for execution is actually executed, would be told off the gates and his grievance would not be considered or heard or merits and he would be thrown off lock, stock and barrel by use of police force by the decree-holder. That would obviously result in irreparable injury to such obstructionist whose grievance would go overboard without being considered on merits and such obstructionist would be condemned totally unheard. Such an order of the Executing Court, therefore, would fail also on the ground of non- compliance with basic principles of natural justice. On the contrary the statutory scheme envisaged by Order XXI Rule 97, CPC as discussed earlier clearly guards against such a pitfall and provides a statutory remedy both to the decree- holder as well as to the obstructionist to have their respective say in the matter and to get proper adjudication before the Executing Court and it is that adjudication which subject to the hierarchy of appeals would remain binding between the parties to such proceedings and separate suit would be barred with a view to seeing that multiplicity of proceedings and parallel proceedings are avoided and the gamut laid down by Order XXI Rules 97 and 103 would remain a complete code and the sole remedy for the concerned parties to have their grievances once and for all finally resolved in execution proceedings themselves.
6
10. On a perusal of the above citation which is furnished by the learned counsel for the petitioner has no application to the present facts of the case.
11. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents also relied upon a case reported in B. Venkata Reddy versus P.A Vanajakshi2, wherein, the Andhra Pradesh High Court held that :
"One of the most complicated stages in adjudication of civil disputes is the execution of a decree, which had become final. Several sections in the body of C.P.C, and Order XXI of its schedule, prescribe the detailed procedure to be followed, in the execution of decrees of different kinds. Attachment of movable or immovable properties of the judgment-debtors, and sale thereof, are the recognized steps in the execution of decrees, for recovery of money. Attachment, is invariably a step, which precedes the sale. Rules 41 to 54 of Order XXI C.P.C, prescribe the procedure for attachment of different kinds of properties. Prominent among them are Rules 43 and 54, which stipulate the manner in which the movable and immovable properties, respectively, can be attached, during the course of execution. Since the articles, that were sought to be attached.
12. In the instant case, the relief sought for by the D.Hr is for attachment of movable properties and Rule 43 is aptly applicable, which reads as under:
2 (2 005) 1 ALD 72 9
7
Rule 43 of Order XXI C.P.C:
43. Attachment of movable property, other than agricultural produce, in possession of judgment-debtor :-Where the property to be attached is movable property, other than agricultural produce, in the possession of the judgment-debtor, the attachment shall be made by actual seizure, and the attaching officer shall keep the property in his own custody or in the custody of one of his subordinates, and shall be responsible for the due custody thereof:
Provided that, when the property seized is subject to speedy and natural decay, or when the expense of keeping it in custody is likely to exceed its value, the attaching officer may sell it at once".
13. From a reading of the same, it is evident that attachment of movable property can be effected only through actual seizure, and assumption of the possession or custody thereof, by an attaching officer. In contrast, attachment of immovable property can be effected under Rule 54, simply by prohibiting the judgment-debtor from transferring or changing the attached property. In the present case, though an order directing attachment of various items of movable properties was made by the Executing Court, on 26.10.2000, it could not be effected, as is evident from the reports filed by the Amin, and
8
endorsement on the docket. If the process of attachment becomes difficult or where the decree holder himself finds that the attachment cannot be proceeded with, for any reason, he may choose to select certain other items of property.
14. Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case and in view of the foregoing discussion, this Court discernable to see that no flaw made by the Court below in passing the order, which is impugned in all these revision petitions and hence finds no merit in the instant revision petitions and the same are liable to be dismissed.
15. Accordingly, the Civil Revision Petitions are dismissed. No order as to costs.
As a sequel, all the pending miscellaneous applications shall stand closed.
______________________________
DR. K. MANMADHA RAO, J.
Date : -02-2023 Gvl
9
HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE K. MANMADHA RAO CIVIL REVISION PETITION Nos.2870, 2871 of 2019 & CRP (SR) No.22473 of 2019
Date : .02.2023 Gvl
10
Alert