- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
KALI CHARAN MAHTO And ORS v. GANGADHAR MAHTO And ORS
High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi — Summary of Opinion (M.A. No. 75 of 2002)
Factual and Procedural Background
This matter arises from Title Partition Suit No. 230 of 1985. The trial court dismissed the partition suit. An appeal was taken (Title Appeal No. 50 of 2000) and the learned 1st Additional Judicial Commissioner, Khunti passed a judgment and decree dated 28.01.2002 (decree signed on 07.02.2002) setting aside the trial court's judgment and remanding the matter to the trial court with a direction that the plaintiffs be permitted to add the Deputy Commissioner, Ranchi as a party. The present appeal (M.A. No. 75 of 2002) challenges that impugned order. The petitioners/appellants and respondents are parties named in the record (multiple family members listed on both sides). The Court heard counsel for both sides on 26.03.2019 and considered legal submissions regarding joinder of the Deputy Commissioner and the applicability of The Bihar Scheduled Areas Regulation, 1969.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Deputy Commissioner (or the State) was a necessary party to the partition suit (Title Partition Suit No. 230 of 1985) such that the lower appellate court was justified in remanding the matter to permit impleading the Deputy Commissioner.
- Whether the proviso added to Order 1, Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure by The Bihar Scheduled Areas Regulation, 1969—which requires the Deputy Commissioner to be joined as a defendant in suits for declaration of title or for possession relating to immovable properties of members of Scheduled Tribes in scheduled areas—applies to a partition suit.
- Whether the lower appellate court ought to have decided the appeal on merits instead of remanding it to the trial court for addition of the Deputy Commissioner.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The appeal challenges the lower appellate court's order which set aside the trial court judgment and remanded the case directing the plaintiffs to add the Deputy Commissioner, Ranchi as a party.
- The underlying suit is a partition suit (Title Partition Suit No. 230 of 1985) and no relief was claimed against the State or Deputy Commissioner; therefore the State/Deputy Commissioner was neither a necessary nor a proper party.
- Issue No. 11 in the trial court had asked whether the suit was barred for non-joinder of a necessary party; the trial court had decided this issue against the plaintiffs. The appellants argued that a plea of non-joinder not raised in the written statement cannot be raised only at the stage of argument.
- Order 1 Rule 3 CPC requires joinder only when rights to relief arise out of the same act/transaction; since no relief was sought against the State, Order 1 Rule 3 does not support impleading the State or Deputy Commissioner.
- Relied on this Court's decision in 2005 (2) JLJR 489 (Uma Pada Choudhary v. Panchanand Choudhary) for the proposition that the State was not a necessary party where no declaration of title or possession was sought against the State.
Respondents' Arguments
- Admitted that the parties are tribals; relied on The Bihar Scheduled Areas Regulation, 1969 and the amendment to Order 1, Rule 3 CPC applicable to scheduled areas.
- Submitted that by virtue of the 1969 regulation, in suits for declaration of title or for possession relating to immovable property of members of Scheduled Tribes as specified in Part III of the Schedule to the Constitution (Scheduled Tribes) Order, 1950, the Deputy Commissioner shall be joined as a defendant; hence the lower court's direction to add the Deputy Commissioner is supported by statute.
- Argued that the court has power to add or delete parties suo motu and the lower appellate court correctly exercised that power in remanding the case to mandate impleading the Deputy Commissioner even though the specific statutory provision was not mentioned in the impugned order.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| 2005 (2) JLJR 489 — Uma Pada Choudhary v. Panchanand Choudhary | Holds that where no declaration of title or possession is sought against the State, the State is not a necessary party; disputes over title and possession between private parties should be decided even in the absence of the State. | The Court relied on Paragraph 8 of this decision to conclude that because no relief was claimed against the State or the Deputy Commissioner in the partition suit, the Deputy Commissioner was not a necessary party and the lower appellate court's remand to add the Deputy Commissioner was not sustainable. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded through the following analytical steps, based on the materials on record and oral submissions:
- Nature of the Suit: The Court recorded that the proceeding arises out of Title Partition Suit No. 230 of 1985 in which the plaintiff claimed a half share in the property and a half share of compensation arising out of land acquisition. The relief sought was partition (and share), not a declaration of title or possession against the State.
- Examination of Reliefs Claimed: The Court found that no relief was claimed against the State or the Deputy Commissioner and no declaration of title and/or possession was sought against the State or the Deputy Commissioner in the title suit.
- Application of Precedent: The Court referred to this Court's earlier decision in 2005 (2) JLJR 489 (Uma Pada Choudhary v. Panchanand Choudhary) and specifically relied on Paragraph 8 of that judgment which held that where plaintiffs seek declaration of right, title and possession against private defendants and no declaration is sought against the State, the State is not a necessary party and the issues should be decided even in the absence of the State.
- Consideration of The Bihar Scheduled Areas Regulation, 1969: The Court acknowledged that the Regulation adds a proviso to Order 1, Rule 3 CPC stating that "in suits for declaration of title or for possession relating to immovable properties, of member of the scheduled Tribes ... the Deputy Commissioner shall also be joined as a defendant." However, the Court held that a partition suit does not fall within "suits for declaration of title or for possession" as contemplated by that proviso.
- Conclusion on Applicability: Because the claim was for partition (a division of jointly owned property and a claim to share) and not for a declaration of title or possession against the State, the Court concluded that the proviso relied upon by respondents (via the 1969 Regulation) does not apply to the facts of the present case.
- Assessment of Lower Appellate Court's Order: For these reasons, the Court found the lower appellate court's conclusion that the Deputy Commissioner was a necessary party and its remand to the trial court for impleading the Deputy Commissioner to be legally unsustainable.
Holding and Implications
The impugned judgment and decree of the lower appellate court are set aside; the direction to add the Deputy Commissioner, Ranchi as a party is not sustainable; and the matter is remitted to the learned lower appellate court for fresh decision of the appeal.
Implications
- Direct effect on the parties: The order remanding the matter to the trial court to permit impleading the Deputy Commissioner (on the basis that the Deputy Commissioner was a necessary party) has been set aside. The appeal is to be taken up and decided afresh by the lower appellate court on merits without the mandatory requirement to join the Deputy Commissioner in this partition suit context.
- Administrative directions: The High Court directed that the lower appellate court take up and decide the appeal as expeditiously as possible and directed that the lower court records be sent back immediately to the concerned court below.
- No new precedent announced: The Court applied existing authority (2005 (2) JLJR 489) and concluded the statutory proviso did not apply to partition suits; the opinion does not purport to establish a novel legal principle beyond its application to the facts before it.
Judge: Hon'ble Mrs. Justice Anubha Rawat Choudhary. Date of hearing noted in the record: 26.03.2019. The Court's order remits the matter to the lower appellate court for fresh disposal and directs expeditious treatment of an appeal originating from a 1985 partition suit with appeal dated 2002.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
M. A. No. 75 of 2002
1. Kali Charan Mahto.
2. Debendra Mahto
3. Meghnath Mahto.
4. Parikshit Mahto
5. Mahendra Mahto All sons of Late Shyam Singh Mahto, residents of village Jopno, P.S. Tamar, Dist. Ranchi.
6. Sundermani, widow of Late SheoCharanMahto.
7. Ganpati Mahto
8. Dinbandhu Mahto both sons of Late Sheo Charan Mahto, residents of Village - Jopno, P.S. Tamar, Dist. Ranchi
9. Savitri, wife of Sri Jogeshwar Mahto, resident of village - Ichadih, P.S. Tamar, Dist. Ranchi.
10. Smt. Shari Devi, wife of Late Deonath Mahto, resident of village Saodih, P.S. Sonahatu, Dist.-Ranchi.
11. Smt. Gurubari Devi, wife of Sri Guhi Ram, resident of village - Burudih, P.S. Tamar, Dist. Ranchi.
12. Smt. Jashoda, wife of Sri Raj Kishore Mahto, resident of village- Landupdih, P.S. Sonahatu, Dist.-Ranchi.
13. Smt. Deoki, wife of Sri BistuMahto, resident of village - Chayadih, P.S. Tamar, Dist. -Ranchi.
14. Smt. Kulowati, wife of Sri Chandra Mohan Mahto, resident of village - Lenkeya, P.S. Tamar, Dist.-Ranchi.
15. Smt. Saraswati Devi, wife of Sri Shankar Mahto, resident of village - Palashdih, P.S. Ichagarh, Dist.-West Singhbhum.
… … Plaintiffs/Appellants/Appellants
Versus
1. Gangadhar Mahto.
2. Rameshwar Mahto.
3. Kripa Mahto
4. BishambharMahto
5. Raj Kapoor Mahto. - all sons of Late Lakhi Ram Mahto - all residents of village Jopno, P.S. Tamar, Dist.- Ranchi.
6. Smt. Balawati, wife of Sri Nagen Mahto, resident of village Chirudih, P.S. Tamar, Dist. Ranchi.
7. Smt. Tarawati, wife of Sri Bhado Mahto, resident of village - Roladih, P.S. Tamar, Dist. Ranchi.
8. Congress Mahto.
9. Bhujan Mahto.
10. Pintu Mahto. - all sons of Late Jai Chand Mahto, residents of village - Diandih, P.S. Khagarh, Dist. Singhbhum West.
… … Defendants/Respondent/ Respondents
---
CORAM: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
1
2
---
For the Appellants : Mr. Kundan Kumar Ambastha, Advocate
For the Respondents : Mr. Lalit Kumar Lal, Advocate ---
16/26.03.2019
1. Heard Mr. Kundan Kumar Ambastha, counsel appearing on behalf of the appellants.
2. Heard Mr. Lalit Kumar Lal, counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents.
3. Counsel for the parties jointly submit that although the instant case has been listed under the heading for orders, but the case may be taken up for final disposal and accordingly they have argued the case on the merits at length.
4. Counsel for the appellants submits that this appeal has been filed against the judgment and decree dated 28.01.2002 (decree signed on 07.02.2002) passed by 1st, Additional Judicial Commissioner, Khunti in Title Appeal No. 50 of 2000 setting aside the judgment and decree passed in Partition Suit No. 230 of 1985 and remanding back the case to the learned trial court directing the plaintiffs/appellants to add the Deputy Commissioner, Ranchi a party in the suit.
5. Counsel for the appellants submits that the matter arose out of Title Partition Suit No. 230 of 1985, which was dismissed by the learned trial court. He submits that in the matter of partition suit, which was involved in this case, no relief was claimed against the State and the State was neither a necessary party nor a proper party and the matter was exclusively between the plaintiffs and the defendants. Accordingly, the learned lower appellate court was not justified in holding that the Deputy Commissioner, Ranchi was a necessary party and remanding the matter to the learned trial court by directing the appellants to make the Deputy Commissioner, Ranchi as a party in the suit. He submits that the suit was for partition of suit land to
3
the extent of ½ share including ½ share in the compensation amount arising out of land acquisition.
6. The counsel further submits that before the learned trial court one of the issues which was framed was issue no. 11 as to whether the suit is barred on account of non-joinder of a necessary party? This issue was decided by the learned trial court vide Para 17 of the judgment against the plaintiff. He submits that even in the written statement, the defendants did not raise a plea that the State having not been made party, the suit was barred on account of non-joinder of necessary party and it was argued by the plaintiff before the learned trial court that such plea was taken at the stage of argument, which is not permissible in law. However, the learned trial court held that the Deputy Commissioner was a necessary party and held that such legal plea can be raised at any stage. The learned trial court dismissed the suit. The appellant filed an appeal and the learned lower appellate court vide impugned order remanded the case to the learned trial court after setting aside the judgment and decree passed by the trial court with a direction to allow the plaintiffs to add Deputy Commissioner as a party in the suit.
7. Counsel for the appellants refers to Order 1, Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 and submits that as per Order 1, Rule 3 of C.P.C., persons may be joined in one suit as defendants, only when any right to relief in respect of, or arising out of the same act or transaction or series of acts or transactions is alleged to exist against such person, whether jointly, severally or in the alternative. He submits that no relief was claimed against the State and accordingly, it cannot be said that the Deputy Commissioner was a necessary party or a proper party. He further submits that the learned lower appellate court ought to have decided the case on merits, instead of remitting back the case to the learned trial court,
4
allowing the plaintiffs/appellants to add the Deputy Commissioner, as a party in the suit. He has relied upon a judgment passed by this Court reported in 2005 (2) JLJR 489 (Uma Pada Choudhary vs. Panchanand Choudhary) and submits that in view of the ratio laid down by this Court at Para 8 of the said judgment, that case that State was not a necessary party, as no declaration of title and so-called possession was sought for against the State and it was held that under such circumstances, there was no necessity of impleading the State as a defendant in the suit.
8. Counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents, on the other hand, submits that admittedly the parties herein are tribals and he has referred to the provisions of Bihar Scheduled Areas Regulation, 1969 and has referred to amendment made in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, so far as it relates Order 1, Rule 3 of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 when applied to schedule areas and submits that by virtue of aforesaid regulation of 1969, it is a statutory requirement that in a suit for declaration of title or for possession relating to immovable property of members of Scheduled Tribe as specified in Part III of the Schedule 2, the Constitution (Scheduled Tribes) Order, 1950, the Deputy Commissioner concerned, shall be joined as a defendant.
9. The counsel submits that Court has power to pass appropriate order for addition or for deletion of party and for that purpose no specific petition is required, particularly when there is a statutory requirement to make the Deputy Commissioner as a party in a suit for declaration of title or for possession relating to immovable properties of Schedule Tribes in schedule areas. He submits that the learned court below has exercised such power and has passed order in consonance with the aforesaid regulation of 1969 although the aforesaid provision of law has not been mentioned in the impugned order and accordingly, there is no illegality or perversity in the
5
impugned order of remand, which does not call for any interference.
10. In response, counsel for the appellants submits that the proceeding involved in the suit was a partition suit and accordingly, the parties were not seeking any declaration of title or for possession and there is no dispute that in the matter regarding partition, all the parties of a family are joint owners of the property and accordingly, he submits that the aforesaid provisions of The Bihar Scheduled Areas Regulation, 1969 amending the Code of Civil Procedure as applicable in schedule areas, has no applicability to the facts and circumstances of this case.
11. After hearing the counsels for the parties and after considering the materials on record, this Court finds that admittedly the proceeding herein arises out of Title Partition Suit No. 230 of 1985, wherein the plaintiff claimed share to the extent of half share of the property involved in the case and half share of the compensation amount.
12. From the perusal of materials on record, this Court further finds that no relief whatsoever was claimed against the State or Deputy Commissioner and no declaration of title and/or possession was sought for by the plaintiff in the title suit much less against the State or the Deputy Commissioner. In such circumstances, in view of the Judgment passed by this Court reported in 2005 (2) JLJR 489 (Uma Pada Choudhary vs. Panchanand Choudhary), this Court is of the considered view that the Deputy Commissioner is not a necessary party in the suit and accordingly, the impugned judgment which has been passed by the learned lower appellate court holding that the Deputy Commissioner is a necessary party and remanding the matter to the learned trial court is not sustainable in law. It has been held in Para 8 of the aforesaid judgment as follows:-
"Having heard the learned Counsel for the appellants and perused the records, I find that plaintiff
6
and sought reliefs of declarations of their right, title and interest and confirmation of possession and for declaration that the order of the Circle Officer for their eviction is illegal and without jurisdiction. No declaration of title and/or possession was sought for against the State of Bihar. Such being the case there was no necessity of impleading the State of Bihar as a defendant in the suit. The nature of the claim of the appellants was purely relating to title and possession with respect to the suit land which were allegedly interfered with, by defendants, giving rise to the cause of action for the suit. In that view, there was no necessity to add the State of Bihar as a defendant as the issues involved were the contesting claims of right, title between the plaintiffs and the defendants. So far the order of the Circle Officer is concerned, the same has not declared any right and title. The Circle Office held that Kurfa settlement in favour of the father of the plaintiff No. 1 was contrary to the provision of Santhal Parganas Tenancy Act without taking into consideration that at the time of the said settlement, the Act itself was not in existence and it was brought on statute book much thereafter. There was no question of contravention of any provision which was then not in existence. The Court below has thus committed serious errors in arriving at the finding that the suit was bad for nonjoinder of the State of Bihar and on that ground dismissing the plaintiffs suit and appeal. It is thus held that the State of Bihar was not a necessary party to the suit and the reliefs prayed for by the plaintiffs relating to declaration of their title and confirmation of possession should have been considered and decided even in absence of the Circle Officer or the State of Bihar."
13. So far as the argument of the counsel for the respondents regarding applicability of The Bihar Scheduled Areas Regulation, 1969 and its amendment to the provisions of Code of Civil Procedure Order 1, Rule 3 is concerned this Court finds that the following provision was added to Rule of Order 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 i.e. :-
"Provided that in suits for declaration of title or for possession relating to immovable properties, of member of the scheduled Tribes as specified in Part III to the Schedule to the Constitution (Scheduled
7
Tribes) Order, 1950" the Deputy Commissioner shall also be joined as a defendant."
14. This Court is of the considered view that a partition suit does not relate to declaration of title or for possession relating to immovable properties and accordingly, the aforesaid provision as relied upon by the counsel for the respondents has no applicability to the facts and circumstances of this case. Although, in the impugned order, The Bihar Scheduled Areas Regulation, 1969 has not been referred, but the impugned order cannot be sustained by referring to the aforesaid regulation of
1969.
15. As a cumulative effect to the aforesaid findings of the impugned judgment and decree are hereby set-aside and the matter is remitted to the learned lower appellate court for fresh decision of the appeal.
16. The partition suit is of the year 1985 and the appeal itself is of the year 2002, accordingly, the learned lower appellate court is directed to take up the appeal and decide the same in accordance with law as expeditiously as possible.
17. The Lower Court Records which has been received, are directed to be immediately sent back to the concerned Court below.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
Mukul
Alert