Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Dilip Kumar v. Brajraj Shrivastava And Another

Supreme Court Of India
Jul 26, 2023
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The first respondent filed a complaint under Section 200 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Cr P C) alleging that the appellant had committed offences under Sections 323, 342, 500, 504, 506, 295-A, 298 and 427 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. On 22 August 2008, the Judicial Magistrate First Class opted to conduct an inquiry himself under Section 202(1) Cr P C. He recorded only the complainant’s statement and, on 18 September 2008, dismissed the complaint under Section 203 Cr P C.

The High Court, in revision, held that the Magistrate had not conducted a proper inquiry under Section 202(1) because none of the eight witnesses named in the complaint had been examined. It set aside the dismissal order and remanded the matter to the Magistrate for a fresh inquiry from the Section 202 stage. The appellant challenged that remand order before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, after choosing to conduct an inquiry under Section 202(1) Cr P C himself, a Magistrate can dismiss the complaint under Section 203 without examining the witnesses named in the complaint.
  2. Whether the High Court erred in remanding the matter to the Magistrate on the ground of an incomplete Section 202 inquiry.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Examination of the complainant alone satisfies the requirement of Section 202; recording statements of additional witnesses is not mandatory.
  • The Magistrate correctly concluded, on the basis of the complaint, the complainant’s statement and other material, that the allegations were mala fide.
  • Relied on Mohinder Singh v. Gunwant Singh (1992) 2 SCC 213 and Nagawwa v. Veeranna Shivalingappa Konjalgi (1976) 3 SCC 736 to support the proposition that the Magistrate may dismiss a complaint at the preliminary stage if the allegations appear groundless.

The opinion does not detail the respondent's arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mohinder Singh v. Gunwant Singh (1992) 2 SCC 213 A Magistrate who embarks on an inquiry under Section 202 must consider the statements of the complainant and his witnesses before dismissing the complaint under Section 203. The Supreme Court held that this principle binds the Magistrate; failure to examine the named witnesses rendered the dismissal improper.
Nagawwa v. Veeranna Shivalingappa Konjalgi (1976) 3 SCC 736 Reiterates that a complaint should not be dismissed at the preliminary stage without adequate inquiry, including consideration of complainant’s witnesses. Used to affirm that the High Court correctly remitted the case because the Magistrate had not adhered to this requirement.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court scrutinised the Magistrate’s orders of 22 August 2008 and 18 September 2008. It noted:

  • Section 202(1) gives the Magistrate discretion either to inquire personally or direct police investigation. The Magistrate elected to inquire personally.
  • The complaint named eight witnesses, but none were examined. No reasons were recorded for omitting their examination.
  • Both Mohinder Singh and Nagawwa establish that, when a Magistrate conducts an inquiry himself, he must consider statements of the complainant and his witnesses before invoking Section 203.
  • Therefore, the Magistrate’s dismissal order contravened well-settled law. The High Court’s decision to remand the matter for a proper Section 202 inquiry was correct.
  • The Supreme Court clarified that observations made by the High Court—including those regarding sanction under Section 197 Cr P C—are merely tentative and will not bind the Magistrate during the fresh inquiry.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed. The Supreme Court upheld the High Court’s order remanding the complaint to the Magistrate for a fresh inquiry under Section 202(1) Cr P C.

Implications: The matter returns to the Magistrate, who must now examine the complainant’s witnesses before deciding whether to issue process or dismiss the complaint. The decision reinforces the procedural safeguard that a Magistrate must fully comply with Section 202 requirements before invoking Section 203. No new precedent was set; the Court applied existing principles.

Show all summary ...

Abhay S. Oka, J.:— A complaint under Section 200 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (for short ‘the Cr. P.C.’) was filed by the first respondent showing the appellant as an accused and alleging offences punishable under Sections 323, 342, 500, 504, 506, 295-A, 298, 427 of the Penal Code, 1860. Considering the limited controversy involved in this appeal, we are not adverting to the allegations made in the complaint.

2. On 22 August, 2008, the learned Magistrate passed an order directing holding of an inquiry under sub-Section (1) of Section 202 of the Cr. P.C. The order indicates that the learned Magistrate intended to himself hold an inquiry. Thereafter, the learned Magistrate recorded the statement of only the first respondent/complainant and passed an order dated 18 September, 2008, dismissing the complaint under Section 203 of the Cr. P.C. By the impugned order, the High Court has interfered with the said order on a limited ground. The High Court was of the view that there was no proper inquiry made by the learned Magistrate in terms of sub-Section (1) of Section 202 of the Cr. P.C. and therefore, the High Court remitted the complaint to the learned Magistrate from the stage of holding an inquiry under sub-Section (1) of Section 202 of the Cr. P.C.

3. The learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant submitted that it was not mandatory for the learned Magistrate to record statements of other witnesses. He submitted that after considering the statement of the first respondent-complainant and the averments made in the complaint and other material on record, the learned Magistrate rightly came to the conclusion that the allegations in the complaint were mala fide. He placed reliance on the decision of this Court in the case of Mohinder Singh v. Gunwant Singh (1992) 2 SCC 213. He relied upon what is held by this Court in paragraph 11 thereof. He also pressed into service another decision of this Court in the case of Nagawwa v. Veeranna Shivalingappa Konjalgi (1976) 3 SCC 736.

4. We have carefully perused the order dated 18 September, 2008 passed by the learned Magistrate and earlier order of 22 August, 2008. Under sub-Section (1) of Section 202 of the Cr. P.C., the learned Magistrate has a discretion either to inquire into the case himself, or to direct a Police Officer to investigate and submit a report. In this case, he took recourse to the first option. A perusal of the complaint shows that eight witnesses were specifically named in the complaint. The learned Magistrate did not examine any of them. In the order dated 18 September, 2008, the learned Magistrate has not recorded reasons for not recording the statements of other witnesses specifically cited in the complaint. The law is well settled, which is found to have been reiterated in the decision in the case of Mohinder Singh (supra). After taking recourse to sub-Section (1) of Section 202 of the Cr. P.C., before dismissing a complaint by taking recourse to Section 203 of the Cr. P.C., the learned Magistrate has to consider the statements of the complainant and his witnesses. In this case, the learned Magistrate has not examined the other witnesses. The view taken by this Court in the case of Nagawwa (supra) is no different.

5. Therefore, we find no error when the High Court came to the conclusion that the complaint deserves to be remanded from the stage of holding an inquiry under sub-Section (1) of Section 202 of the Cr. P.C.

6. The High Court has made certain observations including on the issue of absence of sanction under Section 197 of the Cr. P.C. As the High Court has remanded the case for holding an inquiry in terms of sub-Section (1) of Section 202 of the Cr. P.C., it is obvious that the observations made in the impugned order, including the observations on requirement of sanction under Section 197 of the Cr. P.C., will have to be held as tentative observations, which will have no bearing on ultimate conclusion to be drawn by the learned Magistrate.

7. Subject to what is observed above, no case for interference is made out. The appeal is, accordingly, dismissed.

8. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.