Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mohit Rasiklal Mehta v. Ministry of Shipping

Central Information Commission
Oct 18, 2022

केीय सचू ना आयोग

Central Information Commission

बाबागंगनाथमाग, मुिनरका

Baba Gangnath Marg, Munirka

नईद ली, New Delhi - 110067

File No : CIC/DSHIP/A/2022/639763 Mohit Rasiklal Mehta .…..अपीलकता/ Appellant

VERSUS

बनाम

CPIO,

Tariff Authority For Major Ports, RTI Cell, Bhandar Bhavan, Mujawar Pakhadi Road, Dock Mazgaon, Mumbai, Maharashtra-400010 …. ितवादीगण /Respondent

Date of Hearing : 18/10/2022 Date of Decision : 18/10/2022

INFORMATION COMMISSIONER : Saroj Punhani Relevant facts emerging from appeal:

RTI application filed on : 05/06/2022 CPIO replied on : Not on record First appeal filed on : 24/06/2022 First Appellate Authority order : 14/07/2022 2nd Appeal/Complaint dated : NIL

Information sought:

The Appellant filed an online RTI application dated 05.06.2022 seeking the following information:

"Seeking information related to Land management Policy or Land Policy of Major Port Trust. As per the Policy document it state that approved valuer needs

1

to be engaged for valuation of Land and immovable property for fixation of SOR and rent etc. as per policy. My RTI application is filed to get information regarding definition of the approved valuer held with the authority being custodian of the subject Land Policy. As Policy mention since 2004 about approved valuer and various major port trust appoint approved valuer, i am seeking under mentioned information pointed out in point no.-1 and

2. The information is for public purpose and cannot be denied citing section - 8 or 11. It is in the interest of various port trust and stake holder and government of India. This information i have tried collecting from each port trust and every one has given different response hence it is important for me to get the information from the authority who is IN charge i.e. you under Government allocation of business rules,1961. Hope you will not deny giving information which is in public good. The various port trust invite tenders time to time to appoint approved valuer. however the eligibility criteria i.e. pre qualification criteria fixed for appointing approved valuer is different. Being approved valuer i understand meaning of term approved valuer / govt. approved valuer as per enacted act of parliament, A person ( Individual) registered under section - 34AB of Wealth Tax Act,1957( Not abolished still in force) with Chief Commissioner of Income Tax ( CCIT) under category - I immovable property. SARFAESI Act,2002 and Security Interest(Enforcement) Rules,2002 rule 2 defines approved valuer means a person registered under section 34AB of Wealth Tax Act, 1957 even Black Money Act,2015 under section 77 defines Approved valuer a person registered under section 34AB of Wealth Tax Act, 1957. All the PSU and Govt. Tenders including some of the port trust tenders requires government approved valuer needs to be registered under section - 34AB of Wealth Tax Act,1957 and Restrict any Body Corporate companies under section - 34AC of Wealth Tax Act, 1957 and technically disqualify them. Even if a registered valuer under section - 34AB of Wealth Tax Act,1957 is in employment as a director / employee they disqualify such person under rule 8(12) of Wealth Tax Rules,1957. Hence after getting notices so many tenders by various Major Port Trust where in the pre qualification criteria to select approved valuer varies in each tender for each authority even department to department, i a seeking document held with you as a authority about definition of approved valuer for the purpose of land policy as under.

1) Seeking definition of approved valuer

2) Seeking name of authority who grants approval to valuer under particular provision of particular enacted act of the parliament as adopted in the land management policy monitored by Tariff Authority for Major Port Trust of India."

2

Having not received any response from the CPIO, the appellant filed a First Appeal dated 24.06.2022. FAA's order dated 14.07.2022 held as under:-

"……………..(i) As regards the point made the Appellant brought out in para 4(i) above stating that the Competent Authority has not issued circular or clarification or documented information to various Major Port Trust it is to state that Land Policy guidelines for Major Ports are issued by the Ministry of Ports, Shipping and Waterways (MOPSW) from time to time.

Clarification Circular on Land Policy Guidelines 2014 are issued by the competent authority i.e. MOPSW to the Major Ports in the year 2018 and 2019. These clarification circular issued by the MOPSW are also hosted on the TAMP website for stakeholders and hence are on public domain.

On perusing the Land Policy Guidelines and the clarification circular issued by the MOPSW listed in para 5.2. above and office records, it is seen that the information sought by the Appellant as regards (a). definition of approved valuer and (b). Name of authority who grants approval to valuer are not available in office records.

(ii). As regards, the point made by the Appellant and brought out in para 4(ii) that the objective of Tariff Authority of Major Trust is to effectively implement Land Policy by getting done land valuation by appointing approved valuer, it is to state as per the Major Port Trusts (MPT) Act, 1963 and the Land Policy Guidelines issued by the MOPSW, TAMP is not mandated to undertake land valuation of Major Ports or appoint the approved valuer as contended by the Appellant. The mandate of TAMP under Sections 48 and 50 of the said Act is to frame the Scale of Rates (SOR) along with conditionalities for the Major Port Trusts and for private terminal operators authorised by Major Port Trusts for providing cargo related services, vessel related services and miscellaneous services. As per Section 49 of the MPT Act 1963, TAMP is to frame the SOR (lease rent and license fee) along with conditionalities for major port properties and land. For fixation of lease rent/ license fee for land belonging to Major Ports, TAMP is bound to follow the Land Policy Guidelines issued by the MOPSW. (iii). As regards, the other points made by the Appellant and brought out in para 4(ii) and points at 4(iii) to (iv), it is reiterated that mandate of TAMP is to fix the Scale of Rates for port land following the Land Policy Guidelines issued by the

MOPSW.

The Land Policy Guidelines cited at para 5.1. above do not define the term

"approved valuer" to be appointed by the Major Ports nor do the Guidelines prescribe the authority granting approval for appointing "approved valuer" by Major Ports.

3

(iv). The various other Acts referred by the Appellant about appointment of approved valuer are not found to be prescribed in Land Policy Guidelines of 2004, 2010 and 2014 or in clarification circulars on Land Policy Guidelines, 2014 issued by the MOPSW.

As per the RTI Act, only such information is required to be supplied which already exists and is held by the public authority.

The PIO has furnished the reply dated 17 June 2022 which is reproduced in table in para 2.1. above. On perusing the reply, I see that the PIO has stated that the Land Policy Guidelines issued by the MOPSW does not provide the definition of 'approved valuer' and also there is no specific provision/ process for granting of approval for the valuer. On perusing the relevant records, I find that the information provided by the PIO is factually correct.

That being so, the contention of the Appellant that PIO has denied to furnish information requested by the Appellant is not factually correct.

7. As the information sought by the Appellant are not available as per office records, the question of requesting the PIO to furnish the information does not arise."

Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied, the appellant approached the Commission with the instant Second Appeal.

Relevant Facts emerging during Hearing:

The following were present:-

Appellant: Present through video-conference.

Respondent: Tejal Singh, Deputy Director & PIO along with Anuradha H Sharma, Director and FAA present through intra-video conference. The Appellant raised the following arguments in the instant Appeal which are reproduced below -

" ….. as per ministry guidelines and land management policy, valuation of land is mandatory by approved valuer. Policy is in place since 2014. Hence, it is obvious that all the port trust are getting done land valuation by appointing approved valuer. It is the TAI to monitor and supervise and detect the Port Trust SOR preparation and publication work year on year. SOR is prepared based on the valuation report submitted by approved valuer. Hence, it is necessary for TAI to see that when port trust is appointing approved valuer for their land valuation since 2004 to date, whom they are appointing. In case Port Trust are not appointing approved valuer, than it is not possible to prepare SOR accurately and cause loss to public funds. Hence, it is not

4

possible that since 2004 to date neither Ministry of Shipping Nor TAI nor Port Trust no one known that who qualifies as approved valuer. I have participated in various tenders published by various Port Trust. It is clearly stated in the tender document published by the Port Trust that registered valuer means an Individual person registered under section 34AB of Wealth Tax Act,1957.

As subject of valuer registration and valuation is regulated by Ministry of Finance under Government Allocation of Business Rules,1957, there is no other ministry can register or approve valuer including shipping ministry. Hence all the ministry and department and PSU and India Citizens, Income Tax Department and Income Tax assessee and probable assesse and every one and any one, mandatory needs to be follow Wealth Tax Act,1957, Income Tax Act,1960 and other acts, and definition of valuer. Hence it is not possible for ministry of shipping to define approved valuer which is already defined by Ministry of Finance. As per the Indian Legal System if one definition is defined under an act, it is not possible to redefine in another act, as subject is allocated to particular ministry and department. Hence ministry of shipping and TAI and port trust has no option however to adopt definition of valuer / approved valuer / registered valuer given in various act like Wealth Tax Act,1957, Income Tax Act, Gift Tax, IDC Scheme,2016, SARFAESI Act,2002, Black Money Act,2015, etc. Hence it is mandatory for Port Trust and others to follow the definition of approved valuer. Hence, approved valuer is already defined in other act adopted by the Govt. of India and Port Trust, is already in practice since long time. However rather than providing information by verifying various appointment of registered valuer / approved valuer, PIO and Fist appellant authority denied giving information. If PIO and First Appellant authority are correct that there is no approved valuer defined and adopted by Port Trust since declaration of policy in year 2004 to date in 2022, in that case how Port Trust are appointing approved valuer since year 2004 announcement of the land management policy.

It is very shocking and surprising that TAI since last many years monitoring of land management policy and SOR declared by the port trust. It is necessary to verify that port trust, while appointing approved valuer, they are approved valuer. As TAI suggesting that they do not have kept information about who is approved valuer, in that case they are allowing any one get appointed as a valuer. This is caused huge losses to Port Trust and Govt. of India. In case ministry has not provided definition or clarification circular regarding meaning of approved valuer, it is duty of the TAI to get it from the concerned for effective implementation of the Land Management Policy and valuation of land to prepare SOR. Hence, as TAI is not doing its duties and responsibilities legally, to hide its failure, i.e. each port trust appointing any one and every one as valuer, who ever do some arrangement with Port Trust officers. Hence,

5

by not giving information CPIO and Appellant authority trying to hide and misleading the RTI applicant. So that no complaint can be possible against the various persons. Hence, I am requesting to direct first appellant authority to confirm the definition of approved valuer. Unless they do so, it is not possible to implement Land management policy amended upto date. Hence kindly direct First appellant authority to provide information and according issue a circular…."

The CPIO relied on her written submission dated 12.10.2022 and submitted that a reply clarifying the factual position has already been provided to the Appellant on 17.06.2022 which was further supplemented by the FAA vide order dated 14.07.2022. Relevant extracts of CPIO's reply are reproduced below for ready reference -

"….The Land Policy Guidelines issued by the Ministry of Ports, Shipping & Waterways does not provide the definition of ' approved valuer' and also there is no specific provision/process for granting of approval for the valuer…." Upon Commission's instance the FAA further facilitated a detailed discussion regarding the Land Policy Guidelines and its implementation.

Decision:

The Commission upon a perusal of records and after hearing submissions of the parties finds no infirmity in the replies provided by the CPIO earlier and now vide written submission dated 12.10.2022 as the same were in consonance with the provisions of RTI Act.

Having observed as above, the Commission finds no scope of further action in the matter.

Notwithstanding the aforesaid, the attention of the CPIO is invited to the clause 4 of the CIC's hearing notice which is as under -

"….4. All the parties may submit their written submission, if any, to the Commission at least 3 working days before the date of hearing. A copy of the same shall be served upon opposite party. If any party wishes to make online submission, the same may be sent to the Commission's link only viz., http://dsscic.nic.in/online- link-paper-compliance/add....."

6

In view of the above said point, the CPIO is directed to provide a copy of his written submission dated 12.10.2022 free of cost to the Appellant within 2 days from the date of receipt of this order under due intimation to the Commission.

The appeal is disposed of accordingly. Saroj Punhani (सरोज पुुुुनहािन)

Information Commissioner (सूूचूू ना आयुुुु ) Authenticated true copy

(अिभ मािणत स#यािपत ित)

(C.A. Joseph)

Dy. Registrar

011-26179548/ ca.joseph@nic.in

सी. ए. जोसफे, उप-पंजीयक

दनांक /

7