Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Pradeep Kumar Padhy v. National Building Construction Corporation Limited

Central Information Commission
Mar 3, 2023

1. The Appellant sought following information:

2. Dissatisfied with the response received from PIO, Appellant filed First Appeal, vide letter dated 08.12.2022.

3. Written submission has been received from the Appellant vide letter dated 25.01.2023 stating factual matrix of the case.

4. Written submission has been received from the CPIO vide letter dated 02.03.2023 as under:

RTI Application filed by the RTI applicant, Pradeep Kumar Padhy to CPIO, NBCC was received by this Public Authority on 05.09.2022. CPIO, NBCC disposed off the above RTI Application on 02.03-2023 by furnishing the available information in the records of this Public Authority.

DETAILS OF RTI APPLICATION ALONGWTTH REPLY FURNISHED BY NBCC:

I am the D 903 Green View Apartment Sec 37D Gurgaon Haryana. I was saying there but vacated by your notice dated 3 and 13 October 2021 I have requested for an alternative accommodation responding to your notice to vacate on dated 13 October 2021 in your official register with help desk incharge madam uplabdhi. I accepted your rent proposal too on dtd 18 Jan 2022 but have not received yet till dt. On 2 Aug 2022 on CIC forum your officials assured to talk to management and give it but 1 have not recleved yet. So my few queries to be answered as per RTI Act 2019 in detail as follows

Q 1 Are you going to get me rent or relief I am to get and you have assured at CIC platform

If yes when and how and if no then reasons for iIt and why in details

Reply The offer for Buy Back has already been given (copy enclosed)

Q 2 Please provide me the reports of expert committees report as IIT Delhi ITT Roorkee and CBRI and CTE of CVC

Q 3 As per order orally given by Information Commissioner Heeralal ji on dtd you are to provide me an alternative accommodation temporarily and subsequently a permanent one. Are you giving me as discussed. If so then how and when will you provide me Further nbcc was told to upload expert committees report on website Have you done It If not then reasons for it

Reply The report can be seen during office hours on any working days at the Office of SBG (Delhi-I) AIIMS Redevelopment work, Ayur Vigyan Nagar, August Kranti Marg, New Ansal Plaza, New Delhi-110049

Q 4 Responding to my grievance to repair my flat to MOHA dtd 13 may 2021 your site engineer told me to write an application for change of flat as cracks appear in ceilings too. I applied on dtd 16 July 2021. What is status of it as on dt

Reply The buildings have been declared unsafe for human habitation and stands completely vacated. Further, the buyback offer has been provided to all the allottees.

Q 5 What is your official email id to which I should write to. Similarly your helpline person and number to be guided

Reply Sbg.deihi @nbccindia.com

The officials posted at SBG (Delhl-I) are available during office hours for attending any query and for any support required.

Q 6 What is status of Green View APT as of today and what options are available from your side to owners till date.

Reply The buildings have been declared unsafe for human habitation and stands completely vacated. Further, the buyback offer has been provided to all the allottees.

Q 7 Who all were staying in that Green View Apartment till you served notice to vacate and who all have deposited to get rent and who all getting rent without depositing rent-agreement

Reply. The Information sought by the applicant cannot be shared/disclosed under the provisions of Sections 8(1)(d), and 8(lXe) of the ‘Act’, as the same relates to third parties, containing commercial confidence as also trade secrets, disclosure of which would harm the competitive position of the third party. Furthermore, the information available with this public authority is also in fiduciary relationship.

Q 8 Is rent-agreement a necessary condition to get rent or relief If so Under what rule you have made it a necessary condition and forced owners to stay in rent Reply Yes, documentary evidence is required for payment of rent

It can be seen that, suitable pointwise reply has been given to the appellant under the RTI Act, 2005. It Is requested to condone the delay in reply due to ongoing issues at 37D, Gurugram, Haryana. Since, the office gets too many queries as well as frequent visit from the allottees regularly wherein a lot of time and effort is invested. With the limited staff, NBCC is trying to cope up with the inordinate volume of information/legal work, internal and external coordination and regular internal meetings to find out ways to resolve the matter expeditiously. NBCC assures the Hon'ble Commission that NBCC will, henceforth, be more vigilant and shall try our best to timely respond to all the queries received by NBCC. Therefore, the Second Appeal may kindly be disposed

Grounds for Second Appeal:

5. The PIO has not provided correct information to the Appellant.

Relevant Facts emerging during Hearing:

6. The following were present:—

Appellant: Present

Respondent: 1. Ms. Manjeeta Mahajan, NBCC.

2. Mr. Hansraj Yadav, NBCC

7. The Appellant submitted that the requisite information has not been received within stipulated timeframe. He further requested that the PIO be directed to give complete information as sought in his RTI Application.

8. The Respondent submitted that the requite information has been duly furnished to the Appellant from their official records. They also offered inspection of records to the Appellant. They stated that the delay in furnishing the reply to the Appellant was due to ongoing issues at 37 D, Gurugram, Haryana. They submitted that their office receives various application from the allottees of the project relating to their grievances and allottees frequently visit their office also. Furthermore, they have limited staff and the records relating to the project NBCC Green view is voluminous in nature. They tendered their unconditional apology for the delay in dissemination of information in the instant matter.

DECISION

9. At the outset, Commission expresses severe displeasure over the conduct of the PIO in having provided late reply on the instant RTI Application. Commission warns the PIO to remain extremely careful in future and acquaint herself well with the RTI Act, 2005 so that such lapses do not recur.

10. Now Commission, after perusal of case records and submissions made during hearing, directs the concerned PIO to revisit the instant RTI Application and provide a revised fresh reply with respect to point No. 4 i.e. furnish the action taken report with respect to the grievance application of the Appellant and point No. 7 (i.e. only furnish the name of the persons) of the RTI Application along with necessary annexures, as available in their records, with regards to the instant RTI Application, to the Appellant, free of cost via speed post and email, within 15 days from the date of receipt of this order and accordingly compliance report to this effect be duly sent to the Commission by the PIO.

11. In case relevant information, as sought in the instant RTI Application, pertains to some other Branch/Department of Respondent authority, then the PIO should procure and provide the same to the Appellant. In doing so, PIO must make sure that information which is exempted from disclosure under RTI Act, 2005 must not be disclosed to the Appellant. As regards the other points of the RTI Application commission is of the considered opinion that an appropriate response has been furnished by the Respondent. No further action lies.

12. The appeal is disposed of accordingly.