Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Seshdhar v. Harihar Nath And Another

Allahabad High Court
Dec 7, 2016

Court No. - 19 Case :- SECOND APPEAL No. - 1243 of 2016

Appellant :- Seshdhar

Respondent :- Harihar Nath And Another

Counsel for Appellant :- Ramesh Chandra Shukla,Murli Dhar Mishra

Hon'ble Raghvendra Kumar,J.

Heard learned counsel for the plaintiff appellant. Initially the plaintiff Seshdhar initially preferred an Original suit No. 161 of 2003 against Harihar Nath and Others for the relief of injunction. The learned Trial Court after appreciating the pleadings and the evidence available on record dismissed the suit. Being aggrieved by aforesaid judgment of the Trial Court a First Appeal was preferred by the plaintiff-appellant before the First Appellate Court, which was dismissed vide order dated 17.9.2016. Being aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment & order passed by the Learned Courts below, the instant second appeal is before this Court.

At the very outset, the learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the dispute is with respect to the land marked by Letters 'Pa', 'Pha', 'Ba', 'Bha' in the site plan annexed with the plaint, which is the part of Khasra plot No. 54 and which is owned by plaintiff.

Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the dispute is with respect to a wall raised by the defendants, According to the plaintiff, the wall exists on Plot No. 54 whereas, according to the defendant it exists on Khasra Plot No. 62. Further submission is that the findings, if any,

1

recorded by the learned Criminal Court in respect of proceedings under Section 133 Cr.P.C. is not binding upon the Civil Court. Further submission is that the learned Courts below have failed to take recourse to the Order 16 Rule 14 of C.P.C. It has further been submitted that the learned Court below has failed to appreciate the evidence in its right perspective. During the course of submission learned counsel for the appellant conceded that the Gaon Sabha and the State of U.P. have not been impleaded as parties in the suit instituted by the plaintiff-appellant. So far as the invoking of jurisdiction by the learned Courts below under Order 16 Rule 14 C.P.C is concerned, Order 16 deals with the summoning and securing the attendance of witness and is not attracted.

The Court is not obliged to collect the evidence for benefit of the either party.

From the perusal of record, it is evident that no Survey Commission was issued nor prayer for issuance of Survey Commission was ever made on behalf of the plaintiff- appellant before the Trial Court for establishing the existance of wall on Khasra Plot No. 54 or 62 (which belongs to the Gaon Sabha). There is a specific provision under Order 26 Rule 9 C.P.C. It has been incorporated in the C.P.C. so as to facilitate the parties to establish their pleadings by way of commission. In the absence of Survey Commission, it cannot be opined as to whether the wall exists over the Khasra Plot No. 54 or 62?

The legal position is crystal clear that it is primary obligation of the plaintiff to establish his pleadings by way of cogent and direct evidence.

2

Learned Courts Below have recorded a concurrent finding of the facts that the plaintiff has failed to established that the land marked by letters 'Pa, Pha, Ba, Bha' is the part of Khasra Plot No. 54.

From the critical appraisal of the pleadings and evidence and judgments of the Court's below their appears no perversity in the findings recorded by the learned Court's below nor the findings have been recorded in absence of evidence nor the learned Court's below have committed any mistake of misreading of the evidence. In view of the aforesaid discussions the appeal is bereft of merits and is, accordingly, dismissed.

Order Date :- 7.12.2016 Swati

3