- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Chand Sura Bibi And Another v. State Of West Bengal And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
On 11 January 2022, a police party from Khargram Police Station, Murshidabad, apprehended three persons—Munsur Sk, Rentu Sk, and Barjahan Sk—carrying multicoloured nylon bags with plastic containers. Upon sighting the police, the individuals attempted to flee but were arrested. An FIR (Khargram PS Case No. 30/22) was registered under Sections 21(c) and 29 of the NDPS Act based on a written complaint by SI Ashutosh Das, with seizure conducted before two witnesses. The petitioners claim that Rentu Sk, husband of petitioner No. 1, was at a different location at the time of arrest, prompting the Court to direct production of CCTV footage of the seizure, arrest, and inside the police station. The police reported that CCTV footage inside the station was not preserved beyond one month, contravening Supreme Court directions. The Court also referenced a Division Bench order requiring videography of arrests in NDPS cases. The police attempted to retrieve deleted CCTV footage through technical means. The petitioner’s counsel argued that Rentu Sk was detained a day before the stated arrest date, supported by a conversation with an SI and mobile phone call data records indicating no calls after 6:28 pm on 10 January 2022 but some activity on 11 January 2022. These facts raised doubts about the legitimacy of the arrest and FIR. The Court directed the police to show cause why the accused should not be granted bail and adjourned the matter for further hearing.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the arrest of Rentu Sk and others was lawful and bona fide given the discrepancies in timing and preservation of evidence such as CCTV footage and call data records.
- Whether the police complied with the Supreme Court and Division Bench directions regarding preservation of CCTV footage and videography of arrests in NDPS cases.
- Whether the accused persons should be granted bail in light of the alleged procedural violations and doubts about the FIR’s authenticity.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner’s Arguments
- Rentu Sk was allegedly detained on 10 January 2022, a day before the official arrest date of 11 January 2022, indicating possible fabrication of arrest records.
- The police failed to preserve CCTV footage inside the police station beyond one month, violating Supreme Court directives.
- Call data records show no telephone calls from Rentu Sk after 6:28 pm on 10 January 2022, but SMS activity was recorded at 6:38 pm on 11 January 2022, suggesting inconsistencies in the timeline.
- The NDPS case appears to have been foisted on Rentu Sk, raising questions about the bona fides of the arrest and FIR.
- The petitioner referred to a conversation between petitioner No. 2 and SI Soumen Mondal indicating that Rentu Sk was taken into custody prior to the official arrest date.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal, (2020) 7 SCC 1 | Requirement to preserve CCTV footage inside police stations for at least two years. | The Court found the police violated this principle by not preserving CCTV footage beyond one month, constituting gross non-compliance with Supreme Court directions. |
| Division Bench order dated 22 June 2022 in CRM (NDPS) 492 of 2022 (Kalu Sk. @ Kuran) | Mandated videography of all arrests in NDPS cases. | The Court reiterated this requirement and noted the police’s failure to comply in the instant case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the police report and the petitioners’ submissions, focusing on the preservation of evidence and the timeline of arrest. It noted that the police failed to preserve CCTV footage inside the police station beyond one month, violating Supreme Court mandates established in Arjun Panditrao Khotkar. The Court emphasized the legal requirement for videography of NDPS arrests as per a Division Bench direction. The contradictions in the timing of Rentu Sk’s arrest, supported by call data records and a conversation with police officials, raised serious doubts about the legitimacy of the arrest and the FIR. The Court considered these procedural lapses and discrepancies significant enough to question the bona fides of the detention and arrest. Consequently, the Court directed the police to show cause why bail should not be granted, indicating the potential impact of these violations on the accused’s rights.
Holding and Implications
The Court issued a direction for the Khargram Police to show cause as to why Rentu Sk and the other arrested persons should not be enlarged on bail. The matter was adjourned for further hearing on 20 March 2023.
Holding: The Court did not grant bail immediately but required the police to justify continued detention in light of procedural irregularities and evidentiary concerns.
Implications: This decision underscores the necessity for strict compliance with Supreme Court and Division Bench directions regarding preservation of evidence and videography in NDPS arrests. While no immediate bail was granted, the Court’s scrutiny signals that violations of procedural safeguards can critically affect the prosecution’s case and the accused’s liberty. No new precedent was established; the ruling enforces existing legal standards to ensure fairness and transparency in criminal procedure.
Rajasekhar Mantha, J.:— The O.C., Khargram Police Station, Murshidabad PD has filed a report dated 9 March, 2023 and the same is taken on record.
2. It appears from the report that on 11 January, 2022 at about 6 : 20 pm a police party of the Khargram Police Station had found three persons carrying multicoloured nylon bag with plastic containers inside it. Upon seeing the police personnel, the said persons, namely, Munsur Sk, Rentu Sk and Barjahan Sk tried to flee. They were apprehended and arrested. On written complaint of the SI Ashutosh Das FIR being Khargram PS Case No. 30/22 dated 11 January, 2022 under Sections 21(c) and 29 of the NDPS Act has been initiated. The seizure has been done before two witnesses.
3. This Court had directed the police to produce CCTV footage of two places. Firstly the footage of the seizure and arrest and secondly the CCTV footage inside the police station. The aforesaid footage is required since the petitioners claim that Rentu Sk, husband of the petitioner No. 1, was in a different location at the shown time of arrest.
4. The police report indicates that CCTV footage inside the police station has not been preserved for more than a month. This is to say least in gross violation of the directions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court that in the case of Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal reported in (2020) 7 SCC 1. CCTV footage inside the police station is required to be preserved at least for two years, if not, for a longer period.
5. Further, all arrests in NDPS cases are required to be conducted under a videography in terms of a direction of a Division Bench of this Court dated 22 June, 2022 in the matter of Kalu Sk. @ Kuran in CRM (NDPS) 492 of 2022.
6. Khargram Police addressed to a communication to the Director, West Bengal Electronic Industry Development Corporation Limited on 3 March, 2023 to retrieve the CCTV footage in the police station that has since been deleted. Such retrieval is possible albeit at the hands of an expert by accessing the meta-data.
7. Mr. Samim Ahammed, learned counsel for the petitioner also referred to page 26 (annexure P-3) of the writ petition and submits that extract at the said page is a conversation the petitioner No. 2 had with SI Soumen Mondal of the Khargram Police Station. He submits that his father-in-law Rentu Sk was taken into custody a day before the actual date of arrest i.e. 11 January, 2022.
8. The aforesaid conversation indicates the petitioner No. 2 was asking the sub-inspector as to why his father-in-law was detained.
9. It is also argued that Rentu Sk was arrested on 10 January, 2022 itself and the arrest shown on 11 January, 2022, in connection with the NDPS case is a mere afterthought. It also demonstrates, according to Mr. Samim Ahammed, that the NDPS case has been foisted on his father-in-law Rentu Sk.
10. It is submitted by Mr. Samim Ahammed that the illegality of the detention of his father-in-law Rentu Sk would also be evident from the call data records of his mobile phone. Rentu Sk was taken into custody a day before on the 10 January, 2022 and not on the 11 January, 2022 as stated in the Memo of Arrest. There are absolutely no telephone calls from 10 January, 2022 after 6 : 28 pm. It is also submitted that further SMS appears to have been received on the phone No. 919733000006 at about 6 : 38 pm on 11 January, 2022.
11. The aforesaid omissions and violations by the police, throw up serious question on the bona fides of the detention, arrest of the accused and the FIR itself.
12. Khargram Police shall show cause as to why Rentu Sk and other persons arrested in the instant case should not be enlarged on bail.
13. Let this matter stand adjourned and be listed on 20 March, 2023.
14. All parties shall act on the server copy of this order duly downloaded from the official website of this Court.
Alert