Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Chinmay Gurunath Parale v. State Of Maharashtra...

Bombay High Court
Apr 12, 2023
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner seeks relief under Section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 ("MRTP Act") invoking the deeming fiction that a reservation in a development plan lapses where acquisition is not completed within prescribed periods. The land at issue was reserved for a children's play park by respondent no. 3 in the Development Plan published on 15.12.2004 (Reservation No. 8/31). The petitioner purchased the land by Sale Deed dated 30.12.2012.

The petitioner served a purchase notice dated 21.02.2018 under Section 127 on respondent no. 3 because respondent no. 3 had not taken steps to acquire the land for over ten years. Respondent no. 3 did not respond to that notice. After more than two and a half years, the petitioner issued another notice on 17.11.2020 asking respondent no. 1 to notify lapsing of the reservation due to non-acquisition within 24 months from service of the purchase notice. No steps were taken by the respondents, and the petitioner filed the present writ petition. The Court heard the matter and reserved final orders; the Rule was made returnable forthwith and heard finally by consent.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the reservation under the Development Plan (Reservation No. 8/31) for a children's play park has lapsed under Section 127 of the MRTP Act because acquisition was not completed within the statutory period.
  2. Whether a purchase notice under Section 127 of the MRTP Act is invalid if documents evidencing title and interest are not annexed to the notice.
  3. Whether a purchase notice is invalid for inadequate description of the land (including incorrect town planning scheme number) under Section 127 of the MRTP Act.
  4. Whether a single owner's purchase notice can result in lapsing of reservation with respect to only that owner's land when the reserved area comprises multiple survey numbers and other owners have not issued notices.
  5. Whether, in the circumstances, the Court should direct a conditional period (for example, one year) to permit the Planning Authority to acquire the land before declaring reservation lapsed.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner invoked Section 127 MRTP Act asserting that reservation had lapsed because respondent no. 3 had not acquired the land reserved for a children's play park within the statutory periods following the Development Plan coming into force.
  • The petitioner served a purchase notice on 21.02.2018 and, after no acquisition steps, a further notice on 17.11.2020 asking for notification of lapsing. The petitioner asserted entitlement to relief under Section 127 due to non-acquisition.
  • The purchase notice described the land (CTS No. 1608/13, Plot No. 75, Civil Lines, Solapur) and referenced Reservation No. 8/31; the petitioner maintained that the description was sufficient for identification and compliant with Section 127.

Respondent No. 3's Arguments

  • The primary contention was that the petitioner did not annex documents showing title and interest to the purchase notice; respondent no. 3 submitted that non-supply of those documents vitiates the notice and renders it invalid under the mandatory wording of Section 127.
  • Respondent no. 3 argued the purchase notice was defective for not describing the land in sufficient detail and for incorrectly mentioning T.P. Scheme No. 2 instead of T.P. Scheme No. 3, making the notice invalid under Section 127.
  • Respondent no. 3 further contended that because the reservation comprised multiple city survey numbers and other owners had not issued purchase notices, the reservation could not be deleted in part based on a single owner's notice, and therefore the petition was not maintainable.
  • As a final or alternative contention, respondent no. 3 sought a conditional order giving the Municipal Corporation (respondent no. 3) an opportunity to acquire the land within a specified period (one year), relying on a prior Division Bench order in Ramchandra Laxminarayan Soni.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Municipal Corporation Greater Bombay v. Dr. Hakimwadi Tenants' Association (1988 Supp SCC 55) Section 127 requires a valid purchase notice but does not contemplate a detailed investigation into title by Planning Authority officers; the authority must be prima facie satisfied of ownership but cannot frustrate the running of time by requisitioning information when it already has records. The Court relied on this to hold that absence of annexed title documents was not fatal where the Planning Authority was already aware of or had access to records indicating the petitioner's title/ownership.
Popat Kisan Mhaske v. Hon'ble Minister of Urban Development, Mumbai ((2018) 2 Mah LJ 435) Municipal correspondence evidencing title can make non-issuance of requisite documents with the purchase notice non-fatal to validity of the notice. The Court cited this decision to support the view that correspondence of respondent no. 3 showing awareness of petitioner's title meant the purchase notice without annexures could not be held invalid.
Shri Ramchandra Shankar Joshi v. State of Maharashtra (2016 (1) ALL Mr. 1) Precondition that a purchase notice must describe the land with sufficient clarity as required by Section 127. The Court referred to this authority when assessing whether the petitioner's notice described the land sufficiently and concluded that the description given was adequate.
C.V. Shan and A.V. Bhat v. State of Maharashtra ((2006) 3 Bom CR 216) Requirement that notice must describe the land clearly for the authority to identify the property. Relied upon in evaluating sufficiency of the land description in the petitioner's notice; Court found compliance.
Shri Jeevan Mallapa Tonemare v. The Chief Officer, Kankavali Nagar Panchayat (2022 (3) ALL Mr. 321) Reiterates that a purchase notice must describe land with sufficient clarity under Section 127. Used by the Court as part of the authorities establishing standards for sufficiency of description; Court held the petitioner's notice met those standards.
Girnar Traders v. State of Maharashtra ((2007) 7 SCC 55) Section 127 aims either to utilize reserved land for the reserved purpose within time or let the owner utilize it; steps must be towards acquisition (actual commencement), and authorities cannot frustrate the scheme by taking steps that will not culminate in acquisition. The Court relied on this principle to conclude that failure by the authority to take acquisition steps within the statutory period triggers the deeming fiction of lapse under Section 127.
Piyush s/o Pradeep Sejpal v. State of Maharashtra (Writ Petition No. 3417/2019) Even if the area under a reservation exceeds the land owned by the person issuing the notice, that person is entitled to a declaration of lapsing of reservation only with regard to the land owned by him. The Court applied this to reject respondent no. 3's argument that all owners must issue notices; the petitioner could obtain lapsing only as to his land.
Ramchandra Laxminarayan Soni v. State of Maharashtra (Writ Petition No. 6542/2021 — Division Bench) Division Bench had directed conditional release of land from reservation subject to a one-year bar on use and gave Planning Authority liberty to acquire within that period (relying on Hiraman Sitaram Deorukhar). The Court considered this decision but held it was not helpful to respondent no. 3 because of subsequent Supreme Court pronouncements (Laxmikant) limiting the precedential effect.
Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai v. Hiraman Sitaram Deorukhar ((2019) 14 SCC 411) Division Bench's direction permitting acquisition during a conditional period was issued under Article 142 in differing circumstances. The Court noted that directions in Hiraman Sitaram Deorukhar were issued under Article 142 and that their precedential effect was called into question by a later Supreme Court decision (Laxmikant).
Laxmikant v. State of Maharashtra ((2022) 7 SCC 252) The Supreme Court set aside a direction of another Division Bench that had allowed landowners to use land subject to a one-year bar while permitting Planning Authority to acquire during that period; held that the earlier direction (Hiraman Sitaram Deorukhar) given under Article 142 does not operate as a binding precedent for courts under Article 141/144. The Court relied on Laxmikant to find that the earlier Division Bench decision in Ramchandra Laxminarayan Soni could not be used to require a conditional one-year period for acquisition in this case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began with a textual reading of Section 127 MRTP Act: reservation lapses where acquisition is not completed within ten years from the date a final regional/development plan comes into force (or if a declaration under s.126 is not published), and if, after service of a valid purchase notice, the land is not acquired or no steps have been commenced for acquisition within twenty four months of that service, the reservation shall be deemed to have lapsed and the land released for the owner's permissible development.

The Court analysed the statutory requirement that documents showing title and interest be supplied with a purchase notice. It explained the object of that requirement: to enable the authority to know whether the person issuing notice has a valid title or interest and to be prima facie satisfied about the ownership/interest. However, the Court observed that Section 127 does not contemplate a full investigation of title by officers of the Planning Authority.

Applying these principles to the facts, the Court noted correspondence dated 27.12.2017 from respondent no. 3 and respondent no. 2 which indicated that respondent no. 3 was aware that the petitioner was the owner of the land. Given that awareness, the purpose of annexing title documents was satisfied and the absence of annexures to the purchase notice dated 21.02.2018 was not fatal to its validity.

The Court then examined the contention about defective description. It found the purchase notice described the land as CTS No. 1608/13, Plot No. 75, Civil Lines, Solapur and referenced Reservation No. 8/31. The Court held this description was sufficient for identification. The incorrect mention of a T.P. Scheme number was not decisive because there is no requirement under Section 127 to state the T.P. Scheme number and respondent no. 3, as Planning Authority, is aware of the relevant T.P. Scheme and the Development Plan.

The argument that a single owner's notice cannot result in deletion of part of the reservation was rejected. The Court relied on Section 127's language and the prior decision in Piyush s/o Pradeep Sejpal to hold that a person is entitled to a declaration of lapsing with regard only to the land owned by him even if the reservation covers larger area.

On the question whether any steps towards acquisition were taken within 24 months of the valid notice, the Court found none had been taken by respondent no. 3 or other respondents. Relying on Girnar Traders and other authorities, the Court reiterated that only steps that amount to commencement of acquisition will avert lapsing; perfunctory or non-commencing steps will not suffice.

Finally, the Court addressed respondent no. 3's request for a conditional order giving the authority one year to acquire the land (relying on Ramchandra Laxminarayan Soni). The Court examined the precedential force of that decision and, referring to the Supreme Court's subsequent decision in Laxmikant which limited the binding effect of Hiraman Sitaram Deorukhar (directives issued under Article 142), concluded that Ramchandra Laxminarayan Soni was not helpful to respondent no. 3 and declined to grant a conditional one-year period for acquisition.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court held that the reservation over the petitioner's land (Reservation No. 8/31 for children's play park) has lapsed under Section 127 of the MRTP Act because no steps were taken for acquisition within the statutory periods after service of a valid purchase notice. The petition was allowed and the Rule was made absolute.

Direct Effect: The reservation in respect of the petitioner's land stands lapsed and the land is released from that reservation, making it available to the owner for development as otherwise permissible. There was no order as to costs.

Implications: The Court applied established principles from higher and co-ordinate courts about the limited role of Planning Authority officers in investigating title, the sufficiency of prima facie satisfaction of ownership, the standard for sufficiency of description in a purchase notice, and the requirement that authorities must take concrete steps toward acquisition to prevent lapse. The opinion did not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond applying and distinguishing earlier decisions (including noting the limited applicability of certain Division Bench directions in light of the Supreme Court's ruling in Laxmikant).

Show all summary ...

M.W. Chandwani, J.:— Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Heard finally by consent.

2. The petition seeks to invoke the deeming fiction of lapsing of reservation under Section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (hereinafter referred to as “MRTP Act”).

3. The land in question has been reserved for children's play park under reservation no. 8/31 by respondent no. 3 in development plan (hereinafter referred to as “D.P. Plan”) published on 15.12.2004. The petitioner purchased the said land vide Sale Deed dated 30.12.2012. Since, for a period of more than 10 years, respondent no. 3 did not take any step for acquisition of the petitioner's land, the petitioner served a notice dated 21.02.2018 under Section 127 of the MRTP Act to the respondent no. 3 for purchase of petitioner's land covered under the reservation for children's play park. Respondent no. 3 did not respond to the said purchase notice. After waiting for a period of more than 2½ years, the petitioner issued another notice on 17.11.2020, asking respondent no. 1 for notifying lapsing of reservation due to non-acquisition of the land by respondent no. 3 for the purpose of development of children's play park within 24 months after the receipt of purchase notice issued by the petitioner. No steps were taken by any of the respondents, therefore, the present petition came to be filed.

4. We have heard learned Counsel Mr. Godbole appearing for the petitioner and learned Counsel for respondent no. 3 Mr. Kumbhkoni. We have perused the record. The deeming fiction of lapsing reservation is contained in Section 127 of MRTP Act.

5. A bare reading of Section 127 of the MRTP Act makes it clear that reservation would lapse in case acquisition is not completed within ten years from the date on which a final regional plan or final development plan comes into force or if declaration under sub-section (2) or (4) of Section 126 is not published in the Official Gazette within such period, the owner or any person interested in the land may serve notice for purchase on the Planning Authority, Development Authority, or as the case may be to the appropriate authority; and if within twenty four months from the date of the service of such notice, the land is not acquired or no steps are commenced for its acquisition, the reservation, allotment or designation shall be deemed to have lapsed, and thereupon the land shall be deemed to be released from such reservation, allotment or designation and shall become available to the owner for the purpose of development, as otherwise permissible in the case of adjacent land at the relevant time.

6. Learned Counsel Mr. Kumbhakoni appearing on behalf of respondent no. 3 submits that the petitioner did not annex the documents showing his title and interest in the land in question. He vehemently submits that if the documents showing title and interest of the petitioner in the said land have not been served on the Planning Authority along with purchase notice, the said notice will be vitiated. According to him, mandatory compliance mentioned in Section 127 of the MRTP Act i.e. submitting of documents showing title and interest in the land in question along with purchase notice, has not been complied by the petitioner, therefore, purchase notice dated 21.02.2018 issued by the petitioner is not a valid notice.

7. No doubt, Section 127 of the MRTP Act contemplates serving of document of title and interest in the property along with notice to the Planning Authority or Development Authority or Competent Authority, as the case may be. Object and purpose of supplying the copy showing the title and interest of the person is that the Corporation must know whether the person issuing notice has valid title or interest in the property or not, in case of acquisition of property. Another object appears to be that the Corporation must prima facie be satisfied that the notice served was by the owner of the affected land or a person interested in the land. Though the corporation must satisfy prima facie regarding ownership or interest in the property, Section 127 of the MRTP Act does not contemplate an investigation into title by the Officer of the Planning Authority.

8. Having found the object of supplying the copy of document of title and interest enumerated under Section 127 of the MRTP Act, let's turn to the facts of the case in hand.

9. Letter dated 27.12.2017 by respondent no. 3 addressed to the Principal Secretary, Urban Development Department and letter dated 27.12.2017 of respondent no. 2 addressed to respondent no. 3 depict that respondent no. 3 is aware of the fact that the petitioner is the owner of the land under reservation for children's play park. Thus, the object of supplying copy of document of title and interest in the property in question to respondent no. 3 to enable it to acquire the property from its owner is fulfilled. In these peculiar circumstances, purchase notice served on respondent no. 3 without annexing the document of title and interest in the property in question will not be fatal.

10. We find support to our observations from the decision of Supreme Court in Municipal Corporation Greater Bombay v. Dr. Hakimwadi Tenants' Association reported in 1988 Supp SCC 55, where in paragraph 7, it has held as under:—

“7. According to the plain reading of Section 127 of the Act, it is manifest that the question whether the reservation has lapsed due to the failure of the Planning Authority to take any steps within a period of six months of the date of service of the notice of purchase as stipulated by Section 127, is a mixed question of fact and law. It would therefore be difficult, if not well nigh impossible, to lay down a rule of universal application. It cannot be posited that the period of six months would necessarily begin to run from the date of service of a purchase notice under Section 127 of the Act. The condition prerequisite for the running of time under Section 127 is the service of a valid purchase notice. It is needless to stress that the Corporation must prima facie be satisfied that the notice served was by the owner of the affected land or any person interested in the land. But, at the same time, Section 127 of the Act does not contemplate an investigation into title by the officers of the Planning Authority, nor can the officers prevent the running of time if there is a valid notice. Viewed in that perspective, the High Court rightly held that the Executive Engineer of the Municipal Corporation was not justified in addressing the letter dated July 29, 1977 by which he required respondents nos. 4-7, the trustees, to furnish information regarding their title and ownership, and also to furnish particulars of the tenants, the nature and user of the tenements and the total area occupied by them at present. The Corporation had the requisite information in their records. The High Court was therefore right in reaching the conclusion that it did. In the present case, the Planning Authority was the Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay. It cannot be doubted that the Municipal Corporation has access to all land records including the records pertaining to cadastral survey no. 176 of Tardeo. We are inclined to the view that the aforesaid letter dated July 28, 1977 addressed by the Executive Engineer was just as attempt to prevent the running of time and was of little or no consequence. As was rightly pointed out by respondents nos. 4-7 in their reply dated August 3, 1977, there was no question of the period of six months being reckoned from the date of the receipt from them of the information requisitioned. The Municipal Corporation had been assessing the trust properties to property tax and issuing periodic bills and receipts therefor and obviously could not question the title or ownership of the trust. We are informed that the building being situate on Falkland Road, the occupants are mostly dancing girls and this is in the knowledge of the Corporation authorities. The rateable value of each tenement would also be known by an inspection of the assessment registers. We must accordingly uphold the finding arrived at by the High Court that the appellant having failed to take any steps, namely, of making an application to the State Government for acquiring the land under the Land Acquisition Act within a period of six months from the date of service of the purchase notice, the impugned notification issued by the State Government under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act making the requisite declaration that such land was required for a public purpose i.e. for a recreation ground was invalid, null and void.”

11. It will be also profitable to refer the decision of this Court in Popat Kisan Mhaske v. Hon'ble Minister of Urban Development, Mumbai reported in (2018) 2 Mah LJ 435, wherein it has been held that correspondence of the Municipal Corporation evidencing the title of the land in the name of the person who issued purchase notice and, therefore, non-issuance of requisite documents together with purchase notice cannot render invalid the purchase notice.

12. The correspondence of respondent no. 3 referred to above speaks a lot about title and interest of the petitioner in land in question, which is sufficient for respondent no. 3 to prima facie satisfy itself that the notice is served by the owner of the affected land. The purchase notice dated 21.02.2018 issued by the petitioner cannot be said to be invalid for non-serving of the document of title and interest of the petitioner in affected land along with purchase notice.

13. The learned Counsel for respondent no. 3 vehemently submits that the purchase notice issued by the petitioner is also defective on the ground that it does not describe the land/property in detail. According to him, the description of the land has not been mentioned in the notice and also the petitioner has incorrectly mentioned T.P. Scheme No. 2 instead of T.P. Scheme No. 3 in the purchase notice, therefore, the notice issued by the petitioner is not valid notice as contemplated under Section 127 of the MRTP Act.

14. According to the leaned Counsel for respondent no. 3, if the purchase notice does not describe the proper description of the property, it is not proper notice as required under Section 127 of the MRTP Act, therefore, the petition is liable to be dismissed. To buttress his submission, he seeks to rely on the following cases;

1. Shri Ramchandra Shankar Joshi v. The State of Maharashtra reported in 2016 (1) ALL Mr. 1,

2. C.V. Shan and A.V. Bhat v. State of Maharashtra reported in (2006) 3 Bom CR 216 and

3. Shri Jeevan Mallapa Tonemare v. The Chief Officer, Kankavali Nagar Panchayat reported in 2022 (3) ALL Mr. 321.

15. The common thread running through in all these decisions is as follows:

“The precondition for the land owner or the person interested to claim benefit under the provisions of Section 127 of the Act, 1966 would be to give proper notice describing the land in sufficient clarity and intimating the concerned authority in clear terms.”

16. We have gone through the purchase notice dated 21.02.2018. It describes plot having CTS No. 1608/13, Plot No. 75 situated in Civil Lines, Solapur. We are of the opinion that this description is sufficient for respondent no. 3 to identify the land for acquisition. So far as the mentioning of wrong town planning scheme number, under which the land of the petitioner was reserved, is concerned, let us state here that the Development Plan is the document of respondent no. 3. Respondent no. 3, who is the Planning Authority for Solapur City, is well aware of the T.P. Scheme under which the land of the petitioner is reserved for children's play park. Therefore, we do not find force in the argument of the learned Counsel for respondent no. 3, particularly, when there is no requirement under Section 127 of the MRTP Act to mention town planning scheme number, rather, the notice very well describes the Reservation No. 8/31 under which the land of the petitioner is reserved for children's play park. There is no ambiguity in the purchase notice issued by the petitioner when it describes land in sufficient clarity as held by the Co-ordinate Benches of this Court in the judgments in Shri Ramchandra Shankar Joshi, C.V. Shan and A.V. Bhat and Shri Jeevan Mallapa Tonemare (supra) relied by the respondent no. 3. Thus, the purchase notice issued by the petitioner met the sufficient compliance as contemplated under Section 127 of the MRTP Act.

17. The learned Counsel for respondent no. 3 also objects the petition on the ground that the land which is reserved under Reservation No. 8/31 for children's play park is comprising of various city survey numbers and the owners of the lands of other survey numbers have not issued notice under Section 127 of the MRTP Act and, therefore, the reservation cannot be deleted from the part of the property and, therefore, the writ petition is not maintainable which is filed by the only petitioner. We do not agree with the submission of the learned Counsel for respondent no. 3. What is contemplated under Section 127 of the MRTP Act is that, if no step has been taken for acquisition of the property/land under reservation within 24 months from the date of issuance of purchase notice by the owner, the reservation from the said land will be lapsed. There is no requirement under law that the owners of piece or parcel of land covered under reservation must together issue purchase notice to the Planning Authority under Section 127 of the MRTP Act. Thus, the objection of respondent no. 3 is without any basis. This Court in Writ Petition No. 3417/2019 (Piyush s/o Pradeep Sejpal v. State of Maharashtra) while repelling the similar argument of the Planning Authority has held that even if area under the Reservation exceeds the land owned by the person, the said person would be entitled to a declaration of lapsing of reservation only with regard to land owned by him.

18. Having found the purchase notice issued by the petitioner is valid, we now briefly note the judicial pronouncements on the subject of deeming provision providing lapsing of reservation under section 127 of MRTP Act.

19. In the case of Girnar Traders v. State of Maharashtra reported in (2007) 7 SCC 555 in paragraph no. 56, it is held that:—

“56. The underlying principle envisaged in Section 127 of the MRTP Act is either to utilize the land for the purpose it is reserved in the plan in a given time or let the owner utilize the land for the purpose it is permissible under the Town Planning Scheme. The step taken under the Section within the time stipulated should be towards acquisition of land. It is a step of acquisition of land and not step for acquisition of land. It is trite that failure of authorities to take steps which result in actual commencement of acquisition of land cannot be permitted to defeat the purpose and object of the scheme of acquisition under the MRTP Act by merely moving an application requesting the Government to acquire the land, which Government may or may not accept. Any step which may or may not culminate in the step for acquisition cannot be said to be a step towards acquisition.”

20. Thereafter, the Supreme Court and this Court, in plethora of judgments have held that if the authority failed to acquire the land under reservation within the prescribed period mentioned in section 127, which is presently twenty four months after valid notice, the reservation stands deleted by fiction of law enumerated under section 127 of MRTP Act.

21. Here, the land under set back was reserved for children’ play park in DP on 15.12.2004 and the children’ play park was not developed for more than 10 years. No steps, whatsoever, has been taken for acquisition of land of the petitioner covered under Reservation No. 8/31 for children's play park within 24 months after service of purchase notice as prescribed under Section 127 of the MRTP Act, rather till today. Thus, the case in hand is qualifed for deeming fiction of lapsing reservation.

22. This takes us to the sheet anchor argument of the learned Counsel for respondent no. 3. It is contended on behalf of Solapur Municipal Corporation - respondent no. 3 that no step has been taken for acquisition of the land of the petitioner covered under Reservation No. 8/31 for children's play park, but the children's play park, being public amenity which are lungs of the city, a conditional order be passed giving opportunity to respondent no. 3 to acquire the land for public purpose within a period of one year from today, as done in Writ Petition No. 6542/2021 (Ramchandra Laxminarayan Soni v. State of Maharashtra).

23. We have gone through the decision of the Division Bench of this Court in Ramchandra Laxminarayan Soni (supra) referred by the learned Counsel for respondent no. 3. The Division Bench of this Court relying on a decision of the Supreme Court in Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai v. Hiraman Sitaram Deorukhar reported in (2019) 14 SCC 411, declared that the release of land of the petitioner from reservation with condition that the petitioner shall not use the land for any purpose for a period of one year and entitlement was given to the Planning Authority to proceed for acquisition of the said land during the period of one year.

24. We may refer here that subsequent decision of the Supreme Court in Laxmikant v. State of Maharashtra reported in (2022) 7 SCC 252, while setting aside the direction of another Division Bench of this Court, to the land owner inspite of complying with the provisions of Section 127 of the MRTP Act not to use the land for one year with liberty to the Planning Authority to acquire the land, the Supreme Court has held that the direction issued in Hiraman Sitaram Deorukhar (supra) to Corporation to acquire the land in spite of all compliance made by the petitioner in the said case under Section 127 of the MRTP Act was given under Article 142 of the Constitution of India. The Supreme Court further held that such direction for acquisition of land within certain period issued in case of Hiraman Sitaram Deorukhar (supra) is not a law declared by the Supreme Court which is treated as a binding precedent for this Court and subordinate Courts in terms of Article 141 read with Article 144 of the Constitution of India. In view of this, the decision of the Division Bench of this Court in Ramchandra Laxminarayan Soni (supra) will not be helpful to the respondent no. 3.

25. To sum up, we hold that the Reservation No. 8/31 for children's play park over the land of the petitioner stands lapsed. Accordingly, the petition is allowed.

26. Rule is made absolute in the aforesaid terms with no order as to costs.