Bookmark
PDF
Share
CaseIQ

SHUBHAM CHANDRA TRIPATHI v. DELHI DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY (DDA)

Central Administrative Tribunal

Dec 1, 2022

Judgment

CaseIQ

Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The applicants, who hold engineering degrees, applied for the post of Junior Engineer (JE) in the Delhi Development Authority (DDA). However, the recruitment advertisement dated 11.06.2022 restricted eligibility to candidates possessing a Diploma in Civil, Electrical, or Mechanical Engineering, explicitly excluding candidates who hold only an engineering degree without a prior diploma. The applicants challenged this condition, contending it was contrary to the recruitment rules. An interim order permitted the applicants to appear provisionally in the selection examination, with the results withheld pending the Tribunal's decision. Multiple Original Applications (O.A.s) challenging the same advertisement and conditions were consolidated for hearing, with factual discussion centered on O.A. No. 1741/2022.

Legal Issues Presented

Whether the exclusion of engineering degree holders from eligibility for the post of Junior Engineer under the advertisement dated 11.06.2022 is contrary to the Delhi Development Authority (Junior Engineer) Recruitment Rules, 2018.
Whether a higher qualification (Degree in Engineering) should be considered a disqualification for appointment to a post requiring a lower qualification (Diploma in Engineering).
Whether the interpretation of the recruitment rules by the respondent, restricting eligibility to diploma holders only, is valid and sustainable.
Whether the applicants holding engineering degrees without a diploma are entitled to be considered eligible for recruitment to the post of Junior Engineer.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants' Arguments

The impugned note in the advertisement excluding degree holders contradicts the recruitment rules, which do not disqualify degree holders from applying for the post of Junior Engineer.
The recruitment rules for the post of Assistant Engineer (AE), a promotional post from JE, reserve 50% of vacancies for degree holders, evidencing an intent to prefer degree holders and not exclude them.
Statutory recruitment rules cannot be overridden or amended by an executive direction in an advertisement.
Possession of a higher qualification (Degree) presupposes possession of the lower qualification (Diploma), supported by Supreme Court judgments.
Excluding degree holders jeopardizes the promotion structure and availability of qualified candidates for higher posts.

Respondent's Arguments

The recruitment rules of 2018 specify Diploma in Engineering as the sole qualification for the post of Junior Engineer; degree holders without diploma are not eligible.
The term "equivalent" in the rules refers to equivalence of the institution, not the qualification, and no higher qualification or equivalence is prescribed.
The rules were framed under statutory authority, and the Union of India should have been a necessary party to the proceedings.
A note from the Member (Engineering) clarifies that diploma and degree are not equivalent and allowing degree holders would cause anomalies in pay structure and employment.
Judgments cited support strict adherence to the prescribed qualification without presuming equivalence of a higher degree to a diploma.
The respondent is in the process of amending recruitment rules for the post of Assistant Engineer to address anomalies.
The impugned note allows degree holders who first obtained a diploma to apply, thus not a blanket bar on all degree holders.
Judicial review of recruitment rules framing is limited, and this Tribunal should not interfere with the executive's prerogative.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent	Rule or Principle Cited For	Application by the Court
State of Uttarakhand and Ors. vs. Deep Chandra Tewari and Anr., Civil Appeal No. 9902/2013	Higher qualification presupposing possession of lower qualification in recruitment context.	Supported applicants' argument that degree holders should not be excluded and that higher qualification includes lower qualification unless rules expressly exclude.
Puneet Sharma and Ors. vs. Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Ltd. & Anr., 2021 SCC Online SC 291	Interpretation of recruitment rules regarding eligibility of degree holders for JE posts when a separate quota exists for degree holders in promotion to AE.	Upheld candidature of degree holders for JE posts despite exclusionary condition in advertisement, emphasizing intent of rule makers not to exclude degree holders.
Chief Manager, Punjab National Bank and Another vs. Anil Kumar Das, Civil Appeal No. 3602/2022	Eligibility to be determined strictly as per recruitment rules.	Supported respondent's argument emphasizing strict interpretation of prescribed qualifications without presuming equivalence.
Sangram vs. State of Maharashtra, Writ Petition No. 2908/2016 (Bombay High Court)	Degree holders cannot be presumed to possess lower qualification (Diploma) for eligibility.	Supported respondent's position on strict qualification adherence.
State of Punjab vs. Anita, (2015) 2 SCC 170	Whether recruitment rules provide for appointment of persons with higher qualification when only lower qualification is prescribed.	Supported respondent's argument that absence of provision for higher qualification means degree does not include diploma.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal focused on the limited issue of whether possessing a higher qualification (Degree in Engineering) should disqualify a candidate from appointment to a post requiring a lower qualification (Diploma in Engineering). It accepted the respondent's interpretation that the term "equivalent" in the recruitment rules refers to equivalence of the institution and not the qualification itself, and that the essential qualification prescribed for Junior Engineer is a Diploma in Engineering only.

However, the Tribunal found the exclusion of degree holders from eligibility to be unreasonable and contrary to principles of fairness and merit. It noted that the recruitment rules do not explicitly disqualify degree holders, and the list of disqualifications does not include possession of a higher degree. The Tribunal found the impugned note in the advertisement, which excludes degree holders unless they also possess a diploma, to be convoluted and absurd.

The Tribunal also considered the promotion rules to the post of Assistant Engineer, which reserve 50% of vacancies for degree holders, thereby demonstrating the desirability of having degree holders at the Junior Engineer level. The respondent's admission that this exclusion creates an anomaly was noted, and the limited availability of lateral entry posts for degree holders was highlighted as insufficient to provide fair opportunity.

The Tribunal emphasized that recruitment rules should be interpreted rationally, equitably, and in accordance with the principles of justice and fairness, discouraging interpretations that penalize higher qualifications. It rejected the respondent's justification that allowing degree holders would reduce diploma intake and cause anomalies in pay and employment, deeming it unreasonable.

While acknowledging the executive's prerogative in framing recruitment rules, the Tribunal held that it must interpret rules in the public interest and not allow interpretations that exclude meritorious candidates. The Tribunal found the precedent of Puneet Sharma case particularly instructive and declined to diverge from it.

Holding and Implications

The Tribunal allowed the Original Application. The note in the advertisement excluding candidates possessing only a Degree in Engineering from applying for the post of Junior Engineer was quashed as being contrary to the Recruitment Rules.

Degree holders are declared eligible for recruitment to the post of Junior Engineer irrespective of whether they also possess a Diploma in the relevant field. The respondent is directed to allow degree holders to participate without any impediment in the ongoing and future selection processes for the post of Junior Engineer.

The results of the selection examination for the applicants who appeared provisionally shall be declared, and if successful, they shall be offered appointment subject to fulfillment of other criteria.

No costs were ordered. The order is to be placed on the files of all connected Original Applications.

This decision directly affects the parties by permitting degree holders to compete for JE posts but does not establish a broader precedent beyond the interpretation of the specific Recruitment Rules and advertisement conditions.

Show all summary ...

O.A. No. 1741/2022 &

11 others

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI

OA No. 1741/2022

M.A. No. 1842/2022 With

O.A. No. 2236/2022, O.A. No. 2237/2022, O.A. No. 2168/2022, O.A. No. 1995/2022, O.A. No. 2023/2022, O.A. No. 2019/2022, O.A. No. 2242/2022, O.A. No. 2105/2022, O.A. No. 2331/2022, O.A. No. 2349/2022, O.A. No. 2325/2022

Reserved on : 19.09.2022

Pronounced on : 01.12.2022 Hon'ble Mr. R.N. Singh, Member (J) Hon'ble Mr. Tarun Shridhar, Member (A) O.A. No. 1741/2022,

M.A. No. 1842/2022

1. Shubham Chandra Tripathi, Son of ShriShailesh Chandra Tripath, Resident of B-46, Navi Gali, Karmchari Nagar, Bareilly -243122.

2. Vishal Kumar Shukla Son of Shri Brijesh Shukla Resident of C-816, DDA LIG Flats East of Loni Road Shahdra, Delhi-110093.

3. Mudit Singhal, Son of ShriKailash Chand Singhal, Resident of E -212, Sangharsh Gali, East BabarpurShahdara, Delhi 110032.

4. Dikshant Kumar, Son of ShriDev Kumar, Resident of A-1/402, Milan Vihar Apartment, Plot No. 72, I.P. Extension, Patparganj, Delhi.

5. Manish Kumar Dubey,

Son of ShriKamlesh Kumar Dubey, Resident of Najafgarh, New Delhi -43.

6. Ashish Dabas, Son of Shri S S Dabas, Resident of A-3/6, Sector-3 Rohini, Delhi-85.

7. Vikas Pandey, Son of ShriKailash Nath Pandey, Resident of Pandey Dava Khana, Village Dhanghata, Post Dhanghata, Sant Kabir Nagar-272162.

8. Ashutosh Kumar Soni, Son of ShriMahesh Prasad Soni, Resident of FF1, First Floor Block E, Skanda Apartment,

Lukerganj Prayagraj.

9. Aslam Son of Salimuddin Resident of Arronda, Vairbadshahpur Gautam Budh Nagar

Utter Pradesh-203202

10. Lakshay Saini Son of Shri Pawan Kumar Saini R/o 1217, Shivam Vihar Ganeshur, Roorkee.

11. Madan Mohan Maurya S/o Shri Sivanand Maurya R/o Robertsganj

Sonbhadra

UP 231216

12. Deepak Singh, Son of ShriLate Ajay Prakash Singh,

Resident of Rampur URF, Rudapur, Jagatpur Allahabad.

13. Amit Kumar, Son of Shri Prabhunath, Resident of 119, Gha Kamasin Bujurg, Maharajganj.

14. Ravi Prakash Mishra S/o Shri Nagendra Mishra R/o Barsipar Mishra Tola PO Chakarwa Bahordas PS Salempur District Deoria

15. Rajat Kumar Kanaujia, Son of ShriRishi Pal Singh, Resident of House No-8A, Village -Lalpur, Post -Mjp University, Bareilly.

16. Nikhil Dular, Son of ShriChandrapal Dular, Resident of Ward No-17, Muknadgarh(Rural), Jhunjhunu, Rajasthan-333705.

17. Dinesh Singh S/o Shri Mahavor Singh R/o 485/ ST-10

Mandoli Extension Delhi-110093

18. Arun Tyagi, Son of ShriSunil Tyagi, Resident of 130,Chhapraula Dadri, Gautam Buddha Nagar,

Uttar Pradesh.

19. Rajesh Kumar Roy S/o Sh Mangli Prasad R/o Karwi Chitrakoot

UP 210205

20. Ravi Joshi, Son of Shri Suresh Chandra Josi, Resident of 72, Durga Colony, Kashipur,Udham Singh Nagar, Uttarakhand.

21. Sapna Gautam, Son of ShriSurendra Nath Ram, Resident of Village Bisukia, P.O.Bisukia, District Balia, Uttar Pradesh.

…Applicants

(By Advocate : Ms. Fareha Ahmad Khan with Ms. Shagun Chopra and Ms. Kaveeta Wadia)

Versus

1) DelhiDevelopmentAuthority, Throughits

Chairman,VikasSada

Near INA

Market,NewDelhi-

110023

Email:ddachamberhc@yahoo.com Phoneno:011-23389451 …Respondent

(By Advocate : Ms. Sriparna Chatterjee with Mr. Arun Birbal and Mr. Sanjay Ghosh)

OA No. 2236/2022

1 Geetam Singh, Age 26, Group B S/o Sh. Rakesh Kumar

R/o H.No.250, Shutter Wali Gali, Deoli, Khanpur Village, Khanpur, New Delhi, Delhi 110062

2 Lekhraj Gurjar, Age 26, Group B S/o Sh. Kailash Chand Gurjar R/o GURJARON ka Mohalla, Baswa, Dausa, Rajasthan

3 Prashant Kumar, Age 25, Group B S/o Sh. Jyoti Kumar

R/o Girihinda Kanchi Road, Sheikhpura, Monghyr Bihar 811105

4 Anurag Yadav, Age 27, Group B S/o Sh. Pramendra Singh R/o 885 Professor Colony Bypass Road Shikohabad Uttar Pradesh

5 Ravi Prakash Singh, Age 26, Group B S/o Sh. Jai Prakash Singh

R/o Village Munsipur, Padraw, Post Kuttupur, Iatyen bazar Dist- Jaunpur, Uttar Pradesh

6 Nikhil, Age 25, Group B S/o Sh. Ramsoch Yadav R/o B46 Ground Floor, Gram Sabha, Harijan Basti Bawana, North West Delhi-39

7 Gajender Kumar Age 23, Group B S/o Vinod Kumar

R/o RZ H-55 Nihal Vihar New Delhi-41

8 Narender Kumar Yadav Age 27 Group B S/o Meeta Yadav

R/o Wisdom Point Hostellers, Shutter wali Gali, Khanpur, New Delhi-62

9 Kajal Age 27, Group B D/o Mohan Lal

R/o Village and Post Khajuraul, Dist. Mirzapur, Uttarpradesh 231305

10 Anamika Verma Age 26, Group B D/o Gaya prasad verma

R/o H no 90 Abdullapur

Shahjadpur Akbarpur Ambedkar Nagar Uttar Pradesh - 224122

11 Abutalib Khan Age 26, Group B S/o Abu Haraira Khan

R/o Wisdom Point Hostellers, Shutter wali Gali, Khanpur, New Delhi,110062

12 Abhishek Sagar Age 24, Group B S/o Subhash Chand

R/o 394, Gali no.7

Durgapuri Extn.,

Shahdara Delhi-110093

13 Ajay Parihar Age 26, Group B S/o Himachal Singh,

R/o Basai Bhadauriya

Tehsil: Bah, Agra

Uttar pradesh 283123

14 Anjali Singh Age 29, Group B D/o Mr. Jaswant Singh

Q.no. 158 B Railway Colony Near District Jail Aligarh Uttar pradesh -202001

15 Bhawana Solanki age 23 Group B D/O Kirpal singh

R/o H no. 138

Pooth Kalan,

Sultanpuri C block

Delhi 110086

16 Devendra singh meena age 27 Group B S/o Akhlesh Meena

R/o Ward No. 8 Nand Khurd

Post - Gorda, Tehsil- Tobadhim, District karauli Rajasthan- 321611

17 Hemraj Meena age 28 Group B S/o Jangli ram Meena

R/o Village mereda post khedi Tehsil Todabhim dist karauli Rajasthan -321611

18 Raj kumar meena age 29 group b S/o Babu lal Meena

R/o village and post Palanpur Tehsil Hindaun city, Dist Karauli Rajasthan 322234

19 Rakesh khora age 32 group b S/o Choti Lal Meena

R/o V.P.O. Meenwala,

Sirsi Road Panchyawala Jaipur Rajasthan 302034

20 Ram Manohar Meena age 28 group b S/o Ramawtar Meena

R/o village Gangdwari Tehsil- Sikrai Dausa Rajasthan - 303502

21 Ratan Pal Singh Age 25 Group B S/o Vinod Kumar Singh

R/o Village Sahwa

Post Padauli District Deoria , Uttar Pradesh Pincode -274206

22 Rituparn Mishra age 24 group b S/o chakradhar Mishra

R/o I 2 A Sleeper Ground Shantipuram Alambagh

Lucknow 226005

23 Sanjay Kumar Meena Age 27 Group B S/o Ghitori Meena

R/o Sinduki

Teh.Mahwa Dis.Dausa

Rajasthan 321608

24 Shivkesh Meena Age 26 Group B S/O Kailash Chand Meena R/O vill. Saiwala Post Buglai Sawai Madhopur

Rajasthan-322205

25 Abhishek Tiwari Age 26 Group B S/O Ashok Kumar Sharma

R/O Ward No. 24

Dawaiyo Ki Haweli

Chatikna, teh. Karauli

Rajasthan-322241

26 Anupam Mishra Age 25 Group B S/O Lalta Prasad Mishra R/O Pithipur Ghaughughar, Amethi Uttar Pradesh- 227405

27 Ravi Kumar Meena Age 24 Group B S/o Pappu Ram Meena

R/o Village & Post Nangal Lat Todabhim Karauli

Rajasthan 321611

…Applicants

(By Advocate : Mr. Sumit Sharma with Mr. Mohit)

VERSUS

Delhi Development Authority Through its Chairman Vikas Sadan,

Near INA Market New Delhi-110023 ….Respondents

(By Advocate : Ms. Sriparna Chatterjee with Mr. Arun Birbal and Mr. Sanjay Ghosh)

OA No. 2237/2022

1 MANJEET

Aged 28 Years Group "B"

S/o Jaipal Singh R/o 25/ 556

Ashok Nagar,

Near Power House Bahadurgarh

Jhajjar, Haryana- 124507

2 GAUTAM KANKARWAL

Aged 27 years Group B S/o Subhash Kankarwal R/o 386/20

Near Power House Bahadurgarh

Jhajjar, Haryana- 124507

3 RAVI

Aged 27 Years Group "B"

S/o Lala Ram

Category- SC

R/o 1133 Gali no 2, 45 feet Road Bharat Colony Faridabad Haryana

4 Nitin Kumar Meena Aged about 25 Years Group B S/o Sultan Meena

R/o C-82

Satyadev Upadhyay Marg, Karampura,Moti Nagar, New Delhi - 110015

5 Vikash Aged 24 Years Group "B"

S/o Jagmal Singh Category- SC

R/o VPO-Paintawas khurd Kitlana

Charkhi Dadri- 127309

6 Navdeep Aged 25 Years Group "B"

S/o Anil Kumar

R/o RZ-1A/D

New Heera Park , Dichaon Chowk, Najafgarh New Delhi -110043

7 Vedprakash Sharma Aged 22 years Group "B"

S/o B L Sharma

R/o WZ 1598/1

Bhoop Singh Colony Nagal Raya Delhi-110046

8 Sourabh Sangwan Aged 22 Years Group "B"

S/o Rakesh Sangwan Category General R/o 97 J Sector- 4 Pushp Vihar South Delhi-110017

9 Shrey Srivastava Aged 23 Years Group "B"

S/o Suresh Kumar Srivastava R/o C 39/2,

New Gobind Pura,

Gali no 10,

East Delhi-110075

10 Hitesh Khatri Aged 23 Years Group "B"

S/o Anil Khatri

R/o 347, Bankner Narela, Delhi-40

11 Shubham Rana Aged 21 Years Group "B"

S/o Kuldeep Rana Category General R/o 340,

Village - Siraspur, North West Delhi-110042

12 Keshav Aged 24 Years Group "B"

S/o Bishamber Mishra R/o 7 CPWD Enquiry Office, Sector-8, RK Puram, New Delhi

13 Shivam Raj Sahani Aged 24 Years Group "B"

S/o Sh Mahesh Kumar R/o Mohari bandh. P.O - Jharia, Dhanbad, Jharkhand

14 Deepika Aged 29 Years Group "B"

D/o Surender Kumar R/o 37B Ratni Niwas Katwariya Sarai

New Delhi-110016

15 Kumar Rajhansh Aged 23 Years Group "B"

S/o Nageshwar Pathak Category EWS

R/o Vill - Malti, PO- Pipra Dewas, PS- Phulwaria,

District-Begusarai, Bihar, 851112

16 Aditya Ishan Batsh Aged 24 Years Group "B"

S/o Ashok Kumar Thakur R/o Room no 14A

Near well no 2

Katwaria Sarai

Delhi 110016

17 Vikas Kumar Aged 26 Years Group "B"

S/o Bheem Singh

R/o VPO Medpura Sultan Tehsil- Nagina

District- Bijnor UP- 246762

18 Ayush Dilawar Aged 26 Years Group "B' S/o Surat Singh

R/o3071-72

LIG HBC

SECTOR-15 Sonipat Haryana-131001

19 Ankit Chahal S/o Pratap Singh Aged 26 Years Group "B"

R/o 404 Sundar Nagar Hisar Haryana

20 Ikshvanku Sharma S/o Rajeev Nayan Sharma Aged 26 Years Group "B"

R/o 3,Rangmahal Apartments Jawahar Nagar

Palwal Haryana.

21 Atul Meena S/oDharmsingh Meena R/o MDCBank

Kandi Katwa Road West Bengal-742401

22 Rajesh Meena S/oVishram Meena Aged 25 Years Group "B"

R/o Padli Post - Balghat Tehsil- Todabhim

District- Karauli Rajasthan-322238

23 Shiv Prakash Yadav S/oRaj Bahadur Yadav Aged 24 Years Group "B"

R/o Village Devariya Post Barpur District Jaunpur UP

24 Kunal Jaurwal S/o Kailash Chand Meena Aged 24 Years Group "B"

R/o 29 Saraswati Nagar K1 Jagatpura Jaipur Rajasthan …… Applicants

(By Advocate : Mr. Sumit Sharma with Mr. Mohit)

VERSUS

DELHI DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY

Through its Chairman Vikas Sadan,

Near INA Market New Delhi-110023 …..Respondent

(By Advocate : Ms. Sriparna Chatterjee with Mr. Arun Birbal and Mr. Sanjay Ghosh)

O.A. No. 2168/2022

1) HARENDER KUMAR,

Son of Shri Braham Parkash, Resident of B-50, Nangal Dewat, Vasant Kunj, New Delhi - 110070. Email: harry04prajapati@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9891208440

2) DEEPAK SAINI,

Son of Shri Suresh kumar Saini, Resident of H.No. 148, Fatak wali gali, Bhorgarh Narela ,North West Delhi, Delhi -110040. Email: deepaksn213@gmail.comMobile No.: 8285135002

3) ALPESH MEENA,

Son of Shri Ram niwas meena, Resident of Village-milaksaray, p/o-soap,teh-nadauti,dist-karauli, Rajasthan,322204. Email: alpeshmeena198@gmail.comMobile No.: 7891725440

4) ABHIJEET SHARMA,

Son of Shri Ashok sharma, Resident of A block 1643, Jahangir puri, New Delhi. Email: abhijeetsharma0891@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 9999415085

5) BHAWANI SINGH,

Son of Shri Narayan Singh, Resident of Ramdev Nagar, Bher Osian, Jodhpur 342309. Email: bhawani2398@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 8955552802

6) CHANDRAMAULI OJHA,

Son of Shri Umesh Prasad Ojha, Resident of H. No. 109/D, Azad Nagar Bichhia Gorakhpur, UP - 273014. Email: cmojha98@gmail.comMobile No.: 6392734912

7) SAURABH KUMAR MISHRA,

Son of Shri Sunil Kumar Mishra, Resident of T 23 A AEN COLONY,

NORTHERN RAILWAY VARANASI,

CANTT 221002.

Email: saurabh.kumar15596@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9453068915

8) AJEET SHARMA,

Son of Shri Chetram Sharma, Resident of Village and Post Bohali, District Siddharthnagar,

Pincode 272201.

Email: 11ajeetsh@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8127260981

9) KESHAV GUPTA,

Son of Shri Krishna Gopal, Resident of Budh bazar road, budh bazar, bisaulidistt- badaun , U. P. 243720. Email: kkeshavgupta1998@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 6386495976

10) RAJEEV GANGWAR,

Son of Shri MADAN LAL, Resident of Vill-Dhimri, Po-Bhauwa bazar, TEH-NAWABGANJ, DIST- BAREILLY PIN-262406. Email: rajeevg981@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 9140700414

11) AKANKSHA JAISWAL,

Daughter of Shri Avodhesh Jaiswal, Resident of Azad Nagar, Nawabganj Barabanki, Uttar Pradesh pin. 225001.

Email: akajaiswaliitbhu2@gmail.com Mobile No.: 7317777653

12) VISHAL SINGH,

Son of Shri Sanjay kumar singh, Resident of Prithvipur Rampur, jaunpur-222203. Email: vishalsingpju@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 9005927301

13) YOGESH SHARMA,

Son of Shri P R Sharma, Resident of 37 Sector 11D, Faridabad Haryana. Email: ys200581@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 9871674342

14) AMIT KUMAR,

Son of Shri Mahesh chand, Resident of C-1008, Sangam vihar, New Delhi. Email: amitkumarsingh736@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9716021515

15) HARIOM MEENA,

Son of Shri Badri prasad meena, Resident of Village monapura, post dadenpur tehsil todabhim, district Karauli,

Rajasthan 321611. Email: harimonapura1994@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9887098507

16) SHUBHAM GUPTA,

Son of Shri Radhe Shyam Gupta, Resident of 605/1, Ward No 54, Near kanpur railway line,CP mission compound,Jhansi , U.P - Pincode:284003.

Email: gupta.shubham.sg66@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 8303983377

17) NITIN,

Son of Shri Bharat Bhushan Sah, Resident of B101 Heeralal, Residency Marshal Bazar Danapur, Patna Bihar 801503.

Email: mail2nsah@gmail.com Mobile No.: 7368088421

18) DHANKESH MEENA,

Son of Shri Chhagan lal meena, Resident of Behind stadium, vivek vihar colony gali no 5, plot no 10 karauli,

Rajasthan.

Email: meena.dhankesh1234@gmail.com Mobile No.: 6378655652

19) ADITYA VISHWAKARMA,

Son of Shri R L Vishwakarma, Resident of Qtr No 1B/18, Staff colony Monday market, Banki mongra,Korba, Chhattisgarh- Pin-495447 Email: av27255official@gmail.com Mobile No.: 7587032253

20) MOHIT SINGH,

Son of Shri Rajesh Singh, Resident of H. No A75,

Kalyanpur Kanpur khurd. Email: mohitsingh99cool@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8009060147

21) HARSHA,

Daughter of Shri Suresh kumar, Resident of SECTOR -A, POCKET B and C,

VASANT KUNJ, NEW DELHI.

Email: harsha.kashyap19@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8595532347

22) ANKIT KUMAR,

Son of Shri Pankaj kumar, Resident of Vill- Ramnubigha, po+ps- Mehus,Dist- sheikhpura,Bihar - 811102. Email: ankit.35049@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 7351797624

23) JAG DEV MEENA,

Son of Shri Rajesh Kumar Meena, Resident of Moh buchahera, ward no 18 kotputli,

Jaipur.

Email: jagdevmeena717@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9351373664

24) PRABHAT RANJAN SINGH,

Son of Shri Harendra Singh, Resident of Vill+post-Khewsar, Dist-Ballia(U.P.)

Email: prabhatranjansingh385@gmail.com Mobile No.: 7905285415

25) HUKAM CHAND MEENA,

Son of Shri Madan Lal Meena, Resident of V/p. Matasula ,tehsil todabhim, dist. Karauli,Raj.

Email: hukamcricinfo@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8058215646

26) KAMAL KUMAR GUPT,

Son of Shri Rajendra Prasad Gupta, Resident of Gram-Gaura Goojar, Post-Brahimpur Kusma Tanda, District-Ambedkar Nagar,Pin Code-224190. Email: guptakamal722@gmail.com Mobile No.: 7860501394

27) DILEEP KUMAR,

Son of Shri Shrinath Ram, Resident of Village Bahadurpur, Post Zamania,

District Ghazipur Pin Code 232329. Email: unforgettabledileep@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8418816839

28) SUMIT KUMAR,

Son of Shri Chaman Singh, Resident of Vill. And post duhai, disttGhaziabad

Pin code 201206.

Email: sumit204261@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9818468124

29) NARESH KUMAR SAINI,

Son of Shri Richhpal Saini, Resident of Village -Bagora, Tehsil - Udaipur wati, District -Jhunjhunu , Rajasthan. Email: nareshnitjsr0@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 8298890642

30) VANDANA PRAKASH,

Daughter of Shri Shyam Lal Prasad, Resident of 10/3-G, Vijaynagar Colony, Chaturbhujpur,

Pt. DeenDayal Upadhyaya Nagar, U.P. Email: vandanaprakash1997@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9981190531

31) CHANDAN TIWARI,

Son of Shri Digvijay Tiwari, Resident of VIll- Dambtia ,Post- Sidhuwa Bangar, Distt- Kushinagar.

Email: chandantiwari046@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 8601966196

32) VIKAS KUMAR MEENA,

Son of Shri Ram Khiladi Meena, Resident of dokariya ki dhani, village post peelwa kalan, Near dolika tahsil sikrai district Dausa, Rajasthan 303304.

Email: vikasjaipurmgec@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9413408090

33) JAI DEV,

Son of Shri Jawahar Singh, Resident of Vpo-Sondhad the Hodal, district -Palwal ,

Haryana pin code -121106. Email: jaisorout77@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9990434380

34) ALOK KUMAR SAROJ,

Son of Shri Rakesh Kumar Saroj, Resident of village beermaubishundatta, post pike nagar,

district pratapgarh, uttar uttar pradesh. Email: alokkumarsaroj08@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8874353516

35) DIVY PRAKASH SINGH,

Son of Shri Mukesh Kumar Singh, Resident of L- 2/495 Vineet Khand, Gomti Nagar Lucknow,

U.P. Pin Code 226010.

Email: divyprakashsingh20@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8052928949

36) SAKSHAM DIXIT,

Son of Shri Salil Kumar dixit, Resident of 557/16 a, om nagar, alambaghLucknow. Email: sakshamdixit95@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 8853791543

37) UJJWAL SHUKLA,

Son of Shri Jay Shankar Prasad Shukla, Resident of Near PWD, Moh. Nichi bhud, Gola Gokarannath, Lakhimpur Kheri, Uttar Pradesh-

262802.

Email: ujjwalshukla720@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9911977851

38) RAGHVENDRA PRATAP SINGH,

Son of Shri Vijay Pal Singh, Resident of 229 K/1 Jayantipur, Preetam Nagar, Prayagraj, U. P. Email: raghvendrace0067@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8565835073

39) UDAISINGH MEENA,

Son of Shri Jagdish Prasad, Resident of 78 shivgorakshnagar, model town malviyanagar, Jaipur.Email: udaysinghsm1995@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9660450308

40) ABHISHEK SINGH,

Son of Shri Hitesh Kumar, Resident of 174C Railway colony, Kasganj U.P.

Email: abhisheksingh.ksj@gmail.com Mobile No.: 7007902305

41) RISHI RAJ,

Son of Shri Vinod Bhagat, Resident of Laxmi Chowk,

Brahmapura, Muzaffarpur, Bihar -842003. Email: rishicivil1605@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9163606099

42) ANSHUMAN SINGH,

Son of Shri Uma kant singh, Resident of 33a/2/a, saketnagar, jayantipur, Sulemsarai, Allahabad.

Email: anshuman100singh@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9473544278

43) RISHIKESH MEENA,

Son of Shri Gurjar mal meena, Resident of Vpo- pareeta district -karauli, teshil-karauli, State - Rajasthan.

Email: Mrishikesh734@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 8503903405

44) CHANCHAL SINGH,

Son of Shri Sanjay Singh, Resident of L-383 b sec 9 New Vijay Nagar, Ghaziabad. Email: rathoresingh3415@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 8368513929

45) PRINCE BATRA,

Son of Shri Kishan lal batra, Resident of A-6/60 Sector 17, Rohini Delhi 110085.

Email: prince98batra@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9654768323

46) ARJUN PATEL,

Son of Shri Ramasare Patel, Resident of Vill-Aswari Post-Rajatalab, Dist-Varanasi U.P (221311). Email: ap21098@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 8542014150

47) VISHAL YADAV,

Son of Shri Mahender Singh Yadav, Resident of H -54 h block, kunwar singh nagar, Nangloi Delhi 11004.

Email: vansh.yadav788@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 9711390259

48) BALYOGESH MAHAR,

Son of Shri Mahilal Meena, Resident of Ward no. 36 adarshnagar, Gangapur city (Rajasthan).

Email: balyogeshmeena11@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 7827527949

49) JEETENDRA KUMAR MEENA,

Son of Shri Tej ram meena, Resident of 78 shiv goraksha, al nagar, model town, Jaipur.

Email: jeetendrameena0999@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9887594093

50) ANKUSH PANDEY,

Son of Shri Nand Bahadur Pandey, Resident of B 140 Sangam Vihar, Near B Block Gurudwara. Email: akpandey0718@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8076116987

51) SHUBHAM MEENA,

Son of Shri Bhanwar singh meena, Resident of Vpo palanpur, tehsil-hindaun city, district - karauli. Email: meenashubam97@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8058353031

52) JATIN CHAUDHARY,

Son of Shri Chandrapal singh, Resident of Vpo peepli kala, district amroha U.P.

Email: jatinchaudhary19@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9389461820

53) KAUSHAL KUMAR,

Son of Shri Hariman Meena, Resident of Gram post - Khandeep, Tehseel - Wazirpur, District - Sawai Madhopur, Rajasthan, pin code - 322205.Email: kaushallakwad@gmail.com Mobile No.: 7318082404

54) SANJAY KUMAR MEENA,

Son of Shri Jagmohan Meena, Resident of Karauli,Rajasthan.Email:

sanjaykumarmeena5@gmail.com Mobile No.: 6375092323

55) OMPRAKASH,

Son of Shri Teeku ram, Resident of B,106 shankarnagar, Jodhpur.Email:

prakasom5184@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 8890705249

56) RAVIKANT,

Son of Shri Vedpal, Resident of Amardeep colony, Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh, Pin-247001. Email: ravi2682kant@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 9568933791

57) AKASH,

Son of Shri Bhagwat Prasad, Resident of Vpo bamchari, Tehsil Hodal. Email: akashbhardwaj063@gmail.com Mobile No.: 7988630955

58) SURAJ KUMAR,

Son of Shri Jhamman Lal, Resident of VillEksari Po Maninda,

District SheikhpuraPincode 811105. Email: mrsurajgeu@gmail.com Mobile No.: 7017205744

59) VIKAS MEENA,

Son of Shri Ramdayalmeena, Resident of Radha Govind Nagar, Dausa -303303. Email: vikasmeena3534@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 9782693534

60) VIJAY RAJBHAR,

Son of Shri Kailash Rajbhar, Resident of Vill-parsupur,post-alawalpurafga, dist-Ghazipur UP. 233222.

Email: vijayrajbhar9217@gmail.com Mobile No.: 7905748652

61) DEEPA KANCHAN,

Daughter of Shri Om Prakash Singh, Resident of RammakheraTripurarirpur, Purwa Unnao

209825.

Email: 800deepa076@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8707627930

62) APOORV ANAND AGNIHOTRI,

Son of Shri Manoj Kumar Agnihotri, Resident of C-15/406, Sahara City Homes, Near IIM, Lucknow.

Email: apoorv.agnihotri98@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9918157581

63) AKASH VERMA,

Son of Shri Babu Ram Verma, Resident of Village -Amarakoil, Post- Manitapur District Sant kabirnagar, Utter pradesh 272148.

Email: akashverma16061997@gmail.com Mobile No.: 7570863954

64) SANTOSH KUMAR,

Son of Shri Bhola bhar, Resident of E/152 Miners Colony, Jamuna Colliery Dist Anuppur, (M. P) Pin Code 484444. Email: santoshku2012@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8130898238

65) RAMRAJ MEENA,

Son of Shri Santosh Kumar Meena, Resident of V/P-KaimaTeh.-Nadoti, District -Karouli,

State- Rajasthan, Pin Code -322215. Email: bantimeena27312@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9414366814

66) RINKESH KUMAR MEENA,

Son of Shri Kedarlalmeena, Resident of Vpo-Khohra, Tehsil - Todabhim District - karauli,

Rajasthan - 321611.

Email: rinkeshkumarnareda.97@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9785175565

67) ARBIND KUMAR SINGH,

Son of Shri Gajraj singh, Resident of S/4 gyankhand1, Ghaziabad Inderpuram UP 201010. Email: karbind24@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8700794534

68) CHITRA PRASHAR,

Daughter of Shri Sunil Kumar Pandey, Resident of Khajuriya, Via Areraj East Champaran, Bihar 845411.

Email: chitraparashar99@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 9005358313

69) LOKESH MEENA,

Son of Shri Ramesh meena,

Resident of V/Post - Matasulatehsil, Todabhim Distt - Karauli,

Rajasthan - 321611.

Email: lokesh95meena@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 9694948587

70) DHEERAJ MEENA,

Son of Shri Omprakash meena, Resident of B-20 TapowanviharJagatpura, Jaipur 302017. Email: dheerajchamp07@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 8769667031

71) SUBHAM KUMAR SINGH,

Son of Shri Shiv Jee singh, Resident of Village/PO - Dudhalia, District - Ballia, Uttar Pradesh - 277403.

Email: subhamsingh1397@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 8650259029

72) HIMANSHU KUSHWAHA,

Son of Shri Ram Narayan Kushwaha, Resident of ARG 1675 New ShivaliRoad, Near Gardenia Public School,

BarasirohiKalyanpur Kanpur.

Email: nitkkrhimanshukushwaha@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9455586723

73) ABHISHEK,

Son of Shri Chandrasen Singh, Resident of Gaurapar, post-dihwa, dist- sant Kabir nagar. Email: abhishekjohn.95@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 7071894450

74) RAJENDRA MEENA,

Son of Shri Karan Singh Meena, Resident of Shankarpur Post Kondar, TehKaraul,DistKaraul,

Pin Code -322241.

Email: rajendrakumarmeena400@gmail.com Mobile No.: 7891196897

75) AMAN VERMA,

Son of Shri Arun Kumar Verma, Resident of J 72 Mig World Bank, Barra Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh.

Email: amanverma2801@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 9450288188

76) NIKHIL,

Son of Shri Mukesh Kumar, Resident of 2323/11 jawaharcolony, near air force road Faridabad, Haryana 121001.

Email: nicktomar55@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8800319914

77) NIMISH UPADHYAY,

Son of Shri Dinesh Kumar Sharma, Resident of Ganesh Nagar Bareilly, UP 243001. Email: nupadhyay544@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 9568281693

78) MOHD ATIF KHAN,

Son of Shri Shariful Hasan Khan, Resident of 192, New AzadpuramChawani, Ashraf Khan Izzatnagar,

Bareilly UP 243122.

Email: Khanas1713@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 9140453684

79) NITISH JOSHI,

Son of Shri Raghubardatt Joshi, Resident of C-1/65 Dayalpur, Delhi 110094. Email: nitishjoshi1210@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8287424928

…Applicants

(By Advocate : Ms. Fareha Ahmad Khan with Ms. Shagun Chopra and Ms. Kaveeta Wadia)

Vs.

Delhi Development Authority Through its Chairman Vikas Sadan, Near INA Market New Delhi-110023

Email : ddachamberhc@yahoo.com Phone no : 011-23389451 …Respondent

(By Advocate : Ms. Sriparna Chatterjee with Mr. Arun Birbal and Mr. Sanjay Ghosh)

O.A. No. 1995/2022

1. Chandan Yadav Father Name-Ram Singar Yadav Address- 631/60 Adarsh Nagar kamta chinhut Lucknow 227105 Contact No-9654351335 chandanyadav5676@gmail.com

2. Gaurav singh Son of Shri Narottam singh Resident of 64 Tilakpuram Baksar Mawana Road Meerut Uttar Pradesh 250001

Email- gaurav01aug1997@gmail.com

Mob no. - 7983187551

3. Bhuvnesh kumar, Son of Shri Ashok Kumar Resident of A-147 Subhash Nagar, Kamla Nagar, Agra, UP, 282005 Email: bhuvneshkumar605@gmail.com Mobil1e no: 7060050058

4. Himanshu Singh Son of Shri Harendra Pratap Singh Resident of G-2 PLOT NO 28 SECTOR-1 VAISHALI,

GHAZIABAD 201010

Email : himanshu95827724@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9953181373

5. Abhishek pathak Son of :-virendra kumar pathak Resident of :- plot no 18 ganesh nagar near keshari khera crossing , Krishna nagar lucknow

Email:- nitin01pathak@gmail.com

Mobile no:- 7905431821

6. Vijay Saini Son of Mr. Amar Chand Saini Resident of 69, Shekhawat Marg, Krishna Nagar, Sirsi Road, Vaishali Nagar, Jaipur, Rajasthan, 302021

Email : vijaysaini4060@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9602984060

7. Anurag Kushwaha Son of Shri Babu Lal Maurya Resident- 104D/129 Premnagar, Himmatganj, Prayagraj-211016 Email- anurag20695@gmail.com Mob. No.- 8004117379

8. Abhishek Singh Son of Shri Ajay kumar Singh Resident of kadam rasool, husenabad, jaumpur (U.P.) 222002 Email : pass.abhi16@gmail.com Mobile no. 7042500367

9. Mayank Arya Son of Shri Raj Kumar Prem Nagar Near I.T.I Delhi Road

Saharanpur-247001 Email- mayankarya12@gmail.com Phone no- 8743815260

10. Vivek Kumar son of Tej Pratap Adress- Y2, B91, trivenipuram,

jhunsi, Prayagraj, Uttar Pradesh-211019 Emails- vivek.kumar7003@gmail.com Mobile-8081993521

11. Kaushal, Son of Shri Bhagwan Singh Resident of *M-14, shakurpur colony, near britannia chowk,

Delhi 110034

Email : kaushalbaghel95 @gmail.com Mobile No.: 9953244218

12. Sheelendra Kumar, Son of Shri Balveer Singh Resident of flat no- 602 Jal vayu height, Greater Noida , UP- 201308 Email: skpathra@outlook.com

Mobile No:- 8851347048

13. Abhishek Singh Son of Shri Alok Kumar Singh Resident of Flat no.-30,Type-5, Delhi Technological University, Bawana Road, Delhi -110042 abs20.dtu@gmail.com

8586899064

14. Jeet Chawda Father"s Name:- Shri Devendra Chawda Address: 02 Jawahar Marg, Shamgarh, Dist- Mandsaur (M.P.) PIN - 458883 Email- chawdajeet@gmail.com Mobile no. - 9165374718

15. Anurag Shaharwal Father name : Mr. Braham Singh Address: 424, Khanna nagar, Loni, Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh, 201102 Email: anurag.shaharwal@gmail.com Mobile no. : 9891516530

16. Ayush Kumar Singh Son of Arun Kumar Singh Resident of lal daanth road, bithoria no. 1, Haldwani (Uttarakhand)

Email-ayush.059462@gmail.com

Phone No-7983685255, 9634272372

17. Himanshu Jain Son of Shri Praveen Kumar Jain Resident of E-15/7, Krishna Nagar, Delhi -110051

jainhimanshu285@gmail.com

8076144483

18. Anuruddh Yadav S/o Suresh Chandra Yadav R/o Near Railway Park Malgodam Road Shanti Nagar, Etah (U.P.)-207001

Email : yadav92anuruddh@gmail.com

Mob No. 8010042193

19. Manish Yadav Father name: Santosh Kumar Permanent address: Vill Chaura sarai kirat Post Bhadri Teh Kunda Dist

Pratapgarh Uttar Pradesh pin 230201 Correspondence address: 129/1 Om Gayatri Nagar Post Teliarganj, PRAYAGRAJ Uttarpradesh pin 211004 Email: mohit.yadav1297@gmail.com

Mobile no. 9644780045

20. Manish Son of Ram Chauthi N-22 B/74 Kaushalpuri Azadpur Delhi -110033 manishgec502@gmail.com

8586939546

21. Amanraj singh parmar Son of shri Udayapal singh parmar

Address :

Vill - Naur, PO - kilkileshwar distt. - Tehri garhwal Uttarakhand 249161

Email: amanraj.parmar@gmail.commob.: 9557028628

22. Deepak Kumar Son of Shri devraj singh Resident of 75 civil. Line jhansi :-284001(U.P) Email:- d7983516138d@gmail.com

Mobile no ;- 7983516138

23. Vishal Kumar Son of Uma Chandra Prasad Resident of Qr no- GM 4/B GM Colony, BTPS, Bokaro Thermal

829107

Email : kumarv0309@gmail.com Mobile no : 9508730547

24. Shubham Sharma Son of Mohan Lal Resident of Qtr Number T-1, MES complex,triveni vihar pathankot,punjab

145001

Email : shubhamcivilengg7@gmail.com Mobile No.: 7707891236

25. Dinesh Chand Meena Son of shri parshuram meena Resident of vpo-jakhoda , Teh-sapotra , dist - karauli , Pin-322218 , rajasthan Email- dineshmeena536@gmail.com Mobile No: 8385819265

26. Ravindra Singh Son of shri Bhagirath Bharti Resident of - Nai abadi, Nagla Bhawani Singh, Agra, Uttar Pradesh 282001

Email - ravigodhand@gmail.com Mobile - 8527876499

27. Hritik Kumar Singh Son of Bipin kumar Singh resident of house number 385 Taigore Nagar Ballia district uttar pradesh 277001

Email id hritiksng3@gmail.com Phone number 9319366850

28. Himanshu Dev, Son of "Soran Singh"

Resident of "Vill-Bhimpur Doraha, Tehsil-Dibai, District-Bulandshahr, UP,PIN-203393"

Email : "hrajpoot9525@gmail.com"

Mobile No.:7017021940

29. Jiyalal Raiswal, Son of Shri Ganga Bishan Raiswal, Resident of VPO -JOPADA , Tehsil & Distt-Dausa , Rajasthan Pin-303501,

Email :-jiya.raiswal@gmail.com Mob no.-8386092381

30. Nikhil Chauhan S/o Suresh pal chauhan, Resident of: 3b-89, shakumbhari vihar, avas vikas, Saharanpur,delhi road, mavikalan,247001

Email: nikhilchauhan9755@gmail.com Ph:8587096056

31. Anurag, Son of Shri Sahab lal Resident of Makhauli Ghatampur,

Kanpur Nagar, 209206 Email : anuragsachan1611 @gmail.com

Mobile No.: 7523829603

32. Name: Musheer Ahmed Father Name: Ashfaq Ahmed Residence: 10/98 kolihai Shahganj Agra, UP Email: musheer3132khan@gmail.com Mobile No. 7065173132

33. Shivendra Singh S/o - Ganpati singh Resident of - Little Champs Playway School Near Etah Chauraha,

Shikohabad (283135)

s_singh@ce.iitr.ac.in

8755138574

34. Rajat lohiya Son of chandan singh Resident of 35/114 Nagla Bhawani Singh Bundu Katra Agra Up 282001

Email- lohiyarajat3@gmail.com

Mob.- 8899424233

35. Abhishek Singh Bhadauria Son of Umendra Singh Bhadauria Resident of Village - Lachhwai,Post-Heonra , Distt- Etawah, Uttar Pradesh,206130 krishna6247@gmail.com

7078997999

36. Sachin Kumar Son of Jaivir Singh Resident of Flat Number 35, Kamakshi Apartment, PLOT number 28, Sector 06, Dwarka, New Delhi 110075 Email id- schnkumar28@gmail.com Mobile number -8860113

37. Ravi Pratap Kashyap, Son of Shri Ramesh Chandra Kashyap

Resident of Village Chauki Mahmad Pur, Post Kanjhana,

Farrukhabad Uttar Pradesh, 209602 Email: ravikash1994.rk@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9540204752

38. Sumedh Raman Son Of Shri.Chandrabali Raman Resident of : gali no. 4 Near Ashish Market, Parichha Station Road,

Parichha Jhansi 284305

Email :sumedhraman1@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 8447523102

39. Shivam Srivastava Son of Shri Suresh Chandra Srivastava Resident of 551 Jha/147,

Harihar Prasad Nagar,

Ram Nagar

Bhilawan, Alambagh, Lucknow-226005 Email: s.srivastavashivam@gmail.com Mob:8563019552

40. Alok Singh Tomar Son of Jitendra Singh Tomar Resident of Bard 13 Bhind bypass near karni restaurant porsa district Morena pin code 476115 Madhya Pradesh

Email tomaralok0@gmail.com Mob no. 7828929848

41. Tarun Shukla S/o Om Prakash Shukla Resident of - Vill- Bhauwar, Post - Dubgawan, Teh- Mangawan, Rewa (m.p.) 486111

Email id - tarunshukla1207@gmail.com Mob no.- 7477247373

42. Dhirendra Kumar yadav,

Son of Shri Kameshwar yadav, Resident of Sahraspali Ballia, Distric Ballia, Tehsil Ballia, Uttar pradesh. Pin: 277001 Email: dhirendra3031@gmail.com Mobile no: 9919230331

43. Avinash Sen S/0 Anil Kumar Resident of 162 Jaswant Nagar Maliyana Meerut Uttar Pradesh 250002 Email avinashsen100@gmail.com Phone number 8791634502,8630470908

44. Girraj mohta Son of Suresh Mohta Resident of B-95,mukharji nagar, vidisha (M.P.) 464001

Email- girrajmohta14aug@gmail.com Number- 8818987590

45. Saurabh Kumar Mishra Son of Ambika Prasad Mishra Resident of ward no. 3,rewa road, Ramnagar, Satna,Madhya Pradesh 485881

Email-saurabhmshra199710@gmail.com Mob No. 8602305506

46. Brijendra Singh Meena, Son of Shri Ram Singh Meena Resident of Flat No.C-12 Officers Quarters Lic Colony Ranade marg Alwar Gate Ajmer-305001 (Rajasthan) Email : brijendra1497@gmail.com Mobile No.:8058262985

47. Arjun Gupta S/o Bhagwan Das Gupta resident of Neorhiya Bajar Jaunpur U.P.

222128

Email-arjung9001@gmail.com

7905433327

48. Sanket Paul, son of Subrata Kumar Paul, Resident of 190 Vidyasagar Pally, Siliguri, District: Darjeeling, PO: Siliguri Bazar, Pin: 734005. Email: sanketpaul1907@gmail.com Mobile no.: 8967842854

49. Himanshu Verma Son of Chandrapal Singh Resident of Ram Krishna Nagar, gali no 3, Jalesar Road, Firozabad, Uttar Pradesh. (283203) Email :- Himanshu.vermadec24@gmail.com Mobile no :- 9528All071

50. Manoj Kumar Meena Son Of Ramkishore Meena Resident Of Rzb-15 , GALI NO.-2 , DABRI EXTN. New Delhi -110045

Email:-manojboss94@gmail.com

PH NO.:- 8750011194

51. Neeraj Kumar Verma Son of dalvir singh Resident of 415 sector 12/c avas vikas colony, agra, up

282002

Email: neerajv085@gmail.com Contact no. : 7017987314

52. Jai Krishna, Son of Shri Hazari lal Resident of village Nagla Deviya Post Sonkh Distt Mathura Pin: 281123 Email : jaikrishna211195@gmail.com Mobile No:.7505357407

53. Himanshu Dev,

Son of "Soran Singh"

*Resident of "Vill-Bhimpur Doraha, Tehsil-Dibai, District-Bulandshahr, UP, Pin-203393"

Email : "hrajpoot9525@gmail.com"

Mobile No.:7017021940

54. Diwakar Singh Durga dutt yadav Pahadpur,Jagatpur allahabad

221505

singhdiwakar566@gmail.com

8077286836

55. Anupum Kumar Son of: Shri Ajab Singh Resident of: 59 Tanishka Rajshree Estate Dayalbagh Agra 282005 Email: imkumaranup@gmail.com Phone: 9068567381

56. Prince Upadhyay Son of Rishi dev Upadhyay Vill and post baddopur district azamgarh 276001 Uttar Pradesh,

email princeupadhyay2011@gmail.com Mob no- 9455809721

57. Name: Balram Meena Father's Name : Girraj Prasad Meena Address: Village Post - Sop, Tehsil - Nadoti, District - Karauli, Rajasthan - 322204 Email: yesmeena2012@gmail.com

Mob No.: 9953368612

58. Name - Praduman Kumar Singh Father's Name - Udaya Raj Singh Address - Village and Post Fateh Pur Gayand, Shahabad Hardoi Uttar Pradesh 241124 Email - singhpradumankumar@yahoo.in Mobile no. - 8811940522

59. Name:Sulochana Meena Father name: Surja Ram Meena Address: 640 Type-4 Near NDMC Market Laxmi Bai Nagar INA 110023 Contact No.: 9958245481

sulochanameenarekha@gmail.com

60. Kartik Rana Son of Sh. Sanjeev Rana Resident of 128 Bhagya Laxmi Apartment Sector 9 Rohini Delhi 110085 Email : karthikkranna06@gmail.com Mobile no. 9315773180

61. Yadav Vivek Brijkishor S/O Shri Brijkishor Yadav Q No. 6B Railway Colony Opposite Hapa Railway Station Hapa District Jamnagar Gujarat

mail id : vivekyadav0408@gmail.com Mobile No : 9427236307

62. Vikas Nain Son of Sh. Joginder Nain Resident of V.P.O. - Sacha Khera, Tehsil - Narwana, Distt- Jind, Haryana -126152

Email- vknain1991@gmail.com

Contact-9896393941

63. Niteesh Kumar Son of Ram Bachan Resident of Vill- Jagdishpur, Post - Alipur Sarawan, District - Sultanpur,U.P (Pin code 228171) niteesh.sul01@gmail.com

7068621575

64. Bharat Agarwal Sushil Kumar Agarwal

H.NO.-739 Sector-7 Awas Vikas Colony Bodla Agra,282007

bharatagarwal377@gmail.com

7906909955

65. Jitendra Kumar Son of Shri Chandrabhan Resident of Charan Singh Nagar, Nangli Saledi Singh, Khetri, Jhunjhunu, Rajasthan,333026 Email:jit.c.kumar54@gmail.com Mob no.-9555932120

66. Tanu kumar Son of Shri Birendra Singh Resident of House No-283 Pocket B-3 Sector - 6 Rohini North west Delhi-110085 Email: tanukumar457@gmail.com Mobile No: 7838448684

67. Kunjan Singh Mahendra Singh 46,Vill-Narau,Post-Chhatari, Teh-Shikarpur,##,

UTTAR PRADESH ,203397

kunjansingh452@gmail.com

8958060848

68. Rajneesh Kumar Son of Nandkishor Resident of 3-4-15/20/15/16 Dew Drops Colony, Bolarum, Turkapally Secunderabad, Telangana 500010 e-mail: kumrajneesh105@gmail.com Mobile: 7981127915

69. Vishvendra meena Shiv singh meena V/P - Hateejar, Tehsil- weir, District - Bharatpur State - Rajastha, Pin-321028

vishvendra9800@gmail.com

9079815053

70. Pravesh Yadav Son of Omkar Nath Yadav Resident of Village- Palya Ratna Post- Ratna Ambedkar Nagar

Uttar Pradesh - 224125

Email: pra15@outlook.com

Mobile No.: 9580750120

71. Yogesh Kumar Verma Son of Sardar mal Verma Resident of 100, satya nagar, Vrindavan Colony, Jaipur (Rajasthan) Pin- 302012

Email - yogesh.kverma.civ11@itbhu.ac.in Mobile- 8896024059

72. Pramod Kumar Meena, Son of Shri Lakhan Lal Meena Resident of Khedi Ghatam, Jhareda, Hindaun city, Karauli, Rajasthan,322230

Email: pramodkumar130795@gmail.com

Mobile No:9166871106

73. Sandeep Kumar Yadav S/o Ram Vilas Yadav Add. Govindpur, Po. Dubhinha ,Dist. Ghazipur U.P. 233225 sandipyadav7379@gmail.com

7379884454

74. Mayank prajapati Son of Banwari lal prajapati Resident of 49-A santoshi nagar Kota(Rajasthan)

324009

Email- mayankprajapati273@gmail.com Phone number- 9799538125

75. Sharad Kumar Son Of Lakshman Singh Resident of Vill Nandpur Post Rampur Maniharan Dist Saharanpur, UP Pin - 247451

Email - sharadkumar856107@gmail.com Mob No - 97610All27

76. Name: Niteesh Patel Son of Asha ram Verma Residence of village shivalipur post Rampur MaNGURADILA district Ambedkar Nagar Pincode:224227

Email id: niteeshpatel007@gmail.com Mobile number: 8318800178

77. Lokendra Yadav Father's name : RATAN PRAKASH YADAV DOB : 10/09/1993

Mob no : 7550426800

mail id : lokendraabsh@gmail.com Raja ka Tal, Alinagar Kenjra, Firozabad

Uttar Pradesh 283203

78. Avanish Kumar Pandey Son of Vidhyadhar Pandey Resident of House No. 3, Ponappa Road, New Cantt,Prayagraj,211001 techavanish@gmail.com

8127582568

79. Pragya Sheel Son of JAGLAL Address 78, S/O jaglal vill- Utrejpur, post Mohammdabad Ghona,

Mau,Uttar Pradesh, 276403

Email ce1006800024@gmail.com

Mobile 8004235586

80. Name Vijay maurya Father name -surendra maurya Resident of -ramgarh urf Rajahi, gorakhpur uttar pradesh 273002 Email vijaymauryacivil@gmail.com Mob no-8009712601

81. Name krishna dev yadav Dob 04/03/1993

Father Ramsamujh yadav Add - Unchanikala post kailawar dist Jaunpur Up Pin 222105

Mobile no. 9936892535

Email kdyadav0403@gmail.com

82. Rahul Kumar S/O: Sanjay Kumar Gupta Resident- Singhiya Sagar,Pipra Banjaria Motihari

East Champaran Bihar -845401 ward NO-10 Email: rk2567992@gmail.com

Mobile No:9504926668

83. Yogesh Kumar Father name - Virender Singh Resident address - village and post raispur Ghaziabad U.P.

Email- yk96178@gmail.com

Mobile no.- 7042432833

84. Hitesh Kumar Meena S/o- Kalyan Sahai Meena Resident of- A-30, Devkunj, street No-10, Rajnagar-2, palam colony, new delhi-110077

Mob-8890909979

Email- hiteshk6958@gmail.com

85. Gaurav singh Son of shri Narottam singh Resident of 64 tilakpuram baksar mawana road meerut

Uttar Pradesh 250001

Email- gauravsingh16nov1995@gmail.com Mob no. - 7983187551

86. Gaurav Singh Son of Shri Narottam Singh Resident of 64 Tilakpuram Baksar Mawana Road Meerut Uttar Pradesh

250001

Email- gauravsingh16nov1995@gmail.com Mob no. - 7983187551

87. Vitesh Chauhan Father's name - Mahendra Singh Chauhan Mail id - vitesh.chauhan1993@gmail.com Address - 65 D ballupur chowk new colony, GM's road dehradun, uttarakhand,248001 Phn no - 9758885555

88. Sangram Singh Gyan Singh

H.No 533/31 Mahaveer Ji Ka Purwa Kapoorthala Crossing Aliganj Lucknow.(226006)

sangrams91@gmail.com

8896040242

89. Teeka Ram Meena S/O Ram Singh Meena Vill Khedi Po Khedi Teh Todabhim

Dist Karauli

EMAIL-teekarammeena9430@gmail.com

8947003462

90. Arun Kumar Kushwaha C/o Shiv shankar Kushwaha 116/390 Adarsh Nagar, Rawatpur, Kanpur Nagar arunkushwaha2020@gmail.com

+917897939668

91. Sunil Kumar Father- Rame ADD- H.NO-854 Doula Nanu Mod Distt Baghpat 250601

MOB.7037310064, 7351628055

Email- kanuj4293@gmail.com

92. Namo Narayan Meena, Son Of Hari Man Meena. Resident of v-khedeeshish, post-bargama, tehsil-hindaun city, district-karauli, 322230 Email:meenanamo00@gmail.com

Mobile no.:9983222856

93. Ankit Yadav Ram Singh Yadav Address- lig 7b shastripuram rajendra nagar gorakhpur gorakhnath

Email- ankityadav03333@gmail.com Phone no- 7985010930

94. Name- Vipin Kumar Anand Father's Name- Shivcharan Mother's Name- Urmila Devi Address-

Village- Amdand Post- Narayanpur, District- Sant Kabir Nagar, (U.P.) 272270 Email Id- vipinanand5676849@gmail.com Mobile No- 7618053597

95. Somdutt Pathak Son of Satya Prakash Pathak Resident of 350 Dinesh Nagar Etah,

Etah(Uttar Pradesh) Pin Code: 207001 Email: somduttpathak.etah@gmail.com Mobile No.- 6397221668

96. Saurabh Kumar Singh Father's name - Tarun Kumar Singh Address - Village - barewan, post - bharehata , chunar district - mirzapur 231304

Email - saurabhsingh8018@gmail.com

Phone no. - 8920151563

97. Pankaj Kant Kadwasara Son of Raj Kumar Kadwasara Re sident of - Quarter No. Type II/3, CPWD GPRA Colony, Sagar Road, Bikaner ( Rajasthan) - 334001 Email- pankajkant1995@gmail.com Mobile No.- 9785198021

98. Shubham Verma Son of Mr. Shyam Manohar Verma Resident of D-1/82 Sector F Jankipuram Lucknow

Uttar Pradesh 226021

Mobile : 7905493532

Email : shubhamsmverma@gmail.com

99. Neeraj Sehrawat S/O Ramprasad Sehrawat 8/241 Mehram Nagar, New Delhi Cantt-110010

9999239177

neeraj786sehrawat@gmail.com

100. Deepak Meena Son of Beerbal Meena Address: A 112,113 Vijay Nagar, mohan garden, Uttam Nagar, New Delhi 110059

District -West Delhi

Email: dk033220@gmail.com Mob No : 8802948021

101. Ravi Dhull Son of Rajinder Singh Resident of 177-A, Village Ramana Ramani, District Kaithal, Haryana 136043 Email- ravi.dhull011@gmail.com Mobile- 8194935536

102. Alok Mohan Yadav S/o Rajdev Yadav Village - Siyarampur Post - Rampur Gopalpur District- Gorakhpur

UP 273007

Email - alokmohan20@gmail.con Mob No - 7838557353

103. Shubham jain Son of lokesh kumar Jain Resident of flat no. 005 mahaveer nagar, nasiya colony, gangapur city, rajasthan,322201 shubhamjain6393@gmail.com

Mobile: 9530221335

104. Sunil kumar Son of Rame, Resident of 854 Daula, Daula Baghpat Uttar Pradesh 250601 Email- Kanuj4293@gmail.com M No. - 7037310064

105. Manish kumar Yadav s/o Awadhesh yadav Village ruddi post uskar distt ballia uttar pradesh Pin 221716

MOB 94100 66113

Email manishnith2019@gmail.com

106. Neelesh kumar

S/O Ram Sagar Town area chaman ganj ward number 3 koraon prayagraj ,212306

Mail id neelesh2014ce@gmail.com Mobile no 8352066864

107. Shubham Gopal Son Of Shri Satya Prakash Gopal Resident of

Village Bhatpurwa

Post Basahiya

District AZAMGARH

Pin 223223

Mail id shubhamgopal7@gmail.com Mobile no 8896054911

108. Ashiwani Kumar s/o. Subhash Chandra resident of Vill And Po- Gohand, Tehsil- Sarila, DIST-Hamirpur (Uttar Pradesh),

210430

Email- acewaniii@gmail.com Mob no.- 8218295403

109. Vinay Kumar, Son of Ram Ashish Resident of Village joriyan katui, Post joriyan katui,

Ambedkar Nagar Uttar Pradesh, 224186 Email: vinay95raj@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8766277939

110. Aadesh Kamar Srivastava S/O santosh kumar

Resident of Mallroad Kanpur 208001 Email: aadeshcivil222@gmail.com Mobile: 6393377076

111. Name : Divyanshi Dutt Father's name : Sunil Dutt

Address: Plot No. 1108 Awas Vikas No 3 Kalyanpur Kanpur, U.P. 208017 Email id: divdutt9825@gmail.com Phone no : 9044719162

112. Rahul verma S/o Rakesh verma Resident ... H. No 288 aloo thok hardoi u.p. 241001 Email... rahulvermahardoi5@gmail.com Mobile...9540533869

113. Name-Lokendra kumar meena Father name- prabhu lal meena Address- 7,nandpuri,Malviya nagar,jaipur,302017 Mail- lokendra.9529496470@gmail.com Contact no.- 9529496470

114. Pooja Bai Meena Father Name - Ram Kishor Meena Address - Vill.-Birounda, post Samleti , Teh.- Mahwa, Dist- Dausa 321608 Contact no.- 9461236509

Email Address - 26poojameena@gmail.com

115. Sumit Meena Son Of Kedar Lal Meena Resident of 256 Kusum Vihar Jagatpura Jaipur Rajasthan 302017

Mail id.......sumitmeena1993@gmail.com Mobile no 6376794700

116. Kuldeep meena Father name - Jaldhari meena Resident Adress - VPO - Chandera , Tehsil - sikrai ,Distt - Dausa Rajasthan ,Pin code - 303509 Contact no - 8209515279

Email adress - km8890593963@gmail.com

117.

Name-Ravi Kumar Meena Father-JAI DAYAL MEENA Vill-Peelwa Post Unkroond Teh-Mahwa Dis-Dausa 321613 Contact.No.9376865515 email -Ravimeena8973@gmail.com

118. Ravi Kumar Bujetiya Father name - ghan shyam bujetiya Resident address - 179,gayatri nagar agra road dausa Contact no. 9782786562

Email address - ravibujetiya163@gmail.com

119. Devendra Kumar Meena Son of - KHYALI Prasad meena Address-101 pavan vihar near cbi fatak jagatpura jaipur

302017

Email: jorwaldev12@gmail.com Mobile No:9340013719

120. Ravi Kumar Meena Son of Mr. Roop Singh Meena Address:- Resident of Village - viraganav, post - Dholkhera, th. Mahwa , District - Dausa Pin code - 321613

Email:- ravihppavilion@gmail.com Mobile no:- 7062767628

121. Bhumika Mandawat Fathers name : Prem Chand Meena Resident address : 109,devi nagar nannu marg, new sanganer road sodala jaipur ,Rajasthan Contact No. :9785020141

Email address :bhumimandawat01@gmail.com

122. Avinash Kumar Srivastava Father's Name- Anil Kumar Srivastava Email Id- avinash23april@gmail.com Mobile No. 8808733248

Address : A 91 shivpuri kalyanpur lucknow up

123. Ankit kumar Father name Late sh khushi ram Add-villege nangla rawa post bijwara distt Baghpat uttar pradesh 250345 mail-ankitkumar0514@gmail.com No-9675030895

124. Naresh Chandra Sati Khayali dutt sati Resident: Patli po- amagdi Z distt-Nainital pin-263159 uttarakhand nickksati0012@gmail.com9368008801,7534082109

125. Subhash Chand Mahala Father name - Harful Singh Mahala Address - v/p - dadiya rampura , via -reengus, tehasil - shrimadhopur District-sikar (Rajasthan) Pin code -332404

Email - subhashpce042@gmail.com Phone no - 9509304475

126. Maneesh Kumar, Son of Shri Pramod kumar Resident of Village Nagla Hari Singh, Post Adhiyapur ,

District Etawah UP,

206002

Email : verma213manish @gmail.com Mobile No.: 8868019175

127. Sunny Chaurasia, Son of Sadanand Prasad Chaurasia Resident of sadanand prasad chaurasia, Line paar mirzapur ,

Nawada,Bihar, 805110

Email:- imsunny571@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8340322895

128. Kajod Mal Meena

Son of Shri babu lal meena Resident of *A2a block type-2 Qtr no-74 Bsnl colony janakpuri new delhi-110058 Email : kajod6857@gmail.com* Mobile No-8826362451

129. Arpit Kumar Son of Shri Gajraj Singh Resident of E-343/2 hari nagar part 2 badarpur, jaitpur new delhi:-110044

Email: arpitsingh392@gmail.com

Mobile no.: 8920246710

130. Rohit Kumar Mohan Kumar Dubey rohit8804776052@gmail.com H/100 SD BLOCK SECTOR 45 Noida Uttar Pradesh 201301

9931690939

131. Narendra Kumar Maurya Son of Om Prakash Maurya Residence- Village Devanpur Post kachhauna District Hardoi UP 241126 Email-maunar1996@gmail.com Mob. - 8756503004

132. Jitendra Singh Vijendra Father name- vijendra singh Address - house no 39, Raj bihar colony, near nawada chauraha, post aduki 281006 mathura (u.p) Email- jeet131997@gmail.com Phone no- 7417337827

133. Shivam S/O- Pardeep Kumar R/O- D-5/A,STREET NO.9,WEST JYOTI NAGAR,

NORTH EAST DELHI,DELHI,110094

ks949437@gmail.com

9599373974

134. Ashish Choudhary Son of Prabhakar Narain Choudhary Resident of House.No- J-281/14, Gali.No-6, Vijay Colony, New Usmanpur, Delhi - 110053 Email : ashish776647@gmail.com Mobile No - 7503064964

135. Manendra Singh Meena Contact nb -9414210607 Add- New Indian Public Sen Sec School Shankar Vihar Sawai Gatore Near Malviya Nagar Jaipur 302017 Father name - RAJENDRA SINGH MEENA

manendrasinghmeena@gmail.com

136. Nature Moun Son of Shri Dhramjit Residence:

559 ,Sector 21 Huda, KAITHAL City Haryana136027

Email : naturemoun@gmail.com Mobile number : 7015102778

137. Shan s/o Gulzar Ahmad Address:-Moh Qassaban near masjid Qureshyan Bijnor 246701 Uttar pradesh email:- enggshan7055@gmail.com Phone:- 7055691906

138. Shivang Mathur, Son of Arvind Kumar Mathur Resident of B 740 ,gali no 24, Main Market,Sant Nagar, Burari, 110084

Email : shivangmathur007@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8860756615

139. Kishan Dwivedi

Son of Arbind dwivedi Residents of Vijay Nagar Haweliya jhunsi prayagraj, Uttar pradesh 211019

Email: 017kishandwe@gmail.com

Mob: 9862875353

140. Harish Kumar Father's Name: Brhampal Singh Resident:Type-3,Q.No.1 Nie Campus, NCERT Aurobindo Marg

Hauz Khas South Delhi

DELHI 110016

Email:harishkumar9968@gmail.com Phone NO. 8130203432

141. Ekta Yadav D/O Vinod Kumar Yadav P - 110/5, Kabul Line Delhi Cantt, Delhi 110010 ektay011@gmail.com

8178693203

142. Shivansh Verma S/O Vasudev Verma Village And Post- Pakhrauli , Fatepur , District - Sultanpur, U.P.- PIN- 228001 email. shivanshvermace0088@gmail.com Mob. No. 7906425341

143. Ashutosh chaurasia Father's name: Sanjay chaurasia Resident of : house no.43, om Shanti green, rajghat colony, nandanpura, jhansi, utrar pradesh Mob no. :7905655062

Email ID: asc4225089@gmail. Com

144. Shubham Singh S/O Ram Singh Vill - Tammanpatti , Post-Chunar Dist - Mirzapur Pin-231304

Email - 13shubh13@gmail.com Mob- 9451832381

145. Shubham Kumar Yadav S/O Awadhlal Yadav Address :Village Kaithwal , Post Jagatpur , Tehsil Phulpur ,District Prayagraj Pin code 221505 Email Id shubhamyadav1506@gmail.com Mobile no 7348200526

146. Haris Ahmed Son of Shri Zulfiqar Ahmed Resident of House no 648 street no 26 Jafrabad delhi-110053

Email-Harisahmed566.com

Mobile no- 9953303830

147. Sheetal Niranjan Daughter of shri jitendra singh niranjan Resident of deen dayal nagar khati baba jhansi -284003 Email - sheetalniranjan88@gmail.com

Mobile no. 7985196969

148. Aditya Jakhar, Son of Shri Rajeev Choudhary, Resident of C-3, Krishna Nagar Jodhpur, Rajasthan 342005 Email:- adi.jakhar02@gmail.com Mobile No.:- 9460334508

149. Manoj Kumar Vishwakarma Son Of Ramkishore Vishwakarma Residence Vill parsa dafali post Rampur District Basti 272124

Email manojvishwakarma97@gmail.com Mobile no 8953287060

150. Annu, Daughter of Vijay Pal Singh Resident of 40A/100A, Eshwar Nagar,

Behind Amar Ujala Press, Sikandra, Agra 282007

Email:annuyadav021@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9717539213

151. Sufiyan khan, Son of Ajmal khan, Resident of village -Mahpur, post -karha , Distt-Mau , Uttar Pradesh 276402 Email: sufiyan.khan2593@gmail.com Mobile no.: 8765122593

152. Ambuj Singh Son of Baidya Nath Singh Resident of Village Shitalmau Post Lalganj Ajhara

District Pratapgarh

Uttar Pradesh 230132

Email:ambujsingh232@gmail.com Phone:8510024766

153. Vishwendra Singh, Son of Shri Rajender Singh Resident of - B- 139, Phase-2, GAIL Residential complex, GAIL Vijaipur, Guna, Madhya Pradesh, 473112 Email: vishwendrasingh337@gmail.com

Mobile No. : 9794972629

154. Bhuvnesh kumar, Son of Shri Ashok Kumar Resident of A-147 Subhash Nagar, Kamla Nagar, Agra, UP, 282005 Email: bhuvneshkumar605@gmail.com Mobile no: 7060050058

155. Vivek Kumar Father Name - Manvir Singh Addres - Village - Khardiya Post - mangta tahsil - Dhorimanna District - Barmer

State - Rajasthan

156. Rahul Tomar s/o Rajkumar Tomar Add- Madhuban calony ward no 22 Baraut ( Baghpat )

Uttar Pradesh

Pin code - 250611

Email id - tomar.rahul912@gmail.com

157. Akhilesh Kumar Mishra Father's Name - Vijay Kumar Mishra Resident of House no 5, Village and post panauli, ghorawal , Sonbhadra, 231210

Email - akhilesh.mishra1194@gmail.com Phone no - 9966036901

158. Tushar Kumar Jaiswal Suresh Chandra Jaiswal Ayodhya UP

tushar9639@gmail.com

7217758301

159. Rahul Kumar Son Of Ramesh Chand Meena Resident Of B-66 Pocket B INA Colony New Delhi 110023 EMAIL-meena123rahul@gmail.com Mobile-7891667789

160. Gyandeep gupta Son of -Mata Prasad Gupta Resident of- w-2/62 Damodar nagar Barra bypass, Kanpur Uttar Pradesh

Pincode-208027

Email- gyandeepgupta25@gmail.com

Mob.no-7007902303

161. Bharat Lal Jaiswal Son of Nand Lal Jaiswal Residence - Vill -Harnahi Post-Mahuraon

Dist-Gorakhpur, Uttar Pradesh 273212 Email : bharatlaljai@gmail.com Mobile no:7417106971

162. Dheerendra Pratap Jaiswal Father Name- Dhruv Chandra Jaiswal Resident- Moodhghat Byapss Road Katra District (Basti) Uttar Pradesh 272001

EMAIL ID- dheerucivil21@gmail.com

PHONE NUMBER- 8853356695

163. Shivam Shubhanker Sahu Son of: Late Rajesh Kumar Resident of: Sahu Machinery Store, Shankar Nagar, Muraibagh, Dalmau, Raebareli, U.P., 229207 Email: shivamshubhanker@gmail.com

Mobile No. 9456086434

164. Avinash Kushwaha Father's name - Yashawant kushwaha Resident - Ghazipur (UP) Mail - ayavinash8@gmail.com Mob- 8887547108

165. Monika Gautam Daughter of Om Prakash Gautam

20 NEW LIG W BLOCK KESHAV NAGAR KANPUR

Contact No.- 9140355022

Email address- 029gautammona@gmail.com

166. Tanuj Gupta Son of shri ajay kumar Gupta Resident of H. No. 13, Braham Bazar, Chandausi District :- Sambhal (U.P) 244412 Email:- tanujgupta1501@gmail.com Mobile No:- 9557000767

167. Abhishek Yadav Son of shri prem singh yadav Resident of khekra baghpat Up - 250101

Email : ay09061@gmail.com Mob no- 9759955400

168. Adarsh Sahu S/O Shrawan Kumar Sahu Residence: Vill Pure Chachi Post thulrai, tahseel Dalmau dist : Raebareli, U.P 229125 email: adarsh.sahu6@gmail.com

Mbl no : 8707770971

169. Saurabh Kumar Mishra Son of Ambika Prasad Mishra Resident of ward no 03,near akhada Temple, Ramnagar, Satna,

District-Satna, Madhya Pradesh 485881 Email:- saurabhmshra199710@gmail.com Mobile No:- 8602305506

170. Kapil Sharma s/o vani Vinayak Sharma Address- b-8 irrigation colony shastri nagar A block Ghaziabad Mail id Ks2522227@gmail.com Mobile no 8755503378

171. Saurabh Son of Shri Umakant Yadav Resident of *House NO-653, Village And Post-Indara, District-Mau, State-Uttar Pradesh,Pincode

275102

Email : sorb.ydv@gmail.com Mobile No.:9711788672

172. Shubham Arya Father name - Bansh Bahadur Address - L-374, R. D. A. Colony, indira nagar, raebareli Pincode- 229001

Email - shubhamarya2310@gmail.com *Phone no- 9667016634

173. Vikas Father - Ram jag maurya Address Vill paharpur Post Kalafatpur

Tehsil phoolpur

Distic azamgarh

Pin 276143

Mail Id vikasmaurya664@gmail.com Mobile no 8009383797

174. Pankaj Kumar Gupta Son Of Rajkumar Gupta Resident Of 834/554b Unchawagarhi Rajapur Prayagraj -211001

EMAIL-:pankajjgupta067@gmail.com PHONE NO-:8115238734

175. Bharat Prasad S/o Surendra Prasad Add-H No 134/A, Devi Mandir Wali Gali, Rithala Village, Rohini

New Delhi-110085

Email- bprasad032@gmail.com, +91-9304611714

176. Anil prakash Son of Om prakash Resident of "25/24 Katra Chand khan pajaya old city Bareilly",243005

Email: prakashanil144@gmail.com

Mobile:7906485580

177. Ankit pundir Son of anil pundir Resident of B block lane 2 , Mandakini vihar shastradhara road , Dehradun uttrakhand

248001

Email- ankitpundir003.ap@gmail.com Mobile no- 9027731410

178. Ankit pundir Son of anil pundir Resident of B block lane 2 , Mandakini vihar shastradhara road , Dehradun uttrakhand

248001

Email- ankitpundir003.ap@gmail.com Mobile no- 9027731410

179. Mayank Singh *Son of Ranvijay Singh *Resident of-- Vill-Meuriya Post-Sardaha, Dist-Azamgarh, UP, PIN-276139 Email: smayank306@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 9554732819

180. Sandeep S/o Mahinder singh H.no-54, Bheem bhag, Vijay nagar, ballabgarh, faridabad

9650212050

arravsingh873@gmail.com

181. Sagar kumar Son of sudhir kumar Resident of mahavir sthan bich bazar hisua dist- nawada (Bihar)

Pin 805103

Email - sagarromy.1995@gmail.com Mob no 9995520819

182. Awleena yousuf Daughter of Mohammad yousuf ganie Tangmarg,devdragar,Dewa Dragar, Baramulla, Jammu and Kashmir-193403

Email:awleenans@gmail.com

Mobile no. : 8899622219

183. Ravi Kumar, Son of Late Mahesh Paswan , Resident of near st. Kids school,

jai prakash nagar , sakrugarh , sahebganj, jharkhand - 816109 Ravicena15@gmail.com

8409153206*

184. Gurkirat Aoulakh, Son of Hira Singh Resident of Gol Pahadiya, A B Road, Lashkar, Gird, Gwalior,

Madhya Pradesh 474001

Email : gurkirataoulakh28@gmail.com Mobile No.: 6260903687

185. Pravesh Sonkar Son of Shri Janki Prasad Sonkar Resident of 1242 jankinagar uprahitanpurwa Gonad 271003

Email : praveshsonkar8877@gmail.com Mobile no. : 6394705779

8090718541

186. Dilip Kumar Sena son of Bidyadhar sena Resident of h. No. - 18 E, Bosco colony -B, gopal nagar extn, Najafgarh,

south west delhi, Delhi - 110043 Email : dilipsena8@gmail.com

Mobile no. - 9310477531

187. Satyam Yadav Daughter of Lakhan Singh Residence of RZ C2 House NO- 104 Street NO- 03 Mahavir Enclave New Delhi- 110045 email- satyam10yadav@gmail.com

Mobile No- 7838082405

188. Sagar Son of Parveen kumar Resident of R-218 gali no. 12 a swatantra nagar narela

delhi 110040 Email : sagar.ghiloria@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9911351033

189. Shivam Agrawal, Son of Aditya Kumar Agrawal Resident of M. I. G. II 17, Housing Board Colony, Maihar, distt. Satna (MP) 485771 Email : agrawalshivam1511*@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8871153570

190. Adarsh Singh Son of Dinesh Singh Residential add:Vill saimra Post Semri Distt Banda Email:adarsasingh@gmail.com

Mob:9559992253

191. Aman lal gupta Son of Gagan lal gupta 2,desh ratan road,vidyapati nagar, baridih, jamshedpur, jharkhand, 831017. amanlalgupta06@gmail.com

8002494045

192. Shubham Barnwal s/o Shrikant Barnwal ward no 09, pipra nazir, salempur, dist deoria, pin code 274509

email; sbarnwal243@gmail.com

contact no; 9161287944

193. Akshay Dabas Son of Shri Vijay kumar Resident of h.no. 235 V.P. O. Ranikhera Delhi 110081 Email : mailtomeakshay@gmail.com Mobile No:8375817057

194. Shailza kant sagar

S/o Shri Suraj Mal sagar Resident of B -19 chandan van phase 2 Mathura 281001

Email- shailza.sagar@gmail.com Mob-: 8439771511

195. Sandeep kumar, Son of - Ram Raj Prasad. Add-Vill - SHAHPUR,fatehpur. P.O- DHIBRA,P.S- Parsa bazar,Patna-801505.

7979041825, 8235229419

196. Varish Kumar Son of Shri Vinay kumar Resident of B-1081/112 Gali no2, New indra complex, kheri kalan Near Maharaja aggression eye hospital, Faridabad Haryana 121002

Email : varish.kumar04@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8076197231

197. Puneet Kaushik Son of Shyam Sunder Kaushik Resident of D 63 Rohit Kunj Pitampura Delhi 110034 Email : puneetkaushik00007@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8368014325

9013442025(whatsapp)

198. Rajat Nehra, son of Shri Bijender Singh. Resident of VPO- Bali Qutubpur, tehsil -, ganaur, district - Sonipat, 131101

Email: nehrarajat2814669@gmail.com Mobile No.: 8607030819

199. Vishal Singh Virendra Singh Vill+Post = athilapura tehsil - Rasra district- Ballia 221712

8299676396,9170334627

vs385324@gmail.com

200. Rishabh kumar, Son of Shri Jagdish chand Resident of 3017 bhagwan ganj bahadurgarh road Delhi 110006,

Email: 3017rishabh@gmail.com

Mob no. 8826355926

201. Sandip Sahu Son of Tapan Sahu Resident of - Pal para , Vill. + P. O. - Mallarpur, Dist. - Birbhum,

WEST BENGAL,

731216

Email: sandip35sahu@gmail.com Mobile no - 8116812135

202. Shubham Garg Son of Shri Mohinder Pal Garg Resident of H. no 500 Sector -4 Urban Estate, Kurukshetra 136118 Haryana ,India

Email : gargshubham3434@gmail.com Mobile No: 7015720055

203. Sumit kumar Son of Ashok Kumar VPO Sahoura Tehsil And District Kangra , Himachal Pradesh

sumitkumar604@gmail.com

9871508902

204. Prashant Dabur, son of Baal Singh Resident of Anand Vihar Mohammad Pur Mafi behind Kabir Ashram itc road Saharanpur 247001 email prashantdaburnitk@gmail.com Contact no 7983944367

205. Akash Deep, Son of Shri Sugreeva Ram Resident of 54, Srijan Vihar ,Vipul khand, Gomti Nagar,Lucknow,Uttar Pradesh 226010 Email :adeep4989@gmail.com

Mobile No.: 8127599904

206. Sahdev Rajput S/O Pawan Rajput Resident of sarvodaya colony ring road, bijnor (up) 246701 Email-srjpt007@gmaip.com

Moblie- 8077571260

207. Rishabh kumar, Son of Shri Jagdish chand Resident of 3017 bhagwan ganj bahadurgarh road Delhi 110006,

Email: 3017rishabh@gmail.com

Mob no. 8826355926

208. Praveen Kumar Son of Ram jawahir kanaujia Resident of Ram jawahir kanaujia khatwar sultanpur Uttar pradesh 228119 pk.rjk006@gmail.com

9140075391

209. Kumar Ashmit, Son of Amarjit Nagrath Resident of *407/1Near hitesh apartment Neb Sarai New delhi,

110068

Email :ashmitkumar7@gmail.com *Mobile No.: 7991102296

210. Vinod Kumar Father name:-Brhampal Singh Residents:-Type 3/1 NCERT Campus, Sri Aurobindo Marg, Hauz Khas S. O, South West Delhi, Delhi -110016 E-MAIL:-vinodkumar996810@gmail.com

Ph:-9871506264

211. Byas Nishad, Son of Shri Haridwar Nishad Resident of : Vill. - Achiyapar, Post -Sahjanwa,

Distt. - Gorakhpur,

U.P., 273209

Email: byasnishad1998@gmail.com Mobile No. : 8568886618

212. Saurabh Sharma Son of shri Keshav Dev Resident of 19/180, 7A Adarsh Nagar, pala Road, Aligarh, 202001

Email: ppss99318@gmail.com Mobile Number: 7906943021

213. Name: Pranjul Katiyar Father's name: Narendra Babu Katiyar Address: 430 gunjan vihar Barra 6 kanpur nagar - 208027 Mob no: 9598041808

Email ID: pranjul.ashu06@gmail.com

214. Sourabh Kumar, Son of Late Shri Jasbir Singh Resident of A-63,

Bhim Gali, Kondli,

Delhi,

110096

Email : 100ravgolu @gmail.com

Mobile No.: 7982325583

215. Yatin Sharma Father Name - Jogendra Sharma Resident of - VPO Anwarpur, Pilkhuwa, Hapur, U.P.

245304

Mobile No - 7042902350 E Mail id - yatinsharma150@gmail.com

216. Vishal Kumar Son Of Late Vijay Kumar Resident Of A 204 Dream Jewel Deep Sheetal Engineers pvt Ltd r.k. Puram Danapur Patna Bihar,801503 Email ID- visu18121994@gmail.com

MOBILE NO- 8447288289

217. Manoj kumar vyas Son of Shri Kunwar Pal Singh Resident : Village teeka nagla Hathras , 204101

Email: manojvyas2103@gmail.com Mobile: 8393951471

218. Naincy Srivastava Daughter of Ravi Kumar Resident of HN 3c, Nathpuram, Jangal Mata Din, Shahpur, Gorakhpur, Uttar Pradesh. 273006

Mob. No: 8448475659

Email. : nncsri88@gmail.com

219. Priyam Agrawal Son of Shri Manohar Agrawal Resident of Patel Nagar Ait district jalaun(U.P) 285201 Email. agrawalpriyam1798@gmail.com Mob. 8299360421

220. Vimal Singh Son Of : Kamal Singh Resident OF : H. No.- 70, Shiv Lok Puri, Kanker Khera, Meerut, Uttar Pradesh - 250001

Mob no : 8979990522

Email id : vimalsingh045@gmail.com

221. Kumar Ashmit, Son of Amarjit Nagrath Resident of *407/1Near hitesh apartment Neb Sarai

New delhi, 110068 Email :ashmitkumar7@gmail.com *Mobile No.: 7991102296

222. Dhiraj Singh S/O - Shri Surya Prakash Singh Resident - Vill-Shivpur, Post-Vijaipur, Teh-khaga, Dist-Fatehpur, Uttar Pradesh 212655 Email id - dhirajsingh139@gmail.com Mobno- 7838172425

223. Akshay Kumar Son of shri Laxmi Narayan Resident of 242 c block Shyam nagar Kanpur 208013 Email id : 1996akshaykr@gmail.com Phone number:9455811307

224. Arun khatana Son of Narender khatana Residence of : Vpo Kherla Tehsil Sohna District Gurgaon State Haryana 122102 Email id: arunkhatana03@gmail.com Phn no : 9812221760

225. Mohan Prakash Tyagi S/O Rajkumar Tyagi Resident of Village -Mai , Post - ladukhera , Tehsil- Kheragarh , Distt -Agra (U.P.) , Pin -283124 MailID : mptyagi5995@gmail.com

Mobile no: 7617040453

226. Pradeep Kumar Yadav Father Name Shridhar Singh Yadav Mobile Number 8005451283

GMAIL

PRAYAD3012@GMAIL.COM Permanent Address Vill Khatirpur, Post Khadwadeeh, Tehasil Jakhaniyan, District Ghazipur, PIN 275205

U.P.

227. Rajendra Kumar Meena son of Babu lal meena resident village kundiya post balithal tehsil uniara district tonk Rajasthan (304024).

Email id-rajendrababu108@gmail.com mobile no -8239944404

228. Ashish Singh Son of Shri Nanhe Lal Resident of Vill-Patra Post -Gauramafi Dist-Pratapgarh U.P. 230124 Email id-ashish11278@gmail.com Mobile No-8853998832

229. Sanjay Jaiswal s/o Vijay prakash jaiswal Resident of Karanpur Dhema Jaunpur (U.P.) 222125 Email: jaiswalexpert@gmail.com

Mobile No. 7084229586

230. Aradhana Yadav, daughter of Vidya Pati Yadav, Resident Of Village And Post Bauliya Raja, Tehsil Sadar, District Maharajganj Email : yadavaradhana2097@gmail.com Mobile no. : 9807024861

231. Arti Sharma Rajesh Sharma Near MPDC new Patel Nagar konch jalaun arti2604sharma@gmail.com

7379116064

232. Prabhat Kumar Goel Father's name - Ram Karan Ram Address - Village Raini Post Raini District Mau 275101 Mob number - 9415535548

Email - pkgoel1294@gmail.com

233. Yatender Kumar Son of Sh.Ashok Kumar Rzc-77/2, Nihal Vihar, Nangloi, New Delhi-110041 E-mail:yatender.iwai@gmail.com

Phone : 9746044222

234. Dharmendra Bhardwaj s/o Niranjan Prasad Vpo Lodana Block Jewar G B Nagr U P PI 203141 email id dharmendrabhardwaj2015@gmail.com Mobile Number 8802952127

235. Akash Srivastava, Son of Ashok Kumar Srivastava Resident of Plot No.- 62, Vindhya Wasini Nagar Colony, Mahaveer Mandir Road, Orderly Bazar, Varanasi, UP, Pin- 221002 Email: akashsrivastava727@gmail.com Mobile No.: 6280892787

236. Saurabh Mall Son of N D Mall Resident of (CO Savitri Mall), Satya Marg Shiv Mandir, Bhagini Gali, Mohaddipur Gorakhpur (Uttar Pradesh) Pin code: 273008

Email: mallsaurabh95@gmail.com Mobile No. 8700089908, 8802280271

237. Shivani agrawal Anil Kumar agrawal gmail-shivaniagrawal18400@gmail.com

9630372758

Add: 1111/7E shivaji nagar jhansi 284128

238. Bharat Agarwal Sushil Kumar Agarwal H.NO.-739 Sector-7 Awas Vikas Colony Bodla Agra,282007

bharatagarwal377@gmail.com

7906909955

239. Abhishek yadav, Son of surendra Singh yadav, Resident of c-316 Swarn Jayanti Puram, Ghaziabad(uttar pradesh),

201002

Email-11abhi.yadav@gmail.com Mobile no. - 9944657399

240. Anil Kumar Yadav S/o Deena Nath Yadav Resident of Chakaura Mahrajganj Sant Ravidas Nagar 221314 Email id : anil.kr.yadav97@gmail.com Mobile: 7275560507

241. Pramod Chaurasiya Son of Umesh Chaurasiya Resident of :- 76, Babhani 2, Balaji Mandir, Kasia road Deoria, 274001

Email :- karan2k20hunt@gmail.com Mobile: 8299321654

242. Shweta Gupta Daughter of Mr.Dwarika Prasad Gupta Resident of house no 13,

Gandhi chowk Gola bazar

Nawabganj gonda

Uttar Pradesh 271303

Email: swetagupta591@gmail.com Mobile no. 8750868766

243. Rishabh Singh Son of Brijesh Bahadur Singh Resident of-11/1201, Ramjipuram Bastepur, Raebareli,Uttar Pradesh 229001 Email-rishabh.singh051@gmail.com Mob no.-9450892096

244. Shubham Jaiswar, Son Of Shri Lal Bahadur Jaiswar Resident OF 5/391 Vikas Nagar Lucknow ,Uttar Pradesh,

226022

Email- shubhamjaiswar25@gmail.com Mobile No- 7607712503

245. Pranshu rajput Fathers name-Girish Prakash Address-B-37/1 bhagirathi vihar Delhi-110094 Email-Pranshurj@gmail.com

No-9582433040

246. Prabhat Yadav S/o- Shiv prashad yadav Resident- D161 omicron 1a greater Noida, 201310 Email- prabhaty99@gmail.com

Mobile no- 8700106937, 9718569294

247. Anant Jain Son of Shri Rajiv Jain Resident of B-32 Shyam Park Extension Sahibabad Ghaziabad, U.P. 201005

Email : anantj123@gmail.com

Mobile No. : 9871356454

…Applicants

(By Advocate : Mr. Abhisht Hela)

Vs.

Delhi Development Authority Through its Chairman Vikas Sadan, Near INA Market New Delhi-110023

Email : ddachamberhc@yahoo.com Phone no : 011-23389451 …Respondent

(By Advocate : Ms. Sriparna Chatterjee with Mr. Arun Birbal and Mr. Sanjay Ghosh)

OA No. 2023/2022

Abhishek Panwar S/o Dharam Veer Singh Aged about 24 years, R/o RZ-1E, Gali No.2 Durga Park, New Delhi-45 Group 'B

Sub: Appointment

Mobile No.9990020343

..APPLICANT

(By Advocate : Mr. Ranjit Sharma) V/s

1. Delhi Development Authority Through the Vice Chairman, Vikas Sadan, INA Delhi -| 3

2 The Commissioner, Personnel DDA, Vikas Sadan, INA, Delhi …….Respondents

(By Advocate : Ms. Sriparna Chatterjee with Mr. Arun Birbal and Mr. Sanjay Ghosh)

O.A. No. 2019/2022

1. Mankesh Meena, Age 30 years, Group "C"

S/O Battilalmeena

R/O Gaonkacharoda,TEHSIL-SAPOTRA Kachroda ,Karauli

Rajasthan-322255

2. Mamta, Age 26 , Group "C"

D/o Laxmi Chand

471, Shivpura

Piloda,Piloda, Sawai Madhopur Rajasthan-322205

3. Jitender Singh Age 26 years, Group "C"

C/O Bhimsen

Surakhipura

VTC: JaitpurJamnapar, PO; Jaitpura Par

Sub District: Etawah , District: Etawah State: Uttar Pradesh, PIN Code: 206131

4. Sanjay kumarmeena, Age 27 years, Group "C"

S/O Sohanlalmeena

R/o Ghunawat ka bas, Karoth(Rural), Alwar Rajasthan: 301408

5. Manoj kumarmeena, Age 32 years, Group "C"

S/O Ramkhilarimeena ,Teh. Kathumar Manya ka bas, Alwar

Rajasthan: 301035

6. Harsh kumarmeena ,Age 27 years, Group "C"

S/O Rang lalmeena

Plot no. 67, Rohini nagar

Jaipur , Jaipur

Rajasthan- 302017

7. Lakhan lalmeena , Age 30 years, Group "C"

S/O Shriphalmeena

NAYAGAON, Handiya, Rohtehdiya, Dausa Rajasthan- 321608

8. Kapil meena, Age 28 years, Group "C"

S/O Uday singhmeena

Mauksm post mainpura tehsil wer ,mainapura, bharatpur Rajasthan-321409

9. Anurajmeena, Age 25 years, Group "C"

S/O Bane singh

R/o Village Pahari,

Pahari Karauli , Rajasthan -322238

10. Likhami Ram Meeena, Age 25 years, Group "C"

S/o Pyar Singh Meena

R/o Village Akhawada Tehsil- Todabhim, AkhawaraKarauli, Rajasthan-322220

11. Rishiraj Meena, Age 27 years, Group "C"

S/o Ramkishor Meena, 346, Nangal Sherpur Karauli Rajasthan-32228.

12. Pankaj Meena , Age 28 years, Group "C"

S/o Anoop Singh

R/o 106, Prem Nagar Near Raily, Station Jagatpura Road, Jaipur, Jaipur Rajasthan-302017

13. Nitin Meena, Age 24 years, Group "C"

S/o Anoop Singh Meena

R/o 106, Prem Nagar Near Raily, Station Jagatpura Road, Jaipur, Jaipur Rajasthan-302017

14. Sitaram Meena, Age 31 years, Group "C"

S/o RamkaranMeena ,

Bhajera, Bhajera Alwar

Rajasthan-301409

15. Mahendra Kumar Meena , Age 26 years, Group "C"

S/o Siyaram Meena Puani

Meenapatti, Sikrai, Sikrai,

DausaSikrai, Rajasthan-303508

16. Kanchan Verma, Age 25 years, Group "C"

D/o Anil Kumar Verma

80, Padhin Darwaja, Badi Mata Mandir, Phaphund Road, Auraiya, Auraiya Uttar Pradesh-206122

17. Atul Singh, Age 26 years, Group "C"

S/o Sherpal Singh

R/o 405, Shivlok Puri,

P.o.Kankerkhera

Kankerkhera Meerut

Navinmandi Meerut

Uttar Pradesh -250002

18. Jaikumar, Age 24 years, Group "C"

S/o Bachchu Singh

R/o B-6, Gali no 27, Molar Band Vistar Jaitpur, Jaitpur South Delhi Delhi- 110044

19. Rahul Kumar Meena, Age 30 years, Group "C"

S/o Babu Lal, R/o House No 79,

Saraswati Colony, Bhadana

Kota, Rajasthan-324002

20. Durgesh Kumar Meena, Age 25 years, Group "C"

S/o Santosh Kumar meena

Muliya Ka Pura

Hindaun city, Bargawan, Karauli

Rajasthan-322230

21. Kuldeep Meena ,Age 31years, Group "C"

S/o Manohari Meena,

R/o Meena Mohalla

Dantli, Karauli, Rajasthan-321610

22. Jitendra kumarmeena, Age 27years, Group "C"

S/o Roopram Meena

R/o Nagala Meena, Karauli

Rajasthan-322230

23. Rajesh Kumar Meena, Age 27 years, Group "C"

S/o Natthu Singh Meena,

245,NaiKhoti ki Abadi Nagal Mandal , Nangal Mandal, Karauli, Rajasthan-321611

24. Balram Meena, Age 30 years, Group "C"

S/o Ramesh Chand Meena

R/o Udaipura , Kheda Kalyanpur, Alwar Kathumar

Rajasthan-301035

25. Lokesh Kumar Ghunawat , Age 24 years, Group "C"

S/o Jai Singh Ghunawat

428, ShivpuraPioda, Gangapur, Pioda Sawai Madopur, Pioda, Rajasthan-322205

26. Bahadur Singh Meena, Age 27 years, Group "C"

S/o Badri Lal, Gram and Post

Neendarda , Sawai

Madhopur, Rajasthan- 322027

27. Raju Lal Meena, Age 31 years, Group "C"

S/o KaluramMeena , R/o Ward no 4, SikrodaJatSikroda Meena, Karauli Rajasthan-322230

28. Amit Kumar Meena ,Age 25 years, Group "C"

S/o Manoj Kumar Meena

R/o Udai Kalan ( Rural )

Sawai Madhopur, Rajasthan-322201

29. Rishikash Meena, Age 29 years, Group "C"

S/o Mohan Lal Meena

R/o The.-KarauliSamarda, Karauli, Rajasthan- 322255

30. Sanjay Singh Meena, Age 30 years, Group "C"

S/o Mulya Ram Meena ,

R/o House no 346, Maina Basti,

Mainapura, Teh -Wair, DistBharatpur Rajasthan-321409

31. Khemraj Meena, Age 30 years, Group "C"

S/o Bhagwan Sahay Meena

R/o Nayagoan, Kemla, Kemla,

Sawai Madhopur Rajasthan-322220

32. Manoj Meena , Age 30 years, Group "C"

S/o Shri Lal Meena

R/o 160/123, Sector no 16,

Pratap Nagar, Sanganer, Jaipur Rajesthan-302033

33. Prem Singh MeenaAge 28 years, Group "C"

S/o Prakash Meena Hingot

R/o Danalpur ,Karauli,

Rajasthan -322220

34. Anuradha Meena Age 26 years, Group "C"

D/o Jagadish Prasad meena

R/o Mohala-meenakhelna

Jaipur, Paota( Jaipur)

Rajasthan-303106

35. Pinkesh Meena, Age 27 years, Group "C"

S/o Bhajori Meena

R/o KudawadaLediaKarauli, Rajasthan-322255

36 Vijay Pratap Meena ,Age 29 years, Group "C"

S/o Chiranji Lal Meena

R/o Village Nishana, AmargarhKarauli Rajasthan -322218

……Applicants

(By Advocate : Mr. Yogesh Kr. Mahur with Mr. Harkesh Parashar and Mr. Bharpur Singh)

Delhi Development Authority

Through its Chairman

Vikas Sadan, Near INA Market

New Delhi-110023

…..Respondent

(By Advocate : Ms. Sriparna Chatterjee with Mr. Arun Birbal and Mr. Sanjay Ghosh)

O.A. No. 2242/2022

1) JITENDRA KUMAR MEENA

Son of Shyam Lal Meena, Age-27 years Resident of Village Post Nagla Meena, Tehshil Hindaun City, District Karauli, Rajasthan-322230,

Mobile no. 9828616116

Email: meenajitendra885@gmail.com

2) Shantanu Singh, Son of Bhoop Singh, Age- 26 years, Resident of Village Post Enchera, Tehshil Nadbai, District Bharatpur, Rajasthan- 321602 Mobile no. 8448412919

Email: iamshantanu4@gmail.com

3) Sanatan Kumar, Son of Hari Lal Rajak, Age- 28 years Resident of Village Gadhiya, Post Bhaptiyahi, District supaul,

Bihar-852105.

Mobile no. 9709536915

Email:ersanatancivil@gmail.com

4) Ajay Kumar Meena, Son of Ramkishore Meena, Age- 26 years, Resident of B-3 Bhuminagar Society, Near Manan Complex,Vadodara, Gujrat-390025.

Mobile no. 7755057718

Email: ajay.meena1995@gmail.com

5) Namonarayan Meena, Son of Surgyan Meena, Age-27 years Resident of VPO Baglai, Tehshil Wazirpur, District Sawai Madhopur,

Rajasthan-322205.

Mobile no. 9651891122

Email. namonarayanmeena20@gmail.com

6) Yashpal Singh Rajpurohit, Son of Murli Manohar Singh,Age- 23 years, Resident of VPO Jagir Kot, Khichan, Tehshil Phalodi, District Jodhpur,

Rajasthan-342308

Mobile no. 9521482977

Email: yashpalsinghrajpurohit542gmail.com

7) Neeraj Meena, Son of Dhanraj meena, Age- 23 years, Resident of Vpo Jonl, Tehshil Todabhim, District Karauli, Rajasthan- 321611. Mobile no. 7891548654

Email: neerajmeena907@gmail.com

8) Rishi Raj Meena, Son Muneem Lal Meena,Age- 25 years, Resident of Village Mangrol, Post Bapoti, Tehshil Sapotra, District Karauli,Rajasthan- 322218.

Mobile no. 8947937318,

Email: rishiraj2233@gmail.com

9) Rahul Sharma, Son of kamal sharma,Age- 25 years, Resident of 28, Shripuram Colony, Gurjar Ki Thadi, Jaipur,Rajasthan- 302019

Mobile no. 7690820161

Email: rahlsharma026@gmail.com

10) Devesh Meena, Son of Laxmi Chand Meena, Age- 25 years, Resident of Village Ringuspura, Tehshil Nadoti, District karauli,

Rajasthan-322215

Mobile no. 8953690135

Email: deveshmeena294@gmail.com

11) Devendra Singh Manwal, Son of Jaswant Singh Manwal, Age- 29 years,

Resident of 2c/2132/3, Punjabi Bagh, Hakikat Nagar, Near D.P. School,Saharanpur, U.P-247001

Mob no. 8791660873

Email: ddevendra.singh40@gmail.com

12) Ravi Kumar Meena, Son of Prahlad Meena, Age- 23 years, Resident of Village Post Jharoti, Tehshil Bhusawar, District Bharatpur,

Rajasthan-321615.

Mobile no. 87409477632

Email: ravikumarmeena1822@gmail.com

13) Utkarsh Singh, Son of Ramashish Singh,Age- 24 years, Resident of Flat 204, Shyam Bandho Kunj Kusum Vihar Road no. 7a

Morabadi,Ranchi,

Jharkhand-834008.

Mobile no. 7008298502

Email:utkarshsingh201@gmail.com

14) Mahendra Pratap Singh, Son of Radha Kishan,Age- 29 years, Resident of 30 Kastoori Vihar Deori Road, District agra, U.P. pin 282001. Mobile no. 8755543207

Email: max.payne7200@gmail.com

15) Rajeev Meena, Son of Madan Lal Meena,Age- 23 years, Resident of Vpo Badapura Ronsi, Tehshil Nadoti, District Karauli, Rajasthan. pin 322220. Mobile no. 9587282638

Email :rajeev.meena.9819@gmail.com

16 Rajan Kumar meena, Son of Hem Raj Meena, Age- 24 years, Resident of Village Kherli, Post Baglai, Tehshil Wazirpur,

District Sawai Madhopur, Rajasthan-322205. Mobile no. 7290855262 Email: thirdrajan@gmail.com

17) Abhishek Kumar Meena, Son of Khushi Ram Meena, Age- 23 years, Resident of Vpo Jharoti, Tehshil Bhusawar, District Bharatpur, Rajasthan- 321615. Mobile no. 8387871197

Email: Abhiparya@gmail.com

18) Ashish Jarwal, Son of Ram Prasad Meena,Age-_years, Resident of Plot no. 17 Shiv Nagar, Vistar Colony Ramnagariya Jagatpura, Jaipur,Rajasthan- 302017. Mobile no. 8003352626

Email: ashish50jarwal@gmail.com

19 Gayatri Meena, Doughter of C.L. meena,Age- 22 years, Resident of C 14, locl Colony, near Ambaji Road, Abu Road, Rajasthan-307026.

Mobile no. 9952108366

20) Bhawani Singh Meena, Son of Sukhram Meena,Age- 25 years, Resident of VPO Sikari, Tehshil Sikari, District Dausa, Rajasthan-303508. Mobile No. 94131340113

Email: biorwal1997@gmail.com

21) Sitaram Meena, Son of Bhagwan Sahay Meena,Age- 25 years, Resident of Vpo Gorda, Tehshil Todabhim, District Karauli, Rajasthan- 321611.

Mobile no. 8503032533

Email: srmahar432@gmail.com

22) Rahul Mehar, Son of Dharam Singh,Age- 25 years, Resident of RZ-30A, H-Block Prem Nagar, Najafgarh, New Delhi- 110043. Mobile no. 9968492942

Email: rahulmehar98@gmail.com

23) Praveen Kumar Sheheria, Son of Surendra Kumar Meena,Age- 22 years, Resident of Village Viloj Nagar, Post Salempur, Tehshil Sapotra,

District karauli, Rajasthan-322202.

Mobile no. 9079309589

Email: sheheriapraveen@gmail.com

24) Umakant Arya, Son of Ramdeen Arya, Age- 29 years, Resident of 585/A Babulal Ka Bagicha Khushipura, Jhansi,U.P.- pin 284001.

Mobile no. 9793382147

Email: umakantarya.arya@gmail.com

25) Ajay Kumar Meena, Son of Lohade Lal Meena, Age- 23 years, Resident of Village Kudavda, Post Lediya, Tehshil Sapotra, District Karauli,Rajasthan-322255

Mobile no. 7318020606

Email: ajay160058@gmail.com

26) Neeraj Kumar Meena, Son of Ramdeen Meena, Age-29 years, Resident of VPO Mandawar,District dausa, Rajasthan-303315.

Mobile no. 8769938535

Email: meena.neeraj1993@gmail.com

27) Vinod Kumar Ghunavat, Son of Nahar Singh Meena, Age-24 years, Resident of VPO Piloda, Tehshil Wazipur,

District Sawai Madhopur, Rajasthan- 322205. Mobile no. 9460747378

Email: vinodjdh2015@gmail.com

28) Prashant Kumbhawat, Son of Jagdish Prasad Kumbhawat, Age- 21 years, Resident of Near School Ground Thanagazi, Alwar, Rajasthan- 301022.

Mobile no. 6377331581

Email: pkumbhawat123@email.com

29 Aman Choudhary, Son of Sohan Choudhary,Age- 21 years, Resident of Chakand Station, District Gaya, Bihar- 804404. Mobile no. 7033566141

Email: amankr.7033@gmail.com

30) Bhawani Singh Meena, Son of Vijay Singh Meena, Age- 24 years, Resident of 622/C Deoli Village near Holi Chowk, New Delhi- 110080.

Mobile no. 8368281205.

Email:bhawani3197@gmail.com

31) Prashant Kumar Meena, Son of Satya Ram Meena,Age- 23 years, Resident of Village Khohara, Post Gahanuli, Tehshil Mahwa,

District Dausa, Rajasthan-321612.

Mobile no. 907964068

Email: prashantkumar8347544@gmail.com

32) Ravikant Meena, Son of Brajalal Meena,Age- 23 years, Resident of VPO Dorawali, Tehshil Todabhim, District Karauli, Rajasthan-321611. Mobile no. 8740837122

Email: meenaravikant414@gmail.com

33) Dilip Kumar Meena, Son of Satya Kumar Meena,Age-25 years, Resident of Village Khohara, Post Gahanuli, Tehshil Mahwa,

District Dausa, Rajasthan-321612

Mobile no. 8587034445

Email: dilip0909370@gmail.com

34) MD Hanif, Son of MD Gayas,Age- 23 years, Resident of Maulabagh Raza Colony Phulwari Sharif, Patna, Bihar- 801505

Mobile no. 7903545904

Email: mdhanif8271@gmail.com

35) Khushi Ram Meena, Son of Roop Singh Meena, Age- 24years, Resident of VPO Gunesra, Tehshil Karauli, District Karauli, Rajasthan- 322241 Mobile no. 8824251174

Email: ramnitj99@gmail.com

36) Sumit Bansal, Son of Manmohan Bansal,Age- 25years, Resident of D-283/B, Madhu Vihar, Dwarka Sector-3, near Sai Baba Mandir, New Delhi- 110059

Mobile no. 9540150841

Email: sumitimi139@gmail.com

37) Harvansh Kumar Meena, Son of Mohan Lal Meena, Resident of B-21 Malviya Nagar, Alwar, Rajasthan- 301001 Mobile no. 9351138746

Email: harvansh925meena@gmail.com

38) Nitish Nishchal, Son of Ravindra Prasad,Age- 28 years,

Resident of Village Sabarchak, Thana Naubatpur, Post Shorampur,

Patana, Bihar- 801505.

Mobile no. 8094455544

Email: nitishnishchal.n21@gmail.com

39) Yogita Dhillo, Daughter of Kuldeep Singh,Age- 26 years, Resident of Ranisar Bas, near MS College, Gajner Road, Bikaner, Rajasthan- 334001.

Mobile no. 7023271594

Email: yogitadhillon2130@gmail.com

40) Abhay Pratap Singh, Son of Atyavrat Yadav,Age- 26 years, Resident of 157/Bainpur, Sikandra, Agra, U.P.- 282007.

Mobile no. 9944153677

Email: abhaypsyadav007@gmail.com

41) Tamanna Meena, Daughter of R.C. Meena,Age- 25 years, Resident of Kasba Sahar, Tehshil Nadauti, District Karauli, Rajasthan-322204. Mobile no. 9783927261

Email: tamannam112@gmail.com

42) Abhishek Meena, Son of Shyam Lal Meena, Age- 24 Years, Resident of VPO Gorda, Tehshil Todabhim, District Karauli, Rajasthan-321611. Mobile no. 9667195497

Email: abhijorwal98@gmail.com

43) Ashish, Son of Ramnivas,Age-21 years Resident of Village Kunjela, Tehshil Nadoti, District Karauli, Rajasthan- 322204 Mobile no. 9057207041

Email: mashish1703@gmail.com

44) Ajay Kumar Meena, Son of Kumesh Kumar Meena, Age- 25 years, Resident of VPO Naroli Chaur, Tehshil Bamanwas, District Sawai Madhopur, Rajasthan-332214 Mobile no. 9414252487

Email: ajaym080597@gmail.com

45) Satveer Singh, Son of Mangtu Ram,Age-29years, Resident of VPO Jhadisha, Tehshil Todabhim, District Karauli, Rajasthan-321611. Mobile no. 9610828219

Email:gurjarsatya951@gmail.com

46) Suraj Kumar Meena, Son of Girraj Meena,Age- 23 years, Resident of VPO Dabra, Tehshil Sapotra, District Karauli, Rajasthan- 322255 Mobile no. 7240313239

Email: meenasuraj207@gmail.com

47) Pankaj Kumar Meena, Son of Surendra Kumar Meena,Age- 23 years, Resident of Village Viloj Nagar, Post Salempur, Tehshil Sapotra,

District Karauli, Rajasthan- 322202

Mobile no. 978309252

Email: pankajkumarmeena100@gmail.com

48) Shivkesh Meena, Son of Suresh Meena,Age- 23 years, Resident of Village Tikuti, Post Amargarh, Tehshil Sapotra, District Karauli, Rajasthan-322218

Mobile no. 8696952467

Email: shivkeshmeena2241999@gmail.com

49) Hansraj Meena, Son of Shivram Meena, Age- 21 years, Resident of VPO Jharoti, Tehshil Bhusawar, District Bharatpur, Rajasthan- 321615 Mobile no. 9413992599

Email: hansuparya@gmail.com

50) Shailendra Kumar Meena, Son of Heera Lal Meena,Age-24 years, Resident of Village Binderwara, Post Sikandra, Tehshil Sikari,

District dausa, Rajasthan- 303326

Mobile no. 9887643449

Email: shailendracivil274@gmail.com

51) Atul Kumar Meena, Son of Lakhan Singh,Age- 25 years, Resident of 4/49 Gandhi Nagar, Tonk Phatak, Jaipur, Rajasthan-302015

Mobile no. 9509545671

Email: awesomeatulkumar.7@gmail.com

52) Manoj Kumar Bairwa, Son of Shyam Lal Bairwa,Age- 25 years,

Resident of Village Bada Khilchipur, Post urdain, Tehshil Todabhim,

District Karauli, Rajasthan-322238.

Mobile no. 9694785847

Email: manojkumar.svnit@gmail.com

53) Anuj Kumar Meena, Son of Ustaj Meena,Age- 25 years, Resident of Adarsh Nagar Gangapur City, District Sawai Madhopur, Rajasthan-322201 Mobile no. 9672468471

Email: anujighunawat234@gmail.com

54) Dinesh Kumar, Son of Jag Mohan,Age- 29 years, Resident of 1 857 mangolpuri, Delhi-110083.

Mobile no. 9461740044

Email: meenadinesh77@gmail.com

55) Deepak Sehra, Son of Shiv Lahari Meena,Age- 23 years, Resident of Plot no 2 Kusum Vihar Extension Ram Nagaria Road,

Jagatpura, Jaipur, Rajasthan- 302017.

Mobile no. 9460172154

Email: deepak.sehra.79@gmail.com

56) Gaurav Meena, Son of Radheshyam Meena, Age- 24 years, Resident of VPO Suroth, Tehshil, Suroth, District Karauli, Rajasthan-322252. Mobile no. 9694323280

Email: kantyagaurav2129@gmail.com

57) Manish Kumar Meena, Son of Kedar Nath Meena,Age- 23 years, Resident of Village Kachhpura, Post Angai, Tehshil Baseri, District Dholpur, Rajasthan-328031.

Mobile no. 9079267977

Email: manishkumarmeena9898@gmail.com

58) Nitin Kumar Meena, Son of Mahendra Kumar Meena,Age- 23 years, Resident of VPO Suratpura, Tehshil Lalsot, District Dausa, Rajasthan-303504. Mobile no. 9667883771

Email: Baiplawatnitin98@gmail.com

59) Manish Tiwari, Son of Harish Chandra Tiwari,Age-24 years, Resident of near Degree College Road Dak Banglow Lohaghat

Champawat, Uttarakhand- 262524.

Mobile no. 8979435331

Email: tiwarimanish658@gmail.com

60) Ravi Shankar Meena, Son of Deepchand Meena,Age- 26 years, Resident of VPO Jharoti, Tehsil Bhusawar, District Bharatpur, Rajasthan- 321615. Mobile no. 9414744297

Email: shankarbadgotya95@gmail.com

61) Pankaj Mandawat, Son of P.C. Meena,Age-22 years, Resident of 109 Devi Nagar, Nannu Marg, New Sanganer Road,

Jaipur, Rajasthan- 302019.

Mobile no. 8949312690

Email: pankajmandawat339@gmail.com

62) Aamir, Son of Noor Mohammad,Age- 25 years, Resident of 165, VPO Hamidpur,North West Delhi, Delhi- 110036.

Mobile no. 8287827773

Email: aamir8377831981@gmail.com

63) Sajid Khan,

Son of Mehboob,Age- 22 years, Resident of 165, VPO Hamidpur,North West Delhi, Delhi- 110036.

Mobile no. 8920942999

Email: sajidpathan2k18@gmail.com

64) Mohit Kumar Verma, Son of Ramjilal Verma,Age- 22 years, Resident of VPO Bhudoli, Tehshil Neemkathana, District sikar, Rajasthan-332713. Mobile no. 8209914073

Email: mohitrlverma@gmail.com

65) Hemant Kumar Meena, Son of Ganshyam Meena,Age- 21 years, Resident of Village Hingot, Post Danalpur, Tehshil Hindaun City,

District karauli, Rajasthan-322220.

Mobile no. 8112261149

Email: hemantkumarmeena2511@gmail.com

66) Arif Khan, Son of Noor Mohmad K.R.Age- 22 years, Resident of 165, VPO Hamidpur,North West Delhi, Delhi-110036.

Mobile no. 9718099065

Email: arifkhanofficial07@gmail.com

67) Sunil Kumar Meena, Son of Lohare Lal Meena, Age- 22 years, Resident of Village Dabra, Post Dabra, Tehshil Sapotra, District Karauli, Rajasthan-322255.

Mobile no. 7220900023

Email: sunilyit84@gmail.com

68) Natvar Singh Meena, Son of Dhara Singh Meena,Age-22 years, Resident of VPO Khidarpur, Tehsil Wazirpur, District Sawai Madhopur,

Rajasthan- 322205

Mobile no. 9588070285 Email: nsm16101999@gmail.com

69) Dharmendra Meena, Son of Babu Lal Meena,Age- 23 years, Resident of VPO Danalpur, Tehsil Hindaun City, District Karauli, Rajasthan-322220. Mobile no. 8448834595

Email: dharmendrameena017@gmail.com

70) Badri Narayan Meena, Son of Ghasi Ram, Age- 27 years, Resident of VPO Kundlya, Tehsil Thanagazi, District Awar, Rajasthan-3010222. Mobile no.8561900861

Email: bnmeena004@gmail.com

….Applicants

(By Advocate : Ms. Fareha Ahmad Khan with Ms. Shagun Chopra and Ms. Kaveeta Wadia

Vs.

Delhi Development Authority

Through its Chairman

Vikas Sadan, Near INA Market

New Delhi-110023

…Respondent

(By Advocate : Ms. Sriparna Chatterjee with Mr. Arun Birbal and Mr. Sanjay Ghosh)

O.A. No. 2105/2022

1. Mithilesh Kumar Meena, Age 25 years, Group "C"

S/O RamKishore Meena,

R/O Village Nand, Post Gorda, Tehsil- Todabhim, DistKarauli, Rajasthan-321611

2. Manu Kumar Jha Age 27 years S/O Umesh Kumar Jha, Group "C"

R/O- A-10 d-p-b-s degree college

Mohalla neharuganj , Anupshahr Bulandshahr Uttar Pradesh - 202390

3. Pankaj Kumar Meena Age 26 years S/O Attar Singh Meena, Group "C"

R/o Khanpur Meena the bari, Khanpur Meena, Dholpur,

Rajasthan- 328021

4. Rajesh Meena Age 27 years S/O Ramchandar Meena, Group "C"

R/O Sehrakhar, Karauli, Rajasthan-321611

5. Manoj Kumar Meena Age 27 years S/O Kedar Meena, Group "C"

R/o 285, Mishr Mohalla, Rajasthan- 322034

6. Neeraj Narvariya Age 27 years S/O Rajaram, Group "C"

R/o House Number- F-16, Beer Sarai, Hauz Khas, South Delhi, Hauz Khas, Delhi, 110016

7. Manish Kumar Meena Age 27 years S/O Jal Singh Meena, Group "C"

R/O C-299, Ram gali-6, kusumvihar, Jaipur, Jagatpura,

Rajasthan, 302017

8. Chandrakant Meena Age 24 years S/O Raman Lal Meena, Group "C"

R/o Milakpur, Milakpur, Bharatpur, Rajasthan,

321302

9 Krishna Kant Age 25 years S/O Lalit Mohan, Group "C"

R/O Milakpur, Milakpur, Bharatpur, Rajasthan,

321302

10 Amar Singh Meena Age 27 years S/O Sedyaram Meena, Group "C"

R/o Ramdhan ka pura, Talchida, Karauli, Rajasthan-

322213

11 Munikeshmeena Age 25 years S/O Babulal Meena, Group "C"

R/o Halkara ki jhopadi, Bichhauchh, Bichhauchh, Sawai Madhour, Rajasthan-322214

12. Samay Singh Meena Age 25 years S/O Hariram Meena, Group "C"

R/o Khohra, Karauli, Rajasthan-321611

13. Jitendra Kumar Meena Age 29 years S/O Shivram Meena, Group "C"

R/o Bairoj, Karauli, Padampura, Rajasthan- 321611

14. Bhoor Singh Meena Age 30 years S/O Ramjee Lal, Group "C"

R/o A-94 Tapovanvihar, Jaipur, Jaipur, Rajasthan-

302025

15. Rajiv Pakad Age 25 years S/O Devphool Meena, Group "C"

R/o Kanvti, Ramthara, Kanvti, Rajasthan-322218

16. Yogesh Kumar Age 32 years S/O Jadish Prashad, Group "C"

R/o E-133, mohannagar, Hindaun, Karauli, Hindaun, Rajasthan-322230

17. Anil Kumar Mourya Age 26 years S/O Shiv Chand Mourya, Group "C"

R/o Luniyawas goner, road, pani ki tanki, Jaipur, Jamdoli, Jaipur,Rajasthan-302031

18. Rakesh Meena Age 28 years S/O Halke Ram Meena, Group "C"

R/O Khandeep, Khanseep, Sawai Madhopur, Rajasthan-322205

19. Deepak Kumar Meena Age 26 years S/O Ramesh chand Meena, Group "C"

R/o Sikrai, Dausa, Rajasthan-303508

20. Namonarayah Meena Age 31 years S/O Siyaram Meena, Group "C"

R/O Sikrai, Dausa, Rajasthan-303508

21. Prashant Kumar Age 28 years S/O Kaluram Meena, Group "C"

R/o Village- Khurra, Khujjra, Dausa, Rajasthan-303504

22. Gaurav Kumar Meena Age 28 years S/O Kamal Ram Meena, Group "C"

R/o A-109, tirupatinagar, C.B.I. Phatak, Jagatpura, Jaipur, Jagatpura, Rajasthan-302017

23. Khemraj Meena Age 25 years S/O Ramesh Meena, Group "C"

R/O Khoonlta, Salauna, Sawai Madhopur,

Rajasthan-322201

24. Pankaj Kumar Meena Age 26 years S/O Pappu Kumar Meena, Group "C"

R/O Karauli, Rajasthan-321611

25. Hemraj Meena Age 28 years S/O Seva Ram Meena, Group "C"

R/O Sadpura, Dadanpur, Karauli, Rajasthan-321302

26 Lokesh Meena Age 31 years S/O Hanaram Meena, Group "C"

R/o Talai ka pura, Akhawara, Shekhpura, Karauli, Rajasthan, 322220

27 Samay Singh Age 30 years S/O Bhanjee Lal Meena, Group "C"

R/O Dandli, Dandli, Bhajeda, Karauli, Rajasthan-321610

28 Abishek pal Age 27 years S/O Mahendra Pratap Pal, Group "C"

R/O Argoopur Kalan, Jaunpur, Argupur, Kala, Uttar Pradesh- 222101

29. Shivam Kumar, Age 26 years S/o Vijay Kumar Kashyap R/o A-27, Gali no-13, Near Nalanda School, Mandawali Uncheper, VTC, Shakar Pur Baramad, PO, Shakapur, Sub District Gandhi Nagar, District East Delhi-

110092

....Applicants (By Advocate : Mr. Yogesh Kumar Mahur with Mr. Harkesh Parashar and Mr. Bharpur Singh)

Vs.

Delhi Development Authority Through its Chairman Vikas Sadan, Near INA Market New Delhi-110023

…Respondent

(By Advocate : Mr. J.P. Tiwari, Ms. Sriparna Chatterjee with Mr. Arun Birbal and Mr. Sanjay Ghosh)

OA No. 2331/2022

1. Saurabh Kumar, S/o: Sheojee Prasad Resident of G-83 Tagore Gali no.3 Jagatpuri near Ambedkar gate, Delhi 110051 Email: saurabhk812@gmail.com

Mobile no.9315186019

2. Mithilesh Kumar Singh Son of Shri Ramashray Singh Vill- Manjhariya Post- jeopur Ghazipur Uttar pradesh :232340 Email- mithileshksingh97@gmail.com Phone No- 8738970080

3. Deevit deepak sahni Son of Shri Deepak Sahni Resident of SB-135, shastri nagar, Ghaziabad 201002 Email- dsdeevitsahni@gmail.com Mobile no. - 9711847729

4. Shubham Madhwal Father name Shambhu Prasad madhwal Address-Type2/8,CPWD Colony 2 forest park Dehradun PhoneNo.8171225730

Email id-shubham39madhwal@gmail.com,

5. Shubham Yadav son of sunder Singh Yadav

114 Nandpuri, Malviya Nagar, Jaipur shubhamyadv75@gmail.com 8290525197

6. DURVESH KUMAR

son of PERMESHWARI SINGH Village Faizpur post Rajpura tehsil gunnaur district Sambhal pincode 243727 mob no 8383859235

email - durvesh029@gmail.com

7. Devendra meena Son of Bhajan lal meena Residence of :

Village Brahmbad Tehsil Sikrai Post Chandera District Dausa State Rajasthan 303509 email id :dev.chandwala@gmail.com phone no : 8559934877

8. Abhishek, Father name - chandrasen singh, Village -gaurapar Post -dehwa dist-sant Kabir nagar

Pincode -272162

Email: abhishekjohn.95@gmail.com

(M): 7071894450

9. Abhishek Son of Shri B P Meena Resident of 148, pocket-3 sec-12 Dwarka, south west delhi, delhi 10078 Email : abhishekmeena06@gmail.com Mobile No.: 9650667622

10. Suryakant kumar, son of chandrashekhar prasad, resident of dariyapur, patna, bihar: 803212,

7808831010

prasadsuryakantkumar@ gmail. Com

11. Prakash chand meena Son of kailash chand meena Resident of basa kuan ki dhani gudha chak, Bassi, Post bassi

Tehsil bassi: 303301

100

Email:Prakash9460726880@gmail.com Mobile no:9782368871

12. Abhishek Yadav Father name - V P Singh Yadav ADDRESS - A 27 SARVODAYA Nagar Badaun Road Kargaina Bareilly -243001

Contact no. - 8800467327 email id - abhishekyadav250797@gmail.com

13. Abhishek Kumar Basuki, Son of Shri Jaipal Sah, Resident of AT - Munshipatti, PO - GANGAPUR, PS - Sultanganj, Dist - Bhagalpur, Pincode - 813213, State - BIHAR,

Email : abhishekbasuki@gmail.com,

Mobile No: 9915258865

14. Arpit Sikarwar Father name- Rajesh Kumar Sikarwar , Address- HNo-6 Canal Colony Civil lines Mathura,

Email id- sikarwararpit@gmail.com Phone no- 8791603193

15. Pankaj Kumar Son of Shri Sunhari Lal Resident of Shakti Nagar Tundla Firozabad 283204 Email pankajkumar3017@gmail.com Mobile no 9917869110

16. Devendra Singh Meena s/o akhlesh meena email-devladla006@gmail.com mobile number -9782700543

17. Mohd Atif Khan Son of Shariful Hasan Khan Resident of 192,

New Azadpuram Chawani Ashraf Khan Izzatnagar

BAREILLY UP: 243122

Contact no-- 9140453684/ 9557809040

101

Email address-- Khanas1713@gmail.com

18. Amit Kumar Father's Name-Ram Pratap Yadav Address-Bhadsamanopur PO-Kopaganj Distt-Mau Uttar Pradesh

EMAIL ID-akamit2893@gmail.com PHONE NO-8527065086

19. Amit Prajapati S/o Tulsi Ram Prajapati Resident of Behind shiddheswar Mountain Public School Power House Road Brahma Nagar Iti Jhansi

Uttar Pradesh: 284003

Email: amitsalivahan@gmail.com Mobile no:9625866715 , 8908020550

20. Ashesh singh, Son Of Vijay Singh, Resident of jagdamba nagar Firozabad-283203(U.P) asheshme40@gmail.com

21. Aiyoob Khan Son of Shri IBLE HASAN Resident of VILLAGE-PATEI AIMAN, POST- CHAKANWALA, DISTT-AMROHA(U P) -244225

Email id- aiyoobkhan101@gmail.com

Mobile no. - 9711025269

22. Atul Kumar Gupta S/o- Mangal Prasad Gupta, Address- 103 L.I.G.-2, Jarauli Phase-2, Kanpur Nagar,

Uttar Pradesh - 208027,

Email Id- atulscience2512@gmail.com, Contact no.- 9807114866

23. Vinayak Tiwari Son of Rajesh Narayan Tiwari

102

R/O Village- Kathawaiyan, Kalana,Mirzapur

Uttar Pradesh: 231303; Email-vinayaktiwari.rt@gmail.com ; Mob-9984407093

24. Sourav Uppal S/O JAGDISH LAL UPPAL 1123/24 RAM NAGAR ROHTAK-124001

HARYANA EMAIL- SOURAV660@GMAIL.COM

PH NO 8570840834

25. Kaushlendra singh verma Son of Ram milan verma Resident of House no. MP/0752 Rajpuram colony naka paisar, Tehsil Nawabganj, Barabanki, Uttar pradesh. Pin: 225001 Email: kaushlendraverma107@gmail.com Mobile no: 9452220711

26. Nimesh singh Son of Tej pratap singh Resident of 281/13 swami vivekanand colony Deoria khas Deoria,U.P 274001

Email-nimusingh003@gmail.com

Mobile no. -7084638103

27. Gaurav kumar chaudhary Son of Shri Shalikram chaudhary Resident of village- marwatiya kurmi, Post- Birdpur, Siddharthnagar,

Uttar pradesh, 272202

Email- gaurav021chaudhary@gmail.com

Mob. No.-7065896313

28. Divas Singh Son of Dinesh Singh Resident of -- House No -314 Budheswar Chauraha Vaderkheda Salempur Pataura Pin code 227107 Email- divassingh14@gmail.com Mobile no- 7905467610

103

29. Maheshwari Sonker D/o Subhash Chandra Sonker Address: Kaushalaya katra paharpur Tirana Azamgarh UP 276001

Email: maheshwarisonker12001@gmail.com Phone no: 7052378920

30. Prabhat kumar Verma Son of Shri Rajesh Verma Resident of H no152 village chhauchh, lakhimpur- kheri, UP, 262701 EMAIL- prabhatverma@yahoo.com Mobile- 9715097942

31. Satendra kumar yaduvanshi Son of Mr jagan lal

Resident of village Dalki tehsil bilaspur Dist. Rampur: 244921

Email: skyaduvanshi76@gmail.com Mob: 7351441235

32. Pankaj Yadav S/o asharam

Indira residential colony In front of 28 BN,PAC etawah: 206001 pankajknit22@gmail.com

Mob-9528300815

33. Ketan Kumar s/o Babu Ram Village Binjaheri Post Akbarabad Tehsil Nagina Bijnor UP 246762

34. Manoj kumar gautam S/O Niranjan Prasad Village And Post Bishunpur Raja Gorakhpur UP 273409

Email: mkmanoj971@gmail.com …Applicants

(By Advocate : Mr. Abhisht Hela) Versus

104

DelhiDevelopmentAuthority, Through its

Chairman,VikasSada n,

Near INA

Market,NewDelhi-

110023

Email:ddachamberhc@yahoo.com Phoneno:011-23389451 …Respondent

(By Advocate : Ms. Sriprna Chatterjee with Mr. Arun Birbal and Mr. Sanjay Ghosh)

OA No. 2349/2022

1. Mohd Arif, age 26, Group B, s/o Naseem Ahmed,

r/o Near Wajiba Biwi Imambara, Siaph Jaunpur, Uttar Pradesh

2. Abhishek Pandey, Age 25, Group B S/O Sh. Pradeep Kumar Pandey R/O C-I/251 Sangam Vihar, New Delhi-110080.

3. Mani Ratnam Jaddidi, Age 24, Group B S/O Sh Vasu Deva Rao Jaddidi R/O Type 4, Tower -8, F4,

East Kidwai Nagar,

New Delhi -110023

4. Shubham Kokaria, Age-25, Group B S/o Vijay Choudhary

R/o B-50 Duggal Colony,

Khanpur, New Delhi- 110062

5. Vishal Pandey, Age 23, Group B S/O Sh. Pradeep Kumar Pandey R/O C-I/251 Sangam Vihar, New Delhi-110080

6. Sania Meena, Age 23, Group B, D/o Lakhan Singh Meena

105

R/o 6MB,401 Indira Gandhi nagar Jagatpura Jaipur, Rajasthan

7. Prashant Tiwari Age 26 , Group B S/o Ashok Kumar Tiwari

R/o 110/8, F04/B,

MMM Road Near Rama Hospital, George Town, Allahabad,

Uttar Pradesh -211002

8. Bipin Kumar Verma Age 26, Group B, S/o Ramjeet Verma,

R/o Village Mahanmou,

Post Rampur Bhagan,

Dist - Ayodhya Uttar Pradesh

9. Gourav Yadav Age 28 Group B S/O-Deenbandhu yadav

R/o Ratan colony

behind K SSchool

Morena, Madhya Pradesh.

10. Kamlesh Kumar Kumawat Age 29, Group B, R/o H. No. 145

Village Post Salamgarh,

Tehsil Arnod,

District Pratapgarh,

Rajasthan, 312619

11. Indra Bhushan Kumar, Age 28, Group B, S/O Upendra Yadav

R/o 199, Room no 14 Khanpur

Village Devli Khanpur New Delhi110062

12. Dhirendra Kumar, Age 26, Group B, S/o Mr. Brijesh Kumar,

R/o Urmauira Robertsganj,

Sonebhadra Uttar Pradesh

13. Ashish Kumar ,Age 28 , Group B, S/o Dilip Kumar Yadav

R/o A 13 Deoli Road Khanpur New Delhi -110062

14. Leela Dhar Meena Age 30, Group B, S/o Hari Ram Meena,

R/o Village Baldevpura,

106

Post Taraj, Tehsil - Khanpur, Dist Jhalawar, Rajasthan - 326035

15. Divyanshu Upadhayay Age 25, Group B, S/o Shivdatt Upadhayay

R/o Brahmanpuri Paranee

Tehsil Sikandra Rao

Hathras Uttar Pradesh 204215

16. Vijay Kumar Meena Age 26 group b S/o Kailash Chand Meena,

R/o Paparda, Dhani Thanya Wali Kothi Tehsil Nangal Rajawatan Dausa Rajasthan

17. Ajay kumar meena Age 27, Group B S/o Maya Ram Meena

R/o V/P- Chhoti Udai Teh- wazirpur Dist-Sawai MadhopurRajasthan 322219

18. Preetam Singh Rawat Age 24 Group B S/o Jagat Singh Rawat

R/o Joshiyara Uttarkashi

Uttrakhand

19. Harshit Awasthi Age 25 Group b, S/o Rishi Kumar Awasthi,

R/o 347/ 350 Old Tikait Ganj, Lucknow Uttar Pradesh - 226017

20. Aman Boora, Age 22, Group B S/O Sh. Jagbir Singh Boora, R/O H. No. 322, Sector 14, Rohtak, Haryana 124001

21. Ajay kumar, Age-24, Group-B, S/o Ram Kumar

R/o H. No-3, type-4,

Kali Bari Apartment,

New Delhi-110001

22. Mohd Shariq Habib, Age 26, Group B S/O Sh. Khalil Ullah

R/O 816, Dadiapura,

Shivaji Nagar

Jhansi Uttar Pradesh 284001

23. Seeta Ram Meena, Age 29, Group B, S/O Sh. Ram Singh Meena

107

R/O Gadhouli, Karauli, Rajasthan 322241

24. ABHISHEK MEENA ,Age 25,Group B, S/O BATTILAL MEENA,

R/O B-76 Shyam Vihar Ph-1 Najafgarh New Delhi-110043

25. Ankush, Age 22, Group B, S/O Sh. Mahabir,

R/O VPO Sanghi,

Rohtak, Haryana, 124303

26. Chiranji Lal Bairwa, Age 31, Group B, s/o Bhagat Ram Bairwa,

R/o Village Trishool Dhani,

Tehsil & Post Todabhim

Dist Karauli Rajasthan 321611

27. Naveen Kumar Age 24 Group B, S/O Shubhash Kumar,

R/O Sewla Kalan,

Dehradun, Uttrakhand.

28. Surabhi Lodhi,Age 25 Group b, D/O Sh. Ramesh Chandra

R/O Village post Mirehachi Near post office

Dist. Etah Uttar Pradesh, 207125

29. Purshottam Jatav, Age 28 Group B S/O Sua Lal Jatav,

R/O V.P.O. Chandelipura,

Tehsil Mandrayal,

District Karauli

Rajasthan 322251

30. Anil Kapoor Jatav, Age 28, Group B, s/o Parimal Jatav,

r/o V.P.O. Bhankari,

Tehsil Mandrayal,

Dist Karauli Rajasthan 322249

31. Neeraj Kumar Meena age 25, Group B, S/o Prem singh meena

R/o 32, meena khediya dausa rajasthan 321612

32. Anurag Mahar, age 23, group b, s/o Mukesh Kumar meena,

108

r/o 30, 32 Kedar nagar Jagatpura Jaipur Rajasthan 302017.

33. Vikash Kumar Meena, Age 22, Group B, S/O Sh. Hari Prasad Meena

R/O Village-Raneta, Teh-Sapotra, Dist.-Karauli, Rajasthan 322203

34. Vijendra Meena, Group B, Age-24 S/o Prakash Chand Meena

R/O Gunesra Karauli Karauli Rajasthan 322241

35. Amit kumar Meena, Age 23, Group B, S/O Sh. Harikishan Meena

R/O Village - Deewli pahad, Post- Devli, Tehsil- Laxmangarh, Alwar, Rajasthan 321633

36. Santosh Kumar,age 30, group B, s/o sh. Chain Singh,

R/o v.p.o. mainapura teh bhusawar dist Bharatpur rajasthan 321409

37. Neeraj koli,age 30 group B, S/O Swarup koli

R/O VPO mandakheda,

Teh Masalpur Dist Karauli, Rajasthan 322241

38. Vachan Singh Meena ,Age25, Group B, S/O sh. Brij Lal Meena

R/O Village-Dudupura,

Post-Loharra,Tahsil- Karauli District - Karauli , Rajasthan 322243

39. Pankaj Kumar Meena, age 27, Group B, S/o Radhamohan meena,

R/o v.p.o. Dungarpur,

Tehsil Rahuwas District Dausa, Rajasthan, 303511

40. Pushpendra Kumar,age 27, Group B, S/O sh. Mahesh Chand,

village Reechhauli, Bayana, Bharatpur, Rajasthan 321302

41. Narendra Kumar Meena , Age -27 , Group-B, S/o Hazari Lal Meena,

109

R/o Vill&Post-Biwai, Teh-Baswa, Dist.-Dausa 303315 (Raj.)

42. Ayush Rana, Age 26, Group B, S/O Sh Govind singh rana R/O Village Kholi PO BADASU District Rudraprayag Uttarakhand 246471

43. Mayank, Age 23, Group B, S/O Sh. Mahaveer Singh, R/O Ward no.-6 Vill-Gothra bhukaran Via-Kudan Teh-Dhod,

Dist-Sikar Rajasthan 332031

44. Nahar singh meena Age-28 , Group-B, S/O Jamna lal, Village -gavadiyapura, Post-raghuvanshi, Teh+Dist- Karauli, Rajasthan, Pin Code no.- 322241

45. Balkrishan Mahar, Age - 28 Group B, S/O Mahilal Meena

R/O B- 107 Jawahar Park

Khanpur Delhi 110062.

46. Sapna , age 26, GroupB, D/O Prahlad Singh Meena, R/O D-39A,phase-1,

Shyam vihar Najafgarh New Delhi-110043

47. Ankit kumar meena, Age 23, group b, S/O Om prakash meena

R/O binayaka, kota,

Rajasthan 325004

48. Bharat Lal Mahavar, age 29, Group B, S/O Ramnarayan Mahavar,

R/o baharawanda khurd

Sawai Madhopur (Rajasthan), Pin 322001

49. Vipul chauhan age 23 group b S/o Rajesh Chauhan

R/o Bahadrabad

Haridwar Uttrakhand

50. Anil meena, age 27 group b, R/o V.P.O. Suroth,

Tehsil, Hindaun City,

District Karauli Rajasthan

110

51. Rohan bargoti, Age -25 group b, S/o Asharam meena,

R/o Meena colony udai mode gangapur city rajasthan 322201

52. Ankur Agarwal, age 26, group b, s/o J. K. Agarwal

R/O 127/216/4

Juhi Baradevi Kanpur,

UP(208014)

53. Akash kumar Meena , age 26 , Group B, S/O sh. Dharm Singh Meena,

R/O Village post piloda

district sawai madhopur

Rajasthan 322205

54. Pratibha Yadav, Age 24,Group B, D/O Rajesh Yadav,

R/O 54 mangakodar,

Rudrapur,Deoria,UP, 274204

55. Lokesh meena, age 28, group b, s/o Ram Niwas Meena,

r/o Village Khedi Shish, Post Bargama, Teh. Hinduan City, district Karauli,

Rajasthan 322230

56. Samridh Kumar Singh Age 26yrs Group B, S/o Rameshwar Lal Singh,

r/o HIG 2nd H/no 1,

New Vivekpuram ,Taramandal

Gorakhpur u p 273017

57. Deewan Singh,Age 29,Group B, S/O Sh Sardar Singh,

R/O Village Danda PO Danda,Tehsil, Kalsi Dehradun

248165

58. Dev Karan Meena, age 27, group b, s/o Dhan Pal Meena,

r/o Village Prempura,

Post Neemla, Tehsil Rajgarh, dist- Alwar, Rajasthan- 301415

59. Avdhesh Kumar Meena age 24, group b s/o Mahaveer Meena,

111

r/o Village Toda, Post Tundila, Tehsil Bamanwash, Sawai Madhopur 322211.

60. Aditya Singh Rathore age 26, group b, s/o Narayan singh Rathore

r/o 444 Nayagan city

police line

Baran Road Kota Rajasthan

61. Ashish Kumar Meena, Age 26,Group B, S/O Sh. Raju Lal Meena,

R/O Village- Tajpura,

Post-Dabar,Tehsil-Bamanwas, District -Sawai Madhopur,

Rajasthan 322214

62. Deshraj meena age 30, group b S/o Raju Lal Meena

R/o Village Badramsar,

tehsil Gangapur City

Sawai Madhopur (Rajasthan)

63. Vijay pratap singh age 31, group b s/o Bhagwan das

R/o 1347 B ISAI tola

Khati baba Jhansi

Uttar Pradesh

64. Nikhil kumar age 25 group b s/o Radhey Shyam

R/o 10 B street 08 bank colony Mandoli Delhi -93

65. Gaurav kumar Age 30, group b s/o. Om Prakash singh

r/o H.No. type -1/1 staff colony New Mandi, Hapur, UP- 245101

66. Vinay Gautam Age 29 Group b S/o Roop Chand Gautam

R/o 22 Syndicate Bank Colony Gallana Road, Agra Uttar Pradesh

67. Vinod kumar meena age 31 group b s/o Manohar lal meena

r/o Punderpara Dausa Rajasthan ………APPLICANTS

(By Advocate : Mr. Sumit Sharma with Mr. Mohit)

112

VERSUS

Delhi Development Authority Through its Chairman Vikas Sadan,

Near INA Market New Delhi-110023 ……..RESPONDENT

(By Advocate : Ms. Sriparna Chatterjee with Mr. Arun Birbal and Mr. Sanjay Ghosh)

O.A. No. 2325/2022

1 Rajendra Kumar Meena age 27 group B S/o Somotya Ram Meena

R/o v.p.o Lotwara tehsil baijupara District dausa, Rajasthan 303509

2 Rajendra Kumar Meena age 28 group B S/o Shiv Charan Meena

R/o village bhuda post shakarwara Teh todabhim dist karauli

Rajasthan- 321610

3 Pradeep Kumar Meena, Age 30, Group B S/O Rameswar Prasad

R/o village & post Phulwara tehsil Wazirpur district Sawai Madopur Rajasthan pin code 322219

4 Savita meena age 30, group B D/o Babulal meena

R/o E-27 Ambedkar Nagar near itarana Alwar, Rajasthan

113

5 Sardesh Mukhi Meena age 28 Group B S/o Laxmi Narayan Meena

R/o dhigaria tappa koleshwar Post dhanawar, tehsil Baswa, District dausa, Rajasthan 303304

6 Ravi Kumar Meena, age 32 group B S/o Ramcharan Meena

Address vill brahmbad post chandera tehsil sikrai, district dausa

Rajasthan 303509

7 Rahul Kumar age 27 group B S/o Radhe Lal

R/o village & post Kherli rail Tehsil kathumar district Alwar Rajasthan pin 321606

8 Lokesh Meena age 27 group B S/o Shiv Charan Lal Meena R/o v.p.o. suroth (Patel ka pura) Tehsil hindaun city

Karauli rajasthan- 322252

9 Jagdish Prasad Meena age 28 group B S/o Chuttan Lal Meena

R/o dhigariya Kapoor, post dhigariya bhim, teh baijupara, pin code- 303315

10 Vijay singh age 26 group B S/o Balram

R/o village kachera post mahloni Tehsil bayana dist bharatpur Rajasthan 321401

114

11 Ramakant Meena age 28 group B S/o Siyaram Meena

R/o kanchanpura post baijupara teh baijupara dist Dausa rajasthan- 303315

12 Rajeev Kumar age 29 group B S/o Murahoo Ram

C-1 sai kuteer P.G.

Khanpur extension

New delhi 110062

13 Ashutosh Chaudhary age 28 group B S/o Satish Chandra

C-1 sai kuteer P.G.

Khanpur extension, New delhi 110062

14 Mahender Kumar Gudha Age 28 Group B S/O Jagdish Narayan Meena

R/O Sarpanch ke Dhani Gudha Meena Post- Lalgarh, Tehsil- Bassi Jaipur, Rajasthan 303301

15 Shardul Aswal Age 25 Group B S/O Sudhir Singh aswal R/O 80, Lalpur near beladat, village Lalpur, P/O Padampur Sukhrau Kotdwara

pauri Garhwal Uttarakhand 246149 ....Applicants

(By Advocate : Mr. Sumit Sharma with Mr. Mohit)

Vs.

Delhi Development Authority Through its Chairman Vikas Sadan, Near INA Market New Delhi-110023

…Respondent

(By Advocate : Ms. Sriparna Chatterjee with Mr. Arun Birbal and Mr. Sanjay Ghosh)

115

ORDER

Hon'ble Mr. Tarun Shridhar, Member (A)

In all these O.A(s)., the applicants are challenging the same vacancy advertisement. The applicants are similarly placed and seek identical reliefs; the grounds and the issues flagged in the O.A(s) too are common and quite similar. Accordingly, with the request and consent of all the learned counsel, all the O.A(s) are being taken up together for disposal. However, the facts as contained in only O.A. No. 1741/2022 are being discussed.

2. The applicants who hold a degree in engineering are aspirants for the post of Junior Engineer (JE) in Delhi Development Authority (DDA). However, the advertisement inviting applications for the said post bars such candidates who possess Degree in Engineering until and unless they possess the Diploma too.

3. Aggrieved by such a condition stipulated in the advertisement, they seek the following reliefs by virtue of the present O.A. :

(a) Issue an appropriate Writ, Order or direction quashing the Note in the Advertisement No. 03/2022/Rectt.Cell/Pers./DDA dated 11.06.2022 issued by the Respondent to the extent that the impugned

116

Advertisement permits only those candidates who are in possession of Diploma in Civil Engineering/Diploma in Electrical/Mechanical Engineering or equivalent qualification to apply for the post of Junior Engineer (Civil) and Junior Engineer (Electrical/Mechanical) while excluding candidates who are in possession of a Degree in Civil Engineering or Degree in Electrical, Mechanical Engineering from applying for the said posts of Junior Engineer.

(b) Issue an appropriate Writ, Order or direction directing the

Respondent to adhere and implement the Delhi Development Authority (Junior Engineer) Recruitment Rules, 2018 read with Recruitment Regulations of Assistant Engineer (Civil) and Assistant Engineer (Electrical), Delhi Development Authority, 2005 to consider and uphold the candidature of the degree holders/Petitioners under the Advertisement No. 03/2022/Rectt. Cell/Pers./DDA dated 11.06.2022 issued by the Respondent for the post of Joint Engineer (Civil), Joint Engineer (Electrical), Joint Engineer (Mechanical) in the Respondent.

4. Vide advertisement dated 11.06.2022, the respondent has invited applications for various posts which include Junior Engineer (Civil), Junior Engineer (Electrical/Mechanical). The qualifications for the post of Junior Engineer (JE) is mentioned as "Diploma in

117

Civil/Electrical/Mechanical Engineering from a recognized institution or equivalent"; however, there is a note placed below the table detailing posts and qualifications etc. which reads as under :

*For the post of Junior Engineer (Civil) [Post Code-2] & Junior Engineer (Elect./Mech.) [Post Code - 03]: Only those candidates who are in possession of the Diploma in Civil Engineering/Diploma in Elect./Mech. Engineering or equivalent qualification are eligible to apply for the post of Junior Engineer (Civil) or Junior Engineer (Elect./Mech.). The candidates who are in possession of Degree in Civil Engineering or Degree in Elect./Mech. Engineering cannot apply for the post since, the same has not been considered as equivalent qualification to Diploma. However, if a candidate has first obtained diploma in the respective trade and subsequently obtained the Degree in the respective trade are eligible to apply on the basis of Diploma qualification."

This effectively disqualifies such candidates as have directly obtained the Degree in Engineering instead of first obtaining a Diploma.

5. By way of an interim order dated 13.07.2022, the applicants were permitted to appear in the selection examination provisionally, making it clear that such participation by way of the interim direction shall not confer any right upon them for selection, and further directing that the result of the selection examination with

118

respect to the applicants shall not be declared without the leave of this Tribunal.

6. Learned counsel for the applicants argues that the impugned note/condition set forth in the advertisement which seeks to exclude candidates possessing Degree in Engineering, is contrary to the recruitment rules governing recruitment to the post of Junior Engineer. Nowhere in the rules is contained any provision which either directly or obliquely excludes the degree holders. She argues that statutory rules cannot be amended or interpreted by way of an executive direction in contravention to the specific provisions set forth therein. She further argues that the rules have to be studied and appreciated in the context of rules governing appointment to other posts in the hierarchy, especially the promotional posts. In the present case, the recruitment rules for the post of Assistant Engineer (AE) are quite relevant, she argues. They provide for filling up of 75% of the vacancies of AE by way of promotion from JE, and 50% of these 75% which comes to 37.5% are to be filled up from amongst those JEs who possess a Degree in Engineering with 3 years of service and the rest 50% of these 75%, again

119

37.5% will be filled up from Diploma holders with 8 years of service in the grade.

7. She points out that if the present recruitment were allowed to take place in accordance with the conditions set forth in the advertisement, it would seriously jeopardize the availability of Junior Engineers to the post of Assistant Engineer. The fact that half of the promotional quota has been reserved for degree holders and with lesser number of years as experience required as compared to diploma holders, the intent of the rules was very clear that preferential treatment is to be accorded to degree holders for promotion from JE to AE. However, the condition of exclusion of Degree Engineers in the present advertisement effectively overturns this well established Principle of Service Jurisprudence. The authority framing the rules had consciously appreciated that possession of a higher degree amounts to higher merit and thus deserved preference and this is borne out from the recruitment rules for the post of AE.

8. She goes on to argue that possession of a higher qualification presupposes a lower qualification and finds further support to her argument from the judgment rendered by the Hon"ble Supreme Court in State of

120

Uttarakhand and Ors. vs. Deep Chandra Tewari and Anr. Civil Appeal No. 9902/2013.

9. Learned counsel also extensively quotes from the judgment of the Hon"ble Supreme Court in Puneet Sharma and Ors. Vs. Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Ltd. & Anr. 2021 SCC Online SC 291. In the said case also, the post of AE which was next in the hierarchy of promotion, provided for a quota for those JEs who possess a Degree in Engineering. However, there too, the condition to exclude the degree holders for recruitment to the post of JE was imposed. The Hon"ble Supreme Court had categorically held that the fact that a separate quota was kept for degree holders amongst Junior Engineers clearly showed the intent of rule makers not to exclude the degree holders for consideration for the lower post of JE. Accordingly, the Court had upheld the candidature of the degree holders.

10. Learned counsel for the respondent on the other hand argues that the recruitment rules require a careful reading and such a reading would indicate that the respondent by virtue of the impugned note/condition, have merely interpreted the rules in letter and spirit. He submits that the recruitment rules as notified on

121

02.05.2018 stipulate Diploma in relevant discipline of Engineering as the only qualification. He specifically argues that consciously the rule makers have not chosen to either prescribe a minimum qualification or prescribe an equivalent qualification. The word equivalent used in the rules and also referred to in the advertisement dated 11.06.2022 refers to the equivalence of the institution and not the qualifications. Therefore, according to the learned counsel, the condition set forth which is under challenge in the advertisement, is not inconsistent with the recruitment rules. He reiterates that as per these rules, Diploma in Engineering is the only qualification, hence, the candidates who do not possess this qualification are not eligible. He further submits that there could be no other interpretation; and if candidates not possessing the diploma were allowed to hold the position of JE, the entire exercise of the framing of recruitment rules would be rendered futile.

11. Continuing the arguments, he submits that the rules have been framed by the Central Government through the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs in the exercise of powers conferred under clause (d) of sub- section (2) of section 56 of the Delhi Development Act,

122

1957, therefore, the Union of India through the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs should have been a necessary party in the present proceedings.

12. He also draws attention to file notings wherein the issue of eligibility of degree holders has been considered and points out that Member (Engineering), the highest authority in the engineering cadre has clearly recorded on file that the Recruitment Rules cannot be held to be restrictive as Graduation in Engineering is not the prescribed educational qualification for the post of JE. Quoting extensively from the said note of the Member (Engineering), learned counsel argues that this note is a clear indication that the matter has been carefully considered and decided. For the sake of clarity, the said note is reproduced below :

"Graduation in engineering is not the prescribed educational qualification for the post of JE. Diploma in engineering and degree in engineering are not equivalent. Prescription of degree in engineering has led to anomalies in pay structure which has attracted avoidable litigation in the past. For a post which required diploma in engineering, if opened to degree in engineering eering holders will certainly reduce the intake of diploma engineers. The assertion that the provisions of RRs are restrictive is myopic as the two are not comparable. Allowing degree in engineering as eligibility criterion shall entail under employment on one hand and higher pay

123

scale for the post on the other hand which can be attained at a lower one with diploma as eligibility criterion. Let us carry the RRs forward."

13. Learned counsel draws attention to the judgment rendered by the Hon"ble Supreme Court in Chief Manager, Punjab National Bank and Another vs. Anil Kumar Das Civil Appeal No. 3602/2022, wherein it was held that the eligibility is to be determined strictly in accordance with what has been laid down in the relevant rules. He also finds support in the judgment rendered by the Hon"ble High Court of Bombay in case titled Sangram vs. State of Maharashtra Writ Petition No. 2908/2016, wherein the Court in a similar controversy had held that the candidates who were degree holders could not be presumed to be possessing the lower qualification of Diploma.

14. He goes on to discuss that the issue of a higher degree presupposing the possession of a lower degree was considered by the Hon"ble supreme Court in State of Punjab Vs. Anita (2015) 2 SCC 170 which held that it has to be seen whether the recruitment rules have a specific provision for appointment of persons with a higher qualification. Since there is no such provision in the rules

124

governing recruitment to the post of Junior Engineers, the Degree in Engineering cannot be held to include or presuppose the Diploma, he argues. Moreover, the rules do not provide for any equivalent or higher qualification.

15. The learned counsel informs that the anomaly as pointed out by the learned counsel for the applicant which may arise for promotion to the post of AE is being corrected by the respondent and the required amendment to the recruitment rules of the post of AE is already being processed.

16. Moreover, pointing out to the documents placed on record which indicate that there is a window of lateral entry available to degree holders for the post of Assistant Executive Engineer, he claims that the applicants cannot state that the DDA has shut the doors upon degree holders for direct recruitment.

17. Learned counsel contesting the arguments of learned counsel for the applicants points out that the judgment of Puneet Sharma (supra) case relied upon by the learned counsel for the applicant, would not be relevant in the instant case as the factual premise in the Puneet Sharma case was entirely different. He draws

125

attention to para 8 of his counter affidavit wherein he has given in tabular form the factual differences in the two cases. He particularly reiterates that whereas the recruitment rules for the post of JE in Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board (HPSEB) mentioned a minimum qualification, there is no mention of such a minimum qualification in DDA"s Recruitment Rules. He further points out that HPSEB had initially allowed the degree holders to participate in the selection process, however, the DDA at the outset has clarified that only Diploma holders are allowed to apply for the post of Junior Engineer.

18. He reiterates that DDA has already initiated the process of amendment of Recruitment Rules for the post of AE by providing for filling up of 100% vacancies by promotion from amongst JE"s, irrespective whether the candidate is a Diploma holder or a Degree holder. He clarifies that even in the present condition/note which is impugned, there is no blanket/bar on degree holders; the condition merely states that a degree holder is eligible provided he has obtained Diploma also in the respective trade.

126

19. Learned counsel concluding his arguments submits that the scope for judicial review is limited in the matters of framing the Recruitment Rules which is the exclusive prerogative of the executive, and hence this Tribunal should not be interfering in the same. He submits that there is no challenge to the rules in the instant O.A. and what is impugned is an interpretation of the rules; this interpretation is strictly in terms of what is stated in the rules and what the apparent meaning is. Therefore, there is no scope for any intervention whatsoever by this Tribunal or for interpreting it in a manner which is neither the intent of the rule makers nor stated expressly anywhere in the rules.

20. We have given careful consideration to the arguments put forth by the learned counsel for the parties as also to the voluminous documents on record.

21. Although both the counsel have led extensive arguments, we are consciously referring to and opining about the ones directly related to the issue at stake which in our view, is a limited one i.e. whether the higher qualification is to be considered a disqualification for appointment to a post which carries as an essential qualification, a lower degree. The post in question here is

127

Junior Engineer and the Recruitment Rules mention the educational qualification as Diploma in the relevant field of engineering.

22. We agree with the interpretation explained by the learned counsel for the respondent to the term „equivalent"

that the equivalence mentioned in the Recruitment Rules refers to the equivalence of institution rather than the degree. The learned counsel for the respondent is correct in pointing out that the essential qualification is only Diploma in the relevant field of engineering and not any other equivalent or higher degree, and substantiated his argument by reiterating that the intention of the makers of the rules gets demonstrated effectively since they have not mentioned any other qualification either for an equivalence or for according any preference. Accordingly, if one were to go with the very strict and narrow interpretation, the person to be eligible for appointment to the post of JE should essentially possess a Diploma in Engineering. However, we also note and as has been highlighted by the learned counsel for the applicants that while there may not be any mention of an equivalent or higher degree as a qualification for holding the post of JE, there is also no express disqualification. The relevant

128

rules in Rule 4 deal with the disqualifications and the list of incidences which amount to disqualification, does not include a higher degree. Moreover, we find it hard to digest that a higher qualification should act as a disqualification instead of being an incentive. The language of the impugned note in the vacancy advertisement which has been quoted in para 3 of this order, is also rather curious; while denying the opportunity to degree holders to apply for the post, it also allows such degree holders to apply as have first obtained Diploma in the respective trade. This is rather convoluted, as also absurd.

23. Moreover, the respondent has admitted that by their denial to the degree holders to seek appointment as JE, there would be an anomaly created when it comes to appointment to the higher post of Assistant Engineer, since half of the promotion quota posts are reserved for degree holders. The statement that the respondent may have commenced the exercise for amendment to the Recruitment Rules, does not come to their rescue in view of the clear admission of the anomaly having arisen. Moreover, even though a window may be available to the degree holders for appointment to the post of Assistant

129

Executive Engineer, we cannot fail to notice that the number of posts of Assistant Executive Engineer are minuscule which would deprive a very large numbers a fair opportunity for such an appointment.

24. No doubt, we recognize our limitation when it comes to the issue of framing of rules, however, we need to interpret the rules in a manner which is rational, equitable and adheres to the principles of justice and fairness. Depriving a person possessing a higher technical qualification can certainly not to be called fairness. Rules also do not provide for such a disqualification.

25. If the rules are silent on this issue, as they are in the instant case, we have to interpret them in the larger public interest and in accordance with the Principles of Rule of Law. While making such a consideration, we are not inclined to accept the argument that the essential qualifications as set forth in the rules unambiguously reflect the intent of the makers of the rules. If we allow the interpretation given to the rules by the respondent, we shall, infact, be discouraging young persons from attaining higher education and higher qualifications. The justification given in the relevant file by the Member (Engineering), as quoted in para 13 of this order, is

130

unreasonable, to say the least. The post of the JE being a technical post required a technical qualification. If it were a case of recruitment for an unskilled job, we may have been inclined to accept such a reasoning. How could a higher qualification be made into a disqualification for an enginner"s position ?

26. The purpose of the Recruitment Rules is to set out the qualifications and conditions for recruitment to a post in government and ensure that the recruitment/ selection, is made in a transparent manner. The purpose of recruitment rules is certainly not to watch the interests of a particular section vis a vis others. The justification given that allowing engineering graduates to apply for the post of JE would reduce the intake of diploma engineers and thus, the degree holders should be disqualified, goes beyond the purpose and scope of the rules. Moreover, the concerned officer has given under employment and higher pay scale for the post that allowing engineering graduates would entail as one of the reasons. We cannot fathom this argument.

27. Moreover, the said recording of the Member (Engineering) gives a clear indication that the authorities are pressing for lower qualifications whereas they should

131

actually be encouraging merit. Further, the fact that the promotional quota of the post of AE requires 50% of the posts to be filled up from amongst the degree holders, adequately establishes that there would be a desirability of having adequate number of degree holders at the level of JE. Even though a large number of judgments may have been quoted by the respective learned counsel, the case of Puneet Sharma (supra) adequately covers the instant matter and does not gives us much scope to take any divergent view, nor are we otherwise inclined to.

28. In the light of the facts and discussion detailed above, we have no hesitation in allowing the present original application. The note titled "*For the post of Junior Engineer (Civil) [Post Code-2] & Junior Engineer (Elect./Mech.) [Post Code - 03]:" marked at page 75 of the O.A., and as reproduced in Para 3 of this order, is quashed as being in contravention to the provision of the Recruitment Rules. Holders of degree in engineering are declared qualified and eligible for recruitment to the post of JE, irrespective of the fact whether they also possess a Diploma in relevant field or not. The respondent is accordingly directed to allow them to participate, without any impediment, in the selection

132

process set in motion pursuant to the above referred to advertisement as also any other future selection process that may be initiated for the post of JE. The result with respect to the applicants who may have appeared in the selection examination in compliance of the interim direction given in this O.A. shall be declared and if they have been successful, they shall be offered appointment to the post of Junior Engineer if they meet all other criteria set forth in the relevant rules.

29. The original application stands allowed in the light of these directions. Associated M.A.(s), if any, stand disposed of accordingly.

30. A copy of this order be placed in the file of all the connected O.A(s).

There shall be no orders as to costs.

(Tarun Shridhar) (R.N. Singh) Member (A) Member (J)

/NISHA/

SHUBHAM CHANDRA TRIPATHI v. DELHI DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY (DDA)

O.A./1741/2022

Factual and Procedural Background

Legal Issues Presented

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants' Arguments

Respondent's Arguments

Table of Precedents Cited

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Holding and Implications