जयाकुमार गोपाळराव देशपांडे v. अधिक्षक अभियंता, म. रा. वि. वि. कं. लि.

lct, cict'I Piciiui 3Ig1i, 1Icj. 11t' dclI' ct,1-IIct : 34/2021. dct1 cI1c1 Fiic' : 01/02/2021. dctk ffU1T {jict : 02/11/2022.

)qlczlcj Aigi (3IcP), RT 60 c1

oqcIq : ft c4 T.

E.), 1T. T, [i. ircj. c-ftT-1k, quLfltLfl Ict1rL1I 3Th c1Ic1.

(1) rftf ,ff-[J, IfdUi J-Ic1 ctiqii, c1Ic.

(2) cti4cpi [f[t[dT -DIJ j54 1Cç {cjUI cg41 -fq1, 1 -nT1t ct)lIIc1l, iii flc^j4J•

(3) {cci If-1FT, J)4 I 31T cf,iJ-Iflk HJ- -I1, i1ii 1Ic.

(4) qcf- 4cfl fw4i HlI cLcl {çtu \g4pffq

tqkiq, tij

'it'fl cpT

1'i1c1o, e11c.

(5) iI-Ki 3{I9T, -I6kI f[ [cluI IkclI -1TT, T. 3IT, if. 1Ic.

iuiicff:

'Rc

. Ioct, *Ic

1

51,45

Tf.3 T: / W11

31II

aft. . 'iolsq,, 14*q 9I'I

(1) dPkctc1kFft IIct cicPk fftT Id '3{ff ct1,

t 3t (.), ?IT. 1i. e1Ic T. 13/ 14 14 c.1ItL1I

Ic1l oItLfl 6 f-J 2018-2019 IIJIIH33T FicbItfl e1I4 Fcl 351 )3'-1 IdI1k1 fZ1R

IkiI clI. cicPkctci tiFif tth {icpj-ff tiTuft ioi ujj tIJ LlitUcP -j 1CI clOI dk1I 3f[ cLlIcll lIcf cPl-1i

626910000361

(2) I*c1T &f?4Qfrf &IT cf, ck21I 3f I1R-I Id kii 'PrIT. 1t4/2/2019 tft 4 -IIfcjUI cq1tL 3 5[ Fd cii141 Icl ilcl

S) ufr clk1 4-IlctTh 3-1 PJ-1uI ik-qi RulJI 31 t qI1! sQ-qI. c-1t c jtLfl 31 F1ctii 3{jT{ 1IcL1 k1tci 1)di -iRfl cl1!6l, d1k1 3rTT ZIT4t LicHIHI kii 'q4'i1

f-irr, 4rrr jqcr ¼Yff-ri, [T[tkscl 9fl4

1t4.114-1I T.

(3) clkc1T 3f , 1c c1NlquItfl c1cjj cp.1 tff -i-ii jcf1H

gic1 1 -INIUlI

ft iii cF '311 3ERT

Ql1lt-4I .6,00,000/- oLiMI UTI• 1IIRdJ .50,000/-

2

dcPk 1t4cPIclI .1O,OOO/- UgltI ftf[1T 3ff[ cfUL4Id t1TJ, 3[ 1icfl cicfkdh1i d1

(4) t{ qItLI{dI f tIf .5 LlItLfl cULfl çj 3{1. dI TJJ '31'dUIkI diI J-I3Ic cLlN -fl 3J-J IT 3IT. %ff 3{ d1Iofl t1T qrH4-1I IT;¹

dcPI'ctclI tTT [u v1I 3ff 3TfiiT c1IR.1ctktI1 od11 -ii c?ki1 '-icc1. 't

-icI. 2 cicPk cU'cic1 1d1 c IJj c1I 1'1I1 31T. 33f iii 3c-1, 1l1 I1-4k{ flIo5LN1I t . iii ii lii

(5) t1?4 .5 cPcIIcI c-1k ff Iid1ci dI' tItft cPIcZ5'51 d '311dIcI. i1 dUI1U1) d1 ciIci. c'L1IJ- IIctkt q5UI {-uj )d cicPkctd Zff4 1

&-i +ii^I

-qcf-j^c1I-'-iiciId1 &ff. '31fI-Id:

cictI cULflç '3{Qfl^icfld1 '3IT.

(6) tf{3

ThIR1^qcpIIcq^HIc

&fff cj-fl d1ctd1 LUtL1I 3I \s1d 3UIdItt tcf11 cN1 3{f-mTtt 'dIc -1I -1gi 4-11{thUI cq41 Pii R-u

-Ic

(7) dcPkctclI 1TEt 1lc cict)k, fR

t tIt

ck'1q, 3T 14jT4 cftc1c1

1

3f{dT^clil•1kUII- i11-iiu1 l::ffJ- T cULfi c1 dld 3fffJ cLll

Itfl cf)kuTh-lkll cqitI IcldI UId .

1. {cci iF-fltii dkicflcl {uii t41ti uFlL1lJ

PT.

Icfl {i PT?

2. tf[1Tt dckctcitfRT cUIItL1I ^4- tT?

3. dkcPd1.31ckI1 LI

F1

4. ffIT?

(.

. 1, 2,4 5 tit;

ct,kUI1-fl 4-Ik-jJ

(8) 4I . 1 4

3fIc1 k.1c1 t31 O1 31ci)c1 fThT dckctc11 T4 tff ..lirJ.UcP.-I sl J-1I 5 IcIl Icd 'oI Ic1 ct4-1I 626910000361

(9) dkcPd1Zlt cP%FF 31I

ft, 1~.4/2/2O19 M1 JIIdUI cfqLI 3 5[ d i1F fi I1d dk fff1 Hr

14-UI IIc-4l fu41 {cpIc 3[ PT

fT

T{ .5 tIt cpj qjji 5fTT

1Ic1c 3ITfT c1IAckta 'C.'1I 1T.

(10) '3ffkici Fc-ci 1-1rL! dI' \Q5'1d 35f Ricti 3-ff &!Tf 9T5 1 19t41I

III

4

ftn'i+ j.P.IrIttiI' 17LL i±ft. Ihth'ihI?I?coIh ftli cTrth) Ih$'h IPtalhiiii i!

ft?rin9J 't2I1 I-t thIn9J th2IrIh I-7I2J PCP1Ttih?3 'h ?bIlD IPRDh PTJII5è ir iaa Pii pj uaJ2J JI-tftjitD _____ ?'IE IE 1ft.hD 1Jtr k~1FP IP IlhI?

ftIh ?I-rchIr\JIffl€ 1I 'IJIL IPIc'ID 00 L L J4 6 LO/0it7OII-J P 1P1dllIc' kIh }€- iI-1k Path.IP

-: II1IPIr4hI€

243. OOE JJ' PaFrIi(S) U1i' Pi ()

IP ?hRD ItaIP 'IV\TI()

•IP U73P ht1-jI () Pj ic9E (L)

-: (.?i? IhPIhiInIIj

•_[} ~1th 1tiPIkh' .t. jJL i?-IP I2!InE Ilcth2ft?

..j_1€\ !LLIP U?Da j2!IflC1D1 Pjr\ 1ft? 1Pc4flcP -1h

'trll-tPJ ?IIi+tI 'Ir'tLfttj In1EJ Pj 'iE PJ (LL) J' 'IIRIco ftIpIIhakIV4N 1jcP1h rIhV\4j Ih- ic h17 PIJI 1aJiJccoI' .Ib-hL"5 i-3 Ia. h17 I4II.Z IlI?-rIHah]i Ic IFiIHah 2tIlI-7t ±thPsJ hP

5

czI1I 1fldcLII

t R1 1It

It-I [1. 12 [Th1 \31I'zi 3I1T1 1HId1 35 oIc1L

rfft[

f Y41tI ciii

iiT -i iiid1 '3{T. -IIH

cf

!1TftTEf5UT F[ 4-1, 2010 r-lI PR1J-1 12, 67 58 d 1T1 31T. ZJfj c1UI uqt3) 3{T. c-I c)-1 cicp-q {J-HW-11u)

cf1I.1 -igi 3 -i ZTT cfl c1qk 31c1ld cfI

(12) ck11 ^ciiqil 311cP'1 '3{R1T dIc1I -1Irl-II iciIc1

4

IdUI c1I -fl! {-cI ciR-flt1 Icd

11cl ciI i gd 3nfir cHcon1

dkI cJcPI*1 UJ P4-I1UI i 1cti it*5

\II, 3f R .

(13) RtT 3ff

[cç ^U

II'c1 \3L11 clkJ-114, {cd {cI )F {cci +k -ufl tift QcZ1 -ffI, 'c1 i{ciui cq.-fttfl ii ant ^t

.s it% -1 \c ciIi 3 Ic1Qi ft cik Zffft cp173\yfl dIcl 31TföT d1 cuI {-ui 1ci

9T. tR1 tTT .5 tlF- t 1I1 1I cI1 Q d{1d iI

1I1d.

LJ .5 1T1 ii -i 1i-ii-n kii

3frfJT

1l-1c1I Tq 1Id1Q1 Tq 53J [-tff jc qI4c q{i )&-i 1I-1tLfl c1If1Q1 31 '.3lcolell '31'1I1I, 3f 1 cI

Icd Id clitfl 3{J Rcf 1Ild dI) gc d'1, cLlI1 3flTff4] F~uji

Pt &n. ir cujid]i ic-iIt.-n inii 1y-jcl

Ilcl LldHl 3{T faccI 1]& 31ftI

fWur 1IkLlF {~UI

e-1I 3fffiJ cp

P1.

kii t'1fl { çj fft TP4 cj.j oqcfl '3{FU 3fftJ çL4J flcrd

fl11 f E'tk1c1I J-IIfcl'U1 cq -flj 'IIcI' 3{f. Rci Thf*5 tiNT tflc1 '311k1 T 3{d ll3{J-ff 31-II- cdt 3f {l Iil Td 3ff

(14) 3II F[Mh5 'I)d ctl 3i'iiI tlf1, 2,4 5 cicPkcfd ' lHI Ic1ItLU

dI 3nt tiT FI4d {1QJ 31TTJ tf{ l, 2, 4 5 LitI lQ55flqU1I

sii Fd ctL1l tI1

c11l.1 IeLlI'1 cIItl -k'-1I cf)uLfltLfi tIc1Ic1-1 c'-1l1l JT c1I UIk ITt.

(15) cictl dkMt3f c1i1 'J-qjtL \3l-JjlJIl.

.6,00,000/- '.c1,r1 'l-1IflU1 'clI1 '31T. fR tT1 .5 litLlI -il1I' cicPkc1c11 Z1f4t 31 ttE 1Nk IQI.-Lllc.1 11I-1 -kLfl 1cId1 c1cPkcdI ZTT4t ii c'-H4l 91

ctfl, I11c1 ii -li'ii'.i cic11

cpj') '1kc ll--11 lcfld 3*U 4 jc .39,O46/- cpqld 5t 3{1L 'Th ci-1 F9 1, 350 ? 3t dc&IlC- 3ftT 31"1clI-1I 3[^II4j150I dct1K1 cP1H 1T1 3{ffii1T yt-1Ic1i'1I \31I 1* 1 3 ZIct ;:fl- I1Ilct J- -Jlii'fl 1cictfl cti'E1 'i ci lrJ-U ci)-1 1cx1d ,31lctFciI ctId cId) 'cK1J-1 .43,5O8/- dcPkcPclI Lfl-iI ^t[31T.c1ctId tiNT ylczd 3f 'I 'ii-n1 fllcOq kii d'1tI \1czd ±'thct.IclI 1 Id Id1 ctct 3IcIc1 3{i. 3W-dItlI le-!lkIc1lc IclI 3f Il 1T1 UII -I I1 f& 11ct) ici'. ci 3HIl1 31 icz5k'.1Hd' {d1

Ic1i,

7

qit di1cT ii{i ii ^çqj

* Fi 3HII '3{?T5J c4i) dckctdI -UtlTI \iI1d 31I 148.747 -i iI IT d*1jJ-I24 gjuj W-HUI

11 ilczk1k-1 1I

I1-f 3- Icf. tEf II°II gRgEp 3Tf Iictk1 crkI

It 3R

Icf. Fctic 3{fUff-T &flT[ 4-)c5th W-IIUIIc1. -ll 1tII'

Lffj 1PT cI cii'1ci. 3UTT 1f11 nthcIl1 1T i-fl-ir l-iIJ-I IThkUId: 20 14UI Ic1, 3{ 31I-i cfJI -lL1{cl 3f1. 'II 1I -1c1 WtT

148.747

3c{-lIC-i 80 ITJ 3fThJ dPi d1 LtE

i1 d' 100 cci J^-U

185.933 f 3f \3c-1Ic-1 3f:f I-I[4 c dIctcl LUiI 37.186 ?f iiH

31TfT iIk I1H-II

1k -i .1,900/- c J-1-

acii qI4c 37.186 c1 3f dIIFclI .7O,653/- 1I-i 11 Fuui cictkcdI qi

(16) dcPkctclktft

r^t

iij 'iiii

mi cqh-I! fU liki ULlI+1F .2,00,000/- 3ITTJ, '3{1 P . ijsi 3fRU 3T cPkHl {5T Ici,

cLlI1 '31I 1T - ii ii1 t11ZT tik! ?ff

-I1 UL)JL4 3{t IJc IT2kUId: 1 -I1 --Uq4cI 11II dqT-f IT 1TJ '3RT J-.lR1Io'1 dIcl LlitL1IcI' -IT qc1I, 31T. 3Id Io 3f-1R .2,00,000/- 1a5 '.3Il IIJ 3-Rr I16n1 !.-q cdl d

31J-jHk3-ft c1H g! {coUqI

8

d

(17) dcPcbç ct J -jIj

kft 3fl 1I{cL4 jo5ftqjJ .5O,OOQ/- '1H ce-TI 3iii1 f1Ur thIc4 'JFñ, 1Tft clI tf-i 1d 1T I41J cI1 di1T F -E!T iId1 ITt. c'L1I 4 4HHIUfl 4 Lm

(18) icpkcpclI ZIT4t HI-iFct, iI'thcl[clf .5O,OOO/- cpt1 -iiiu1 5Id 3IT. ct)1H LItfl ctcJ 6dl-1I cJ )d cl—cI ur1d1c aThT&[ 11dId. 3{ {J t, dcPkcfd OqcHRfl

ffIT 3f{; 1T oL1c1*HN I ctcild. 3T \JId rtjd cql-1I

?'ic1-j oq Iii f )d1i, -iji, {cci J4cI5 . UIIc IT cIH cf11-f -kgI ucp ç jj '8Ic1I PIci ii1ii 3fi. 1H qj Wtd [ I-1I Jc4 cIctTh ckt1 c5t flTJ c-lIJ dckctdI 1I-1I J-lHIcP T1 '-i'-f P ciiFcp -lI'1{Ict I1Ic{(1I 5QQQ/ flcouq cic1ItdI qI 3f1, Z1T c1çj d

(19) c1ctIctd Z1F1t .1O,OOO/- clPk -:Ef 1Iicii, Fid1 d1 31T. c-lItl cj jc 3fffi J-jJ{çjU tF1 dctictc1 i-iJ $iI"1 -kgI f [4IJ cIcPkctci ti rlJ 1ItI dcPk ck1 'flT[ q 3fi*

thfI 3{ d) cu1 cI't UIft 3{ 11I IT? ff[

cll ficf cic1l'c idfrlI TfT ctfl 3gOL ci). cqi z cicPk t1Fci dcPRcfcl .3,OOO/- q4 31TT tfl 1U4cl

9

(20) T1 3 &fl. dcPkPdIN[T FclId, 1i d 1Tt. c-1I cLlitL1 fR 3!TT -1Rld

(21) 3[ {tNI3fth T ^{. 13dcd'}iiff U1Id I1 3HtT T .4

)rd! iId1efl1J-!IU &ftJ^ULId.

3iii

1. cicPkctdItffEt 1lct dctk ?r1TT: JJ U.flcl

2. f?^tf[.1, 2, 4 5 T4t dkctdI qi -ii ulcfld 3I {1I1k

.7O,653/-

1I1 -IYI IIct1dF .10,000/- c1H

IRft

10

1I5cP c1'i

. 34/2021 1f 3i*I6Hd .qjqfuq / 3iipi.. 1TI. 11k11 i 31TU, '3fZtf ('31I1c*i cPI4-FR) qItIkJ :-

(1) IIJ 31RII 'ic-1 fl. . iö'kc Zff 4Qc ç j cUIIJ- 31TT / T 3ff çjtqJ 3cjt1 3{{

ci T .3

c1ØJq11 .31'ci1gii tfl 3fff 5VT? ic'qi*i tIT -Ic14clI cffoLlI FtHI'c1 '3114-IcI 3llc c1l 4 II{dl 3fT: )ckfzff' 3I' 3,-J c1ci3 tffEI HIcfç 1T1 cfçl 4- / 3{fT cl 3ff 3fffdTT 3.{T1 çqìcq / 31RIkTT &1t-fTtI _11Id 4-fft[ 3f{.

(2) \3{ kki , 3T ,1h-1 J-JgirL 31rIj .6,OO,OOO/- til -NJU1 PkcPd Z[F '31T. ki1 II1c$ f1i'1'Ici -1jsii ldc 1cfi'fl 1Ik II--11t.1I L1II 31lc-i '3fTTT 15 1HIU)

22.312 ?i ctqld Ujçj 31T. c-I rHIT 1Jfr t. ?[ .1,9OO/- -

G1 .43,5O8/- cPJBd '3!T. ft6/4/2019 4ftt ccP-1 .43,5O8/- dcpkcpdl qi-ii -ld 3f{. '3fflT cicpkcNlI Z[PEII '*x1d 3E '1Ii 1oq c1I 3{rI! 3IffT \3l1d 11IclI ct)qId id1 'ccc c1cpc clI qi -ii 1IkI IJel 3ff. iic)qfl IoqI1 'ilcl iii iii IIca'fl1 c,4-1 dIctdI HI 3fT I1

cJ 3E RII'II1 dPIc1 c -JH dPId qj [ .ii1ci. cL1IJ-J, I1Jc1ILl 3 IOc tirJTI 3fRT J-1dIfl i -1cf 31T.

N

11

(?ZL LZ/PJPJ&) -0-

(iII-t) i4iic' IumN1Dd Nc5P cIr i'J

(Ni-tdPjj) (ru IUI-tU)

°O?/L L/ : _____ JDl?cP pJJ-E' IhII-?J j7 Ihp-M ikiJII?I' I-)h'?Jh .23J 17 pIr3 -/000'EI1N5 ____ ___ -/OOO'lPJcDII .DkJHFt INhPDkP ftth S . 17 'E h 1iI ID .4P2 9 ••i: 1hè?IP

1iiJIF?1±PJ ?'I¹⁷I-1lhII?lIi

___ HI -/OOO'OL.

Icp1t9IIHh PIc45PLIi S .17'LIP ih t- Pthn?Pft:pIMc Ic5P ir U2I PkPI L

1II

jè4 Pft?n IPJ1D 17IP E •IP 1'tI-2j P:PF:(E)

12

TI CC/34/2021 4JI4 dR icii&ui 3iI.IdI, i-J1IaiIGlI4

oJIcI, -ti' o-IIcl^- 1,a1N. k

fç1,(Ul ^. (Te-i T d5hI'. fi,ui 31I'dI, Q1Ici Z1T 3I'ldIk- c1

c-I5bi' 5bcHIcb /oR?

JT1

1T. 'I1 'UI c-15hk lIJI 3114)dl, F$ 3TIIacl) -dc-

3TfRT.)

'(-dc 311FT (1~40114^- RT. ,I -'L1 d,Il6ch c- 15bR fctjuj 3- ku1dI,

Z[ti 31TT d-ii

J31TIdii.I

PRO/°RR/'-3Ri3 i?o-1Icb - RR.QR°R € 31TIIcc1, ici 1JIct d'I'( flcll'(UI 3iIL4'^dI,

c'IIc T 31k'IdIIc-1)c1 -dd c- hId-lt VJ cbII chc as ($) d'dk. ft. tTT. Ld. 4-lIdl,

, -1c- ie-I d)Il- dc'R fciii 3-H41dI, --1IdIlI, Icc'1

d-1tU -d1ç1 d 3*.

'3t. rrri r.

*iIdI(, -.q zjj- cc1RI - ?. k-cjd 14cb.Uil cflc cI'c'1 c*ldIC-lIt1 c^-I'k1 3T1It1 c'l'k*ol 3TTdT 3ITT

9hd-llcl-) , $, , clldcl c-I d,1ld' d9bk f1dil 3-1k-1')dl, c'llc-k lIt) 3-1tZ1 (3ci-d

r[R) -ld--1 Zff L*,d-ld 31*. d-tI 3-1TT 5bd-flch^d-fla1 ItA-II

1T1 3TtZ{8J dc it1 d-ld 3Hc'1l d 1cI. -dd d5bk dkcdI 1T Tft 1C1d dl10-flt1 dk. I fcbld.

cjo ji-1 aw2T

Ia5a1 a1d1a1 Ic4ItI dI'& 31*. cUflç- ¶Q T[ T€ f 1i1u!IJ1 dHd'I ZITE{{ i '-flic '1c ,d Icc 31*. 1--c,d

13

2 CC/34/2021 CI'sJc 9Tt c'-1IcHⁱbId id I,1d-IIUIId 1Ic ic1i3T1Tt 1t^ji

1c*'d d9bkchdi I1I i T ¶chldc-o-i ¶cIIc1

J-lIl^c1cbcI) 'HRsH cI-)IIo-!I ?L1T dk- I dIicIdI&1 oIc1l 31T c1ctItc1 dk.cbdi 1Tff ¶J-ljoR c1c1iH Ia1

t 3* d j'' ¶ticiitfl tc4- d-1 I)Q1 ~a1jcb^OOQ

tt5 'dI'LSH l41a1Io1 d9hkchdi 11T 'AIa1 icc ^{it'1a-l!°°R}r11tAH cbII') r-lIcich -Ic1'o1 1~i d5hk11di Tt i 1d chRIJ i-1It IlchdI pU.Id 3-lic1c c1-cbcH

o,000/- t 1dL1 3cIt1 RT cJ-ld 3-1*. c'1Idc? 3E b-1Ioi 3'YI )4dl d5hltchdI -1II dld, 1T^cbdt d 31*.

. cI $1 RT. 11d1cfl T 31tT (31icd R3-1fl) 4Jt4 fu

1d-Qf

çjt) tT cIt' -dd Uflcc1 l -I 41 'd-1çi 31*.

- O3.O?.O$

tii r. fl'ni)

(I 4JIcf d'I' Iijui 3iN1'1I,

-J1Ia1II4

14