- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
United India I. Co. Ltd. v. Smt. Janki Devi
Court No. - 33
Case :- FIRST APPEAL FROM ORDER No. - 64 of 1992
Appellant :- United India I. Co. Ltd.
Respondent :- Smt. Janki Devi
Counsel for Appellant :- A.B.Saran,Ajai Singh,Ajay Singh
Hon'ble Dr. Kaushal Jayendra Thaker,J.
1. Heard learned counsel for appellant. Though respondents are served, none appeared on their behalf. While admitting this appeal, notice was issued to Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. but none appears on its behalf too.
2. This is an appeal preferred against the order dated 1.10.1991 passed by Motor Accident Claim Tribunal/VI Additional District Judge, Gorakhpur in M.A.C.T. No. 382 of 1989, Smt. Janki Devi and others Vs. Mohd. Ali and others, awarding a compensation of Rs.2,90,000/- in favour of the claimant.
3. As per the claim petition, on 23.10.1989 at about 11.00 a.m., deceased Digvijay Singh was proceeding on road leading to Gorakhpur by a jeep having Registration No. U.T. Z.1348. One D.C.M. having Registration No. U.P. 53-9032 came rashly and negligently from behind and while overtaking, its rear part collided with the head part of jeep on account of which jeep went disbalanced and collided with a tree. Resultantly, persons boarded in the jeep got injured and deceased succumbed to injuries on the spot. It is stated that age of the deceased at the time of accident was 33 years. He was working on the post of Lecturr in Ratan Sen Smarak Inter College, Nichlaul, Maharajganj and his income was Rs.2,400/- per mensem. Deceased was survived by two sons, two daughters and parents who were dependent upon other.
4. Learned counsel for appellants submitted that Tribunal has erred in law while passing said award. The deceased was a passenger in the jeep which was admittedly insured with the appellant company as a taxi. Liability of the Insurance Company would be a limited liability as per proviso of Section 147 (2). The accident had taken place on 23.10.1989, i.e., within four months from the coming into force of Motor Vehicles Neutral Citation No. - 2020:AHC:34487
1
Act, 1988, i.e., on 23.10.1988. Premium of Rs.12 was charged which covered liability of Rs.15,000/-. It is submitted that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of DCM mini truck insured with Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. Holding both the vehicles negligent is bad. It is submitted that findings recorded by the Tribunal are against the evidence as the claim petition, no where suggested that the driver of the jeep was driving the vehicle in rash and negligent manner. The jeep was dashed by rear side of the truck as a result of which sudden death of deceased occurred. It is further submitted that as deceased was 33 years of age, multiplier 15 might not have been applied. Further dependency of Rs.1,000/- could not have been given.
5. At the outset, the principles for deciding negligence will have to be looked into. The term contributory negligence and composite negligence has been discussed time and again a person who either contributes or is author of the accident would be liable for his contribution to the accident having taken place. The Apex Court in
Pawan Kumar & Anr vs M/S Harkishan Dass Mohan Lal & Ors decided on 29 January, 2014 has held as follows:-
"7. Where the plaintiff/claimant himself is found to be a party to the negligence the question of joint and several liability cannot arise and the plaintiff's claim to the extent of his own negligence, as may be quantified, will have to be severed. In such a situation the plaintiff can only be held entitled to such part of damages/compensation that is not attributable to his own negligence. The above principle has been explained in T.O. Anthony (supra) followed in K. Hemlatha & Ors. (supra). Paras 6 and 7 of T.O. Anthony (supra) which are relevant may be extracted hereinbelow:
"6. "Composite negligence" refers to the negligence on the part of two or more persons. Where a person is injured as a result of negligence on the part of two or more wrongdoers, it is said that the person was injured on account of the composite negligence of those wrongdoers. In such a case, each wrongdoer is jointly and severally liable to the injured for payment of the entire damages and the injured person has the choice of proceeding against all or any of them. In such a case, the
2
injured need not establish the extent of responsibility of each wrongdoer separately, nor is it necessary for the court to determine the extent of liability of each wrongdoer separately. On the other hand where a person suffers injury, partly due to the negligence on the part of another person or persons, and partly as a result of his own negligence, then the negligence on the part of the injured which contributed to the accident is referred to as his contributory negligence. Where the injured is guilty of some negligence, his claim for damages is not defeated merely by reason of the negligence on his part but the damages recoverable by him in respect of the injuries stand reduced in proportion to his contributory negligence.
7. Therefore, when two vehicles are involved in an accident, and one of the drivers claims compensation from the other driver alleging negligence, and the other driver denies negligence or claims that the injured claimant himself was negligent, then it becomes necessary to consider whether the injured claimant was negligent and if so, whether he was solely or partly responsible for the accident and the extent of his responsibility, that is, his contributory negligence. Therefore where the injured is himself partly liable, the principle of "composite negligence" will not apply nor can there be an automatic inference that the negligence was 50:50 as has been assumed in this case. The Tribunal ought to have examined the extent of contributory negligence of the appellant and thereby avoided confusion between composite negligence and contributory negligence. The High Court has failed to correct the said error."
6. The Division Bench of this Court in First Appeal From Order No.1818 of 2012 ( Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Company Limited Versus Smt. Renu Singh and others) decided on 19.7.2016 has held as under: -
3
"16. The term negligence means failure to exercise required degree of care and caution expected of a prudent driver. Negligence is the omission to do something which a reasonable man, guided upon the considerations, which ordinarily regulate conduct of human affairs, would do, or doing something which a prudent and reasonable man would not do. Negligence is not always a question of direct evidence. It is an inference to be drawn from proved facts. Negligence is not an absolute term, but is a relative one. It is rather a comparative term. What may be negligence in one case may not be so in another. Where there is no duty to exercise care, negligence in the popular sense has no legal consequence. Where there is a duty to exercise care, reasonable care must be taken to avoid acts or omissions which would be reasonably foreseen likely to cause physical injury to person. The degree of care required, of course, depends upon facts in each case. On these broad principles, negligence of drivers is required to be assessed.
17. It would be seen that burden of proof for contributory negligence on the part of deceased has to be discharged by the opponents. It is the duty of driver of the offending vehicle to explain the accident. It is well settled law that at intersection where two roads cross each other, it is the duty of a fast moving vehicle to slow down and if driver did not slow down at intersection, but continued to proceed at a high speed without caring to notice that another vehicle was crossing, then the conduct of driver necessarily leads to conclusion that vehicle was being driven by him rashly as well as negligently.
18. 10th Schedule appended to Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 contain statutory regulations for driving of motor vehicles which also form part of every Driving License. Clause-6 of such Regulation clearly directs that the driver of every motor vehicle should slow down vehicle at every intersection or junction of roads or at a turning of the road. It is also provided that driver of the vehicle should not enter intersection or junction of roads unless he makes sure that he would not thereby endanger any other person. Merely, because driver of the Truck was driving vehicle on the left side of road would not absolve him from his responsibility to slow down vehicle as he approaches intersection of roads, particularly when he could have easily seen, that the car over which deceased was riding, was approaching intersection. This is termed negligence.
4
19.In view of the fast and constantly increasing volume of traffic, motor vehicles upon roads may be regarded to some extent as coming within the principle of liability defined in
Rylands V/s. Fletcher, (1868) 3 HL (LR) 330 from the point of view of pedestrian, the roads of this country have been rendered by the use of motor vehicles, highly dangerous. 'Hit and run' cases where drivers of motor vehicles who have caused accidents, are unknown. In fact such cases are increasing in number. Where a pedestrian without negligence on his part is injured or killed by a motorist, whether negligently or not, he or his legal representatives, as the case may be, should be entitled to recover damages if principle of social justice should have any meaning at all.
20. In light of the above discussion, I am of the view that even if courts may not by interpretation displace the principles of law which are considered to be well settled and, therefore, Courts cannot dispense with proof of negligence altogether in all cases of motor vehicle accidents, it is possible to develop the law further on the following lines; when a motor vehicle is being driven with reasonable care, it would ordinarily not meet with an accident and, therefore, rule of res- ipsa loquitor as a rule of evidence may be invoked in motor accident cases with greater frequency than in ordinary civil suits.
21. By the above process, the burden of proof may ordinarily be cast on the defendants in a motor accident claim petition to prove that motor vehicle was being driven with reasonable care or that there is equal negligence on the part of driver of another vehicle."
7. The fact accident having occurred on 23.8.1989 at about 11 a.m. involving two vehicles causing death of the deceased, is not in dispute. While going through the Judgment and the record, it is very clear that the issue no.1 has been decided considering all the facts. Mini truck tried to overtake the jeep and while trying to overtake, mini truck came on the driver side of the jeep and dashed with the jeep as result of which Dr. Digvijay Singh, who was sitting in jeep died. The witness, who has been projected as an eye witness, namely, Mohd. Ali Khalil and truck driver both have orally testified that the jeep driver was also driving jeep at a considerable high speed. While going through the records, it appears that the Tribunal has recorded a finding that if drivers of both the vehicles were negligent, they will be held equally negligent for causing accident.
5
The said finding is not bad in law and cannot be justified as far as compensation is concerned. The deceased was a professor and had fixed pay of Rs.2586/-. However, the Tribunal has very conservatively considered Rs.1333/- as his income and deducted 1/3 for his personal expenses and considered that the family would be entitled to Rs.1,000/- per mensem, which being multiplied with 12 came to Rs.12,000/- per annum and after applying multiplier of 25, it came to Rs.3,00,000/-.
8. I am in agreement with Sri Ajay Singh that multiplier of 25 could not have been applied to Rs.12,000/-, however, while going through the record, it is clear that the Tribunal granted a sum of Rs.2,90,000/-. The Tribunal deducted bonus, pension and all other amounts which could not have been done.
9. May that as it may be, the recalculation would be necessary while going through the recalculation, it cannot be said that the amount Rs.2,90,000/- is on higher side even in the year of accident. However, rate of interest which is 12% of interest could not have been granted. However, non grant of future loss of income would be compensated by 12 per cent rate of interest.
10. With the aforesaid observations, appeal is disposed of.
11. Record and proceedings be sent back to the Tribunal.
12. This Court is thankful to Sri Ajay Singh for getting the matter of 1992 disposed of.
Order Date:14.1.2020 Ram Murti
6
Alert