- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
SWARNENDU BANERJEE v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, Swarnendu Banerjee, is a playing member of the West Bengal Bridge Association and has participated in several Bridge Tournaments organised by the respondent no. 3, the Bridge Federation of India (BFI). The West Bengal Bridge Association is affiliated to BFI. The petitioner challenged two notices issued by BFI dated 20th July, 2022 and 1st August, 2022, by which he was suspended from all Bridge Tournaments pending enquiry and debarred from participating in any tournament conducted or approved by BFI, including international events of the World Bridge Federation, for a period of 18 months effective from 15th July, 2022.
The petitioner filed a writ petition seeking quashing of these notices. The BFI contended that the writ petition was not maintainable as it is not an entity amenable to judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The Court first addressed the maintainability of the petition before proceeding to the merits.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Bridge Federation of India (BFI) is amenable to judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution of India despite not being a 'state' under Article 12.
- Whether the petitioner’s suspension and debarment notices issued by BFI were valid and complied with the procedural requirements under the Rules and Regulations of BFI.
- Whether the alleged social media posts by the petitioner constituted an "impropriety" as defined under Rule XXXVIII(i) of the BFI Rules, warranting disciplinary action equivalent to cheating or fraud.
- Whether the disciplinary procedure under Rule XXXVIII was properly followed before imposing the suspension and debarment on the petitioner.
Arguments of the Parties
Respondent (BFI) Arguments
- The writ petition is not maintainable as BFI is not a state entity amenable to jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution.
- The writ petition is in the nature of a service dispute and therefore not maintainable.
Petitioner Arguments
- BFI exercises exclusive control over Bridge Tournaments and player selection at national and international levels, making it amenable to judicial review akin to the BCCI.
- The suspension and debarment notices do not comply with the procedural safeguards under the BFI Rules, specifically the involvement of the Executive Committee and Disciplinary Committee.
- The social media posts do not amount to "impropriety" as defined in Rule XXXVIII(i) and cannot be equated with cheating or fraud.
- The punishment of 18 months debarment is arbitrary and excessive without justification or procedural compliance.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Board of Control for Cricket in India vs. Cricket Association of Bihar (2015) 3 SCC 251 | Determination that BCCI is amenable to judicial review under Article 226 despite not being a 'state' under Article 12. | The Court applied the rationale to BFI, holding that BFI’s exclusive control over Bridge Tournaments and player selection makes it amenable to judicial review. |
| St. Mary's Education Society vs. Rajendra Prasad Bhargava, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1091 | Definition of "public duty" as involving a public law element and requiring a direct nexus between the act complained of and discharge of public duty. | The Court held that BFI’s actions have an indisputable nexus with the discharge of public duty, justifying maintainability of the writ petition. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court began by addressing the maintainability of the writ petition. It relied on the Supreme Court’s decision in the BCCI case to hold that BFI, like BCCI, exercises exclusive control over the sport of Bridge in India and is therefore amenable to judicial review under Article 226, despite not being a 'state' under Article 12. The Court noted the financial connection between BFI and public sports bodies, reinforcing this conclusion.
The Court rejected the argument that the petition was a service dispute, noting the petitioner is not a member of BFI but a player affiliated via the West Bengal Bridge Association. The Court emphasized the public law element involved in BFI’s functions of player selection and regulation.
On the merits, the Court examined the impugned notices suspending and debarring the petitioner. It found that the notices were issued by the Honorary General Secretary without any indication that the Executive Committee, as required under Rule XXII, had determined the penalty. The Court reviewed Rule XXXVIII, which mandates a disciplinary process including appointment of a Disciplinary Committee, investigation of complaints, notice to the accused, and an opportunity to be heard before disciplinary action.
The Court found no evidence that this procedure was followed. The second notice did not show that the petitioner was given a hearing or opportunity to respond to findings of the Disciplinary Committee. The Court also interpreted the term "impropriety" in Rule XXXVIII(i) in context with "cheating" and "fraud," holding that the petitioner’s social media posts alleging ineffective governance and misuse of funds did not amount to an impropriety of comparable gravity.
Furthermore, the Court found the 18-month debarment arbitrary and unreasonable, lacking any explanation or justification. The Court viewed the disciplinary action as disproportionate and potentially retaliatory against a whistle-blower.
Consequently, the Court quashed the impugned notices and granted an injunction restraining BFI from acting on them.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition (WPA No. 19570 of 2022) is allowed and the impugned suspension and debarment notices dated 20th July, 2022 and 1st August, 2022 are quashed.
The Bridge Federation of India is restrained from suspending or debarring the petitioner from participating in national and international Bridge Tournaments conducted or approved by BFI pursuant to these notices. The decision restores the petitioner’s eligibility to participate in such tournaments pending due disciplinary process. No new legal precedent beyond the application of existing principles regarding the nature of sporting bodies and procedural fairness in disciplinary actions is established by this judgment.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction Appellate Side
Present :-
The Hon'ble Justice Moushumi Bhattacharya. W.P.A 19570 of 2022
Vs.
Union of India & ors.
For the petitioner : Mr. Rahul Karmakar, Adv. Mr. Sounak Mukherjee, Adv.
For the respondent nos. 1 & 2 : Mr. Sandip Kumar Bhattacharyya, Adv. For the respondent no. 3 : Mr. Soumya Majumder, Adv. Ms. Sanjukta Dutta, Adv.
Last Heard on : 29.11.2022
Delivered on : 06.12.2022
Moushumi Bhattacharya, J.
1. The petitioner is a playing member of the West Bengal Bridge Association and has participated in several Bridge Tournaments organised by the respondent no. 3/Bridge Federation of India (BFI). The West Bengal Bridge Association is affiliated to the Bridge Federation of India. The
1
2
petitioner seeks quashing of two notices issued by the BFI dated 20thJuly, 2022 and 1stAugust, 2022. By these letters, the petitioner was suspended from all Bridge Tournaments pending enquiry and was debarred from participating in any tournament conducted by the BFI as well as international events of the World Bridge Federation for a period of 18 months effective from 15thJuly, 2022.
2. The BFI, represented by learned counsel, urges that the writ petition is not maintainable since the Bridge Federation of India against who reliefs have been sought, is not an entity amenable to Article 226 of The Constitution of India.
3. The point of maintainability is being answered first.
4. It is undisputed that BFI is the sole custodian of the right to select players for national and international Bridge Tournaments and approves their participation in such events. BFI hence is the only decision-making body in matters of permitting selected players for participating in national and international Bridge Tournaments. The Supreme Court dealt with a similar question on whether the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) was amenable to judicial review: Board of Control for Cricket in India vs. Cricket Association of Bihar; (2015) 3 SCC 251. The Supreme Court held that BCCI falls within Article 226 of the Constitution even though it is not a 'state' within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution. The rationale of the Supreme Court was based on the nature of the duties and function
3
performed by BCCI; one of the grounds being that BCCI has complete control over the game of cricket in this country to the exclusion of all others.
5. Paragraph 33 of the Report applies with full vigour to the facts and logic in the present case. Like the BCCI, the respondent no. 3/Bridge Federation of India, formulates the regulations, norms and standards covering all aspects of Bridge Tournaments played in the country as well as outside India. The power of choosing the members of the national team and of disqualifying players is also a common function shared by both BFI and BCCI. This would be borne out from the impugned decisions of suspension and debarment made against the petitioner in the present case as well as the Rules and Regulations forming part of the Memorandum and Articles of Association of BFI. The Rules and Regulations indicate that BFI has complete sway over the game of Bridge in the country and exercises sole authority which may irrevocably impact the sporting career of a Bridge player. The facts concerning the merits of the case in the following paragraphs would substantiate this point.
6. Besides, the balance-sheet of BFI as of 31stMarch, 2019 reflects the grants and sponsorships received from the Sports Authority of India which further goes to show the financial connection between BFI and public bodies related to sports in the country.
7. The argument of learned counsel appearing for BFI that the writ petition is in the nature of a service dispute is liable to be rejected. The argument may have been persuasive had the petitioner been a member of
4
BFI. This is evidently not the case since a 'member' of BFI can only mean a State association or an All India Sports Control Body affiliated to BFI under Rule I(14) of the Rules and Regulations of BFI. Rule 1(18) also provides that a permanent member shall only mean the association registered under the relevant Act framed in the State/UT having registered players to conduct bridge events in the State/UT. The fact that the petitioner is not a member of BFI hence deflates the argument of the writ petition being in the nature of a service dispute. In St. Mary's Education Society vs. Rajendra Prasad Bhargava; 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1091, the Supreme Court explained the meaning of the expression "public duty" as a duty or obligation to the public involving a public law element. The Supreme Court proceeded to hold that the act complained of must have a direct nexus with the discharge of public duty. In the present case, BFI being the sole repository of rights in connection with selection of players including for grant of permission to play in national and international Bridge Tournaments, has debarred the petitioner from both national and international events of BFI. Hence there is an indisputable nexus between the act complained of and the discharge of public duty in the present case.
8. This Court therefore is inclined to reject the argument of the BFI and hold that the writ petition is maintainable.
9. Now to the merits of the case. The two impugned letters under challenge are of 20thJuly, 2022 and 1stAugust, 2022. By the first letter, the petitioner was communicated that a "disciplinary committee" of BFI has decided to suspend the petitioner from all Bridge Tournaments with
5
immediate effect and the petitioner was asked to reply to the same. The second letter treated the first letter as a show-cause notice and noted the 'un-satisfactory' reply of 25thJuly, 2022 of the petitioner and proceeded to debar the petitioner from tournaments conducted/approved by BFI and also international events of the World Bridge Federation for a period of 18 months starting from 15thJuly, 2022.
10. The impugned letters are a result of a series of posts on the social media by the petitioner in July, 2022 against the administrators/portfolio holders of BFI. The posts do not bear a direct reference to the administrators by name but draw a slanted reference to other governing body members of sports organisations across the country who have brought disrepute to the organisations. The posts refer to misuse of Central Government funds allocated to BFI.
11. The issue is not whether the allegations made by the petitioner against the office bearers of BFI are true or false. The issue is whether the BFI could have show-caused the petitioner with suspension and debarred the petitioner from taking part in any national and international Bridge Tournaments which are conducted/approved by BFI. The issue directly brings the Court to the Rules and Regulations of the BFI contained in its Memorandum and Articles of Association. Under Rule XXII (b)(v), "Executive Committee" has the power to determine penalties to be inflicted on any member or any player for an infringement of the Rules of the game and the Rules of the Federation. The constitution of the Executive Committee is found in Rule I(17) and is further defined in Rule XXII to mean the office
6
bearers of the Federation and the Chairmen of the Technical Development Committee and National Laws Commission. "Office bearers", under Rule I(19) means the President, the Vice-Presidents, the Honorary General Secretary and Executive members and finds a more exhaustive explanation under Rule XIII.
12. The first lacunae in the impugned notice is the absence of any indication that the Executive Committee, as constituted under Rule XXII determined the penalty imposed on the petitioner in the form of suspension or debarment.
13. Rule XXXVIII is also relevant to the present adjudication. Rule XXXVIII - "Code of Disciplinary Regulations" empowers the Executive Committee to expel, suspend or otherwise discipline a player for any of the reasons provided under the Rule. Rule XXVIII(i) is one of the instances in which the Executive Committee exercise its power to discipline a player;
"Rule XXVIII.
....................
(i) in case of impropriety/ cheating/ fraud committed by the said player."
14. The alleged impropriety of the posts on the social media suggesting ineffective management of BFI and financial malpractices will have to be read in the context of the other two conditions in Rule XXXVIII(i) i.e
"cheating/ fraud". The requirement to read "impropriety" in its contextual and surrounding sense arises from the use of the "/" between the three words namely "impropriety/ cheating/ fraud" committed by the player. The
"/" though commonly used to mean either/or or a substitute arises from the
7
word "Obliquus" (latin) which means oblique; cross; transverse; co-lateral:
Black's Law Dictionary, 6thEd.
15. This definition assists the petitioner in convincing the Court that
"impropriety" must be read in conjunction with or in contextual reference to the other two offences under Rule XXXVIII (i) i.e. 'cheating' and 'fraud'. In other words, the impropriety must be of a level and of a degree and gravity similar to an offence of cheating and fraud committed by a player in order to warrant expulsion, suspension or any other form of disciplinary measure. In the present case, the social media posts suggesting ineffective and self- serving governance of BFI does not qualify as an impropriety which can be equated with cheating or fraud.
16. The next question is of more significance, whether the impugned debarment was in compliance of and followed the procedure laid down under Rule XXXVIII
17. Under Rule XXXVIII(1), the Executive Committee shall appoint a
"Disciplinary Committee" which shall consist of 5 members. Under Rule XXXVIII(2), complaints of misconduct against a player shall be referred to the Disciplinary Committee unless the Executive Committee decides otherwise. Rule XXXVIII(4) mandates that no action shall be taken by the Executive Committee or Disciplinary Committee without first notifying the accused player of the nature of charges against him and allowing sufficient time to the accused to answer such charges. More important, under Rule XXXVIII(5), the Disciplinary Committee shall investigate the complaints
8
against the player and adjudge such complaints after notice and opportunity to the player for being heard before the player is censured, suspended, expelled, etc. The right of representation of the player also forms part of Rule
XXXVIII(5).
18. In the present case, the impugned notices were issued by the Honorary General Secretary of BFI with copies to the West Bengal Bridge Association, and all Member State Associations. The material before the Court does not contain any evidence of the step-wise procedure envisaged under Rule XXXVIII being followed by BFI before the petitioner was debarred or disciplined for the reasons under the said Rule. The step-wise procedure contains a requirement of not only the accused player having notice of the charges against him (which may have been done in the present case by the first notice) but also the requirement of the disciplinary committee to investigate complaints and a further opportunity of hearing to the player before any further disciplinary action is taken against the player [Rule
XXXVIII(5)].
19. Moreover, the second impugned letter of 1stAugust, 2022 does not indicate that the petitioner was given any such opportunity before the debarment or any material of the findings of the Disciplinary Committee which the petitioner could have answered to had the petitioner been given such an opportunity. The only ground given is the alleged un-satisfactory reply of the petitioner. The impugned decision appears more to be of a collective and concerted retaliation against a "whistle-blower" although the posts do not point to any particular office-bearer of BFI.
9
20. Notably, the debarment for a period of 18 months is also arbitrary since there is no reason given for the length of the period of debarment. A debarment of 18 months is unreasonable and extreme for a player who regularly participates in Bridge Tournaments across the country, unless such punishment is justified under the Rules and Regulations framed by BFI. This Court is informed that the petitioner has already missed out on several Bridge Tournaments from the date of the impugned notices.
21. Having found that the alleged impropriety does not fall under Rule XXXVIII of the Rules and Regulations of the BFI, and that the impugned letters were not issued by a properly-constituted Executive Committee and further that the procedure provided under the Rules was not followed for imposing the penalty on the petitioner, this Court is inclined to quash the impugned notices of 20thJuly, 2022 and 1stAugust, 2022. There shall be an injunction on BFI from acting in terms of the notices in the matter of suspension or debarring the petitioner from national and international Bridge Tournaments conducted or approved by the BFI.
22. WPA No. 19570 of 2022 is accordingly disposed of in terms of this judgment.
Urgent Photostat certified copies of this judgment, if applied for, be supplied to the respective parties upon fulfillment of requisite formalities. (Moushumi Bhattacharya, J.)
Alert