- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
VIBHUTI SHANKAR PANDEY v. THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant was engaged in 1980 as a Supervisor on a daily-rated basis under a project of the State Water Resources Department, Madhya Pradesh. He sought regularization on the post of Supervisor/Time Keeper. The minimum qualification for that post was matriculation with mathematics, which the appellant did not initially possess. A Government Circular dated 31.12.2010 relaxed these qualifications, after which the appellant renewed his claim for regularization, citing his long service.
In an earlier writ petition (W.P. 13997/2010), the Madhya Pradesh High Court, by order dated 02.11.2017, directed the State Government to decide the appellant’s claim in accordance with law. The Office of the Chief Engineer, Rani Avanti Bai Lodhi Sagar Project, by order dated 18.06.2018, rejected regularization on the grounds that: (i) the appellant had never been appointed against any sanctioned post; (ii) his appointment was not made by the competent authority; and (iii) there were no posts available for regularization at that time. It was also noted that the relaxed qualification would not, by itself, bar regularization, but the other deficiencies remained.
The appellant contended that persons junior to him, engaged as daily wagers, had been regularized in 1990 or earlier. A learned Single Judge of the High Court, by order dated 27.06.2019, allowed the writ petition and directed the appellant’s regularization from the date on which his juniors were regularized. The State Government appealed. A Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court, by order dated 13.02.2020, allowed the appeal and set aside the Single Judge’s order, holding that the governing principles in Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (2006) 4 SCC 1 were not followed.
Before the Supreme Court, leave was granted. The present appeal challenges the Division Bench’s order. The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether regularization can be granted when the initial engagement was not made by the competent authority and the employee was not working against a sanctioned post, in light of the principles laid down in Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (2006) 4 SCC 1.
- Whether the relaxation of minimum educational qualifications by Government Circular dated 31.12.2010 entitles the appellant to regularization notwithstanding the absence of a sanctioned post and a valid appointment by a competent authority.
- Whether the regularization of junior daily-rated workers in 1990 or earlier affords a valid basis to direct regularization of the appellant.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- He was engaged as a daily-rated Supervisor since 1980 and had served for a long period.
- Following the Government Circular dated 31.12.2010 relaxing the minimum qualification (matriculation with mathematics), he was qualified for the post of Supervisor/Time Keeper.
- Persons junior to him as daily wagers were regularized in 1990 or earlier, and he sought parity and regularization from the same date.
State Government's Position (as recorded in the 18.06.2018 order)
- The appellant was never appointed against any sanctioned post.
- His appointment was not made by the competent authority.
- No posts were available for regularization at the relevant time.
- While the qualification requirement would not, by itself, impede regularization due to relaxation, the foregoing deficiencies barred his claim.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (2006) 4 SCC 1 | Regularization cannot be granted unless the initial appointment is by a competent authority and the employee works against a sanctioned post. | The Court affirmed that both conditions were missing in the appellant’s case; therefore, he had no entitlement to regularization, and the Division Bench correctly set aside the Single Judge’s order. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court endorsed the Division Bench’s approach grounded in the Constitution Bench decision in Umadevi. The critical legal requirements for regularization are: (i) the initial appointment must be made by a competent authority; and (ii) the employee must be working against a sanctioned post. On the record, it was undisputed that the appellant’s initial engagement was not against any post and was not made by the competent authority. The administrative decision dated 18.06.2018 also recorded the non-availability of posts for regularization.
Although the qualification requirement (matriculation with mathematics) had been relaxed by the Government Circular dated 31.12.2010—removing one potential impediment—the absence of a sanctioned post and a valid appointment by a competent authority remained fatal under Umadevi. The Single Judge’s direction to regularize the appellant from the date his juniors were regularized did not align with these controlling principles. The Division Bench, therefore, correctly applied Umadevi in allowing the State’s appeal and setting aside the Single Judge’s order. The Supreme Court found no basis to interfere, concluding that, in view of Umadevi, the appellant had no case for regularization.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: APPEAL DISMISSED. The Supreme Court declined to interfere with the Division Bench’s order dated 13.02.2020, which had set aside the Single Judge’s order granting regularization.
Implications: The appellant is not entitled to regularization on the post of Supervisor/Time Keeper. The decision reaffirms the binding principles of Umadevi: regularization cannot be ordered absent a sanctioned post and a valid appointment by a competent authority. The ruling applies existing precedent to the facts and does not establish a new legal principle.
1. Leave granted.
2. This appeal has been filed by the appellant who is aggrieved by the order dated 13.02.2020, by which a Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court has set aside the order of the learned Single Judge dated 27.06.2019, which had granted the benefit of regularization to the present appellant.
3. The case of the appellant is that he was engaged in 1980 as a Supervisor, on daily rated basis, under a project of the State Water Resources Department of Madhya Pradesh. The appellant sought regularization on the post of Supervisor/Time Keeper. Admittedly, the minimum qualification for the said post was matriculation with mathematics; a qualification which the appellant did not possess. These qualifications were relaxed by a Government Circular dated 31.12.2010 and the appellant sought his regularization on the post of Supervisor/Time Keeper, as he was qualified for the post and had been working on daily wage basis for a long period of time. In fact, in another writ petition (W.P. 13997/2010) filed by the appellant earlier, the High Court of Madhya Pradesh vide order dated 02.11.2017, had given directions to the State Government to decide the claim of the writ petitioner in accordance with law. Vide order dated 18.06.2018 issued by the Office of Chief Engineer, Rani Avanti Bai Lodhi Sagar Project, the claim of the appellant for regularization was rejected for the reasons that though the minimum qualifications of matriculation with mathematics will not come in the way for his regularization, but the fact remains that the appellant was never appointed against any post. Moreover, his appointment was never made by the competent authority and there were no posts available at the time for regularization. The appellant on the other hand, had set his claim for regularization as persons who were junior to him as daily wagers were regularized in the year 1990 or even before. The learned Single Judge while allowing the writ petition gave directions for regularization of the appellant from the date on which his juniors were regularized. This order was challenged by the State Government before a Division Bench which allowed the appeal of the State Government. The Division Bench rightly held that the learned Single Judge has not followed the principle of law as given by this Court in Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (2006) 4 SCC 1, as initial appointment must be done by the competent authority and there must be a sanctioned post on which the daily rated employee must be working. These two conditions were clearly missing in the case of the present appellant. The Division Bench of the High Court therefore has to our mind rightly allowed the appeal and set aside the order dated 27.06.2019.
4. In view of the law laid down by the Constitution Bench of this Court in Uma Devi (supra), the appellant had no case for regularization. There is no scope, hence, for our interference with the order of the Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court. Appeal is dismissed.
Alert