Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Devendra Kumar Srivasatava v. Prabhat Kumar Srivastava @ Bachchanjee

Patna High Court
Aug 8, 2023
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The case arises from a dispute involving partition of joint properties originally initiated by Late Radha Prasad in Title (Partition) Suit No. 151 of 1991 filed in the Court of learned Sub-Judge, Siwan. The suit was transferred by this Court to the Civil Court, Patna, where it proceeded before the Sub-Judge, Patna. A Civil Review petition challenging the transfer was dismissed by this Court with costs. After the death of Radha Prasad, his heirs were substituted as plaintiffs, but the suit was dismissed in default in 2011 due to non-prosecution. Subsequently, Prabhat Kumar Srivastava, son of Late Radha Prasad, filed a fresh partition suit at Siwan in 2019 (Title (Partition) Suit No. 151 of 2019). The petitioner filed a caveat objecting to the fresh suit on the grounds that the earlier suit was pending and transferred to Patna, and thus the fresh suit should not be entertained. The trial court admitted the fresh suit on the basis that the cause of action in partition suits is recurring. The petitioner challenged this admission by filing the present Civil Miscellaneous Application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the fresh partition suit filed in 2019 is barred under Order IX Rule 9 or Order XXII Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure due to the earlier suit filed in 1991 being dismissed in default.
  2. Whether the principle of recurring cause of action applies in partition suits such that a fresh suit can be admitted despite dismissal of a prior suit.
  3. Whether the fresh suit should have been transferred from Siwan Civil Court to Patna Civil Court in light of the earlier suit’s transfer.
  4. Whether the plaintiff’s institution of the fresh suit amounts to contempt of court or mala fide conduct.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The earlier Title (Partition) Suit No. 151 of 1991 and the present suit of 2019 are essentially the same suit.
  • Order IX Rule 9 CPC precludes the plaintiff from bringing a fresh suit after dismissal of the earlier suit, which the learned court below failed to appreciate.
  • The plaintiff should have sought revival of the earlier suit in Patna where pleadings were complete, instead of filing a new suit.
  • The plaintiff acted mala fide by instituting a fresh suit despite the earlier suit being transferred and dismissed, amounting to contempt of court.
  • The present suit is liable to be transferred from Siwan Civil Court to Patna Civil Court.
  • Relied on Supreme Court precedent emphasizing that parties must come to court with clean hands.
  • Referred to Calcutta High Court authority on breach of undertakings to court amounting to contempt.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Partition is a recurring cause of action until the property is finally partitioned, thus a fresh suit after dismissal in default is not barred under Order IX Rule 9 CPC.
  • Dismissal of the earlier suit under Order IX Rule 8 CPC does not preclude filing a fresh partition suit.
  • The earlier suit’s delay and dismissal were due to compromise talks among parties.
  • The petitioner is not a party to the suit and has filed the caveat petition mala fide to delay proceedings.
  • Contempt proceedings cannot be initiated in the present suit proceeding.
  • The petitioner’s challenge to admission of the suit is misplaced; the proper remedy for rejection is under Order VII Rule 11 CPC.
  • Relied on this Court’s previous judgments holding that partition suits involve recurring cause of action and fresh suits are maintainable so long as properties remain joint.
  • There is no jurisdictional error or illegality in admitting the fresh suit.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu (dead) by L.Rs. v. Jagannath (dead) by L.Rs., (1994) 1 SCC 1 (AIR 1994 SC 853) Parties must come to court with clean hands; courts are for imparting justice. Referenced by petitioner to allege mala fide conduct by plaintiff; court noted but did not find contempt in current proceedings.
Raj Rajeshwari Jiu v. Gati Krishna Chakrabarti, (1924 Calcutta 453) Breach of undertaking to court amounts to contempt; litigant guilty of such contempt may be barred from being heard until purged. Petitioner relied on this to allege contempt; court held contempt proceedings not appropriate in present suit.
Ram Krishna Thakur v. Om Prakash Thakur, (2010) 1 PLJR 293 Partition is a recurring cause of action until final partition. Followed by court to hold fresh partition suit maintainable despite dismissal of earlier suit.
Sheo Nandan Singh v. Ram Bali Singh, (2010) 1 PLJR 567 Partition suits involve recurring cause of action; subsequent suits not barred if property remains joint. Applied by court to uphold admission of fresh suit.
Dilo Rana v. Munshi Kunj Behari Prasad, AIR 1948 Pat 244 Partition is recurring cause of action so long as property is joint. Followed by court to support principle allowing fresh partition suit.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the history of the original partition suit filed in 1991, noting that it was transferred to Patna Civil Court and ultimately dismissed in default in 2011. The review petition challenging transfer was dismissed with directions and costs. The court relied on established legal principles that partition suits involve recurring cause of action as long as the property remains joint. Consequently, dismissal of a prior suit for default does not bar filing a fresh suit under Order IX Rule 9 or Order XXII Rule 9 CPC. The court observed that the fresh suit was admitted correctly on the ground of recurring cause of action. The petitioner’s contention that the suit should be transferred back to Patna was noted but held that an appropriate petition should be filed for transfer if so advised. The court also clarified that allegations of contempt could not be decided in the present proceedings. The court found no jurisdictional error or illegality in the impugned order admitting the fresh suit and dismissed the petitioner’s application as devoid of merit.

Holding and Implications

The Civil Miscellaneous Application is dismissed.

The court’s decision upholds the principle that partition suits involve a recurring cause of action, permitting a fresh suit even after dismissal of an earlier suit for default. The fresh partition suit admitted by the trial court stands valid. The petitioner’s objections regarding transfer and alleged contempt were not accepted in this proceeding. The ruling directly affects the parties by allowing the fresh suit to proceed but does not establish any new precedent beyond reaffirming existing legal principles regarding recurring cause of action in partition suits.

Show all summary ...

Sunil Dutta Mishra, J.:— Heard learned counsel for the parties.

2. This Civil Miscellaneous Application is directed against the order dated 02.04.2019 passed by learned Sub Judge-1, Siwan, in Title (Partition) Suit No. 151 of 2019 by which he has admitted the said Title Suit filed by the plaintiff for partition of the properties.

3. The brief facts of the case are that father of the plaintiff namely Late Radha Prasad had earlier filed the Title (Partition) Suit No. 151 of 1991 in the Court of learned Sub-Judge, Siwan for partition of joint properties and by order of this Court dated 17.07.1997 in M.J.C. No. 746 of 1992 proceeding of the said Title (Partition) Suit No. 151 of 1991 was transferred to Civil Court, Patna where it proceeded in the Court of Sub-Judge, Patna. The Civil Review No. 175 of 1997 was filed against the judgment dated 17.07.1997 passed in M.J.C. No. 746 of 1992 which was dismissed by this Court vide order dated 25.01.2002 passed in Civil Review No. 175 of 1997 with cost of Rs. 2500/-.

4. The original plaintiff Radha Prasad had died and his sons and daughters have been substituted in his place. The substituted plaintiffs stopped pursuing the suit due to that reason the said suit was dismissed in default in 2011. Prabhat Kumar Srivastava who is the son of Late Radha Prasad again filed partition suit at Siwan being Title (Partition) Suit No. 151 of 2019 for partition of said properties. The petitioner filed a Caveat registered as Miscellaneous Case No. 40 of 2019 raising the objection that the Title (Partition) Suit No. 151 of 1991 was earlier filed by the father of petitioner which was transferred by this Court to Patna Civil Court and the review petition against transfer order was also dismissed with certain directions and imposing cost and the said suit was dismissed in default in 2011, then filing of the present Partition Suit is liable to be not heard. The said Miscellaneous Case No. 40 of 2019 was dismissed vide order dated 02.04.2019 and the suit has been admitted vide separate order dated 02.04.2019 on the ground that in partition suit cause of action is recurring.

5. Learned senior counsel for the petitioner has submitted that earlier Title (Partition) Suit no. 151 of 1991 and present Title Partition Suit No. 151 of 2019 are the one and same. Further, he has submitted that the learned Court below completely failed to appreciate that Order 9 Rule 9 CPC mandates that the plaintiff is precluded from bringing a fresh suit but deliberately ignoring this the learned Court below illegally admitted the fresh suit on false and frivolous story of the plaintiff. He has further submitted that learned Court below also failed to appreciate that the so called remedy to the plaintiff was to take steps for revival of the earlier Title (Partition) Suit No. 151 of 1991 at Patna in which the pleadings were completed. He further submits that the party to a suit must come to the Court with clean hands and the plaintiff mala fide instituted another suit at Siwan and thus repeated institution of frivolous suit/proceeding is per se contempt of this Court in view of the fact that the earlier suit was transferred by this Court from Siwan to Patna Court. Lastly, he has submitted that the present suit is liable to be transferred from Siwan Civil Court to Civil Court at Patna.

6. Learned senior counsel for the petitioner referred the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu (dead) by L.Rs. v. Jagannath (dead) by L.Rs. ((1994) 1 SCC 1 : AIR 1994 SC 853) wherein it has been observed that “the Courts of Law are meant for imparting Justice between the parties. One who comes to the Court, must come with clean hands.”

7. He also referred the judgment of Calcutta High Court in Raj Rajeshwari Jiu v. Gati Krishna Chakrabarti (1924 Calcutta 453) wherein it was observed that “It is unquestionable that the breach of an undertaking given to the Court by a litigant, pending proceedings, on the faith of which the Court sanctions a particular course of action or inaction is misconduct amounting to contempt. It is further well settled that when a person is guilty of such contempt he places himself in a perilous situation so as not to be heard by the Court till he has purged his contempt.”

8. On the other hand, learned counsel for the plaintiff/respondent No. 1 has submitted that partition is a recurring cause of action till the property is not partitioned finally and thus the subsequent partition suit when the previous partition suit was dismissed in default cannot be held to be barred by the law under Order 9 Rule 9 of CPC as it was not adjudicated finally. The dismissal of previous suit under Order 9 Rule 8 of CPC does not create a bar for filing a fresh Partition Suit under Order 9 Rule 9. He has further submitted that after death of Late Kapildeo Narayan and Late Radha Prasad a compromise talk started between the parties due to which pairvi in Suit No. 151 of 1991 became slow and lastly, it was dismissed in default. He has further submitted that petitioner is not even the party in the Suit and with mala fide filed the petition to delay the proceeding in the suit which is liable to be rejected. The procedure for initiation of contempt is separate proceedings which cannot be invoked in fresh suit proceeding. He has further submitted that for rejection of suit the proper grounds are stated in Order VII Rule 11 CPC and the petitioner instead of filing such petition filed Miscellaneous (Caveat) Case No. 40 of 2019 which has been rightly rejected vide order dated 02.04.2019 which has not been challenged by the petitioner and the petitioner challenged the order dated 02.04.2019 passed in T.S. No. 151 of 2019 by which the suit has been admitted for hearing on the ground that in Partition Suit there is recurring cause of action. He has referred the judgments of this Court in Ram Krishna Thakur v. Om Prakash Thakur, (2010) 1 PLJR 293 and Sheo Nandan Singh v. Ram Bali Singh, (2010) 1 PLJR 567 wherein it was observed that partition is recurring cause of action till the property is not partitioned finally, thus, the subsequent partition suit could not be held to be barred under the Order XXII Rule 9 so long the properties concerned remain joint. This Court had followed the decision of Division Bench of this Court in Dilo Rana v. Munshi Kunj Behari Prasad, AIR 1948 Pat 244 in which it was held that partition is a recurring cause of action so long as property is joint. Hence, in such a case plaintiff's right of partition will subsist even after the abatement of previous suit for partition. There is no jurisdictional error or illegality in the impugned order requiring interference by this Court in Supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

9. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the material on record, it appears that admittedly earlier suit filed by the father of plaintiff for partition being Title (Partition) Suit No. 151 of 1991 was transferred to Patna Civil Court which was lastly, dismissed in default in 2011. The Review petition against the transfer of the said suit was also dismissed by this Court with certain observation and direction. The trial court admitted the fresh suit being Title (Partition) Suit No. 151 of 2019 observing that in partition suit, recurring cause of action arises. It was also observed that in Miscellaneous Case No. 40 of 2019 which has been filed as Caveat, the petitioner of Caveat petition Devendra Kumar Srivastava is not named in defendant column.

10. In partition suit, the principle is well settled that the cause of action in fact is a recurring one and the contention with regard to Order IX Rule 9 or Order XXII Rule 9 CPC bar of subsequent suit is without substance. Even after dismissal of the former suit, the jointness continues and there is a continuing cause of action. In the present case, the earlier suit was not decided on merit but dismissed for default/non-prosecution. The petitioner if wants to transfer the suit from Siwan Civil Court to Patna Civil Court he can file the appropriate petition before this Court if so advised. The question whether the plaintiff/Respondent No. 1 has violated any order of this Court and committed contempt cannot be decided in the present proceeding.

11. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, I do not find any jurisdictional error or illegality in the impugned order and this Miscellaneous Application is devoid of merit and liable to be dismissed.

12. This Civil Miscellaneous Application is, accordingly, dismissed.