- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
KALPANABEN GOVINDBHAI BHAVSAR v. STATE OF GUJARAT
R/CR.A/1345/2018 ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1345 of 2018
==========================================================
KALPANABEN GOVINDBHAI BHAVSAR
Versus
STATE OF GUJARAT
========================================================== Appearance:
MR. NISARG D SHAH(7299) for the PETITIONER(s) No. 1,2 VIVEK P DWIVEDI(8474) for the PETITIONER(s) No. 1 DS AFF.NOT FILED (R)(71) for the RESPONDENT(s) No. 2 MR.PRANAV TRIVEDI, APP for the RESPONDENT(s) No. 1 ==========================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE G.R.UDHWANI
Date : 27/11/2018
ORAL ORDER
1. Order dated 27thAugust, 2018 rendered by Special Sessions Judge (Atrocity Act), City Civil & Sessions Court, Ahmedabad in Criminal Misc. Application No.5312 of 2018 denying the anticipatory bail to the appellant under the provisions of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (for short 'the SC&ST Act') for the offences punishable under Sections 143, 147, 323, 294(b), 452, 507 of the Indian Penal Code (for short 'IPC') as also Sections 3(1)(r)(z), 3(2)(5A) of the SC&ST Act in connection with the F.I.R. being C.R. No.I-139 of 2018 registered with Naroda Police Station, Ahmedabad is sought to be assailed in this appeal preferred under the provisions of the SC&ST Act.
Page 1 of 5
2. While the learned counsel for the appellant and the learned APP has made oral submissions, the respondent No.2 who is an advocate practicing in the lower Court has merely tendered objections to the grant of anticipatory bail during the course of hearing without orally addressing this Court.
3. Having considered the rival contentions, it transpires that the mandatory averments as indicated in Section 3 of SC&ST Act that the accused is not the member of Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe are lacking from the F.I.R.; in similar circumstances in
Gorige Pentaiah V/s. State of Andhra Pradesh & Others - 2008 (12) SCC 531 the F.I.R. devoid of such averments itself was quashed. Thus, prima-facie sustainability of charge against the appellant under the provisions of the SC&ST Act is doubtful.
4. So far as the averments on merits are concerned, it is pointed out by the learned counsel for the appellant that at different intervals, the complainant has been adding accused persons at will and the appellant is the person who has been subsequently added in the said manner as an accused person though not named initially in the F.I.R.
5. The dispute by the complainant is raised against the members of the society and the provisions other than Atrocities Act are those referred to here-in- above. Commission of an offence is not sufficient to deny a liberty to a person. Be it noted that; at the stage of trial/even during the trial, the accused is
Page 2 of 5
required to be presumed as innocent. The Court cannot be oblivious of the fact that he is yet to be tried and his criminal liability is yet to be fixed. The Court also must be conscious of the fact that denial of bail may not result into pretrial conviction of the accused. The court below failed to consider the above referred well settled principles of law while considering the bail or anticipatory bail. Learned APP is not able to point out as to how the ends of justice would be served by keeping the appellant in jail during trial.
6. As per ratio laid down in Subhash Kashinath Mahajan v. State of Maharashtra [AIR 2018 SC 1498],
it is settled legal position that unless the case on merits under the provisions of the SC&ST Act is prima-facie made out, or if the allegations are prima-facie found to be motivated or false, exclusion of Section 438 of the Code of Criminal Procedure as contemplated by recent amendment would not apply. In so far as present case is concerned, it arose prior to the amendment and therefore, amendment would not have any adverse effect on the rights of the appellant to seek anticipatory bail under Section 438 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Moreover, as indicated above the necessary averments that the appellant is not the member of the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe as contemplated in Section 3 of the SC&ST Act are lacking from the F.I.R. and thus prima-facie the allegations against the appellant under the SC&ST Act are not likely to be sustained.
Page 3 of 5
7. For the above mentioned reasons, the impugned order dated 27.08.2018 passed by learned Special Sessions Judge (Atrocity Act), City Civil & Sessions Court, Ahmedabad is quashed and set aside. The appellant is ordered to be admitted to bail in anticipation of his arrest in connection with the F.I.R. being C.R. No.I-139 of 2018 registered with Naroda Police Station, Ahmedabad on furnishing a bail bond of Rs.10,000/- (Rupees Ten Thousand only) with two sureties of the like amount on following conditions :-
[a] shall cooperate with the investigation and make himself available for interrogation whenever required;
[b] shall remain present at concerned Police Station on 01.12.2018 between 11.00 am to 2.00 pm;
[c] shall not hamper the investigation in any manner nor shall directly or indirectly make any inducement, threat or promise to any witness so as to dissuade them from disclosing such facts to the Court or to any Police Officer;
[d] shall at the time of execution of bond, furnish the address to the Investigating Officer and the Court concerned and shall intimate the change of residence if made by accused during the pendency of the case.
[e] shall not leave India without the permission of the Court and, if is holding a Passport, shall surrender the same before the trial Court
Page 4 of 5
immediately.
[f] despite this order, it would be open for the Investigating Agency to apply to the competent Magistrate, for police remand of the appellant. The appellant shall remain present before the learned Magistrate on the first date of hearing of such application and on all subsequent occasions, as may be directed by the learned Magistrate. This would be sufficient to treat the accused in the judicial custody for the purpose of entertaining application of the prosecution for police remand. This is, however, without prejudice to the right of the accused to seek stay against an order of remand, if ultimately granted, and the power of the learned Magistrate to consider such a request in accordance with law. It is clarified that the appellant, even if, remanded to the police custody, upon completion of such period of police remand, shall be set free immediately, subject to other conditions of this anticipatory bail order.
8. At the trial, the trial court shall not be influenced by the prima facie observations made by this Court while enlarging the appellant on bail.
9. Direct service is permitted.
(G.R.UDHWANI, J)
RAVI PATEL
Page 5 of 5
Alert