- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
GUJARAT STATE FERTIL... v. LHS OF DECD. VIHARIB...
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitions arise from execution proceedings initiated following an award dated 28.9.1992 by the Special Land Acquisition Officer for lands acquired by the petitioner company. The petitioner challenged the award for enhancement of compensation before the District Court, Vadodara, which was allowed by the 14th Additional Senior Civil Judge, Vadodara, on 31.8.2018, enhancing the compensation amount. The petitioner contends that no notice was served to them regarding these proceedings. Subsequently, execution proceedings were initiated to enforce the enhanced compensation judgment, during which a Warrant of Attachment dated 10.10.2022 was issued against the petitioner’s movable properties by the 17th Additional Senior Civil Judge, Vadodara. The petitioner filed these petitions seeking to quash and set aside the impugned Warrant of Attachment.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the impugned Warrant of Attachment issued in the execution proceedings is valid in the absence of effective service of notice on the petitioner as required under Order 29 Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC).
- Whether the execution proceedings complied with the requirements of Order 21 Rule 22 of CPC regarding issuance of notice when execution is sought after a significant lapse of time from the date of the decree.
- Whether the petitioner, being a company and not a government company, was properly served through the Collector as claimed by the respondents.
- The scope of the High Court's supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India in interfering with the execution proceedings.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner’s Arguments
- The cause title of the execution proceedings mentions service of notice through the Collector, Vadodara, but the petitioner was not effectively served as required under Order 29 Rules 1 and 2 CPC.
- Execution proceedings were initiated after nearly four years from the date of the award without issuing or serving the petitioner any notice, violating Order 21 Rule 22 CPC.
- The petitioner is not a government company, contrary to the respondents’ claim, and thus service through the Collector is not valid.
- Reliance was placed on the judgment in Satyanarain Bajoria and another v. Ramnarain Tibrewal and another (1993) 4 SCC 414, emphasizing the necessity of effective notice service in execution proceedings.
- Also relied on M/s Shalimar Rope Works Ltd. v. M/s Abdul Hussain H.M.Hasanbhai Rassiwala and Others (1980) 3 SCC 595 concerning service on corporations under Order 29 Rule 2(b) CPC.
- Invoked the High Court’s supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution to challenge the impugned order as it prejudices the petitioner’s rights by depriving it of an opportunity to represent its case.
Respondents’ Arguments
- Notice was issued by the Executing Court on 2.7.2022, and thus it cannot be said that no notice was issued prior to the impugned order.
- Although the record is unclear on actual service, the petitioner being a government company, service through the Collector is proper and valid.
- Therefore, there is no justification for interference with the impugned Warrant of Attachment.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Satyanarain Bajoria and another v. Ramnarain Tibrewal and another, (1993) 4 SCC 414 | Requirement of effective service of notice in execution proceedings under CPC | The Court relied on this precedent to emphasize that absence of effective notice service violates procedural safeguards and warrants interference under Article 227. |
| M/s Shalimar Rope Works Ltd. v. M/s Abdul Hussain H.M.Hasanbhai Rassiwala and Others, (1980) 3 SCC 595 | Service on corporations under Order 29 Rule 2(b) CPC | The Court used this case to clarify the proper mode of service on companies and rejected the respondents’ claim that petitioner could be served through the Collector as a government company. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the procedural requirements under Order 29 Rules 1 and 2 and Order 21 Rule 22 of the CPC concerning service of notice in execution proceedings against a corporation. It found that the notice was not effectively served on the petitioner company as required by law, which prejudiced the petitioner’s right to represent its case. The Court rejected the respondents’ contention that service through the Collector was valid by noting that the petitioner is not a government company. The Court invoked its supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution to quash the impugned Warrants of Attachment. It emphasized the necessity of adherence to procedural safeguards to ensure fairness in execution proceedings and directed the petitioner to be given an opportunity to appear and raise contentions before the Executing Court. The Court also noted the respondent’s interest in receiving the awarded amount but underscored that such interest cannot override due process requirements.
Holding and Implications
The Court allowed the petitions and quashed and set aside the impugned Warrants of Attachment dated 10.10.2022 issued by the 17th Additional Senior Civil Judge, Vadodara. The amount deposited before the Registry pursuant to an earlier order was directed to be transferred to the Executing Court within one week. The petitioner was permitted to appear and raise all necessary contentions in the execution proceedings, which the Executing Court must consider expeditiously and in accordance with law, after hearing the parties.
This decision directly affects the parties by setting aside the attachment order for non-compliance with procedural requirements but does not establish any new legal precedent beyond reinforcing existing principles of notice and fair procedure in execution proceedings.
C/SCA/39/2023 ORDER DATED: 29/04/2023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 39 of 2023 With
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 42 of 2023
==========================================================
GUJARAT STATE FERTILIZERS AND CHEMICALS LTD.
Versus
LHS OF DECD. VIHARIBHAI FULABHAI PATEL, LH OF DECD
NARSHINBHAI VIHARIBHAI PATEL
========================================================== Appearance:
MR MIHIR JOSHI, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MR KUNAL VYAS FOR
GANDHI LAW ASSOCIATES(12275) for the Petitioner(s) No. 1 for the Respondent(s) No. 1,2,3
MR HRIDAY BUCH, for the Respondent(s) No.
1.1,1.2,1.3,2.1,2.2,3.1,3.2,4,5,6
MS SUMAN MOTLA, AGP for the Respondent(s) No. 7 ==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SANDEEP N. BHATT
Date : 29/04/2023
COMMON ORAL ORDER
1. These petitions are filed for quashing and setting the impugned Warrant of Attachment dated 10.10.2022 issued by learned 17thAdditional Senior Civil Judge, Vadodara in Exe.LAR No.23 of 2022 and Exe.LAR No 22 of 2022 respectively.
2. The brief facts leading to filing of these petitions are as such that the Special Land Acquisition Officer passed an award dated 28.9.1992 for the lands acquired by the petitioner company in Land Reference
Page 1 of 9
Cases which was challenged for enhancement of compensation before the District Court, Vadodara. The said Reference Cases were allowed by the 14thAdditional Senior Civil Judge, Vadodara vide order dated 31.8.2018 and enhanced the amount of compensation. It is averred in the petitions that no notice was served to the petitioner company regarding the said proceedings.
3. It is averred that thereafter the Execution proceedings were filed for execution of the judgment and order dated 31.8.2018, in which the learned civil Court, Vadodara issued the impugned Warrant of Attachment of movable properties of the petitioner company. Hence, these petitions are filed.
4. Heard learned senior advocate Mr.Mihir Joshi assisted by learned advocate Mr.Kunal Vyas for the petitioner, learned advocate Mr.Hriday Buch for the private respondents and learned AGP Ms.Suman Motla for respondent-Special Land Acquisition Officer.
5. Learned senior advocate Mr.Joshi has raised essentially two important contentions; firstly, by drawing
Page 2 of 9
my attention to the cause title of the execution proceedings, that it is mentioned therein that General Manager, Gujarat State Fertilizers Company, Polymer Unit, Ranoli, Ta.Dist.Vadodara and notice to be served through the Collector, Vadodara, and submitted that as per the provisions of Order 29 Rules 1 and 2 of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (`CPC' for short), the notice is not effectively served on the present petitioner and secondly, by drawing attention to the provisions to Order 21 Rule 22 of CPC and submitted that though the execution proceedings are filed after almost four years from the date of award, no notice is issued or served on the present petitioner.
6. Learned senior advocate Mr.Joshi relied on the judgment in the case of Satyanarain Bajoria and another V/s Ramnarain Tibrewal and another, reported in (1993)
4 SCC 414, more particularly, paragraph 13 therein, and submitted that in absence of effective service of notice to the petitioner, the impugned order passed by the Executing Court against the present petitioner is required to be interfered with by this Court by exercising supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the
Page 3 of 9
Constitution of India and it is not in consonance with law.
7. Per Contra, learned advocate Mr.Buch for the private respondents has strongly objected to the submissions made on behalf of the petitioner and submitted that notice is issued on 2.7.2022 by the Executing Court and therefore it cannot be said that no notice is issued prior to passing of the impugned order. However, it is not clear from the record that notice is served and therefore he has made a further statement that the petitioner being a government company and notice is served through Collector, it can be considered as proper service and therefore there is no reason for this Court to interfere with the impugned order.
8. Learned senior advocate Mr.Joshi submitted that the petitioner is not a government company, as submitted by learned advocate Mr.Buch for the private respondents, and in actual sense, it is not government company. In support of the contention, he relied on the judgment in the case of M/s Shalimar Rope Works Ltd. V/s M/s Abdul Hussain H.M.Hasanbhai Rassiwala and
Page 4 of 9
Others, reported in (1980) 3 SCC 595, which pertains to Order 29, Rule 2(b) of CPC.
"Order 29 of CPC reads as under:
"1. Subscription and verification of pleading. In suits by or against a corporation, any pleading may be signed and verified on behalf of the corporation by the secretary or by any director or other principal officer of the corporation who is able to depose to the facts of the case.
2. Service on corporation. Subject to any statutory provision regulating service of process, where the suit is against a corporation, the summons may be served ___
(a) on the secretary, or on any director, or other principal officer of the corporation, or
(b) by leaving it or sending it by post addressed to the corporation at the registered office, or if there is no registered office then at the place where the corporation carries on business."
Order 21 Rule 22 of CPC reads as under:
22. Notice to show cause against execution in certain cases.__(1) Where an application for execution is made __
(a) more than one year after the date of the decree, or (b) against the legal representative of a party to the decree, 1 [or where an application is made for execution of a decree
Page 5 of 9
filed under the provisions of section 44A,] the Court executing the decree shall issue a notice to the person against whom execution is applied for requiring him to show cause, on a date to be fixed, why the decree should not be executed against him:
Provided that no such notice shall be necessary in consequence of more than one year having elapsed between the date of the decree and the application for execution if the application is made within one year from the date of the last order against the party against whom execution is applied for, made on any previous application for execution, or in consequence of the application being made against the legal representative of the judgmentdebtor, if upon a previous application for execution against the same person the Court has ordered execution to issue against him.
(2) Nothing in the foregoing subrule shall be deemed to preclude the Court from issuing any process in execution of a decree without issuing the notice thereby prescribed, if, for reasons to be recorded, it considers that the issue of such notice would cause unreasonable delay or would defeat the ends of justice."
9. Considering the rival submissions made at the bar and considering the provisions of Order 29 Rule 1 of CPC, it clearly transpires that there is violation of
Page 6 of 9
necessary procedure about the service of notice to the corporation or company and on this count only that no notice is served as required under the law to the petitioner, the interference of this Court is required as it amounts to causing prejudice to the rights of the present petitioner and depriving it to represent its case.
10. Article 227 of the Constitution of India reads as under:
"227. [(1) Every High Court shall have superintendence over all courts and tribunals throughout the territories in relation to which it exercises jurisdiction.]
(2) Without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing provision, the High Court may—
(a) call for returns from such courts;
(b) make and issue general rules and prescribe forms for regulating the practice and proceedings of such courts; and
(c) prescribe forms in which books, entries and accounts shall be kept by the officers of any such courts.
(3) The High Court may also settle tables of fees to be allowed to the sheriff and all clerks and officers of such courts and to attorneys, advocates and pleaders practising therein: Provided that any rules made, forms prescribed or tables settled under clause (2) or clause (3) shall not be
Page 7 of 9
inconsistent with the provision of any law for the time being in force, and shall require the previous approval of the Governor.
(4) Nothing in this article shall be deemed to confer on a High Court powers of superintendence over any court or tribunal constituted by or under any law relating to the Armed Forces."
11. Considering the above facts and circumstances of the case, these petitions are allowed. The impugned Warrants of Attachment 10.10.2022 issued by learned 17th Additional Senior Civil Judge, Vadodara in Exe.LAR No.23 of 2022 and Exe.LAR No 22 of 2022 respectively are quashed and set aside. The amount deposited before the Registry of this Court pursuant to the order dated 3.1.2023 passed by coordinate Bench of this Court be transferred to the Executing Court within a period of one week from today. It is appropriate to observe that the petitioner may appear in the execution proceedings, raise all necessary contentions and make prayers, which shall be considered by the Executing Court as expeditiously as possible after giving opportunity of hearing to the parties, in accordance with law. It is also relevant to note that respondent is also waiting for the
Page 8 of 9
amount awarded by the Reference Court.
12. With the above observation, these petitions are allowed.
(SANDEEP N. BHATT,J)
SRILATHA
Page 9 of 9
Alert