- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Danish v. State of U.P.
Factual and Procedural Background
The applicant, Danish, filed a bail application in Case Crime No. 3 of 2023 at Police Station Janakpuri, District Saharanpur, under Sections 384, 326A, 195, and 120B IPC. The FIR was lodged on 6.1.2023 against the applicant and eight others, including the wife of the informant, alleging the preparation of a fake medical certificate for co-accused Fariyal. The alleged fake certificate led to lodging a false FIR against the informant and others under section 326A IPC. The informant, husband of Fariyal, had earlier lodged an FIR on 3.1.2023 against the applicant and others under section 326A IPC. The investigation included CCTV footage which suggested that Fariyal appeared perfectly alright at the hospital, supporting the claim of a fake medical certificate. The applicant has been in custody since 28.3.2023, and the bail application was filed during the pendency of the trial.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the applicant is entitled to bail despite being accused under serious sections including 326A IPC, given the nature of allegations and evidence on record.
- Whether the FIR under section 326A IPC was properly lodged against the applicant considering the facts and investigation findings.
- The applicability and effect of section 195 IPC as a non-cognizable offence in relation to the applicant's involvement.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant's Arguments
- The allegations against the applicant are false and baseless.
- The FIR under section 326A IPC was improperly lodged despite no acid attack allegations against the applicant.
- The Investigating Officer conducted the investigation perfunctorily and negligently.
- The applicant was implicated merely on general allegations due to his relationship as cousin brother of co-accused Fariyal.
- The only applicable offence against the applicant could be under section 195 IPC, which is non-cognizable and does not warrant FIR or custody.
- The applicant has no criminal history and has been in custody since 28.3.2023.
Opposite Party's Arguments
- The applicant and co-accused Fariyal prepared the fake medical report as evidenced by CCTV footage.
- Bail of co-accused Farzand Ali was dismissed by a co-ordinate Bench, supporting the seriousness of the offence.
- Co-accused Farzand Ali was an agent of the hospital; other co-accused persons have been granted bail or anticipatory bail.
- Section 195 IPC is non-cognizable, but the offence under other sections including 326A IPC is serious.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analyzed the facts and noted that the FIR lodged on 3.1.2023 against the informant and others under section 326A IPC alleged an acid attack on co-accused Fariyal. Subsequently, when it was revealed that Fariyal's medical report was fake, the present FIR was lodged. The court observed no specific allegation against the applicant beyond general accusations. The CCTV footage, relied upon by the prosecution, did not disclose the applicant's name explicitly, and the applicant's presence was only noted during the medical examination of Fariyal. The court distinguished the applicant's case from that of co-accused Farzand Ali, who was an agent of the hospital and whose bail was dismissed. Since there was no acid attack allegation against the applicant, the court found the FIR under section 326A IPC questionable as applied to him. The court also noted that the offence under section 195 IPC, potentially applicable to the applicant, is non-cognizable. Based on these factors, the court concluded that the applicant was entitled to bail.
Holding and Implications
The bail application of the applicant Danish is allowed.
The applicant is ordered to be released on bail upon furnishing a personal bond and two sureties to the satisfaction of the trial court, subject to conditions including appearing before the court as required, refraining from influencing witnesses or tampering with evidence, and avoiding criminal or anti-social activities. The court clarified that its observations are limited to the bail proceedings and do not affect the merits of the case during trial. This decision directly affects the applicant by granting bail but does not establish any new legal precedent.
Neutral Citation No. - 2023:AHC:110311
Court No. - 74 Case :- CRIMINAL MISC. BAIL APPLICATION No. - 18682 of
2023
Applicant :- Danish
Opposite Party :- State of U.P.
Counsel for Applicant :- Ashfaq Ahmed Ansari
Counsel for Opposite Party :- G.A.,Shamshad Ahmad
Hon'ble Sameer Jain,J.
1. Heard Sri Ashfaq Ahmed Ansari, learned counsel for the applicant; Sri Shamshad Ahmad, learned counsel for the informant and Dr. S. B. Maurya, learned AGA-I for the State-respondent.
2. The instant application has been filed seeking release of the applicant on bail in Case Crime No. 3 of 2023, under Sections 384, 326A, 195, 120B IPC, Police Station Janakpuri, District Saharanpur, during pendency of the trial in the court below.
3. FIR of the present case was lodged against applicant and eight others on 6.1.2023 and according to the FIR applicant and other co-accused persons including the wife of informant prepared a fake medical certificate of co-accused Fariyal i.e. wife of the informant and after preparing the fake medical certificate on 4.1.2023, a false FIR was lodged against informant and others under section 326A IPC.
4. Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the entire allegations made against the applicants are false and baseless and surprisingly, FIR of the present case was lodged under sections 384, 326A, 195, 120B IPC but as there is allegation of preparation of the forged medical of the alleged injured, therefore, there was no question to lodge FIR under section 326A IPC and this fact clearly suggest that Investigating Officer in most perfunctory and negligent manner conducted the investigation of the present matter and it appears that only to show that the matter is quite serious, FIR was lodged also under section 326 A IPC although admittedly there is no allegation of throwing acid against any of the accused persons nominated in the FIR including applicant.
5. He next submitted that actually informant of the case is the husband of injured Fariyal i.e. co-accused in the present matter and
1
as against him and his family members on 3.1.2023 from the side of co-accused Fariyal and applicant, a FIR was lodged under section 326 A IPC, therefore, only with intention to save his skin from that case, FIR of the present case was lodged on 6.1.2023. He further submitted that from the perusal of the case diary, it appears that during investigation Investigating Officer procured the CCTV Footage and on the basis of CCTV footage he came to the conclusion that when alleged injured Fariyal i.e. co-accused of the present matter arrived at the hospital then she was perfectly alright, therefore, it appears that a fake medical certificate of Fariyal was prepared but in the entire scene, there is no role of the applicant and even if the allegations are accepted then merely on the basis of general allegation, applicant who is cousin brother of Fariyal has been made accused in the present matter and if the allegations are accepted then also only offence under section 195 IPC can only be made against the applicant which is a non cognizable offence and no FIR can be lodged against the applicant and as even as per the allegation applicant committed non cognizabe offence, therefore, he may be released on bail.
6. He next submitted that applicant is not having any criminal history and he is in jail since 28.3.2023.
7. Per contra, learned AGA as well as learned counsel for the informant vehemently opposed the prayer for bail and submitted that applicant is cousin brother of the co-accused Fariyal and they prepared the fake medical report of co-accused Fariyal and this fact is evident from the CCTV footage and bail of one co-accused Farzand Ali has been dismissed by the co-ordinate Bench of this Court vide order dated 17.3.2023 passed in Crl. Misc. Bail Application No. 10555 of 2023 but could not dispute the fact that co-accused Farzand Ali whose bail was dismissed was agent of the hospital and further one co-accused Tausif Ali, Advocate who also participated in crime has been released on bail by the court concerned itself and other co-accused person Masroor Ali has been released on anticipatory bail by this Court, the junior of co-accused Tausif Ali and further offence under section 195 IPC is non congnizable offence.
8. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record of the case.
9. It is a case in which a FIR was lodged on 3.1.2023 against informant and others under section 326 A IPC with the allegation that they thrown Acid on co-accused Fariyal of the present matter and wife of the informant but subsequently when it was revealed
2
that the medical report of the co-accused Fariyal was fake then FIR of the present case was lodged and from the perusal of the FIR and other material on record, it appears that there is no specific allegation against the applicant and he alongwith eight others have been made accused in the present matter on the basis of general allegation. Although during investigation, it appears that Investigating Officer procured a CCTV footage but from the perusal of the details of CCTV footage which was produced by the learned AGA and learned counsel for the informant, it appears that in the noting of the CCTV footage, Investigating Officer did not disclose the name of the applicant and as per prosecution, applicant was present at the time when co-accused Fariyal was being medically examined and except this there is no other evidence against the applicant.
10. Although bail of co-accused Fazand Ali has been dismissed by this Court but it appears that the case of applicant is distinguishable from him as he was agent of the hospital where the fake medical report was prepared and further there is no allegation of throwing any acid, therefore, there was no question to lodge the FIR under section 326A IPC but surprisingly not only FIR was lodged under section 326A IPC but till date, investigation has been conducted under section 326A IPC and bail of applicant was also dismissed under section 326A IPC and offence under section 195 IPC is non cognizable offence.
11. Therefore, from the discussions made above, in my view, applicant is entitled to be released on bail.
12. Accordingly, without expressing any opinion on the merits of the case, the instant bail application is allowed.
13. Let the applicant-Danish be released on bail in the aforesaid case on furnishing a personal bond and two sureties each in the like amount to the satisfaction of the court concerned with the following conditions:-
(i) The applicant shall appear before the trial court on the dates fixed, unless his personal presence is exempted.
(ii) The applicant shall not directly or indirectly, make inducement, threat or promise to any person acquainted with the facts of the case so as to dissuade him from disclosing such facts to the Court or any police officer or tamper with the evidence.
(iii) The applicant shall not indulge in any criminal and anti-social
3
activity.
14. In case of breach of any of the above condition, the prosecution will be at liberty to move an application before this Court for cancellation of the bail of the applicant.
15. It is clarified that the observations made herein are limited to the facts brought in by the parties pertaining to the disposal of bail application and the said observations shall have no bearing on the merits of the case during trial.
Order Date :- 18.5.2023
S.A.
4
Alert