Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

RAJIV GANDHI UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES v. MR SAMARTH S S

Karnataka High Court
Jan 11, 2023

- 1 -

WA No. 1208 of 2022 & WA No.1214 of 2022, WA No.1215 OF 2022

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

DATED THIS THE 11THDAY OF JANUARY, 2023

PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR PRASANNA B. VARALE, CHIEF JUSTICE

AND

THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE ASHOK S.KINAGI

WRIT APPEAL NO. 1208 OF 2022 (EDN-RES)

AND

W.A.NO.1214 OF 2022, W.A.NO.1215 OF 2022

IN W.A. No.1208 OF 2022

BETWEEN:

1 . RAJIV GANDHI UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES

4THT BLOCK, JAYANAGAR

BENGALURU - 560041

REP. BY ITS VICE CHANCELLOR

NOW REP. BY REGISTRAR

2 . THE REGISTRAR

RAJIV GANDHI UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES,

4THT BLOCK, JAYANAGAR

BENGALURU - 560041

...APPELLANTS

(BY SRI. D.N. NANJUNDA REDDY, SR. ADVOCATE FOR

SMT. FARAH FATHIMA, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1 . MR. SAMARTH S S

S/O SATISH S R

- 2 -

AGED 21 YEARS,

REG. NO. 20M4370 R/O NO. 434,

7THB CROSS, VINAYAKA LAYOUT,

NAGARABHAVI

2NDSTAGE, BENGALURU - 560072

2 . MS SANJANA K

D/O DR. KUMAR GOWDA S M V

AGED 20 YEARS

UNI. REG. NO. 20M4000

R/O SAI NILAYA MUTHYLPETE MULBAGAL KOLAR - 563131

3 . MR. SYED TAHA ZAYD

S/O SYED MOHIUDDIN

AGED 19 YEARS

UNI REG. NO. 20M6985 R/O 401A,

ESTEEM ENCLAVE

AREKERE, 2NDCROSS,

BANNERGHATTA ROAD

BENGALURU - 560076

4 . MR. KARTHIK S KUMAR

S/O MR. K K SATHEESH KUMAR

AGED 20 YEARS

UNI. REG. 20M4120 R/O CHENGAT HOUSE, CHANDERA

MANIYAT, KASARGOD PO

KERALA - 673 005

5 . MR RAKSHITH MUDEGOWDRU

S/O GIRISH MUDEGOWDRU

AGED 20 YEARS

UNI. REG. NO. 20M6196 R/O NO. 1637/10 SADASHIVA,

1STCROSS, 2NDMAIN,

TARALABALU

DAVANAGERE - 577 005

6 . MR. FARHAD VIRAF BHADHA

S/O MR. VIRAF F BHADHA

AGED 21 YEARS

UNI REG. NO. 20M3174

- 3 -

R/O BUILDING NO.15,

FLAT NO.4, OLD KHAREGHAT COLONY

HUGHES ROAD,

MUMBAI - 400 007

7 . MR VINAYAKA M M

S/O MALLIKARJUNA M K

AGED 24 YEARS

UNI. REG. NO. 20M6258

R/O NO. 2543/1, 6THMAIN ROAD

M C C A BLOCK,

DAVANAGERE - 577 004

8 . MS. ANKITA A

D/O ASHOK AMBALGI

AGED 22 YEARS

UNI. REG. NO. 19M5604

R/O MSK MILL, GDA LAYOUT

BEHIND CENTRAL BUS STAND

KALABURAGI - 585 103

9 . MR. VARUN HIREN PATHAK

AGED 20 YEARS

S/O HIREN TARUN PATHAK

UNI. REG. NO. 20M4454

R/O NO.28, SANGAM SOCIETY CITY LIGHT ROAD

NUPOOR HOSPITAL SURAT NR

GUJARAT - 395 007

10 . MR PRAJWAL BIRADAR

S/O BASAVARAJ BIRADAR

AGED 20 YEARS

UNI. REG. NO. 20M5293 H.NO. 3-104212

DARGA ROAD, SIDDESHWAR NAGAR

GAZIPUR, KALABURAGI - 585 102

11 . MS NIDHI SRIDHAR

D/O SRIDHAR N

AGED 21 YEARS UNI REG. NO. 20M5883 R/O 1217/2,

2NDBLOCK, BEL LAYOUT

NANJAPPA ROAD,

- 4 -

VIDYARANYAPURA

BENGALURU - 560097

12 . MS. SAMITHA RANJOLKAR

D/O SHIVARAJ RANJOLKAR

AGED 20 YEARS

UNI. REG. NO. 20M7184 R/O H.NO. 10-3/9/2 PLOT NO.53 8THCROSS, VITTAL NAGAR KALABURAGI -

585 102

13 . MS. LEKHASHREE G

D/O G S GOVINDAPPA

AGED 21 YEARS

UNI. REG. NO. 20M5104 R/O 1ST CROSS, THYAGARAJA

COLONY

MULBAGAL KOLAR - 563 131

14 . MS FIRDOSE SIDDIQ D

D/O B DADAPEER

AGED 20 YEARS

UNI. REG NO. 20M6146

R/O GANESH LAYOUT,

2NDMAIN, 5THCROSS,

DAVANAGERE - 577 001

15 . MS RAKSHITHA K M

D/O MURALIDHARA K R

AGED 21 YEARS

UNI REG. NO. 20M6197

R/O GIRLS HOSTEL,

S S INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES

AND RESEARCH CENTRE,

SOG COLONY

SHRI RAMANAGARA

DAVANAGERE - 577 003

16 . MS AIWARAYA T S

D/O SURESHBABU T V

AGED 20 YEARS

UNI. REG. NO. 20M4580

R/O THARAYIL HOUSE,

- 5 -

EITHURUTH KODUNGALLUR

PO THRISSUR KERALA - 620 680

17 . MS. POOJA M REDDY

D/O MANJUNATH REDDY M M

AGED 22 YEARS

UNI. REG. NO. 20M3699 R/O NO. 1495,

18THCROSS, 14THMAIN,

KUMARASWAMY LAYOUT, 1STSTAGE

BENGALURU - 560078

18 . MS. SHREYA

D/O CHANNABASAVARAJ K PATIL

AGED 20 YEARS

UNI. REG. NO. 20M1013

R/O H NO. 8-4-45, BHER PETH,

NEAR NATH TEMPLE ALAND,

KALABURAGI - 585 302

19 . MS. NIKITA ARUNKUMAR KOLUR

D/O ARUNKUMAR KOLUR

AGED 20 YEARS

UNI REG. NO. 20M4335

ARUNKUMAR KOLUR

DSP OFFICE TELAGI ROAD,

BASAVANA BAGEWADI,

VIJAYAPURA - 586 203

20 . MS. SREELAKSHMI RENJITH

D/O RENJITH THARAMMAL

AGED 20 YEARS

UNI REG. NO. 19M3865

R/O HARISREE VILLA,

NO.15, SHALIMAR GARDEN,

ATHANIKKAL WESTHILL

KOZHIKODE, KERALA - 673 005

21 . MR. DRUPADH K P

S/O SUNIL K P

AGED 23 YEARS

UNI. REG. NO. 19M3779,

- 6 -

R/O SNEHATHEERAM (H)

KURUNGOTTU PADIKKAL

KANNADIKKAL VENGERI

KOZHIKODE,

KERALA - 673 005

22 . MS. ELSA AJU THOMAS

D/O AJU THOMAS

AGED 21 YEARS

UNI REG. NO. 19M3936

R/O A J LADIES HOSTEL

A J INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES,

MANGALORE - 575 004

23 . MR. M B SHREYAS

S/O M K BHASKAR

AGED 22 YEARS

UNI REG. NO. 19M4012 R/O NO. 1959,

1STMAIN, 1STCROSS, E BLOCK,

3RDSTAGE, DATTAGAHALLY

MYSORE - 570 022

24 . MS. HAFEEZAH KHANUM

D/O NOOR KHAN

AGED 22 YEARS

UNI. REG. NO. 19M0885

R/O ABOVE INDIAN CUMC

GANGAMMA TEMPLE ROAD,

M V EXTENSION

HOSKOTE, BENGALURU - 562114

25 . MS. GOWRI M PATTANASHETTY

D/O MURUGESH P H

AGED 21 YEARS,

REG NO.19M3650

R/O GIRLS HOSTEL,

BASWESHWARA MEDICAL COLLEGE AND HOSPITAL

CHITRADURGA-577 502.

26 . MS.SHALINI S

D/O SHIVAPPA N

- 7 -

AGED 21 YEARS,

UNI.REG.NO.19M529

R/O WARD NO.15, STREET NO.4,

VINAYAKA NAGAR, CHINTAMANI

CHIKKABALLAPURA-563 125.

27 . MS.SUJATHA S CHAVAN

D/O MR.SHIVAPPA H LAMANI

AGED 21 YEARS,

UNI.REG.NO.19M1712

NO.7, 4THCROSS,

D BLOCK, KRISHNA GARDEN,

RR NAGAR, BENGALURU-560098.

28 . NATIONAL MEDICAL COMMISSION

UNDER GRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION BOARD

POCKET 14 SECTOR, 8 DWARAKA PHASE-I NEW DELHI-110 077

BY ITS PRESIDENT/CHAIRMAN

…..RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. D.R. RAVISHANKAR, SR. ADVOCATE FOR

SRI. ABHISHEK PATIL, ADVOCATE FOR

C/RESPONDENTS 1,3,5,7,16,20 & 25

SRI. ABHISHEK MALIPATIL, ADVOCATE FOR

RESPONDENT Nos.2, 4, 6, 8-15, 17-19, 21-24, 26 & 27

SRI. N. KHETTY, ADVOCATE FOR R28)

IN W.A.NO.1214 OF 2022

BETWEEN:

1 . RAJIV GANDHI UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES

4THT BLOCK, JAYANAGAR

BENGALURU - 560041

REP. BY ITS VICE CHANCELLOR

NOW REP. BY REGISTRAR

2 . THE REGISTRAR

RAJIV GANDHI UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES,

- 8 -

4THT BLOCK, JAYANAGAR

BENGALURU - 560041

...APPELLANTS

(BY SRI. D.N. NANJUNDA REDDY, SR. ADVOCATE FOR

SMT. FARAH FATHIMA, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1 . MR HRISHIK REDDY R

S/O RAJA REDDY

AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS

UNI REG NO.20M3334

R/O 91/B, KEMPAMMA DEVI ROAD

NEW THIPPASANDRA

BENGALURU-560075

2 . NATIONAL MEDICAL COMMISSION

UNDER GRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION BOARD

POCKET-14, SECTOR 8, DWARAKA PHASE-1 NEW DELHI-110077

BY ITS PRESIDENT/CHAIRMAN

….RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. ABHISHEK MALIPATIL, ADVOCATE FOR R1

SRI. N. KHETTY, ADVOCATE FOR R2)

IN W.A.NO.1215 OF 2022

BETWEEN:

1 . RAJIV GANDHI UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES

4THT BLOCK, JAYANAGAR

BENGALURU - 560041

REP. BY ITS VICE CHANCELLOR

NOW REP. BY REGISTRAR

2 . THE REGISTRAR

RAJIV GANDHI UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES,

4THT BLOCK, JAYANAGAR

BENGALURU - 560041

...APPELLANTS

- 9 -

(BY SRI. D.N. NANJUNDA REDDY, SR. ADVOCATE FOR

SMT. FARAH FATHIMA, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1 . MS. MAANYA H

D/O MR. H.R. HARISH KUMAR

AGED 20 YEARS

UNI REG NO.20M4945

R/O 94, 10THMAIN, 1STSTAGE

1STBLOCK, MANJUNATH NAGAR

BENGALURU-560010

2 . NATIONAL MEDICAL COMMISSION

UNDER GRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION BOARD

POCKET-14, SECTOR 8, DWARAKA PHASE-1 NEW DELHI-110077

BY ITS PRESIDENT/CHAIRMAN

….RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. ABHISHEK MALIPATIL, ADVOCATE FOR C/R1

SRI. N. KHETTY, ADVOCATE FOR R2)

THESE WRIT APPEALS ARE FILED UNDER SECTION 4 OF

THE KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961, PRAYING TO CALL

FOR RECORDS IN WP No-16352/2022 AND CONNECTED WRIT

PETITIONS AND SET ASIDE THE COMMON ORDER DATED

09.11.2022 PASSED BY THE LEARNED SINGLE JUDGE OF THIS

HON'BLE COURT IN WP No-16352/2022, WP No-16606/2022 AND WP No-20531/2022 AND ETC.

THESE WRIT APPEALS COMING ON FOR HEARING THIS

DAY, ASHOK S. KINAGI, J., DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

JUDGMENT

These intra-court appeals are filed under Section 4 of the Karnataka High Courts Act assailing the order dated

- 10 -

09.11.2021 passed in W.P.No.16352/2022 c/w W.P.Nos.16606/2022 and 20531/2022 by the learned Single Judge.

2. Brief facts leading rise to filing of these appeals are as under:

The respondents - Students admitted for the medical course for the academic year 2019-20. The appellant issued a time table for examination scheduled to be held in the month of May 2022. The respondent - Students have appeared for the examination for RS4 batch (1stbatch of the academic year 2019-2020) held in the month of May 2022. The University declared the results and conducted valuation of the answer scripts in terms of the Ordinance dated 01.02.2021. The Ordinance dated 01.02.2021 was placed before the academic council for its concurrence and approval as required under Section 35(3) of the Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences Act, 1994 (for short 'the RGUHS Act'). The Committee of the academic council in its meeting held on 18.02.2021 ratified the said

- 11 -

ordinance and recommended the same to be placed before the Syndicate having deliberated on the same, passed a resolution dated 21.02.2021 for approval of the said Ordinance. Few students have filed a writ petition in W.P.No.13626/2021 challenging the validity of the Ordinance dated 01.02.2021. The learned Single Judge vide its order dated 07.10.2021, allowed the writ petition and quashed the Ordinance dated 01.02.2021 and subsequently, directed the University - appellant to ensure to act according to the advice of the academic council committee before promulgation of next Ordinance and directed the University to conduct revaluation by applying the provisions of Ordinance dated 15.06.2012. The same Ordinance shall apply to those students where the 3rd valuation was done under the Ordinance dated 01.02.2021 along with various other directions. The appellant- University complied with the directions issued by the learned Single Judge in W.P.No.13626/2021 and announced the results. Meanwhile, the learned Single Judge in the case of VISHWEHWARA.C VS. REGISTRAR

- 12 -

(EVALUATION) RGUHS in W.P.No.9619/2021 and connected cases, upheld the Ordinance dated 01.02.2021 and consequently, dismissed the writ petitions. The learned Single Judge in the case of

M S. PRAGYA VS. RGUHS in W.P.No.9004/2022, held that the judgment dated 17.12.2021 in W.P.No.9619/2021 in case of Vishweswara (Supra) is per incurrium as previous judgment dated 07.10.2021 in W.P.No.13626/2021 is not referred. The appellant - University in compliance of the directions issued in W.P.No.9004/2022 in the case of Pragya (Supra), extended the same benefit to all similarly placed students of RS4 batch of February, 2022 examination and conducted 3rd valuation. On 07.06.2022, Syndicate meeting was held and it was resolved to consider the recommendation of academic council dated 20.04.2022. On the said date, no decision was taken as mandated under Section 35(4) of the RGUHS Act. The appellant - University announced the results of May 2022 supplementary examination of RS4 batch students of MBBS Course. The respondents - Students failed in the

- 13 -

said examination. The University adopted the procedure that the marks obtained in paper I and II are to be calculated and those who secure 50% aggregate have to be declared passed. It is contended that the appellant - University has not adopted the procedure as per the resolution of the academic council by calculating the highest marks out of two valuation is to be awarded by the examiner. The respondent - Students aggrieved by in action on the part of the appellant - University in not adopting the procedure as per the Ordinance dated 01.02.2021 of academic council, has filed the writ petition. The appellant - University has filed the statement of objections contending that, based on the directions issued in W.P.No.13626/2021 and connected petitions and the recommendation of the academic council, the meeting of the Syndicate was held and new Ordinance dated 05.09.2022 was passed and the petitioners are governed by the Ordinance dated 05.09.2022 and not as per the

- 14 -

previous Ordinance dated 01.02.2021 and sought for dismissal of the writ petitions.

The learned Single Judge after hearing the parties, allowed the writ petition filed by the respondent - Students vide order dated 09.11.2022 and directed the appellant - University to re-compute the results of the Students of MBBS (RS4) Examination conducted during May, 2022 in terms of the decision of the academic council of the respondent - University dated 20.04.2022 and further, directed the University to complete the entire exercise of re-computing the results within two weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order and announce the results, further directed upon revaluation of the results if the student becomes eligible to be promoted to the second year or third year course then such student shall be permitted to attend the classes of second year or third year of MBBS Course respectively, as the case may be. Further directed that such students shall be provided with make-up classes and such students who become

- 15 -

eligible for the second year or third year MBBS course, shall be treated on par with the present second year or third year MBBS course students. The University aggrieved by the order passed by the learned Single Judge in the aforesaid writ petition, has filed these writ appeals.

3. Heard Sri D.N.Nanjunda Reddy, learned Senior counsel appearing for Smt. Farah Fathima, for the appellant, Sri D.R.Ravishankar, learned Senior counsel for Sri Abhishek Patil for respondent - Students and Sri N.Khetty, learned counsel for the respondent - National Medical Commission.

4. Learned Senior counsel for the appellant submits that the University has issued Ordinance dated 01.02.2021. He submits that re-computation exercise cannot be done only for the petitioner as the other failed students may also ask for re-computation, then it will be a impossible and further such direction will create chaos in academic field. He submits that the learned Single Judge

- 16 -

substituted the decision of the Syndicate by its order by recommending the date of decision of the academic council. Further, he submits that in the absence of any Ordinance, the University is bound to follow the directions issued by the learned Single Judge in the case of

M S. SAHANA KALASAGOND, wherein the learned Single Judge while quashing the Ordinance dated 01.02.2021, directed the University to apply the provisions of Ordinance of 2012, wherever there is difference of 15% or more between the marks awarded by the two evaluators, the same shall be sent for third valuation. In case where third valuation was already done pursuant to the Ordinance dated 01.02.2021, nevertheless, revaluation shall be conducted even in such cases, in terms of the Ordinance of 2012. Further, he places reliance on the orders passed by the learned Single Judge. He submits that the learned Single Judge has merely relied on the Ordinance of academic council and has passed the impugned order. Hence, on these grounds, he prayed to allow the writ appeals.

- 17 -

5. Per contra, Sri D.R.Ravishankar, learned Senior counsel for the petitioner submits that the Ordinance dated 01.02.2021 are challenged before this Court in W.P.No.13626/2021 and connected matters. This Court vide order dated 07.10.2021 quashed and set aside the Ordinance dated 01.02.2021. The order of the learned Single Judge was complied with by the University. There was no Ordinance between 07.10.2021 to 20.04.2022 and admittedly, the petitioners have appeared for the examinations held in the month of May, 2022. He further submits that which is the scheme applicable for the examination conducted in the month of May, 2022, the University is silent on this aspect as to which Ordinance it was adhering for conduct of examinations of May, 2022. The Ordinance made by the academic council shall come into force from the date of approval by the Syndicate and reference was made to Section 35 of the RGUHS Act. He further submits that the said situation and decision of the academic council was considered by the learned Single

- 18 -

Judge. The University adopted the procedure of earlier Ordinance, which was quashed. Further, he refers to the observations made by the learned Single Judge in para No.13 i.e., suffice to say that the respondent - University ought to have adopted the procedure, as mentioned in the said deliberation that the decision to take highest marks out of two valuations shall be made applicable to the examinations commencing from 1stMay 2022, irrespective of the scheme of the examination. The interpretation of the law cannot be pre-judicial to the academic. W.P.No.13626/2021 order was accepted by the University. He submits that the respondent-University by applying the Ordinance of their choice is acting contrary to the earlier order passed by this Court. There is no anomaly while allotting marks. Therefore, the University has not adopted any appropriate formula. The students shall not suffer for the anomaly, but be benefited by the formula, whereby anomaly is removed. He submits that there is no illegality in the order passed by the learned Single Judge. He submits that every student shall stand to the game of the

- 19 -

order of the learned Single Judge. He further submits that Syndicate took a decision which is in verbatim of academic council and he submits that the order passed by the learned Single Judge is just and proper and does not call for any interference. Hence, on these grounds, he prayed to allow the writ appeals.

6. Learned counsel for the appellant in reply to the argument addressed by the learned Senior counsel for the petitioner submits that the Ordinance dated 01.02.2021 was struck down by this Court. Further, the University was directed to follow the Ordinance of 2012 and subsequently, the first examination was conducted in the month of February, 2022 by following the Ordinance dated 01.02.2021. He further submits that the learned Single Judge has dismissed the W.P.No.13312/2022 on 27.07.2022 in the case of M R. JORDAN RIDHYA RASQUINHA AND OTHERS VS. RGUHS AND OTHERS. Therefore, the University has followed the directions issued by this Court by following the Ordinance of 2012 and he further submits

- 20 -

that there was no Ordinance in the filed is unacceptable. Hence, on these grounds, he prays to allow the writ appeals.

7. Perused the records and considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the parties.

8. The academic council of Rajiv Gandhi University issued a notification dated 01.02.2021 relating to Central Assessment Program (CAT) for theory assessment of MBBS Course. The said notification was under challenge in the writ petition No.13626/2021. The learned Single Judge vide order dated 07.10.2021 had quashed and set aside the Ordinance dated 01.02.2021. Further directed the University that before promulgating the next Ordinance, the University shall ensure that the matter is placed before its Committee of academic council and to ensure to act according to the advise of the academic council and further directed to apply the provisions of Ordinance of 2012, wherever there is difference of 15% or more

- 21 -

between the marks awarded by the two evaluators, the same shall be sent for third valuation. In case where third valuation was already done pursuant to the impugned Ordinance, nevertheless, revaluation shall be conducted even in such cases, in terms of the Ordinance of 2012 (emphasis supplied). This shall apply not only to the petitioners, but to all the students, similarly situated. After the disposal of the said writ petition, the meeting of academic council Committee was held on 20.04.2022 and discussed about the formation of Ordinance governing Central Assessment Program (CAP) for theory paper assessment of all undergraduate, postgraduate and super speciality and all other courses in all faculty examination to the Rajiv Gandhi University. After deliberation, a resolution was passed that all the answer-scripts of undergraduate, postgraduate, super speciality and all other medical/dental/ayush etc., shall be subjected to two evaluations by the eligible examiner of the respective faculties through the digital valuation system. The highest of total marks awarded by the two evaluators for the

- 22 -

paper which is rounded of to the next highest shall be considered by the computation of the results. The marks awarded and the results so declared shall be final and under no circumstances further valuation shall be entertained, the said resolution shall be applicable for the examinations which were scheduled from 01.05.2022 onwards, irrespective scheme of examination or date of admission.

9. The appellant - University held examination for (RS4) batch students in the month of February, 2022 and in view of the subsequent order dated 17.12.2021 passed in W.P.No.9619/2021 i.e., in the case of V ISHVESWARA

(Supra), the appellant - University conducted the valuations in terms of the Ordinance dated 01.02.2021. Few students of RS4 batch, who failed in February, 2022, aggrieved by the evaluation done in terms of the Ordinance dated 01.02.2021 and not ordinance dated 15.06.2012, approached this Court in W.P.No.9004/2022 in PRAGYA (Supra), wherein the learned Single Judge of

- 23 -

this Court vide order dated 28.04.2021 held that subsequent judgment dated 17.12.2021 in W.P.No.9619/2021 is per incurium as previous judgment dated 07.10.2021 passed in W.P.No.13626/2021 is not referred and further reiterated the directions issued in W.P.No.13626/2021. In the said writ petition, this Court directed the University to conduct third valuation, wherein the difference in award of marks between two valuation was 15% and more, in terms of Ordinance dated 15.06.2012 to RS4 batch. Admittedly, the respondents are the students of RS4 batch. Pursuant to the judgment in

P RAGY (supra), the University conducted the revaluation process for failed students of February, 2022 examination in terms of the judgment passed in W.P.No.9004/2022.

10. The meeting of academic council was held on 20.04.2022, wherein the academic council recommended for evaluation process for all the examinations commencing from 01.05.2022. However, the said recommendation dated 20.04.2022 was neither approved

- 24 -

nor notified under any Ordinance by the Syndicate at any point of time. It is necessary to consider Section 35 of the RGUHS Act, which is extracted hereunder:

"35. Ordinances: (1) The Syndicate may, from time to time, make Ordinances and amend or repeal the same.

(3) In making an Ordinance the Syndicate shall consult,-

(a) the Boards of Studies in matters relating to the appointment and duties of examiners; and

(b) the Academic Council in matter relating to conduct or standard of examination or conditions of residence of students.

(4) Every Ordinance made by the Syndicate shall have effect from such date as

the Syndicate may specify, and every Ordinance so made shall be submitted to the

Chancellor and the senate for information."

11. Section 35(4) of the RGUHS Act provides that every Ordinance made by the Syndicate shall have effect from such date as the Syndicate may specify, and every Ordinance so made shall be submitted to the chancellor and the senate for information.

12. In the present case, the Ordinance dated 05.09.2022, specifically indicates that the said Ordinance

- 25 -

will come into force w.e.f. 01.09.2022. The said ordinance cannot be given retrospective effect.

13. The appellant - University conducted supplementary examinations in the month of May, 2022. The respondent-Students have appeared in the said supplementary examinations held in the month of May, 2022. The University conducted the valuation of the answer scripts of all the students in terms of the directions issued in W.P.No.13626/2021 and announced the results on 08.06.2022. The respondent - Students have failed in the said examination. Thereafter, they approached this Court in the writ petition seeking directions to the appellant - University to recompute the results of the failed subjects of MBBS (RS4) batch examination of May, 2022 by considering the highest marks awarded by the examiners cum amongst the valuation marks awarded, for the purpose of computation of the results, in terms of the decision of the academic council of the university taken on 20.04.2022, in the

- 26 -

absence of Ordinance applicable to the petitioners- students (RS4) and to announce the results afresh without delay. It is clear from the record that the academic council decision/ recommendation dated 20.04.2022 was not notified by way of Ordinance as mandated under Section 35 of the RGUHS Act. When the said Ordinance dated 20.04.2022 cannot be enforced for the examination of May, 2022 with retrospective effect. The meeting of the Committee of academic council was held on 25.08.2022, 26.08.2022 and 29.08.2022, wherein the Committee of academic council deliberated the issue raised in the previous academic council meeting dated 20.04.2022 and recommended the procedure for valuation of the examinations being conducted on or after 01.09.2022 for Medical along with other Courses. As observed above, the Ordinance dated 05.09.2022 notified under Section 35 RGUHS Act cannot be implemented with retrospective effect for the examinations held in the month of May, 2022 as the Ordinance dated 05.09.2022 came into effect from 01.09.2022. As the Ordinance dated 01.02.2021 was set

- 27 -

aside by this Court because it had not complied with the rigor of Section 35 of the RGUHS Act. Hence, the question of implementing the decision of academic council without approval of Syndicate under Section 35(3) of the RGUHS Act would not arise.

14. The learned counsel for the appellant has pointed out that few students of RS3 batch approached this Court for implementation of decision of the Committee of academic council dated 20.04.2022 in

W.P.No.13312/2022 for the examination held in the month of February, 2022. The learned Single Judge dismissed the said writ petition vide order dated 27.07.2022 and further observed that in the absence of Ordinance being issued by the appellant - University, the petitioner - Students cannot claim a mandamus to implement a mere resolution which recommends for a particular course of action.

15. Learned counsel for the appellant further brought to our notice that the similar students of RS4

- 28 -

batch who failed in the examination conducted in the month of May, 2022 filed a writ petition in W.P.No.14605/2022. The learned Single Judge vide order dated 06.09.2022, quashed the Ordinance of academic council dated 01.02.2021 and observed that the appellant - University by applying the provisions of Ordinance of 2012, shall conduct revaluation in terms of Ordinance dated 15.06.2012 for the May, 2021 examination and the new Ordinance is prospectively applicable from 01.09.2022 and the same cannot be retrospective for RS4 students out of their examination in May, 2022. The learned Single Judge in the aforesaid order at paragraph No.14, which is extracted hereunder:

"14. The material on record discloses that there is some dispute between the parties in relation to, whether a third valuation in terms of 2012 Ordinance has been conducted by RGUHS. Be that as it may, for the purpose of disposal of the present petitions, suffice it to state that the same deserve to be disposed of directing the respondent - RGUHS to conduct third valuation in respect of the petitioners, if not already conducted as on today as expeditiously as possible in terms of the Ordinance dated 15.06.2012 issued by the RGUHS; needless to state that the new Ordinance dated 01.09.2022 which came into force during the pendency of the present petitions would not be applicable, since the same is not retrospective in operation and would not apply to the

- 29 -

petitioners and other students who took their examinations in May, 2022."

The learned Single Judge failed to take note of the directions issued by this Court in W.P.No.14605/2022. The learned Single Judge in the impugned order has observed that pursuant to the decision of the academic council meeting dated 20.04.2022, the said recommendation was placed before 170thSyndicate meeting held on 07.06.2022 and the Syndicate had only resolved to consider the decision at the earliest. The learned Single Judge has erred in concluding that a decision was taken by the Syndicate on the said recommendation dated 20.04.2022, whereas in reality there was no decision taken by the Syndicate in 170thmeeting. The learned Single Judge as observed that the Syndicate meeting in its 170thmeeting has only resolved to consider the same at the earliest and there was no decision taken, has passed the impugned order. The university in the absence of the Ordinance of the Syndicate and directions issued by this Court in the case of W.P.No.13626/2021 dated 06.10.2021, applied the

- 30 -

provisions of Ordinance, 2012. The impugned order is contrary to the order passed in W.P.No.13312/2022 disposed of on 27.07.2022 and order passed in W.P.No.13626/2021, the learned Single Judge has committed an error in passing the impugned order without considering the earlier orders passed by the learned Single Judge. Hence, in view of the above discussion, we are of the opinion that the learned Single Judge has committed an error in passing the impugned order. Hence, we are inclined to interfere with the impugned order.

16. Accordingly, we proceed to pass the following:

ORDER

i. The writ appeals are allowed.

ii. The impugned order dated 09.11.2021 passed in W.P.No.16352/2022 c/w W.P.

Nos.16606/2022 and 20531/2022 are set aside.

iii. Consequently, the writ petitions filed by the petitioners are dismissed.

- 31 -

In view of disposal of the writ appeals, pending IAs., if any, do not survive for consideration and are accordingly disposed of.

Sd/-

CHIEF JUSTICE

Sd/-

JUDGE

SSB