- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Subhash Tiwari And 5 Others v. State of U.P. and Another
Court No. - 65 Case :- APPLICATION U/S 482 No. - 12167 of 2023
Applicant :- Subhash Tiwari And 5 Others
Opposite Party :- State of U.P. and Another
Counsel for Applicant :- Maya Pati Pandey
Counsel for Opposite Party :- G.A.
Hon'ble Rajiv Gupta,J.
Heard learned counsel for the applicants, learned AGA for the State and perused the record.
This application under Section 482 CrPC has been filed against the order dated 19.11.2022 passed by Sessions Judge, Siddharth Nagar in Sessions Trial No. 587 of 2021 (State Vs. Subhash Tiwari and Others), arising out of Case Crime No. 22 of 2019, by which charges have been framed against the applicants for the offence under Sections 147, 148, 323, 504, 325/149, 506, 308/149, 452/149 IPC, Police Station Pathra Bazar, District Siddharth Nagar.
The only submission made by learned counsel for the applicants is that offence under Section 308 IPC is not made out against the applicants as the injuries sustained by the injured, are simple in nature.
Per contra, learned AGA has drawn the attention of the Court to the statement of the victim Madhuri Devi recorded under Section 161 CrPC, in which, she has categorically stated that on the date of incident at about 7:30 PM, when she was all alone in her house, on account of land dispute, the applicants, who were five in number, forcibly entered in her house armed with lathi, danda and ballam and started hurling abuses by extending death threats to her. On account of assault made by the applicants, she suffered serious injuries and fell unconscious and thereafter, she was taken to the hospital for the medical treatment and she is still undergoing treatment.
Learned AGA has further submitted that even Doctor, in his statement, has submitted that injuries sustained by the victim may or may not cause death, which shall be determined on recording of evidence during the course of trial, however, at this stage it will be premature to hold that the offence under Section 308 IPC is not made out
1
against the applicants. Having considered the rival submissions made by learned counsel for the parties and taking into consideration the statement of the victim as well as the Doctor and the injury report, whether the case would fall under Section 308 or 324 IPC could be decided by the trial court only after the evaluation of entire oral evidence that may be led by the prosecution as well as by the defence that may come on record. Ultimately, upon appreciation of the entire evidence on record at the end of the trial, the trial court may take one view or the other i.e. whether it is a case of attempt to commit culpable homicide or voluntarily causing hurt by the dangerous weapons. But at the stage of framing of the charge, the trial court could not reach to such a conclusion merely relying upon the injury report on record. Once, the trial court decides to discharge an accused from the offence punishable under Section 308 IPC and proceeds to frame the lesser charge for the offence punishable under Section 324 IPC, the prosecution thereafter would not in a position to lead any evidence beyond the charge as framed. In such, circumstances, in the facts of the present case, it would be more prudent to permit the prosecution to lead appropriate evidence whatever its worth in accordance with its original case as put in the charge-sheet. Such approach of the trial court at times may prove to be more rational and prudent as held by the Hon'ble Apex Court in
Special Leave to Petition (Criminal) No. 4599 of 2021 (Ghulam Hassan Beigh Vs. Mohammad Maqbool Magrey and Others).
In view of the aforesaid proposition of law laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court, I am of the considered opinion that the order passed by the court below framing charge against the applicant under Section 308 IPC is just, proper and legal and do not call for any interference at this stage.
Present application under Section 482 CrPC is devoid of merits and is accordingly dismissed.
Order Date :- 18.4.2023
Nadim
2
Alert