Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Suchitra Dubey v. Sattar And Others

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Jun 30, 2023
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This Revision under Section 115 of the CPC was preferred by defendant No. 6/petitioner, aggrieved by the order dated 05.07.2022 passed by the 4 Additional District Judge, Indore in Civil Suit No. 31-A/2016. The order rejected defendant No. 6's application under Order 7 Rule 11 read with Section 151 of the CPC for rejection of the plaint.

The plaintiffs/respondents No. 1 to 3 instituted the suit on 11.03.2016 seeking declaration of their title to the suit lands, declaring the mutation in favor of defendants 1 and 2 and the sale deed dated 24.05.2006 in favor of defendant No. 3 as null and void, and for permanent injunction restraining defendants from interfering with their possession.

Defendant No. 6 filed an application on 06.05.2022 under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC for rejection of the plaint on the ground of limitation under Article 58 of the Limitation Act, 1963, alleging suppression of material facts by the plaintiffs, prior dismissal of two suits, and that plaintiffs neither have possession nor title. The trial Court rejected this application.

Subsequently, plaintiffs filed an application under Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC on 27.07.2022, which was not decided before the impugned order on the Order 7 Rule 11 application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial Court erred in rejecting the application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC without first deciding the pending application under Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC filed by the plaintiffs.
  2. Whether an application under Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC (for amendment of pleadings) should be considered prior to an application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC (for rejection of plaint).

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant No. 6's Arguments

  • The suit is barred by limitation under Article 58 of the Limitation Act, 1963, as per the plaint itself, requiring no evidence.
  • There has been suppression of material facts by the plaintiffs, including concealment of prior dismissed suits and prior proceedings decided in 2008-2009.
  • The plaint is vexatious, mischievous, and an abuse of process of law, and thus liable to be rejected at this stage.
  • Reliance on several Supreme Court decisions including Dahiben v. Arvindbhai Kalyanji Bhanusali, Khatri Hotels Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India, Howrah Daw Mangla Hat B.B. Samity v. Pranab Kumar Daw, and T. Arivandandam v. T.V. Satyapal.

Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • The impugned order rejecting the application under Order 7 Rule 11 is just and legal and does not require interference.
  • The claim is within limitation, which is a mixed question of fact and law requiring evidence.
  • Plaintiffs are in possession of the suit lands, and mutation is not proof of title.
  • The grounds raised by defendant No. 6 under Order 7 Rule 11 can only be considered at an appropriate stage, not at this stage.
  • An application under Order 6 Rule 17 filed on 02.07.2022 is pending and ought to have been decided before the Order 7 Rule 11 application.
  • Reliance on decisions of Delhi High Court in Rajesh Kumar Mehlawat v. Naresh Gupta, Punjab and Haryana High Court in Dera Baba Bhumman Shah Sangar Sarista v. Dr. Subhash Narula, and Bombay High Court in Gaganmal Ramchand v. Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation.

Defendant No. 3's Arguments

  • Supported defendant No. 6's submissions and the contention that the trial Court erred in rejecting the application under Order 7 Rule 11.
  • Relied on the same authorities as the contesting parties.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dahiben v. Arvindbhai Kalyanji Bhanusali (Gajra) (dead) through LRs, (2020) 7 SCC 366 Principles on limitation and rejection of plaint under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC Relied upon by defendant No. 6 to argue that suit is barred by limitation and plaint is liable to be rejected.
Khatri Hotels Private Limited v. Union of India, (2011) 9 SCC 126 Relevant principles on rejection of plaint and limitation Relied upon by defendant No. 6 in support of rejection of plaint.
Howrah Daw Mangla Hat B.B. Samity v. Pranab Kumar Daw, (2001) 6 SCC 534 Principle that mutation is not proof of title Used to support plaintiffs' claim that mutation does not prove title and plaint should not be rejected.
T. Arivandandam v. T.V. Satyapal, (1977) 4 SCC 467 Power of Court to allow amendment of pleadings under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC Relied upon to assert that amendment can be allowed to prevent rejection of plaint.
Rajesh Kumar Mehlawat Petitioner v. Naresh Gupta, 2017 SCC OnLine Del 9645 Order 6 Rule 17 CPC must be decided before Order 7 Rule 11 CPC application Held that an amendment application must be considered before rejection of plaint application; cited to direct trial Court to first decide amendment application.
Dera Baba Bhumman Shah Sangar Sarista v. Dr. Subhash Narula, 2020 SCC OnLine P&H 1625 Order 6 Rule 17 CPC to be decided prior to Order 7 Rule 11 CPC application Held that deciding Order 7 Rule 11 application before Order 6 Rule 17 application is illegal; relied on to set aside impugned order.
Gaganmal Ramchand v. Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation, AIR 1950 Bom 345 Power to amend plaint under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC not restricted by Order 7 Rule 11 CPC Held that amendment can prevent rejection of plaint; cited to support plaintiffs' right to amend before rejection.
Wasudhir Foundation v. C. Lal & Sons, 1991 Supp DRJ 483 Order 6 Rule 17 CPC is not controlled or restricted by Order 7 Rule 11 CPC Emphasized that amendment application should be considered to avoid unnecessary dismissal and fresh suit; applied to direct trial Court to consider amendment first.
Pramod v. Shantaram Balkrushna Dhok, (2017) 3 Mah LJ 223 Amendment application under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC should be considered on merits before rejection of plaint Supported the principle that amendment should be considered before deciding rejection application; applied in directing trial Court.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the procedural sequence of applications filed before the trial Court. Defendant No. 6 filed an application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC for rejection of the plaint on limitation grounds. Subsequently, plaintiffs filed an application under Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC for amendment of the plaint, which was not decided before the rejection application.

Relying on binding precedents, the Court held that the application for amendment under Order 6 Rule 17 must be decided first, as it is not controlled or restricted by Order 7 Rule 11. The Court emphasized that allowing amendment may obviate the need for rejection of the plaint and prevent unnecessary dismissal and fresh proceedings.

The Court found that the trial Court committed a jurisdictional error and material irregularity by deciding the Order 7 Rule 11 application without first deciding the pending Order 6 Rule 17 application. This procedural misstep warranted setting aside the impugned order and remanding the matter for proper sequential consideration of the applications.

The Court explicitly refrained from expressing any opinion on the merits of the case or the substantive claims, limiting its analysis to procedural correctness.

Holding and Implications

The impugned order dated 05.07.2022 is set aside. The trial Court is directed to first consider the application under Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC filed by the plaintiffs and, after its lawful decision, to reconsider the application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC in accordance with law.

The Court has not expressed any opinion on the merits of the suit. The decision ensures procedural propriety by mandating that amendment applications be disposed of before considering rejection of plaint applications. This prevents premature dismissal and unnecessary litigation delays.

No new precedent is established; the ruling enforces established procedural principles to safeguard the interests of justice and orderly conduct of civil proceedings.

Show all summary ...

Pranay Verma, J.:— This Revision under Section 115 of the CPC has been preferred by defendant No. 6/petitioner being aggrieved by order dated 05.07.2022 passed by 4 Additional District Judge, Indore in Civil Suit No. 31-A/2016 whereby her application under Order 7 Rule 11 read with Section 151 of the CPC for rejection of the plaint has been rejected.

2. The plaintiffs/respondents No. 1 to 3 have instituted an action on 11-03-2016 for declaration of their title to the suit lands, for declaration that mutation in favour of defendants 1 and 2 and the sale deed dated 24-05-2006 executed in favour of defendant No. 3 is null and void and for permanent injunction restraining the defendants from interfering with their possession over the suit lands.

3. On 06.05.2022 defendant No. 6 filed an application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC for rejection of the plaint on the ground that the same is barred by time as per Article 58 of the Limitation Act, 1963. There has been gross suppression of material facts, fraud and malice on part of plaintiffs. Two suits instituted by them earlier have already been dismissed as withdrawn in 2008 and 2009 respectively which fact has been concealed by them. The plaintiffs had instituted various proceedings before the Revenue Courts with respect to the suit lands which have already been decided in the year 2008-2009 itself. The plaintiffs are neither in possession nor have any title to the suit lands. The plaint is hence liable to be rejected. The plaintiffs contested the application by filing their reply to the same.

4. By the impugned order the trial Court has rejected the application by holding that the grounds which have taken by defendant No. 6 for rejection of the plaint are not sufficient. Plaintiffs are challenging a void sale deed and mutation is not proof of title. They have claimed to be in possession of the suit lands hence the plaint is not liable to be rejected.

5. Learned Senior Counsel for defendant No. 6 has submitted that the impugned order is illegal and contrary to law. The suit as per the plaint averments themselves is barred under Article 58 of the Limitation Act, 1963 and does not require any evidence to be led. The plaintiffs were always aware of the sale deed and the mutation entries in favour of defendants. The plaint is vexatious, mischievous and is an abuse of process of law and deserves to be rejected at this stage itself. Various public documents which have been filed by defendant No. 6 in this revision clearly demonstrate that the suit is barred by law. The plaint has to be read as a whole and not in isolation and when read in its entirety it leaves no room for doubt that the same is frivolous and vexatious. Reliance has been placed on the decision of the Supreme Court in Dahiben v. Arvindbhai Kalyanji Bhanusali (Gajra) (dead) through LRs, (2020) 7 SCC 366, Khatri Hotels Private Limited v. Union of India, (2011) 9 SCC 126, Howrah Daw Mangla Hat B.B. Samity v. Pranab Kumar Daw, (2001) 6 SCC 534, T. Arivandandam v. T.V Satyapal, (1977) 4 SCC 467 and various other decisions of the Supreme Court and of this Court on the same lines. 6. Per contra learned counsel for plaintiffs have submitted that the impugned order is perfectly just and legal and needs no interference. The claim is well within time which is even otherwise a mixed question of facts and law. The plaintiffs are in possession of the suit lands. The grounds raised by defendant No. 6 in her application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC can be considered only at the appropriate stage and not at this stage. In the alternate, it is also submitted that an application under Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC was filed by plaintiffs before the trial Court on 02.07.2022 which is still pending and the same ought to have been decided prior to deciding the application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC. In this regard, reliance has been placed on the decision of the Delhi High Court in Rajesh Kumar Mehlawat Petitioner v. Naresh Gupta, 2017 SCC OnLine Del 9645, of the Punjab and Haryana High Court in Dera Baba Bhumman Shah Sangar Sarista v. Dr. Subhash Narula, 2020 SCC OnLine P&H 1625, and Gaganmal Ramchand v. Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation, AIR 1950 Bom 345.

6. Learned counsel for defendant No. 3 has supported defendant No. 6 and has submitted that the trial Court has erred in rejecting the application filed by her. Reliance has been placed by him on the decisions which have been relied upon by the contesting parties.

7. I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the parties and have perused the record.

8. Though various submissions have been made by learned counsel for the parties on merits of the impugned order, but the record shows that on filing of application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC by defendant No. 6 on 06.05.2022, the plaintiffs filed an application under Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC on 27.07.2022. That application was admittedly not decided by the trial Court prior to passing of the impugned order deciding the application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC. The question which thus arises is as to whether the trial Court ought to have first decided the application under Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC filed by plaintiffs and only thereafter should have proceeded to consider the application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC.

9. In Dera Baba Bhumman Shah Sangar Sarista (supra) it was categorically held that the application under Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC has to be decided before the decision of the application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC. The order on application under Order 7 Rule 11 prior to decision of pending application under Order 6 Rule 17 is an illegality and that pending application ought to have been decided prior to decision on the application under Order 7 Rule 11. In Rajesh Kumar Mehlawat (supra) also it was held, though on the basis of concession, that the settled principle of law is that an application under Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC even if filed after filing of an application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC or before the order on such an application is pronounced, has to be considered first.

10. In Gaganmal Ramchand (supra) it was held that the power of the Court to allow amendment of pleadings should not in any manner be restricted or controlled by the provisions contained in Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC. Though it is incumbent upon the Court to reject the plaint that does not disclose a cause of action but it does not follow that it is not open to the Court to allow a plaint to be amended so that it should disclose a cause of action. The Court may prevent the operation of Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC and save the plaint from being rejected by exercising its power under Order 6 Rule 17. It was held as under:—

“Mr. Seervai's argument is that when a plaint comes before the Court and that plaint does not disclose a cause of action, it is mandatory upon the Court to reject that plaint and dismiss the suit and the Court has no power to permit the plaint to be amended In other words, Mr. Seervai's contention is that O. VI, r. 17, is controlled by O. VII, r. 11, and in cases falling under O. VII, r. 11, the Court has no jurisdiction to order the amendment of the plaint. I am unable to accept that contention. I see no reason whatever why the power of the Court to allow amendment of pleadings should be in any way restricted or controlled by the provisions contained in O. VII, r. 11. It is perfectly true that it is incumbent upon the Court to reject a plaint that does not disclose a cause of action, but it does not follow that it is not open to the Court to allow a plaint to be amended so that it should disclose a cause of action. It is only when a plaint does not disclose a cause of action that the Court is called upon to exercise its power under O. VII, r. 11. But the Court may prevent the operation of O. VII, r. 11, and may save the plaint being rejected by exercising its power under O. VI, r. 17, and allowing the plaint to be amended. It would indeed be an extraordinary proposition to lay down that if various averments had to be made in the plaint which would go to constitute a cause of action, and by some oversight or some mistake the plaintiff failed to make one of the averments, then in that case the plaint must be dismissed and the plaintiff could not apply for an amendment and make the necessary averment.

11. In Wasudhir Foundation v. C. Lal & Sons, 1991 Supp DRJ 483 it was held by the High Court of Delhi that Order 6 Rule 17 is neither restricted nor controlled by Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC. It was held in paragraph No. 5, 7 and 9 as under:—

“5. This is the righteous path and, if this be so is it not necessary, in the ends of justice, to extend the beneficial legal principles ensconced in Order 6 rule 17 More so, when one hardly discerns anything in Order 7 rule 11 which may lead one to take the view that it takes away the power of the court to allow amendment or places hurdles in performance of its duty? After all what is the effect of Order 7 rule 11? It is, if I understand correctly, that the plaintiff would not be precluded from filing a fresh suit in respect of the same cause of action if he so desires. See Order 7 Rule 13. If such be the effect, why not permit the amendment of the plaint so as to remove the defect and prevent the operation of the Rule? Why make him first invite the rejection of the plaint, then allow him to file a fresh suit at the expense of delay and heavy costs? Why not straightaway allow him to amend the plaint, remove the defect and permit him, thereby, to proceed with the same suit? Why this rigmarole? After all, procedural law is intended to facilitate and not to obstruct the course of justice.

7. The ouster of Order 6 rule 17 will throttle the very life line of Order 7 rule 11. Instead of promoting, it would defeat the ends of justice. I refuse to be a party to such an approach.

9. Order 6 rule 17 is thus held to be neither restricted nor controlled by Order 7 rule 11.”

12. Further more in Pramod v. Shantaram Balkrushna Dhok, (2017) 3 Mah LJ 223 it was held that application for amendment of plaint should be considered on its own merits before consideration of application for rejection of the plaint. It was held in paragraph No. 5 as under:—

“5. After considering the submissions made by the learned Advocates for the respective parties, I am of the view that the learned trial Judge has committed an error in rejecting the application (Exhibit No. 27) and refusing to consider the application (Exhibit No. 22) before considering the application (Exhibit No. 18). The provisions of Order VII, Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure lay down that if the plaint is rejected under Order VII, Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, then the plaintiff is not precluded from presenting a fresh plaint in respect of the same cause of action. Thus if the application (Exhibit No. 18) is decided first and the trial Court finds favour with the defendant, then the plaint shall be rejected and it would be permissible for the plaintiff to file fresh plaint including the proposed amendment in the pleadings. Thus, in my view, it will not serve any purpose by not considering the application (Exhibit No. 22) before considering the application (Exhibit No. 18). Of course the application (Exhibit No. 22) will have to be considered on its own merits according to law.”

13. The position which hence emerges is that the provisions of Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC are not restricted or controlled by provisions of Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC. Where an application under Order 6 Rule 17 is filed and is pending then the same ought to be decided first prior to decision on the application under Order 7 Rule 11. The same would be more so when the application under Order 6 Rule 17 is filed pursuant to filing of an application under Order 7 Rule 11 and intends to remedy the defects as pointed out in the said application. Such consideration of an application under Order 6 Rule 17 would be in the interest of justice. If there is some objection as regards maintainability of the claim and that objection is sought to be remedied by plaintiff by appropriately amending the plaint, then such amendment application needs to be considered first.

14. As per Order 7 Rule 13 of the CPC where a plaint is rejected under Order 7 Rule 11 then plaintiff is not precluded from presenting a fresh plaint in respect of the same cause of action. Thus, if the application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC is decided first and the plaint is rejected it would still be permissible for plaintiff to file a fresh plaint and including therein the proposed amendment in the pleadings. That would not serve any purpose but would only be a prolongation of the proceedings and shall result in unnecessary expenditure and delay for both the parties. It would be proper to permit amendment of the plaint so as to remove the defect therein.

15. The Trial Court hence ought to have first decided the application Under Order 6 rule 17 of the CPC filed by plaintiffs and thereafter only should have proceeded to decide the application Under Order 7 Rule 11 filed by defendant No. 6. In not doing so it has exercised its jurisdiction with material irregularity.

16. Thus, in view of the aforesaid discussion, the impugned order is set aside. The trial Court is directed to consider the application under Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC filed by plaintiffs and after lawful decision of the said application to reconsider the application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC in accordance with law. It is made clear that this Court has not expressed any opinion on merits of the case and the trial Court shall decide both the applications under legal parameters.

17. The Revision is accordingly disposed off.