Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ruchi Mishra v. State Of Madhya Prad...

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Jun 23, 2023
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Gurpal Singh Ahluwalia, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed a writ petition under Article 226 seeking, inter alia, (i) a mandamus directing respondents to decide/consider a representation (Annexure P/4); (ii) a mandamus directing respondents to relax or grant additional time for submission/provision of the CPCT Examination and to allow continuation of service at the current place of posting with consequential service benefits; and (iii) any other direction the Court deems fit.

The petitioner was appointed on compassionate grounds by an order dated 17.06.2019 subject to the condition that she obtain a Computer Diploma and a Computer Proficiency Certification Test (CPCT) certificate within three years from the date of appointment. She obtained the Computer Diploma in November 2020. She did not qualify the CPCT within the initial three-year period; by an order dated 24.11.2022 her probation was extended by one year to 17.06.2023 to enable her to clear the CPCT. The petitioner subsequently made a representation dated 09.06.2023 noting that she had cleared the Computer Diploma and seeking consideration/relief concerning the CPCT requirement.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conduct of the petitioner’s counsel in not disclosing that the petitioner had in fact appeared in the CPCT examination and had failed, and in instead asserting that no CPCT examination was conducted due to the COVID-19 pandemic, amounted to a bona fide omission or constituted suppression/misleading of material facts.
  2. Whether, in light of that conduct and the factual record (including the CPCT score card), the petitioner was entitled to the reliefs sought (extension/relaxation to allow continuation in service and consideration of the representation).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner was appointed on compassionate grounds but was required to obtain both a Computer Diploma and a CPCT certificate within three years of appointment.
  • The petitioner obtained the Computer Diploma (November 2020) but could not clear the CPCT within three years.
  • The petitioner’s counsel argued, during submissions, that no CPCT examination had been conducted by the department because of the COVID-19 pandemic, and that this justified relaxation/granting of further time.
  • The petitioner made a representation on 09.06.2023 (Annexure P/4), asserting she had cleared the Computer Diploma and seeking relief concerning CPCT requirements.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any specific arguments presented by the respondents.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bhaskar Laxman Jadhav v. Karamveer Kakasaheb Wagh Education Society, (2013) 11 SCC 531 Litigants must disclose all facts; mere partial or en passant references are insufficient. The Court relied on this authority to emphasize the obligation on litigants to make full disclosure and that incomplete disclosure is inadequate; used to support the view that the petitioner/counsel failed to make required disclosure.
Hari Narain v. Badri Das, AIR 1963 SC 1558 Litigants must eschew inaccurate, untrue or misleading statements; leave granted may be revoked if statements are inaccurate/misleading. Quoted to show established precedent that misleading statements warrant revocation of relief and justify refusal to grant discretionary relief; used to support dismissal for misleading the Court.
Ramjas Foundation v. Union of India, (2010) 14 SCC 38 (2011) 4 SCC (Civ) 889 Principle that a person who does not come to court with clean hands is not entitled to relief; courts must protect themselves from unscrupulous litigants. Applied to underscore that courts may refuse relief where a litigant misstates or suppresses facts; reinforced the proposition that unclean hands disentitle relief under Articles 32, 226 and 136.
Arunima Baruah v. Union of India, (2007) 6 SCC 120 Judicial review is discretionary; access to justice is a human right but discretionary remedies can be denied if litigant lacks clean hands. Used to balance the right of access to judicial redress with the discretionary refusal of equitable relief where suppression/misleading conduct is established.
Dwarka Prasad Agarwal v. B.D. Agarwal, (2003) 6 SCC 230 (referenced) Access to justice and related jurisprudence (contextual reference). Referenced in support of the general discussion on access to justice and the discretionary nature of writ jurisdiction; not separately applied beyond that context in the opinion.
Bhagubhai Dhanabhai Khalasi v. State of Gujarat, (2007) 4 SCC 241 (referenced) Referenced on access to justice and related principles. Referenced to support the principle that access to justice exists but equitable relief may be denied for non-disclosure or misleading conduct.
Zee Telefilms Ltd. v. Union of India, (2005) 4 SCC 649 (referenced) Referenced on the theme of access to legal redress. Referenced to underscore the human-rights concept of access to justice within the Court's jurisprudential discussion.
Dalip Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh, (2010) 2 SCC 114 Condemnation of falsehood, misrepresentation and suppression; litigants who "pollute the stream of justice" are not entitled to relief. Quoted and relied upon to demonstrate established judicial intolerance for misleading litigation conduct and to justify refusal of relief in such circumstances.
Welcom Hotel v. State of A.P., (1983) 4 SCC 575 A party which has misled the Court in obtaining an order is not entitled to be heard on the merits. Applied to support the proposition that misleading the Court can bar a party from further relief and justify dismissal.
G. Narayanaswamy Reddy v. Govt. of Karnataka, (1991) 3 SCC 261 Non-disclosure of interim orders/stay that bear on the matter amounts to suppression of material facts; discretionary relief liable to be rejected. Cited for the principle that suppression of material facts affecting adjudication warrants dismissal of discretionary relief; Court invoked it to show suppression is fatal.
S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu v. Jagannath, (1994) 1 SCC 1 Withholding an important document from the Court can justify throwing the party out at any stage. Referenced to illustrate severity of consequences where crucial material is withheld; used to reinforce the need for full disclosure.
Prestige Lights Ltd. v. State Bank of India, (2007) 8 SCC 449 High Court under Article 226 is a court of equity; party invoking writ jurisdiction must disclose all facts; suppression justifies refusal to entertain petition. Applied to emphasize the High Court's equitable power to dismiss a petition if facts are suppressed or distorted; reinforced dismissal in the present case.
R. v. Kensington Income Tax Commissioners, [1917] 1 K.B. 486 (CA) Classic English authority: applicants for ex parte relief must make full and fair disclosure of material facts; misleading affidavits justify refusal to proceed. Quoted and used as an authoritative source for the longstanding rule that ex parte or discretionary applications require full disclosure and that deception justifies refusal to proceed further.
Shri K. Jayaram v. Bangalore Development Authority, Civil Appeal No. 7550-7553 of 2021 (decided 08.12.2021) Reiterates that writ jurisdiction is extraordinary, equitable and discretionary and that petitioners must come with clean hands; non-disclosure can lead to dismissal at threshold. Referred to for the modern articulation of the clean-hands rule and the discretionary character of writ relief; used to justify refusal to grant relief where material facts are suppressed.
K.D. Sharma v. Steel Authority of India Limited (referenced) Reinforces that petitioners must come with clean hands when approaching extraordinary writ jurisdiction. Referenced as part of the jurisprudential foundation emphasizing the requirement of candid disclosure in writ petitions.
Hatton v. United Kingdom, [15 BHRC 259] (referenced) Referenced in the context of access to justice as a human right (international authority). Used as a contextual reference in the discussion on access to justice; not separately applied to operative facts of the case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in two interconnected strands: (A) assessment of the candour of the petitioner's pleadings and oral submissions; and (B) consideration of whether, on the facts and the relevant exercise of discretion, any relief could be properly granted.

A. On disclosure and candour:

  • The Court observed that the petitioner’s counsel repeatedly asserted that no CPCT examination had been conducted due to the COVID-19 pandemic, thereby seeking relaxation/extension on that basis.
  • However, the writ petition itself (paragraph 5.4) and documents filed by the petitioner included an admission that the petitioner had in fact appeared in the CPCT examination but had failed to qualify.
  • When directed to read paragraph 5.4, the petitioner’s counsel admitted that the petitioner had appeared in the CPCT examination and had not succeeded.
  • The petitioner had also filed the CPCT score card as Annexure-P/3, showing failure to qualify in Computer Proficiency and Typing Speed (English and Hindi), which contradicted the oral submission that no CPCT exam had been conducted.
  • The Court concluded that the counsel deliberately attempted to mislead the Court by claiming non-conduct of CPCT exams due to the pandemic when the pleadings and documents showed otherwise; this conduct amounted to suppression/misleading statements rather than bona fide omission.
  • The Court relied on established principles from the cited precedents — that parties approaching extraordinary equitable jurisdiction must come with clean hands, and suppression or misrepresentation of material facts disentitles them to discretionary relief — to find the petitioner’s position unacceptable.

B. On merits and relief:

  • The appointment on compassionate grounds was conditional: the petitioner had to obtain a Computer Diploma and pass CPCT within three years from appointment.
  • The petitioner did obtain the Computer Diploma (Nov 2020) but did not qualify the CPCT. The respondents had already extended probation by one year (to 17.06.2023) to facilitate the petitioner, but she still did not succeed in CPCT.
  • The petitioner’s counsel could not point to any discretion available to the authorities to further extend the probation or to relax the CPCT requirement for an additional year beyond the extension already granted.
  • Given the misrepresentation/misleading conduct and the lack of a demonstrated discretionary basis to grant further relief, the Court found no basis to grant the writs sought by the petitioner.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is dismissed.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the petitioner is denied the mandamus reliefs sought (consideration of Annexure P/4, relaxation/extension to permit submission of CPCT results, and continuation in service with consequential benefits) and the petition fails.
  • The dismissal is grounded both on the petitioner’s failure to comply with the conditional terms of appointment (failure to qualify CPCT despite extension of probation) and, importantly, on the finding that the petitioner’s counsel misled the Court by asserting that no CPCT examination had been conducted when the record showed the petitioner had appeared and failed.
  • The Court applied established precedent concerning the clean-hands doctrine and the discretionary nature of writ relief; the opinion does not purport to lay down any new legal principle or broader precedent beyond applying settled authorities to the facts of this case.

This summary is prepared strictly from the content of the provided opinion. Where the opinion did not provide specific information (for example detailed respondent submissions), that absence has been noted rather than inferred upon.

Show all summary ...

Gurpal Singh Ahluwalia, J.:— This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India has been filed seeking the following reliefs:—

“I. Issue a writ in the nature of mandamus directing the Respondents to decide/consider the representation of the Petitioner produced as Annexure P/4.

II. Issue a writ in the nature of mandamus directing the Respondents to relax/grant the time for submitting/providing the CPCT Examination and continue the services at present place of posting along with all consequential service benefit.

III. Issue any other writ, order or direction as this Hon'ble Court deems fit.”

2. It is submitted by the counsel for the petitioner that the petitioner was granted appointment on compassionate ground with a rider that she will have to obtain computer diploma and CPCT certificate within a period of 3 years from the date of appointment. The petitioner was given appointment on compassionate ground by order dated 17.06.2019. Although, the petitioner cleared her Computer Diploma Examination in the month of November, 2020 but she could not clear her CPCT Exam within a period of 3 years and accordingly by order dated 24.11.2022 the probation period of the petitioner was extended by a further period of 1 year i.e. 17.06.2023. It is further submitted by the counsel for the petitioner that because of Covid-19 Pandemic, the examination for CPCT was not conducted and, therefore, she could not clear the CPCT Examination. Thus, she has made a representation to the respondents on 09.06.2023 that she had already cleared Computer Diploma.

3. During the course of arguments, the counsel for the petitioner did not disclose that the petitioner had already participated in CPCT Examination but she could not succeed. But on the contrary, he was all the time was trying to pursue this Court by submitting that no CPCT examination has conducted on account of Covid-19 Pandemic. Accordingly, after conclusion of arguments by the petitioner, this Court directed the counsel for the petitioner to read out paragraph 5.4 of the writ petition. After reading out the said paragraph, the counsel for the petitioner admitted that in fact the petitioner had appeared in CPCT Examination but could not succeed. Thus, it is clear that the counsel for the petitioner had made every attempt to mislead this Court by submitting that no examination of CPCT was conducted by the department due to Covid-19 Pandemic, therefore, the petitioner could not clear the CPCT Examination.

4. The next question for consideration is as to whether this conduct of the counsel for the petitioner in not disclosing the correct facts and in making the misleading submissions that no examination of CPCT was conducted due to Covid-19 Pandemic can be said to be bonafide or it is a suppression of material fact.

5. In the representation Annexure-P/4, the petitioner has not claimed that no examination of CPCT was ever conducted by the concerning department.

6. It is really surprising that even in the representation dated 09.06.2023, the petitioner did not disclose that she had appeared in CPCT Examination but could not succeed. The petitioner has also filed the Score Card of Computer Proficiency Certification Test (CPCT) as Annexure-P/3 and it is clear that she could not qualify even in Computer Proficiency and Typing Speed of English Typing and Hindi Typing. Thus, the attempt made by the counsel for the petitioner that the examination of CPCT was not conducted is contrary to the pleadings as well as the documents.

7. The counsels are required to disclose all material facts during the course of arguments. It cannot be expected from the Court that it shall go through each and every word of the writ petition to find out as to whether the petitioner has a prima facie case or not?

8. Unfortunately, the counsel for the petitioner adopted a method which cannot be tolerated and made an attempt to mislead the Court by making a false statement that no examination of CPCT was ever conducted on account of Covid-19 Pandemic. Mere mention of “having failed in CPCT Examination” in the writ petition is not sufficient.

9. The Supreme Court in the case of Bhaskar Laxman Jadhav v. Karamveer Kakasaheb Wagh Education Society reported in (2013) 11 SCC 531 has held as under:

“44. It is not for a litigant to decide what fact is material for adjudicating a case and what is not material. It is the obligation of a litigant to disclose all the facts of a case and leave the decision-making to the court. True, there is a mention of the order dated 2-5-2003 in the order dated 24-7-2006 passed by the JCC, but that is not enough disclosure. The petitioners have not clearly disclosed the facts and circumstances in which the order dated 2-5-2003 was passed or that it has attained finality.

45. We may only refer to two cases on this subject. In Hari Narain v. Badri Das . [AIR 1963 SC 1558] stress was laid on litigants eschewing inaccurate, untrue or misleading statements, otherwise leave granted to an appellant may be revoked. It was observed as follows : (AIR p. 1560, para 9)

“9. … It is of utmost importance that in making material statements and setting forth grounds in applications for special leave care must be taken not to make any statements which are inaccurate, untrue or misleading. In dealing with applications for special leave, the Court naturally takes statements of fact and grounds of fact contained in the petitions at their face value and it would be unfair to betray the confidence of the Court by making statements which are untrue and misleading. That is why we have come to the conclusion that in the present case, special leave granted to the appellant ought to be revoked. Accordingly, special leave is revoked and the appeal is dismissed. The appellant will pay the costs of the respondent.”

46. More recently, in Ramjas Foundation v. Union of India [(2010) 14 SCC 38 : (2011) 4 SCC (Civ) 889] the case law on the subject was discussed. It was held that if a litigant does not come to the court with clean hands, he is not entitled to be heard and indeed, such a person is not entitled to any relief from any judicial forum. It was said : (SCC p. 51, para 21)

“21. The principle that a person who does not come to the court with clean hands is not entitled to be heard on the merits of his grievance and, in any case, such person is not entitled to any relief is applicable not only to the petitions filed under Articles 32, 226 and 136 of the Constitution but also to the cases instituted in others courts and judicial forums. The object underlying the principle is that every court is not only entitled but is duty-bound to protect itself from unscrupulous litigants who do not have any respect for truth and who try to pollute the stream of justice by resorting to falsehood or by making misstatement or by suppressing facts which have a bearing on adjudication of the issue(s) arising in the case.”

47. A mere reference to the order dated 2-5-2003, en passant, in the order dated 24-7-2006 does not serve the requirement of disclosure. It is not for the court to look into every word of the pleadings, documents and annexures to fish out a fact. It is for the litigant to come upfront and clean with all material facts and then, on the basis of the submissions made by the learned counsel, leave it to the court to determine whether or not a particular fact is relevant for arriving at a decision. Unfortunately, the petitioners have not done this and must suffer the consequence thereof.”

10. An attempt to mislead the Court during the course of argument is not an Advocacy. It is a jugglery, manipulation, manoeuvring or misrepresentation, which has no place in equitable and prerogative jurisdiction.

11. The Supreme Court in the case of Arunima Baruah v. Union of India reported in (2007) 6 SCC 120 has held as under:

10. On the one hand, judicial review is a basic feature of the Constitution, on the other, it provides for a discretionary remedy. Access to justice is a human right. (See Dwarka Prasad Agarwal v. B.D. Agarwal [(2003) 6 SCC 230] and Bhagubhai Dhanabhai Khalasi v. State of Gujarat [(2007) 4 SCC 241 : (2007) 2 SCC (Cri) 260 : (2007) 5 Scale 357].) A person who has a grievance against a State, a forum must be provided for redressal thereof. (See Hatton v. United Kingdom [15 BHRC 259]. For reference see also Zee Telefilms Ltd. v. Union of India [(2005) 4 SCC 649].)

11. The court's jurisdiction to determine the lis between the parties, therefore, may be viewed from the human rights concept of access to justice. The same, however, would not mean that the court will have no jurisdiction to deny equitable relief when the complainant does not approach the court with a pair of clean hands; but to what extent such relief should be denied is the question.

12. It is trite law that so as to enable the court to refuse to exercise its discretionary jurisdiction suppression must be of material fact. What would be a material fact, suppression whereof would disentitle the appellant to obtain a discretionary relief, would depend upon the facts and circumstances of each case. Material fact would mean material for the purpose of determination of the lis, the logical corollary whereof would be that whether the same was material for grant or denial of the relief. If the fact suppressed is not material for determination of the lis between the parties, the court may not refuse to exercise its discretionary jurisdiction. It is also trite that a person invoking the discretionary jurisdiction of the court cannot be allowed to approach it with a pair of dirty hands. But even if the said dirt is removed and the hands become clean, whether the relief would still be denied is the question.

12. The Supreme Court in the case of Dalip Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh reported in (2010) 2 SCC 114 has held as under:

1. For many centuries Indian society cherished two basic values of life i.e. “satya” (truth) and “ahimsa” (non-violence). Mahavir, Gautam Buddha and Mahatma Gandhi guided the people to ingrain these values in their daily life. Truth constituted an integral part of the justice-delivery system which was in vogue in the pre-Independence era and the people used to feel proud to tell truth in the courts irrespective of the consequences. However, post-Independence period has seen drastic changes in our value system. The materialism has overshadowed the old ethos and the quest for personal gain has become so intense that those involved in litigation do not hesitate to take shelter of falsehood, misrepresentation and suppression of facts in the court proceedings.

2. In the last 40 years, a new creed of litigants has cropped up. Those who belong to this creed do not have any respect for truth. They shamelessly resort to falsehood and unethical means for achieving their goals. In order to meet the challenge posed by this new creed of litigants, the courts have, from time to time, evolved new rules and it is now well established that a litigant, who attempts to pollute the stream of justice or who touches the pure fountain of justice with tainted hands, is not entitled to any relief, interim or final.

3. In Hari Narain v. Badri Das . [AIR 1963 SC 1558] this Court adverted to the aforesaid rule and revoked the leave granted to the appellant by making the following observations : (AIR p. 1558)

“It is of utmost importance that in making material statements and setting forth grounds in applications for special leave made under Article 136 of the Constitution, care must be taken not to make any statements which are inaccurate, untrue or misleading. In dealing with applications for special leave, the Court naturally takes statements of fact and grounds of fact contained in the petitions at their face value and it would be unfair to betray the confidence of the Court by making statements which are untrue and misleading. Thus, if at the hearing of the appeal the Supreme Court is satisfied that the material statements made by the appellant in his application for special leave are inaccurate and misleading, and the respondent is entitled to contend that the appellant may have obtained special leave from the Supreme Court on the strength of what he characterises as misrepresentations of facts contained in the petition for special leave, the Supreme Court may come to the conclusion that in such a case special leave granted to the appellant ought to be revoked.”

4. In Welcom Hotel v. State of A.P. [(1983) 4 SCC 575 : 1983 SCC (Cri) 872 : AIR 1983 SC 1015] the Court held that a party which has misled the Court in passing an order in its favour is not entitled to be heard on the merits of the case.

5. In G. Narayanaswamy Reddy v. Govt. of Karnataka [(1991) 3 SCC 261 : AIR 1991 SC 1726] the Court denied relief to the appellant who had concealed the fact that the award was not made by the Land Acquisition Officer within the time specified in Section 11-A of the Land Acquisition Act because of the stay order passed by the High Court. While dismissing the special leave petition, the Court observed : (SCC p. 263, para 2)

“2. … Curiously enough, there is no reference in the special leave petitions to any of the stay orders and we came to know about these orders only when the respondents appeared in response to the notice and filed their counter-affidavit. In our view, the said interim orders have a direct bearing on the question raised and the non-disclosure of the same certainly amounts to suppression of material facts. On this ground alone, the special leave petitions are liable to be rejected. It is well settled in law that the relief under Article 136 of the Constitution is discretionary and a petitioner who approaches this Court for such relief must come with frank and full disclosure of facts. If he fails to do so and suppresses material facts, his application is liable to be dismissed. We accordingly dismiss the special leave petitions.”

6. In S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu v. Jagannath [(1994) 1 SCC 1 : JT (1993) 6 SC 331] the Court held that where a preliminary decree was obtained by withholding an important document from the court, the party concerned deserves to be thrown out at any stage of the litigation.

7. In Prestige Lights Ltd. v. State Bank Of India . [(2007) 8 SCC 449] it was held that in exercising power under Article 226 of the Constitution of India the High Court is not just a court of law, but is also a court of equity and a person who invokes the High Court's jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution is duty-bound to place all the facts before the Court without any reservation. If there is suppression of material facts or twisted facts have been placed before the High Court then it will be fully justified in refusing to entertain a petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution. This Court referred to the judgment of Scrutton, L.J. in R. v. Kensington Income Tax Commissioners [[1917] 1 K.B. 486 (CA)], and observed : (Prestige Lights Ltd. case [(2007) 8 SCC 449], SCC p. 462, para 35)

In exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, the High Court will always keep in mind the conduct of the party who is invoking such jurisdiction. If the applicant does not disclose full facts or suppresses relevant materials or is otherwise guilty of misleading the court, then the Court may dismiss the action without adjudicating the matter on merits. The rule has been evolved in larger public interest to deter unscrupulous litigants from abusing the process of court by deceiving it. The very basis of the writ jurisdiction rests in disclosure of true, complete and correct facts. If the material facts are not candidly stated or are suppressed or are distorted, the very functioning of the writ courts would become impossible.

13. The Supreme Court in the case of Shri K. Jayaram v. Bangalore Development Authority decided on 08.12.2021 in Civil Appeal No. 7550-7553 of 2021 has held as under:

15. In K.D. Sharma v. Steel Authority of India Limited, it was held thus:

“34. The jurisdiction of the Supreme Court under Article 32 and of the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution is extraordinary, equitable and discretionary. Prerogative writs mentioned therein are issued for doing substantial justice. It is, therefore, of utmost necessity that the petitioner approaching the writ court must come with clean hands, put forward all the facts before the court without concealing or suppressing anything and seek an appropriate relief. If there is no candid disclosure of relevant and material facts or the petitioner is guilty of misleading the court, his petition may be dismissed at the threshold without considering the merits of the claim.

35. The underlying object has been succinctly stated by Scrutton, L.J., in the leading case of R. v. Kensington Income Tax Commrs.-[1917] 1 K.B. 486 : 86 LJKB 257 : 116 LT 136 (CA) in the following words : (KB p. 514) “… “…… it has been for many years the rule of the court, and one which it is of the greatest importance to maintain, that when an applicant comes to the court to obtain relief on an ex parte statement he should make a full and fair disclosure of all the material facts-it says facts, not law. He must not misstate the law if he can help it-the court is supposed to know the law. But it knows nothing about the facts, and the applicant must state fully and fairly the facts; and the penalty by which the court enforces that obligation is that if it finds out that the facts have not been fully and fairly stated to it, the court will set aside any action which it has taken on the faith of the imperfect statement.”

(emphasis supplied)

36. A prerogative remedy is not a matter of course. While exercising extraordinary power a writ court would certainly bear in mind the conduct of the party who invokes the jurisdiction of the court. If the applicant makes a false statement or suppresses material fact or attempts to mislead the court, the court may dismiss the action on that ground alone and may refuse to enter into the merits of the case by stating, “We will not listen to your application because of what you have done.” The rule has been evolved in the larger public interest to deter unscrupulous litigants from abusing the process of court by deceiving it.

37. In Kensington Income Tax Commrs. (supra), Viscount Reading, C.J. observed : (KB pp. 495-96)

“… Where an ex parte application has been made to this Court for a rule nisi or other process, if the Court comes to the conclusion that the affidavit in support of the application was not candid and did not fairly state the facts, but stated them in such a way as to mislead the Court as to the true facts, the Court ought, for its own protection and to prevent an abuse of its process, to refuse to proceed any further with the examination of the merits. This is a power inherent in the Court, but one which should only be used in cases which bring conviction to the mind of the Court that it has been deceived. Before coming to this conclusion a careful examination will be made of the facts as they are and as they have been stated in the applicant's affidavit, and everything will be heard that can be urged to influence the view of the Court when it reads the affidavit and knows the true facts. But if the result of this examination and hearing is to leave no doubt that the Court has been deceived, then it will refuse to hear anything further from the applicant in a proceeding which has only been set in motion by means of a misleading affidavit.”

(emphasis supplied)

38. The above principles have been accepted in our legal system also. As per settled law, the party who invokes the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court under Article 32 or of a High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution is supposed to be truthful, frank and open. He must disclose all material facts without any reservation even if they are against him. He cannot be allowed to play “hide and seek” or to “pick and choose” the facts he likes to disclose and to suppress (keep back) or not to disclose (conceal) other facts. The very basis of the writ jurisdiction rests in disclosure of true and complete (correct) facts. If material facts are suppressed or distorted, the very functioning of writ courts and exercise would become impossible. The petitioner must disclose all the facts having a bearing on the relief sought without any qualification. This is because “the court knows law but not facts”.

39. If the primary object as highlighted in Kensington Income Tax Commrs. (supra) is kept in mind, an applicant who does not come with candid facts and “clean breast” cannot hold a writ of the court with “soiled hands”. Suppression or concealment of material facts is not an advocacy. It is a jugglery, manipulation, manoeuvring or misrepresentation, which has no place in equitable and prerogative jurisdiction. If the applicant does not disclose all the material facts fairly and truly but states them in a distorted manner and misleads the court, the court has inherent power in order to protect itself and to prevent an abuse of its process to discharge the rule nisi and refuse to proceed further with the examination of the case on merits. If the court does not reject the petition on that ground, the court would be failing in its duty. In fact, such an applicant requires to be dealt with for contempt of court for abusing the process of the court.”

16. It is necessary for us to state here that in order to check multiplicity of proceedings pertaining to the same subject-matter and more importantly to stop the menace of soliciting inconsistent orders through different judicial forums by suppressing material facts either by remaining silent or by making misleading statements in the pleadings in order to escape the liability of making a false statement, we are of the view that the parties have to disclose the details of all legal proceedings and litigations either past or present concerning any part of the subject-matter of dispute which is within their knowledge. In case, according to the parties to the dispute, no legal proceedings or court litigations was or is pending, they have to mandatorily state so in their pleadings in order to resolve the dispute between the parties in accordance with law.

14. Apart from the misrepresentation, this Court is of the considered opinion that the petitioner has no merits in the case. Although, the petitioner was granted appointment on compassionate ground but it was a conditional order and petitioner was required to obtain Computer Diploma as well as to pass Computer Proficiency Certification Test (CPCT). Although, the petitioner successfully obtained Computer Diploma in the year 2020 itself but could not clear Computer Proficiency Certification Test (CPCT). The respondents had also extended the period of probation by 1 year in order to facilitate the petitioner to clear the CPCT, however, the petitioner could not succeed.

15. It is true that the petitioner had got an appointment on compassionate ground and present situation may be a heart burning situation but the counsel for the petitioner could not point out any discretion available with the authorities to extend the probation period by a further period of 1 year to enable the petitioner to clear CPCT Examination.

16. Under these circumstances, this Court is of the considered opinion that no relief can be granted to the petitioner.

17. Accordingly, the petition fails and is hereby dismissed.