- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
RAVI VISHWANATH GHUMRE v. THE DIVISIONAL JOINT...
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, Ravi Vishwanath Ghumre, is the legal heir of Vishwanath Ghumre, a founder member of the Siddharth Purpidit Magas Vargiya Griha Nirman Co-operative Society (Respondent No.3), registered under the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 (MCS Act). After the death of Vishwanath Ghumre in 2013, the petitioner applied to the Deputy Registrar (Respondent No.2) for admission as a member of the society in place of his deceased father, submitting a death certificate and certificate of heirship. The Deputy Registrar directed the society to consider the application and subsequently, on 19.10.2016, passed an order under Section 23 of the MCS Act allowing the petitioner’s appeal and directing the society to admit him as a member.
Subsequently, the petitioner filed a dispute before the Cooperative Court challenging the legality of the society’s election held on 27.8.2017. The society contested the petitioner’s membership status, but the Cooperative Court upheld the petitioner’s membership based on the earlier order of 19.10.2016. The society then filed a revision application (No.50/2018) before the Divisional Joint Registrar (Respondent No.1), alleging that the order dated 19.10.2016 was obtained by fraud. The Divisional Joint Registrar quashed the Deputy Registrar’s order and remanded the matter for fresh consideration on the ground that no notice was given to the society during the original proceeding under Section 23 of the MCS Act. The petitioner challenged this order by filing the present writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Divisional Joint Registrar had jurisdiction under Section 154 of the MCS Act to entertain the revision application challenging the order passed by the Deputy Registrar under Section 23 of the MCS Act, given that the Deputy Registrar acts as a delegatee of the Registrar.
- Whether the order passed by the Deputy Registrar on 19.10.2016 can be quashed and remanded on the ground of non-service of notice to the society.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner’s Arguments
- The order passed by the Deputy Registrar under Section 23 of the MCS Act should be treated as an order passed by the Registrar, since the Deputy Registrar acts as a delegatee of the Registrar.
- Because the order is effectively that of the Registrar, the Divisional Joint Registrar, being subordinate to the Registrar, had no jurisdiction to entertain the revision application under Section 154 of the MCS Act.
- The revision filed by the society was therefore not maintainable and the impugned order quashing the Deputy Registrar’s order should be set aside.
- Relied on the judgment of this Court in Bajarang Labour Co-operative Society, Mahagaon (2016 (2) Mh.L.J. 849) to support the contention on jurisdiction.
Respondents’ Arguments
- The Divisional Joint Registrar (Respondent No.1) took into account that the Deputy Registrar’s order was passed ex parte without hearing the society (Respondent No.3), which prejudiced the society’s rights.
- The remand for fresh consideration was justified to ensure fair hearing and no prejudice was caused to the petitioner by this remand.
- The society supported the order of the Divisional Joint Registrar, asserting that no notice was issued to it during the original proceeding, justifying the revision and remand.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bajarang Labour Co-operative Society, Mahagaon, 2016 (2) Mh.L.J. 849 | Held that orders passed by the District Deputy Registrar under Section 23 (1-A) of the MCS Act are orders of the Registrar; hence, the Divisional Joint Registrar has no jurisdiction to entertain revision against such orders. | The Court applied this precedent to determine that the Divisional Joint Registrar lacked jurisdiction to entertain the revision application filed by the society and accordingly quashed the impugned order. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the statutory delegation of powers by the State Government under Section 158 of the MCS Act, whereby the District Deputy Registrar is empowered to act as a delegatee of the Registrar. As such, orders passed by the District Deputy Registrar under Section 23 (1-A) of the MCS Act are effectively orders of the Registrar himself. The Court noted the Notification dated 11.9.2012 confirming this delegation.
Relying on the precedent in Bajarang Labour Co-operative Society, the Court held that the Divisional Joint Registrar, being subordinate to the Registrar, does not have jurisdiction to entertain revisions challenging orders passed by the District Deputy Registrar acting as the Registrar’s delegatee under Section 23 (1-A). Therefore, the revision application filed by the society before the Divisional Joint Registrar was not maintainable.
Consequently, the impugned order quashing the Deputy Registrar’s order and remanding the matter back was without jurisdiction and unsustainable. The Court, however, granted liberty to the society to challenge the Deputy Registrar’s order before an appropriate forum in accordance with law, clarifying that it had not expressed any opinion on the merits of the case.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition is allowed by quashing and setting aside the impugned order passed by the Divisional Joint Registrar.
The Court’s decision directly reinstates the validity of the Deputy Registrar’s order dated 19.10.2016 admitting the petitioner as a member of the society, by holding that the Divisional Joint Registrar lacked jurisdiction to entertain the revision. The society is granted liberty to pursue its challenge through appropriate legal channels. No new precedent is established beyond the application of existing law on jurisdiction under the MCS Act.
1 WP 1234.19.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR
WRIT PETITION NO.1234 OF 2019
Ravi Vishwanath Ghumre, Aged 39 years, Occupation:Labourer, residing at Sidharth Wadi, Washim Bye-pass Road, Akola, Taluqa and District-Akola. .. Petitioner (Original Applicant)
.. Versus ..
1] The Divisional Joint Registrar, Maharashtra Co-operative Society, Amravati having its office at Amravati.
2] The Deputy Registrar, Maharashtra Co-operative Society, Akola, having its office at Gangadhar Plot, Station Road, Akola.
3] Siddharth Purpidit Magas Vargiya Griha Nirman, Co-operative Society bearing registration No.1054 through its Secretary Shatrughna Shankar Munde, having address at Sidharth Wadi, Washim Bye-pass Road, Akola,
Taluqa and District-Akola. .. Respondents
(Ori. Non-applicants)
……….
Shri Rahul D. Dhande, Advocate for the petitioner, Ms M.H. Deshmukh, AGP for respondent nos.1 and 2, Shri D.S. Patil, Advocate for respondent no.3. ……….
1
CORAM : N.B. SURYAWANSHI, J.
RESERVED ON : 26.07.2021.
PRONOUNCED ON : 26.08.2021.
JUDGMENT
1. Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Heard finally with the consent of the parties.
2. This petition filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India takes exception to the order dated 28.11.2018 (Annexure-S) passed by the Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Amravati (R-1) in Revision Application No.50/2018, whereby the order dated 19.10.2016 (Annexure-I) passed by the Deputy Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Akola (R-2), was quashed and set aside and the matter was remanded back to the said authority for fresh consideration.
3. The petitioner is the legal heir of one Vishwanath Ghumre, who was one of the founder member of respondent no.3- Siddharth Purpidit Magas Vargiya Griha Nirman Co-operative Society, duly registered under the provisions of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 (for short 'MCS Act'). The primary object of the said society is to obtain loans on behalf of its members and construct houses for them. Vishwanath Ghumare, the father of the petitioner, expired on 29.6.2013. After the death of Vishwanath, the petitioner,
2
being the legal heir, made an application to respondent no.2 for admission to the membership of the said society in place of his father. Along with application, the petitioner submitted copy of death certificate and certificate of heirship issued by Civil Judge, Junior Division, Akola. On 15.5.2014, the respondent no.2 issued a letter to the society directing them to consider the application of the petitioner for admission of the membership of the society. On 16.7.2016, the petitioner filed an application under Section 23 r/w Section 30 of the MCS Act before the respondent no.2. It is the case of the petitioner that the Deputy Registrar (R-2) called upon the society to appear before it. The petitioner further contends that on 19.10.2016, the respondent no.2 passed an order allowing the appeal of the petitioner under Section 23 of the MCS Act and directed the society to accept the name of the petitioner as a member of the society.
4. On 27.9.2017, the petitioner filed Dispute No.177/2017 before the Cooperative Court, Akola against the ten members of the society, Deputy Registrar and Election Officer, seeking directions to hold and declare that the election of the society allegedly held on 27.8.2017 as illegal and arbitrary, also seeking further direction to hold fresh elections. In the said proceeding, an application was filed to reject the dispute on the ground that the petitioner was not a
3
member of the society, the same was rejected by the Cooperative Court, vide order dated 5.2.2018 holding that on 19.10.2016, the respondent had confirmed the membership of the petitioner and the said order was not challenged. The society thereafter approached the Divisional Joint Registrar claiming that the order passed in favour of the petitioner in the proceeding under Section 23 of the MCS Act was obtained by fraud. The Divisional Joint Registrar therefore directed an enquiry through Deputy Registrar. The District Deputy Registrar called upon the petitioner to produce the documents in respect of the proceeding under Section 23 of the MCS Act. During the pendency of the said proceeding, the respondent-society preferred a Revision Application No.50/2018 before the Divisional Joint Registrar under Section 154 of the MCS Act challenging the order passed by the Deputy Registrar on 19.10.2016 along with the said application. The petitioner, by filing say, opposed the revision. According to the petitioner, the same was filed belatedly. According to the petitioner, in the said revision a report dated 30.8.2018 was filed by the Deputy Registrar stating that the petitioner had duly made an application under Section 23 of the MCS Act and vide order dated 19.10.2016, the direction was given to the society to accept the name of the petitioner as a member and hence the petitioner is a member of the said society. However, by the impugned order, the respondent-Divisional Joint Registrar quashed the order passed by
4
the Deputy Registrar dated 19.10.2016 and remanded the matter back to the Deputy Registrar on the ground that no notice was given to the society in the proceeding under Section 23 of the MCS Act. This order is impugned in the present petition.
5. Heard the learned Advocate for the petitioner, the learned Assistant Government Pleader for respondent nos.1 and 2 and the learned Advocate for the respondent no.3.
6. The learned Advocate for the petitioner submitted that the order passed by the Deputy Registrar under Section 23 of the MCS Act has to be considered as order passed by the Registrar, since the District Deputy Registrar acts as a delegatee of the Registrar. As that order is passed by the Registrar, it cannot be challenged under Section 154 of the MCS Act before the Divisional Joint Registrar, who is subordinate to the Registrar. The Divisional Joint Registrar had no jurisdiction to entertain the revision filed by the respondent before him. In support of this submission, he relied upon the judgment of this court in Bajarang Labour Co-operative Society, Mahagaon
(Z) .vs. Divisional Joint Registrar of Cooperative Societies, Nagpur and others, 2016 (2) Mh.L.J. 849.
7. On the other hand, the learned Assistant Government Pleader for respondent nos.1 and 2, by relying upon affidavit-in-reply
5
filed by respondent no.1, submitted that the respondent no.1 had taken into consideration the fact that an exparte order was passed by the respondent no.2, without hearing the respondent no.3-Society. No prejudice is caused to the petitioner and the matter is only remanded back for fresh consideration on merits. The reasoned order is passed by the respondent no.1 and no interference is warranted in that order.
8. The learned Advocate for the respondent no.3 supported the order passed by the respondent no.1 and contended that the order impugned in the revision was passed without giving an opportunity of hearing to the respondent no.3. No notices were issued to the respondent no.3 and hence the respondent no.1 was justified in allowing the revision and remanding the matter back. According to him, no prejudice is caused to the petitioner by remanding the matter back.
9. The order passed under Section 23 of the MCS Act in favour of the petitioner was challenged by the respondent no.3 by filing revision under Section 154 of the MCS Act before the respondent no.1. The State Government has delegated powers of Registrar to the District Deputy Registrar under Section 158 of the MCS Act. Therefore, the orders passed by the District Deputy Registrar under Section 23 (1-A) of the MCS Act are, in fact, the
6
orders passed by the Registrar. Admittedly, the State Government has issued a Notification dated 11.9.2012 thereby delegating powers of the Registrar to the District Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Nagpur City (2) and to the Divisional Joint Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Nagpur City. It is therefore clear that the orders of the District Deputy Registrar under Section 23 (1-A) of the MCS Act are, in fact, the orders of the Registrar. In Bajrang Labour Co-operative Society, Mahagaon (supra), this Court has held that the Divisional Joint Registrar can exercise revisional jurisdiction to examine legality of order passed by District Deputy Registrar or any officer subordinate to Divisional Joint Registrar as a delegatee of Registrar and the Divisional Joint Registrar had no jurisdiction to entertain and decide the revision challenging the orders passed by the District Deputy Registrar under Section 23 (1-A) of the MCS Act. The said ratio is squarely applicable to the facts of the present case.
10. The revision therefore filed by the respondent no.3 before the respondent no.1 under Section 154 of the MCS Act was not maintainable and the impugned order passed by the respondent no.1 is therefore without jurisdiction and cannot be sustained and the same is hereby quashed and set aside.
11. In the peculiar facts of the present case, liberty is granted to the respondent no.3 to challenge the said order before appropriate
7
forum in accordance with law. It is made clear that this Court has not expressed any opinion on merits of the case. All contentions of the respective parties are kept open. Rule in the above terms. No costs.
(N.B. Suryawanshi, J.)
Gulande
8
Alert