Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

BMH Concare Technology Inc v. TECPRO SYSTEM LIMITED

National Company Law Tribunal
Feb 20, 2023
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The present Company Application (CA) was filed by M/s BMH Concare Technology Inc (Applicant), an Operational Creditor, under Sections 230-232 of the Companies Act, 2013, seeking approval of a Scheme of Compromise and Arrangement in respect of M/s Tecpro Systems Limited (Corporate Debtor), which is undergoing liquidation under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), 2016 since January 16, 2020. The Application was not filed by the Liquidator but by the Applicant creditor with the support of a non-applicant sponsor, M/s Kaira Power Private Limited. The Tribunal initially directed examination of the maintainability of the Application before considering its merits. Both parties were heard on the maintainability issue, and written submissions were allowed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a Scheme of Compromise and Arrangement under Sections 230-232 of the Companies Act, 2013, for a company under liquidation under IBC, 2016, can be filed by a creditor instead of the Liquidator.
  2. Whether compliance with Section 230(2)(c) of the Companies Act, 2013, requiring consent of 75% of secured creditors for schemes involving Corporate Debt Restructuring, is mandatory in the present case.
  3. Whether a scheme proposed and effectively controlled by a non-creditor sponsor, with a creditor applicant acting as a "dummy" propounder, is maintainable.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • Section 230(1) of the Companies Act, 2013 allows an application for a scheme to be filed by the company, any creditor, or member; the Liquidator is not the exclusive person entitled to file such an application.
  • Rule 3(3) of the Companies (Compromises, Arrangements and Amalgamations) Rules, 2016 requires service on the Liquidator only if the company is not the applicant; if the Liquidator files the application, no such service is needed.
  • The Scheme is not a Corporate Debt Restructuring but involves Financial Creditors, Operational Creditors, Shareholders, and Employees; hence Section 230(2)(c) is not applicable.
  • There is no bar on a non-applicant sponsor supporting the Scheme, and the Application is filed by an Operational Creditor.
  • The Liquidator provided comments and necessary documents for the Scheme, indicating cooperation and no delay in filing.
  • Reliance was placed on a prior decision in SIDBI vs Delicious Coco Water Park Ltd. to support the filing of the Scheme by a person other than the Liquidator.
  • Reliance was also placed on a NCLAT judgment (Atiuttam Prasad Singh Vs Utsav Securities) to argue that the Liquidator is not the exclusive person to file such applications.

Liquidator's Arguments

  • The Application is not maintainable as per the proviso to Regulation 2B of the IBBI (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016, which restricts filing such applications to the Liquidator only.
  • The Scheme involves Corporate Debt Restructuring, requiring consent of 75% of secured creditors under Section 230(2)(c) of the Companies Act, 2013, which was not obtained.
  • The Scheme is effectively controlled by the Sponsor, who is not a creditor, making the Applicant a mere proforma party; the Sponsor is not entitled to propose the Scheme.
  • Relied on Karnataka High Court judgment in S Krishna Murthy Vs Hoysala Building Development Company Pvt. Ltd. to support the proposition that a person not falling under categories specified in the Companies Act cannot propound the scheme.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
National Steel & General Mills Vs. Official Liquidator [MANU/DE/0265/1989] A scheme for a company under liquidation can be proposed by any member, creditor, or the company itself besides the Liquidator. Supported the Applicant's argument that Liquidator is not the exclusive person to file the scheme application under Companies Act, 1956/2013.
Arun Kumar Jagatramka Vs. Jindal Steel and Power Ltd. and Ors. (MANU/SC/0182/2021) Affirmed that scheme applications can be filed by creditors or members, not exclusively by Liquidator. Reinforced the principle that multiple parties can propose schemes even when company is under liquidation.
Bankey Bihari Infrahomes Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Aru Kumar Kuchchal & Anr. (Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) No. 718 of 2022) Confirmed that the Liquidator is not the exclusive person to file scheme applications. Applicant relied on this to argue maintainability of their application.
SIDBI Vs Delicious Coco Water Park Ltd [CP (113) 575 (ND) of 2017] Scheme of Compromise and Arrangement filed by a person other than Liquidator in liquidation context. Court found facts of that case distinguishable as the application was actually filed by the Liquidator, not a creditor.
S Krishna Murthy Vs Hoysala Building Development Company Pvt. Ltd. (Karnataka High Court, 21.03.2012) Only persons specified under the Companies Act can propound schemes; a person not a creditor or member cannot propose scheme. Supported Liquidator's objection that the Sponsor, not being a creditor, cannot propound the scheme indirectly via a dummy applicant.
S.K. Gupta v. K.P. Jain (1979) 49 Comp. Cas. 342 (Supreme Court) Only a creditor, member, or liquidator is entitled to file an application under section 391 (corresponding to section 230 of Companies Act 2013). Used to emphasize the eligibility to file scheme applications and reject applications by unauthorized persons.
Ramesh Kumar Chaudhary & Ors. Vs. Anju Agarwal & Ors., Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) No. 957 of 2021 For schemes involving Corporate Debt Restructuring, consent of not less than 75% of secured creditors is mandatory before filing the application. Applied to hold that the present Scheme, involving conversion of secured debt into equity, required such consent which was not obtained, rendering the application not maintainable.
Arcelor Mittal India Private Limited Vs Satish Kumar Gupta & Ors, Civil Appeal Nos.9402-9405 Of 2018 (Supreme Court) Resolution Professional's role is to examine and confirm prima facie eligibility of resolution plans under Section 29A of IBC, 2016. Used to highlight that in liquidation, the Liquidator must scrutinize eligibility of scheme propounders to ensure compliance with Section 29A and related regulations.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the statutory provisions under the Companies Act, 2013, the IBC, 2016, and related rules and regulations. It acknowledged that Section 230(1) permits a scheme application to be filed by the company, any creditor, or member, and that the Liquidator is an additional person entitled to file in case of winding up. However, the Court emphasized that the IBC 2016 and its regulations, particularly Regulation 2B of the IBBI (Liquidation Process) Regulations, impose restrictions confining the right to file such schemes to the Liquidator alone for companies under liquidation.

The Court found the Applicant’s reliance on precedents where the scheme was filed by persons other than the Liquidator to be factually incorrect, as in those cases the application was actually filed by the Liquidator. The Court distinguished the act of propounding a scheme from the act of filing an application under Section 230(1), holding that filing the application is a separate act that must be done by the Liquidator in liquidation cases.

Regarding the Scheme’s nature, the Court observed that the proposed Scheme involves conversion of secured financial creditors’ debt into equity shares, constituting Corporate Debt Restructuring. Under Section 230(2)(c) of the Companies Act, 2013, such schemes require prior consent of at least 75% of secured creditors. The Applicant failed to demonstrate compliance with this mandatory condition, and no affidavit or list of secured creditors was filed.

The Court also scrutinized the role of the Sponsor, a non-creditor, who was effectively controlling the Scheme, while the Applicant creditor was merely a "dummy" propounder to meet eligibility requirements. This arrangement was found to be impermissible as the Sponsor is neither a creditor nor a member, and cannot propound the Scheme indirectly bypassing the Liquidator.

Finally, the Court underscored the importance of the Liquidator’s role in scrutinizing the eligibility of the scheme propounder under Section 29A of the IBC, 2016, ensuring compliance with the law and preventing circumvention of statutory safeguards. Since the Applicant filed the Scheme bypassing the Liquidator, no such scrutiny was possible, further rendering the application not maintainable.

Holding and Implications

The Tribunal dismissed the Company Application No. CA (CAA) 74(ND)/2021 as not maintainable.

The direct consequence is that the Scheme of Compromise and Arrangement proposed by the Operational Creditor, supported by a non-creditor Sponsor, cannot proceed without being filed through the Liquidator, who is the only authorized person to file such applications for companies under liquidation under the IBC, 2016. The decision clarifies that compliance with Section 230(2)(c) is mandatory for schemes involving Corporate Debt Restructuring, including obtaining consent of 75% of secured creditors. The ruling does not create new precedent but reinforces the existing legal framework governing scheme filings in liquidation contexts, emphasizing the Liquidator’s exclusive role and the necessity of statutory compliance to maintain the integrity of the liquidation process.

Show all summary ...

CA. (CAA) 74(ND)/2021 Tecpro Systems Ltd. and Kaira Power Ltd. Page 1 of 30

NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL

NEW DELHI BENCH (COURT-II) Company Application No. CA (CAA) 74(ND)/2021

IN THE MATTER OF:

1. Tecpro Systems Limited (in Liquidation)

Registered office at :

Vishwadeep Tower, Plot No. 4, District Centre, Janakpuri, New Delhi - 110058

… Non-Applicant/ Corporate Debtor

2. M/s BMH Concare Technology Inc

Office at :

Plot No. 56, Shiravane Service Industrial Area, Sector No. 1, Nerul (East), Navi Mumbai, Maharashtra - 400706

… Applicant/ Operational Creditor

3. Kaira Power Private Limited

Registered office at :

C-273, First Floor, Sector - 63,

Noida - 201301

… Non-Applicant/ Sponsor of the Scheme Order Delivered on: 20.02.2023 Section: 230 to 232 of the Companies Act, 2013

CORAM:

SH. ASHOK KUMAR BHARDWAJ, HON'BLE MEMBER (J) SH. L. N. GUPTA, HON'BLE MEMBER (T)

PRESENT:

For the Applicant : Adv. Rajeev K. Goel, Adv. Kartikeya Goel

For the Liquidator : Adv. Anurag Bhatt, Adv. Lokesh Pathak, Adv. Vaibhav Vijayvargiay

1

ORDER

PER: SH. L. N. GUPTA, MEMBER (TECHNICAL)

The present Company Application (CA) is preferred by M/s. BMH Concare Technology Inc (hereinafter, referred to as the "Applicant") under Section 230-232 of Companies Act, 2013, seeking approval of Scheme of Compromise and Arrangement in respect of M/s Tecpro Systems Limited (hereinafter, referred to as the "Company/ Corporate Debtor"), which is a Company undergoing Liquidation under the provisions of IBC, 2016 in IB - 197/PB/2017 since 16.01.2020.

2. During the preliminary hearing, it was noticed that the present Application is not preferred through Liquidator of the Corporate Debtor, rather it is preferred by the Applicant M/s BMH Concare Technology Inc.,

one of the Creditors, with the support of a non-Applicant namely, M/s Kaira Power Private Limited, stated to be the sponsor of the Scheme. Hence, before considering the Application on merits, it was observed vide order dated 22.12.2022 to examine the maintainability of the present Application. Accordingly, arguments of the parties were heard on maintainability of the Application on 23.12.2022 and 10.01.2023 and order was reserved. Further, both the parties were given liberty to file their written synopsis of arguments on maintainability of the present Application.

3. To establish that the present Application is maintainable, the Ld. Counsel for the Applicant argued the following and reiterated the same in its Written Submissions filed on the DMS:

2

3.1 In terms of the provisions of Section 230(1) of the Companies Act, 2013, the Application for Scheme of Compromise or Arrangement can be preferred by the Company or any Creditor or Member of the Company. Further, in the case of a Company which is being wound up, the Application can also be made by the Liquidator, being an additional person. However, Liquidator is not to be the exclusive person for preferring such an application. This intention of the Legislation is absolutely clear from the procedure as laid down under Section 230 of the Act and the Rules made thereunder.

3.2 The Rule 3(3) of the Companies (Compromises, Arrangements and Amalgamations) Rules, 2016 provides that where the company is not the applicant, a copy of the notice of admission and of the affidavit shall be served on the company, or, where the company is being wound up, on its liquidator, not less than fourteen days before the date fixed for the hearing of the notice of admission. If Application is filed by the liquidator, there is no need for the service of the Application on the Liquidator.

3.3 Section 230(6) of the Act provides the effect of approval of Scheme. Where at a meeting held in pursuance of Subsection (1), majority of persons representing three-fourths in value of the creditors, or class of creditors or members or class of members, as the case may be, voting in person or by proxy or by postal ballot, agree to any compromise or arrangement and if such compromise or arrangement is sanctioned by the Tribunal by an order, the same shall be binding on the company, all the creditors, or class of creditors or members or class of members, as the case may be, or, in case

3

of a company being wound up, on the liquidator and the contributories of the company.

3.4 Regulation 2(B)(3) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016 provides that any cost incurred by the liquidator in relation to compromise or arrangement shall be borne by the corporate debtor, where such compromise or arrangement is sanctioned by the Tribunal under sub-section (6) of section 230. Provided that such cost shall be borne by the parties who proposed compromise or arrangement, where such compromise or arrangement is sanctioned by the Tribunal under sub-section (6) of section 230. The aforesaid provision also indicates that the Compromise or Arrangement can be proposed by the members or creditors, etc., in addition to the Liquidator.

3.5 It is pertinent to mention that the Companies Act, 1956 also had the similar provision with regard to filing of an Application for a Scheme. The wordings of Section 230(1) of the Companies Act, 2013 are similar to that of the Section 391(1) of the Companies Act, 1956. There are number of decisions by various High Courts upholding the view that a Company which is under liquidation, an Application for a Scheme can be proposed by any member or creditor in addition to the Liquidator. A Comprehensive decision was taken by the Division Bench of the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in the matter of National Steel & General Mills Vs. Official Liquidator [MANU/DE/0265/1989], which considered this question and discussed various Orders passed by different High Courts in this regard. It was held that the petition seeking permission to the scheme of arrangement, could

4

be moved by any member, creditor or the company itself besides the liquidator. Similar view has been taken by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of Arun Kumar Jagatramka Vs. Respondent: Jindal Steel and Power Ltd. and Ors. (MANU/SC/0182/2021) and by the Hon'ble NCLAT, New Delhi in the matter of Bankey Bihari Infrahomes Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Aru Kumar Kuchchal & Anr. (Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) No. 718 of 20221.

3.6 In the matter of SIDBI Vs Delicious Coco Water Park Ltd [CP No.

(113) 575 (ND) of 2017], a similar Scheme of Compromise and Arrangement was filed by a person other than the Liquidator with respect to a Company which was under liquidation. This Bench passed necessary directions for convening of meetings under the provisions of Section 230 of the Companies Act, 2013.

3.7 The instant Application has been made by an Operational Creditor of Tecpro Systems Ltd, namely, M/s BMH Concare Inc. The said fact is very much clear from the Memo of Parties filed along with the 1st motion Company Application, as well as from the cause title of the Application. Whereas, Kaira Power Pvt. Ltd. is only supporting the Application as a sponsor of the Scheme and is not an Applicant. It may be noted that there is no bar for any person to support a Scheme of Compromise and Arrangement.

3.8 Notice inviting expression of interest was published/issued by the liquidator on 24thMarch 2021. The proposed Scheme of Compromise and Arrangement was circulated to the Liquidator for his comments in the

5

month of 31stMay, 2021. Subsequently, after deliberation and consultation the Liquidator provided his comments on the Scheme, which were duly incorporated by the Applicant in the Scheme.

3.9 The Applicant subsequently requested the Liquidator to provide certain documents such as the Audited Balance Sheet of the Company, etc. which was required to be filed along with the Application, and the Liquidator has provided such documents to the Applicant. Accordingly, once all the necessary documents are collated by the Applicant, the Application along with the Scheme has been filed with this Tribunal. Further, it is submitted that there is no delay in filing of the Scheme in terms of the provisions of Regulation 2B of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016.

3.10 Compliance of Section 230(2)(c) of the Companies Act is not required to be made in the present case, as the Scheme proposed is not in the nature of Corporate Debt Restructuring. It is submitted that a Scheme for Corporate Debt Restructuring is only between the Company and its Secured Creditors. However, the present Scheme of Compromise and Arrangement is between the Company & its Financial Creditors, Operational Creditors, Shareholders and Employees. Accordingly, approval from Financial Creditors and Operational Creditors on the Scheme is only required in terms of provisions of Section 230(6) of the Companies Act, 2013.

4. Though the Liquidator has not filed its written submissions, its reply to the present CA is on record, in which the Liquidator has raised the issue of maintainability of the present application. Since we are only adjudicating

6

the maintainability of the present Application, we will consider reply of the Liquidator to the extent relating to maintainability of the application. The submissions of the Liquidator on maintainability as made in its reply and during the hearing, in nutshell, are reflected below:

4.1 The present application is not maintainable in terms of proviso to Regulation 2B of IBBI (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016, since only the Liquidator is entitled to file such an application. The contents of the Regulation are reproduced below:

4.2 The present Scheme of Compromise and Arrangement involves Corporate Debt Restructuring. Hence, the Applicant was required to comply with the provisions of Section 230(2)(c) of Companies Act, 2013 by obtaining consent of 75% the secured Creditors in value, which is not obtained in the instant case.

7

4.3 The present Scheme has been funded by the Sponsor of the Scheme, who is not the Creditor of the Corporate Debtor. The Operational Creditor is merely a Proforma party and all the major acts will be executed through sponsor. Since the Sponsor is not the Creditor of the Corporate Debtor, it is not entitled to propose the Scheme. The Liquidator has relied upon the Judgement of the Karnataka High Court in the matter of "S Krishna Murthy Vs Hoysala Building Development Company Pvt. Ltd." dated 21.03.2012, wherein the following is observed:

"10. In that backdrop, a perusal of the scheme of arrangement (Annexure C) which is very brief would indicate that the said pleading is also reflected in the scheme so as to state the Sri Varaha Venkatesh is the main propounder though the name of Sri S. Krishnamurthy i.e., the first applicant representing the investors in the flats is also shown in tabular representation. The fact that the said Sri Varaha Venkatesh who is the propounder of the scheme does not belong to any one of the categories contemplated in section 391 of the Act in relation to the company is evident inasmuch as the petitioners themselves have subsequently deleted his name from the instant petition. However, no change has been made in the scheme and the fact that he is the person who would be bringing in the money remains un-altered though presently petitioner Nos. 2 to 5 have been impleaded to the petition. In fact, the response filed on behalf of the Regional Director has also raised the said question of a person other than the one contemplated under section 391 of the Act having propounded the scheme as the same is not permissible in law. It is no doubt true that the money to be brought in by such person would be beneficial to a class of creditors inasmuch as they would receive the amount due from the company but the question is whether such scheme is in

8

compliance of law and whether this Court can grant its seal of approval unmindful of the interest of the company or the shareholders and above all, if it is contrary to public policy.

11. In fact, a similar scheme had arisen for consideration before this Court in the case of Sri Kashinath Dikshit v. Surgicals & Pharmaceuticals Company (Mysore) Limited AIR 2003 Kar. HCR (NOC) 55, except that the first petitioner therein was a shareholder. In the said case, the relevant contention (which is similar to the instant case) while opposing the scheme was as hereunder.

"10. The official liquidator attached to this Court has filed his objections opposing the scheme of arrangement propounded by the petitioners. Apart from others, the primary objection of the official liquidator seems to be that though the first petitioner is a member of the company in liquidation is not the propounder of the scheme and the second petitioner, who seems to be the propounder of the scheme is neither the shareholder nor the creditor of the company in liquidation and therefore the request made in the petition for approval of the scheme of arrangement is not maintainable under section 391 of the Act, since under that provision, an application/petition can be filed for sanction of the scheme of arrangement either by a creditor or a member of the company in liquidation or by the official liquidator. The second objection seems to be that the first petitioner has not demonstrated before this Court that on his own how he would revive the company in liquidation and therefore, the arrangement is not a real arrangement for revival of the company in liquidation and it only a ruse to sell the assets of the company to the second petitioner for a

9

price. Therefore, requests this Court not to grant the relief claimed in the petition."

12. The Court on taking note of the above contention in the background of the law, with reference to the scheme has answered as hereunder:

"17. Petitioners have produced a copy of the scheme of arrangement, which they want it to be sanctioned by this Court. In that, it is stated that one of the shareholders of the company as on the date of winding up order, namely, one Sri Kashinath Dikshit has identified Sri N.J. Patel with a view to revive the company, and the said person is willing to settle the claims of the creditors of the company with a view to revive the company provided the entire share capital of the company is transferred to him and to his nominees in consideration of his settling the claims of the creditors of the company."

18. One of the shareholders of the company in liquidation is the first petitioner in this company petition. He has identified the second petitioner to revive the company in liquidation. This clearly shows that he is not the propounder of the scheme of arrangement for revival of the company. The second petitioner is neither a member nor a creditor of the company. He is willing to settle the claims of the creditors of the company with a view to revive the company in liquidation, provided the entire share capital of the company is transferred in his favour and his nominees. In order to attract section 391 of the Act, it is necessary that a compromise or arrangement between a company and its creditors or any class of them, or between the company or its members or class of them should propose a compromise or arrangement When such a scheme is proposed, and the sanction is requested, the Court will have to be satisfied

10

as to the prima facie, that the scheme of arrangement is genuine, bona fide and would be in the interest of the company and its creditors and the application is filed by a person, who is authorised under the provisions of section 391 of the Act. The Apex Court in the case of S.K. Gupta v. K.P. Jain reported in (1979) 49 Comp. Cas. 342, while considering the scope of section 391(1) of the Act and who can move the application under that section was pleased to observe:

Section 391 enables a member or a creditor of the company or a company which is being wound up, its liquidator, to make an application to the court proposing a compromise or arrangement between the company and its creditors or any class of them or between the company and its members or any class of them and seeking directions of the Court to convene a meeting of each class of creditors and/or each class of members to whom the compromise or arrangement is offered. On the Court's giving the directions, the meeting would be convened in which the proposed scheme of compromise and/or arrangement would be submitted for consideration and each class will have to vote upon it and if the scheme is accepted by a majority in number representing three-fourths in value of the creditors or members or class of members, as the case may be, present and voting either in person or where proxy is allowed, by proxy, such approved scheme has to be placed before the Court for sanction of the Court as envisaged in section 391(2).

19. The Court was further pleased to observe:

"Section 391(1) itself by a specific and positive provision prescribes, who can move an application under it. Only the creditor or member of that company

11

or a liquidator in the case of company being wound up is entitled to move an application proposing compromise or arrangement. By necessary implication any one other than those specified in the section would not be entitled to move such an application.

20. The second petitioner, who is the propounder for the sanction of scheme of arrangement is neither a member nor a creditor of the company. He has no interest in the affairs of the company. He has only come forward to purchase the assets and liabilities of the company in liquidation by filing an application styled one under section 391 of the Act. The first petitioner though a member of the company in liquidation, is not the propounder under the scheme. He is only an intermediary in assisting the second petitioner to purchase the assets of the company in liquidation. Therefore, in my opinion, the petition filed for sanction of scheme of arrangement is not maintainable under section 391 of the Act."

5. After hearing submissions of both the parties, this Bench observes that the Liquidator has objected to the maintainability of the present Application on the following grounds:

a) In terms of Proviso to Regulation 2B of IBBI (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016, only the Liquidator is entitled to prefer an application for approval of the Scheme.

b) The present Scheme of Compromise and Arrangement involves Corporate Debt Restructuring and the Applicant has not obtained

12

consent of 75% of Secured Creditors, in value, as required in terms of Section 230(2)(c) of the Companies Act, 2013.

c) The Scheme is effectively executed through the Sponsor, who is not the Creditor of the Corporate Debtor and therefore, is not entitled to present the Scheme.

6. Per Contra, the Applicant has stated that the present Application is maintainable on the following grounds -

a) Under Section 230(1) of the Companies Act 2013, a Creditor is entitled to file an Application seeking approval of Scheme, despite the fact the Company is under Liquidation process under

IBC, 2016.

b) The present Scheme of Compromise and Arrangement is not in the nature of Corporate Debt Restructuring and it is a Scheme between the Company and its Financial Creditors, Operational Creditors, Shareholders and Employees. Hence Section 230(2)(c) is not applicable to the present case.

c) There is no bar on the Sponsor to support the Scheme and moreover, the present Application is preferred by an Operational Creditor.

7. We would like to examine the contentions of both the parties. The Applicant, inter alia, has relied upon the Judgement of this Bench passed in the matter of "SIDBI vs Delicious Coco Water Park Ltd." [CP no. 575 (ND) of 2017] to demonstrate that in that case too, the Scheme of

13

Compromise and Arrangement in respect of a Company under liquidation, was filed by a person other than the Liquidator. When we refer to the facts of that case, we find this submission of the Applicant factually incorrect and misleading. As a matter of fact, the Application for approval of the Scheme of Compromise and Arrangement in that matter of "SIDBI vs Delicious Coco Water Park Ltd.", was preferred by the Liquidator itself. Whereas the present Application, in respect of a Company under liquidation, is filed through a Creditor. Hence, the facts of the present case are at clear variance from the facts of "SIDBI vs Delicious Coco Water Park Ltd." The relevant extracts of the order dated 09.11.2022 in IA 2308 of 2022 in IB-575/ND/2017 are reproduced below:

"The present IA. No. 2308 of 2022 is filed by Mr. K.G Somani, Liquidator of the Corporate Debtor M/s. Delicious Coco Water Private Limited (the 'Applicant/ Liquidator') under Section 230 of the Companies Act, 2013 read with Section 60(5) of IBC, 2016, read with Regulation 2B of IBBI (Liquidation Process) regulations, 2016."

…..

8. Similarly, the Applicant has also relied upon the Judgement of Hon'ble NCLAT passed in the matter of Atiuttam Prasad Singh Vs Utsav Securities (P.) Ltd. Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) No.124 of 2022 to demonstrate that the Liquidator is not the exclusive person to file the Application for approval of scheme of compromise and arrangement. When we refer to the facts of that case, we find again the contention of the Applicant untrue and misleading. On perusal of the memo of I.A 4116/ND/2021 in CP(IB) 2260(ND) of 2019 (reproduced below for

14

immediate reference), available on DMS of this Tribunal, we discovered that the said Application for approval of Scheme under Section 230-232, as a matter of fact, was preferred by the Liquidator itself.

9. Since in that case, the Scheme was propounded by an Independent Director and his eligibility was under challenge, the Hon'ble NCLAT found that the said Independent Director was not disqualified under Section 29A to propose the scheme of Compromise and Arrangement. Whereas we have never questioned the eligibility of the Creditor to propound the Scheme, the issue here is regarding the eligibility of the Creditor to file an application (before this Tribunal) bypassing the Liquidator, as in our view, propounding the scheme and preferring an application for approval under Section 230(1) of the Companies Act 2013, for a Company which is under Liquidation under the ambit of IBC 2016, are two different acts.

15

10. We would now, like to examine the contention of the Applicant that Compliance of Section 230(2)(c) of the Companies Act, 2013 is not required to be made in the present case, as the Scheme proposed is not in the nature of Corporate Debt Restructuring and there is no debt restructuring taking place with the Secured Financial Creditors, therefore Section 230(2)(c) of Companies Act, 2013 is not applicable to the present case.

11. At this juncture, we consider it appropriate to refer to Section 230(2) of Companies Act, 2013, the contents of which are reproduced below:

12. From the above, it is observed that Section 230(2)(c)(ii) bifurcates the Creditors into two categories i.e., Secured and Unsecured Creditors. In this context, when we peruse the present Application for the First Motion, we don't find any specific list of Secured or Unsecured Creditors brought by the Applicant on record. The Applicant has only provided the list of the Financial and Operational Creditors. Hence, to find out whether the

16

Corporate Debtor has been advanced with any secured debt, we visit the Master Data of the Corporate Debtor available in public domain at the website of MCA, the relevant extracts of which are reproduced below:

17

On perusal of the Master Data (ibid) of the Corporate Debtor, we observe that a large number of "Charges" have been created and subsisting against the Corporate Debtor, which substantiates the fact that the Corporate Debtor has Secured Creditors.

13. Under the IBC, 2016, not only the terms "Secured Creditor" and

"Unsecured Creditors" are recognised but also their priority rights/manner in the distribution of Assets during Liquidation are different in terms of Section 53 of IBC, 2016. The contents of Section 53 of IBC, 2016 are reproduced below, for immediate reference:

14. Further, the term "Secured Creditor" is defined under Section 3(30) of IBC, 2016, which reads as under:

"Secured Creditor" means a creditor in favour of whom security interest is created;

18

15. The term "Security Interest" is further defined under Section 3(31) of IBC 2016 as below:

(31) "Security Interest" means right, title or interest or a claim to property, created in favour of, or provided for a secured creditor by a transaction which secures payment or performance of an obligation and includes mortgage, charge, hypothecation, assignment and encumbrance or any other agreement or arrangement securing payment or performance of any obligation of any person:

Provided that security interest shall not include a performance guarantee;"

(Emphasis provided)

16. When we peruse the present Scheme to examine as to whether any treatment is given to the Secured Creditors, we come across the following:

17. On perusal of the above, it is evident that the proposed Scheme involves conversion of debt of Secured Financial Creditors into Equity

19

Shares, which is nothing but a form of Corporate Debt Restructuring (with the Secured Financial Creditors) and for such Corporate Debt Restructuring, Section 230(2)(c) of the Companies Act 2013, mandates a pre-requisite approval of 75% of Secured Financial Creditors, in value, before filing the Application, which admittedly, has not been complied with by the Applicant in the present case. At this juncture, we refer to the Judgment of Hon'ble NCLAT passed in the matter of Ramesh Kumar Chaudhary & Ors. Vs. Anju Agarwal & Ors. In Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) No. 957 of 2021, dated 15.03.2022, wherein the following is held:

"21. During the submissions before us as well as in the meeting of the Stakeholders Consultation Committee, reliance has been placed by the Appellants as well as the Liquidator on Section 230(2)(c). Shri Arun Kathpalia, Learned Senior Counsel for the Appellants submits that any scheme for corporate debt restructuring is to be consented by not less than 75% of the secured creditors and unless there is consent of 75% of secured creditors, no Application for compromise or arrangement can be entertained by the Liquidator. He submits that fulfilment of requirement under Section 230(2)(c) is a condition precedent for consideration of any scheme or to make arrangement. Learned Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 submitted that Section 230(2) (c) i.e. requirement of not less than 75% of the consent of the Corporate Debtor is not a condition precedent. Section 230(2) is as follows:"

…..

"27. We accept the submission of Shri Arun Kathpalia, learned Senior Counsel for the Appellant that the Scheme proposed by Respondent Nos.2 and 3 is an arrangement by Respondents, wherein alternations have been proposed in the terms of

20

the loan and lesser amount have been proposed to be paid for settling the claim, which is restructuring of corporate debt. Hence, the Scheme under Section 230 submitted by Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 ought to have consent of not less than 75% of the Secured Creditors, and an affidavit to that effect ought to accompany with the Scheme.

28. Obligation to obtain the consent of 75% of the Creditors is on the person who proposes the Scheme…….." (Emphasis Supplied)

18. Thus, from the Judgement of the Hon'ble NCLAT (Supra), it is clear that consent of 75% of secured creditors is a condition pre-cedent for consideration of any Scheme of Compromise and Arrangement, involving Corporate Debt Restructuring and an affidavit to that effect ought to accompany with the Scheme. In the instant case, not only such an Affidavit has not been filed but also the applicant has denied any Debt Restructuring with Secured Creditors. Also, we find no list of Secured Creditors annexed with the scheme. Hence, the present Application does not fulfil the criteria stipulated under Section 230(2)(c) of the Companies Act, 2013, hence, in our considered view, the Application is not maintainable.

Though this ground alone is sufficient to dismiss the present Application, however, we would still like to examine the other issues emerged during the course of hearing of the matter.

19. It is further contended by the Liquidator that the Scheme is proposed by a Creditor, who is merely a proforma party. The scheme proposed shall effectively be executed through the Sponsor (arrayed as non-Applicant), who is not the Creditor of the Corporate Debtor and therefore, is not entitled to

21

present the Scheme. Per Contra, it is argued by the Applicant that there is no bar on the Sponsor to support the Scheme and moreover, the present Application is preferred by an Operational Creditor. On a preliminary glance of the Scheme, we find the following:

xxxx xxxxx xxxxx

xxxx xxxxx xxxxx

xxxx xxxxx xxxxx

22

20. On perusal of the above, we find that all the major acts in the Scheme are done through the Sponsor only and the Creditor (who is the propounder) has no role in implementation of the Scheme. Further, the management and control on approval of the Scheme is proposed to be vested with the Sponsor (a Non-Applicant). Thus, in effect, what cannot be done directly by the Sponsor, is being planned to be done indirectly by introducing a Creditor (the Applicant) only for the purpose of "proposing"

the Scheme, ostensibly to meet the criteria under Section 230(1) of Companies Act, 2013. Thus, when we lift the veil, the Sponsor (Non- Applicant), who is admittedly neither a member nor a Creditor of the Corporate Debtor, emerges as the real beneficiary of the proposed Scheme.

Hence, we are of the view that the Scheme cannot be propounded by a dummy applicant qua the Sponsor (Non-Applicant), who is not a creditor of the Corporate Debtor, bypassing the Liquidator.

21. Further, we are aware that under Section 230(1) of the Companies Act 2013, the legislature has empowered any Creditor or member of the Company, in case the Company is being wound up, or the Liquidator to file an Application under Section 230(1) of IBC, 2016. Even the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in its Judgement dated 09.03.1989 in the matter of "National Steel & General Mills Vs. Official Liquidator; Civil Appeal No. 2319 of 1988" had held that Liquidator is not the exclusive person to file an Application under Section 391 of Companies Act 1956. However, the aforesaid observations were in respect of the Companies Act, 1956, when IBC, 2016 was not in force. The Liquidation Proceedings under the Companies Act, 1956 and the IBC, 2016 are not the same. Under the IBC

23

2016, the Company has to go through a mandatory CIR Process, which was/is not the case in respect of the Winding Up Proceedings under the Companies Act, 1956 or 2013. Under the Companies Act, 1956 or the present Companies Act, 2013, there is no restriction regarding the eligibility of the Scheme propounder, whereas the Section 29A of IBC, 2016 read with Proviso to Regulation 2B of Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016 puts certain restrictions on eligibility of a propounder of the Scheme. The contents of the Proviso to Regulation 2B are reproduced below, for the immediate reference:

.

22. It goes without saying that it is the duty of the RP/Liquidator as the case may be, to make sure that the Scheme Propounder is eligible and not barred under any of the criteria laid down under Section 29A of IBC, 2016. At this juncture, we refer to the Judgement of Hon'ble Supreme Court passed in the matter of Arcelor Mittal India Private Limited Vs Satish Kumar Gupta & Ors Civil Appeal Nos.9402-9405 Of 2018 dated 04.10.2018, the relevant extracts of which is reproduced below:

"77. However, it must not be forgotten that a Resolution Professional is only to "examine" and "confirm" that each resolution plan conforms to what is provided by Section 30(2). Under Section 25(2)(i), the Resolution Professional shall undertake to present all resolution plans at the meetings of the Committee of Creditors. This is followed by Section 30(3), which states that

24

the Resolution Professional shall present to the Committee of Creditors, for its approval, such resolution plans which confirm the conditions referred to in sub-section (2). This provision has to be read in conjunction with Section 25(2)(i), and with the second proviso to Section 30(4), which provides that where a resolution applicant is found to be ineligible under Section 29A(c), the resolution applicant shall be allowed by the Committee of Creditors such period, not exceeding 30 days, to make payment of overdue amounts in accordance with the proviso to Section 29A(c). A conspectus of all these provisions would show that the Resolution Professional is required to examine that the resolution plan submitted by various applicants is complete in all respects, before submitting it to the Committee of Creditors. The Resolution Professional is not required to take any decision, but merely to ensure that the resolution plans submitted are complete in all respects before they are placed before the Committee of Creditors, who may or may not approve it.

The fact that the Resolution Professional is also to confirm that a resolution plan does not contravene any of the provisions of law for the time-being in force, including Section 29A of the Code, only means that his prima facie opinion is to be given to the Committee of Creditors that a law has or has not been contravened. Section 30(2)(e) does not empower the Resolution Professional to "decide" whether the resolution plan does or does not contravene the provisions of law. Regulation 36A of the CIRP Regulations specifically provides as follows……. (Emphasis Supplied)

23. On perusal of the above, it is observed that the Resolution Professional in case of CIRP is required to make a prima facie opinion whether the Resolution Applicant is eligible or barred under Section 29A of the IBC, 2016. Similarly, if the Corporate Debtor is under Liquidation, and

25

a scheme of Compromise and Arrangement under Section 230-232 of the Companies Act is being proposed, it is the Liquidator, who has to determine that the Scheme propounder is not barred under Section 29A of IBC, 2016. In a situation, where the scheme under Section 230-232 of Companies Act, 2013 is proposed for a company under Liquidation under the provisions of IBC 2016, bypassing the Liquidator, then there will be no scrutiny of the propounder's eligibility as stipulated under Section 29A of IBC, 2016 read with Proviso to Regulation 2B of Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016.

24. While we are not expressing any view regarding eligibility of the Scheme propounder herein, nevertheless, we cannot ignore this fact that eligibility of the Scheme propounder in the present case has not been scrutinized by the Liquidator under Section 29A of IBC, 2016.

25. Thus, in our view the Scheme under Section 230-232 of Companies Act 2013 for a Corporate Debtor under Liquidation under the provisions of IBC 2016, can only be preferred by the Liquidator.

26. Hence, in sequel to the aforesaid discussion and the conclusions drawn in Para 18, 20 and 25 above, the Company Application No. CA (CAA) 74(ND)/2021 is dismissed, being not maintainable.

Sd/- Sd/-

(L.N. GUPTA) (ASHOK KUMAR BHARDWAJ)

MEMBER (T) MEMBER (J)

26