Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND 2 ORS v. MUNGASAJI LIMBAJI KATEKAR THR. LRS. AM KATEKAR

Bombay High Court
Nov 28, 2019

fa273.12 1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

NAGPUR BENCH

FIRST APPEAL NO. 273 OF 2012

AND

CROSS OBJECTION NO. 10 OF 2013

FIRST APPEAL NO. 273 OF 2012

1. The State of Maharashtra

2. The Collector, Yavatmal.

3. The Land Acquisition Officer & Sub-Divisional Officer, Darwha, Tq. Darwha, Dist. Yavatmal. ... APPELLANTS Versus

Mungasaji Limbaji Katekar,

(since deceased through LR)

Smt. Anjanabai w/o Mungasaji

Katekar, aged 55 years, occupation - Household work, r/o Pelu,

Tq. Digras, District - Yavatmal … RESPONDENT

CROSS OBJECTION NO. 10 OF 2013

Smt. Anjanabai w/o Mungasaji Katekar, aged 63 years, occupation - Housewife, r/o Pelu, Tq. Digras, District - Yavatmal … CROSS OBJECTOR (Org. RESPONDENT)

Versus

1. The State of Maharashtra represented by the Collector, Yavatmal.

2. The Collector, Yavatmal.

1

3. Sub-Divisional Officer, Land Acquisition Officer, r/o Darwha, Tahsil - Darwha, District - Yavatmal. ... RESPONDENTS (Org. APPELLANTS)

Shri S.D. Sirpurkar, AGP for the State authorities. Shri R.J. Shinde, Advocate for the claimant. …..

CORAM : PUSHPA V. GANEDIWALA, J.

NOVEMBER 28, 2019.

ORAL JUDGMENT :

Heard Shri S.D. Sirpurkar, learned Assistant Government Pleader for the State authorities and Shri R.J. Shinde, learned counsel for the claimant.

2. First Appeal No. 273 of 2012 is filed by the State of Maharashtra through the Collector, Yavatmal, challenging the Judgment and Award dated 28.04.2009 passed by the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Darwha, in L.A.C. No. 675 of 2004. The claimant also filed Cross Objection No. 10 of 2013 claiming enhancement in the amount of compensation.

3. In the impugned judgment and award, the learned

2

Reference Court enhanced compensation to Rs. 3,00,000/- per hectare. The facts in brief necessary to decide the First Appeal and Cross Objection are as under :

For the extension of Gaothan of Village - Pelu, a land ad-measuring 1.48 HR from Field Survey No. 23/7, in village - Pelu, Tq. Digras, District - Yavatmal owned by the claimants was acquired by the Government vide L.A.C. No. 17/47/92-93. Notification under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, was issued on 20.04.1995 and the Award was passed on 18.11.1995. The learned Land Acquisition Officer valued the compensation of the land to the tune @ Rs. 22,500/- per hectare.

4. Being dissatisfied with the compensation awarded by the Land Acquisition Officer, the claimant filed Reference under Section 18 of the said Act. The appellant - State of Maharashtra, resisted the claim by filing its written statement. The learned Reference Court framed necessary issues and recorded evidence as adduced by the parties and on merit, partly allowed the Reference by enhancing compensation @ Rs.

3

3,00,000/- per hectare with all other statutory benefits.

5. Both the State of Maharashtra and the claimant have challenged the judgment and award of the Reference Court in the Appeal and Cross Objection respectively.

6. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties. The following points arise for determination of this Court.

"1. Whether the learned Reference Court has correctly valued the acquired property ?

2. Whether, the claimants are entitled to further enhancement in compensation ?"

7. Shri Shinde, learned counsel for the claimant has heavily relied on the copy of sale deed Exh. 36 of Village - Pelu for the land ad measuring 225 square feet which was sold on 10.09.1993 for total consideration of Rs.3,000/- (i.e. approximately Rs.10/- per square feet). It is submitted that since the land was acquired for the purposes of extension of Gaothan of Village - Pelu, the claimant is entitled to receive compensation on square feet basis and comparable sale instance

4

for land which was sold on square feet basis can be relied on in view of the pronouncements of this Court and the Hon'ble Apex Court.

8. The learned counsel for the claimant, in support of his arguments, relied on the following authorities:

(1) Atma Singh (died) through L.Rs and Ors. vs. State of Haryana and Anr., reported at AIR 2008 SC 709.

(2) The State of Maharashtra thr. the Collector, Yavatmal & Ors. vs. Kisan Lahuji Gajbhare (FA No. 459 of 2003 decided on 07.12.2016).

(3) The State of Maharashtra & Ors. vs. Akbar s/o Umar Teli (FA No. 454 of 1993 with connected Appeals decided on

26.11.2007).

9. Per contra, Shri Sirpurkar, learned AGP submitted that the learned Reference Court, without properly appreciating the material on record, assessed the market value of the land on the basis of guess work. The learned AGP further submitted that the learned Reference Court has already awarded exorbitant amount of compensation and, therefore, claimant

5

are not entitled at all to any enhancement. Furthermore, the land of the claimants was not developed while the land in the sale instance is situated within the Gaothan area and therefore the same cannot be compared to assess the true market value of the acquired land.

10. I have considered the submissions made on behalf of both the parties.

11. The learned counsel for the claimant relied on the sale instance below Exh. 36 which is a sale deed for a very small piece of land i.e. 225 square feet against the acquired land, ad-measuring 3 Hectare. There are catena of judgments of the Hon'ble Apex Court holding that for assessing the true value of the land, a sale instance of small piece of land cannot be taken as a comparable sale instance to assess the market value.

12. However, it cannot be disputed that the subject land, which was chosen for extension of Gaothan of village - Pelu, itself reflects the residential and commercial potential of the said land. As the village Gaothan is already established, naturally there would have been all necessary amenities and

6

facilities, though the acquired land and the land in the vicinity of the acquired land remained agricultural land.

13. Therefore, in the opinion of this court, though the sale instance below Exh. 36 is not a comparable sale instance, considering the residential and commercial potential of the acquired land and the purpose for which it was acquired the reasonable compensation could have been Rs. 4,00,000/- per hectare.

14. For the foregoing reasons recorded, the State's Appeal needs to be dismissed and Cross Objection of the claimant needs to be allowed partly. The judgment and award of the Reference Court is modified to the extent that the acquiring body shall pay the enhanced compensation @ Rs. 4,00,000/- (Rs. Four lakhs only) per hectare with all other statutory benefits. The appellants - State authorities shall deposit the enhanced amount of compensation with the Registry of this Court within a period of six months and thereafter the claimant shall be entitled to withdraw the same.

7

15. Accordingly, First Appeal No. 273 of 2012 is dismissed and Cross Objection No. 10 of 2013 is partly allowed. However, in the facts and circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.

JUDGE

****** *GS.

8