- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
HABIBUR RAHAMAN v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL
Structured Summary of Judicial Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal (C.R.A. 277 of 2016) arises from conviction and sentences imposed by the Additional Sessions Judge, 4th Court, Malda, by judgments dated 30th and 31st March 2016 in Sessions Case No. 216 of 2015 (Sessions Trial Case No. 55(5) of 2015) arising out of Baisnabnagar P.S. Case No. 435 of 2014 dated 05.11.2014. The appellant is Habibur Rahaman; the respondent is the State of West Bengal. The appellant was convicted under Sections 489B and 489C IPC and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment (terms described in the trial court orders) and fined; the sentences were ordered to run concurrently.
Material factual allegations made in the prosecution case are: on 4 November 2014 Md. Shakur (P.W.1), SI of BSF at Baisnabnagar, received secret information that two persons were travelling from Malda to NTPC with fake Indian currency notes (FICNs). A raid was conducted at "Township More" (variously described by witnesses) and two persons (the appellant and his nephew Nasiruddin Sheikh, the latter a juvenile) were apprehended. From the appellant eight bundles of notes in denomination of Rs.1,000/- (each bundle said to contain 800 pieces) wrapped in a coffee-colour cloth bag were recovered and from the juvenile two bundles (denominations Rs.1,000 and Rs.500) were recovered. The seized notes were sent to Salboni Mint for examination; the report (Exhibit 3) found the notes counterfeit. A charge-sheet was filed against the appellant; the juvenile's case was sent to the Juvenile Justice Board. The appellant was tried in the regular court, pleaded not guilty, and the prosecution examined nine witnesses and produced documentary exhibits. The trial court convicted and sentenced the appellant; he appealed to the High Court.
The appeal was heard on multiple dates and judgment rendered on 24.02.2022 by a division bench comprising Joymalya Bagchi, J. and Bivas Pattanayak, J.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the prosecution proved the ingredients of the offences under Sections 489B (selling, buying, receiving or trafficking in counterfeit currency) and 489C IPC (possession of counterfeit currency with intent to use) against the appellant.
- Whether contradictions/variations in the testimony of official witnesses (place and time of search, descriptions of where accused were found) and non-support by independent witnesses affected the reliability of the prosecution case.
- Whether the charge as framed (specifically including "attempt to use/traffic") put the appellant on adequate notice to sustain conviction under Section 489B IPC, in light of precedents where lack of such a charge has affected convictions.
- Whether procedural safeguards (e.g., putting incriminating circumstances to accused under Section 313 CrPC) were complied with and whether any lapse vitiated conviction.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The prosecution case is "out and out false" and amounts to false implication.
- Independent witnesses did not support the prosecution and the official witnesses' versions vary among themselves (e.g., place described as "sitting in a tailor shop" vs "loitering at PTS More"; time of operation variously given as between 7 p.m. to 11 p.m. or starting at 8 p.m.).
- All incriminating circumstances were not put to the accused during his examination under Section 313 CrPC.
- There was no evidence of actual use of the currency notes, and therefore conviction under Section 489B (trafficking/use) is unfounded.
- Prayed for acquittal of the appellant.
State's Arguments
- Prosecution evidence established the ingredients of the offences: the appellant (with the juvenile) was apprehended carrying a large volume of FICNs in a public place and could not explain possession.
- The charge under Section 489B specifically accused the appellant of trafficking/transportation of counterfeit notes, so he was put on notice accordingly.
- Independent witnesses had been "won over" and turned hostile; variations in official witnesses' depositions were minor and did not go to the root of the case.
- Therefore, conviction under Sections 489B and 489C is justified.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Hoda Sk. vs. State of West Bengal, 2020 SCC OnLine Cal 1 478 | Principle that conviction under Section 489B cannot be sustained where the trial court did not frame a charge for trafficking (i.e., accused was not put on notice of trafficking). | The court distinguished Hoda Sk.: unlike that case, the present case contained a charge specifically alleging attempt to use/traffic counterfeit notes; therefore Hoda Sk. did not warrant interference with the present conviction under Section 489B. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the evidence and submissions in a step-by-step manner and reached conclusions based on contemporaneous documents and witness testimony:
- Place of occurrence and seizure list: The seizure list prepared at the spot described the place of seizure as "township area," approximately 1.6 km from BNHQ and 2.5 km from Baishnabnagar. A rough sketch map (prepared by P.W.9, the investigating officer) situates the occurrence at Township More with the western side noted as PTS side. The court treated P.W.7's reference to "PTS More" as a loose description reconcilable with the seizure list and the sketch map; the contemporaneous seizure list (signed at the spot) was not challenged and carried weight.
- Time and minor variations: Variations in testimony as to the time the raid commenced (P.W.1 said operation continued from 7 p.m. to 11 p.m.; P.W.5 said arrival at 8.10 p.m.) were deemed minor and not material, because witnesses agreed on key facts of search and seizure of FICNs from the appellant.
- Independent witnesses turned hostile: The court found that two independent witnesses (P.Ws.4 and 8) had been "won over" and gave parrot-like statements that they only signed the seizure list at the police station; their earlier statements to police contradicted their court testimony. The court applied settled law that if official witnesses are clear, convincing and inspire confidence, the hostility or non-support of independent witnesses who have been won over does not necessarily destroy the prosecution case.
- Chain of custody and expert report: The investigating officers (P.W.9 and P.W.8) established a chain of custody from seizure to examination at Salboni Mint. Exhibit 3 (the Salboni Mint report) was accepted as proving the seized notes were counterfeit.
- Ingredients of Section 489B/489C: The court found that when the appellant was apprehended in a public place carrying a large volume of FICNs and could not explain possession, an inference of knowingly trafficking/transporting counterfeit currency could be drawn. The charge-sheet and charge specifically alleged "attempt to use/traffic" counterfeit notes and gave the appellant notice of that accusation.
- Precedent distinguished: The court distinguished Hoda Sk. because in that precedent the trial court had not framed a charge for trafficking; in the present case the charge for trafficking had been specifically framed and served on the accused, so the rationale in Hoda Sk. did not apply here.
- Procedural points such as alleged deficiencies in Section 313 questioning were raised by the appellant but the court’s analysis focused on the strength and cogency of the official evidence, the contemporaneous seizure list, expert report, and chain of custody to sustain conviction.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: APPEAL DISMISSED; CONVICTION AND SENTENCE UPHELD.
Direct consequences imposed by the court:
- The conviction and sentence of the appellant under Sections 489B and 489C IPC as recorded by the trial court are affirmed.
- The period of detention already suffered by the appellant during investigation, enquiry and trial is to be set off from the substantive sentence in terms of Section 428 CrPC.
- The High Court directed that a copy of the judgment along with the lower court records be sent down to the trial court for compliance, and that an urgent certified photostat copy of the order, if applied for, be supplied after compliance with legal formalities.
The opinion does not discuss broader doctrinal or systemic implications beyond the case-specific determination. The court expressly distinguished an earlier decision (Hoda Sk.) rather than overruling it or purporting to lay down a new precedent; the decision therefore operates to uphold the trial court's findings on the facts and the correctness of the charge framing in this case.
Miscellaneous Case Details (as recorded in the opinion)
- Bench: Hon'ble Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Hon'ble Justice Bivas Pattanayak.
- Counsel for Appellant: Mr. Goutam Wilson, Mr. Ashok Kumar Jha, Ms. Moumita Mondal.
- Counsel for State: Mr. Angshuman Chakraborty.
- Hearing Dates: 07.01.2022, 27.01.2022, 04.02.2022, 16.02.2022 & 24.02.2022.
- Judgment Date: 24.02.2022.
Sl. No. 18
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon'ble Justice Joymalya Bagchi And
The Hon'ble Justice Bivas Pattanayak C.R.A. 277 of 2016
Habibur Rahaman
-Vs-
State of West Bengal
For the Appellant : Mr. Goutam Wilson, Adv. Mr. Ashok Kumar Jha, Adv.
Ms. Moumita Mondal, Adv.
For the State : Mr. Angshuman Chakraborty, Adv. Heard on : 07.01.2022, 27.01.2022, 04.02.2022, 16.02.2022 & 24.02.2022 Judgment on : 24.02.2022
Joymalya Bagchi, J. :-
The appellant has assailed the judgment and order dated 30thMarch, 2016 and 31stMarch, 2016 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, 4thCourt, Malda, in Sessions Case No. 216 of 2015 corresponding to Sessions Trial Case No. 55(5) of 2015 arising out of Baisnabnagar Police Station Case No. 435 of 2014 dated 05.11.2014 convicting the appellant for commission of offence punishable under Sections 489B/489C of the Indian Penal Code and sentencing him to suffer rigorous imprisonment for ten years
1
and to pay fine of Rs.5,000/-, in default, to suffer rigorous imprisonment for six months more for the offence punishable under Section 489B of the Indian Penal Code and to suffer rigorous imprisonment for seven years and to pay fine of Rs.5,000/-, in default, to suffer rigorous imprisonment for six months more for the offence punishable under Section 489C of the Indian Penal Code; both the sentences to run concurrently.
The prosecution case as alleged against the appellant is to the effect that on 4thNovember, 2014, Md. Shakur, S.I. of BSF at Baisnabnagar Police Station (P.W. 1) received secret information that two persons are going from Malda to NTPC with fake Indian currency notes. He along with others went to the local police station and with police force proceeded towards the Township More. At that spot, they found two persons sitting in a tailor shop. Upon search, eight bundles of currency notes suspected to be fake in denomination of Rs.1000/- (each bundle containing 800 pieces) valued at 8 lakhs wrapped in a coffee colour cloth bag was recovered from the appellant, Habibur Rahaman and two bundles of fake Indian currency notes in denomination of Rs.1,000/- and Rs. 500/- (one bundle containing 176 pieces and another containing 48 pieces respectively) valued at Rs. 2 lakhs was recovered from his nephew, Nasiruddin Sheikh, who was a juvenile at the time of occurrence. Other articles including genuine currency notes were also recovered. Suspected currency notes were seized under a seizure list and the aforesaid miscreants were arrested. P.W. 1 lodged written complaint at the police station resulting in registration of Baisnabnagar Police Station Case No. 435 of 2014 dated 05.11.2014 under Sections 489B/489C/120B of the Indian
2
Penal Code. Seized notes were sent for examination and upon receipt of the report from the expert (Exhibit 3) charge-sheet was filed against the appellant and the juvenile. Case of the juvenile was sent to the Juvenile Justice Board while the appellant was tried in regular court. Charges under Sections 489B/489C were framed against the appellant. He pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried. In the course of trial, prosecution examined nine witnesses and exhibited a number of documents. Defence of the appellant was one of innocence and false implication. In conclusion of trial, learned trial Judge by the impugned judgement and order dated 30thMarch, 2016 and 31stMarch, 2016 convicted and sentenced the appellant, as aforesaid. Mr. Wilson, learned Counsel appearing for the appellant submits that prosecution case is out and out false. Independent witnesses have not supported the case. On the other hand, version of official witnesses are at variance to one another. While in F.I.R. it was stated that appellants were standing near a tailor shop at Township More, P.W. 1 in court stated that they were sitting in the tailor shop. P.W. 7 stated that the accused persons were found loitering at PTS More. P.W. 1 claimed that the operation took place between 7 p.m. to 11 p.m. but P.W. 5 stated they reached the spot at 8 p.m. It is also submitted that all incriminating circumstances had not been put to the accused persons during their examination under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. It is also submitted that there is no evidence with regard to use of currency notes. Hence, conviction under Section 489B is unfounded. He prays for acquittal of the appellant.
3
On the other hand, Mr. Chakraborty, learned Counsel appearing for the State submits that the prosecution evidence has clearly established the ingredients of the alleged offences. Appellant along with juvenile was apprehended with a large volume of FICNs in public place. They could not give any explanation with regard to carrying such counterfeit notes. Hence, ingredients of the offence under Sections 489B and 489C have been proved. Charge under Section 489B was framed with regard to "trafficking in currency notes" and therefore the appellant was put on notice with regard to the accusation of transportation of fake Indian currency notes. Independent witnesses had been won over and, therefore, did not support the prosecution case. Variation in the deposition of the official witnesses are minor and do not go to the root of the prosecution case.
P.W. 1, Md. Shakur, is the informant and leader of the raiding party. He deposed in the evening at 6p.m. he received a secret information that two persons are going from Malda to NTPC and carrying fake currency notes. He along with Ajit and another constable at first went to local police station and then took police force from local police station and went to Township More. They found two persons were sitting in a tailor shop and they searched them. Upon search, they recovered counterfeit notes valued at Rs. 8 lakhs from the appellant and Rs. 2 lakhs from Nasiruddin Sheikh, who is the nephew of the appellant. Other articles were also recovered. Seizure list was prepared. Number of counterfeit notes were noted down in the seizure list. Accused persons were apprehended and were taken to the police station along with the seized articles. He prepared written complaint and lodged it at the local police
4
station. He identified the seized counterfeit notes in court as material Exhibits I and II.
P.Ws. 2, 3 and 5 are the constables attached to BSF at Baisnabnagar
16 Mile. They accompanied P.W. 1 to the raid. They have substantially corroborated the evidence of P.W. 1.
P.W. 7, Koushik Sarkar is an ASI attached to Malda PS. He deposed he along with constable Akhtar Hossain went to PTS More and was instructed to keep in touch with BSF personnel. After reaching there, he found two suspected persons loitering. BSF personnel apprehended them and recovered counterfeit currency notes to the tune of Rs. 10 lakhs. He stated that local persons signed on the seizure list. He identified the accused persons in Court. Mr. Wilson, learned lawyer appearing for the appellant argues that there are grave contradictions in the evidence of the official witnesses. P.W. 1 stated the accused persons were sitting in a tailor shop at township more where they were searched but P.W. 7 deposed they were found loitering near PTS More and were searched. It is also submitted there is variation with regard to time when the search operation commenced.
I have examined evidence of the witnesses in the light of the aforesaid submission. All the witnesses stated seizure list was prepared at the spot. They had also signed on the seizure list. In the seizure list place of seizure has been described as "township area" approximately 1.6 km from BNHQ and
2.5 km from Baishnabnagar. Investigating officer P.W. 9 has prepared rough sketch map of the place of occurrence wherefrom it appears that the place of
5
occurrence was at the Township More and western side of the Township More is noted as PTS side.
From the aforesaid materials on record it appears that the description of the place of occurrence by P.W. 7 as PTS More is a loose and casual one. Incident occurred at Township More which was noted in the seizure list contemporaneously prepared by P.W. 1. Contents of the seizure list have not been challenged. On the other hand, P.W. 1 and other witnesses have clearly proved the place of occurrence as Township More. Version of P.W. 7 with regard to place of occurrence is, therefore, to be assessed in the backdrop of other evidence on record. As appearing from the sketch map, western side of Township is described as PTS area, hence, P.W. 7 may have loosely described the place of occurrence as PTS More. Version of P.W. 7 with regard to place of occurrence is clearly reconciliable with regard with other evidence on record and does not affect the credibility of the prosecution case. P.W. 1 stated he received secret information with regard to two persons carrying counterfeit currency notes from Malda to NTPC at 6 p.m. and proceeded to work out the information. He went to the local police station and obtained police assistance. Then he proceeded to Township More and apprehended the accused persons. Entire operation continued from 7 p.m to 11p.m. But P.W. 5 claimed they conducted raid at 8.10 p.m. This minor variation with regard to time of commencement of raid is of little consequence when the witnesses are ad idem on the search and seizure of FICNs from the appellant. Thus, I am of the view the evidence of the official witnesses have proved the prosecution case.
6
It is contended independent witnesses P.Ws. 4 and 8 have not supported the case. Both of them appear to have been won over and stated in a parrot-like manner they had signed the seizure list in the police station. Falsehood in their deposition was clearly exposed when they were confronted with their earlier statements to the police. P.W. 7 categorically stated that the local witnesses had signed the seizure list at the place of occurrence. It is settled law if the evidence of the official witnesses are clear, convincing and inspire confidence, lack of support from the independent witnesses who have been won over and had turned hostile would not make a dent in the prosecution case. Hence, I am of the opinion, seizure of counterfeit notes suspected to be forged valued at Rs. 8 laks from the appellant and Rs. 2 lakh from the juvenile accused has been proved. P.Ws. 9 and 10 are the investigating officers of the case. PW 9 was the first investigating officer. He visited the place of occurrence and prepared rough sketch map with index Exhibit 5 and 5/1. He took steps to send the FICN at Salboni Mint for examination. Thereafter he handed over the case to IC Baisnabnagar P.S.
P.W. 8 collected the report from Salboni Mint and submitted charge sheet. Report from Salboni Mint has been proved as Exhibit 3. Evidence of the investigating officers clearly establish the chain of custody between the counterfeit currency notes which were seized from the possession of the appellant and those examined at Salboni Mint. Exhibit 3 proves the seized notes are counterfeit.
7
Lastly, it is argued ingredients of offence under section 489B IPC have not been proved. Prosecution evidence clearly shows that the appellant and the co-accused was apprehended in front of a tailor shop while carry counterfeit currency notes totaling to Rs 10 lakhs.
When the appellant was found carrying a large volume of FICNs in a public place and he is unable to give any explanation for the said possession, one can safely held the appellant was knowingly trafficking in counterfeit currency notes. Section 489B of the Indian Penal Code makes selling, buying, receiving or trafficking in counterfeit currency notes culpable. In this regard, it may be apposite to refer to the charge framed against the appellant under section 489B of the Indian Penal Code which reads as follows:-
"that you on 4.11.2014 at township More on NH 34, under Baisnabnagar PS Dist Malda attempted to use/traffic forged or counterfeit Indian currency notes of Rs. 9,76,000/- of denomination of Rs. 1,000/- each (976 pieces) and Rs. 24,000/- of denomination of Rs. 500/- each (48 pieces) and totaling Rs 10,00,000/- knowing the same to be counterfeit and as per seizure list dated 4.11.2014, a copy of which was served to you, knowing the same to be forged or counterfeit."
Plain reading of the aforesaid charge shows the prosecution had put the appellant on notice that he was being accused of "attempt to sell/trafficking"
in counterfeit notes. As discussed above, evidence on record unequivocally shows the appellant and co-accused were apprehended while carrying a large volume of counterfeit notes in a public place. Thus, transportation of counterfeit notes by the appellant is clearly established. Facts of the instant
8
case are clearly distinguishable from that in Hoda Sk. vs. State of West Bengal1. In that case, no charge for trafficking of counterfeit notes had been framed by the trial court and on such premise this court was of the view the conviction under section 489B IPC on the score of trafficking could not be upheld. On the other hand, in the present case appellant had been charged of trafficking in counterfeit currency notes. Thus, conviction of the appellant under section 489B IPC does not call for interference. In the light of the aforesaid discussion, conviction and sentence of the appellant is upheld.
Appeal is accordingly dismissed.
Period of detention suffered by the appellant during investigation, enquiry and trial shall be set off from the substantive sentence imposed upon the appellant in terms of Section 428 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Copy of the judgment along with Lower Court Records be sent down to the trial court at once for necessary compliance.
Urgent Photostat Certified copy of this order, if applied for, be supplied expeditiously after complying with all necessary legal formalities. I agree.
(Bivas Pattanayak, J.) (Joymalya Bagchi, J.)
sdas/tkm/PA (Sohel)
1 2020 SCC OnLine Cal 1 478
9
Alert