- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor Of Maharashtra And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
A batch of cases is presently before the Court. During the course of the hearing, certain counsel requested that the Constitution Bench decision in Nabam Rebia and Bamang Felix v. Deputy Speaker, Arunachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly, (2016) 8 SCC 1 (“Nabam Rebia”) be reconsidered by a larger Bench of seven judges. Arguments on this preliminary issue have been completed. The Court has now fixed the entire batch for a full hearing on the merits on 21 February 2023 at 10:30 a.m., indicating that the reference question will be taken up together with the substantive disputes.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the decision in Nabam Rebia requires reconsideration by a Bench of seven judges.
- Whether the principle stated in Nabam Rebia—that a Speaker should not adjudicate disqualification petitions under the Tenth Schedule while a notice for his own removal is pending—has a material impact on the facts of the present matter.
Arguments of the Parties
Senior Counsel Seeking Reference
- Mr. Kapil Sibal, Dr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi and Mr. Devadatt Kamat urged that the correctness of Nabam Rebia should be reconsidered by a seven-judge Bench.
Senior Counsel Opposing Reference
- Mr. Harish Salve, Mr. Neeraj Kishan Kaul, Mr. Mahesh Jethmalani, Mr. Maninder Singh and Mr. Siddharth Bhatnagar opposed any reference to a larger Bench.
Solicitor General
- Mr. Tushar Mehta appeared for the Governor of Maharashtra; the opinion does not record a separate substantive submission from him on the reference question.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Nabam Rebia and Bamang Felix v. Deputy Speaker, Arunachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly, (2016) 8 SCC 1 | Majority opinions hold that a Speaker must refrain from deciding disqualification petitions under the Tenth Schedule while a motion for his own removal is pending. | The Court contrasted the majority view with Justice Lokur’s separate view, and observed that whether this principle requires reconsideration must be assessed in conjunction with the facts of the present case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court noted that:
- The majority in Nabam Rebia (opinions of Khehar J. and Dipak Misra J.) articulated a prohibition on the Speaker adjudicating disqualification petitions while a notice seeking his removal is pending.
- Justice Lokur, however, expressly stated that the issue did not arise for decision in that case.
- Given this divergence, any decision on referring Nabam Rebia cannot be taken “in the abstract”; it must be evaluated in the factual matrix of the present disputes.
Accordingly, the Bench concluded that the request for reference and the merits of the underlying cases are inter-linked and should be heard together.
Holding and Implications
ORDER: The Court directed that the entire batch of cases be listed for hearing on merits on 21 February 2023 at 10:30 a.m.; the question of referring Nabam Rebia to a seven-judge Bench will be decided along with those merits.
Implications: The Court has not yet ruled on the validity of Nabam Rebia. The immediate effect is a deferment: parties must prepare to address both the substantive controversy and the possible reference at the upcoming hearing. No new precedent is set by this interim order.
1. During the course of the hearing, a preliminary submission has been made before the Court to the effect that the decision in Nabam Rebia and Bamang Felix v. Deputy Speaker, Arunachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly (2016) 8 SCC 1, requires reconsideration by a Bench of seven Judges.
2. Mr. Kapil Sibal, Dr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi and Mr. Devadatt Kamat, learned Senior Counsel seek a reference to a larger Bench. The submission has been opposed by Mr. Harish Salve, Mr. Neeraj Kishan Kaul, Mr. Mahesh Jethmalani, Mr. Maninder Singh and Mr. Siddharth Bhatnagar, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the other side. Mr. Tushar Mehta, learned Solicitor General, appeared on behalf of the Governor of the State of Maharashtra.
3. Arguments have been concluded on the issue as to whether a reference should be made on the correctness of the decision in Nabam Rebia (supra) to a Bench of seven Judges.
4. In Nabam Rebia (supra), three judgments were delivered for the Constitution Bench, by Justice J S Khehar, Justice Dipak Misra (as the learned Chief Justices then were) and by Justice Madan B Lokur.
5. The opinions of Justice J S Khehar and Justice Dipak Misra hold that the Speaker should desist from considering a petition for disqualification under the Tenth Schedule to the Constitution when a notice indicating an intent to remove him has been moved. This principle is formulated in the following observations in the decision of Justice J S Khehar:
“194…we hereby hold, that it would be constitutionally impermissible for a Speaker to adjudicate upon disqualification petitions under the Tenth Schedule, while a notice of resolution for his own removal from the Office of the Speaker, is pending.”
6. A similar view has been expressed by Justice Dipak Misra in the following extract:
“238…When there is an expression of intention to move the resolution to remove him, it is requisite that he should stand the test and then proceed. That is the intendment of Article 179(c) and the said interpretation serves the litmus test of sustained democracy founded on Rule of Law; and the Founding Fathers had so intended and the constitutional value, trust and morality unequivocally so suggest. It would be an anathema to the concept of constitutional adjudication, if the Speaker is allowed to initiate proceeding under the Tenth Schedule of the Constitution after intention to remove him from his Office is moved…”
7. However, Justice Madan B Lokur, in the course of his judgment, held that:
“401. In the view that I have taken, I am of the opinion that the view expressed by my learned Brothers relating to the power or propriety of the Speaker taking a decision under the Tenth Schedule of the Constitution with regard to the fourteen Members of the Legislative Assembly does not at all arise in these appeals.”
8. The issue of whether a reference to a Bench of seven Judges should be made cannot be considered in the abstract; isolated or divorced from the facts of the case. Whether, the above principle which has been formulated in Nabam Rebia (supra) has an impact upon the factual position in the present case, needs deliberation.
9. In the above backdrop, the issue whether a reference of the decision in Nabam Rebia (supra) to a larger Bench is warranted, would be determined together with the merits of the case.
10. Consequently, the batch of cases is set down for hearing on merits on Tuesday, 21 February 2023 at 10.30 am.
Alert