- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
AJAY SHANKAR SRIVASTAVA v. BAR COUNCIL OF INDIA
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, a practising advocate, sought relief from the Supreme Court against two matters: (1) an office order dated 1 November 2022 issued by the Bar Council of India (BCI) to all State Bar Councils which, according to the petitioner, halted the ongoing verification of advocates’ enrolment and degrees; and (2) the procedure for co-opting members to fill casual vacancies in State Bar Councils.
In 2015 the BCI framed the “Bar Council of India Certificate and Place of Practice (Verification) Rules, 2015”. Multiple High Courts entertained challenges to these Rules, which were later transferred to the Supreme Court (Transferred Case (Civil) No. 126 of 2015). A High-Powered Committee had earlier been constituted by the BCI to supervise verification, but progress stalled due to universities charging fees for verifying degree certificates. On 1 March 2017, a two-judge Bench of the Supreme Court directed universities not to demand such fees.
The verification exercise covers approximately 20.57 lakh enrolled advocates, yet only about 9.22 lakh forms or declarations have been submitted. The BCI contends that non-compliant advocates may include individuals with fake degrees who disrupt court work, underscoring the need for strict verification.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the BCI’s letter dated 1 November 2022 unlawfully suspended the verification of advocates’ educational qualifications and certificates of practice by State Bar Councils.
- What mechanism should be adopted to ensure expeditious, reliable, and comprehensive verification of advocates’ credentials across India.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The 1 November 2022 office order effectively halted the verification process, thereby permitting unqualified persons to continue practising law.
- The petitioner also questioned the existing method of co-opting members to State Bar Councils for casual vacancies.
Bar Council of India’s Arguments
- The intent of the 1 November 2022 communication was not to stop verification but to ensure that verification is not conducted perfunctorily on the basis of certificates of practice alone; the genuineness of degree certificates must also be examined.
- A significant number of enrolled advocates have yet to submit verification forms; many among them may possess fake degrees, posing a threat to the integrity of the justice system.
- BCI supported the creation of a Supreme-Court-appointed High-Powered Committee to monitor verification nationwide.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Order dated 1-3-2017, 2017 SCC OnLine SC 2167 | Directed all universities not to charge any fee for verification of advocates’ educational certificates. | Recalled as an existing directive and reiterated to ensure that universities continue verifying certificates free of cost. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court emphasised that verifying advocates’ educational qualifications is essential to safeguard the integrity of the justice delivery system. It accepted the BCI’s justification that many unverified practitioners could be unqualified, use fake degrees, and even gain positions in Bar Councils or the judiciary, thereby endangering public confidence.
While acknowledging confusion created by the BCI’s 1 November 2022 letter, the Court accepted the Chairperson’s clarification that the letter aimed only to prevent superficial verification processes. Recognising the “larger dimensions” involved, the Court held that direct judicial oversight was necessary. Accordingly, it determined that a new High-Powered Committee, chaired by a former Supreme Court judge and comprising judicial and senior-advocate members along with three BCI nominees, should be established to monitor and guide the verification exercise.
The Court further mandated that universities and examination boards comply with verification requests without charging fees and ordered all State Bar Councils to follow the Committee’s directions and report compliance.
Holding and Implications
ORDER: The Supreme Court constituted a five-member High-Powered Committee (plus three BCI nominees) to monitor nationwide verification of advocates’ educational degrees and enrolment certificates, with power to issue guidelines and directions. Universities must verify certificates free of charge; State Bar Councils must comply. A status report is due by 31 August 2023, and the matter is listed for 11 September 2023.
Implications: The decision immediately operationalises a judicially supervised mechanism for cleansing the rolls of practising advocates, aiming to eliminate fake degree-holders and enhance public trust in the legal profession. No new legal precedent was set regarding substantive law, but the Court’s supervisory framework signals stricter future scrutiny of professional eligibility in the bar.
Dr D.Y. Chandrachud, C.J.— The petitioner, who is a practising advocate, has invoked the jurisdiction of this Court to seek two distinct reliefs. The first of them is for challenging an office order dated 1-11-2022 of the Bar Council of India to all the State Bar Councils, the purport of which (according to the petitioner) was to interdict the process of verification of advocates who are enrolled with the State Bar Councils for scrutinising the genuineness of their degrees and enrolments. The second issue deals with the method of co-opting members of the State Bar Councils to fill up casual vacancies.
2. We have heard Mr Anand Nandan, counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner and Mr Manan Kumar Mishra, Senior Counsel, appearing on behalf of the Bar Council of India with Mr Apurba Kumar Sharma.
3. In 2015, the Bar Council of India notified the Bar Council of India Certificate and Place of Practice (Verification) Rules, 2015 (“the 2015 Rules”). The process of verification of the certificates and place of practice commenced with efforts by the State Bar Councils and the Bar Council of India.
4. The 2015 Rules were challenged before several High Courts, including the High Court of Delhi. A transfer petition was instituted before this Court by the Bar Council of India. The proceedings pending before diverse High Courts were transferred to this Court in Transferred Case (Civil) No. 126 of 2015.
5. The Bar Council of India constituted a High Powered Committee for monitoring the process of verification which was headed by a former Judge of the Supreme Court, two former Judges of the High Courts and three members of the Bar Council of India.
6. The process of verification encountered difficulties as a result of the charges which were demanded by the Universities for verification of the educational certificates of the advocates. On 1-3-2017 2017 SCC OnLine SC 2167, a two-Judge Bench of this Court issued a direction to all the Universities not to demand charges for verification of educational certificates.
7. The process of verification has consumed time as the number of advocates which stood at 16 lakhs, at the material time, is estimated to be almost
25.70 lakh, at the present. The counter-affidavit which has been filed by the Bar Council of India indicates the State-wise position in regard to verification of enrolled advocates. The tabulated statement is produced below:
Sl. Nos. State Total No. of Advocates enrolled Total No. of forms Received Under verification Total No. of forms Received Under declaration 1 2 3 1. Andhra Pradesh 63,394 28,323 9053 2. Delhi 1,46,556 32,195 12,204 3. Gujarat 1,13,110 31,479 7385 4. Himachal Pradesh 11,426 3548 4194 5. Jharkhand 32,768 16,670 618 6. Karnataka 1,10,125 49,073 7578 7. Kerala 62,776 21,910 5878 8. Maharashtra & Goa 2,20,450 67,944 22,550 9. Odisha 59,198 29,152 6781 10. Punjab & Haryana 1,30,662 41,719 2250 11. Rajasthan 97,730 47,475 2015 12. Tamil Nadu 1,22,591 38,230 21,756 13. Tripura 1801 660 18 14. Uttar Pradesh 4,14,568 1,57,347 55,747 15. Uttarakhand 19,499 8011 3313 16. West Bengal 75,353 26,004 6800 17. Assam, Nagaland, etc. 38,307 21,495 4365 18. Bihar 1,34,227 49,851 4938 19. Chhattisgarh 31,825 12,600 1099 20. Madhya Pradesh 1,22,082 47,937 17,206 21. Manipur 778 649 649 22. Telangana 46,847 22,547 2912 23. Meghalaya 1347 268 428 24. Jarnmu & Kashmir Information has not been received Total 20,57,420 7,55,087 1,99,737
Total forms received Number of degrees sent to Universities for Verification Number of report received back from University ofter Verification Detail of fake degree/fake advocates, it any, after verification Data received on 4 5 6 7 8 37,376 27,347 17,174 14 18-11-2022 44,399 86,850 67,780 117 26-11-2022 38,264 21,550 8942 0 23-11-2022 3548 6903 6903 0 29-11-2022 17,288 19,019 10,253 2 25-11-2022 56,651 43,886 18,500 0 19-11-2022 0 24,494 20,001 0 15-11-2022 90,494 69,605 51,000 7 29-11-2022 35,933 25,857 1757 0 15-12-2022 43,969 39,690 21,950 0 9-12-2022 49,490 45,377 37,330 0 14-11-2022 59,986 38,007 28,773 0 14-11-2022 678 639 594 0 9-12-2022 2,13,094 1,37,608 67,913 0 2-12-2022 11,324 8011 5343 0 11-11-2022 32,804 23,435 9000 0 29-11-2022 25,860 7309 8 0 23-11-2022 54,789 12,313 849 2 6-11-2022 13,699 11,761 10,713 0 11-11-2022 65,143 27,591 8245 0 5-1-2023 649 649 11 0 15-11-2022 25,459 17,557 10,116 2 23-11-2022 1571 0 0 0 21-12-2022 9,22,468 6,95,458 4,03,155 144
8. The above statement indicates that out of 20.57 lakh advocates, about 7.55 lakh forms were received for the purpose of verification. Senior Advocates and Advocates-on-Record were only required to issue a declaration and, accordingly, 1.99 lakh declarations have been received. The total number of forms received is, thus, 9.22 lakhs, as indicated in the above table.
9. The above table indicates that a majority of advocates enrolled with the State Bar Councils have not submitted their verification forms. The Bar Council of India apprehends that many advocates who have not submitted their forms for verification are persons who are not qualified or are “in possession of fake degrees”. The Bar Council of India has submitted and, with justification, that this class of persons, without the possession of qualifications required for law practice, is known to enter upon the arena of courts for extraneous purposes, including the disruption of work. The Bar Council of India is justified in asserting that such persons have to be identified and weeded out from the list of advocates enrolled with the Bar Councils.
10. The due verification of advocates who are enrolled with the State Bar Councils, is of utmost importance to preserve the integrity of the administration of justice. Persons who profess to be lawyers, but do not either have the educational qualifications or degree certificates on the basis of which they could have lawfully been granted entry to the Bar, pose a grave danger to the administration of justice to citizens. Hence, it is the duty of every genuine advocate of the country to ensure that they cooperate with the Bar Council of India which is seeking to ensure that the certificates of practice are duly verified, together with the underlying educational degree certificates. Unless this exercise is carried out periodically, there is a danger that the administration of justice would be under a serious cloud. The written submission which has been placed on the record by the Bar Council of India indicates that several such persons have been elected to State Bar Councils and some persons have thereafter occupied judicial office in the district judiciary as well.
11. The communication which was issued by the Bar Council of India on 1-11-2022 took exception to the fact that the Bar Council of the State of Uttar Pradesh had started the process of verification in a hurried manner without verifying the genuineness and validity of the educational certificates and degrees of advocates. The letter adverts to the fact that certificates of practice were being issued by the State Bar Council. Hence, all State Bar Councils were directed not to proceed with the process of verification till further orders. However, it was clarified that the State Bar Councils which are verifying the genuineness and validity of degree certificates shall continue to do so.
12. Mr Manan Kumar Mishra, Senior Counsel and the Chairperson of the Bar Council of India, has clarified, during the course of the submission, that the intent of the letter dated 1-11-2022 was not to direct the cessation of the process of verification, but only to ensure that the process of verification was not carried out merely on the basis of the certificates of practice issued by the State Bar Council without verifying the genuineness and validity of degree certificates.
13. Having regard to the larger dimensions of this matter and the direct impact which the enrolment of fake degree-holders and other persons who are not found to be in possession of the qualifications required for entry into the Bar have on the administration of justice, we accede to the suggestion of the Bar Council of India that a High Powered Committee should be constituted by this Court to monitor the process of verification. In our view, such a High Powered Committee should be chaired by a former Judge of this Court and its members should consist of : (i) two Judges of the High Court; (ii) two Senior Advocates; and (iii) three members of the Bar Council of India. The above suggestion has been accepted by the Bar Council of India.
14. We accordingly direct that the Committee shall consist of the following persons:
(i) Mr Justice Deepak Gupta, former Judge of the Supreme Court;
(ii) Mr Justice Arun Tandon, former Judge of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad;
(iii) Mr Justice Rajendra Menon, former Chief Justice of the High Court of Delhi;
(iv) Mr Rakesh Dwivedi, Senior Advocate; and
(v) Mr Maninder Singh, Senior Advocate.
The Bar Council of India shall be at liberty to nominate three members. The Secretary to the Bar Council of India shall be the nodal officer to facilitate all logistical assistance to be rendered to the members of the Committee. The honorarium payable to the members of the Committee shall be fixed by the Chairperson in consultation with the Bar Council of India.
15. The Committee constituted by this Court is empowered to monitor the process of verification. The Committee would be at liberty to issue necessary guidelines and directions to ensure that the process of verification of advocates is duly carried out. The process of verification shall encompass both the educational degree certificates and the certificates of enrolment of the advocates concerned. All State Bar Councils shall comply with the directions of the Committee and report compliance.
16. All Universities and Examination Boards shall verify the genuineness of the educational certificates without charging any fee for the purpose of verification. The requisitions made by the Bar Councils shall be carried out without undue delay and the reports of the verification shall be submitted expeditiously.
17. We request the Committee to commence work at its early convenience by convening the first meeting on a mutually convenient date and time. A status report shall be submitted before this Court by 31-8-2023 on the process which is being carried out.
18. We clarify that the present order for constituting the Committee in order to effectuate the process of verification shall not be in and of itself construed as a direction for extending the existing terms of the Bar Councils.
19. List the petition on 11-9-2023.
Alert