Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

SADDA v. THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH CENTRAL NARCOTICS BUREAU

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Nov 2, 2022

Cr.A. No.1377/2018 1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH

AT INDORE

BEFORE

HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE RAJENDRA KUMAR (VERMA) CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1377 of 2018 BETWEEN:-

SADDA S/O TEJA BANJARA, AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS, GRAM

GINGERKHEDA, TEH. MANASA, DISTT. NEEMUCH (MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....APPELLANT

( SHRI SANTOSH KUMAR MEENA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE

APPELLANT[P-1].

AND

THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH CENTRAL NARCOTICS

BUREAU CENTRAL NARCOTICS BUREAU, NEEMUCH (MADHYA

PRADESH)

.....RESPONDENTS

(SHRI MANOJ KUMAR SONI, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE

RESPONDENT [R-1][SC].

HEARD ON.23.06.2022

JUDGEMENT PASSED ON 02.11.2022

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1

Appellant has preferred this appeal under Section 374(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short 'the Code') against the judgment dated 06/11/2006 and conviction dated 08/12/2017 passed by Special Judge (N.D.P.S. Act), Neemuch, District Neemuch in Special. S.T. No.56/2002, whereby the appellant has been convicted for the offence punishable under Section 8/18(b) and 29 of Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (for brevity, 'the Act') and sentenced to undergo 10 years R.I with a fine of Rs.1,00,000/-, in default of payment of fine, to further undergo 1 year R.I.

02. The prosecution story, briefly stated, is that on 09/04/1999 at about 7.40 PM, M.L. Malecha alongwith his team of CBN, Neemuch, upon receiving secret information, reached on CRPF Neemuch roadway (tiraha) alongwith the Panchwitness namely Naveen Bhatnagar and Sathish, where at about 8 PM, the team found that two persons are coming towards the tri-junction (tiraha) out of the both persons, one was carrying a steel can and another person was carrying a canvas bag. On being enquired, they informed their names as Babulal and Sadda. Police intimated the accused persons about their right under the provisions of Section 50 of the Act and searched them and the

2

team recovered 5 Kgs of opium from the steel can carried by Babulal. The team has taken two samples of 25 grams each, sealed the same and sent the samples for Forensic Science Laboratory which confirmed the substance as opium. Paint Shirt of the co-accused Babulal containing in a canvass bag were also sezied from possession of the present appellant as usual the appellant used to wear Dhoti Kurta and the co-accused used to wear Paint Shirt. After completing necessary formalities, Police arrested the accused persons and registered FIR bearing crime No.05/1999 for offence under Sections 8/18(b) and 29 of 'the Act'. After due investigation, charge-sheet was filed against the appellants/accused persons.

03. Appellant was charged for offence under Section 8/18(b) and 29 of 'the Act'. He abjured his guilt and took a plea that he has been falsely implicated in the present crime. During trial, the prosecution, in order to bring him guilt, examined as many as 7 witnesses and exhibited 23 documents. None was examined in the defence.

04. Learned trial Court, on appreciation of the evidence adduced by the parties, pronounced the impugned judgment on 06/11/2006 and at this stage, the appellant was absconded and on

3

28.11.2006 perpetual warrant of arrest was issued against the appellant and he could hardly arrested on 17.05.2017. During this period of absconsion of the appellant, co-accused Babulal was arrested and trial was over and on 01.06.2013 and record of trial court was requisitioned in criminal appeal filed by co-accused Babulal. On 07.12.2017 record was sent back and the learned trial Court has concluded the matter and convicted and sentenced the appellant vide impugned order dated 08.12.2017, as stated above.

05. The appellant has preferred the present appeal mainly on the ground that judgment and order of the trial Court is contrary to law and facts available on record. The learned trial Court committed error in not considering the material contradictions and omissions appeared in the statements of prosecution witnesses and also in discarding defence version. The appellant, at the time of incident was having no contraband in his possession which clearly reflects from the fact of the record which established that there was no "conscious possession" of the present appellant and also from the impugned judgement, even after, the learned trial Court has convicted the appellant without considering the evidence and the fact that the no seizure has been made from the applicant. The learned trial Court has not considered that independent witnesses Navin (PW-4) and Satish

4

(PW-5) have not supported the case of the prosecution and have completely turned hostile and this fact itself has accepted by the learned trial Court in para no.26 of the impugned judgement. The appellant has been implicated falsely without having any cogent evidence against the appellant. The appellant has been convicted by the learned trial Court wrongly on the basis of alleged confession of the appellant which has been made under pressure. Nothing has been proved by the prosecution regarding possession of the clothes which were seized from the appellant and even after none seizure from the appellant, the learned trial Court has wrongly convicted the appellant without following the procedure of law. It is further submitted that the judgement was earlier passed in way back in the year 2006 and almost lapse of 11 years, the final conclusion of the sentence part was decided by the learned trial Court much later, which itself vitiates the right of the appellant. The learned trial court has not appreciated the evidence available on record and erred in ignoring the material contradictions and discrepancies in the evidence of the prosecution, hence, the appeal is liable to be allowed and the appellant may be acquitted

6. Learned Public Prosecutor has opposed the prayer. Inviting my attention towards the conclusive paragraphs of the impugned

5

judgement, learned public prosecutor has submitted that that substance has been confirmed by the Forensic Science Laboratory as Opium which was commercial in nature but fairly admitted that the same was seized from the possession of the co-accused not from the present appellant. It is further submitted that the possession was joint possession as per the confession of the appellant regarding the substance. It is also submitted that the co- accused Babulal used to wear paint shirt while the present appellant used to wear Dhoti Kurta/Kamij but at the time of seizure, paint shirt and other cloths containing in a canvass bag were seized from possession of the appellant. He supported the judgment and order by submitting that there is clear evidence against the appellant, therefore, according to the learned Public Prosecutor, the appeal deserves to be dismissed.

7. In reply, learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that in view of the settled position of law, only conscious possession can be possession of the co-accused and the confession made by the appellant is immaterial in the present case, because, if there is no possession as per the mandatory requirement to establish the conscious possession, the appellant can not be held guilty in any manner. It is an established fact that the contraband was recovered from conscious possession of co-

6

accused which itself is the case of prosecution, hence, the presumption of joint possession cannot be established.

8. Learned counsel for the appellant has placed reliance over the judgement of Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Tofan Singh vs. State of Tamilnadu AIIR 2020 SC 5592 (Three Judge Bench) whereby the learned Apex Court has held that the statements recorded under Section 67 of the NDPS Act cannot be used a confessional statement in the trial of an offence under the NDPS Act. In the present case, the appellant has been convicted by the learned trial count only on the basis of statements of the appellant recorded under Section 67 of the NDPS Act. Hence, in view of the settled proposition of law, the appellant is entitled for acquittal.

9. I have considered rival contentions of the parties and have perused the record.

10. The appellant here in, set out the limits of his arguments regarding two issued only firstly the prosecution has failed to establish conscious possession of the appellant and secondly; on the basis of statements of the appellant recorded under Section 67 of the NDPS Act, conviction is vitiated.

11. To answer first issue, it is necessary to point out conscious

7

possession of the appellant. In the present case, the appellant was going with another co-accused person, they were holding the steel can having the contraband by periodically and the appellant was well aware about the contraband, hence, conscious possession of the applicant is well established.

12. The expression 'possession' is a polymorphous term which assumes different colours in different contexts. It may carry different meanings in contextually different backgrounds. It is impossible, as was observed in Superintendent & Remembrancer of Legal Affairs, West Bengal v. Anil Kumar Bhunja and Ors. (AIR 1980 SC 52), to work out a completely logical and precise definition of "possession" uniformally applicable to all situations in the context of all statutes. The word 'conscious' means awareness about a particular fact. It is a state of mind which is deliberate or intended.

13. As noted in Gunwantlal v. The State of M.P. (AIR 1972 SC 1756) possession in a given case need not be physical possession but can be constructive, having power and control over the article in case in question, while the person whom physical possession is given holds it subject to that power or control.

8

14. In various judicial pronouncements the term "conscious possession" has been considered and in all of them the same is concluded, but on the different basis of facts and circumstances of the case. One of the landmark judgment passed by the apex Court in the case of Dharampal Singh vs. State of Punjab 2010

(9) SCC 608, the Court has observed that the co-accused was driving the car in which 65KG of opium was found to be transporting, the Court took cognizance. The apex Court held that Once possession is established the Court can presume that the accused had culpable mental state and have committed the offence

15. The fact of conscious possession has been considered by this Court in the case of Gopal Sharma and Another vs. Central Bureau of Narcotics, Indore ILR (2008) M.P. 131=2008 (2) MPHT 299 whereby the Court has held that if someone was carry two bus tickets of herself and other two persons who was sitting adjacent and the bag containing contraband was seized from possession of ticket holder, the association of the accused person sitting adjacent in a bus to each other and out of which one was having the tickets of all, then the possession of the contraband was with consent and connivance of others, conscious possession was held.

9

16. In the case in hand, they were holding the steel can periodically and at the time of seizure the can was handled by co- accused but the applicant was handling his cloths which they both have admitted. Hence, the appellant was very much aware about the contraband and hence, the conscious possession is established in view of the settled law in the case of Gopal Sharma (supra).

17. Now, the statements of the accused recorded under Section 67 of the NDPS Act, has no relevancy as the conscious possession of the appellant has already been proved further, it is corroborating the conscious possession of the appellant and co- accused. Hence, the learned trial Court has not committed any error in considering the material available on record, hence, the arguments placed by counsel for the appellant has no force. The appeal is dismissed.

(Rajendra Kumar Verma) Judge

amit

10