Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

HIRENDRA SINGH RATHORE v. STATE OF RAJASTHAN

Rajasthan High Court
Apr 6, 2023
Smart Summary (Beta)

Opinion Summary: High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan at Jodhpur (06/04/2023)

Case series: Multiple connected S.B. Civil Writ Petitions (examples include S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 19701/2022 Hirendra Singh Rathore v. State of Rajasthan & Ors). Judge: Hon'ble Mr. Justice Vinit Kumar Mathur. Order date: 06/04/2023.

Factual and Procedural Background

The opinion disposes of a large bunch of connected writ petitions raising similar controversy concerning recruitment to the post of Physical Training Instructor (P.T.I.) pursuant to Advertisement dated 16.06.2022. Petitioners appeared in the examination and the result was declared with an initial answer key published by the respondents. On receipt of objections, the respondents referred the answer key to an expert committee and published a reviewed/re-published answer key. The reviewed answer key altered the correctness of certain questions that had been adjudicated correct in the first answer key and, as a consequence, several petitioners who would have been selected according to the first answer key no longer featured in the merit list after the review. Petitioners sought, inter alia, quashing of orders denying selection/appointment, quashing of the result and the reviewed answer key, constitution of an expert committee to re-examine challenged questions, award of marks/bonus marks where appropriate and consequential revision of the result and appointment if they stand in merit.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the answers adjudicated in the reviewed/re-published answer key (following referral to an expert committee) can be re-examined afresh on the objections raised by the petitioners.
  2. Whether, upon re-examination of the challenged questions, any change in answers should lead to reshuffling/revision of the result and consequential selection/appointment of petitioners who then stand in merit.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners appeared in the P.T.I. examination (advertisement dated 16.06.2022) and, according to the first answer key published by the respondents, the marks obtained by them would have resulted in their selection.
  • Following publication of a reviewed answer key, certain questions previously adjudicated correct were found to be incorrect; this altered petitioners' positions in the merit list resulting in loss of selection.
  • The petitioners contend that the expert committee's adjudication is erroneous in respect of a number of specific questions and that those answers are correct as per the textbooks relied upon by them in the writ petitions.
  • They sought constitution (or reconsideration by) of an expert committee to re-examine the challenged/deleted/out-of-syllabus/multi-option questions, award appropriate marks/bonus marks and revise the result accordingly; petitioners stated they would be satisfied if their contentions were examined by an expert body appointed by respondents.

Respondents' Position (as recorded)

  • On instructions, learned counsel for the respondents submitted that they will get the petitioners' contentions/objections re-examined through the expert committee and pass appropriate orders after such re-examination.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court heard learned counsel for the parties and noted that the controversy in the connected writ petitions was similar; accordingly the matters were disposed of by a common order for efficiency and brevity. The court took the prayer of one representative petition (S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.19701/2022) as encapsulating the reliefs sought across the bunch and recorded the petitioners' submissions regarding the change between the first and the reviewed answer key and the resultant effect on the merit list.

The court then inquired whether the expert committee (which had examined objections to the first answer key and produced a reviewed key) could re-consider and re-examine the matters afresh. On instructions, the respondents' counsel assured the court that the contentions/objections of the petitioners would be re-examined through the expert committee and appropriate orders would be passed.

Given these assurances and the nature of the complaints (specific questions identified by petitioners where they claim the answers were correct), the court deemed it appropriate to direct the respondents to have the expert committee reconsider/re-examine the answers to the objectionable questions raised in the writ petitions. The court framed the petitioners' contentions as objections for the expert committee's consideration and required the expert committee to pass appropriate orders with respect to the adjudications previously made on those questions.

The court imposed a timeline for completion of this exercise and made clear the consequence that any change in answers arising from re-examination would require the respondents to reshuffle/revise the result accordingly. The court thereby provided an effective remedy short of deciding correctness of particular answers itself, by directing an administrative re-examination with a firm timeline.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The connected writ petitions are disposed of by a common order with a direction that the respondents shall have the expert committee reconsider and re-examine the answers to the objectionable questions raised in the writ petitions, treating the petitioners' contentions as objections, and the expert committee shall pass appropriate orders within six weeks from the date of the order (06/04/2023). Any change arising from such re-examination shall lead to reshuffling/revision of the result by the respondents. Stay petitions were disposed of accordingly.

Implications:

  • The direct effect on the parties is that the petitioners' identified objections will be re-examined by the expert committee within the stipulated six-week period and, if the expert committee alters its adjudication, the respondents must revise the result and consequentially adjust selection/appointment outcomes.
  • The order does not purport to decide the substantive correctness of any particular answer; instead, it mandates administrative re-examination by the expert committee. The opinion does not state or establish any broader legal precedent beyond directing reconsideration and revision of results where appropriate.

Order pronounced by: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINIT KUMAR MATHUR (06/04/2023).

Show all summary ...

[2023/RJJD/009148]

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN AT

JODHPUR

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 1128/2023 Mahendra Meena S/o Shri Chiman Singh Meena, Aged About 32 Years, R/o Ward No. 4 Vir Durga Das Nagar Marwar Junction, District Pali, Rajasthan.

----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary Department Of Secondary Education, Secretariat, Jaipur, Rajasthan.

2. Director, Secondary Education Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur, Through Its Chairman Premises Of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

Connected With

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 16400/2022 Manju Gurjar D/o Rameshwar Gurjar, Aged About 22 Years, Village Ralayta, Post Hukumpura, Tehsil Phooliya Kalan, District Bhilwara.

----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through Director Secondary Education Department, Rajasthan, Bikaner (Raj.).

2. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Through Its Secretary Having Its Office At State Institute On Agriculture Management Premises, Durgapura, Jaipur (Raj.). ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 16458/2022

Sharmila Kumari W/o Shri Daulat Ram Saran, Aged About 31 Years, Resident Of 17 Jaat Ka Baas, Dalman, Sardarshahar, District - Churu.

----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary, Department Of Education, Government Of Rajasthan, Secretariat, Jaipur.

1

2. Rajasthan Subordinate And Ministerial Service Selection Board, State Institute Of Agriculture Management Premise, Durgapura, Jaipur, Through Its Secretary. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 16687/2022

Madan Lal S/o Naurang Lal, Aged About 32 Years, Ward No. 5, Harijan Mohalla, Dhadhela, Hanumangarh.

----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Director Secondary Education, Bikaner (Raj.).

2. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Krishi Prabandh Sansthan Parisar, Durgapura, Jaipur Through Its Secretary.

----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 16741/2022

1. Mahaveer Prasad S/o Shri Rai Singh, Aged About 30 Years, R/o Chack 4, B.g.m., Bhagu Khajuwala Bikaner.

2. Pushpa D/o Rameshwar Lal Jat, Aged About 29 Years, R/o Benisar, Bikaner

3. Begraj S/o Shri Bhola Ram, Aged About 31 Years, R/o Ward No. 07/08 Dpn Hanumangarh, Bharwana

4. Ishwar Prajapat S/o Bhagga Ram, Aged About 23 Years, R/o Kumharoka Bas Atapara,pali

5. Kamlesh Jat S/o Balu Ram, Aged About 33 Years, R/o Naya Udaipur Road Kapasan, Chithorgarh

6. Lakhvinder Singh S/o Prem Singh, Aged About 27 Years, R/o 12 Knd Rawla, Shri Ganganagar

7. Magraj Bhadu S/o Chutra Ram, Aged About 29 Years, R/o Bhaduonkatalanetrad, Barmer

8. Kesha Ram S/o Gumnaram, Aged About 40 Years, R/o Vill. Kanod, Barmer

9. Shyamlal Acharya S/o Babulal Acharrya, Aged About 48 Years, R/o Vpobhadsora Th. Bhadesar, Chhitorgarh

10. Suman Jnagu D/o Pema Ram Jangu, Aged About 24 Years, R/o Dhakikidhanidasanakallanakoda, Nagaur

11. Manju Swami D/o Hari Ram Swami, Aged About 35 Years,

2

R/o Vpo Kishorpura, Ajeetgarh, Shri Madhopur

12. Manju Bala D/o Satbir Singh, Aged About 33 Years, R/o Dhokhaharya Tehsil Chdadri, Bhiwanihariyana

13. Sudhir Kumar S/o Sarwan Kumar, Aged About 35 Years, R/o 2 Tk Ward No. 06 Disst. Shri Ganganagar

14. Shravan Ram S/o Hanuman Ram, Aged About 23 Years, R/o Ward No. 11 Khokhrana, Bikaner

15. Sachin Choudhary S/o Sukhveer Singh, Aged About 24 Years, R/o Mahapalwasteh. Sureajgarh, Jhunjhunu

16. Sushil Kumar S/o Prahalad Ram Puniya, Aged About 28 Years, R/o Kesardesarjatan, Bikaner

17. Partap Singh Sisodia S/o Megh Singh, Aged About 31 Years, R/o Veilavadi Jawad, Tehsarada, Udaipur

18. Savitri Jat D/o Ram Narayan Jat, Aged About 21 Years, R/o Shiv Colony Dudu Road Malpurra,tonk

19. Vikas Kumar S/o Madan Lal, Aged About 19 Years, R/o 12 Knd, Shri Ganganagar

20. Prahlad Kumawat S/o Laxmanlalkumawat, Aged About 32 Years, R/o Puraniparsoli Dist. Bhilwara

21. Sanju Kumawat D/o Mohan Lalkumawat, Aged About 29 Years, R/o Puraniparsoli Dist. Bhilwara

22. Subham Suthar S/o Shiv Sankar, Aged About 21 Years, R/o Bothragaliudairamsar, Bikaner

23. Monika Sahu D/o Kanhaiyalalsahu, Aged About 26 Years, R/o Satynarayan Marg Chhotibhrampuri Udaipur

24. Anita Kumari D/o Ram Dhankaswan, Aged About 26 Years, R/o Ward No 05 Ramsar, Bikaner

25. Bal Ram Singh Yadav S/o Rampal Singh Yadav, Aged About 36 Years, R/o Kasimpur Pakri Alambag Lacknow, Utar Pradesh

26. Gourav Suwalka S/o Gopal Suwalka, Aged About 26 Years, R/o 01 R.k. Colony, Bhilwara

27. Tarsem Singh S/o Ram Kala, Aged About 26 Years, R/o Near New Bus Stand Kaithal, Hariyana

28. Ram Niwas Kaswan S/o Anna Ram Kaswan, Aged About

29 Years, R/o Kesardesarjatan, Bikaner

29. Om Prakash S/o Gopal Dan, Aged About 28 Years, R/o

3

Laxmangarh, Sikar

30. Ravi Sharma S/o Vinod Sharma, Aged About 32 Years, R/o Beeslam, Surtpura, Rajgarh, Churu

31. Rakesh S/o Sugna Ram, Aged About 25 Years, R/o Jatoka Bas Bedawari Kalan, Nagaur

32. Sarita Choudhary D/o Pukhraj, Aged About 27 Years, R/o Sohanpura, Barna, Nagaur

33. Saurabh Singh Jat S/o Gopal Singh, Aged About 28 Years, R/o Kherihewalkhedihewalhindoun,

34. Kalwant Swami S/o Shri Devi Lal Swami, Aged About 32 Years, R/o 15Z, Shri Ganga Nagar.

35. Nirma Rinwa D/o Shri Daman, Aged About 29 Years, R/o Village Chawatakhurd, Nagaur.

36. Onkar Mal Siyag S/o Shri Bhanwarlalsiyag, Aged About 26 Years, R/o Ward No.3, Maghwalon Ki Basit, Bassi, District Bikaner.

37. Dinesh Brahman S/o Sukhdev, Aged About 25 Years, R/o

143 Jajroka Bas Khakharakinagaur.

38. Rachana D/o Rampratap, Aged About 27 Years, R/o Ward No. 03, 09 Md, Munda, District Hanumangarh.

39. Vinod Kumar S/o Rajender Kumar, Aged About 30 Years, R/o Ward No.11 5 Pbn Pilibangahanumangarh.

40. Vikram S/o Mohan Lal, Aged About 29 Years, R/o Ward No.8, Mahiyanwali, District Sri Ganganagar.

41. Suresh Bhakar S/o Jagdish Ram, Aged About 29 Years, R/o Near Malibhawan, Didwana Road, Nagaur.

42. Soda Ram S/o Surata Ram, Aged About 31 Years, R/o Chitraberapholodi Jodhpur

43. Rajnish Kumar S/o Liladhar, Aged About 25 Years, R/o Vpo Bhojasar, Tehsil Bhadra, District Hanumangarh. ----Petitioners

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through Its Secretary, Department Of Secondary Education, Government Of Rajasthan, Secretariat, Jaipur.

2. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Through Its Secretary, State Institute Of Agriculture Management Premises,

4

Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 17083/2022

1. Mahendra Kumar S/o Shri Nemi Chand, Aged About 24 Years, R/o Bera, Badiya Ke Samna, Sandiya, Tehsil - Sojat City, District - Pali, Rajasthan.

2. Rajaram Yadav S/o Shri Badri Narayan Yadav, Aged About

24 Years, R/o Vpo- Bhojyara, Tehsil - Chaksu, District - Jaipur, Rajasthan.

----Petitioners

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary Department Of Secondary Education, Secretariat, Jaipur, And Rajasthan.

2. Director, Secondary Education Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur, Through Its Chairman Premises Of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 17102/2022

1. Narayan Singh S/o Shri Lal Singh, Aged About 38 Years, R/o Village Ishru, Tehsil Bapini, District Jodhpur, Rajasthan.

2. Padam Singh Rathore S/o Shri Ugam Singh Rathore, Aged About 42 Years, R/o Vpo Lorta Haridasota, Tehsil Balesar, District Jodhpur, Rajasthan.

3. Sharwan Kumar S/o Shri Parhlad Ram, Aged About 38 Years, R/o Village Manewara, Post Champasar, Tehsil Ghanityali, District Jodhpur, Rajasthan.

4. Sahi Ram Bishnoi S/o Shri Bhopala Ram, Aged About 42 Years, R/o Village Nokhara Charnan, Post Aau, Tehsil Phalodi, District Jodhpur, Rajasthan.

5. Bhanwar Lal S/o Shri Pancha Ram, Aged About 40 Years, R/o Village Kelansar, Tehsil Bap, District Jodhpur, Rajasthan.

6. Gopi Ram S/o Shri Foola Ram, Aged About 38 Years, R/o Village Jaisla, Tehsil Bap, District Jodhpur, Rajasthan.

5

7. Sharwan Kumar Ranwa S/o Shri Ramchandra Singh, Aged About 38 Years, R/o Vpo Fatehpura, Tehsil Dhod, District Sikar, Rajasthan.

8. Joga Ram S/o Shri Banna Ram, Aged About 41 Years, R/o Vpo Chuntisara, District Nagaur, Rajasthan.

9. Ravindra Singh Rathore S/o Shri Braham Singh Rathore, Aged About 36 Years, R/o Village Sawaipura, Post Bhagwanpura, Tehsil Pisangan, District Ajmer, Rajasthan.

10. Shree Ram Bishnoi S/o Shri Jora Ram, Aged About 38 Years, R/o Village Nokhara Godara, Tehsil Phalodi, District Jodhpur, Rajasthan.

11. Jitendra Singh S/o Shri Karan Singh, Aged About 38 Years, R/o Vpo Danwara, Tehsil Baori, District Jodhpur, Rajasthan.

12. Kesha Ram S/o Shri Gumna Ram, Aged About 40 Years, Vpo Kanod, Tehsil Gira, District Barmer, Rajasthan ----Petitioners

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary Department Of Secondary Education, Secretariat, Jaipur, Rajasthan.

2. Director, Secondary Education Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur, Through Its Chairman Premises Of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 17404/2022 Urja Ram Siyag S/o Ramu Ram, Aged About 46 Years, 185, Ward No. 03, Bhani Bass Basi, District Bikaner, Rajasthan. ----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary Department Of Secondary Education, Secretariat, Jaipur, And Rajasthan.

2. Director, Secondary Education Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Through Its Chairman Premises Of State Agriculture Management Institute

6

Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 17553/2022

1. Naveen S/o Shri Ramesh Kumar, Aged About 20 Years, Resident Of Ward No. 10, Vpo Nukera, Tehsil Sangaria, District Hanumangarh, (Raj.).

2. Mohit S/o Shri Ranjeet Singh, Aged About 22 Years, Resident Of Ward No. 01, Vpo Nukera, Tehsil Sangaria, District Hanumangarh, (Raj.).

----Petitioners

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through Secretary, Department Of Education, Government Of Rajasthan, Secretariat, Jaipur.

2. The Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur, Through Its Chairman.

3. The Rajasthan Employees Selection Board, Jaipur, Through Its Secretary.

4. Director, Secondary Education Rajasthan, Bikaner. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 18013/2022 Mrs. Karishma Patidar W/o Krishan Prasad Patidar, Aged About

28 Years, R/o Village Semaliya Ghata, Tehsil Galiyakot, District Dungarpur, Rajasthan .

----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary Department Of Secondary Education, Secretariat, Jaipur, Rajasthan.

2. Director, Secondary Education Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur, Through Its Chairman Premises Of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 18090/2022

1. Ajay Kumar Yadav S/o Shri Nihal Singh Yadav, Aged About 39 Years, R/o Village - Jodhpura, Post Office -

7

Mohanpura, Tehsil - Kotputli, District - Jaipur, Rajasthan. Presently Residing At C/o Deep Singh Rathore S/o Late Shri Amer Singh Rathore R/o Plot No. 62 B Baldev Nagar, Near Nagar Nigam Jodhpur, District - Jodhpur, Rajasthan.

2. Sandeep S/o Shri Chet Ram, Aged About 35 Years, R/o Village - Untoli, Post - Kohrana, Tehsil - Behror, District - Alwar, Rajasthan.

----Petitioners

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary Department Of Secondary Education, Secretariat, Jaipur, Rajasthan.

2. Director, Secondary Education Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur, Through Its Chairman Premises Of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 18282/2022 Pooja Dadheech W/o Anurag Dadheech, Aged About 41 Years, 12-D, Bapu Nagar, Senthi, Vtc, Chittorgarh, Rajasthan, 312001 ----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Secretary, Department Of Education, Government Of Rajasthan, Secretariat, Jaipur.

2. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Through Its Secretary, Having Office At State Institute Of Agriculture Management Premises, Tonk Rd, Shreeji Nagar, Prithviraj Colony, Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan 302018 ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 18396/2022

Gurpreet Singh S/o Shri Sukhdev Singh, Aged About 36 Years, Resident Of Ward No. 5, Mukund Singh Up Sarpanch Wali Gali, Haripura, 2Stp, Hanumangarh, Rajasthan.

----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through Secretary, Elementary

8

Education, Government Of Rajasthan, Secretariat, Jaipur.

2. Director, Elementary Education, Rajasthan, Bikaner.

3. Rajasthan Subordinate And Ministerial Service Selection Board, Durgapura, Jaipur Through Its Chairman. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 18424/2022

Manju W/o Rajeev Saharan, Aged About 26 Years, Resident Of Jaitsisar, Sardarshahar, District - Churu. ----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary, Department Of Education, Government Of Rajasthan, Secretariat, Jaipur.

2. Rajasthan Subordinate And Ministerial Service Selection Board, State Institute Of Agriculture Management Premise, Durgapura, Jaipur, Through Its Secretary. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 18698/2022

Vijay Singh S/o Shri Harish Chandra, Aged About 36 Years, Resident Of Vpo Phephana, Tehsil Nohar, District Hanumangarh, Rajasthan.

----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through Secretary, Elementary Education, Government Of Rajasthan, Secretariat, Jaipur.

2. Director, Elementary Education, Rajasthan, Bikaner.

3. Rajasthan Subordinate And Ministerial Service Selection Board, Durgapura, Jodhpur Through Its Chairman. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 19542/2022

Om Prakash S/o Shri Rawal Ram, Aged About 28 Years, Resident Of Dayasagar Khara, Tehsil Phalodi, District Jodhpur (Raj.). ----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through Its Principal Secretary, Education Department, Secretariat, Rajasthan, Jaipur.

9

2. The Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, State Institute Of Agriculture Management Premises, Durgapura, Jaipur Through Its Secretary.

3. Director, Secondary Education, Rajasthan, Bikaner. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 19626/2022

1. Sunil Menaria S/o Shri Radheshyam Menaria, Aged About

23 Years, 9/1 Agaravas Bedwas, Tehsil Girwa, District Udaipur, Rajasthan.

2. Nikhil Purbia S/o Shri Prem Chand, Aged About 23 Years, 20, Near Central Jail, Opposite J.c. Boss Hostel, Tekri Road, Udaipur, District Udaipur, Rajasthan. ----Petitioners

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary Department Of Secondary Education, Secretariat, Jaipur.

2. Director, Secondary Education, Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur, Through Its Chairman Premises Of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 19701/2022 Hirendra Singh Rathore S/o Shri Karan Singh Rathore, Aged About 33 Years, Sardar Singh Ki Dhani Mansagar Danwara, Tehsil Bawari, District Jodhpur, Rajasthan.

----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary Department Of Secondary Education, Secretariat, Jaipur, Rajasthan.

2. Dirctor Secondary Education, Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur Through Its Chairman Premises Of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

10

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14/2023 Yogendra Singh S/o Shri Renwant Singh, Aged About 29 Years, Vpo Badoda Gaon, Tehsil And District Jaisalmer, Rajasthan. ----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary Department Of Secondary Education, Secretariat, Jaipur, And Rajasthan.

2. Director, Secondary Education, Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur Through Its Chairman Premises Of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 53/2023

Ummed Singh S/o Shri Devi Singh, Aged About 38 Years, 7 Sinla Market, Ajmer Road, Gajsingh Colony, Jodhpur District Jodhpur, Rajasthan.

----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary Department Of Secondary Education, Secretariat, Jaipur, And Rajasthan.

2. Director, Secondary Education Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur, Through Its Chairman Premises Of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 417/2023

1. Pukhraj Kala S/o Hari Ram, Aged About 26 Years, R/o Near Thakhur Ji Ka Mandir Village Basni Khaleel, Post Gajoo, Tehsil Marwar Mundawa, Dist. Nagaur, Raj.

2. Sunil Inaniyan S/o Om Prakash, Aged About 22 Years, R/o Village Inana, District Nagaur, Rajasthan.

3. Jaiveer Singh S/o Narpat Singh, Aged About 39 Years, R/o Village Merwara, Tehsil Degana, Dist. Nagaur, Rajasthan.

4. Sushila D/o Mohan Ram, Aged About 31 Years, R/o Village

11

Inana, District Nagaur, Rajasthan. ----Petitioners

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary Department Of Secondary Education, Secretariat, Jaipur, And Rajasthan.

2. Director, Secondary Education, Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur Through Its Chairman Premises Of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgarpura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 460/2023

Mukund Joshi S/o Shri Prabhakar Joshi, Aged About 23 Years, R/o 115 Neem Ki Gali, Darjiwara, Khanda Falsa, Jodhpur, District Jodhpur, Rajasthan.

----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary Department Of Secondary Education, Secretariat, Jaipur And Rajasthan.

2. Director, Secondary Education Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur Through Its Chairman Premises Of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 502/2023

1. Shaitan Singh S/o Aashu Ram, Aged About 21 Years, R/o Danta Tehsil Sanchore District Jalore.

2. Shrawan Kumar S/o Keshu Ram, Aged About 23 Years, R/o Sarnau Tehsil Sanchore, District Jalore. ----Petitioners

Versus

Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur, State Agriculture Management Institution Compound, Durgapura, Jaipur. ----Respondent

12

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 503/2023 Mahendra Kumar Yadav S/o Shri Madan Lal Yadav, Aged About

33 Years, R/o Village Bhaloji, Tehsil Kotputli, District Jaipur, Rajasthan. Presently Residing At C/o Deep Singh Rathore S/o Late Shri Amer Singh Rathore R/o Plot No. 62 B Baldev Nagar, Near Nagar Nigam Jodhpur, District Jodhpur, Rajasthan. ----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary Department Of Secondary Education, Secretariat, Jaipur And Rajasthan.

2. Director, Secondary Education Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur Through Its Chairman Premises Of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 550/2023

Kaushal Kishore Vyas S/o Shri Nand Kishore Vyas, Aged About

34 Years, R/o Chand Bawri Mohalla, Ranisar Ghati Old Fort Road, District - Jodhpur, Rajasthan.

----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary Department Of Secondary Education, Secretariat, Jaipur And Rajasthan.

2. Director, Secondary Education Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur, Through Its Chairman Premises Of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 730/2023

Moomal D/o Shri Bheema Ram, Aged About 25 Years, R/o Village Nada, Post Kapuriya, Tehsil Fatehgarh, District Jaisalmer, Rajasthan.

----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary

13

Department Of Secondary Education, Secretariat, Jaipur And Rajasthan.

2. Director, Secondary Education Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur Through Its Chairman Premises Of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 732/2023

Dheeresh Kumar S/o Shri Babu Ram, Aged About 27 Years, R/o V/p Sankara, Tehsil Pokaran, District Jaisalmer, Rajasthan. ----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary Department Of Secondary Education, Secretariat, Jaipur And Rajasthan.

2. Director, Secondary Education Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur Through Its Chairman Premises Of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 988/2023

Deepak Bijawat S/o Late Shri Surendra Kumar, Aged About 36 Years, R/o 2-J-14, Opp. Mahesh Park, Pratap Nagar, Jodhpur, Rajasthan.

----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through Its Principal Secretary, Department Of School Education, Secretariat, Government Of Rajasthan, Jaipur, Rajasthan.

2. The Chairman, Rajasthan Employees Selection Board, Jaipur, Rajasthan.

3. The Secretary, Rajasthan Employees Selection Board, Jaipur, Rajasthan.

4. Board Of Secondary Education Rajasthan, Through Its Secretary, Ajmer, Rajasthan.

----Respondents

14

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 1034/2023 Laxmi D/o Shri Kishnaram W/o Shri Ashok, Aged About 30 Years, Resident Of Karni Colony, Nagaur, (Raj.).

----Petitioner

Versus

1. The State Of Rajasthan, Through Secretary To The Government, Department Of Secondary Education, Rajasthan, Jaipur (Raj.).

2. The Director, Secondary Education, Bikaner.

3. The Secretary, Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Rajya Krishi Prabandh Sansthan Parisar, Durgapura, Jaipur. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 1528/2023

Saroj Kunwar Bhati D/o Shri Bhim Singh Bhati, Aged About 24 Years, R/o Vpo Hingwaniya, Tehsil Kapasan, District Chittorgarh, Rajasthan.

----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary Department Of Secondary Education, Secretariat, Jaipur And Rajasthan.

2. Director, Secondary Education Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur Through Its Chairman Premises Of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 2142/2023

1. Deepak S/o Karna Ram, Aged About 28 Years, R/o Village Narsar, Tehsil Bhopalgarh, District Jodhpur, Rajasthan.

2. Chuna Ram S/o Naru Ram, Aged About 22 Years, R/o Mornawara, Soyla, Dist. Jodhpur, Rajasthan. ----Petitioners

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary Department Of Secondary Education, Secretariat, Jaipur And Rajasthan.

15

2. Director, Secondary Education Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur Through Its Chairman Premises Of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 2638/2023 Gurdeep Mahyach S/o Kedar Mahyach, Aged about 28 years, R/o Ward No.3, VPO Dhandela, District Hanumangarh, Rajasthan.

----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through Secretary Elementary Eduction, Government of Rajasthan, Secretariat, Jaipur.

2. Director, Elementary Education, Rajasthan, Bikaner.

3. Rajasthan Subordinate & Ministerial Service Selection Board, Durgapura, Jaipur through its Chairman. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 1981/2023

Ganesh Ram S/o Syokn Ram, Aged about 30 years, R/o House No.278, Puniya Bass, Kapoorisa, District Bikaner, Rajasthan.

----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through Its Principal Secretary, Department Of School Education, Secretariat, Government Of Rajasthan, Jaipur, Rajasthan.

2. Director, Secondary Education Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur, Through its Chairman Premises of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan. ----Respondents

16

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 299/2023 Ramesh Kumar S/o Shri Ash Ram, Aged about 44 years, R/o Wad No.13, Village Mehariy, Sherara, Tehsil Bhadra, District Hanumangarh.

----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through Its Principal Secretary, Department of Education, Government Of Rajasthan, Jaipur.

2. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur, State Agriculture Management Institute Campus, Durgapura, Jaipur, through its Secretary.

3. Director, Secondary Education, Bikaner. ----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 1306/2023 Ramesh Bishnoi S/o Hansraj Bishnoi, Aged about 25 years, R/o Jivan Natha Ji Ke Bagiche Ke Pas, Bikaner, Rajasthan.

----Petitioner

Versus

1. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur, through its Chairman, State Institute of Agriculture Management Premises, Shreeji Nagar, Prithviraj Colony, Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajatshan.

2. State of Rajathan through Director, Secondary Education Rajasthan, Bikaner.

----Respondents

S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 17222/2022 Birbal Godara S/o Hariram Godara, Aged about 30 years R/o VPO Barsinghsar, District Bikaner. ----Petitioner

Versus

1. State Of Rajasthan, Through the Principal Secretary, Department Of Secondary Education,

17

Secretariat, Jaipur, Rajasthan.

2. Director, Secondary Education Bikaner, Rajasthan.

3. Rajasthan Staff Selection Board, Jaipur, Through its Chairman Premises of State Agriculture Management Institute Durgapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan.

---Respondents

For Petitioner(s) : Mr. Vikas Bijarnia Mr. Tanwar Singh

Mr. Bhawani Singh Ransi for

Mr. Manas Khatri

Mr. Ashvini Kumar

Mr. Raghu Nandan Sharma Through

VC

Mr. M.L. Deora Mr. Shubhendu Chouhan for Mr. K.R. Saharan

Mr. S.K. Shreemali Mr. Devendra Singh Rathore Mr. Inderjeet Yadav Mr. V.D. Vaishnav

Mr. Vikash Choudhary Mr. Yash Pal Khileree Mr. Vineet R.Dave

Mr. R.J. Punia

Mr. Karan Parihar

Mr. Vikram Singh

Mr. Anil Bidan Halu Mr. O.P. Sangwa

Mr. Devendra Singh Rathore For Respondent(s) : Mr. Vinit Sanadhya Mr. Vishal Jangid, Dy.G.C.

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINIT KUMAR MATHUR Order

06/04/2023

Heard learned counsel for the parties. The controversy involved in the present bunch of writ petitions is similar in nature, therefore, they are being disposed of by this common order.

18

For brevity, the prayer of S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.19701/2022 "Hirendra Singh Rathore Vs. State of Rajasthan & Ors." is taken into consideration which reads as under:

"A. By an appropriate writ order or direction, any verbal/written order denying the selection and appointment to the petitioner for the post of PTI in pursuance of the advertisement 16.06.2022 (Annex-1) may kindly be quashed and set aside. B. By an appropriate writ order or direction, result dated 21.10.2022 (Annex-5) and subsequent first and Final answer key in pursuance of the advertisement 16.06.2022 (Annex-1) may kindly be quashed and set aside.

C. By an appropriate writ order or direction, the respondents may kindly be directed to Constitute Expert Committee and relook in the deleted/out of syllabus/multi option and question challenged by the petitioner and award bonus marks/award marks and revise the result in pursuance of the advertisement 16.06.2022 (Annex-1). D. By an appropriate writ order or direction, the respondents may kindly be directed to award Bonus marks for deleted questions/multi option and also award marks for correct answer/out of syllabus questions to the petitioner in pursuance of the advertisement 16.06.2022 (Annex-1) and revise result afresh.

E. By an appropriate writ order or direction, the respondents may kindly be directed to permit the petitioner in the further selection process and afford the appointment to the petitioners on the post of PTI against their respective category if they stand in merit with all consequential benefits in pursuance of the advertisement dated 16.06.2022 (Annex-1)."

Learned counsel for the petitioners submit that the petitioners have appeared in the examination conducted for filling up the posts of Physical Training Instructor (P.T.I.) vide advertisement dated 16.06.2022. After declaration of the result, the answer key was published by the respondents, however, on certain objections being raised, the answer key was referred to the expert committee and a reviewed answer key was published. Learned counsel for the petitioners submit that as per the

19

reviewed and republished answer key, the questions which were adjudicated to be correct in the first answer key have been found to be incorrect and the answers to these questions in the question paper for PTI examination have been changed.

Learned counsel for the petitioners further submit that as per the first answer key published by the respondents, if the numbers obtained by the petitioners are taken into consideration, then they are selected on the basis of the first answer key. However, on review being made, those questions to which the petitioners have answered have not been adjudicated to be correct and therefore, their names do not find place in the merit list. Learned counsel for the petitioners submit that the matter requires reconsideration and an expert commitee may be constituted to re-examine the infirmities mentioned by them in the writ petitions while adjudicating the correct answers to the questions. It is prayed by the petitioners that they will be satisfied, if the contentions raised in support of their correct answers in writ petition are examined by the expert body to be appointed by the respondents. In the aforementioned bunch of writ petitions, there are number of questions which have been mentioned and according to the petitioners, the answers to those questions given by them are correct as per the text books relied upon by them in these writ petitions and therefore, they submit that they should have been awarded marks for the same, but the expert committee has not found those answers to be correct.

On the submissions made by the learned counsel for the petitioner, learned counsel for the respondents were directed to

20

complete the instructions as to whether the expert committee which has examined the objections received on the first answer key can re-consider and re-examine the matter afresh. Learned counsel for the respondents on instructions submit that they will get the contentions/objections of the petitioners re-examined through the expert committee and pass appropriate order after their re-examination.

In view of the contentions raised by the learned counsel for the parties, this Court deems it appropriate to dispose of these writ petitions with a direction to the respondents to reconsider/re- examine the answers to the objectionable questions challenged in these writ petition by the expert committee. While examining the same, the contentions raised in these writ petitions may be considered as objections. The expert committee shall pass the appropriate orders with respect to the adjudication made by them on the objectionable questions raised in the writ petitions. The said exercise of examination by the expert committee shall be completed within a period of six weeks from today. Needless to say, if any change is made in the answers after the re-examination by the expert committee, as a consequence, the result shall also be reshuffled by the respondents. Stay petitions stand disposed of accordingly.

(VINIT KUMAR MATHUR),J

38-44, 46-69, 166 & C-1 to C-4/Vivek/-

21