Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M/S. SHREE LAKSHMI GARMENTS AND TEXTILES v. M/S. SRI SAI SILKS

Karnataka High Court
Jul 7, 2023
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from a Civil Revision Petition filed under Section 18 of the Small Causes Court Act, 1964, challenging an order dated 16.01.2023 passed by the XV Additional Small Cause Judge & XXIII ACMM, Bengaluru. The order rejected an interlocutory application filed under Order 7 Rule 10A read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) seeking to return the plaint on the ground of lack of jurisdiction. The petitioner contended that the suit should be filed in Surathkal, Dakshina Kannada District, as the defendant's business and payments were located there. The trial court held that the Bengaluru court had jurisdiction since the cause of action arose there, prompting the petitioner to file this revision petition before the High Court of Karnataka.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court erred in rejecting the application to return the plaint on the ground that it lacked jurisdiction under Order 7 Rule 10A read with Section 151 CPC.
  2. Whether the court at Bengaluru had jurisdiction to entertain the suit when the defendant's business and payments were at Surathkal, Dakshina Kannada District.
  3. Interpretation and application of Section 20(c) of the CPC regarding jurisdiction based on the place where the cause of action wholly or partly arises.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The trial court lacked jurisdiction to entertain the suit as the defendant carries on business and payments were made at Surathkal, Dakshina Kannada District.
  • The plaint should be returned and the suit should be filed in the courts at Surathkal, which alone have jurisdiction over the dispute.
  • Relied on the principle that jurisdiction lies where the defendant resides or carries on business and payments are made, supporting exclusive jurisdiction of Surathkal courts.

Plaintiff’s Arguments

  • The application to return the plaint was frivolous, vexatious, and intended to mislead the court.
  • The cause of action arose at Bengaluru, where the plaintiff's business is located and where the transaction took place.
  • Goods were supplied to the defendant’s place at Surathkal, but the contractual nexus and cause of action arose in Bengaluru, justifying jurisdiction of Bengaluru courts.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dashrath Rupsingh Rathod v. State of Maharashtra and another (2014) 9 SCC 129 Interpretation of Section 20 of CPC regarding jurisdiction; the court where the defendant resides, carries on business, or where cause of action arises; use of "or" in Section 20(c) allowing suit to be filed at any place where cause of action arises. The court held that the principles laid down in this judgment did not assist the petitioner, as Section 20(c) permits filing suit where cause of action arises, regardless of defendant’s presence.
Mohanakumaran Nair v. Vijayakumaran Nair 2006 SCC OnLine Ker 102 Jurisdiction under Section 20(a) and (b) of CPC; confers jurisdiction based on residence or business of defendant. The court found this precedent inapplicable as it did not address Section 20(c) of CPC, which was decisive in the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the jurisdictional challenge based on Section 20 of the CPC, particularly clause (c), which permits a suit to be filed where the cause of action wholly or partly arises. The trial court had found that although goods were delivered and payments made at Surathkal, the cause of action arose in Bengaluru where the plaintiff’s business is located and the transaction took place. The Court considered the petitioner’s reliance on jurisdiction based on the defendant’s place of business and payments but found that the use of the word "or" in Section 20(c) allows the plaintiff to file suit at any place where the cause of action arises, even if the defendant does not have a subordinate office there. The Court also reviewed the cited precedents and concluded that the principles therein did not support the petitioner’s claim for exclusive jurisdiction of Surathkal courts. Consequently, the Court found no error in the trial court’s conclusion that Bengaluru courts have jurisdiction over the suit.

Holding and Implications

The Court rejected the revision petition, thereby upholding the trial court’s order refusing to return the plaint on jurisdictional grounds.

The direct effect of this decision is that the suit shall proceed in the Bengaluru court, affirming that jurisdiction under Section 20(c) CPC can be based on the place where the cause of action arises, even if the defendant’s business or payments are located elsewhere. No new precedent was set beyond affirming the existing interpretation of Section 20(c).

Show all summary ...

- 1 -

NC: 2023:KHC:23448

CRP No. 368 of 2023

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

DATED THIS THE 7TH DAY OF JULY, 2023

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE H.P.SANDESH

CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO. 368 OF 2023 (SC)

BETWEEN:

1. M/S. SHREE LAKSHMI GARMENTS AND TEXTILES

OLD POLICE STATION ROAD,

SURATHKAL, MANGALORE, D.K.

REP. BY ITS PROPRIETOR

SRI MURALIDHARA

…PETITIONER

(BY SRI. VEERESH MAHESH UPPIN, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. M/S. SRI SAI SILKS NO.86-91, 3RDFLOOR,

MALAKALA MARKET, C.T.STREET,

BANGALORE-560002

REP. BY ITS PROPRIETOR

SRI SUDHAKAR PATANGE

S/O MARUTHI RAO PATANGE

AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS

…RESPONDENT

THIS CRP IS FILED UNDER SECTION 18 OF SMALL

CAUSES COURT ACT, 1964 PASSED ON I.A. IN

SC.NO.15079/2022 ON THE FILE OF THE XV ADDITIONAL

SMALL CAUSE JUDGE AND XXIII ACMM, BENGALURU,

REJECTING THE I.A. FILED UNDER ORDER 7 RULE 10 A R/W

SEC.151 OF CPC.

THIS PETITION COMING ON FOR ADMISSION THIS DAY,

THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING:

- 2 -

ORDER

This matter is listed for admission. Heard the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner.

2. In this revision petition, the defendant has challenged the order of rejection dated 16.01.2023 passed on I.A. filed under Order 7 Rule 10A read with Section 151 of CPC in S.C.No.15079/2022 on the file of XV Additional Small Cause Judge & XXIII ACMM, Bengaluru (SCCH-9).

3. The main contention of the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner/defendant before the Trial Court by invoking Order 7 Rule 10A read with Section 151 of CPC is that the Court is not having jurisdiction to return the plaint and direct to present the same before the jurisdictional Court contending that in the instant case the place at which the defendant is carrying on the business is at Surathkal, Dakshina Kannada District and payments were made at Surathkal, D.K., hence, the Courts of Surathkal, D.K., have sole jurisdiction to adjudicate on the dispute.

4. The plaintiff appeared and filed the objections statement contending that the very application is frivolous,

- 3 -

vexatious and with an intention to mislead the Court, the present application is filed. It is also contended, the plaintiff claimed that, the cause of action arose in M/s. Sri Sai Silks, No.86-91, 3rdfloor, Malkala Market, C.T. Street, Bengaluru-2 and goods supplied to defendant's place i.e., Surathkal is also true and correct. The transaction took place between parties in Bengaluru. Hence, the Court has got jurisdiction and the cause of action arises at Bengaluru. Hence, the application is not maintainable.

5. The Trial Court having considered the grounds urged in the application, extracted the provision of Section 20 of CPC and also considering the pleading made in the plaint that the cause of action arises at Bengaluru; in paragraph No.10 discussed the provision of Section 20(c) of CPC and rejected the contention of the defendant and came to the conclusion that the Court has got the jurisdiction. Hence, the present revision petition is filed before this Court.

6. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner would vehemently contend that the Trial Court has committed an error in rejecting the application when the goods are

- 4 -

supplied at Surathkal and also the payments are made at Surathkal, the Surathkal Court only has the sole jurisdiction and not the Bengaluru Court.

7. The learned counsel in support of his arguments he relied upon the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of

Dashrath Rupsingh Rathod v. State of Maharashtra and another reported in (2014) 9 SCC 129, and brought to the notice of this Court paragraph No.12, wherein, discussed with regard to the judicial approach on jurisdiction is concerned, held that the local limits of whose jurisdiction the defendant actually and voluntarily resides, or carries on business, or personally works for gain, or where the cause of action wholly or in part, arises and also discussed in detail that, a plain reading of Section 20 of CPC and also discussed the clause 20 (a),(b) and (c) and having taken note of clause 20(c), as the use of the word 'or' appears to permit the plaintiff to file the suit at any of the places where the cause of action may have arisen regardless of whether the defendant has even a subordinate office at that place. The principles laid down in the judgment will not come to the aid of the petitioner when taking into note of Section 20(c) of CPC.

- 5 -

8. The learned counsel also relied upon the judgment of the Kerala High Court in the case of Mohanakumaran Nair

v. Vijayakumaran Nair reported in 2006 SCC OnLine Ker 102, and also brought to the notice of this Court paragraph No.9 of the judgment with regard to the purpose of Section 20(a) which confers jurisdiction and also taken note of the jurisdiction under Section 20(a) and (b), but in paragraph No.9, not discussed anything about Section 20(c) of CPC. Hence, this judgment also will not come to the aid of the petitioner.

9. The Trial Court having considered Section 20(c) of CPC, when the supply is made from Bengaluru, the cause of action arises in Bengaluru, though delivery was made at Surathkal and the payments are made at Surathkal, but the cause of action arose at Bengaluru. Hence, I do not find any error in filing the suit before Bengaluru Court and no merit in the Revision Petition.

10. In view of the discussions made above, I pass the following:

ORDER

The revision petition is rejected.

- 6 -

In view of rejection of the petition, IA-1/2023 for stay does not survive for consideration, the same stands disposed of.

Sd/-

JUDGE

CP

List No.: 1 Sl No.: 45