- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Nikita Sinha v. Amarnath Grih Nirman...
Sanjay Dwivedi, J.:— The instant petition was languishing since 2018 to see its fate and listed under caption ‘held up cases’. With the consent of learned counsel for both the parties, the matter was heard finally.
2. This petition has been filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India questioning the validity of the order dated 28.11.2017 (Annexure-P/5) passed by the Court below whereby an application submitted by the plaintiff-petitioner in a pending suit for declaration and permanent injunction seeking relief for possession also, has been rejected.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner sanguinely submitted that the impugned order is de hors the law and not sustainable for the reason that the application has been rejected mainly on the ground that if plea of possession is inserted that would change the nature of suit. He submitted that there was pleading in the plaint, but under misconception, the relief of possession could not be claimed, which was later-on claimed by moving amendment application and that does not change the nature of suit and thus the observation made by the Court below is not proper inasmuch as the plea of possession can be raised by the plaintiff during the pendency of suit, especially when relief of possession is not barred by limitation. To avoid multiplicity of litigation, it is appropriate for the plaintiff to claim the relief of possession in the pending suit only. To reinforce, he placed reliance on a decision in the case of Abdul Rahman v. Mohd. Ruldu, 2013 (1) SC CD 78 (SC) wherein the Supreme Court has enunciated that merely because relief clause is sought to be amended and additional relief is claimed, it cannot be termed as a change in the nature of suit.
4. In contrast, learned counsel for the respondents supported the impugned order and submitted that the request of the plaintiff has been rightly turned down as it would change the nature of suit. He placed reliance on a decision rendered in W.P. No. 21249/2011 (Pushpa Arora v. Anita Arora).
5. I have given anxious consideration to the submissions urged by learned counsel for the rival parties and perused the documents made available on record.
6. Indeed, the suit has been filed for declaration and permanent injunction in the year 2015 seeking declaration that the sale-deed dated 29.05.2006 be cancelled and declared null & void. In the pending civil suit, application under Order VI Rule 17 read with Section 151 of CPC was filed on 19.06.2017 seeking amendment in the relief Clause that the possession of the land in question be also delivered to the plaintiff. The said application was opposed by the defendants (respondents herein) on the ground that the amendment would change the nature of suit and therefore said amendment cannot be green-signaled. Opposition was also made on the fulcrum that the plaintiff did not disclose as to why the amendment claiming relief of possession was not brought in time and thus after commencement of trial as per proviso appended to Order VI Rule 17 of CPC amendment cannot be permitted to be incorporated.
7. It emerged from the plaint that there was pleading that over a plot purchased by the plaintiff-petitioner, defendant No. 1 has already raised construction. Meaning thereby, the plaintiff was out of possession, but in the suit for declaration relief of possession was not claimed and as such relief of possession is being demanded by way of amendment application. Since facts of the case are same and only additional relief of possession is sought to be added, in my opinion it does not change the nature of suit anyway. The suit was filed in the year 2015 and relief of possession is sought by way of amendment application in 2017, therefore stand taken by the respondents that relief which is being claimed by way of amendment is barred by time, has no strength. Even otherwise, in view of the law laid down by the Supreme Court in re Ragu Thilak D. John v. S. Rayappan, (2001) 2 SCC 472 : AIR 2001 SC 699 even when the relief is barred by time can also be added by way of amendment and if so required, the issue with regard to limitation can be framed by the Court below and relief claimed by way of amendment can be allowed.
8. At this juncture it is expedient to go-through the decision, relied upon on behalf of the respondents, in re Pushpa Arora (supra), in that, although one of the conditions runs against the petitioner that if amendment is necessary for the purpose of determining the real question in controversy between parties, but in the case at hand, since declaration of quashing of sale-deed in favour of defendant No. 1 has been sought and as per the pleadings over the land which had been purchased by the petitioner, construction has been made by defendant No. 1 and claiming possession is also a necessary relief, which remained unclaimed and therefore such relief is necessary for proper adjudication and also to avoid multiplicity of litigation and as such amendment cannot be denied. It is not clear from the record as to whether process of recording statement of witnesses is started or not. Therefore, in absence of considering the said aspect by the court below, the application cannot be rejected on the ground that it has been filed after commencement of trial.
9. I firmly find that to evade multiplicity of limitation, amendment application should havze been allowed. Obviously, the court below exceeded its jurisdiction holding that the amendment would change the nature of suit ignoring the fact that there was no change asked for in the pleadings and in the existing facts and circumstances, the relief, according to plaintiff, under misconception could not be claimed, therefore, is being sought to be added additionally by way of amendment application. The impugned order dated 28.11.2017 being unsustainable, is hereby set aside. The application filed by the plaintiff under Order VI Rule 17 of CPC is allowed and the petitioner shall be permitted to carry out necessary amendment in the plaint within appropriate time.
10. The petition is accordingly allowed and disposed of.
11. No order as to costs.
Alert