Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

ANJU P.ANIL KUMAR, v. STATE OF KERALA

Kerala High Court
Apr 6, 2022
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — High Court of Kerala (6 April 2022)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner (the wife of the detenu) challenged a preventive detention order passed under the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007 (KAA(P)A). The detention order (Ext.P1) was dated 01.09.2021, the preventive detention was for one year and its execution commenced on 04.09.2021. The detenu had been in custody in relation to a crime from 12.06.2021 and the last prejudicial act was recorded on 11.06.2021.

The Sponsoring Authority recommended preventive detention by a report dated 05.08.2021. Two bail orders are noted in the file: Ext.P5 dated 05.08.2021 and Ext.P6 dated 13.09.2021. Representations against the detention were made: one (Ext.P2) on 10.09.2021 by the Advocate and another on 14.09.2021 by the detenu through the Superintendent of Police. The representation was ultimately disposed of and the detenu informed on 30.10.2021; the Government's confirmation/approval (Ext.P3) is recorded as being dated 22.09.2021 (approval order) and the order of confirmation is dated 29.10.2021.

The petition was argued by learned counsel for the petitioner and by the learned Government Pleader before a Division Bench (K. Vinod Chandran & C. Jayachandran JJ). The Bench examined multiple procedural objections to the detention and delivered its judgment on 06.04.2022.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the preventive detention could be vitiated for failure to forward the detention order and records "forthwith" to the Government in terms of the KAA(P)A (issues in the opinion reference S.3(3) and S.7(3) of the Act).
  2. Whether the delay between passing the detention order (01.09.2021) and its execution (04.09.2021), when the detenu was already in judicial custody, unlawfully prejudiced the detenu.
  3. Whether the disposal of the detenu's representation after confirmation of the detention order (and the timing of intimation) violated the principles laid down in earlier decisions.
  4. Whether non-supply of material documents (notably Ext.P5 — bail order dated 05.08.2021) to the Detaining Authority vitiates the detention.
  5. Whether the temporal "live link" between the last prejudicial act and the detention was broken by the two-to-three months gap between the last act (11.06.2021) and the detention order (01.09.2021), as argued with reference to precedent.
  6. Whether illegible or incomplete copies of records supplied to the detenu vitiate detention and to what extent the supplied copies sufficed.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The detenu was in custody from 12.06.2021 but preventive detention was ordered on 01.09.2021 and executed only on 04.09.2021; even a short delay prejudices the detenu.
  • There was delay in forwarding the detention order and records to the Government; "forthwith" forwarding as required under S.3(3) (as pleaded) was not observed.
  • A representation (Ext.P2) was made on 10.09.2021 (by Advocate) and on 14.09.2021 (by the detenu), but it was disposed only on 30.10.2021 (after 55 days) and after the order was confirmed — this, it was argued, conflicts with the dictum in Joseph Sebastian v. State of Kerala [2018 (3) KHC 889].
  • The earlier detention order and certain bail orders (Exts.P5 & P6 dated 05.08.2021 & 13.09.2021) were not supplied to or perused by the Detaining Authority; the absence of Ext.P5 from the Detaining Authority's consideration vitiates the detention.
  • The last prejudicial act was on 11.06.2021 and the detention order was passed about two-and-a-half months later, breaking the live link between the act and detention (relying on Jimesh Jose v. State Of Kerala [2013 (1) KHC 49]).
  • The Detaining Authority failed to take into consideration S.107 proceedings (the opinion cites S.107 proceedings with dates in different paragraphs — 19.02.2021 and 19.07.2021).
  • Many pages of the documents supplied to the detenu were illegible; reliance placed on Mary Selma v. State of Kerala [2021 KHC 127].

Respondent's Arguments

  • The detention order was sent forthwith and the Government's approval followed within the required period; any intervening Saturdays were holiday days declared because of the pandemic.
  • There was no delay in disposal of Ext.P2 (the representation) insofar as it was initially addressed to the Advisory Board and only later transmitted to the Government along with the Advisory Board's recommendation (dated 21.10.2021 and received by Government on 22.10.2021); rejection/confirmation occurred contemporaneously (order confirmed 29.10.2021; intimation 30.10.2021).
  • One bail order (Ext.P5) was dated 05.08.2021 — the same date as the Sponsoring Authority's recommendation — and the other (Ext.P6 dated 13.09.2021) was passed after the detention order and therefore could not have been perused by the Detaining Authority.
  • The Detaining Authority had noticed the S.107 proceedings but found them insufficient to restrain the detenu from committing further offences; the detenu is described as a habitual offender/history sheeter and one of the attacks resulted in a fractured shoulder of a police officer.
  • As regards illegible copies, there were multiple cases; even if some copies were illegible, if the number of legible and complete copies required under the KAA(P)A are supplied for at least one requisite crime, the detention need not be vitiated.
  • The Government relied upon precedents including Rafiya v. State of Kerala [2019 (1) KHC 63] and Joicy v. State of Kerala [2018 (3) KHC 37] to support its positions on timing and on crimes initiated by police officers.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Joseph Sebastian v. State of Kerala [2018 (3) KHC 889] Addressed by petitioner to challenge disposal of representation after confirmation (principle regarding timing and consideration of representation). The petitioner relied on this dictum to argue that disposing of the representation after confirmation was impermissible. The Court examined the file timing and communications (noting Advisory Board transmission and Government dates) and explained that the communication dated 30.10.2021 was an intimation to the detenu and considered the sequence of transmission; the Court did not sustain the representation-related challenge as independently vitiating, except for the issues it specifically upheld.
Jimesh Jose v. State Of Kerala [2013 (1) KHC 49] Principle that a detention must maintain a "live link" between the last prejudicial act and the order of detention. The petitioner invoked this case to argue that the two-to-three month gap broke the live link. The Court found that because the detenu was arrested and remanded immediately after the last prejudicial act, investigation proceeded and the Sponsoring Authority's later recommendation did not, in the Court's view, break the live link in the circumstances; the Court did not find that the temporal gap alone vitiated detention on that basis.
Mary Selma v. State of Kerala [2021 KHC 127] Authority relied on regarding illegible copies and when illegible records can vitiate detention. The petitioner relied on this case to argue that illegible pages vitiate the detention. The Court observed the general principle from Mary Selma (that illegible copies can vitiate) but declined to examine each page because it had already found the detention vitiated on other grounds; the Court also noted the settled position that if the requisite number of copies for at least one crime are legible and complete, illegibility of other pages may not necessarily vitiate detention.
Rafiya v. State of Kerala [2019 (1) KHC 63] Interpreted in relation to the meaning of "forthwith" and the permissible period for forwarding records (i.e., that five days may run foul of the requirement). The Court referred to Rafiya to assess whether forwarding of the detention order and records "forthwith" to the Government had occurred. The Court noted Rafiya's observation that while "forthwith" is not instantaneous, a five-day delay may be unacceptable; in the present file the Court found the entire records reached the Government after five days, and this non-compliance formed part of the basis for vitiation.
Joicy v. State of Kerala [2018 (3) KHC 37] Addressed the position regarding crimes initiated by police officers and whether such complaints are excluded from consideration under the KAA(P)A. The Court relied on Joicy to reject the petitioner's contention that crimes initiated by police officers could be excluded; the Court noted that an attack resulting in grievous injury to a policeman would not be excluded under the KAA(P)A and Joicy answers that contention.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court conducted a focused, step-by-step analysis of the procedural objections raised to the preventive detention:

  • On the temporal connection between the last prejudicial act and detention: The Court observed that the detenu was arrested and remanded on 12.06.2021 immediately after the last prejudicial act (11.06.2021). Investigation proceeded thereafter and the Sponsoring Authority recommended preventive detention on 05.08.2021, cognizant of the potential that the detenu might be released on expiry of three months without a final report. For these reasons, the Court did not treat the gap alone as sufficient to vitiate the detention.
  • On the requirement to forward the detention order and records "forthwith" to the Government: The Court noted an actual delay — the order dated 01.09.2021 was received by the Government only on 06.09.2021, i.e., after five days — and referenced Rafiya (which held that five days may run foul of "forthwith"). The Court found that the entire records reached the Government after five days, which did not satisfy the statutory mandate and constituted a ground for invalidation.
  • On execution delay (01.09.2021 order executed on 04.09.2021) while detenu was in custody: The Court explained that when a person is in judicial custody (remanded), the police require permission from the court in whose custody the detenu remains before executing a preventive detention. The JFCM I Court Ettumanoor was approached and granted permission on 03.09.2021; the Court found no fault in the three-day interval given this procedural necessity.
  • On Government approval timing (Ext.P3 dated 22.09.2021 and confirmation dated 29.10.2021): The Court examined whether Saturdays should be excluded as non-working days because of pandemic-declared holidays and, verifying from the Registry, accepted the Government's position that certain Saturdays were holidays; accordingly, Ext.P3 was passed within twelve working days as required under the statute.
  • On disposal of representations (Ext.P2): The Court documented that the representations were addressed to the Advisory Board and that the Government only received the representation when it was transmitted along with the Advisory Board's recommendation (dated 21.10.2021 and received on 22.10.2021). The Court held that the communication dated 30.10.2021 was an intimation to the detenu and not the operative date for consideration; it did not accept that this sequence by itself fatally vitiated the process except insofar as other procedural lapses existed.
  • On non-supply of bail order Ext.P5 (05.08.2021) to the Detaining Authority: The Court analysed that Ext.P5 fell on the date of the Sponsoring Authority's recommendation and, although the Sponsoring Authority could not have been aware of subsequent events, the Detaining Authority had the recommendation pending before it. The Court held that it was incumbent on the Sponsoring Authority to inform the Detaining Authority about the subsequent bail order so that the Detaining Authority could consider whether the bail conditions would suffice to restrain the detenu and thereby obviate preventive detention. The Court found non-supply of Ext.P5 to the Detaining Authority to vitiate the detention.
  • On S.107 proceedings and illegible copies: The Court noted the S.107 proceedings had been noticed but found them insufficient to prevent the detenu from committing further offences given the detenu's subsequent conduct. Regarding illegible copies, the Court reiterated the established principle that illegible copies may vitiate detention but observed that if the required number of legible and complete copies for at least one crime are supplied, illegibility of other pages may not necessarily vitiate. The Court did not scrutinize each page because it had already found vitiation on other grounds.
  • On crimes initiated by police: The Court applied Joicy to reject the petitioner's contention that crimes initiated by police were excluded from consideration; where an attack resulted in grievous injury to a police officer, that conduct remained relevant under the KAA(P)A.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Division Bench held that the preventive detention could not be sustained. The Court identified two principal procedural defects as grounds for vitiation: (1) failure to "forthwith" communicate the detention order and records to the Government in accordance with the statutory mandate (the records reached the Government after five days), and (2) non-supply of the bail order Ext.P5 (05.08.2021) to the Detaining Authority for its consideration.

The Court ordered that the detenu "shall be released forthwith from custody, if he is not required in any other case," and directed the Registry to communicate the order to the concerned prison.

Implications: The direct consequence is the release of the detenu unless required in other matters. The Court's conclusions rest on specific procedural non-compliances in this file (failure of forthwith transmission and failure to place a material bail order before the Detaining Authority). The opinion does not purport to lay down a broader new precedent beyond its application of existing authorities to the facts of this case.

This summary is strictly confined to the facts, arguments and reasoning as set out in the provided opinion. No additional facts or inferences beyond the opinion's text have been introduced.

Show all summary ...

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

PRESENT

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K.VINOD CHANDRAN

&

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C. JAYACHANDRAN

WEDNESDAY, THE 6TH DAY OF APRIL 2022 / 16TH CHAITHRA, 1944

WP(CRL.) NO. 474 OF 2021

PETITIONER:

ANJU P.ANIL KUMAR,AGED 24 YEARS

W/O.ACHU SANTHOSH, PUTHEN THARAYIL HOSUE,

ATHIRANPUZHA P.O., NALPATHIMALA,

KOTTAYAM, PIN-686 562.

BY ADV M.H.HANIS(K/264/2007).

RESPONDEN T S:

1 STATE OF KERALA,

REPRESENTED BY THE ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY TO

GOVERNMENT, HOME AND VIGILANCE DEPARTMENT,

GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,

THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN-695 001.

2 THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR & DISTRICT MAGISTRATE, KOTTAYAM, PIN-686 002.

3 THE DISTRICT POLICE CHIEF,

KOTTAYAM, PIN-686 002.

4 THE CHAIRMAN, ADVISORY BOARD,

KAAPA, SRENIVAS, PADAM ROAD, VIVEKANANDA NAGAR,

ELAMAKKARA, PIN-682 026.

5 THE SUPERINTENDENT OF JAIL,

CENTRAL JAIL, VIYYUR, PIN-680 010.

BY ADV ADDL.DIRECTOR GENERAL OF PROSECUTION

OTHER PRESENT:

ADGP SRI.GRACIOUS KURIAKOSE WITH SRI.K.A.ANAS, GP

THIS WRIT PETITION (CRIMINAL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION

ON 06.04.2022, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE

FOLLOWING:

1

2

K.VINOD CHANDRAN & C. JAYACHANDRAN JJ ----------------------------------------- WP(Crl)No.474 of 2021

----------------------------------------- Dated, this the 6th April, 2022

JUDGMENT

Vinod Chandran, J. The wife of the detenu is before this Court challenging the order of detention passed under Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention)Act, 2007 (for brevity KAA(P)A) on various grounds. The detention was for one year and commenced on 04.09.2021. We heard both the learned Counsel for the petitioner and the learned Government Pleader.

2. Sri.M.H.Hanis, the learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner, raises the following allegations against the detention, which he categorise as illegal. The detenu was remaining in custody from 12.06.2021 in a crime and the detention order was passed on 01.09.2021. Despite being in custody, the petitioner was taken into preventive detention only on 04.09.2021 and the delay even though of three days prejudices the detenue. It is further submitted that there is delay in forwarding the detention order,

3

which has to be 'forthwith' as laid down in S.3(3) of the KAA(P)A. There is a representation made before the Advisory Board dated 10.09.2021 by the Advocate and on 14.09.2021 by the detenu through the Superintendent of Police. The representation was disposed of on 30.10.2021 after 55 days, which prejudices the petitioner. It is also submitted that the representation was disposed of after the order was confirmed, which is against the dictum in Joseph Sebstian v. State of Kerala [2018 (3) KHC 889]. On the supply of documents it was argued that the earlier detention order was not supplied to the detenu and the last two bail orders, Exts.P5 & P6 dated 05.08.2021 & 13.09.2021 were not supplied to the detenu or perused by the Detaining Authority. It is argued that the last prejudicial act was on 11.06.2021 and the detention order was passed 2 1/2 months later, breaking the live link between the prejudicial act and the detenu as held in Jimesh Jose v. State Of Kerala [2013 (1) KHC 49]. The Detaining Authority had not taken into consideration S.107 proceedings on 19.02.2021

4

initiated before the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Kottayam. Finally it was argued that, many of the pages of the documents supplied to the detenu were not legible. Reliance was placed on Mary Selma v. State of Kerala [2021 KHC 127].

3. Sri Anas, learned Government Pleader would contend that the detention order was sent forthwith and after execution, approval was within 12 working days. It is pointed out that the Saturdays were holidays due to the pandemic situation. There is no delay in disposal of Ext.P2 representation which was sent only to the Advisory Board and not to the Government. The representation was received by the Government on the same being transmitted to it along with the recommendation of the Advisory Board which was dated 21.10.2021 and received by the Government on 22.10.2021. The order was confirmed on 29.10.2021 and the intimation dated 30.10.2021, regarding the rejection of the representation sent to the detenu. The decision to reject the representation was taken simultaneous to the order of confirmation. As far as

5

the two bail orders alleged to have been not placed before the detaining authority, one was on 05.08.2021, the date of the recommendation of the Sponsoring Authority and the other, after the order of detention. The 107 proceedings were noticed by the detaining authority and the same found to be insufficient to restrain the detenu from committing further offences; he being a habitual offender and history sheeter. As far as service of legible copies it is argued that there were three cases after the earlier detention. Even if such irregularities arise in two such cases, the requirement is of only one case when there is an earlier order of detention. As far as the complaints being those initiated by Police Officers, it is pointed out that in one of the attacks by the detenu, the shoulder of a Police Officer was fractured. The learned Government Pleader relied on Rafiya v. State of Kerala [2019 (1) KHC 63] and Joicy v. State of Kerala [2018 (3) KHC 37].

4. The detention order at Ext.P1 was dated 01.09.2021 and the last prejudicial act on 11.06.2021.

6

It is to be noticed that immediately after the last prejudicial act the detenu was taken into custody and remanded, ie: on 12.06.2021. Obviously investigation would have proceeded and since there was no final report filed, after about two months, the Sponsoring Authority recommended preventive detention by report dated 05.08.2021. This would have been fully realizing that the detenu would be released on expiry of three months, without the final report being filed. We do not find the delay as having vitiated the detention order especially since the detenu was arrested and remanded after the last prejudicial act. If the Sponsoring Authority had initiated proceedings earlier, it would have been argued that there was no necessity. The next contention is with respect to the detention order having not been forthwith forwarded as as required under S.7(3). We are told that the order dated 01.09.2021 was received by the Government only on 06.09.2021, the same having been sent by hand; which violates the mandate under S.7(3). Rafiya V State of Kerala 2019 (1) KHC 63 held that though forthwith

7

does not mean instantaneous, five days would run foul of the requirement. In that case the detention order was forwarded forthwith but the other records were sent delayed. Here the entire records along with the detention order reached the Government only after five days.

5. We have already found the detention order to be vitiated, but we would address the other arguments for completion. The execution of the order was on 04.09.2021 and the delay though only of three days is assailed on the ground that even one day's delay results in unnecessary incarceration of the detenu. True the detenu was in custody on 12.06.2021. When the order on 01.09.2021 was passed merely because the detenu was remanded, the Police cannot arrest him forthwith. The detenu has been remanded to judicial custody and it is a requirement of law that permission be obtained from the Court in whose custody the detenu remains, before the preventive detention order is executed. The JFCM I Court Ettumanoor was approached immediately which permitted the execution of the

8

preventive detention order, by order dated 03.09.2021 and on the next day the detenu was taken into preventive detention. We find no reason to find fault with the detention on the ground of the delay urged in executing the order. The next ground of delay is regarding the order of approval, Ext.P3, dated 22.09.2021 passed by the Government. The consideration of the above issued revolves around whether Saturdays were declared holidays. We have verified from the Registry itself and we are told that due to the pandemic situation Saturdays between April 24 and September 18 were declared holidays by the Government of Kerala, which was adopted for the High Court also. If that be so, Ext.P3 order of approval was passed within twelve working days as is required under S.7(3); excluding the weekend days and a holiday on the 21st. The next ground of delay is, disposal of Ext.P2 representation dated 10.09.2021. The representations were addressed to the Advisory Board and would have reached the Advisory Board even before the reference of the detention order by the Government

9

to the Advisory Board. The Government received it only on 22.10.2021 and the same was rejected just prior to the order of conformation as we see from the files. The Communication dated 30.10.2021 is just an intimation given to the detenu and it cannot be said that the date of the said communication is the date of intimation. The grounds raised of delay, except that of the forthwith communication to the Government under Section 3(3) of the KAA(P)A having not been carried out, does not impress us and are rejected.

6. Ext.P6 is a bail order dated 13.09.2021 passed after the detention order. Definitely the said order could not have been perused by the detaining authority. There is no requirement for the sponsoring authority to place the subsequent order before the Government or the Advisory Board, since what is considered is the satisfaction of the detaining authority as on the date of order of detention. Nothing prevented the detenu who filed a representation through a Counsel to place the order before the Advisory Board or the Government as a

10

mitigating factor. However, Ext.P5 is dated 05.08.2021, which, as pointed out by the learned Government Pleader, was on the date of the report of the Sanctioning Authority. True, the Sanctioning Authority would not have been aware of the bail order, on the day on which the said authority had recommended preventive detention. The recommendation was pending before the Detaining Authority and it was incumbent upon the Sponsoring Authority to inform the Detaining Authority about the subsequent order of bail. This would ensure that the Detaining Authority also considers the conditions on which the detenu has been released, and ascertain whether that would be sufficient to restrain the detenu; so as to avoid a preventive detention. Here we have to emphatically notice that when the bail order was passed on 05.08.2021 the Detaining Authority issued the detention order on 01.09.2021; between which period the issue was pending before the Detaining Authority. Non supply of bail order to the Detaining Authority vitiates the detention.

11

7. As far as 107 proceedings is concerned the argument of the learned Counsel is that such proceedings dated 19.07.2021 was unnecessary since the detenu was in custody. Besides the fact that the said argument could only be raised in the S.107 proceedings, we cannot but observe that herein, a person who was once detained under the KA(P)A, immediately on release, again committed three crimes. This would have motivated the Police to take up the S.107 proceedings, again fully realizing that there is possibility of the accused being released on bail. As far as the illegible copy supplied to the detenu, we desist from going through each of the pages since already we have found the detention to be vitiated. It is trite that if the copies, with reference to the relevant crimes are not legible the detention would stand vitiated. But, it is equally trite that if the copies supplied as against the number of crimes required under the KAA(P)A are legible and complete, then, the detention would not be vitiated merely because there were illegible copies supplied in the

12

case of the other crimes. As far as the crimes being initiated by Police, Joicy (supra) answers the contention raised. The attack resulted in grievous injury to the Policemen and that would not stand excluded under the KAA(P)A.

8. On the grounds of the detention order, not having been forthwith communicated to the Government as provided under S.3(3) of the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007 and also on the ground that Ext.P5 bail order was not put before the Detaining Authority for consideration, we are of the opinion that preventive detention cannot be sustained. The detenue shall be released forthwith from custody, if he is not required in any other case. The Registry shall communicate this order to the concerned prison.

Sd/-

K.VINOD CHANDRAN, JUDGE

Sd/-

C.JAYACHANDRAN, JUDGE

sp/jma/06/04/2022