Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

YOGESH MANOHARLAL BHATI v. STATE OF GUJARAT

Gujarat High Court
Feb 8, 2019
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Yogesh Manoharlal Bhati, filed a petition seeking compensation and other reliefs alleging illegal detention by respondent nos. 2 to 5 from 23rd December 2013 to 27th December 2013. The petitioner claimed mental and psychological torture during this period and sought departmental proceedings against the respondents as well as an inquiry and action taken report. The respondents denied the allegations through detailed affidavits. The matter proceeded before the High Court of Gujarat, where the petitioner’s claims were examined.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner was illegally detained by respondent nos. 2 to 5 from 23.12.2013 to 27.12.2013.
  2. Whether compensation is payable to the petitioner for the alleged illegal detention.
  3. Whether departmental proceedings should be initiated against respondent nos. 2 to 5 for the alleged illegal detention.
  4. Whether an inquiry and action taken report should be directed against respondent nos. 2 to 5.
  5. Whether the breach of guidelines laid down by the Supreme Court in Joginder Kumar Versus State of UP & Ors and provisions of the CrPC occurred during the alleged detention.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner asserted he was summoned on 23.12.2013 and taken into custody from that date until 27.12.2013, constituting illegal detention.
  • He relied on a letter addressed to the Assistant Commissioner of Police asserting detention at D.C.B. Police Station between 23.12.2013 and 27.12.2013 as evidence of illegal custody.
  • He invoked the Supreme Court’s guidelines in Joginder Kumar Versus State of UP & Ors and sought compensation and departmental action for violation of those guidelines and CrPC provisions.
  • The petitioner relied on the decision in Sangita Vilas Ingle versus State of Maharashtra & others to argue that writ petitions seeking compensation for illegal detention are maintainable.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The respondents emphatically denied the allegation of illegal detention through a detailed affidavit.
  • They contended that the petitioner’s letter asserting detention does not constitute an admission of illegal custody.
  • The respondents disputed the very basis of the petitioner’s claim, thereby raising a question of fact regarding the alleged detention.
  • The respondents argued that since illegal detention is denied, no compensation or departmental action can be considered by the court at this stage.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Joginder Kumar Versus State of UP & Ors, AIR 1994 SC 1349 Guidelines for arrest and detention to prevent illegal custody and safeguard fundamental rights. The petitioner sought action for breach of these guidelines; however, the court found no admitted illegal detention to apply these guidelines.
Sangita Vilas Ingle versus State of Maharashtra and others, (2017) 2 SCC 728 Maintainability of writ petitions seeking compensation for illegal detention. The court noted that the Supreme Court remanded the matter due to disputed facts and did not establish a precedent that writ petitions for compensation are maintainable as a matter of law.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the petitioner’s claim of illegal detention from 23.12.2013 to 27.12.2013 and noted that the respondents denied such detention through detailed affidavits. The petitioner’s own letter asserting detention was held not to be an admission of illegal custody. The court emphasized that the determination of illegal detention involves disputed questions of fact. Since the respondents denied the allegations, the court could not consider awarding compensation or initiating departmental proceedings without an admission or proof of illegal detention. The petitioner’s reliance on the Sangita Vilas Ingle case was found misplaced as that case involved remand for fresh consideration due to factual disputes and did not create a binding precedent on maintainability. Consequently, the court held that the petition was misconceived and liable to be dismissed.

Holding and Implications

The petition is dismissed.

The court’s decision directly results in the denial of compensation and reliefs sought by the petitioner for alleged illegal detention. No departmental proceedings or inquiry are directed against the respondents. The dismissal is based on the absence of admitted illegal detention and the presence of disputed facts. No new legal precedent was established by this order.

Show all summary ...

R/SCR.A/1276/2014 ORDER

IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD

R/SPECIAL CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO. 1276 of 2014

==========================================================

YOGESH MANOHARLAL BHATI

Versus

STATE OF GUJARAT

========================================================== Appearance:

MR BM GUPTA(336) for the PETITIONER(s) No. 1 NOTICE SERVED(4) for the RESPONDENT(s) No. 2,3,4,5,6 MR RAKESH PATEL, APP for the RESPONDENT(s) No. 1 ==========================================================

CORAM: HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE UMESH A. TRIVEDI

Date : 08/02/2019

ORAL ORDER

1. By way of this petition, the petitioner seeks following reliefs:

"(A) This Hon'ble Court be pleased to award compensation from respondent no.2 to 5 to petitioner for detaining petitioner in illegal custody from 23/12/2013 to 27/12/2013 .i.e. for 5 days and for giving mental and psychological torture during these period.

(B) This Hon'ble Court be pleased to direct respondent no.1 to initiate departmental proceeding against respondent no.2 to 5 for detaining petitioner in illegal custody from 23/12/2013 to 27/12/2013 i.e. for 5 days and given mental and psychological torture during these period.

(C) This Hon'ble Court be pleased to direct respondent no.6 to initiate inquiry and file "action taken report against the respondent no.2 to 5"

and/or any sort of direction to that nature, which this Hon'ble Court deems fit, just and proper.

(D) This Hon'ble Court may be pleased to take

Page 1 of 4

necessary action for violation and breach of guidelines of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India given in the case of AIR 1994 SC 1349 in the matter of Joginder Kumar Versus State of UP & Ors. and for failure to keep the provision of the CrPC while detaining the petitioner for the period 23/12/2013 to 27/12/2013 and thereby breach and violation of the provisions of law;

(E) Such other and further relief as this Hon'ble Court may deem just, fit and expedient be granted in favour of the petitioner.

(F) Costs of this petition be provided for to the petitioner."

2. Essentially, this petition is seeking compensation from respondent nos.2 to 5 for illegal detention of the petitioner in illegal custody from 23.12.2013 to 27.12.2013 i.e. for five days.

3. Mr. Chandrashekhar Gupta, learned advocate for the petitioner relying on summons dated 22.12.2013 at page no.18 asserted that summons dated 22.12.2013 was served to him on 23.12.2013 at 10:40 a.m. at Ahmedabad and he was required to remain present before Surat Police at 11:00 a.m. and therefore, the very basis for issuing summons is not correct. However, he contended that from 23.12.2013, he was taken into custody by the person who served him summons which is emphatically denied by filing a detailed affidavit on behalf of respondent nos.2 to 5 in para-4 and para-6 in the affidavit which is at page no.37 of the compilation. Relying on page no.22, Mr. Gupta further contended that on 28.12.2013 he addressed one letter to Mr. J.A. Patel, Assistant Commissioner of Police, "D" Division, Surat City wherein he has asserted that from 4:30 p.m. dated 23.12.2013 to 27.12.2013 up to 9:30 p.m., he was in D.C.B. Police Station.

Page 2 of 4

Receipt of that letter wherein assertion is made that he was in custody of the police up to this period is being argued as an admission of illegal detention on behalf of respondent nos.2 to 5 which is wholly misconceived. Taking me to different paragraphs in the affidavit in reply, learned advocate for the petitioner wanted to believe that the petitioner was held in illegal custody by respondent nos.2 to 5 and therefore, relying on decision in the case of Sangita Vilas Ingle versus State of Maharashtra and others reported in (2017) 2 SCC 728, he attempted to argue that writ petition seeking compensation for illegal detention is maintainable. Drawing attention of this Court to the prayers made before the High Court in that case, the Hon'ble Supreme Court remanded back the matter as there were several prayers in it which were not considered on the ground of disputed question of fact and therefore, for a fresh decision the case was remanded back. In the case relied on by learned advocate for the petitioner, no such precedent is evolved by the Hon'ble Supreme Court which is sought to be canvased before me that the writ petition is maintainable seeking compensation for illegal detention. Therefore, the reliance placed on the said judgment itself is misplaced.

4. At the same time, since the assertion made by the petitioner that he was illegally detained for five days which is denied and disputed on behalf of respondent nos.2 to 5, even the determination of question of illegal detention involves disputed questions of facts unless and until illegal detention is accepted or admitted, no Court can consider awarding compensation thereof. Herein, in this case, even illegal custody is denied and disputed. The emphatic assertions based on his own communications wherein it is repeatedly mentioned about illegal detention, the said assertion does not become proof of

Page 3 of 4

illegal detention when it has been denied. Thus, this petition itself is misconceived seeking compensation for illegal detention which is required to be dismissed on that ground alone. Another prayer sought for in this petition is for initiating departmental proceedings against respondent nos.2 to 5 for detaining the petitioner in illegal custody for five days is again based on petitioner's own conclusion that he was illegally detained. Therefore, for that relief also, this petition cannot be entertained. Since a detailed affidavit refuting the allegations leveled by the petitioner in his petition and the correspondence, remaining reliefs claimed in the petition itself cannot be entertained.

5. Since this petition is misconceived, it is hereby dismissed. Notice is discharged.

(UMESH A. TRIVEDI, J)

TAUSIF SAIYED

Page 4 of 4