- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Satyendar Kumar Jain Petitioner(s) v. Directorate Of Enforcement (s).
Factual and Procedural Background
The opinion concerns an application seeking grant of interim bail on medical grounds. The petitioner’s senior counsel relied on the petitioner’s weight loss and medical condition, placing before the court a medical report from the G.B. Pant Institute of Post Graduate Medical Education and Research, New Delhi dated 04.05.2023. The Enforcement Directorate, represented by the Additional Solicitor General, opposed interim bail and sought an independent medical examination at AIIMS. The court heard both sides and passed an order granting interim bail for a limited duration, subject to conditions, and fixed a further date for orders.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner should be granted interim bail on medical grounds based on the medical report from the G.B. Pant Institute.
- Whether an independent medical examination at AIIMS was necessary before considering interim bail.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner’s Arguments
- Interim bail was pressed on the basis of the petitioner’s weight loss and medical condition.
- The medical report dated 04.05.2023 from the G.B. Pant Institute of Post Graduate Medical Education and Research, New Delhi was relied upon for the court’s consideration.
Enforcement Directorate’s Arguments
- The Additional Solicitor General opposed the prayer for interim bail.
- An independent medical examination at AIIMS was requested before grant of such relief.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court, after hearing counsel for both sides, stated that at present there was no reason to disbelieve the report of the G.B. Pant Institute. On that basis, it declined (at that stage) to proceed on the assumption that the report required disbelief or replacement by a fresh independent examination. The court further articulated that a citizen has a right to take treatment of his choice, at his own expense, in a private hospital. Considering these factors, the court found it appropriate to grant interim bail on medical grounds for a limited period of six weeks, while safeguarding the proceedings through additional restrictive conditions.
Holding and Implications
INTERIM BAIL GRANTED on medical grounds for a limited period of six weeks, subject to terms and conditions to be imposed by the trial court and additional conditions imposed by the court.
The petitioner is to be released until the next date of listing, with conditions including: (i) not influencing or meeting listed witnesses; (ii) not leaving the National Capital Region (NCR) without leave of the trial court; (iii) producing relevant treatment papers and prognosis before the court during interim bail; and (iv) refraining from appearing before print/electronic media or social media to make statements on any issue during interim bail. The matter was directed to be re-listed for further orders on 10.07.2023. The opinion does not indicate any broader implications beyond this interim arrangement, and it does not set out or apply any cited precedent.
1. Learned senior counsel has pressed the application for grant of interim bail looking to the weight loss and medical condition of the petitioner. The Report of the G.B. Pant Institute of Post Graduate Medical Education and Research, New Delhi, dated 04.05.2023 has been pressed before us for consideration.
2. The Additional Solicitor General representing Enforcement Directorate opposed such prayer and pressed upon for independent medical examination before All India Institute of Medical Sciences [AIIMS].
3. After hearing learned counsel for the parties, at present there is no reason to disbelieve the Report of G.B. Pant Institute of Post Graduate Medical Education and Research. We think it appropriate that the citizen is having a right to take treatment of his choice, at his own expenses, in a private hospital.
4. Therefore, we deem it appropriate to release the petitioner on interim bail on medical grounds for a limited period of six weeks.
5. Until the next date of listing, the petitioner be released on interim bail on medical grounds, on such terms and conditions as may be imposed by the trial court, with additional conditions viz:—
(i) That the petitioner shall not influence and meet with any of the witnesses, which is scheduled in the witness list;
(ii) he shall not leave the area of National Capital Region (NCR) without leave of the trial court;
(iii) During the interim bail, all the relevant treatment papers and prognosis at such treatment shall be produced before this Court.
(iv) The petitioner shall refrain himself to appear before Print or Electronic Media or any social media platform to give any statement on any issue during the interim bail.
6. Re-list the matter for further orders on 10.07.2023.
Alert