- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
RAJEEV MOHAN v. Chief Commissioner of Income Tax (CCA) , Lucknow
केीय सूचना आयोग
Central Information Commission
बाबागगं नाथमाग, मुिनरका
Baba Gangnath Marg, Munirka
नईद ली, New Delhi - 110067
File No : CIC/CCITL/A/2020/692976 Rajeev Mohan .…..अपीलकता/ Appellant
VERSUS
बनाम
CPIO,
O/o the Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax, RTI Cell, 5, Ashok Marg, Aayakar Bhawan, Lucknow-226001,
Uttar Pradesh …. ितवादीगण /Respondent
Date of Hearing : 07/12/2022 Date of Decision : 07/12/2022
INFORMATION COMMISSIONER : Saroj Punhani Relevant facts emerging from appeal:
RTI application filed on : 17/06/2020 CPIO replied on : Not on record First appeal filed on : 05/08/2020 First Appellate Authority's order : 21/08/2020 2nd Appeal/Complaint dated : 17/11/2020
Information sought:
1
The Appellant filed an RTI application dated 17.06.2020 seeking the following information:
"It is personally observed and noted by me with all proofs that officers commanding the O/o the my personal experience had been that these so called egoist and highly arrogant commanders do all kinds of corruption under the safe umbrella of Pr. CCIT's office. Exactly this kind of fraud, malfeasance and misfeasance was got proved single handedly by me when Apex Court had declared department's fraud in 2014. Mr. Neil Jain is posted as head quarters under your kind office in Lucknow and I am told that he allegedly had kept all public complaints against him in his safe custody only.
In this connection, I need the following information's immediately:-
1. Give me copy of complaint against Mr. Neil Jain, Addl. CIT allegedly lodged by Shri Nay Srivastava vide his letter dated 11.03.2020 which allegedly was got received in your office on dt. 10,03.2020.
2. Give me the copy of complaint against 'gala Jain, Addl. CIT allegedly lodged by Mr. Manindra Par Rastogi allegedly. Lucknow vide his complaint dated 04.09.2019 received on 15.09.2019.
3. Give me information about the current status of the complaints of the charges of corruption 'edged against the officers by the public.
4. Give me information about his current additional posting (i.e. on the date of this Mt)."
Having not received any response from the CPIO, the appellant filed a First Appeal dated 05.08.2020. FAA's order dated 21.08.2020 held as under:-
"…………The DOPT vide its 0M No. 11/2/2013-IR(Pt.) dated 14.08.2013, circulated the CIC decision in the case of Shri Manoj Arya vs CPIO, Cabinet Secretariat (CIC/SM/A/2013/000058) dated 26.06.2013 in which it was held that the complaints made against an Officer of the Government and any possible action the authorities might have taken on those complaints qualifies as personal information within the meaning of provision of section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act, 2005. It is pertinent to mention here that the CIC while deciding the above mentioned case has cited the decision of Supreme Court of India in the matter Girish Ramchandra Deshpande Vs CIC. In this case itself, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held the following :
"The performance of an employee/ Officer in an Organisation is primarily a matter between the employee and the employer and normally those aspects are governed by the service rules
2
which fall under the expression 'personal information', the disclosure of which has no relationship to any public activity or public interest. On the other hand, the disclosure of which could cause unwarranted invasion of the privacy of that individual"
6. In view of the above, the undersigned is of the considered opinion that the entire information sought by the petitioner is about the complaints against the Officers and its status which falls under the purview of personal information and no public interest is involved at large. The disclosure of the information may also result in invasion of the privacy of the concerned Officer.
Therefore, it is held that CPIO rightly denied the information to the petitioner and the information sought is exempt from disclosure within the meaning of provision of section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act, 2005 since it is in within the ambit of personal information. Hence, the appeal is hereby rejected.
7. Furthermore, the RTI is available to citizens of the country. In the instant case, the applicant has sought information in his capacity as an officer of the Department. It would have been still acceptable, had the information sought been related to his own matters. However, in the instant case, the officer has sought the third party information, that too of a confidential nature. It is a normal office procedure that complaints are dealt as "Confidential Communication". An officer is duty bound under conduct rules to not to try to access to confidential information which he is not authorised to access. Rule 11 of Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964 explicitly bans communication of unauthorised information. OM No. 25/54/53-Ests of Ministry of Home Affairs states that "a Government servant may not communicate directly or indirectly to other Government servants or to non-official persons or to the press any documents or information which may have come into his possession in the course of his public duties. Retention of such documents or information by a Government servant in his personal custody for use in furtherance of his personal interest, e.g. in making representation to the authorities concerned, is not only objectionable but also constitutes an offence under Section 5 of the Official Secrets Act, 1923. A person contravening the provisions of the above Act renders himself liable to prosecution. Contravention of the provisions of the Act and of the Conduct Rules can also be dealt with departmentally under the relevant Discipline Rules, and may well justify the
3
imposition of a suitable penalty with reference to the facts and circumstances of each case."
On perusal of the records, it has been noticed that the applicant officer has apparently obtained access to the copies of complaints as he enclosed the first pages of the complaints along with his RTI application. The communication of such documents and its retention by unauthorised persons is not only improper but also involves contravention of Rule 11 of CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964. As such in this case, the applicant cannot claim a "right" while ignoring his "duties" under the extant rules. As such, I find that the information has been rightly denied by the CPIO." Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied, the appellant approached the Commission with the instant Second Appeal.
Relevant Facts emerging during Hearing:
The following were present:-
Appellant: Not present.
Respondent: Anviksha Sharma, DCIT (HQ) & CPIO present through video conference.
The CPIO reiterated the denial of the information under Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act.
Decision:
The Commission based on a perusal of the facts on record observes that the information sought for in the RTI Application relates to complaints filed by and against third parties and the denial of the same under Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act is completely appropriate.
In this regard, the attention of the Appellant is further drawn towards a judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of Central Public Information Officer, Supreme Court of India Vs. Subhash Chandra Agarwal in Civil Appeal No. 10044 of 2010 with Civil Appeal No. 10045 of 2010 and Civil Appeal No. 2683 of 2010
wherein the import of "personal information" envisaged under Section 8(1)(j) of RTI Act has been exemplified in the context of earlier ratios laid down by the same Court in the matter(s) of Canara Bank Vs. C.S. Shyam in Civil Appeal No.22 of 2009; Girish Ramchandra Deshpande vs. Central Information Commissioner &
4
Ors., (2013) 1 SCC 212 and R.K. Jain vs. Union of India & Anr., (2013) 14 SCC 794.
The following was thus held:
"59. Reading of the aforesaid judicial precedents, in our opinion, would indicate that personal records, including name, address, physical, mental and psychological status, marks obtained, grades and answer sheets, are all treated as personal information. Similarly, professional records, including qualification, performance, evaluation reports, ACRs, disciplinary proceedings, etc. are all personal information. Medical records, treatment, choice of medicine, list of hospitals and doctors visited, findings recorded, including that of the family members, information relating to assets, liabilities, income tax returns, details of investments, lending and borrowing, etc. are personal information. Such personal information is entitled to protection from unwarranted invasion of privacy and conditional access is available when stipulation of larger public interest is satisfied. This list is indicative and not exhaustive…" Emphasis Supplied Having observed as above, no action is warranted in the matter.
The appeal is disposed of accordingly. Saroj Punhani (सरोज पुुुुनहािन)
Information Commissioner (सूूचूू ना आयुुुु ) Authenticated true copy
(अिभ मािणत स#यािपत ित)
(C.A. Joseph)
Dy. Registrar
011-26179548/ ca.joseph@nic.in
सी. ए. जोसफे, उप-पंजीयक
दनांक /
5
Alert